In the past few decades marketers have begun experimenting with pricing strategies that have consumers decide the final price for a product or service. These pricing strategies are believed to engage consumers, boost sales, enhance brand loyalty, and contribute to a sellers’ overall competitive position. However, in recent years many firms, including Priceline.com, Panera Bread, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York have abandoned their once famous use of participative pricing (i.e., Pay What You Want) and reverted back to fixed prices. In this research, we critically examine participative pricing to understand how and under what conditions it might enhance purchases.