1. The New Project Management
By J. Davidson Frame
The new business environment:
• Downsizing
• Flattening
• Empowering Employees
• Outsourcing
The new project management:
• Need for a customer focus
• Need to acquire nontraditional project management skills
• “hard” skills—basics of contracting, business finance, integrated
cost/schedule control, measuring work performance, monitoring
quality, and conducting risk analysis
• “soft” skills—negotiating, managing change, being politically astute,
and understanding the needs and wants of the people they deal with
(including customers, peers, staff and managers)
• Redefine role of project managers
• Primarily seen as implementers but need new paradigm
• Project managers must be customer focused
• Project managers must be empowered to operate effectively
• Majority of their decisions can be made independently without having
to pass through the chain of command
• They possess substantial profit and loss responsibilities
• They see themselves largely as independent business persons running
their own business
Traits of the new project manager:
• Thorough understanding of project goals
• Capable of understanding staff needs
• Good head for details
• Strong commitment to the project (willing to put in long hours on the project)
• Able to cope with setbacks and disappointments
• Good negotiation skills
• Results oriented and practical
• Cost conscious and possesses basic business skills
• Politically savvy (aware of what NOT to do as well as what to do)
• High tolerance for ambiguity
Common dualities project managers face:
• Seeing the big picture vs. paying attention to details
• Maintaining firmness vs. being flexible
• Being hard vs. being soft in dealing with people
• Possessing analytical skills vs. trusting one’s instincts
bookreviewframenewpmnotes-doc-101020012442-phpapp02.doc Page 1 of 6
Dee Pink 10/20/10
2. Change management strategies:
• Develop a pro-change mind-set
• Develop appreciation of change through education and training
• Encourage upside-down thinking such as:
o Operations and maintenance efforts should be treated as part of the
project life cycle
o Technical people must be adept at understanding and offering
business solutions to problems
o There is no such thing as “the” customer. There are always multiple
customers
o A key function of managers is to support their workers, not to direct
them
• Use crises to shake up stagnant attitudes
Traits of effective Needs Analysts:
• Strong ability to deal with customers and extract from them a sense of what they
truly need
• Good political skills
• Technically competent
• Open-minded and possess a good imagination
• High tolerance for ambiguity
• Articulate
Steps for improving needs definition:
1. Understand the present system in its total context
2. Identify multiple customers and prioritize their needs
3. Put together a needs-defining task force
4. Educate the customers
Organizing to achieve customer satisfaction:
1. Reformulation of corporate culture--Corporate culture must be changed to
support a customer-focused approach. Project managers and other project staff—
the frontline troops encountering customers on a daily basis—must be empowered
to do what it takes to assure customer satisfaction
• Focus on value
• Tolerate and encourage upside-down thinking
• Share power throughout organization
• Take a long-term view
• Assume total customer focus
2. Focus on stability and continuity--Develop projects as islands of stability in a sea
of change
3. Assume life cycle perspective--Organization must adopt total life cycle outlook on
its project efforts. Project staff must do their work with one eye always focused
on operations and maintenance of final product.
bookreviewframenewpmnotes-doc-101020012442-phpapp02.doc Page 2 of 6
Dee Pink 10/20/10
3. 4. Establish mechanisms to assure customer satisfaction—development of methods
and procedures to ensure customer sensibilities will not be violated by oversights
and sloppy procedures.
5. Strengthen capabilities of project staff--Everything possible must be done to
improve the capabilities of project staff. Basic business skills: capital budgeting
techniques, contracting basics, decision-making methodologies, forecasting, and
reading financial statements.
What to do when customers don’t cooperate:
1. Remind customer organization of its contractual obligations
2. Emphasize very clearly at the outset of the project the importance to project
success of meeting certain key milestones, including those requiring customer
inputs. Periodically remind them of upcoming obligations.
3. Establish a steering committee to oversee project progress. Members should
include individuals from customer organization as well as the project
organization.
Politics: the process whereby attempts are made to achieve goals through
accommodation and the exercise of influence.
Players to contend with in project environment:
• Bosses
• Peers
• Functional managers controlling resources
• Customers
• Vendors
• Others (purchasing, information resource management, contracts, secretaries)
Common political pitfalls:
• Accepting things at face value—good politicians are adept at penetrating through
the superficial to identify the real issues.
• Insensitivity to political realities
• The hyper-politician—being too political; pursues too much of a good thing
• The hypo-politician—under performs politically; avoids or ignores something that
will definitely affect them.
How to become more politically effective:
1. Develop a positive attitude toward politics
2. Lay a solid foundation for political action by developing a base of authority
3. Identify key elements of the environment
• Who are the players?
• What are the goals of the players?
• Who am I? Know thyself (strengths, weaknesses) and how colleagues view
you.
4. Define the problem, then identify and implement a course of action
bookreviewframenewpmnotes-doc-101020012442-phpapp02.doc Page 3 of 6
Dee Pink 10/20/10
4. Types of authority: (PMs should develop as many bases of authority as possible)
• Formal authority
• Charismatic authority
• Purse-string authority
• Bureaucratic authority
• Authority based on competence
• Follow-thru authority
• Authority based on trust
• Management by intimidation
• Authority based on physical appearance
• Authority of the initiative
• Crisis authority
• Old boy network/the sisterhood
PM must know how to manage their own managers:
• Articulate the need for support; maintain visibility
o Regular status briefings
o Regular written reports
• Dealing with the truly non-supportive boss
o Move on to better job environment
o Overwhelm the non-supportive boss with competence; make manager look
good
o Develop powerful allies (boss’s boss, managers who control resources,
boss’s peers) who can protect PM from the consequences of manager’s
bad management practices; could backfire—others may perceive PM as a
political operator and not a team player
Building teams with borrowed resources:
• Make the team as tangible as possible
o Hold productive meetings
o Create team space
o Create team “signs”
o Publicize team efforts
• Develop rewards for good behavior
• Develop effective personal touch
o Provide positive feedback on performance
o Publicly acknowledge good performance
o Show interest in team members
o Be a “shirt sleeve” manager
o Be accessible
o Be clear in defining your expectations and in describing work
requirements
o Be consistent and stick to the rules
o Empower team members to make decisions
bookreviewframenewpmnotes-doc-101020012442-phpapp02.doc Page 4 of 6
Dee Pink 10/20/10
5. o Acknowledge special occasions (birthday, anniversaries)
o When critical milestones have been achieved, celebrate with milestone
parties
o Don’t publicly criticize team members
o Don’t put blame on the team when problems arise
General rules for selecting projects:
1. Be explicit about what is important in choosing projects
2. Identify explicit procedures for choosing projects, then stick to them
3. Be prepared to rigorously challenge all assertations
4. Constitute a project selection team whose members represent a broad array of
stakeholders
5. Involve key project personnel in the selection process
Causes of poor estimation:
• Inexperience guessers
• Lack of continuity between the pre-award and post-award phases
• Bad technical guesses
• Changes to the project
• Psychological factors
• Lowballing
• Politics
Strategies for dealing with poor estimates:
• Use data to illustrate the problem of lack of resources
• Strengthen change management procedures
• Prioritize goals
Types of evaluations:
• Bid/no bid evaluation
• Business case evaluation
• Feasibility studies
• Technical evaluation
• Proposal evaluation
• Acceptance testing
• Postmortems
• Performance appraisals
• Audits
• Quality assurance
The structured walk-thorough:
1. The group being evaluated chooses its judge and jury
2. The group being evaluated determines the rules of the evaluation efforts
3. The group being evaluated runs the evaluation meetings
4. No upper-level managers should be present at the evaluation sessions
bookreviewframenewpmnotes-doc-101020012442-phpapp02.doc Page 5 of 6
Dee Pink 10/20/10
6. 5. Customers should not be present at the evaluation sessions
6. Maintain good documentation throughout the whole evaluation process
Role of measurement in managing projects:
• Establishing clear targets
• Tracking performance
• Rewarding/punishing behavior
• Modeling and predicting project performance
Approaches to generate measures:
1. Generating measures from existing data
• Time sheets
• Budgets
• Previous schedules
• Status reports
• Postmortems
2. Generating new measures
• Questionnaires and interviews
• Direct measures/usability
bookreviewframenewpmnotes-doc-101020012442-phpapp02.doc Page 6 of 6
Dee Pink 10/20/10