SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 23
When Discovery and Technology Meet: The Pre-Discovery Conference Michael Legg, Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law, UNSW and Consultant, Clayton Utz 15 April 2011 © Michael Legg
Overview ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Pre-discovery Conference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Pre-requisites for an effective conference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Pre-requisites for an effective conference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Pre-requisites for an effective conference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Topics for the Conference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Scope of Discovery ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Scope of Discovery ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Search Strategy ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Preservation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Privilege ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Privilege and ESI ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
NSW Practice Note SC Gen 7 ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Quick-peek ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Claw-back ,[object Object]
Quick-peek and Claw-back ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Waiver of Privilege ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
US Solution - FRE 502(d) ,[object Object]
Co-operation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Co-operation in Australia ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
When Discovery and Technology Meet: The Pre-Discovery Conference Michael Legg, Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law, UNSW and Consultant, Clayton Utz 15 April 2011 © Michael Legg

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Lawyer competency in the age of e-discovery
Lawyer competency in the age of e-discovery Lawyer competency in the age of e-discovery
Lawyer competency in the age of e-discovery
Logikcull.com
 
Contoural Kazeon Webinar Insourcing E Discovery Nov 08 V1 1 3
Contoural Kazeon Webinar Insourcing E Discovery Nov 08 V1 1 3Contoural Kazeon Webinar Insourcing E Discovery Nov 08 V1 1 3
Contoural Kazeon Webinar Insourcing E Discovery Nov 08 V1 1 3
J. David Morris
 
Orange Legal Technologies Considering Meet And Confer I L T A Prod...
Orange  Legal  Technologies    Considering  Meet And  Confer    I L T A  Prod...Orange  Legal  Technologies    Considering  Meet And  Confer    I L T A  Prod...
Orange Legal Technologies Considering Meet And Confer I L T A Prod...
Rob Robinson
 

Mais procurados (20)

Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
 
Lawyer competency in the age of e-discovery
Lawyer competency in the age of e-discovery Lawyer competency in the age of e-discovery
Lawyer competency in the age of e-discovery
 
June 2010 Newsletter
June 2010 NewsletterJune 2010 Newsletter
June 2010 Newsletter
 
Ediscovery model order
Ediscovery model orderEdiscovery model order
Ediscovery model order
 
Licensing Agreement Terms
Licensing Agreement TermsLicensing Agreement Terms
Licensing Agreement Terms
 
Georgetown Univ. Law Center Conference: Strategies for Worldwide Patent Litig...
Georgetown Univ. Law Center Conference: Strategies for Worldwide Patent Litig...Georgetown Univ. Law Center Conference: Strategies for Worldwide Patent Litig...
Georgetown Univ. Law Center Conference: Strategies for Worldwide Patent Litig...
 
Surviving Technology 2009 & The Paralegal
Surviving Technology 2009 & The ParalegalSurviving Technology 2009 & The Paralegal
Surviving Technology 2009 & The Paralegal
 
Weber patent-best-practices-may-4-2021
Weber patent-best-practices-may-4-2021Weber patent-best-practices-may-4-2021
Weber patent-best-practices-may-4-2021
 
Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to Know
Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to KnowElectronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to Know
Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to Know
 
IP 101 for Emerging Companies
IP 101 for Emerging Companies IP 101 for Emerging Companies
IP 101 for Emerging Companies
 
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Cambridge
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - CambridgeIT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Cambridge
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Cambridge
 
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Leeds
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - LeedsIT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Leeds
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Leeds
 
E Discovery
E DiscoveryE Discovery
E Discovery
 
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - London
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - LondonIT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - London
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - London
 
Contoural Kazeon Webinar Insourcing E Discovery Nov 08 V1 1 3
Contoural Kazeon Webinar Insourcing E Discovery Nov 08 V1 1 3Contoural Kazeon Webinar Insourcing E Discovery Nov 08 V1 1 3
Contoural Kazeon Webinar Insourcing E Discovery Nov 08 V1 1 3
 
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Cardiff
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - CardiffIT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Cardiff
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Cardiff
 
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Manchester
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - ManchesterIT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Manchester
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Manchester
 
Orange Legal Technologies Considering Meet And Confer I L T A Prod...
Orange  Legal  Technologies    Considering  Meet And  Confer    I L T A  Prod...Orange  Legal  Technologies    Considering  Meet And  Confer    I L T A  Prod...
Orange Legal Technologies Considering Meet And Confer I L T A Prod...
 
Patenting Issues For Biomedical Start Ups
Patenting Issues For Biomedical Start UpsPatenting Issues For Biomedical Start Ups
Patenting Issues For Biomedical Start Ups
 
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Nottingham
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - NottinghamIT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Nottingham
IT:AM Semina Series - Managing your secrets, protecting your assets - Nottingham
 

Semelhante a Michael Legg

Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New RulesEnsuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
rlhicksjr
 
EDiscovery Presentation
EDiscovery PresentationEDiscovery Presentation
EDiscovery Presentation
scubastog
 
Controlling The Cost Of Discovery In A Digital Age.Doc
Controlling The Cost Of Discovery In A Digital Age.DocControlling The Cost Of Discovery In A Digital Age.Doc
Controlling The Cost Of Discovery In A Digital Age.Doc
David Haines
 
Translating Geek To Attorneys It Security
Translating Geek To Attorneys It SecurityTranslating Geek To Attorneys It Security
Translating Geek To Attorneys It Security
CTIN
 
Amcto presentation final
Amcto presentation finalAmcto presentation final
Amcto presentation final
Dan Michaluk
 
HNBA Boston - eDiscovery
HNBA Boston - eDiscoveryHNBA Boston - eDiscovery
HNBA Boston - eDiscovery
Abel Cruz
 
Class Action Seminar.
Class Action Seminar.Class Action Seminar.
Class Action Seminar.
Bill Daniels
 

Semelhante a Michael Legg (20)

Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New RulesEnsuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
 
Proportionality in Ediscovery
Proportionality in EdiscoveryProportionality in Ediscovery
Proportionality in Ediscovery
 
EDiscovery Presentation
EDiscovery PresentationEDiscovery Presentation
EDiscovery Presentation
 
DBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby Drake
DBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby DrakeDBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby Drake
DBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby Drake
 
Why is it important to master the document review process.pdf
Why is it important to master the document review process.pdfWhy is it important to master the document review process.pdf
Why is it important to master the document review process.pdf
 
Controlling The Cost Of Discovery In A Digital Age.Doc
Controlling The Cost Of Discovery In A Digital Age.DocControlling The Cost Of Discovery In A Digital Age.Doc
Controlling The Cost Of Discovery In A Digital Age.Doc
 
What’s new in Fla. Bar 02.24.17
What’s new in Fla. Bar 02.24.17What’s new in Fla. Bar 02.24.17
What’s new in Fla. Bar 02.24.17
 
Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?
Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?
Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?
 
Ethical Dangers of Technology in the Law Practice
Ethical Dangers of Technology in the Law PracticeEthical Dangers of Technology in the Law Practice
Ethical Dangers of Technology in the Law Practice
 
BoyarMiller – What Every Attorney Needs to Know Regarding Document Retention,...
BoyarMiller – What Every Attorney Needs to Know Regarding Document Retention,...BoyarMiller – What Every Attorney Needs to Know Regarding Document Retention,...
BoyarMiller – What Every Attorney Needs to Know Regarding Document Retention,...
 
Translating Geek To Attorneys It Security
Translating Geek To Attorneys It SecurityTranslating Geek To Attorneys It Security
Translating Geek To Attorneys It Security
 
Amcto presentation final
Amcto presentation finalAmcto presentation final
Amcto presentation final
 
Discovery Practice
 Discovery Practice Discovery Practice
Discovery Practice
 
What Every Attorney Needs to Know
What Every Attorney Needs to KnowWhat Every Attorney Needs to Know
What Every Attorney Needs to Know
 
Streamlining Document Review & Production: Pitfalls and Best Practices
Streamlining Document Review & Production: Pitfalls and Best Practices Streamlining Document Review & Production: Pitfalls and Best Practices
Streamlining Document Review & Production: Pitfalls and Best Practices
 
HNBA Boston - eDiscovery
HNBA Boston - eDiscoveryHNBA Boston - eDiscovery
HNBA Boston - eDiscovery
 
Class Action Seminar.
Class Action Seminar.Class Action Seminar.
Class Action Seminar.
 
Discovery Practice (Series: Newbie Litigator School - Fall Edition)
Discovery Practice (Series: Newbie Litigator School - Fall Edition)Discovery Practice (Series: Newbie Litigator School - Fall Edition)
Discovery Practice (Series: Newbie Litigator School - Fall Edition)
 
Hot Off the Presses: Recent Cases & Decisions (Series: Legal Ethics - Best Pr...
Hot Off the Presses: Recent Cases & Decisions (Series: Legal Ethics - Best Pr...Hot Off the Presses: Recent Cases & Decisions (Series: Legal Ethics - Best Pr...
Hot Off the Presses: Recent Cases & Decisions (Series: Legal Ethics - Best Pr...
 
The Litigation Hold – Systems, Processes and Challenges | Daniel S. Day
The Litigation Hold – Systems, Processes and Challenges | Daniel S. DayThe Litigation Hold – Systems, Processes and Challenges | Daniel S. Day
The Litigation Hold – Systems, Processes and Challenges | Daniel S. Day
 

Mais de Ark Group Australia Pty Ltd

Games for the Australian Government
Games for the Australian GovernmentGames for the Australian Government
Games for the Australian Government
Ark Group Australia Pty Ltd
 
Content Creation and the Australian Public Sector - one day only in Canberra
Content Creation and the Australian Public Sector - one day only in CanberraContent Creation and the Australian Public Sector - one day only in Canberra
Content Creation and the Australian Public Sector - one day only in Canberra
Ark Group Australia Pty Ltd
 
The Essential Toolkit for Your: EDRM Renovation Australia 2017
The Essential Toolkit for Your: EDRM Renovation Australia 2017  The Essential Toolkit for Your: EDRM Renovation Australia 2017
The Essential Toolkit for Your: EDRM Renovation Australia 2017
Ark Group Australia Pty Ltd
 
Intranet Change
Intranet ChangeIntranet Change
The Australian Government Online Learning Toolkit
The Australian Government Online Learning ToolkitThe Australian Government Online Learning Toolkit
The Australian Government Online Learning Toolkit
Ark Group Australia Pty Ltd
 
Improving Performance Through Business Process Management
Improving Performance Through Business Process ManagementImproving Performance Through Business Process Management
Improving Performance Through Business Process Management
Ark Group Australia Pty Ltd
 
Creative Knowledge Retention - A Two-Day Knowledge Huddle
Creative Knowledge Retention - A Two-Day Knowledge HuddleCreative Knowledge Retention - A Two-Day Knowledge Huddle
Creative Knowledge Retention - A Two-Day Knowledge Huddle
Ark Group Australia Pty Ltd
 
KM Australia 2012 Congress
KM Australia 2012 CongressKM Australia 2012 Congress
KM Australia 2012 Congress
Ark Group Australia Pty Ltd
 

Mais de Ark Group Australia Pty Ltd (20)

Games for the Australian Government
Games for the Australian GovernmentGames for the Australian Government
Games for the Australian Government
 
Content Creation and the Australian Public Sector - one day only in Canberra
Content Creation and the Australian Public Sector - one day only in CanberraContent Creation and the Australian Public Sector - one day only in Canberra
Content Creation and the Australian Public Sector - one day only in Canberra
 
The Essential Toolkit for Your: EDRM Renovation Australia 2017
The Essential Toolkit for Your: EDRM Renovation Australia 2017  The Essential Toolkit for Your: EDRM Renovation Australia 2017
The Essential Toolkit for Your: EDRM Renovation Australia 2017
 
The Wheels of Knowledge Management in Australia: Bill Kaplan and Zach Wahl
The Wheels of Knowledge Management in Australia: Bill Kaplan and Zach WahlThe Wheels of Knowledge Management in Australia: Bill Kaplan and Zach Wahl
The Wheels of Knowledge Management in Australia: Bill Kaplan and Zach Wahl
 
And Now for Something Completely Different: Change Management for the Austral...
And Now for Something Completely Different: Change Management for the Austral...And Now for Something Completely Different: Change Management for the Austral...
And Now for Something Completely Different: Change Management for the Austral...
 
Knowledge Management Australia 2016
Knowledge Management Australia 2016Knowledge Management Australia 2016
Knowledge Management Australia 2016
 
Marketing and the Australian Public Sector 2016
Marketing and the Australian Public Sector 2016Marketing and the Australian Public Sector 2016
Marketing and the Australian Public Sector 2016
 
Knowledge Management Australia 2015: The Discovery and Re-Discovery of Knowledge
Knowledge Management Australia 2015: The Discovery and Re-Discovery of KnowledgeKnowledge Management Australia 2015: The Discovery and Re-Discovery of Knowledge
Knowledge Management Australia 2015: The Discovery and Re-Discovery of Knowledge
 
Intranet Change
Intranet ChangeIntranet Change
Intranet Change
 
Threats and Legal Issues in Social Media
Threats and Legal Issues in Social MediaThreats and Legal Issues in Social Media
Threats and Legal Issues in Social Media
 
Transforming Your Library
Transforming Your LibraryTransforming Your Library
Transforming Your Library
 
The Australian Government Online Learning Toolkit
The Australian Government Online Learning ToolkitThe Australian Government Online Learning Toolkit
The Australian Government Online Learning Toolkit
 
Knowledge Management Australia 2013
Knowledge Management Australia 2013Knowledge Management Australia 2013
Knowledge Management Australia 2013
 
Getting to the point through Internal Communication
Getting to the point through Internal CommunicationGetting to the point through Internal Communication
Getting to the point through Internal Communication
 
Improving Performance Through Business Process Management
Improving Performance Through Business Process ManagementImproving Performance Through Business Process Management
Improving Performance Through Business Process Management
 
The Everyday Intranet
The Everyday Intranet The Everyday Intranet
The Everyday Intranet
 
E025intranets web
E025intranets webE025intranets web
E025intranets web
 
Creative Knowledge Retention - A Two-Day Knowledge Huddle
Creative Knowledge Retention - A Two-Day Knowledge HuddleCreative Knowledge Retention - A Two-Day Knowledge Huddle
Creative Knowledge Retention - A Two-Day Knowledge Huddle
 
KM Australia 2012 Congress
KM Australia 2012 CongressKM Australia 2012 Congress
KM Australia 2012 Congress
 
Leading the way in Internal Communication
Leading the way in Internal CommunicationLeading the way in Internal Communication
Leading the way in Internal Communication
 

Michael Legg

  • 1. When Discovery and Technology Meet: The Pre-Discovery Conference Michael Legg, Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law, UNSW and Consultant, Clayton Utz 15 April 2011 © Michael Legg
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23. When Discovery and Technology Meet: The Pre-Discovery Conference Michael Legg, Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law, UNSW and Consultant, Clayton Utz 15 April 2011 © Michael Legg

Notas do Editor

  1. Supreme Court of Victoria, Practice Note 1 of 2007: Guidelines for the Use of Technology in any Civil Litigation Matter (2007) [2.8.2], [6.7], Supreme Court of New South Wales, Practice Note SC Gen 7 - Use of Technology , 9 July 2008 [12] and Federal Court of Australia, Practice Note CM6 - Electronic Technology in Litigation , 25 September 2009 [7].
  2. Fed Court CM6 NSW SC Gen 7: 12. Practitioners must advise their opponents at an early stage of the proceedings of potentially discoverable electronically stored information and meet to agree upon matters including: the format of the electronic database for the electronic discovery, noting that metadata, mark-up or other “hidden” data will be automatically discovered if native format is used. Because of potential costs, the Court would ordinarily expect it should only be discovered where the relevance outweighs the cost the protocol to be used for the electronic discovery including electronically stored information the type and extent of the electronically stored information that is to be discovered how legacy or deleted data is to be dealt with. The existence of ESI that is not reasonably or readily accessible should be disclosed between the parties, but the Court would ordinarily expect that it would not need to be retrieved unless necessary for the conduct of the proceedings whether electronically stored information is to be discovered on an agreed without prejudice basis without the need to go through the information in detail to categorise it into privileged and non-privileged information and without prejudice to an entitlement to subsequently claim privilege over any information that has been discovered and is claimed to be privileged under s 118 and/or s119 of the Evidence Act 1995 and/or at common law. Such ESI could be produced separately on a CD-ROM or DVD and appropriately marked to enable the Court to determine any privilege issue.
  3. In the Federal Court and Supreme Court of Victoria a party is required to discover documents that it is aware of at the time it makes discovery having conducted a reasonable search. A party must discover documents: that it relies on which adversely affect the party’s case and that support or adversely affect another party’s case. Federal Court Rules Order 15 rule 2(5).
  4. how to avoid loss of privilege? search strategies can find privileged documents eg search on "privilege" and known lawyer's names - but not perfect
  5. At common law, a client who would otherwise be entitled to the benefit of legal professional privilege, might waive that privilege and that waiver might be express or implied. See Mann v Carnell (1999) 201 CLR 1 at [28]-[29] and Osland v Secretary, Dept of Justice (2008) 234 CLR 275 at [35], [44]–[46] and [48]–[50]. The Evidence Act 1995, s 122 also provides for waiver and has been amended to adopt the test in Mann. See Explanatory Memorandum, Evidence Amendment Bill 2008 (Cth) at 27.
  6. FRE 502(e) Controlling effect of a party agreement.— An agreement on the effect of disclosure in a Federal proceeding is binding only on the parties to the agreement, unless it is incorporated into a court order.
  7. Sedona Conference Cooperation Proclamation
  8. Federal Court Fast Track 5.1    The Court expects the parties and their representatives to cooperate with, and assist, the Court in ensuring the proceeding is conducted in accordance with the Fast Track Directions so that the real issues in dispute are identified as early as possible and are dealt with in the most efficient way possible.