SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 32
Table of Content:

Constitution, Its Meaning, Kinds and Rules Of Interpertation.......................................... 2

Islamic point of view about constitution: ........................................................................... 6

Constitution making ............................................................................................................ 7

Constitutional history of Pakistan: ..................................................................................... 8

Constitution of 1956: ......................................................................................................... 21

Constitution of 1962: ......................................................................................................... 23

Constitution of 1973 .......................................................................................................... 25

Amendment of constitution .............................................................................................. 29

Procedure for Amendment of the Constitution ................................................................ 30

Conclusion; ........................................................................................................................ 31

References ......................................................................................................................... 32




                                                                                                                                     1
Constitution, Its Meaning, inds and Rules of Interpertation:
Constitution is the fundamental law of the land and it is from this source that all the

laws spring. This law can be made or altered not in the manner of ordinary laws but in a

much different way, that is, by a defined authority and in the prescribed manner. As far

as Muslim states, particularly Pakistan, are concerned the laws are not derived from the

constitution but from the Almighty Allah who has revealed them in his book and which

have been interpreted and explained by Holy Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) through his

sayings. Conduct and actual practice. For practical purpose we can assume that laws

which are not repugnant to the holy Quran and Sunnah have to be framed under the

authority of the constitution and cannot be antagonistic to its command and spirit.


(Anjum.S.Ahsan.1983)


Forms of Constitution:

A constitution may be unwritten. As for instance the English Constitution which mostly

consist of constitutional as ages, traditions and conventions, or written, as most of the

modern constitutions are. Or partly unwritten. A written constitution is usually rigid

and inflexible in as much as, intended to be permanent, it does not admit of alteration

by ordinary legislative process and requires some extraordinary procedure for its

amendment. A constitution may be Unitarian or federal according to whether power

resets in the centre or is distributed between it and the federating units. A Unitarian

constitution is flexible if it can be amended by ordinary legislative process and rigid if it

requires a special procedure for its alteration.


(Anjum.S.Ahsan.1983)



                                                                                            2
Kinds of Constitution:


       Federal and unitary constitutions

This classification is based on the principle by which the powers of government and the

constitution government established for its constituent parts. Under a federal

constitution there is a scheme of distribution of powers between the central and local

units which are to a certain extent independent within their own territorial limits. The

central government has its own sphere of operation of its laws, while the federating

units are governed by their own laws. No one is subordinate nor are acts as an agent of

the other, e.g. the constitution of Switzerland, Australia and India.


In the unitary constitution the legislature of the whole country is the supreme law

making body which may permit other legislatures to exist subordinates to it. Sweden,

New Zealand, France, have unitary constitutions.


       Republican and monarchical( Autocratic )constitutions

Constitutions are sometimes classified into “republican” and |”monarchical”. There is

difference between popular or democratic government as opposed to an autocracy or

dictatorship which established absolutism of the executive. It is difficult to find today

even one solitary example of the latter type of the constitution. A republican constitution

on the other hand illustrates almost every system of government from democracy to

dictatorship.




                                                                                         3
Conventional

The English constitution is based largely upon rules of practice, or convention. Many of

the rules of the English constitutional government possess merely a conventional

character. This is shown by the fact that no legal proceedings can be taken for a breach

of their established terms, since they are merely matters of practice. The conventions of

the constitution are in the last resort founded upon the law of the land; and they have

their sanction in the force of law.


       Unitary

The English constitution involves one central government which pervades the whole

country.


       Flexible

In flexible constitution every law of every description can legally be changed with the

same ease and in the same manner by one and the same body.


A flexible constitution is likely to be unstable due to its capacity to undergo constant

changes. But at the same time there is this advantage that it facilitates all necessary

changes required by the changing political and economic ideas and circumstances, and

secures the growth of the constitution without the possibility of any revolution. The

English constitution with the supremacy of parliament is an instance of a flexible

constitution.




                                                                                        4
Rigid

A rigid constitution on the other hand is one under which certain laws cannot be

changed in the same manner as ordinary laws. They can be altered or amended by the

special machinery provided in the constitution itself.


(Anjum.S.Ahsan.1983)


Rules to interpret of a Constitution:

      The constitution is fundamental or organic or supreme law standing on a

      somewhat higher position than the other laws of the country.

      The constitution is the source from which all governmental power emanates and

      it defines its scope and ambit so that each functionary should act within his

      respective sphere.

      The courts are components of the constitution; they derive their powers and

      jurisdictions from the constitution and must confine themselves within the limits

      set by the constitution.

      Under a constitution prescribing a system where there is a tracheotomy of

      sovereign powers the judicial power must from the very nature of things is vested

      in a judiciary.

      Thus the judiciary does claim and has always claimed that it has the right to

      interpret the constitution and to say as to what a particular provision of the

      constitution means or does not mean even if it is a provision seeking to oust its

      own jurisdiction.



                                                                                      5
In the latter case an ouster of jurisdiction is not to be readily inferred, because,

       the consistent rule is that provisions seeking to oust the jurisdiction of superior

       courts, even by a constitutional provision, are to be construed strictly with a

       pronounced learning against ouster.

       It is not, however, the function of the judiciary to legislate or to question the

       wisdom of the law giver if the law has been competently made without

       transgressing the limitations of the constitution. If a law has been competently

       made the judiciary cannot refuse to enforce it even if the result be to nullify its

       own decisions.

       The law-giver has also very right to change, emend or clarify the law if the

       judiciary has found that the language used conveyed by the law-giver.

       The constitution has to be construed like other document reading it as a whole

       and giving to every part therefore a meaning consistent with the other provisions

       of the constitution.

       As far as possible each provision of the constitution should be construed so as to

       harmonies with all the others.

       (Anjum.S.Ahsan.1983)


Islamic point of view about constitution:
The first Muslim constitution was promulgated by the holy prophet of Islam

Mohammad (pbuh) when he migrated to madina and foundation was laid for the

government of a city state. This constitution was framed and put into effect with the full

consensus of not only the followers of the prophet Mohammad (pbuh) but also had the

concurrence of the Jews and other non-converts. The constitution thus framed gave the

details of the rights and duties of the ruler and the ruled.
                                                                                         6
The characteristic of Muslim administration had been that the people including the

rulers were subject to shariat and it was enforced with greater force of equity, justice

and good conscience in the case of those who did not embrace the faith of Islam. Such

notions as “the king can do no wrong”, “the king cannot be tried in his own court”, “act

of state” and “privilege” etc, are unknown to Islamic jurisprudence. Even the first four

rightly guided caliphs had great respect for the law and would humbly appear before the

Qazi if ever such an occasion arose.


Muslim theologians and jurists believe in the supremacy of the law as laid down in the

holy Quran and interpreted by Sunnah and hold it to be eternal and immutable. This law

was therefore the actual sovereign in Muslim lands. Sovereignty, says the Holy Quran,

belongs to almighty Allah alone and the authority to be exercised by the state is

therefore a sacred trust on behalf of Allah and must be exercised within the limits

prescribed by Him.


(Mehmood.M,1995).


Constitution making
The constituent assembly of Pakistan could not, frame a constitution during the lifetime

of the quaid-e-azam. In March 1949 a resolution known as the objectives Resolution

came to be passed by unanimous vote of the house. This resolution merely enunciated

the principles or guidelines on which the constitution was to be framed and could well

be regarded as the preamble of the constitution of Pakistan.


The constitution – making went on till in 1954 a draft of the constitution was prepared

with the leaders of the various groups in the assembly but in October, 1054 Mr. Ghulam

Muhammad, the then Governor- General, put armed guards outside the assembly hall,

                                                                                       7
dissolved the constituent assembly by proclamation and allowed none to enter the

premises so as to pass the constitution. This step was taken by him to keep his gaddi

intact and for life, because he knew full well that he would have to vacate the office in

favor of the duly elected representative of the people.


Maulvi Tamizuddin Khan, the speaker of the Constituent Assembly challenged his

resolution in the chief court of sindh and sought for a declaration that the orders of the

Governor-General were unauthorized, unconstitutional, and illegal and without force.

The Chief court issued a write restraining the governor- General. The matter went up in

appeal to the Federal Court headed by justice Munir who allowed the appeal and

dismissed the writ petition.


The federal court judgment in us if paatel case observed that the first concern of the

Government would have been to bring into existence another representative body to

exercise the powers of the Constituent Assembly so that all invalid legislation could have

been immediately validated by the new body.


Acting on this advice a new Constituent Assembly was elected by the members of the

Provincial Assemblies on basis of proportional representation and this Assembly

succeeded in framing a Constitution in 1956.


(Dr.Muhammad.B, 1995)


Constitutional history of Pakistan:
The constitutional history of Pakistan is full of turmoil and toil. It may be said to have

commenced from Indian independence act, 1947 but there are certain important




                                                                                         8
enactments which tell us at least a part of story and furnish implied source of historical

background.


Indian act 1858:

Although the war of independence 1857, could not achieve the object for which it was

fought but it certainly put an end to the rule of East India Company. It was realized that

a trading company whose main objective was profit could not be entrusted with the

work of administration of a sub-continent like India. A bill was introduced by Lord

Palmerstone for the better Government of India in Parliament, which was passed and

became Government of India Act 1858, the first most important constitutional

document in the history of sub-continent. This act abolished the East India Company

and transferred the government of India from the hands of East India Company to the

Crown.


The Act of 1858 mainly provided:


   1. India shall be governed by and in the name of Queen. The Governor-General

      came to be known as the Viceroy.

   2. The Board of Control and Court of Directors were abolished and all the powers

      possessed by them were given to the Secretary of State for India and his Indian

      Council.

   3. The Secretary of State was to preside over the meetings of the Indian Council. He

      was declared to be corporate body which could sue and be sued.


Indian Council’s Act 1861:


                                                                                         9
The act of 1858 which transferred the Government of India into the hands of the Crown

did not make any change in the Indian administration. It was therefore necessary that

something should be done to reform the Indian machinery also. That was done by the

Act of 1861.


   1. The Act empowered the Governor-General to delegate special business to

       individual members of the Executive Council.

   2. The Executive Council of the Governor-General was strengthened.

   3. The Governments of Bombay and Madras where given the power of nominating

       the Advocate-General and additional members of the Executive Council for the

       purpose of legislation.

   4. No distinction was made between the central and provincial subjects. However,

       subjects concerning public debt, finances, currency, post-office, telegraph,

       religion, patents and copyright were ordinary put under the control of the Central

       Government.

   5. The governor-General was given the power to create new provinces. He was also

       given the power to appoint lieutenant-Governors. He was also authorized to

       divide the limits of any presidency and province.


The Indian Council Act 1861 marked an important step in the constitutional history of

Indo-Pakistan. It made a beginning in representative institutions and legislative

devolution. Herein the policy of association was given effect to. However, it may be

noted that the non-official members of the Council were nominated by the Viceroy ad

not elected by the people. The legislative power given to these Councils was very wide

but was put under severe restrictions. The non-official members had practically no say


                                                                                      10
in the matter. In this way, the Act of 1861 was defective and required improvements of

representative institutions.


Indian Council’s Act of 1892:

     1. This Act enlarged the functions of the Legislative Councils. They were

        authorized to discuss the annual financial statement under certain conditions

        and restrictions.

     2. The members of the Council were given the right of addressing questions to the

        Government on matters of public interest.

     3. The number of additional members in the council was increased subject to

        certain restrictions and rules made by Governor-General.

     4. As a result of the pressure brought by the Indian National Congress, the

        principle of elected members was accepted. But the elected members could only

        take their seats if nominated by the Governor-General.

        Mehmood.M, (1995).


Minto-Marley Reforms 1909:

The discontented people of the sub-continent were not satisfied with the hollow

provisions of the Act of 1892, with the result that the period between 1892 to 1909 was

one of storm and stress. The people resented autocratic attitude of the Government. The

agitation against the partition of Bengal was widespread. In 1906 a Muslim deputation,

headed by H.H. the Agha Khan waited upon Lord Minto and demanded separate

representation of Muslims. In December 1909 the Nawab of Dacca appealed to the

Muslims of India to form the All India Muslim Confederacy’. Lord Minto, the then

                                                                                     11
Viceroy of India took a serious note of the situation and reported the matter to the

Home Government. In December, 1906 Lord Morley introduced his famous Bill in the

House of Lords. The Bill was passed in 1909 as the India Council Act.


   1. The Act of 1909 enlarged the size of Legislative Council.

   2. It was provided that the imperial Legislative Council shall consist of 37 official

      and 32 non- 0fficial members.

   3. It was decided that there would be no official majority in the provincial

      Legislative Councils but such majority was considered essential in the Central

      Legislature.

   4. The principle of territorial representation was not accepted. “Representation by

      classes and benefit was considered to be the only practical method of embodying

      the elective principle in the constitution of the Indian Legislative Council.” The

      Act provided for separate or extraordinary electorates for the due representation

      of the different communities, classes and benefit.

   5. The functions of the Legislative Councils were increased. Described rules were

      made for the discussion of the budget in the Imperial Legislative Council. Every

      member was given the right to move any resolution relating to any alteration in

      taxation, any new loans or any additional grant to local Governments proposed or

      mentioned in the financial statement or explanatory memorandum. However, the

      Council was not permitted to discuss expenditure on interest, on debt,

      ecclesiastical expenditure and State Railway etc.

   6. The members were given the right of asking question and supplementary

      questions for the purpose of further elucidating any point.


                                                                                     12
7. The members were given the power to move resolutions in the Councils.

8. Rules were framed for the discussion of matters of general public interest in the

   Legislative Councils. But no discussion was permitted on any subject not within

   the competence of the particular Legislature, any matter affecting the relations of

   the Government of India with a Foreign Power or a native state, and any matter

   under adjudication by a court of law.

9. In the provinces, Landlords, district Boards and Municipalities and Chambers of

   Commerce were to select members.

10. Muslims were given separate representation. Muslim members of the legislation

   were elected by the Muslims themselves.

   (Khan Hamid, 2005)


Government of India Act 1919:

The preamble of the Government of India Act 1919 stated that it was the declared

policy of the British Parliament to provide for increasing association of Indians in

every branch of administration and for the gradual development of self-governing

institutions, with a view of the progressive realization of responsible government in

British India. However, it said, progress in giving effect to this policy could only be

achieved in successive stages.


Some of the main provisions of the Government of India Act, 1919 were as under:


   1. The Act provided that the Secretary of State for India was to be paid out of

      British revenues. The Secretary of State continued to possess and perform the

      duty of superintendence, direction, and control upon the affairs of India. The


                                                                                    13
Governor-General of India was obliged to carry out the orders of the Secretary

   of State.

2. The Act set up a bicameral legislature at the centre in place of the imperial

   Council consisting of one house. The two Houses were called Central

   Legislative Assembly and the Council of State.

3. Direct elections were provided for both houses of the Central Legislative

   though the franchise was very restricted.

4. The duration of the term for the Central Legislative Assembly was three years,

   and for the Council of State five years, which could be extended by the

   Governor-General. The Governor-General had the power to summon,

   prorogue, and dissolve the houses of the Central Legislature. He could also

   address both houses.

5. The Central Legislature had the power to make laws for all of British India, for

   Indian subjects wherever they might be, and for all persons employed in the

   defense forces. It could also repeal or emend laws for the time being in force.

   However, prior sanction of the Secretary of State-in-Council was required to

   pass a law abolishing any High Court. Prior sanction of the Governor-General

   was required to introduce bills on the following subjects:

      The public profit or public revenues of India.

      Religion or religious rites and usages of British subjects in India.

      Discipline or maintenance of the land.

      Relations of the government of India with foreign states or Indian states.

      Any measures repealing or emending any Act of Legislature or any

      Ordinance passed by the Governor-General.

                                                                                   14
The governor-General could also prevent consideration of a Bill or a part of it if,

   in his opinion, it affects the safety or tranquility of British India, or any part

   therefore.


   6. The Governor-General could issue an Ordinance for a period of six months

       which had the same force and effect as an Act of the Central Legislature. He

       had the power of veto over the Bills passed by the Central Legislature.

   7. The Central Budget was presented before the Central Legislature in the form

       of demands for grants. There were certain non-votable items which were not

       open to discussion unless the Governor-General so allowed. All other items

       were submitted to vote. In an emergency, the Governor-General was

       empowered to authorize such expenditure as, in his opinion, was necessary

       for the safety or tranquility of British India or any part before.

       (Hassan.u.Masud,2001)


The Government of India Act 1935:

The Act was a comprehensive statue running into 321 sections and two schedules. It

was a comprehensive written Constitution given to India by its colonial masters.

That was partly due to the fact that the Act dealt with a highly complex type of a

federal constitution and also because it sought to provide legal safeguards against

misbehavior on the part of the Indian Ministers and the legislature.


Special features of the Act of 1935:


    The acceptance of an All India Federation.

    The introduction of partial responsibility in the form of diarchy at the Centre.

                                                                                    15
 The grant of autonomy to the provinces.

        Safeguards, reservations, special responsibilities, overriding Powers, etc.in the

          hands of the Governors and the governor-General.

        Creation of a Federal Court, Federal Railway authority, the reserve Bank of

          India, public service Commission for the Federation and provinces.


Complexity of the scheme:


Although the government of India act, 1935, is considered to be a masterpiece of

draftsmanship, it is the most complicated instrument in the whole history of

Constitutional development in India. The complexity arises from various reasons,

the chief of which is unique nature of the problem which the scheme was designed to

solve.


Basic purposes of the act:


There were three basic purposes of the Act:-


  i.      Establishment of a Federation.

 ii.      Provincial autonomy with parliamentary Government.

iii.      The separation of Burma from India.


Provisions:


Provincial Autonomy:


It introduced responsible governments in the provinces which came to be known as

provincial autonomy. Under it the whole provincial administration, with certain



                                                                                       16
reservations, was transferred to the control of Indian Ministers, working on cabinet

principles, responsible to provincial Legislatures.


All India Federation:


The Act also proposed to abolish the unitary front of government which had been

working in India since the regulating Act. Its place was to be taken by an All India

Federation compromising 11 provinces (Governors) and 5 provinces (Chief

Commissioners) plus such states, as were willing to join the Federation. Thus for the

first time the whole of India including Indian states was to be integrated under one

Constitution.


Diarchy at the Centre:


The act proposed to establish Diarchy at the centre, i.e. Diarchy was to be abolished

in the provinces, only to be crated at the centre. The central administration was to be

divided into two parts. One part to be in charge of the Councilors, responsible to the

Governor General alone, and it included some key departments.


Safeguards:


Lastly were safeguards of special responsibilities. Under the Act, entire Provincial

   administration was given to Indian Ministers, but the Governor was given certain

   special powers of interference which could be used whenever necessary. In

   certain cased he could act o discretion without consulting Ministers, yet in other

   cased, he could act on his individual judgment, consult has Ministers but take

   decision independently. In addition to these exceptions, the Governor was

   charged with special responsibilities regarding peace and other within his
                                                                                    17
jurisdiction protection of the rights of minorities. All India service Indian States

       and prevention of discrimination against the British subjects and British firms.

       All such precautionary measures were known as special responsibility of the

       Governor or his safeguards.


   Rigid Constitution…


   The constitution of 1935 was rigid. The British Government


   Alone was given the authority to emend the constitution.


   (Dr. Mahmood Safdar. 1992).


Constitution making 1947 to 1956

The modified Government of India Act (1935) became the Interim Constitution of

Pakistan in1947. The Constituent Assembly (CA) was given the task of framing the

Constitution. The process began with the passing of the Objectives Resolution in which

the Islamic and democratic values were adopted as grounds for the future constitution.

The Basic Principles Committee (BPC) consisting of 24 members was made to work for

the constitution. The various sub-committees on Federal and provincial duties,

Franchise, Judiciary, and Fundamental Rights started working. Board of Talimat-i-

Islamia was also set to look for advice on the religious matters.

First Basic Principle Committee Report, 1950

1: The Objectives Resolution to be built-in in the Constitution as the order principles.

2: Legislature: Two houses of the parliament.

Upper: (House of Units) Equal representation for the units



                                                                                           18
Lower: (House of People) On the basis of Population. Both the Houses would benefit

from the same power.

3: The Head of State elected by joint session would be for five years (Two times only).

President had optional and emergency, appointment and other powers. President was

not responsible to give answer to anyone, might be a Muslim or non-Muslim, would be

assist by the Prime Minister (PM) and Cabinet that would be responsible to the CA.

Parliament may charge him by 2/3 majority. He was given the power to break the

constitution.

4: Cabinet responsible to both the Houses.

5: No mention of national language

Criticism:

This report was severely criticized throughout the country. It could not suit both the

wings, East and West. The religious group objects that the report contained nothing

about Islamisation. On the question of depiction, the East Pakistan (EP) protested that

their majority had been denied by the Report. They remark that they were thrown into a

permanent minority. The population of EP was a little larger than that of the West

Pakistan (WP) but it was treated as the

Small provinces because both the Houses were given equal power. So the authority of

WP was intolerable for the East wing. The language problem proves dissident to the

national solidarity. The Eastern Pakistanis destined the proposal that made Urdu as

official language.

Second Basic Principle Committee Report, 1952

1. Head of State would be Muslim and no change in powers.

2. Equal representation to East and West wings:

                                                                                    19
UH (Upper House) 60, 60 LH 200, 200

3. More powers were given to Lower House. Cabinet was made responsible to Lower

House.

4. It was promised that law making would be in accordance with ISLAM. No law would

be made in disobedience of Islamic principles.

5. Advisory Board of five Islamic scholars was founded.

6. Quiet on national language.

Criticism:

The politicians particularly from the Punjab deplore the Report because configuration of

the UH on the basis of representation was not suitable. It was stated against the

principle of federation.

The WP superior equality only for Upper House. The political crisis removed Prime

Minister Nazimuddin and attention unfocused from the main issue.

Constituent Assembly Dissolution

In October 1954, GG (Governor General) dissolved the CA that was challenged in the

Sindh court by Maulvi Tamizuddin. The court confirmed the dissolution illegal but the

Federal Court upholds the GG action but asked for setting up an elected CA.

2nd Constituent Assembly, June-July 1955

Ghulam Muhammad called a Convention on May 10, 1955. All its members were to be

elected not directly (by the provincial assemblies). In this way, the 2nd CA came into

survival

One Unit Scheme, October 1955

The presence of different provinces in the WP had complicated the issue of the WP

representation in the CA. It was handled by uniting all the WP units into ONE (One

                                                                                     20
Unit, October 30, 1955). Now both the parts had become two units and could be

addressed equally.

(Dr.Muhammad.B, 1995)

Constitution-making

One Unit scheme helped the task of constitution making to achieve successfully. The

previous committees report helped the new Assembly that completed its work and

presented in the 2nd CA on January 9, 1956. It, with certain amendments, was approved

on January 29, 1956 and imposed on March 23. With this Pakistan had become an

Islamic Republic.


Constitution of 1956:
The first constitution of the country was enforced on 23rd march, 1956. The main points

of this constitution are as follows:

   1. Pakistan was to be federal republic based on Islamic Ideology.

   2. A detailed and comprehensive list of fundamental rights with an Independent

       Judiciary was provided in the constitution.

   3. The system of the parliamentary form of government was adopted both at the

       Centre and in the provinces.

   4. There was distribution of powers between the Centre and the provinces.

   5. The constitution provided for Pakistan, wherein equality between East and West

       wings had been maintained.

   6. For the distribution of subjects between the centre and the provinces, three lists

       of subject had been drawn up.

   7. There was a special procedure to be adopted for the amendment of the

       constitution, yet it was the least rigid constitution. It was reasonably flexible.

                                                                                            21
8. It had provided for two National languages Urdu for the West Pakistan and

          Bengali for the East Pakistan.

       9. Instead of double citizenship, one citizenship system was provided for the

          Federation of Pakistan.

       10. The constitution was silent as to be method of conducting elections both for the

          Central and the Provincial legislatures.

       11. And finally, there were the Islamic characters of the constitution.

Islamic provisions of the 1956 constitution:

  i.      The name of the country will be Islamic republic of Pakistan.

 ii.      The preamble of the constitution embodied the sovereignty of God Almighty.

iii.      The Head of the State shall be a Muslim.

 iv.      Islamic Advisory Council shall be set up.

 v.       No Law detrimental to Islam shall be enacted.

The political conditions of the country could not be improved even after the first

constitution was enforced. The political instability remained rampant. The elections

could not be held till 1858. The constitution invited criticism from certain quarters.

Martial Law was declared in the Country on 8th October, 1958. General Ayub,

commander in chief of the Army, took over the government and became the Head of the

State on 27th October 1958.

After taking over President Ayub Khan set up a constitutional commission under justice

Shahab-ud-Din to suggest recommendation for the new constitution of the country. The

commission after through and lengthy discussion submitted its report on 6th March

1961.



                                                                                        22
The report was examined by president. In its report the commission highlighted the

reasons of the failure of parliamentary democracy in Pakistan. It fixed the responsibility

for the debacle of democracy on the lack of dedicated leadership, absence of well

organized political parties and the self aggrandizement of the greedy politicians. In the

view of the recommendation of the commission a new constitution was not framed by a

constitutional body which was elected nor did it enjoy popular support. The constitution

was thrust upon the people in an undemocratic and authoritarian manner.

(Mehmood.M, (1995).


Constitution of 1962:
Salient Features of the Constitution

   1. Title of the State will be Islamic Republic of Pakistan.

   2. A Powerful President who was responsible for administration and affairs of the

      state. He should be a Muslim, no less than 40 years of age, should be capable to

      be a member of NA. He would be elected through not direct elections for a time of

      five years. If he has held office for more than 8 years, he could look for reelection

      with the support of the NA and the PAs.National Assembly was given the power

      to charge the president, however it was difficult to achieve. President could

      dissolve the NA but in that case he must seek re-election.

   3. President was the central point of all the Executive, Legislative and Judicial

      powers. Cabinet was responsible to him. All key appointments were to be made

      by President. He could issue Ordinances. He could also announce State of

      Emergency in the country.




                                                                                        23
4. NA was consisted of one house on the basis of principle of parity between two

       wings of the country. There were 150 seats plus 6 seats were reserved for women.

       All were elected indirectly. For the membership minimum age limit was 25 years.

   5. NA had all the powers of law making but law was to be finally ratified by the

       president. President could sign, reject or return the bill.

   6. Financial Powers of NA were limited. Only new expenses could be voted. NA

       could not reject join Fund List and Recurring Expenditure.

   7. There were two provinces of the federation: East Pakistan and West Pakistan.

       Only one list of subjects, i.e. the Central list was given in the constitution.

   8. Governors were head of the provinces and govern the province with his cabinet.

       Provincial governments were directly under the control of President. There was a

       strong center with a Powerful President. He had enough powers to manage

       provincial affairs. In case of emergency powers Central government could take

       direct control of the province.

   9. Principles of Policy

• National solidarity would be observed.

• Interests of backward people would be looked after.

• Opportunities for participation in national life.

• Education and well being of people.

• Islam would be implemented in day to day life.

   10. Fundamental Rights were provided in the constitution.

   11. Originally Political Parties were not allowed. Political Parties Act was introduced

       in 1962.



                                                                                         24
12. Objectives Resolution was the Preamble of the Constitution. Other Islamic

        provisions were a part of Principles of Policy and not the constitution.

   13. An Advisory Council for Islamic Ideology was made in the constitution having 5-

        12 members. It was a recommendatory body.

   14. It was designed for the Research and instructions in Islam for assisting the

        reconstruction of Muslim society on truly Islamic lines.

Constitution remained enforced from June 8, 1962 to March 25, 1969.

(Gankovsky.V.Y & Moskalenko.N.V, (1975).


Constitution of 1973
Background

Abrogation of the 1962 Constitution on March 25, 1969 led to second martial law in the

country. Yahya Khan handed over power to Zulfikar Ali Bhutto on December 20, 1971

after the first general elections. But martial law continued and there was no

constitution. National Assembly approved a temporary Constitution, which was

imposed on April 21, 1972.

Constitution Making

Constitutional Committee comprising National Assembly (NA) members from all

parties was set up in April 1972. Law Minister was the Chairman of this Committee. All

parties agreed on the future political system in October 1972. The Committee reported

on December 31, 1972. After long deliberations and compromises final draft was

approved commonly on April 10, 1973. The new Constitution was imposed on August 14,

1973.

The Constitution functioned since then with two gaps. It remained operational during

following periods:

                                                                                    25
1973-77: Operational

1977-1985: Suspended

1985-1999: Operational after changes

1999-2002: Suspended

2002 onwards Operational after changes

Features of the Constitution

   1. Parliamentary System

It was a parliamentary constitution having powerful Prime Minister (PM) as head of

government with a very weak President. President must act on the advice of PM. All his

orders were to be countersigned by PM. Prime Minister to be elected by the NA. PM

exercised all executive authority.

PM was answerable to the NA. In 1985, powers of the President were increased. He

enjoyed some discretion in appointments of

PM. He had power to break up the NA. He had the powers of appointment of caretaker

PM. He gives his assent to bills passed by the parliament or returns these.

   2. President:

Must be at least 45 years of age, Muslim, qualified to become member of the NA. He is

elected by the Parliament and the Provincial Assemblies for 5 years.

   3. Parliament with two houses:

• Upper House called Senate. In this house equal representation is given to Provinces.

Seats are reserved for the tribal areas, women and technocrats. Its original strength was

63, which was later raised to 87 and then 100. Senate is elected indirectly. It’s a

permanent House as half of its members are elected after three years.



                                                                                      26
• Lower House: National Assembly is elected on population basis. Its Original strength

was 210 but now it is 342. NA is elected for five years.

• Senate: Indirect elections

• National Assembly: Direct elections

• Voting age for the franchise is lowered from 21 to 18.

• Parliament under 1973 constitution is a powerful legislative body. It enjoys all

legislative powers. It has control of the executive through questions, resolutions,

parliamentary committees etc.

• National Assembly is more powerful than the Senate. Budget is presented before NA.

Cabinet is answerable to National Assembly.

   4. Federal System

Federation of Pakistan has four provinces and federally administered areas. Two lists

are given in the constitution: Federal list and Concurrent list. Residuary powers belong

To provinces.

   5. Provincial Structure:

Provincial Governors are appointed by the President on the advice of the PM. Elected

Chief Minister exercises executive powers. Parliamentary system is there in the

provinces.

Size of the provincial assemblies varies:

In 2002:

Punjab 371

Sindh 168

NWFP 124

Balochistan 65

                                                                                       27
Enough provincial independence is guaranteed. Tradition of strong centre continues.

Centre has emergency powers. Governor’s rule can be forced if the government cannot

function in the provinces. Provinces are dependent on centre for Finances.

   6. Principles of Policy:

Islamic provisions are provided in Principles of Policy.

   7. Fundamental Rights:

Fundamental Rights are protected in the constitution and are implemented through the

highest court.

   8. Islamic Provisions:

Title of the state is Islamic Republic of Pakistan.

The objectives resolution was the Preamble in the initial constitution but through article

2-A of 8th amendment it was inserted in the constitution in 1985.

Islam was declared the State Religion of Pakistan.

Definition of Muslim was included by an amendment.

Principles of Policy also carry some Islamic clauses.

Council for Islamic Ideology is recognized under the constitution.

Federal Shariat Court was added in 1981.

   9. National Language:

Urdu is declared National Language, however English may be used for official purposes

until preparations would be made for its replacement by Urdu.

Provincial Assembly may prescribe measures for teaching, promotion and use of a

provincial language in addition to the national language.

   10. National Security Council:

National Security Council was added in 2002 in advisory capacity.

                                                                                       28
11. Judiciary:

An independent judiciary is given under the constitution. Supreme Court of Pakistan is

the highest court. One High Court is established in each province and one in Azad

Kashmir. A chain of lower courts is there under the high courts.



      12. Rigid

A constitution is rigid or flexible can be tested by seeing the procedure laid down for its

change or amendment. A flexible Constitution can legally be amended by the same

process of law-making as an ordinary law, while in a rigid Constitution specific

machinery is provided in itself by which any change or amendment can be effected.

(Ishaq.M.Khan. (1973).


Amendment of constitution
  I.     A bill to amendment the constitution shall create in the national Assembly and

         when the Bill has been passed by the votes of not less than two-thirds of the total

         membership of Assembly it shall be transferred to the senate.

 II.     If a Bill is passed by the senate with amendments it shall be reconsidered by the

         National Assembly; and if the Bill as amended by the Senate is passed by the

         Assembly by the votes of not less than two-thirds of the total membership of the

         Assembly, it shall be presented to the President for the assent.

III.     If the Bill is passed by the Senate by a majority of the total membership of the

         Senate it shall be presented to the President for assent.

IV.      If the Bill is not passed by the Senate within ninety days from the day of its

         receipt the Bill shall be deemed to have been rejected by the senate.



                                                                                         29
V.    The President shall assent to the Bill within seven days of the presentation of the

       Bill to him, and if he fails to do so he shall be deemed to have assented thereto at

       the expiration of that period.

VI.    When the President has assented to or is deemed to have assented to the Bill, the

       Bill shall become Act of Parliament and the Constitution shall stand amended in

       accordance with the terms thereof.

VII.   A bill to amend the Constitution which would have the effect of altering the limits

       of a Province shall not be passed by the National Assembly of that Province

       passed by the votes of not less than two-thirds of the total membership of that

       Assembly.


Procedure for Amendment of the Constitution
The Committee is of the view that the process of amending the constitution should be

made difficult. It is accordingly decided that the following procedure should be

recommended.

If a notice is received signed by than one-third of the Members of a House seeking

permission for the circulation of their motion for amendment of the Constitution

amongst the Provinces for opinion, it should be placed on the agenda of the House

concerned and considered. In case it is passed by a majority, the matter should be

referred to the other House for consideration for the same purpose. When permission is

granted by the second House, the proposal should be circulated to the Provinces by the

chairman of the House in which it is initiated. The chairman of the legislature of every

province, by whom the proposal is received for consideration, should convey the

decision of the respective Legislature to the Chairman who circulated the proposal. The

decision in the Central as well as the Provincial Legislature should be taken by majority

                                                                                        30
of votes. If a majority of the Provinces support the consideration of the Bill, it should be

placed on the agenda of the originating House for consideration. In case it is passed by

the House with two-thirds majority of the members present and voting, it should be

referred to the other House for similar action. If the latter House also passes the

proposal by a like majority, the amendment should be deemed to have been passed.

(Dr. Mahmood Safdar. (1992).



Conclusion;
The constitutional history of Pakistan is a reflection of all the peculiarities and

contradictions of its social, economic and political development since independence for

more than a quarter of the century. The struggle over particular formulations in various

drafts of the Constitution which went on in the legislative bodies was often an

expression of the clash between the vital interests of the main social groups in Pakistan.

It is not surprising therefore that the struggle over many constitutional issues (the state

language, from of elections, division of powers between the Federation and the

Provinces, etc.) went on for years, leading to bloody clashes in which thousands of

people were victims and often precipitating acute political crises.

The constitution of 1073 was an expression of the balance of class forces established

after the political crises of 1971 and the collapse of the military dictatorship.

The present Constitution of Pakistan is characterized by such fundamental principles as

a parliamentary republican system, federal state structure, and proclamation of

democracy, freedom, equality, tolerance and other bourgeois-democratic freedoms, and

the attainment of social justice as the supreme aim of the state.




                                                                                         31
References
  1. Chaudhry.g.A, (1997).Constitutional History of Pakistan, published by our press,

     Lahore, Pakistan

  2. Mehmood.M, (1995). The Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan,

     published by markazi kutub khana, Lahore, Pakistan

  3. Hassan.u.Masud, (2001). The Constitutional History of Pakistan, printed by

     chaudhary Abdul Sattar press, Lahore, Pakistan

  4. Khan Hamid, (2005). The Constitutional and Political History of Pakistan,

     published by Ameena Saiyed, oxford university press.Landon

  5. Anjum.S.Ahsan, (1983). The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan,

     published by Mian asad Hakim Lahore, Pakistan

  6. Ali Ashfaq, (2004). The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan,

     published by    khusnood Book house, Karachi, Pakistan

  7. Dr.Muhammad.B, (1995). Constitution making in Pakistan, published by Royal

     Book Company, Lahore, Pakistan

  8. Gankovsky.V.Y & Moskalenko.N.V, (1975). The Three Constitutions of Pakistan,

     publishes by Abdur Rauf Malik.Karachi, Pakistan

  9. Dr. Mahmood Safdar. (1992). the constitutional Foundations of Pakistan.

     Published by M.Amin, Lahore, Pakistan

  10. Ishaq.M.Khan. (1973). The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan.

     Published by Khyber Law house, Lahore, Pakistan




                                                                                  32

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados (20)

1970 elections in East & west Pakistan
1970 elections in East & west Pakistan1970 elections in East & west Pakistan
1970 elections in East & west Pakistan
 
CONSTITUTION 1956,1962
CONSTITUTION 1956,1962CONSTITUTION 1956,1962
CONSTITUTION 1956,1962
 
lahore resolution
 lahore resolution lahore resolution
lahore resolution
 
Political culture
Political culturePolitical culture
Political culture
 
1962 constitution
1962 constitution1962 constitution
1962 constitution
 
1956 constitution of Pakistan
1956 constitution of Pakistan1956 constitution of Pakistan
1956 constitution of Pakistan
 
Constitutions of pakistan
Constitutions of pakistanConstitutions of pakistan
Constitutions of pakistan
 
Nehru Report
Nehru ReportNehru Report
Nehru Report
 
8 amendment in 1973 constitution
8 amendment in 1973 constitution8 amendment in 1973 constitution
8 amendment in 1973 constitution
 
East pakistan crisis
East pakistan crisisEast pakistan crisis
East pakistan crisis
 
Lucknow Pact 1916
Lucknow Pact 1916Lucknow Pact 1916
Lucknow Pact 1916
 
Lecture 17 ayub khan period (1958 1969) - copy
Lecture 17 ayub khan period (1958 1969) - copyLecture 17 ayub khan period (1958 1969) - copy
Lecture 17 ayub khan period (1958 1969) - copy
 
Causes of fall of east pakistan
Causes of fall of east pakistanCauses of fall of east pakistan
Causes of fall of east pakistan
 
1935 act
1935 act1935 act
1935 act
 
Ayub regime 1958 to 1969
Ayub regime 1958 to 1969 Ayub regime 1958 to 1969
Ayub regime 1958 to 1969
 
Government systems of pakistan
Government systems of pakistanGovernment systems of pakistan
Government systems of pakistan
 
Federalism in Pakistan
Federalism in PakistanFederalism in Pakistan
Federalism in Pakistan
 
Salient feature of the constitution of 1973
Salient feature of the constitution of 1973Salient feature of the constitution of 1973
Salient feature of the constitution of 1973
 
The constitution of 1962
The constitution of 1962The constitution of 1962
The constitution of 1962
 
Basic principle committee
Basic principle committeeBasic principle committee
Basic principle committee
 

Destaque

Constitutional development of pakistan since 1947 to the (1)
Constitutional development of pakistan since 1947 to the (1)Constitutional development of pakistan since 1947 to the (1)
Constitutional development of pakistan since 1947 to the (1)Muhammad Attique Shah
 
Tamizzudin's Case
Tamizzudin's CaseTamizzudin's Case
Tamizzudin's CaseFazal Akbar
 
5 constitutional development in pakistan 1947 58
5 constitutional development in pakistan 1947 585 constitutional development in pakistan 1947 58
5 constitutional development in pakistan 1947 5813023901-016
 
Constitutions of pakistan
Constitutions of pakistanConstitutions of pakistan
Constitutions of pakistanknowledge1995
 
Constitutional devolopment in pakistan 1947 to 18th Amenment.
Constitutional devolopment in pakistan 1947 to 18th Amenment.Constitutional devolopment in pakistan 1947 to 18th Amenment.
Constitutional devolopment in pakistan 1947 to 18th Amenment.Dr Tahir Jamil
 
1956 constitution of Pakistan
1956 constitution of Pakistan1956 constitution of Pakistan
1956 constitution of PakistanFaizan Shabbir
 
1947-58, Political Developments!
1947-58, Political Developments!1947-58, Political Developments!
1947-58, Political Developments!Mehroze Azeem
 
Pakistan studies notes
Pakistan studies notesPakistan studies notes
Pakistan studies notesDaw Wad
 
Northern renaissance
Northern renaissanceNorthern renaissance
Northern renaissancecugellb
 
Constitutions and political crisis in pakistan (1947-2014)
Constitutions and political crisis in pakistan (1947-2014)Constitutions and political crisis in pakistan (1947-2014)
Constitutions and political crisis in pakistan (1947-2014)Tallat Satti
 
Political History of Pakistan
Political History of PakistanPolitical History of Pakistan
Political History of Pakistanafrinish
 
Constitutional development in pakistan by Ammara Battool iiui
Constitutional development in pakistan by Ammara Battool iiuiConstitutional development in pakistan by Ammara Battool iiui
Constitutional development in pakistan by Ammara Battool iiuiAmmaraAwanKhan
 
Shahbuddin commision its report
Shahbuddin commision its reportShahbuddin commision its report
Shahbuddin commision its reportAbdul Latif
 
Constitutional Development from 1947 to 1958
Constitutional Development from 1947 to 1958Constitutional Development from 1947 to 1958
Constitutional Development from 1947 to 1958S.Saeed H
 
Pakistan Constitutional History from 1947 to 1956
Pakistan Constitutional History from 1947 to 1956Pakistan Constitutional History from 1947 to 1956
Pakistan Constitutional History from 1947 to 1956FaHaD .H. NooR
 
Islamic provision of 1973 constitution in urdu by sohail ahmed solangi
Islamic provision of 1973 constitution in urdu by sohail ahmed solangiIslamic provision of 1973 constitution in urdu by sohail ahmed solangi
Islamic provision of 1973 constitution in urdu by sohail ahmed solangiSohail Ahmed Solangi
 
Political Development from 1947 to 1958
Political Development  from 1947 to 1958Political Development  from 1947 to 1958
Political Development from 1947 to 1958S.Saeed H
 
Constitution of Pakistan and Peoples Rights
Constitution of Pakistan and Peoples RightsConstitution of Pakistan and Peoples Rights
Constitution of Pakistan and Peoples RightsNazeer Mahar
 

Destaque (20)

Constitutional development of pakistan since 1947 to the (1)
Constitutional development of pakistan since 1947 to the (1)Constitutional development of pakistan since 1947 to the (1)
Constitutional development of pakistan since 1947 to the (1)
 
Tamizzudin's Case
Tamizzudin's CaseTamizzudin's Case
Tamizzudin's Case
 
5 constitutional development in pakistan 1947 58
5 constitutional development in pakistan 1947 585 constitutional development in pakistan 1947 58
5 constitutional development in pakistan 1947 58
 
Constitutions of pakistan
Constitutions of pakistanConstitutions of pakistan
Constitutions of pakistan
 
Constitutional devolopment in pakistan 1947 to 18th Amenment.
Constitutional devolopment in pakistan 1947 to 18th Amenment.Constitutional devolopment in pakistan 1947 to 18th Amenment.
Constitutional devolopment in pakistan 1947 to 18th Amenment.
 
1973 constitution
1973 constitution1973 constitution
1973 constitution
 
1956 constitution of Pakistan
1956 constitution of Pakistan1956 constitution of Pakistan
1956 constitution of Pakistan
 
Constitution of pak
Constitution of pakConstitution of pak
Constitution of pak
 
1947-58, Political Developments!
1947-58, Political Developments!1947-58, Political Developments!
1947-58, Political Developments!
 
Pakistan studies notes
Pakistan studies notesPakistan studies notes
Pakistan studies notes
 
Northern renaissance
Northern renaissanceNorthern renaissance
Northern renaissance
 
Constitutions and political crisis in pakistan (1947-2014)
Constitutions and political crisis in pakistan (1947-2014)Constitutions and political crisis in pakistan (1947-2014)
Constitutions and political crisis in pakistan (1947-2014)
 
Political History of Pakistan
Political History of PakistanPolitical History of Pakistan
Political History of Pakistan
 
Constitutional development in pakistan by Ammara Battool iiui
Constitutional development in pakistan by Ammara Battool iiuiConstitutional development in pakistan by Ammara Battool iiui
Constitutional development in pakistan by Ammara Battool iiui
 
Shahbuddin commision its report
Shahbuddin commision its reportShahbuddin commision its report
Shahbuddin commision its report
 
Constitutional Development from 1947 to 1958
Constitutional Development from 1947 to 1958Constitutional Development from 1947 to 1958
Constitutional Development from 1947 to 1958
 
Pakistan Constitutional History from 1947 to 1956
Pakistan Constitutional History from 1947 to 1956Pakistan Constitutional History from 1947 to 1956
Pakistan Constitutional History from 1947 to 1956
 
Islamic provision of 1973 constitution in urdu by sohail ahmed solangi
Islamic provision of 1973 constitution in urdu by sohail ahmed solangiIslamic provision of 1973 constitution in urdu by sohail ahmed solangi
Islamic provision of 1973 constitution in urdu by sohail ahmed solangi
 
Political Development from 1947 to 1958
Political Development  from 1947 to 1958Political Development  from 1947 to 1958
Political Development from 1947 to 1958
 
Constitution of Pakistan and Peoples Rights
Constitution of Pakistan and Peoples RightsConstitution of Pakistan and Peoples Rights
Constitution of Pakistan and Peoples Rights
 

Semelhante a Constitutional development in pakistan by ammara batool iiui

Contitutional development in Pakistan
Contitutional development in PakistanContitutional development in Pakistan
Contitutional development in PakistanZeeshan Murtaza Ali
 
Constitutional Development Of Pakistan
Constitutional Development Of PakistanConstitutional Development Of Pakistan
Constitutional Development Of PakistanDaniyal Munir
 
Concept of constitution polsci slide
Concept of constitution polsci slideConcept of constitution polsci slide
Concept of constitution polsci slideQuenieMalingin
 
Amendments to the constitution discussion paper 7
Amendments to the constitution discussion paper 7Amendments to the constitution discussion paper 7
Amendments to the constitution discussion paper 7Austin Msowoya, Esq
 
Definition of law_1-_jurisprudence
Definition of law_1-_jurisprudenceDefinition of law_1-_jurisprudence
Definition of law_1-_jurisprudenceStudent
 
CHAPT 3 INTRO TO POL SCI.ppt
CHAPT 3 INTRO TO POL SCI.pptCHAPT 3 INTRO TO POL SCI.ppt
CHAPT 3 INTRO TO POL SCI.pptIsmael Buchanan
 
The rule of law with special reference to bangladesh
The rule of law with special reference to bangladeshThe rule of law with special reference to bangladesh
The rule of law with special reference to bangladeshBiman Bangladesh Airlines
 
Federalist Papers No 47, Structure of New Government
Federalist Papers No 47, Structure of New GovernmentFederalist Papers No 47, Structure of New Government
Federalist Papers No 47, Structure of New GovernmentChuck Thompson
 
ANALYZING THE CONSTITUTIONAL RULES OF INTERPRETATION
ANALYZING THE CONSTITUTIONAL RULES OF INTERPRETATIONANALYZING THE CONSTITUTIONAL RULES OF INTERPRETATION
ANALYZING THE CONSTITUTIONAL RULES OF INTERPRETATIONAnushka Singh
 
Separation_of_Powers1_iv_semester.pdf
Separation_of_Powers1_iv_semester.pdfSeparation_of_Powers1_iv_semester.pdf
Separation_of_Powers1_iv_semester.pdf21ECBOA439MusharrafW
 
Concept of constitution
Concept of constitutionConcept of constitution
Concept of constitutionLie Bacani
 
Concept of constitution
Concept of constitutionConcept of constitution
Concept of constitutionLie Bacani
 
The UK legal system 2_JLVieites
The UK legal system 2_JLVieitesThe UK legal system 2_JLVieites
The UK legal system 2_JLVieitesJESUS L. VIEITES
 
Coi 1st and 2nd unit
Coi 1st and 2nd unitCoi 1st and 2nd unit
Coi 1st and 2nd unitraj207209
 
Constitutional governance miniorities and secularism 2
Constitutional governance miniorities and secularism 2Constitutional governance miniorities and secularism 2
Constitutional governance miniorities and secularism 2YOGENDRA VERMA
 
Law - sources & types, part of planning legislation
Law - sources & types, part of planning legislationLaw - sources & types, part of planning legislation
Law - sources & types, part of planning legislationChhabiYadav2
 
Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...
Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...
Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...sundarsasane
 

Semelhante a Constitutional development in pakistan by ammara batool iiui (20)

Constitutional development
Constitutional developmentConstitutional development
Constitutional development
 
Contitutional development in Pakistan
Contitutional development in PakistanContitutional development in Pakistan
Contitutional development in Pakistan
 
Constitutional Development Of Pakistan
Constitutional Development Of PakistanConstitutional Development Of Pakistan
Constitutional Development Of Pakistan
 
Concept of constitution polsci slide
Concept of constitution polsci slideConcept of constitution polsci slide
Concept of constitution polsci slide
 
Constitution timmy
Constitution timmyConstitution timmy
Constitution timmy
 
Amendments to the constitution discussion paper 7
Amendments to the constitution discussion paper 7Amendments to the constitution discussion paper 7
Amendments to the constitution discussion paper 7
 
Concepts of constitution
Concepts of constitutionConcepts of constitution
Concepts of constitution
 
Definition of law_1-_jurisprudence
Definition of law_1-_jurisprudenceDefinition of law_1-_jurisprudence
Definition of law_1-_jurisprudence
 
CHAPT 3 INTRO TO POL SCI.ppt
CHAPT 3 INTRO TO POL SCI.pptCHAPT 3 INTRO TO POL SCI.ppt
CHAPT 3 INTRO TO POL SCI.ppt
 
The rule of law with special reference to bangladesh
The rule of law with special reference to bangladeshThe rule of law with special reference to bangladesh
The rule of law with special reference to bangladesh
 
Federalist Papers No 47, Structure of New Government
Federalist Papers No 47, Structure of New GovernmentFederalist Papers No 47, Structure of New Government
Federalist Papers No 47, Structure of New Government
 
ANALYZING THE CONSTITUTIONAL RULES OF INTERPRETATION
ANALYZING THE CONSTITUTIONAL RULES OF INTERPRETATIONANALYZING THE CONSTITUTIONAL RULES OF INTERPRETATION
ANALYZING THE CONSTITUTIONAL RULES OF INTERPRETATION
 
Separation_of_Powers1_iv_semester.pdf
Separation_of_Powers1_iv_semester.pdfSeparation_of_Powers1_iv_semester.pdf
Separation_of_Powers1_iv_semester.pdf
 
Concept of constitution
Concept of constitutionConcept of constitution
Concept of constitution
 
Concept of constitution
Concept of constitutionConcept of constitution
Concept of constitution
 
The UK legal system 2_JLVieites
The UK legal system 2_JLVieitesThe UK legal system 2_JLVieites
The UK legal system 2_JLVieites
 
Coi 1st and 2nd unit
Coi 1st and 2nd unitCoi 1st and 2nd unit
Coi 1st and 2nd unit
 
Constitutional governance miniorities and secularism 2
Constitutional governance miniorities and secularism 2Constitutional governance miniorities and secularism 2
Constitutional governance miniorities and secularism 2
 
Law - sources & types, part of planning legislation
Law - sources & types, part of planning legislationLaw - sources & types, part of planning legislation
Law - sources & types, part of planning legislation
 
Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...
Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...
Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...
 

Constitutional development in pakistan by ammara batool iiui

  • 1. Table of Content: Constitution, Its Meaning, Kinds and Rules Of Interpertation.......................................... 2 Islamic point of view about constitution: ........................................................................... 6 Constitution making ............................................................................................................ 7 Constitutional history of Pakistan: ..................................................................................... 8 Constitution of 1956: ......................................................................................................... 21 Constitution of 1962: ......................................................................................................... 23 Constitution of 1973 .......................................................................................................... 25 Amendment of constitution .............................................................................................. 29 Procedure for Amendment of the Constitution ................................................................ 30 Conclusion; ........................................................................................................................ 31 References ......................................................................................................................... 32 1
  • 2. Constitution, Its Meaning, inds and Rules of Interpertation: Constitution is the fundamental law of the land and it is from this source that all the laws spring. This law can be made or altered not in the manner of ordinary laws but in a much different way, that is, by a defined authority and in the prescribed manner. As far as Muslim states, particularly Pakistan, are concerned the laws are not derived from the constitution but from the Almighty Allah who has revealed them in his book and which have been interpreted and explained by Holy Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) through his sayings. Conduct and actual practice. For practical purpose we can assume that laws which are not repugnant to the holy Quran and Sunnah have to be framed under the authority of the constitution and cannot be antagonistic to its command and spirit. (Anjum.S.Ahsan.1983) Forms of Constitution: A constitution may be unwritten. As for instance the English Constitution which mostly consist of constitutional as ages, traditions and conventions, or written, as most of the modern constitutions are. Or partly unwritten. A written constitution is usually rigid and inflexible in as much as, intended to be permanent, it does not admit of alteration by ordinary legislative process and requires some extraordinary procedure for its amendment. A constitution may be Unitarian or federal according to whether power resets in the centre or is distributed between it and the federating units. A Unitarian constitution is flexible if it can be amended by ordinary legislative process and rigid if it requires a special procedure for its alteration. (Anjum.S.Ahsan.1983) 2
  • 3. Kinds of Constitution: Federal and unitary constitutions This classification is based on the principle by which the powers of government and the constitution government established for its constituent parts. Under a federal constitution there is a scheme of distribution of powers between the central and local units which are to a certain extent independent within their own territorial limits. The central government has its own sphere of operation of its laws, while the federating units are governed by their own laws. No one is subordinate nor are acts as an agent of the other, e.g. the constitution of Switzerland, Australia and India. In the unitary constitution the legislature of the whole country is the supreme law making body which may permit other legislatures to exist subordinates to it. Sweden, New Zealand, France, have unitary constitutions. Republican and monarchical( Autocratic )constitutions Constitutions are sometimes classified into “republican” and |”monarchical”. There is difference between popular or democratic government as opposed to an autocracy or dictatorship which established absolutism of the executive. It is difficult to find today even one solitary example of the latter type of the constitution. A republican constitution on the other hand illustrates almost every system of government from democracy to dictatorship. 3
  • 4. Conventional The English constitution is based largely upon rules of practice, or convention. Many of the rules of the English constitutional government possess merely a conventional character. This is shown by the fact that no legal proceedings can be taken for a breach of their established terms, since they are merely matters of practice. The conventions of the constitution are in the last resort founded upon the law of the land; and they have their sanction in the force of law. Unitary The English constitution involves one central government which pervades the whole country. Flexible In flexible constitution every law of every description can legally be changed with the same ease and in the same manner by one and the same body. A flexible constitution is likely to be unstable due to its capacity to undergo constant changes. But at the same time there is this advantage that it facilitates all necessary changes required by the changing political and economic ideas and circumstances, and secures the growth of the constitution without the possibility of any revolution. The English constitution with the supremacy of parliament is an instance of a flexible constitution. 4
  • 5. Rigid A rigid constitution on the other hand is one under which certain laws cannot be changed in the same manner as ordinary laws. They can be altered or amended by the special machinery provided in the constitution itself. (Anjum.S.Ahsan.1983) Rules to interpret of a Constitution: The constitution is fundamental or organic or supreme law standing on a somewhat higher position than the other laws of the country. The constitution is the source from which all governmental power emanates and it defines its scope and ambit so that each functionary should act within his respective sphere. The courts are components of the constitution; they derive their powers and jurisdictions from the constitution and must confine themselves within the limits set by the constitution. Under a constitution prescribing a system where there is a tracheotomy of sovereign powers the judicial power must from the very nature of things is vested in a judiciary. Thus the judiciary does claim and has always claimed that it has the right to interpret the constitution and to say as to what a particular provision of the constitution means or does not mean even if it is a provision seeking to oust its own jurisdiction. 5
  • 6. In the latter case an ouster of jurisdiction is not to be readily inferred, because, the consistent rule is that provisions seeking to oust the jurisdiction of superior courts, even by a constitutional provision, are to be construed strictly with a pronounced learning against ouster. It is not, however, the function of the judiciary to legislate or to question the wisdom of the law giver if the law has been competently made without transgressing the limitations of the constitution. If a law has been competently made the judiciary cannot refuse to enforce it even if the result be to nullify its own decisions. The law-giver has also very right to change, emend or clarify the law if the judiciary has found that the language used conveyed by the law-giver. The constitution has to be construed like other document reading it as a whole and giving to every part therefore a meaning consistent with the other provisions of the constitution. As far as possible each provision of the constitution should be construed so as to harmonies with all the others. (Anjum.S.Ahsan.1983) Islamic point of view about constitution: The first Muslim constitution was promulgated by the holy prophet of Islam Mohammad (pbuh) when he migrated to madina and foundation was laid for the government of a city state. This constitution was framed and put into effect with the full consensus of not only the followers of the prophet Mohammad (pbuh) but also had the concurrence of the Jews and other non-converts. The constitution thus framed gave the details of the rights and duties of the ruler and the ruled. 6
  • 7. The characteristic of Muslim administration had been that the people including the rulers were subject to shariat and it was enforced with greater force of equity, justice and good conscience in the case of those who did not embrace the faith of Islam. Such notions as “the king can do no wrong”, “the king cannot be tried in his own court”, “act of state” and “privilege” etc, are unknown to Islamic jurisprudence. Even the first four rightly guided caliphs had great respect for the law and would humbly appear before the Qazi if ever such an occasion arose. Muslim theologians and jurists believe in the supremacy of the law as laid down in the holy Quran and interpreted by Sunnah and hold it to be eternal and immutable. This law was therefore the actual sovereign in Muslim lands. Sovereignty, says the Holy Quran, belongs to almighty Allah alone and the authority to be exercised by the state is therefore a sacred trust on behalf of Allah and must be exercised within the limits prescribed by Him. (Mehmood.M,1995). Constitution making The constituent assembly of Pakistan could not, frame a constitution during the lifetime of the quaid-e-azam. In March 1949 a resolution known as the objectives Resolution came to be passed by unanimous vote of the house. This resolution merely enunciated the principles or guidelines on which the constitution was to be framed and could well be regarded as the preamble of the constitution of Pakistan. The constitution – making went on till in 1954 a draft of the constitution was prepared with the leaders of the various groups in the assembly but in October, 1054 Mr. Ghulam Muhammad, the then Governor- General, put armed guards outside the assembly hall, 7
  • 8. dissolved the constituent assembly by proclamation and allowed none to enter the premises so as to pass the constitution. This step was taken by him to keep his gaddi intact and for life, because he knew full well that he would have to vacate the office in favor of the duly elected representative of the people. Maulvi Tamizuddin Khan, the speaker of the Constituent Assembly challenged his resolution in the chief court of sindh and sought for a declaration that the orders of the Governor-General were unauthorized, unconstitutional, and illegal and without force. The Chief court issued a write restraining the governor- General. The matter went up in appeal to the Federal Court headed by justice Munir who allowed the appeal and dismissed the writ petition. The federal court judgment in us if paatel case observed that the first concern of the Government would have been to bring into existence another representative body to exercise the powers of the Constituent Assembly so that all invalid legislation could have been immediately validated by the new body. Acting on this advice a new Constituent Assembly was elected by the members of the Provincial Assemblies on basis of proportional representation and this Assembly succeeded in framing a Constitution in 1956. (Dr.Muhammad.B, 1995) Constitutional history of Pakistan: The constitutional history of Pakistan is full of turmoil and toil. It may be said to have commenced from Indian independence act, 1947 but there are certain important 8
  • 9. enactments which tell us at least a part of story and furnish implied source of historical background. Indian act 1858: Although the war of independence 1857, could not achieve the object for which it was fought but it certainly put an end to the rule of East India Company. It was realized that a trading company whose main objective was profit could not be entrusted with the work of administration of a sub-continent like India. A bill was introduced by Lord Palmerstone for the better Government of India in Parliament, which was passed and became Government of India Act 1858, the first most important constitutional document in the history of sub-continent. This act abolished the East India Company and transferred the government of India from the hands of East India Company to the Crown. The Act of 1858 mainly provided: 1. India shall be governed by and in the name of Queen. The Governor-General came to be known as the Viceroy. 2. The Board of Control and Court of Directors were abolished and all the powers possessed by them were given to the Secretary of State for India and his Indian Council. 3. The Secretary of State was to preside over the meetings of the Indian Council. He was declared to be corporate body which could sue and be sued. Indian Council’s Act 1861: 9
  • 10. The act of 1858 which transferred the Government of India into the hands of the Crown did not make any change in the Indian administration. It was therefore necessary that something should be done to reform the Indian machinery also. That was done by the Act of 1861. 1. The Act empowered the Governor-General to delegate special business to individual members of the Executive Council. 2. The Executive Council of the Governor-General was strengthened. 3. The Governments of Bombay and Madras where given the power of nominating the Advocate-General and additional members of the Executive Council for the purpose of legislation. 4. No distinction was made between the central and provincial subjects. However, subjects concerning public debt, finances, currency, post-office, telegraph, religion, patents and copyright were ordinary put under the control of the Central Government. 5. The governor-General was given the power to create new provinces. He was also given the power to appoint lieutenant-Governors. He was also authorized to divide the limits of any presidency and province. The Indian Council Act 1861 marked an important step in the constitutional history of Indo-Pakistan. It made a beginning in representative institutions and legislative devolution. Herein the policy of association was given effect to. However, it may be noted that the non-official members of the Council were nominated by the Viceroy ad not elected by the people. The legislative power given to these Councils was very wide but was put under severe restrictions. The non-official members had practically no say 10
  • 11. in the matter. In this way, the Act of 1861 was defective and required improvements of representative institutions. Indian Council’s Act of 1892: 1. This Act enlarged the functions of the Legislative Councils. They were authorized to discuss the annual financial statement under certain conditions and restrictions. 2. The members of the Council were given the right of addressing questions to the Government on matters of public interest. 3. The number of additional members in the council was increased subject to certain restrictions and rules made by Governor-General. 4. As a result of the pressure brought by the Indian National Congress, the principle of elected members was accepted. But the elected members could only take their seats if nominated by the Governor-General. Mehmood.M, (1995). Minto-Marley Reforms 1909: The discontented people of the sub-continent were not satisfied with the hollow provisions of the Act of 1892, with the result that the period between 1892 to 1909 was one of storm and stress. The people resented autocratic attitude of the Government. The agitation against the partition of Bengal was widespread. In 1906 a Muslim deputation, headed by H.H. the Agha Khan waited upon Lord Minto and demanded separate representation of Muslims. In December 1909 the Nawab of Dacca appealed to the Muslims of India to form the All India Muslim Confederacy’. Lord Minto, the then 11
  • 12. Viceroy of India took a serious note of the situation and reported the matter to the Home Government. In December, 1906 Lord Morley introduced his famous Bill in the House of Lords. The Bill was passed in 1909 as the India Council Act. 1. The Act of 1909 enlarged the size of Legislative Council. 2. It was provided that the imperial Legislative Council shall consist of 37 official and 32 non- 0fficial members. 3. It was decided that there would be no official majority in the provincial Legislative Councils but such majority was considered essential in the Central Legislature. 4. The principle of territorial representation was not accepted. “Representation by classes and benefit was considered to be the only practical method of embodying the elective principle in the constitution of the Indian Legislative Council.” The Act provided for separate or extraordinary electorates for the due representation of the different communities, classes and benefit. 5. The functions of the Legislative Councils were increased. Described rules were made for the discussion of the budget in the Imperial Legislative Council. Every member was given the right to move any resolution relating to any alteration in taxation, any new loans or any additional grant to local Governments proposed or mentioned in the financial statement or explanatory memorandum. However, the Council was not permitted to discuss expenditure on interest, on debt, ecclesiastical expenditure and State Railway etc. 6. The members were given the right of asking question and supplementary questions for the purpose of further elucidating any point. 12
  • 13. 7. The members were given the power to move resolutions in the Councils. 8. Rules were framed for the discussion of matters of general public interest in the Legislative Councils. But no discussion was permitted on any subject not within the competence of the particular Legislature, any matter affecting the relations of the Government of India with a Foreign Power or a native state, and any matter under adjudication by a court of law. 9. In the provinces, Landlords, district Boards and Municipalities and Chambers of Commerce were to select members. 10. Muslims were given separate representation. Muslim members of the legislation were elected by the Muslims themselves. (Khan Hamid, 2005) Government of India Act 1919: The preamble of the Government of India Act 1919 stated that it was the declared policy of the British Parliament to provide for increasing association of Indians in every branch of administration and for the gradual development of self-governing institutions, with a view of the progressive realization of responsible government in British India. However, it said, progress in giving effect to this policy could only be achieved in successive stages. Some of the main provisions of the Government of India Act, 1919 were as under: 1. The Act provided that the Secretary of State for India was to be paid out of British revenues. The Secretary of State continued to possess and perform the duty of superintendence, direction, and control upon the affairs of India. The 13
  • 14. Governor-General of India was obliged to carry out the orders of the Secretary of State. 2. The Act set up a bicameral legislature at the centre in place of the imperial Council consisting of one house. The two Houses were called Central Legislative Assembly and the Council of State. 3. Direct elections were provided for both houses of the Central Legislative though the franchise was very restricted. 4. The duration of the term for the Central Legislative Assembly was three years, and for the Council of State five years, which could be extended by the Governor-General. The Governor-General had the power to summon, prorogue, and dissolve the houses of the Central Legislature. He could also address both houses. 5. The Central Legislature had the power to make laws for all of British India, for Indian subjects wherever they might be, and for all persons employed in the defense forces. It could also repeal or emend laws for the time being in force. However, prior sanction of the Secretary of State-in-Council was required to pass a law abolishing any High Court. Prior sanction of the Governor-General was required to introduce bills on the following subjects: The public profit or public revenues of India. Religion or religious rites and usages of British subjects in India. Discipline or maintenance of the land. Relations of the government of India with foreign states or Indian states. Any measures repealing or emending any Act of Legislature or any Ordinance passed by the Governor-General. 14
  • 15. The governor-General could also prevent consideration of a Bill or a part of it if, in his opinion, it affects the safety or tranquility of British India, or any part therefore. 6. The Governor-General could issue an Ordinance for a period of six months which had the same force and effect as an Act of the Central Legislature. He had the power of veto over the Bills passed by the Central Legislature. 7. The Central Budget was presented before the Central Legislature in the form of demands for grants. There were certain non-votable items which were not open to discussion unless the Governor-General so allowed. All other items were submitted to vote. In an emergency, the Governor-General was empowered to authorize such expenditure as, in his opinion, was necessary for the safety or tranquility of British India or any part before. (Hassan.u.Masud,2001) The Government of India Act 1935: The Act was a comprehensive statue running into 321 sections and two schedules. It was a comprehensive written Constitution given to India by its colonial masters. That was partly due to the fact that the Act dealt with a highly complex type of a federal constitution and also because it sought to provide legal safeguards against misbehavior on the part of the Indian Ministers and the legislature. Special features of the Act of 1935:  The acceptance of an All India Federation.  The introduction of partial responsibility in the form of diarchy at the Centre. 15
  • 16.  The grant of autonomy to the provinces.  Safeguards, reservations, special responsibilities, overriding Powers, etc.in the hands of the Governors and the governor-General.  Creation of a Federal Court, Federal Railway authority, the reserve Bank of India, public service Commission for the Federation and provinces. Complexity of the scheme: Although the government of India act, 1935, is considered to be a masterpiece of draftsmanship, it is the most complicated instrument in the whole history of Constitutional development in India. The complexity arises from various reasons, the chief of which is unique nature of the problem which the scheme was designed to solve. Basic purposes of the act: There were three basic purposes of the Act:- i. Establishment of a Federation. ii. Provincial autonomy with parliamentary Government. iii. The separation of Burma from India. Provisions: Provincial Autonomy: It introduced responsible governments in the provinces which came to be known as provincial autonomy. Under it the whole provincial administration, with certain 16
  • 17. reservations, was transferred to the control of Indian Ministers, working on cabinet principles, responsible to provincial Legislatures. All India Federation: The Act also proposed to abolish the unitary front of government which had been working in India since the regulating Act. Its place was to be taken by an All India Federation compromising 11 provinces (Governors) and 5 provinces (Chief Commissioners) plus such states, as were willing to join the Federation. Thus for the first time the whole of India including Indian states was to be integrated under one Constitution. Diarchy at the Centre: The act proposed to establish Diarchy at the centre, i.e. Diarchy was to be abolished in the provinces, only to be crated at the centre. The central administration was to be divided into two parts. One part to be in charge of the Councilors, responsible to the Governor General alone, and it included some key departments. Safeguards: Lastly were safeguards of special responsibilities. Under the Act, entire Provincial administration was given to Indian Ministers, but the Governor was given certain special powers of interference which could be used whenever necessary. In certain cased he could act o discretion without consulting Ministers, yet in other cased, he could act on his individual judgment, consult has Ministers but take decision independently. In addition to these exceptions, the Governor was charged with special responsibilities regarding peace and other within his 17
  • 18. jurisdiction protection of the rights of minorities. All India service Indian States and prevention of discrimination against the British subjects and British firms. All such precautionary measures were known as special responsibility of the Governor or his safeguards. Rigid Constitution… The constitution of 1935 was rigid. The British Government Alone was given the authority to emend the constitution. (Dr. Mahmood Safdar. 1992). Constitution making 1947 to 1956 The modified Government of India Act (1935) became the Interim Constitution of Pakistan in1947. The Constituent Assembly (CA) was given the task of framing the Constitution. The process began with the passing of the Objectives Resolution in which the Islamic and democratic values were adopted as grounds for the future constitution. The Basic Principles Committee (BPC) consisting of 24 members was made to work for the constitution. The various sub-committees on Federal and provincial duties, Franchise, Judiciary, and Fundamental Rights started working. Board of Talimat-i- Islamia was also set to look for advice on the religious matters. First Basic Principle Committee Report, 1950 1: The Objectives Resolution to be built-in in the Constitution as the order principles. 2: Legislature: Two houses of the parliament. Upper: (House of Units) Equal representation for the units 18
  • 19. Lower: (House of People) On the basis of Population. Both the Houses would benefit from the same power. 3: The Head of State elected by joint session would be for five years (Two times only). President had optional and emergency, appointment and other powers. President was not responsible to give answer to anyone, might be a Muslim or non-Muslim, would be assist by the Prime Minister (PM) and Cabinet that would be responsible to the CA. Parliament may charge him by 2/3 majority. He was given the power to break the constitution. 4: Cabinet responsible to both the Houses. 5: No mention of national language Criticism: This report was severely criticized throughout the country. It could not suit both the wings, East and West. The religious group objects that the report contained nothing about Islamisation. On the question of depiction, the East Pakistan (EP) protested that their majority had been denied by the Report. They remark that they were thrown into a permanent minority. The population of EP was a little larger than that of the West Pakistan (WP) but it was treated as the Small provinces because both the Houses were given equal power. So the authority of WP was intolerable for the East wing. The language problem proves dissident to the national solidarity. The Eastern Pakistanis destined the proposal that made Urdu as official language. Second Basic Principle Committee Report, 1952 1. Head of State would be Muslim and no change in powers. 2. Equal representation to East and West wings: 19
  • 20. UH (Upper House) 60, 60 LH 200, 200 3. More powers were given to Lower House. Cabinet was made responsible to Lower House. 4. It was promised that law making would be in accordance with ISLAM. No law would be made in disobedience of Islamic principles. 5. Advisory Board of five Islamic scholars was founded. 6. Quiet on national language. Criticism: The politicians particularly from the Punjab deplore the Report because configuration of the UH on the basis of representation was not suitable. It was stated against the principle of federation. The WP superior equality only for Upper House. The political crisis removed Prime Minister Nazimuddin and attention unfocused from the main issue. Constituent Assembly Dissolution In October 1954, GG (Governor General) dissolved the CA that was challenged in the Sindh court by Maulvi Tamizuddin. The court confirmed the dissolution illegal but the Federal Court upholds the GG action but asked for setting up an elected CA. 2nd Constituent Assembly, June-July 1955 Ghulam Muhammad called a Convention on May 10, 1955. All its members were to be elected not directly (by the provincial assemblies). In this way, the 2nd CA came into survival One Unit Scheme, October 1955 The presence of different provinces in the WP had complicated the issue of the WP representation in the CA. It was handled by uniting all the WP units into ONE (One 20
  • 21. Unit, October 30, 1955). Now both the parts had become two units and could be addressed equally. (Dr.Muhammad.B, 1995) Constitution-making One Unit scheme helped the task of constitution making to achieve successfully. The previous committees report helped the new Assembly that completed its work and presented in the 2nd CA on January 9, 1956. It, with certain amendments, was approved on January 29, 1956 and imposed on March 23. With this Pakistan had become an Islamic Republic. Constitution of 1956: The first constitution of the country was enforced on 23rd march, 1956. The main points of this constitution are as follows: 1. Pakistan was to be federal republic based on Islamic Ideology. 2. A detailed and comprehensive list of fundamental rights with an Independent Judiciary was provided in the constitution. 3. The system of the parliamentary form of government was adopted both at the Centre and in the provinces. 4. There was distribution of powers between the Centre and the provinces. 5. The constitution provided for Pakistan, wherein equality between East and West wings had been maintained. 6. For the distribution of subjects between the centre and the provinces, three lists of subject had been drawn up. 7. There was a special procedure to be adopted for the amendment of the constitution, yet it was the least rigid constitution. It was reasonably flexible. 21
  • 22. 8. It had provided for two National languages Urdu for the West Pakistan and Bengali for the East Pakistan. 9. Instead of double citizenship, one citizenship system was provided for the Federation of Pakistan. 10. The constitution was silent as to be method of conducting elections both for the Central and the Provincial legislatures. 11. And finally, there were the Islamic characters of the constitution. Islamic provisions of the 1956 constitution: i. The name of the country will be Islamic republic of Pakistan. ii. The preamble of the constitution embodied the sovereignty of God Almighty. iii. The Head of the State shall be a Muslim. iv. Islamic Advisory Council shall be set up. v. No Law detrimental to Islam shall be enacted. The political conditions of the country could not be improved even after the first constitution was enforced. The political instability remained rampant. The elections could not be held till 1858. The constitution invited criticism from certain quarters. Martial Law was declared in the Country on 8th October, 1958. General Ayub, commander in chief of the Army, took over the government and became the Head of the State on 27th October 1958. After taking over President Ayub Khan set up a constitutional commission under justice Shahab-ud-Din to suggest recommendation for the new constitution of the country. The commission after through and lengthy discussion submitted its report on 6th March 1961. 22
  • 23. The report was examined by president. In its report the commission highlighted the reasons of the failure of parliamentary democracy in Pakistan. It fixed the responsibility for the debacle of democracy on the lack of dedicated leadership, absence of well organized political parties and the self aggrandizement of the greedy politicians. In the view of the recommendation of the commission a new constitution was not framed by a constitutional body which was elected nor did it enjoy popular support. The constitution was thrust upon the people in an undemocratic and authoritarian manner. (Mehmood.M, (1995). Constitution of 1962: Salient Features of the Constitution 1. Title of the State will be Islamic Republic of Pakistan. 2. A Powerful President who was responsible for administration and affairs of the state. He should be a Muslim, no less than 40 years of age, should be capable to be a member of NA. He would be elected through not direct elections for a time of five years. If he has held office for more than 8 years, he could look for reelection with the support of the NA and the PAs.National Assembly was given the power to charge the president, however it was difficult to achieve. President could dissolve the NA but in that case he must seek re-election. 3. President was the central point of all the Executive, Legislative and Judicial powers. Cabinet was responsible to him. All key appointments were to be made by President. He could issue Ordinances. He could also announce State of Emergency in the country. 23
  • 24. 4. NA was consisted of one house on the basis of principle of parity between two wings of the country. There were 150 seats plus 6 seats were reserved for women. All were elected indirectly. For the membership minimum age limit was 25 years. 5. NA had all the powers of law making but law was to be finally ratified by the president. President could sign, reject or return the bill. 6. Financial Powers of NA were limited. Only new expenses could be voted. NA could not reject join Fund List and Recurring Expenditure. 7. There were two provinces of the federation: East Pakistan and West Pakistan. Only one list of subjects, i.e. the Central list was given in the constitution. 8. Governors were head of the provinces and govern the province with his cabinet. Provincial governments were directly under the control of President. There was a strong center with a Powerful President. He had enough powers to manage provincial affairs. In case of emergency powers Central government could take direct control of the province. 9. Principles of Policy • National solidarity would be observed. • Interests of backward people would be looked after. • Opportunities for participation in national life. • Education and well being of people. • Islam would be implemented in day to day life. 10. Fundamental Rights were provided in the constitution. 11. Originally Political Parties were not allowed. Political Parties Act was introduced in 1962. 24
  • 25. 12. Objectives Resolution was the Preamble of the Constitution. Other Islamic provisions were a part of Principles of Policy and not the constitution. 13. An Advisory Council for Islamic Ideology was made in the constitution having 5- 12 members. It was a recommendatory body. 14. It was designed for the Research and instructions in Islam for assisting the reconstruction of Muslim society on truly Islamic lines. Constitution remained enforced from June 8, 1962 to March 25, 1969. (Gankovsky.V.Y & Moskalenko.N.V, (1975). Constitution of 1973 Background Abrogation of the 1962 Constitution on March 25, 1969 led to second martial law in the country. Yahya Khan handed over power to Zulfikar Ali Bhutto on December 20, 1971 after the first general elections. But martial law continued and there was no constitution. National Assembly approved a temporary Constitution, which was imposed on April 21, 1972. Constitution Making Constitutional Committee comprising National Assembly (NA) members from all parties was set up in April 1972. Law Minister was the Chairman of this Committee. All parties agreed on the future political system in October 1972. The Committee reported on December 31, 1972. After long deliberations and compromises final draft was approved commonly on April 10, 1973. The new Constitution was imposed on August 14, 1973. The Constitution functioned since then with two gaps. It remained operational during following periods: 25
  • 26. 1973-77: Operational 1977-1985: Suspended 1985-1999: Operational after changes 1999-2002: Suspended 2002 onwards Operational after changes Features of the Constitution 1. Parliamentary System It was a parliamentary constitution having powerful Prime Minister (PM) as head of government with a very weak President. President must act on the advice of PM. All his orders were to be countersigned by PM. Prime Minister to be elected by the NA. PM exercised all executive authority. PM was answerable to the NA. In 1985, powers of the President were increased. He enjoyed some discretion in appointments of PM. He had power to break up the NA. He had the powers of appointment of caretaker PM. He gives his assent to bills passed by the parliament or returns these. 2. President: Must be at least 45 years of age, Muslim, qualified to become member of the NA. He is elected by the Parliament and the Provincial Assemblies for 5 years. 3. Parliament with two houses: • Upper House called Senate. In this house equal representation is given to Provinces. Seats are reserved for the tribal areas, women and technocrats. Its original strength was 63, which was later raised to 87 and then 100. Senate is elected indirectly. It’s a permanent House as half of its members are elected after three years. 26
  • 27. • Lower House: National Assembly is elected on population basis. Its Original strength was 210 but now it is 342. NA is elected for five years. • Senate: Indirect elections • National Assembly: Direct elections • Voting age for the franchise is lowered from 21 to 18. • Parliament under 1973 constitution is a powerful legislative body. It enjoys all legislative powers. It has control of the executive through questions, resolutions, parliamentary committees etc. • National Assembly is more powerful than the Senate. Budget is presented before NA. Cabinet is answerable to National Assembly. 4. Federal System Federation of Pakistan has four provinces and federally administered areas. Two lists are given in the constitution: Federal list and Concurrent list. Residuary powers belong To provinces. 5. Provincial Structure: Provincial Governors are appointed by the President on the advice of the PM. Elected Chief Minister exercises executive powers. Parliamentary system is there in the provinces. Size of the provincial assemblies varies: In 2002: Punjab 371 Sindh 168 NWFP 124 Balochistan 65 27
  • 28. Enough provincial independence is guaranteed. Tradition of strong centre continues. Centre has emergency powers. Governor’s rule can be forced if the government cannot function in the provinces. Provinces are dependent on centre for Finances. 6. Principles of Policy: Islamic provisions are provided in Principles of Policy. 7. Fundamental Rights: Fundamental Rights are protected in the constitution and are implemented through the highest court. 8. Islamic Provisions: Title of the state is Islamic Republic of Pakistan. The objectives resolution was the Preamble in the initial constitution but through article 2-A of 8th amendment it was inserted in the constitution in 1985. Islam was declared the State Religion of Pakistan. Definition of Muslim was included by an amendment. Principles of Policy also carry some Islamic clauses. Council for Islamic Ideology is recognized under the constitution. Federal Shariat Court was added in 1981. 9. National Language: Urdu is declared National Language, however English may be used for official purposes until preparations would be made for its replacement by Urdu. Provincial Assembly may prescribe measures for teaching, promotion and use of a provincial language in addition to the national language. 10. National Security Council: National Security Council was added in 2002 in advisory capacity. 28
  • 29. 11. Judiciary: An independent judiciary is given under the constitution. Supreme Court of Pakistan is the highest court. One High Court is established in each province and one in Azad Kashmir. A chain of lower courts is there under the high courts. 12. Rigid A constitution is rigid or flexible can be tested by seeing the procedure laid down for its change or amendment. A flexible Constitution can legally be amended by the same process of law-making as an ordinary law, while in a rigid Constitution specific machinery is provided in itself by which any change or amendment can be effected. (Ishaq.M.Khan. (1973). Amendment of constitution I. A bill to amendment the constitution shall create in the national Assembly and when the Bill has been passed by the votes of not less than two-thirds of the total membership of Assembly it shall be transferred to the senate. II. If a Bill is passed by the senate with amendments it shall be reconsidered by the National Assembly; and if the Bill as amended by the Senate is passed by the Assembly by the votes of not less than two-thirds of the total membership of the Assembly, it shall be presented to the President for the assent. III. If the Bill is passed by the Senate by a majority of the total membership of the Senate it shall be presented to the President for assent. IV. If the Bill is not passed by the Senate within ninety days from the day of its receipt the Bill shall be deemed to have been rejected by the senate. 29
  • 30. V. The President shall assent to the Bill within seven days of the presentation of the Bill to him, and if he fails to do so he shall be deemed to have assented thereto at the expiration of that period. VI. When the President has assented to or is deemed to have assented to the Bill, the Bill shall become Act of Parliament and the Constitution shall stand amended in accordance with the terms thereof. VII. A bill to amend the Constitution which would have the effect of altering the limits of a Province shall not be passed by the National Assembly of that Province passed by the votes of not less than two-thirds of the total membership of that Assembly. Procedure for Amendment of the Constitution The Committee is of the view that the process of amending the constitution should be made difficult. It is accordingly decided that the following procedure should be recommended. If a notice is received signed by than one-third of the Members of a House seeking permission for the circulation of their motion for amendment of the Constitution amongst the Provinces for opinion, it should be placed on the agenda of the House concerned and considered. In case it is passed by a majority, the matter should be referred to the other House for consideration for the same purpose. When permission is granted by the second House, the proposal should be circulated to the Provinces by the chairman of the House in which it is initiated. The chairman of the legislature of every province, by whom the proposal is received for consideration, should convey the decision of the respective Legislature to the Chairman who circulated the proposal. The decision in the Central as well as the Provincial Legislature should be taken by majority 30
  • 31. of votes. If a majority of the Provinces support the consideration of the Bill, it should be placed on the agenda of the originating House for consideration. In case it is passed by the House with two-thirds majority of the members present and voting, it should be referred to the other House for similar action. If the latter House also passes the proposal by a like majority, the amendment should be deemed to have been passed. (Dr. Mahmood Safdar. (1992). Conclusion; The constitutional history of Pakistan is a reflection of all the peculiarities and contradictions of its social, economic and political development since independence for more than a quarter of the century. The struggle over particular formulations in various drafts of the Constitution which went on in the legislative bodies was often an expression of the clash between the vital interests of the main social groups in Pakistan. It is not surprising therefore that the struggle over many constitutional issues (the state language, from of elections, division of powers between the Federation and the Provinces, etc.) went on for years, leading to bloody clashes in which thousands of people were victims and often precipitating acute political crises. The constitution of 1073 was an expression of the balance of class forces established after the political crises of 1971 and the collapse of the military dictatorship. The present Constitution of Pakistan is characterized by such fundamental principles as a parliamentary republican system, federal state structure, and proclamation of democracy, freedom, equality, tolerance and other bourgeois-democratic freedoms, and the attainment of social justice as the supreme aim of the state. 31
  • 32. References 1. Chaudhry.g.A, (1997).Constitutional History of Pakistan, published by our press, Lahore, Pakistan 2. Mehmood.M, (1995). The Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan, published by markazi kutub khana, Lahore, Pakistan 3. Hassan.u.Masud, (2001). The Constitutional History of Pakistan, printed by chaudhary Abdul Sattar press, Lahore, Pakistan 4. Khan Hamid, (2005). The Constitutional and Political History of Pakistan, published by Ameena Saiyed, oxford university press.Landon 5. Anjum.S.Ahsan, (1983). The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, published by Mian asad Hakim Lahore, Pakistan 6. Ali Ashfaq, (2004). The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, published by khusnood Book house, Karachi, Pakistan 7. Dr.Muhammad.B, (1995). Constitution making in Pakistan, published by Royal Book Company, Lahore, Pakistan 8. Gankovsky.V.Y & Moskalenko.N.V, (1975). The Three Constitutions of Pakistan, publishes by Abdur Rauf Malik.Karachi, Pakistan 9. Dr. Mahmood Safdar. (1992). the constitutional Foundations of Pakistan. Published by M.Amin, Lahore, Pakistan 10. Ishaq.M.Khan. (1973). The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. Published by Khyber Law house, Lahore, Pakistan 32