SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 6
Baixar para ler offline
Environmental Health                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      BioMed Central



Review                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Open Access
Communicating human biomonitoring results to ensure policy
coherence with public health recommendations: analysing
breastmilk whilst protecting, promoting and supporting
breastfeeding
Maryse Arendt

Address: Institute for Improvements around Birth of Initiativ Liewensufank, 20 rue de Contern, 5955 Itzig, Luxembourg
Email: Maryse Arendt - info@liewensufank.lu




from Ethics and communication in human biomonitoring in Europe: results from preparation of pilot studies
Copenhagen, Denmark. 11–13 March 2007

Published: 5 June 2008
Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6                                                                                                                      doi:10.1186/1476-069X-7-S1-S6

<supplement> <title> <p>Ethics and communication in human biomonitoring: European perspectives</p> </title> <editor>Lisbeth E Knudsen, Franco Domenico Merlo and Ann Dyreborg Larsen</editor> <note>Reviews and Research</note> <url>http://www.biomedcentral.com/content/files/pdf/1476-069X-7-S1-info.pdf</url> </supplement>




This article is available from: http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6
© 2008 Arendt; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0),
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.




                                                                Abstract
                                                                This article addresses the problem of how to ensure consistency in messages communicating public
                                                                health recommendations on environmental health and on child health. The World Health
                                                                Organization states that the protection, promotion and support of breastfeeding rank among the
                                                                most effective interventions to improve child survival. International public health policy
                                                                recommends exclusive breastfeeding for six months, followed by continued breastfeeding with the
                                                                addition of safe and adequate complementary foods for two years and beyond. Biomonitoring of
                                                                breastmilk is used as an indicator of environmental pollution ending up in mankind. This article will
                                                                therefore present the biomonitoring results of concentrations of residues in breastmilk in a wider
                                                                context. These results are the mirror that reflects the chemical substances accumulated in the
                                                                bodies of both men and women in the course of a lifetime. The accumulated substances in our
                                                                bodies may have an effect on male or female reproductive cells; they are present in the womb,
                                                                directly affecting the environment of the fragile developing foetus; they are also present in
                                                                breastmilk. Evidence of man-made chemical residues in breastmilk can provide a shock tactic to
                                                                push for stronger laws to protect the environment. However, messages about chemicals detected
                                                                in breastmilk can become dramatized by the media and cause a backlash against breastfeeding, thus
                                                                contradicting the public health messages issued by the World Health Organization. Analyses of
                                                                breastmilk show the presence of important nutritional components and live protective factors
                                                                active in building up the immune system, in gastro intestinal maturation, in immune defence and in
                                                                providing antiviral, antiparasitic and antibacterial activity. Through cohort studies researchers in
                                                                environmental health have concluded that long-term breastfeeding counterbalances the effect of
                                                                prenatal exposure to chemicals causing delay in mental and psychomotor development. Therefore
                                                                caution should be exercised when presenting the results of biomonitoring of breastmilk. The
                                                                results should be a motivation to enact strong legislation on chemicals and review the use of
                                                                chemical substances present in breastmilk, but the results should not be used to undermine the
                                                                confidence in breastmilk as the optimal food for infants and young children.



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Page 1 of 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  (page number not for citation purposes)
Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6                                           http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6




Introduction                                                   they are present in our bodies before conception and may
This article discusses how analysing breastmilk for the        have an effect on male or female reproductive cells; the
presence of environmental chemicals bears the risk of          chemicals are present in the womb thus affecting the
undermining the confidence of mothers, parents and             direct environment of the fragile developing foetus. These
health professionals in breastfeeding and/or long term         substances can harm conception by affecting fertility or by
breastfeeding. In 2006, during the debate on REACH leg-        having teratogenic effects on reproductive cells. This issue
islation, a report was presented in the European parlia-       is now discussed in numerous scientific articles. Studies
ment entitled "Toxic inheritance – more than 300               have shown that semen quality and semen counts deteri-
pollutants in breastmilk" [1]. This publication issued by      orate [5-7]. Male-mediated developmental toxicity is a
the NGOs "BUND" Germany and "Friends of the Earth              concept becoming more widely known to researchers in
Europe" was based on a translation of a German publica-        this field [8-10]. The paternal impact on reproductive dis-
tion from 2005 which compiled data of biomonitoring            orders and childhood cancers as a result of occupational
for a number of substances in breastmilk from around the       exposure has been documented for e.g. pesticides or wood
world. The focus was to alert parliamentarians to the pres-    preservatives [11-13]. But this impact of residues remains
ence of chemicals in humans, with special focus on vul-        less discussed amongst the wider public, whereas residues
nerable babies to guarantee more media attention. The          found in breastmilk are discussed or used for media head-
presence of chemical residues in breastmilk is a shocking      lines to grab attention. The attention given to breastmilk
reality, yet breastfeeding is the natural way and optimal to   may be triggered by the fact that breastmilk, containing
feed infants and young children. Paediatricians and policy     pollutants, is violating a basic social concept of 'purity' of
makers agree that the protection, promotion and support        this food and this unique relationship of a mother and
of breastfeeding are public health priorities. Today we        baby.
know that breastfed children are healthier than infants
receiving only some breast milk or none at all [2]. There-     Repeated biomonitoring of breastmilk or other body flu-
fore this article will present the biomonitoring results of    ids provides the evidence base for strengthening legisla-
breastmilk in a wider context linked to the ethical issue of   tion to phase out or reduce chemicals such as PCB and
communication to ensure consistency with public health         DDT. Effective legislation has had beneficial results: the
policy.                                                        levels of these chemicals measured as concentrations in
                                                               our bodies are lower today than 10 or 20 years ago [4,14].
Breastmilk as a biomonitoring fluid                            Comparing biomonitoring results between countries with
Breastmilk is often used in human biomonitoring to             and without legislation for reduced use of chemicals
detect persistent residues of man-made chemicals accu-         shows great differences.
mulated in human bodies along the food chain. It is used
as an indicator and as a monitoring instrument of fat sol-     Breastfeeding as a unique food, containing live
uble and persistent substances [3]. Breastmilk is often        protective factors
seen as an easy tool for biomonitoring because it is non       "Breastfeeding is the natural way to feed infants and
invasive, though this ignores the fact that it may not be      young children. Exclusive breastfeeding for the first six
easy for the mother to deliver the needed amount, as           months of life ensures optimal growth, development and
pumping or expressing breastmilk can be problematic for        health. After that, breastfeeding, with appropriate comple-
some women. Information on chemicals in breastmilk             mentary foods continues to contribute to the infant's and
may affect the mother and her social network in a way that     young child's nutrition development and health", as cited
undermines their confidence in the continuation of             in the document: "Protection, promotion and support of
breastfeeding. Our association is regularly questioned by      breastfeeding in Europe: a Blueprint for action."[15]. This
anxious parents or by health professionals after headlines     explains why breastmilk needs to be protected from envi-
on residues in breastmilk have been issued.                    ronmental pollution and why paediatricians and policy
                                                               makers agree that protection, promotion and support of
Today we can detect a wide range of foreign substances in      breastfeeding are a public health priority [2,16]. Breast-
breastmilk. The results presented are the mirror of chemi-     milk contains an ample set of potent beneficial substances
cal substances accumulated over the lifespan in the bodies     such as: Special long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids,
of both men and women. The biomonitoring of breast-            lysozymes, secretory IgA, lactoferrin, lipase, prostagland-
milk reveals residues of pesticides like DDT, Lindane,         ins, macrophages, cytokines, epidermal growth factor,
HCH and their breakdown products as well as chemicals          relaxin, interferon, antioxidants, leucocytes, adiponectin
like PCB, Bisphenol A, phthalates, synthetic perfumes          and leptin to name only a few [17-19]. These substances
(musks), flame retardants, sunscreen, perchlorate and          are active in neural maturation, in building up the
chemical by-products like dioxins [1,4]. The fact that these   immune system, in gastrointestinal maturation, in
substances are to be found in breast milk indicates that       immune defence and in setting and regulating body func-


                                                                                                                     Page 2 of 6
                                                                                             (page number not for citation purposes)
Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6                                           http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6



tions and metabolic processes. Some substances have             tive impact on cognitive and neurological development is
antiviral, antiparasitic and antibacterial activity. It has     measurable for exposure in uterus. Findings from these
been shown that infants fed on breastmilk substitutes           cohort studies, which included biomonitoring and moni-
such as infant formula are less healthy than breastfed          toring of breastfed status and duration of breastfeeding,
infants. Many studies have proved that there is a dose          may be unexpected for those looking only at the measure-
dependent effect; the more and longer an infant is breast-      ments and the figures of the residues in breastmilk and
fed, the more beneficial is the effect on growth and            ignoring the bioactive factors contained in breastmilk.
healthy development. When infants are breastfed their           Breastmilk enhances immunologic development and gut
immune system is better developed, the brain and neuro-         maturation, it has antimicrobial and anti-inflammatory
logical system can mature in an optimal way and the gut         properties [20].
system develops better. Breastfed infants suffer less from
respiratory diseases, diarrhoea, otitis media and urinary       Boersma and Lanting showed that at six years of age cog-
tract infections. They have optimal visual and intellectual     nitive development is affected by prenatal exposure to
development and a reduced risk of Diabetes type 1 and 2,        PCBs and dioxins [21]. Breastfed children however, when
allergic diseases, obesity, Crohn's disease, malignant lym-     compared to formula fed children, had an advantage in
phomas and cardiovascular disease in adulthood [2]. It          terms of quality of movements, fluency and cognitive
can be concluded that breastfeeding strengthens the             development tests at 18 and 42 months of age and at six
infant's developing immune system and decreases the             years, despite a higher PCB exposure from breast milk.
incidence or severity of infectious diseases. Breastfeeding     The conclusions of Boersma and Lanting were: "These
is also associated with a slightly enhanced performance         data give evidence that prenatal exposure to PCBs do have
on tests of cognitive development. Studies of cognitive         subtle negative effects on neurological and cognitive
development in relation to breastfeeding have all been          development of the child up to school-age (....). Our stud-
performed in western environments with present levels of        ies showed evidence that breast feeding counteracts the
pollution. Based on the strong scientific evidence of the       adverse developmental effects of PCBs and dioxins" [21].
benefits of breastfeeding the American Academy of Pedi-
atrics [2], WHO, UNICEF [16] and other organisations of         The results are supported by a study of Ribas-Fitó et al.,
health professionals recommend exclusive breastfeeding          who studied a birth cohort of 92 mother-infant pairs
for the first six months of life and continued breastfeeding    highly exposed to organochlorine compounds. The
up to two years and beyond. The American Paediatric             researchers published their findings in 2003 in Pediatrics
Association recommends in their latest policy document          and their conclusion stated: "Prenatal exposure to
that: "Breastfeeding should be continued for at least the       p,p'DDE was associated with a delay in mental and psy-
first year of life and beyond for as long as mutually desired   chomotor development at 13 months. Long-term breast-
by mother and child. There is no upper limit to the dura-       feeding was found to be beneficial to neurodevelopment,
tion of breastfeeding and no evidence of psychologic or         potentially counterbalancing the impact of exposure to
developmental harm from breastfeeding into the third            these chemicals through breast-milk" [22].
year of life or longer"[2]. The WHO recommendation for
optimal infant and young child feeding is: "The expert          In a review Feeley and Brouwer concluded that: "Little if
consultation recommends exclusive breastfeeding for six         any adverse health effects have been associated with
months, with introduction of complementary foods and            breast-feeding. In fact, the beneficial effect from breast-
continued breastfeeding thereafter for up to two years of       feeding on neurological measures has been observed"
age or beyond" [16]. The recommendation was adopted             [23].
by all WHO member governments in 2002 at the World
Health Assembly in the Global Strategy on Infant and            The positive results of breastfeeding are also found in an
Young Child Feeding [16]. This is a global public health        exploratory study by Vreugdenhil et al. who suggest that
recommendation and should be implemented at national            prenatal exposure to environmental levels of PCBs and
level.                                                          related compounds delays mechanisms in the central
                                                                nervous system that evaluate and process relevant stimuli,
The evidence base: Study results of perinatally exposed         whereas breastfeeding accelerates these mechanisms [24].
cohorts
Prenatal exposure to chemicals during pregnancy, when           In recent studies the issue of cognitive development and
the vulnerability of the foetus is highest, may harm or         breastfeeding has been further addressed. In a study from
impair the neurological and cognitive development of the        Pediatrics published in 2006 by Charnley and Kimbrough
unborn child and may have a negative impact on the              the researchers state that: "Breast-fed infants have higher
immune system. Numerous cohort studies on infants               exposures than formula-fed infants, but studies consist-
born and living in exposed regions conclude that a nega-        ently find that breast-fed infants perform better on devel-


                                                                                                                     Page 3 of 6
                                                                                             (page number not for citation purposes)
Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6                                            http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6



opmental neurologic tests than their formula-fed               indicator of the body burden of all human beings and that
counterparts, supporting the well-recognized benefits of       the focus is not only directed towards "contaminated
breast feeding" [25]. The benefits of breastfeeding despite    breastmilk". The results should be an exhortation to polit-
exposure to higher levels of chemicals were also found in      ical action for strong legislation on the production,
another recent study published in Pediatrics by Eskenazi       release, and use of these chemicals detected in breastmilk.
et al, who concluded that: "Prenatal exposure to DDT, and      The results should not be used to undermine confidence
to a lesser extent DDE, was associated with neurodevelop-      in breastmilk as the optimal food for infants and young
mental delays during early childhood, although breast-         children. The existence of chemical residues in breastmilk
feeding was found to be beneficial even among women            is not a reason for limiting breastfeeding. On the contrary
with high levels of exposure" [26].                            those findings are one of the reasons to breastfeed because
                                                               breastmilk contains substances that help the child
These findings all show what happens with breastfed            develop a stronger immune system and optimal neural
infants born into our present polluted environment.            and brain maturation. Thus breastfeeding can help limit
However, because of the lack of a control group living in      the damage caused by foetal exposure to these chemicals.
an unexposed environment, it is not possible to assess the
total positive health and development impact of breast-        Examples of good communication messages
feeding.                                                       For persons involved in human biomonitoring of breast-
                                                               milk it is paramount to protect breastmilk and breastfeed-
Communication of results                                       ing as the best possible nutrition for growth and healthy
In the media breastmilk, when used as a biomonitoring          development of infants and young children [27,28]. This
tool for analysing the human body burden, is often por-        can be done by elucidating a comprehensive picture of
trayed as being contaminated with persistent organic pol-      exposure, as explained above. To include lactation special-
lutants [1]. Sensational messages about contaminants in        ists e.g. lactation consultants and NGOs working on pro-
breastmilk undermine the value of breastfeeding and the        tection and support of breastfeeding in planning and
confidence of parents and health care professionals in         communication efforts could also be a valuable tool.
breastfeeding and long term breastfeeding. Perceptions         Agencies and NGOs active in biomonitoring of breastmilk
created by communication of the findings of residues           are becoming aware of this situation and of the need for a
detected in breastmilk place the focus on breastmilk,          change in their communication methods [29].
thereby indirectly blaming the breastfeeding mother.
Attention is drawn away from the pollutants which create       In May 2005, WHO and UNEP entered into a Memorandum
this situation and from the industries that produce, use or    of Agreement for the coordination of human milk surveys for
release the chemicals and thereby create environmental         the purpose of the Stockholm Convention.
pollution. Attention is deflected from the fact that these
persistent chemicals accumulate in the food chain and          "At the same time, evidence for the health advantages of breast-
have adverse effects that are more or less documented on       feeding and scientific evidence to support breastfeeding has con-
all species high up on the food chain, including human         tinued to increase.
beings. Nevertheless NGOs have legitimate normative
and political reasons to expose this, in trying to galvanise   • WHO can now say with full confidence that breastfeeding
public pressure for political action to prevent, reduce and    reduces child mortality and has health benefits that extend into
eliminate the sources of contaminating chemicals. In cur-      adulthood.
rent messages communicating the detection of residues in
breastmilk, the whole situational context is overlooked:       On a population basis, exclusive breastfeeding for six months is
"polluted breastmilk" is the main focus and avoidance of       the recommended feeding mode for the vast majority of infants,
breastfeeding is seen as a possible option. It is forgotten    followed by continued breastfeeding with appropriate comple-
that breastmilk is an indicator of the bioaccumulation of      mentary foods for up to two years or beyond."
persistent chemical substances in both men and women.
The questioning of female body fluids, with "white" and        In 2005, the World Health Organisation (WHO) issued
"pure" milk portrayed as being polluted and "impure",          the 4th WHO coordinated survey of human milk for per-
leads emotions into ancient fears. Insensitive communica-      sistent organic pollutants with the following message: "In
tion of biomonitoring results focussing only on the pres-      all cases human milk will be promoted as the naturally
ence of substances that should not be in breastmilk and        superior food for infants (...) This survey being consistent
their measured values undermines the confidence of             with the promotion of human milk as the optimal food
mothers, fathers, and health professionals in breastfeed-      for infants could provide the ideal basis for possible
ing. It is very important that communication on residues       source-directed measures to ultimately reduce levels of
detected in breastmilk during biomonitoring is seen as an      POPs in human milk" [3]. In the revised protocol of 2007


                                                                                                                      Page 4 of 6
                                                                                              (page number not for citation purposes)
Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6                                                            http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6



WHO, now in cooperation with UNEP (United Nations                          European perspectives. The full contents of the supplement are available
Environment Programme) goes beyond this by extending                       online at http://www.ehjournal.net/supplements/7/S1.
the messages about breastfeeding [3,30,31]; "WHO can
now say with full confidence that breastfeeding reduces                    References
                                                                           1.    FOE: Toxic inheritance. 2005 [http://www.foeeurope.org/publica
child mortality and has health benefits that extend into                         tions/2005/toxic_inheritance.pdf].
adulthood. On a population basis, exclusive breastfeeding                  2.    AAP: POLICY STATEMENT Breastfeeding and the Use of
for six months is the recommended feeding mode for the                           Human Milk. PEDIATRICS 2005, 115:496-506.
                                                                           3.    WHO: Fourth WHO-Coordinated Survey of Human Milk for
vast majority of infants, followed by continued breast-                          Persistent Organic Pollutants. 2005 [http://www.who.int/food
feeding with appropriate complementary foods for up to                           safety/chem/pops/en/index.html].
                                                                           4.    van Leeuwen R, Malisch R: Results of the third round of the who-
two years or beyond" [30]. WHO and UNEP have now                                 coordinated exposure study on the levels of PCBS, PCDDS
developed an annex to their Protocol for Collection, Han-                        and PCDFS in human milk. Organohalog compd 2002, 56:311-316.
dling and Analysis of Samples at the Country Level named                   5.    CPCHE: A Father's day Report – Men, boys and environmen-
                                                                                 tal health threats.            2007 [http://www.healthyenvironment
"The value of breastfeeding" [30], which contains follow-                        forkids.ca/img_upload/13297cd6a147585a24c1c6233d8d96d8/
ing message: "Breastfeeding is the ideal way to feed                             father__s_day_report_summary.pdf].
infants; its benefits go far beyond sound nutrition, and                   6.    Oliva A, Spira A, Multigner L: Contribution of environmental fac-
                                                                                 tors to the risk of male infertility. Hum Reprod 2001,
children should not needlessly be deprived of it" [30].                          16:1768-1776.
                                                                           7.    Whorton D, Milby TH, Krauss RM, Stubbs HA: Testicular function
                                                                                 in DBCP exposed pesticide workers. J Occup Med 1979,
In this protocol WHO has even gone beyond the messages                           21:161-166.
quoted above by not only targeting organisers of biomon-                   8.    Nelson BK, Moorman WJ, Schrader SM: Review of experimental
itoring of breastmilk and field workers in contact with                          male-mediated behavioral and neurochemical disorders.
                                                                                 Neurotoxicol Teratol 1996, 18:611-616.
mothers, but by also including communication addressed                     9.    Olshan AF, Faustman EM: Male-mediated developmental toxic-
directly to mothers. They have developed a prenatal infor-                       ity. Annu Rev Public Health 1993, 14:159-181.
                                                                           10.   Sever LE: Male-mediated developmental toxicity. Epidemiology
mation sheet on breastfeeding for mothers selected to be                         1995, 6:573-574.
included in their survey.                                                  11.   Dimich-Ward H, Hertzman C, Teschke K, Marion SA, Ostry A, Kelly
                                                                                 S: Reproductive effects of paternal exposure to chlorophen-
                                                                                 ate wood preservatives in the sawmill industry. Scand J Work
Messages such as those above, including scientific evi-                          Environ Health 1996, 22:267-273.
dence both promote and protect breastfeeding whenever                      12.   Infante-Revard C, Sinnett D: Preconceptional paternal exposure
breastmilk is collected, sampled and analysed for bio-                           to pesticides and increased risk of childhood leukaemia. Lan-
                                                                                 cet 1999, 354:1819.
monitoring.                                                                13.   Pierik FH, Burdorf A, Deddens JA, Juttmann RE, Weber RF: Mater-
                                                                                 nal and paternal risk factors for cryptorchidism and hypospa-
                                                                                 dias: a case-control study in newborn boys. Environ Health
Awareness about similar caution in communication is                              Perspect 2004, 112:1570-1576.
being discussed when publishing levels of chemicals in                     14.   WHO: Children's environmental health.                  2007 [http://
fish versus the positive health effects of consuming fish, or                    www.who.int/ceh/publications/en/poster15new.pdf].
                                                                           15.   Cattaneo A: Breastfeeding in Europe: a blueprint for action. J
residues of pesticides in fruit and vegetables while pro-                        Public Health 2005, 13:89-96.
moting a recommended amount of fruit or vegetables a                       16.   WHO, UNICEF: Global strategy for infant and young child
                                                                                 feeding.             2003       [http://www.paho.org/english/ad/fch/ca/
day.                                                                             GSIYCF_infantfeeding_eng.pdf].
                                                                           17.   Cattaneo A, Lehners M: Comment on "Breast milk: an optimal
Conclusion                                                                       food". Environ Health Perspect 2005, 113:A18-A19.
                                                                           18.   Labbok MH, Clark D, Goldman AS: Breastfeeding: maintaining
Breastfeeding rates in Europe are rising but they are still                      an irreplaceable immunological resource. Nat Rev Immunol
far away from the recommendation of the World Health                             2004, 4:565-572.
Organisation, as shown in Cattaneo [15]: it is therefore                   19.   Pronczuk J, Moy G, Vallenas C: Breast milk: an optimal food.
                                                                                 Environ Health Perspect 2004, 112:A722-A723.
important that messages about biomonitoring results do                     20.   Lawrence R, Lawrence R: Breastfeeding – A Guide for the medical pro-
not harm or undermine public health messages for the                             fession 6th edition. Elsevier Mosby; 2005.
                                                                           21.   Boersma ER, Lanting CI: Environmental exposure to polychlo-
protection, promotion and support of breastfeeding. On                           rinated biphenyls (PCBs) and dioxins. Consequences for
the other hand, breastmilk and breastfeeding should be                           longterm neurological and cognitive development of the
protected against harmful substances and harmful mes-                            child lactation. Adv Exp Med Biol 2000, 478:271-287.
                                                                           22.   Ribas-Fitó N, Cardo E, Sala M, Eulália de Muga M, Mazón C, Verdú A,
sages. The communication efforts by WHO to ensure pol-                           et al.: Breastfeeding, exposure to organochlorine compounds,
icy consistency provide a good example and should be                             and neurodevelopment in infants. Pediatrics 2003, 111(5 Pt
implemented whenever breastmilk is analysed.                                     1):e580-e585.
                                                                           23.   Feeley M, Brouwer A: Health risks to infants from exposure to
                                                                                 PCBs, PCDDs and PCDFs. Food Addit Contam 2000, 17:325-333.
Competing interests                                                        24.   Vreugdenhil H, Van Zanten GA, Brocaar MP, Mulders PG, Weisglas-
                                                                                 Kuperus N: Prenatal exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.                       and breastfeeding: opposing effects on auditory P300 laten-
                                                                                 cies in 9-year-old Dutch children. Dev Med Child Neurol 2004,
Acknowledgements                                                                 46:398-405.
                                                                           25.   Charnley G, Kimbrough RD: Overview of exposure, toxicity, and
This article has been published as part of Environmental Health Volume 7         risks to children from current levels of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorod-
Supplement 1, 2008: Ethics and communication in human biomonitoring:


                                                                                                                                         Page 5 of 6
                                                                                                                 (page number not for citation purposes)
Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6                                                               http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6



      ibenzo-p-dioxin and related compounds in the USA. Food
      Chem Toxicol 2006, 44:601-615.
26.   Eskenazi B, Marks AR, Bradman A, Fenster L, Johnson C, Barr DB,
      Jewell NP: In utero exposure to dichlorodiphenyltrichlo-
      roethane (DDT) and dichlorodiphenyldichloroethylene
      (DDE) and neurodevelopment among young Mexican Amer-
      ican children. Pediatrics 2006, 118:233-241.
27.   Berlin CM, Crase BL, Fürst P, LaKind JS, Moy G, Needham LL, et al.:
      Methodologic considerations for improving and facilitating
      human milk research.             J Toxicol Environ Health A 2005,
      68:1803-1823.
28.   Berlin CM, LaKind JS, Fenton SE, Wang RY, Bates MN, Brent RL, et
      al.: Conclusions and recommendations of the expert panel:
      technical workshop on human milk surveillance and biomon-
      itoring for environmental chemicals in the United States. J
      Toxicol Environ Health A 2005, 68:1825-1831.
29.   EEN, IBFAN: Press release and EP-event: Pro-REACH groups
      says; breast is still best. Health and Environment alliance 2006
      [http://www.env-health.org/a/2172].
30.   WHO: Biomonitoring of human milk A Protocol for Collec-
      tion, Handling and Analysis of Samples at the Country Level.
      2007 [http://www.who.int/foodsafety/chem/POPprotocol.pdf].
31.   WHO: technical note: Biomonitoring of Human Milk. 2007
      [http://www.who.int/foodsafety/chem/POPtechnicalnote.pdf].




                                                                                     Publish with Bio Med Central and every
                                                                                    scientist can read your work free of charge
                                                                                "BioMed Central will be the most significant development for
                                                                                disseminating the results of biomedical researc h in our lifetime."
                                                                                     Sir Paul Nurse, Cancer Research UK

                                                                                   Your research papers will be:
                                                                                     available free of charge to the entire biomedical community
                                                                                     peer reviewed and published immediately upon acceptance
                                                                                     cited in PubMed and archived on PubMed Central
                                                                                     yours — you keep the copyright

                                                                            Submit your manuscript here:                                BioMedcentral
                                                                            http://www.biomedcentral.com/info/publishing_adv.asp




                                                                                                                                              Page 6 of 6
                                                                                                                      (page number not for citation purposes)

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

Куда летят облака? Примеры внедрений, вопросы и прогнозы развития в России v.1.1
Куда летят облака? Примеры внедрений, вопросы и прогнозы развития в России v.1.1Куда летят облака? Примеры внедрений, вопросы и прогнозы развития в России v.1.1
Куда летят облака? Примеры внедрений, вопросы и прогнозы развития в России v.1.1Michael Kozloff
 
MarketingProfs 2012 State of Social Media
MarketingProfs 2012 State of Social Media MarketingProfs 2012 State of Social Media
MarketingProfs 2012 State of Social Media Lithium
 
Funzione Strumentale area Supporto multimediale ai docenti
Funzione Strumentale area Supporto multimediale ai docentiFunzione Strumentale area Supporto multimediale ai docenti
Funzione Strumentale area Supporto multimediale ai docentiLoreto Grimaldi
 
Randomized, Controlled Trial Of A Prenatal And Postnatal Lactation Consultant
Randomized, Controlled Trial Of A Prenatal And Postnatal Lactation ConsultantRandomized, Controlled Trial Of A Prenatal And Postnatal Lactation Consultant
Randomized, Controlled Trial Of A Prenatal And Postnatal Lactation ConsultantBiblioteca Virtual
 
Ipodtouch Elearning
Ipodtouch ElearningIpodtouch Elearning
Ipodtouch Elearningbobbartley
 
Implications Of The 14 19 Reforms
Implications Of The 14 19 ReformsImplications Of The 14 19 Reforms
Implications Of The 14 19 ReformsJamesWaring
 
Hcm 8.9 Setup Manager
Hcm 8.9 Setup ManagerHcm 8.9 Setup Manager
Hcm 8.9 Setup Managerguestb6b62d22
 
Nutritional Factors In Milk From Brazilian Mothers Delivering Small For Gesta...
Nutritional Factors In Milk From Brazilian Mothers Delivering Small For Gesta...Nutritional Factors In Milk From Brazilian Mothers Delivering Small For Gesta...
Nutritional Factors In Milk From Brazilian Mothers Delivering Small For Gesta...Biblioteca Virtual
 
Infant Formula Contaminated By Enterobacteria
Infant Formula Contaminated By EnterobacteriaInfant Formula Contaminated By Enterobacteria
Infant Formula Contaminated By EnterobacteriaBiblioteca Virtual
 
NAWBO Presentation
NAWBO PresentationNAWBO Presentation
NAWBO PresentationJean Baker
 
Lithium Likes to Loves Tour - Silicon Valley
Lithium Likes to Loves Tour - Silicon ValleyLithium Likes to Loves Tour - Silicon Valley
Lithium Likes to Loves Tour - Silicon ValleyLithium
 
Forever Flowing Ch1.1
Forever Flowing Ch1.1Forever Flowing Ch1.1
Forever Flowing Ch1.1Geminiasp
 
Analgesia And Anesthesia For The Breastfeeding Mother
Analgesia And Anesthesia For The Breastfeeding MotherAnalgesia And Anesthesia For The Breastfeeding Mother
Analgesia And Anesthesia For The Breastfeeding MotherBiblioteca Virtual
 
Bbm for android-1.0_user_guide-beta
Bbm for android-1.0_user_guide-betaBbm for android-1.0_user_guide-beta
Bbm for android-1.0_user_guide-betaAndrin Fauzi
 
Viatge a argelès sur-mer (frança)
Viatge a argelès sur-mer (frança)Viatge a argelès sur-mer (frança)
Viatge a argelès sur-mer (frança)monsieurprats
 

Destaque (20)

Куда летят облака? Примеры внедрений, вопросы и прогнозы развития в России v.1.1
Куда летят облака? Примеры внедрений, вопросы и прогнозы развития в России v.1.1Куда летят облака? Примеры внедрений, вопросы и прогнозы развития в России v.1.1
Куда летят облака? Примеры внедрений, вопросы и прогнозы развития в России v.1.1
 
MarketingProfs 2012 State of Social Media
MarketingProfs 2012 State of Social Media MarketingProfs 2012 State of Social Media
MarketingProfs 2012 State of Social Media
 
Let's Talk About Scrubs
Let's Talk About ScrubsLet's Talk About Scrubs
Let's Talk About Scrubs
 
Funzione Strumentale area Supporto multimediale ai docenti
Funzione Strumentale area Supporto multimediale ai docentiFunzione Strumentale area Supporto multimediale ai docenti
Funzione Strumentale area Supporto multimediale ai docenti
 
Randomized, Controlled Trial Of A Prenatal And Postnatal Lactation Consultant
Randomized, Controlled Trial Of A Prenatal And Postnatal Lactation ConsultantRandomized, Controlled Trial Of A Prenatal And Postnatal Lactation Consultant
Randomized, Controlled Trial Of A Prenatal And Postnatal Lactation Consultant
 
Ipodtouch Elearning
Ipodtouch ElearningIpodtouch Elearning
Ipodtouch Elearning
 
Implications Of The 14 19 Reforms
Implications Of The 14 19 ReformsImplications Of The 14 19 Reforms
Implications Of The 14 19 Reforms
 
Hcm 8.9 Setup Manager
Hcm 8.9 Setup ManagerHcm 8.9 Setup Manager
Hcm 8.9 Setup Manager
 
Basic textminingrm
Basic textminingrmBasic textminingrm
Basic textminingrm
 
U.s.polo presentation
U.s.polo presentationU.s.polo presentation
U.s.polo presentation
 
Nutritional Factors In Milk From Brazilian Mothers Delivering Small For Gesta...
Nutritional Factors In Milk From Brazilian Mothers Delivering Small For Gesta...Nutritional Factors In Milk From Brazilian Mothers Delivering Small For Gesta...
Nutritional Factors In Milk From Brazilian Mothers Delivering Small For Gesta...
 
Infant Formula Contaminated By Enterobacteria
Infant Formula Contaminated By EnterobacteriaInfant Formula Contaminated By Enterobacteria
Infant Formula Contaminated By Enterobacteria
 
NAWBO Presentation
NAWBO PresentationNAWBO Presentation
NAWBO Presentation
 
Lithium Likes to Loves Tour - Silicon Valley
Lithium Likes to Loves Tour - Silicon ValleyLithium Likes to Loves Tour - Silicon Valley
Lithium Likes to Loves Tour - Silicon Valley
 
Chisholm Gallery, LLC , Louise Mellon, Polo Portraits
Chisholm Gallery, LLC , Louise Mellon, Polo PortraitsChisholm Gallery, LLC , Louise Mellon, Polo Portraits
Chisholm Gallery, LLC , Louise Mellon, Polo Portraits
 
Forever Flowing Ch1.1
Forever Flowing Ch1.1Forever Flowing Ch1.1
Forever Flowing Ch1.1
 
Analgesia And Anesthesia For The Breastfeeding Mother
Analgesia And Anesthesia For The Breastfeeding MotherAnalgesia And Anesthesia For The Breastfeeding Mother
Analgesia And Anesthesia For The Breastfeeding Mother
 
Bbm for android-1.0_user_guide-beta
Bbm for android-1.0_user_guide-betaBbm for android-1.0_user_guide-beta
Bbm for android-1.0_user_guide-beta
 
Gerard Keenan 2, Courtesy of Chisholm Gallery
Gerard Keenan 2, Courtesy of Chisholm GalleryGerard Keenan 2, Courtesy of Chisholm Gallery
Gerard Keenan 2, Courtesy of Chisholm Gallery
 
Viatge a argelès sur-mer (frança)
Viatge a argelès sur-mer (frança)Viatge a argelès sur-mer (frança)
Viatge a argelès sur-mer (frança)
 

Semelhante a Communicating Human Biomonitoring Results To Ensure Policy Coherence With Public Health Recommendations Analyzing Breastmilk Whilst Protecting, Promoting And Supporting Breastfeeding

Frequently Asked Questions (Faq) About Breastfeeding In A Contaminated Enviro...
Frequently Asked Questions (Faq) About Breastfeeding In A Contaminated Enviro...Frequently Asked Questions (Faq) About Breastfeeding In A Contaminated Enviro...
Frequently Asked Questions (Faq) About Breastfeeding In A Contaminated Enviro...Biblioteca Virtual
 
Effectiveness Of Exclusive Breastfeeding Promotion In Low Income Mothers A Ra...
Effectiveness Of Exclusive Breastfeeding Promotion In Low Income Mothers A Ra...Effectiveness Of Exclusive Breastfeeding Promotion In Low Income Mothers A Ra...
Effectiveness Of Exclusive Breastfeeding Promotion In Low Income Mothers A Ra...Biblioteca Virtual
 
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parentingGreat research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parentingEcoInspired
 
Breast Milk & Environmental Pollutants
Breast Milk & Environmental Pollutants Breast Milk & Environmental Pollutants
Breast Milk & Environmental Pollutants v2zq
 
Am j clin nutr 2007-raiten-577 s-83s
Am j clin nutr 2007-raiten-577 s-83sAm j clin nutr 2007-raiten-577 s-83s
Am j clin nutr 2007-raiten-577 s-83sanugrahhumairah
 
Role of prenatal probiotics in preterm birth
Role of prenatal probiotics in preterm birthRole of prenatal probiotics in preterm birth
Role of prenatal probiotics in preterm birthNARENDRA MALHOTRA
 
Microbiome Probiotics Asia Agenda
Microbiome Probiotics Asia AgendaMicrobiome Probiotics Asia Agenda
Microbiome Probiotics Asia AgendaMaxime L
 
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parentingGreat research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parentingEcoInspired
 
Powdered Infant Formula How Safe Is It
Powdered Infant Formula   How Safe Is ItPowdered Infant Formula   How Safe Is It
Powdered Infant Formula How Safe Is ItBiblioteca Virtual
 
Dealing With Fears Of Chemical Pollution Of Breastmilk
Dealing With Fears Of Chemical Pollution Of BreastmilkDealing With Fears Of Chemical Pollution Of Breastmilk
Dealing With Fears Of Chemical Pollution Of BreastmilkBiblioteca Virtual
 
Mediating Effects of Intention On The Factors Affecting Organic Food Products...
Mediating Effects of Intention On The Factors Affecting Organic Food Products...Mediating Effects of Intention On The Factors Affecting Organic Food Products...
Mediating Effects of Intention On The Factors Affecting Organic Food Products...CSCJournals
 
Anil kumar srivastava
Anil kumar srivastavaAnil kumar srivastava
Anil kumar srivastavaneerjayakult
 
Ethics in food and public health safety in bangladesh
Ethics in food and public health safety in bangladeshEthics in food and public health safety in bangladesh
Ethics in food and public health safety in bangladeshTafhim Bin Nasir
 
Role baby friendly hospital initiative on KAP of nursing mothers
Role baby friendly hospital initiative on KAP of nursing mothersRole baby friendly hospital initiative on KAP of nursing mothers
Role baby friendly hospital initiative on KAP of nursing mothersAnjum Hashmi MPH
 
Ensuring child health - Role of civil society
Ensuring child health - Role of civil societyEnsuring child health - Role of civil society
Ensuring child health - Role of civil societyJagannath Chatterjee
 
Understanding the Importance of Having Probiotics in Your Diet
Understanding the Importance of Having Probiotics in Your DietUnderstanding the Importance of Having Probiotics in Your Diet
Understanding the Importance of Having Probiotics in Your DietPatriot Power Greens
 
TUFF YOUR FACE. LOSE WEIGHT.
TUFF YOUR FACE. LOSE WEIGHT.TUFF YOUR FACE. LOSE WEIGHT.
TUFF YOUR FACE. LOSE WEIGHT.YohendyColon1
 

Semelhante a Communicating Human Biomonitoring Results To Ensure Policy Coherence With Public Health Recommendations Analyzing Breastmilk Whilst Protecting, Promoting And Supporting Breastfeeding (20)

Frequently Asked Questions (Faq) About Breastfeeding In A Contaminated Enviro...
Frequently Asked Questions (Faq) About Breastfeeding In A Contaminated Enviro...Frequently Asked Questions (Faq) About Breastfeeding In A Contaminated Enviro...
Frequently Asked Questions (Faq) About Breastfeeding In A Contaminated Enviro...
 
Effectiveness Of Exclusive Breastfeeding Promotion In Low Income Mothers A Ra...
Effectiveness Of Exclusive Breastfeeding Promotion In Low Income Mothers A Ra...Effectiveness Of Exclusive Breastfeeding Promotion In Low Income Mothers A Ra...
Effectiveness Of Exclusive Breastfeeding Promotion In Low Income Mothers A Ra...
 
Sjnhc 32 32-40
Sjnhc 32 32-40Sjnhc 32 32-40
Sjnhc 32 32-40
 
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parentingGreat research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
 
Breast Milk & Environmental Pollutants
Breast Milk & Environmental Pollutants Breast Milk & Environmental Pollutants
Breast Milk & Environmental Pollutants
 
Am j clin nutr 2007-raiten-577 s-83s
Am j clin nutr 2007-raiten-577 s-83sAm j clin nutr 2007-raiten-577 s-83s
Am j clin nutr 2007-raiten-577 s-83s
 
Biowold doc
Biowold docBiowold doc
Biowold doc
 
Role of prenatal probiotics in preterm birth
Role of prenatal probiotics in preterm birthRole of prenatal probiotics in preterm birth
Role of prenatal probiotics in preterm birth
 
Microbiome Probiotics Asia Agenda
Microbiome Probiotics Asia AgendaMicrobiome Probiotics Asia Agenda
Microbiome Probiotics Asia Agenda
 
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parentingGreat research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
Great research data on children, wellbeing and parenting
 
Powdered Infant Formula How Safe Is It
Powdered Infant Formula   How Safe Is ItPowdered Infant Formula   How Safe Is It
Powdered Infant Formula How Safe Is It
 
Dealing With Fears Of Chemical Pollution Of Breastmilk
Dealing With Fears Of Chemical Pollution Of BreastmilkDealing With Fears Of Chemical Pollution Of Breastmilk
Dealing With Fears Of Chemical Pollution Of Breastmilk
 
Position Paper: Healthy growth and nutrition in children
Position Paper: Healthy growth and nutrition in childrenPosition Paper: Healthy growth and nutrition in children
Position Paper: Healthy growth and nutrition in children
 
Mediating Effects of Intention On The Factors Affecting Organic Food Products...
Mediating Effects of Intention On The Factors Affecting Organic Food Products...Mediating Effects of Intention On The Factors Affecting Organic Food Products...
Mediating Effects of Intention On The Factors Affecting Organic Food Products...
 
Anil kumar srivastava
Anil kumar srivastavaAnil kumar srivastava
Anil kumar srivastava
 
Ethics in food and public health safety in bangladesh
Ethics in food and public health safety in bangladeshEthics in food and public health safety in bangladesh
Ethics in food and public health safety in bangladesh
 
Role baby friendly hospital initiative on KAP of nursing mothers
Role baby friendly hospital initiative on KAP of nursing mothersRole baby friendly hospital initiative on KAP of nursing mothers
Role baby friendly hospital initiative on KAP of nursing mothers
 
Ensuring child health - Role of civil society
Ensuring child health - Role of civil societyEnsuring child health - Role of civil society
Ensuring child health - Role of civil society
 
Understanding the Importance of Having Probiotics in Your Diet
Understanding the Importance of Having Probiotics in Your DietUnderstanding the Importance of Having Probiotics in Your Diet
Understanding the Importance of Having Probiotics in Your Diet
 
TUFF YOUR FACE. LOSE WEIGHT.
TUFF YOUR FACE. LOSE WEIGHT.TUFF YOUR FACE. LOSE WEIGHT.
TUFF YOUR FACE. LOSE WEIGHT.
 

Mais de Biblioteca Virtual

Aleitamento Materno Manual De OrientaçãO
Aleitamento Materno   Manual De OrientaçãOAleitamento Materno   Manual De OrientaçãO
Aleitamento Materno Manual De OrientaçãOBiblioteca Virtual
 
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce ExaminationStatistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce ExaminationBiblioteca Virtual
 
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level ILactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level IBiblioteca Virtual
 
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...Biblioteca Virtual
 
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...Biblioteca Virtual
 
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce ExaminationStatistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce ExaminationBiblioteca Virtual
 
Uk Formula Marketing Practices
Uk Formula Marketing PracticesUk Formula Marketing Practices
Uk Formula Marketing PracticesBiblioteca Virtual
 
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce ExaminationStatistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce ExaminationBiblioteca Virtual
 
PromoçãO, ProtecçãO E Apoio. Apoio RepresentaçõEs Sociais Em Aleitamento Materno
PromoçãO, ProtecçãO E Apoio. Apoio RepresentaçõEs Sociais Em Aleitamento MaternoPromoçãO, ProtecçãO E Apoio. Apoio RepresentaçõEs Sociais Em Aleitamento Materno
PromoçãO, ProtecçãO E Apoio. Apoio RepresentaçõEs Sociais Em Aleitamento MaternoBiblioteca Virtual
 
O Ensino De Aleitamento Materno Na GraduaçãO Em Medicina Um Estudo De Caso
O Ensino De Aleitamento Materno Na GraduaçãO Em Medicina   Um Estudo De CasoO Ensino De Aleitamento Materno Na GraduaçãO Em Medicina   Um Estudo De Caso
O Ensino De Aleitamento Materno Na GraduaçãO Em Medicina Um Estudo De CasoBiblioteca Virtual
 
No Seio Da FamíLia AmamentaçãO E PromoçãO Da SaúDe No Programa De SaúDe Da ...
No Seio Da FamíLia   AmamentaçãO E PromoçãO Da SaúDe No Programa De SaúDe Da ...No Seio Da FamíLia   AmamentaçãO E PromoçãO Da SaúDe No Programa De SaúDe Da ...
No Seio Da FamíLia AmamentaçãO E PromoçãO Da SaúDe No Programa De SaúDe Da ...Biblioteca Virtual
 
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level ILactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level IBiblioteca Virtual
 
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...Biblioteca Virtual
 
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...Biblioteca Virtual
 
Iblce Regional Office In Europe Candidate Information Guide
Iblce Regional Office In Europe   Candidate Information GuideIblce Regional Office In Europe   Candidate Information Guide
Iblce Regional Office In Europe Candidate Information GuideBiblioteca Virtual
 
A ImportâNcia Da AmamentaçãO Para A SaúDe Da Mulher Que Amamenta
A ImportâNcia Da AmamentaçãO Para A SaúDe Da Mulher Que AmamentaA ImportâNcia Da AmamentaçãO Para A SaúDe Da Mulher Que Amamenta
A ImportâNcia Da AmamentaçãO Para A SaúDe Da Mulher Que AmamentaBiblioteca Virtual
 
AmamentaçãO E Uso De AntiinflamatóRios NãO EsteróIdes Pela Nutriz InformaçõEs...
AmamentaçãO E Uso De AntiinflamatóRios NãO EsteróIdes Pela Nutriz InformaçõEs...AmamentaçãO E Uso De AntiinflamatóRios NãO EsteróIdes Pela Nutriz InformaçõEs...
AmamentaçãO E Uso De AntiinflamatóRios NãO EsteróIdes Pela Nutriz InformaçõEs...Biblioteca Virtual
 
Contribution Of Environmental Factors To The Risk Of Male Infertility
Contribution Of Environmental Factors To The Risk Of Male InfertilityContribution Of Environmental Factors To The Risk Of Male Infertility
Contribution Of Environmental Factors To The Risk Of Male InfertilityBiblioteca Virtual
 
Contraindications To Breastfeeding
Contraindications To BreastfeedingContraindications To Breastfeeding
Contraindications To BreastfeedingBiblioteca Virtual
 

Mais de Biblioteca Virtual (20)

Aleitamento Materno Manual De OrientaçãO
Aleitamento Materno   Manual De OrientaçãOAleitamento Materno   Manual De OrientaçãO
Aleitamento Materno Manual De OrientaçãO
 
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce ExaminationStatistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
 
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level ILactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
 
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
 
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
 
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce ExaminationStatistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
 
Uk Formula Marketing Practices
Uk Formula Marketing PracticesUk Formula Marketing Practices
Uk Formula Marketing Practices
 
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce ExaminationStatistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
Statistical Report Of The 2008 Iblce Examination
 
PromoçãO, ProtecçãO E Apoio. Apoio RepresentaçõEs Sociais Em Aleitamento Materno
PromoçãO, ProtecçãO E Apoio. Apoio RepresentaçõEs Sociais Em Aleitamento MaternoPromoçãO, ProtecçãO E Apoio. Apoio RepresentaçõEs Sociais Em Aleitamento Materno
PromoçãO, ProtecçãO E Apoio. Apoio RepresentaçõEs Sociais Em Aleitamento Materno
 
O Ensino De Aleitamento Materno Na GraduaçãO Em Medicina Um Estudo De Caso
O Ensino De Aleitamento Materno Na GraduaçãO Em Medicina   Um Estudo De CasoO Ensino De Aleitamento Materno Na GraduaçãO Em Medicina   Um Estudo De Caso
O Ensino De Aleitamento Materno Na GraduaçãO Em Medicina Um Estudo De Caso
 
No Seio Da FamíLia AmamentaçãO E PromoçãO Da SaúDe No Programa De SaúDe Da ...
No Seio Da FamíLia   AmamentaçãO E PromoçãO Da SaúDe No Programa De SaúDe Da ...No Seio Da FamíLia   AmamentaçãO E PromoçãO Da SaúDe No Programa De SaúDe Da ...
No Seio Da FamíLia AmamentaçãO E PromoçãO Da SaúDe No Programa De SaúDe Da ...
 
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level ILactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
Lactation Management Self Study Modules Level I
 
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
AnáLise Da Efetividade De Um Programa De Incentivo Ao Aleitamento Materno Exc...
 
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
AvaliaçãO Do Impacto De Um Programa De Puericultura Na PromoçãO Da Amamentaçã...
 
Iblce Regional Office In Europe Candidate Information Guide
Iblce Regional Office In Europe   Candidate Information GuideIblce Regional Office In Europe   Candidate Information Guide
Iblce Regional Office In Europe Candidate Information Guide
 
A ImportâNcia Da AmamentaçãO Para A SaúDe Da Mulher Que Amamenta
A ImportâNcia Da AmamentaçãO Para A SaúDe Da Mulher Que AmamentaA ImportâNcia Da AmamentaçãO Para A SaúDe Da Mulher Que Amamenta
A ImportâNcia Da AmamentaçãO Para A SaúDe Da Mulher Que Amamenta
 
AmamentaçãO E Uso De AntiinflamatóRios NãO EsteróIdes Pela Nutriz InformaçõEs...
AmamentaçãO E Uso De AntiinflamatóRios NãO EsteróIdes Pela Nutriz InformaçõEs...AmamentaçãO E Uso De AntiinflamatóRios NãO EsteróIdes Pela Nutriz InformaçõEs...
AmamentaçãO E Uso De AntiinflamatóRios NãO EsteróIdes Pela Nutriz InformaçõEs...
 
Anatomofisiologia[1]
Anatomofisiologia[1]Anatomofisiologia[1]
Anatomofisiologia[1]
 
Contribution Of Environmental Factors To The Risk Of Male Infertility
Contribution Of Environmental Factors To The Risk Of Male InfertilityContribution Of Environmental Factors To The Risk Of Male Infertility
Contribution Of Environmental Factors To The Risk Of Male Infertility
 
Contraindications To Breastfeeding
Contraindications To BreastfeedingContraindications To Breastfeeding
Contraindications To Breastfeeding
 

Communicating Human Biomonitoring Results To Ensure Policy Coherence With Public Health Recommendations Analyzing Breastmilk Whilst Protecting, Promoting And Supporting Breastfeeding

  • 1. Environmental Health BioMed Central Review Open Access Communicating human biomonitoring results to ensure policy coherence with public health recommendations: analysing breastmilk whilst protecting, promoting and supporting breastfeeding Maryse Arendt Address: Institute for Improvements around Birth of Initiativ Liewensufank, 20 rue de Contern, 5955 Itzig, Luxembourg Email: Maryse Arendt - info@liewensufank.lu from Ethics and communication in human biomonitoring in Europe: results from preparation of pilot studies Copenhagen, Denmark. 11–13 March 2007 Published: 5 June 2008 Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6 doi:10.1186/1476-069X-7-S1-S6 <supplement> <title> <p>Ethics and communication in human biomonitoring: European perspectives</p> </title> <editor>Lisbeth E Knudsen, Franco Domenico Merlo and Ann Dyreborg Larsen</editor> <note>Reviews and Research</note> <url>http://www.biomedcentral.com/content/files/pdf/1476-069X-7-S1-info.pdf</url> </supplement> This article is available from: http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6 © 2008 Arendt; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Abstract This article addresses the problem of how to ensure consistency in messages communicating public health recommendations on environmental health and on child health. The World Health Organization states that the protection, promotion and support of breastfeeding rank among the most effective interventions to improve child survival. International public health policy recommends exclusive breastfeeding for six months, followed by continued breastfeeding with the addition of safe and adequate complementary foods for two years and beyond. Biomonitoring of breastmilk is used as an indicator of environmental pollution ending up in mankind. This article will therefore present the biomonitoring results of concentrations of residues in breastmilk in a wider context. These results are the mirror that reflects the chemical substances accumulated in the bodies of both men and women in the course of a lifetime. The accumulated substances in our bodies may have an effect on male or female reproductive cells; they are present in the womb, directly affecting the environment of the fragile developing foetus; they are also present in breastmilk. Evidence of man-made chemical residues in breastmilk can provide a shock tactic to push for stronger laws to protect the environment. However, messages about chemicals detected in breastmilk can become dramatized by the media and cause a backlash against breastfeeding, thus contradicting the public health messages issued by the World Health Organization. Analyses of breastmilk show the presence of important nutritional components and live protective factors active in building up the immune system, in gastro intestinal maturation, in immune defence and in providing antiviral, antiparasitic and antibacterial activity. Through cohort studies researchers in environmental health have concluded that long-term breastfeeding counterbalances the effect of prenatal exposure to chemicals causing delay in mental and psychomotor development. Therefore caution should be exercised when presenting the results of biomonitoring of breastmilk. The results should be a motivation to enact strong legislation on chemicals and review the use of chemical substances present in breastmilk, but the results should not be used to undermine the confidence in breastmilk as the optimal food for infants and young children. Page 1 of 6 (page number not for citation purposes)
  • 2. Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6 http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6 Introduction they are present in our bodies before conception and may This article discusses how analysing breastmilk for the have an effect on male or female reproductive cells; the presence of environmental chemicals bears the risk of chemicals are present in the womb thus affecting the undermining the confidence of mothers, parents and direct environment of the fragile developing foetus. These health professionals in breastfeeding and/or long term substances can harm conception by affecting fertility or by breastfeeding. In 2006, during the debate on REACH leg- having teratogenic effects on reproductive cells. This issue islation, a report was presented in the European parlia- is now discussed in numerous scientific articles. Studies ment entitled "Toxic inheritance – more than 300 have shown that semen quality and semen counts deteri- pollutants in breastmilk" [1]. This publication issued by orate [5-7]. Male-mediated developmental toxicity is a the NGOs "BUND" Germany and "Friends of the Earth concept becoming more widely known to researchers in Europe" was based on a translation of a German publica- this field [8-10]. The paternal impact on reproductive dis- tion from 2005 which compiled data of biomonitoring orders and childhood cancers as a result of occupational for a number of substances in breastmilk from around the exposure has been documented for e.g. pesticides or wood world. The focus was to alert parliamentarians to the pres- preservatives [11-13]. But this impact of residues remains ence of chemicals in humans, with special focus on vul- less discussed amongst the wider public, whereas residues nerable babies to guarantee more media attention. The found in breastmilk are discussed or used for media head- presence of chemical residues in breastmilk is a shocking lines to grab attention. The attention given to breastmilk reality, yet breastfeeding is the natural way and optimal to may be triggered by the fact that breastmilk, containing feed infants and young children. Paediatricians and policy pollutants, is violating a basic social concept of 'purity' of makers agree that the protection, promotion and support this food and this unique relationship of a mother and of breastfeeding are public health priorities. Today we baby. know that breastfed children are healthier than infants receiving only some breast milk or none at all [2]. There- Repeated biomonitoring of breastmilk or other body flu- fore this article will present the biomonitoring results of ids provides the evidence base for strengthening legisla- breastmilk in a wider context linked to the ethical issue of tion to phase out or reduce chemicals such as PCB and communication to ensure consistency with public health DDT. Effective legislation has had beneficial results: the policy. levels of these chemicals measured as concentrations in our bodies are lower today than 10 or 20 years ago [4,14]. Breastmilk as a biomonitoring fluid Comparing biomonitoring results between countries with Breastmilk is often used in human biomonitoring to and without legislation for reduced use of chemicals detect persistent residues of man-made chemicals accu- shows great differences. mulated in human bodies along the food chain. It is used as an indicator and as a monitoring instrument of fat sol- Breastfeeding as a unique food, containing live uble and persistent substances [3]. Breastmilk is often protective factors seen as an easy tool for biomonitoring because it is non "Breastfeeding is the natural way to feed infants and invasive, though this ignores the fact that it may not be young children. Exclusive breastfeeding for the first six easy for the mother to deliver the needed amount, as months of life ensures optimal growth, development and pumping or expressing breastmilk can be problematic for health. After that, breastfeeding, with appropriate comple- some women. Information on chemicals in breastmilk mentary foods continues to contribute to the infant's and may affect the mother and her social network in a way that young child's nutrition development and health", as cited undermines their confidence in the continuation of in the document: "Protection, promotion and support of breastfeeding. Our association is regularly questioned by breastfeeding in Europe: a Blueprint for action."[15]. This anxious parents or by health professionals after headlines explains why breastmilk needs to be protected from envi- on residues in breastmilk have been issued. ronmental pollution and why paediatricians and policy makers agree that protection, promotion and support of Today we can detect a wide range of foreign substances in breastfeeding are a public health priority [2,16]. Breast- breastmilk. The results presented are the mirror of chemi- milk contains an ample set of potent beneficial substances cal substances accumulated over the lifespan in the bodies such as: Special long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids, of both men and women. The biomonitoring of breast- lysozymes, secretory IgA, lactoferrin, lipase, prostagland- milk reveals residues of pesticides like DDT, Lindane, ins, macrophages, cytokines, epidermal growth factor, HCH and their breakdown products as well as chemicals relaxin, interferon, antioxidants, leucocytes, adiponectin like PCB, Bisphenol A, phthalates, synthetic perfumes and leptin to name only a few [17-19]. These substances (musks), flame retardants, sunscreen, perchlorate and are active in neural maturation, in building up the chemical by-products like dioxins [1,4]. The fact that these immune system, in gastrointestinal maturation, in substances are to be found in breast milk indicates that immune defence and in setting and regulating body func- Page 2 of 6 (page number not for citation purposes)
  • 3. Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6 http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6 tions and metabolic processes. Some substances have tive impact on cognitive and neurological development is antiviral, antiparasitic and antibacterial activity. It has measurable for exposure in uterus. Findings from these been shown that infants fed on breastmilk substitutes cohort studies, which included biomonitoring and moni- such as infant formula are less healthy than breastfed toring of breastfed status and duration of breastfeeding, infants. Many studies have proved that there is a dose may be unexpected for those looking only at the measure- dependent effect; the more and longer an infant is breast- ments and the figures of the residues in breastmilk and fed, the more beneficial is the effect on growth and ignoring the bioactive factors contained in breastmilk. healthy development. When infants are breastfed their Breastmilk enhances immunologic development and gut immune system is better developed, the brain and neuro- maturation, it has antimicrobial and anti-inflammatory logical system can mature in an optimal way and the gut properties [20]. system develops better. Breastfed infants suffer less from respiratory diseases, diarrhoea, otitis media and urinary Boersma and Lanting showed that at six years of age cog- tract infections. They have optimal visual and intellectual nitive development is affected by prenatal exposure to development and a reduced risk of Diabetes type 1 and 2, PCBs and dioxins [21]. Breastfed children however, when allergic diseases, obesity, Crohn's disease, malignant lym- compared to formula fed children, had an advantage in phomas and cardiovascular disease in adulthood [2]. It terms of quality of movements, fluency and cognitive can be concluded that breastfeeding strengthens the development tests at 18 and 42 months of age and at six infant's developing immune system and decreases the years, despite a higher PCB exposure from breast milk. incidence or severity of infectious diseases. Breastfeeding The conclusions of Boersma and Lanting were: "These is also associated with a slightly enhanced performance data give evidence that prenatal exposure to PCBs do have on tests of cognitive development. Studies of cognitive subtle negative effects on neurological and cognitive development in relation to breastfeeding have all been development of the child up to school-age (....). Our stud- performed in western environments with present levels of ies showed evidence that breast feeding counteracts the pollution. Based on the strong scientific evidence of the adverse developmental effects of PCBs and dioxins" [21]. benefits of breastfeeding the American Academy of Pedi- atrics [2], WHO, UNICEF [16] and other organisations of The results are supported by a study of Ribas-Fitó et al., health professionals recommend exclusive breastfeeding who studied a birth cohort of 92 mother-infant pairs for the first six months of life and continued breastfeeding highly exposed to organochlorine compounds. The up to two years and beyond. The American Paediatric researchers published their findings in 2003 in Pediatrics Association recommends in their latest policy document and their conclusion stated: "Prenatal exposure to that: "Breastfeeding should be continued for at least the p,p'DDE was associated with a delay in mental and psy- first year of life and beyond for as long as mutually desired chomotor development at 13 months. Long-term breast- by mother and child. There is no upper limit to the dura- feeding was found to be beneficial to neurodevelopment, tion of breastfeeding and no evidence of psychologic or potentially counterbalancing the impact of exposure to developmental harm from breastfeeding into the third these chemicals through breast-milk" [22]. year of life or longer"[2]. The WHO recommendation for optimal infant and young child feeding is: "The expert In a review Feeley and Brouwer concluded that: "Little if consultation recommends exclusive breastfeeding for six any adverse health effects have been associated with months, with introduction of complementary foods and breast-feeding. In fact, the beneficial effect from breast- continued breastfeeding thereafter for up to two years of feeding on neurological measures has been observed" age or beyond" [16]. The recommendation was adopted [23]. by all WHO member governments in 2002 at the World Health Assembly in the Global Strategy on Infant and The positive results of breastfeeding are also found in an Young Child Feeding [16]. This is a global public health exploratory study by Vreugdenhil et al. who suggest that recommendation and should be implemented at national prenatal exposure to environmental levels of PCBs and level. related compounds delays mechanisms in the central nervous system that evaluate and process relevant stimuli, The evidence base: Study results of perinatally exposed whereas breastfeeding accelerates these mechanisms [24]. cohorts Prenatal exposure to chemicals during pregnancy, when In recent studies the issue of cognitive development and the vulnerability of the foetus is highest, may harm or breastfeeding has been further addressed. In a study from impair the neurological and cognitive development of the Pediatrics published in 2006 by Charnley and Kimbrough unborn child and may have a negative impact on the the researchers state that: "Breast-fed infants have higher immune system. Numerous cohort studies on infants exposures than formula-fed infants, but studies consist- born and living in exposed regions conclude that a nega- ently find that breast-fed infants perform better on devel- Page 3 of 6 (page number not for citation purposes)
  • 4. Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6 http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6 opmental neurologic tests than their formula-fed indicator of the body burden of all human beings and that counterparts, supporting the well-recognized benefits of the focus is not only directed towards "contaminated breast feeding" [25]. The benefits of breastfeeding despite breastmilk". The results should be an exhortation to polit- exposure to higher levels of chemicals were also found in ical action for strong legislation on the production, another recent study published in Pediatrics by Eskenazi release, and use of these chemicals detected in breastmilk. et al, who concluded that: "Prenatal exposure to DDT, and The results should not be used to undermine confidence to a lesser extent DDE, was associated with neurodevelop- in breastmilk as the optimal food for infants and young mental delays during early childhood, although breast- children. The existence of chemical residues in breastmilk feeding was found to be beneficial even among women is not a reason for limiting breastfeeding. On the contrary with high levels of exposure" [26]. those findings are one of the reasons to breastfeed because breastmilk contains substances that help the child These findings all show what happens with breastfed develop a stronger immune system and optimal neural infants born into our present polluted environment. and brain maturation. Thus breastfeeding can help limit However, because of the lack of a control group living in the damage caused by foetal exposure to these chemicals. an unexposed environment, it is not possible to assess the total positive health and development impact of breast- Examples of good communication messages feeding. For persons involved in human biomonitoring of breast- milk it is paramount to protect breastmilk and breastfeed- Communication of results ing as the best possible nutrition for growth and healthy In the media breastmilk, when used as a biomonitoring development of infants and young children [27,28]. This tool for analysing the human body burden, is often por- can be done by elucidating a comprehensive picture of trayed as being contaminated with persistent organic pol- exposure, as explained above. To include lactation special- lutants [1]. Sensational messages about contaminants in ists e.g. lactation consultants and NGOs working on pro- breastmilk undermine the value of breastfeeding and the tection and support of breastfeeding in planning and confidence of parents and health care professionals in communication efforts could also be a valuable tool. breastfeeding and long term breastfeeding. Perceptions Agencies and NGOs active in biomonitoring of breastmilk created by communication of the findings of residues are becoming aware of this situation and of the need for a detected in breastmilk place the focus on breastmilk, change in their communication methods [29]. thereby indirectly blaming the breastfeeding mother. Attention is drawn away from the pollutants which create In May 2005, WHO and UNEP entered into a Memorandum this situation and from the industries that produce, use or of Agreement for the coordination of human milk surveys for release the chemicals and thereby create environmental the purpose of the Stockholm Convention. pollution. Attention is deflected from the fact that these persistent chemicals accumulate in the food chain and "At the same time, evidence for the health advantages of breast- have adverse effects that are more or less documented on feeding and scientific evidence to support breastfeeding has con- all species high up on the food chain, including human tinued to increase. beings. Nevertheless NGOs have legitimate normative and political reasons to expose this, in trying to galvanise • WHO can now say with full confidence that breastfeeding public pressure for political action to prevent, reduce and reduces child mortality and has health benefits that extend into eliminate the sources of contaminating chemicals. In cur- adulthood. rent messages communicating the detection of residues in breastmilk, the whole situational context is overlooked: On a population basis, exclusive breastfeeding for six months is "polluted breastmilk" is the main focus and avoidance of the recommended feeding mode for the vast majority of infants, breastfeeding is seen as a possible option. It is forgotten followed by continued breastfeeding with appropriate comple- that breastmilk is an indicator of the bioaccumulation of mentary foods for up to two years or beyond." persistent chemical substances in both men and women. The questioning of female body fluids, with "white" and In 2005, the World Health Organisation (WHO) issued "pure" milk portrayed as being polluted and "impure", the 4th WHO coordinated survey of human milk for per- leads emotions into ancient fears. Insensitive communica- sistent organic pollutants with the following message: "In tion of biomonitoring results focussing only on the pres- all cases human milk will be promoted as the naturally ence of substances that should not be in breastmilk and superior food for infants (...) This survey being consistent their measured values undermines the confidence of with the promotion of human milk as the optimal food mothers, fathers, and health professionals in breastfeed- for infants could provide the ideal basis for possible ing. It is very important that communication on residues source-directed measures to ultimately reduce levels of detected in breastmilk during biomonitoring is seen as an POPs in human milk" [3]. In the revised protocol of 2007 Page 4 of 6 (page number not for citation purposes)
  • 5. Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6 http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6 WHO, now in cooperation with UNEP (United Nations European perspectives. The full contents of the supplement are available Environment Programme) goes beyond this by extending online at http://www.ehjournal.net/supplements/7/S1. the messages about breastfeeding [3,30,31]; "WHO can now say with full confidence that breastfeeding reduces References 1. FOE: Toxic inheritance. 2005 [http://www.foeeurope.org/publica child mortality and has health benefits that extend into tions/2005/toxic_inheritance.pdf]. adulthood. On a population basis, exclusive breastfeeding 2. AAP: POLICY STATEMENT Breastfeeding and the Use of for six months is the recommended feeding mode for the Human Milk. PEDIATRICS 2005, 115:496-506. 3. WHO: Fourth WHO-Coordinated Survey of Human Milk for vast majority of infants, followed by continued breast- Persistent Organic Pollutants. 2005 [http://www.who.int/food feeding with appropriate complementary foods for up to safety/chem/pops/en/index.html]. 4. van Leeuwen R, Malisch R: Results of the third round of the who- two years or beyond" [30]. WHO and UNEP have now coordinated exposure study on the levels of PCBS, PCDDS developed an annex to their Protocol for Collection, Han- and PCDFS in human milk. Organohalog compd 2002, 56:311-316. dling and Analysis of Samples at the Country Level named 5. CPCHE: A Father's day Report – Men, boys and environmen- tal health threats. 2007 [http://www.healthyenvironment "The value of breastfeeding" [30], which contains follow- forkids.ca/img_upload/13297cd6a147585a24c1c6233d8d96d8/ ing message: "Breastfeeding is the ideal way to feed father__s_day_report_summary.pdf]. infants; its benefits go far beyond sound nutrition, and 6. Oliva A, Spira A, Multigner L: Contribution of environmental fac- tors to the risk of male infertility. Hum Reprod 2001, children should not needlessly be deprived of it" [30]. 16:1768-1776. 7. Whorton D, Milby TH, Krauss RM, Stubbs HA: Testicular function in DBCP exposed pesticide workers. J Occup Med 1979, In this protocol WHO has even gone beyond the messages 21:161-166. quoted above by not only targeting organisers of biomon- 8. Nelson BK, Moorman WJ, Schrader SM: Review of experimental itoring of breastmilk and field workers in contact with male-mediated behavioral and neurochemical disorders. Neurotoxicol Teratol 1996, 18:611-616. mothers, but by also including communication addressed 9. Olshan AF, Faustman EM: Male-mediated developmental toxic- directly to mothers. They have developed a prenatal infor- ity. Annu Rev Public Health 1993, 14:159-181. 10. Sever LE: Male-mediated developmental toxicity. Epidemiology mation sheet on breastfeeding for mothers selected to be 1995, 6:573-574. included in their survey. 11. Dimich-Ward H, Hertzman C, Teschke K, Marion SA, Ostry A, Kelly S: Reproductive effects of paternal exposure to chlorophen- ate wood preservatives in the sawmill industry. Scand J Work Messages such as those above, including scientific evi- Environ Health 1996, 22:267-273. dence both promote and protect breastfeeding whenever 12. Infante-Revard C, Sinnett D: Preconceptional paternal exposure breastmilk is collected, sampled and analysed for bio- to pesticides and increased risk of childhood leukaemia. Lan- cet 1999, 354:1819. monitoring. 13. Pierik FH, Burdorf A, Deddens JA, Juttmann RE, Weber RF: Mater- nal and paternal risk factors for cryptorchidism and hypospa- dias: a case-control study in newborn boys. Environ Health Awareness about similar caution in communication is Perspect 2004, 112:1570-1576. being discussed when publishing levels of chemicals in 14. WHO: Children's environmental health. 2007 [http:// fish versus the positive health effects of consuming fish, or www.who.int/ceh/publications/en/poster15new.pdf]. 15. Cattaneo A: Breastfeeding in Europe: a blueprint for action. J residues of pesticides in fruit and vegetables while pro- Public Health 2005, 13:89-96. moting a recommended amount of fruit or vegetables a 16. WHO, UNICEF: Global strategy for infant and young child feeding. 2003 [http://www.paho.org/english/ad/fch/ca/ day. GSIYCF_infantfeeding_eng.pdf]. 17. Cattaneo A, Lehners M: Comment on "Breast milk: an optimal Conclusion food". Environ Health Perspect 2005, 113:A18-A19. 18. Labbok MH, Clark D, Goldman AS: Breastfeeding: maintaining Breastfeeding rates in Europe are rising but they are still an irreplaceable immunological resource. Nat Rev Immunol far away from the recommendation of the World Health 2004, 4:565-572. Organisation, as shown in Cattaneo [15]: it is therefore 19. Pronczuk J, Moy G, Vallenas C: Breast milk: an optimal food. Environ Health Perspect 2004, 112:A722-A723. important that messages about biomonitoring results do 20. Lawrence R, Lawrence R: Breastfeeding – A Guide for the medical pro- not harm or undermine public health messages for the fession 6th edition. Elsevier Mosby; 2005. 21. Boersma ER, Lanting CI: Environmental exposure to polychlo- protection, promotion and support of breastfeeding. On rinated biphenyls (PCBs) and dioxins. Consequences for the other hand, breastmilk and breastfeeding should be longterm neurological and cognitive development of the protected against harmful substances and harmful mes- child lactation. Adv Exp Med Biol 2000, 478:271-287. 22. Ribas-Fitó N, Cardo E, Sala M, Eulália de Muga M, Mazón C, Verdú A, sages. The communication efforts by WHO to ensure pol- et al.: Breastfeeding, exposure to organochlorine compounds, icy consistency provide a good example and should be and neurodevelopment in infants. Pediatrics 2003, 111(5 Pt implemented whenever breastmilk is analysed. 1):e580-e585. 23. Feeley M, Brouwer A: Health risks to infants from exposure to PCBs, PCDDs and PCDFs. Food Addit Contam 2000, 17:325-333. Competing interests 24. Vreugdenhil H, Van Zanten GA, Brocaar MP, Mulders PG, Weisglas- Kuperus N: Prenatal exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls The authors declare that they have no competing interests. and breastfeeding: opposing effects on auditory P300 laten- cies in 9-year-old Dutch children. Dev Med Child Neurol 2004, Acknowledgements 46:398-405. 25. Charnley G, Kimbrough RD: Overview of exposure, toxicity, and This article has been published as part of Environmental Health Volume 7 risks to children from current levels of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorod- Supplement 1, 2008: Ethics and communication in human biomonitoring: Page 5 of 6 (page number not for citation purposes)
  • 6. Environmental Health 2008, 7(Suppl 1):S6 http://www.ehjournal.net/content/7/S1/S6 ibenzo-p-dioxin and related compounds in the USA. Food Chem Toxicol 2006, 44:601-615. 26. Eskenazi B, Marks AR, Bradman A, Fenster L, Johnson C, Barr DB, Jewell NP: In utero exposure to dichlorodiphenyltrichlo- roethane (DDT) and dichlorodiphenyldichloroethylene (DDE) and neurodevelopment among young Mexican Amer- ican children. Pediatrics 2006, 118:233-241. 27. Berlin CM, Crase BL, Fürst P, LaKind JS, Moy G, Needham LL, et al.: Methodologic considerations for improving and facilitating human milk research. J Toxicol Environ Health A 2005, 68:1803-1823. 28. Berlin CM, LaKind JS, Fenton SE, Wang RY, Bates MN, Brent RL, et al.: Conclusions and recommendations of the expert panel: technical workshop on human milk surveillance and biomon- itoring for environmental chemicals in the United States. J Toxicol Environ Health A 2005, 68:1825-1831. 29. EEN, IBFAN: Press release and EP-event: Pro-REACH groups says; breast is still best. Health and Environment alliance 2006 [http://www.env-health.org/a/2172]. 30. WHO: Biomonitoring of human milk A Protocol for Collec- tion, Handling and Analysis of Samples at the Country Level. 2007 [http://www.who.int/foodsafety/chem/POPprotocol.pdf]. 31. WHO: technical note: Biomonitoring of Human Milk. 2007 [http://www.who.int/foodsafety/chem/POPtechnicalnote.pdf]. Publish with Bio Med Central and every scientist can read your work free of charge "BioMed Central will be the most significant development for disseminating the results of biomedical researc h in our lifetime." Sir Paul Nurse, Cancer Research UK Your research papers will be: available free of charge to the entire biomedical community peer reviewed and published immediately upon acceptance cited in PubMed and archived on PubMed Central yours — you keep the copyright Submit your manuscript here: BioMedcentral http://www.biomedcentral.com/info/publishing_adv.asp Page 6 of 6 (page number not for citation purposes)