SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 25
Baixar para ler offline
TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY OF CRETE
DEPARTMENT OF MINERAL RESOURCES ENGINEERING
APPLIED GEOPHYSICS LAB
73 100 CHANIA
TEL: (+30-28210) 37670 - Fax: (+30-28210) 69554 – e-mail: gkritik@mred.tuc.gr
USERS’ MANUAL FOR kriSIS v1.04
Open Source Matlab™ Algorithms for Analysis of Surface Waves
Programmed by g. kritikakis
Manual v. 1.1
July 2010
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik2
USERS’ MANUAL FOR kriSIS v1.04
kriSIS OPEN SOURCE ALGORITHMS HAVE BEEN TESTED IN MATLAB™ 6.5
RUNNING ON WINDOWS XP sp2 AND ARE DISTRIBUTED FOR FREE "AS IS",
WITHOUT WARRANTIES AS TO PERFORMANCE OR MERCHANTABILITY OR
ANY OTHER WARRANTIES WHETHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED. NO
WARRANTY OF FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE IS OFFERED.
Consult the installation guide before running kriSIS v1.04.
Run the command “kriSIS_auto” on the command window to launch the
application. For further documentation press “help kriSIS_auto“ on the
command window. The MASW data processing is competed to 5 steps:
1. The first step includes reading SGY seismic files or importing a dispersion
curve.
To proceed with the first step, press “Continue”. To terminate the process
press “Cancel”.
IMPORTANT: The byte of binary SGY data must be 32-Bit Floating Point
ordered as “Most Significant Byte First”. To create SGY file from a Matlab
array use the command DATA2SGY(data,dt,offset).
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik3
Dispersion curves can be imported either by an *.RDC file (from previously
processed data) or just a (stored as *.mat file) 3-column ([frequency phase
velocity dispersion curve error]) MATLAB table. IMPORTANT: The selection
of this kind of date bypasses the steps 2 and 3.
2. The second step includes the transformation of seismic data from Time-
Distance domain to Frequency-Phase velocity domain where the dispersion
curves will be shown among the local energy maxima.
To proceed with the second step, press “Continue”. To terminate the
process, press “Cancel”. To return to the previous step press “Back”.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik4
The kriSIS uses the available from file headers information to set up “Shot
Geometry” parameters. IMPORTANT: All that matters is the relative position
of the seismic source compare to the geophones. It is also correct, for
example, to insert as Source Coordinate 0.00, and first Receiver Coordinate
7.5, instead of –7.5 and 0.0, respectively.
If the geophones were placed in irregular intervals along seismic line, the user
can edit geophone offsets individually by pressing the “Get from Headers
/ Set Irregular Group Intervals” button.
If you set on (default option) the “Normalize amplitudes of original
(t,x) data” radio button, the amplitudes of seismic traces will be
normalized (before the wavefield transformation) to revert the seismic energy
loss due to geometrical spreading.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik5
Phase velocity – Frequency domain window is selected by setting the
minimum and maximum values of phase velocity and frequency as well as
their increment. Normally, the default values are adequate to image the
dispersion curve of the most seismic records. The user can refine the window
afterwards using the “Back” option.
3. The third step includes the selection of fundamental and higher mode
dispersion curves from the local energy maxima.
To proceed with the third step, press “Continue”. To terminate the
process, press “Cancel”. To return to the previous step press “Back”.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik6
There is an option to import dispersion curves (DCs) from adjacent seismic
records as a guide DCs for easier selection. Dispersion curves can be
imported either by an *.RDC file (from previously processed data) or just a
(stored as *.mat file) 3-column ([frequency phase velocity dispersion curve
error]) MATLAB table.
Fundamental DC selection is performed by surrounding the white crosses
(which correspond to the local maxima along frequency) using a polygon.
LEFT mouse key sets a point of the polygon on the image, DELETE button
deletes previously set points and RIGHT mouse key is used to terminate the
selection. IMPORTANT: Usually the fundamental dispersion curve is
appeared at lower frequencies and phase velocities than higher modes. Make
sure that the first DC you select corresponds to the fundamental one.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik7
In MATLAB 6.5, the selected crosses are automatically highlighted with
magenta squares and an estimation of the DC standard deviation is calculated
(bounds). DC standard deviation is calculated along each frequency by the
determination of the difference between the phase velocity, which corresponds
to selected DC point and the phase velocity of a point with energy equal to
63% of the corresponding energy of selected DC point. IMPORTANT: In
MATLAB 7.5 (R2007b) the polygon selection must be verified by pressing
RIGHT mouse button and selecting the option “Create Mask”
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik8
Afterwards, kriSIS prompts a window to request if the user intends to select
the next higher mode. IMPORTANT: You cannot neglect the selection of a
higher mode in order to proceed with the selection of the next one. Thus,
higher modes must be selected sequentially.
Higher mode selection is repeated (up to 9 modes including fundamental)
unless the user terminates DC selection by pressing “NO” button.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik9
4. The forth step includes the selection of initial model, inversion parameters
and convergence criteria.
To proceed with the forth step, press “Continue”. To terminate the
process, press “Cancel”. To return to the previous step press “Back”.
MODEL PARAMETERS
kriSIS_auto creates automatically an initial model parameters based on the
values of fundamental dispersion curve. In this case, the “No of Layers“ is
affected from the selection of DC to initial model transformation mode
(“Coarse“, “Medium“, “Fine“). IMPORTANT: Usually, only the low depth
layers are split when the user increases the level of layering (i.e. to Fine). The
default value is “Coarse“. The first layer is common to get greater thickness
than the second, third, etc.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik10
The user can modify the “No of Layers“ from 2 to 35, either by writing the
number in the box, or using the up and down arrows. In this case, the DC to
initial model transformation mode is turned automatically to “Variable“ layer
thickness and the model layers receive gradually increased thickness as the
depth increases.
Maximum investigation depth is correlated to the greatest observed
wavelength (λ=VR/f) with “λ / depth ratio”. This ratio can be modified
from 1 to 3. However, by pressing the “OR” button, the user can define the
maximum depth. In this case “λ / depth ratio” is deactivated.
IMPORTANT: Extreme values of depth (compared to the proposed) may lead
to erroneous solutions or unstable inversion.
The model layers can also be equal by pressing the “Equal” radio button.
Initial model can be imported by reading the best iteration from an
“ACDC_OUT.txt” export file of a previously processed record or DC file (see
saved files further down).
By pressing “Default”, the model parameters are set according to the
values: “Medium“ layering calculated from DC and “λ / depth ratio =
2.0”
All table elements are adjustable apart from depth (Z) values, which are
calculated from layers Thickness.
Either Vp, or Poisson’s ratio (ν) value of each layer must be fixed during the
inversion. Fixing value equal to 1 means that the model parameter of the
corresponding layer is free to change during the inversion. Fixing value equal
to 0 means the opposite. IMPORTANT: Any a-priory information can be
retained during the inversion by fixing the appropriate values. IMPORTANT:
Vp, ν and density (ρ) ARE NOT inverted. They just change values every
iteration according to the fixed values (Vp or ν) and the values of Vs.
Fixing all values of Vp, Poisson’s ratio or density can be done by selecting the
corresponding check box (“fix all Vp”, “fix all Pois”, “fix all ρ”).
The values of all Poisson’s ratios can also be edited by setting its value to the
“all Pois” box.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik11
Poisson’s ratio values is calculated from the Vs and Vp values according to
the formula:
1
15.0
2
2
−⎟
⎠
⎞
⎜
⎝
⎛
−⎟
⎠
⎞
⎜
⎝
⎛
⋅
=
Vs
Vp
Vs
Vp
ν , while density is calculated from:
ρ = 0.0002·Vp + 1.7 (g/cm3
)
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik12
INVERSION PARAMETERS
The values of Jacobian matrix can be calculated numerically from Thomson-
Haskell method using Ridder’s discrete differentiation technique (“T – H”
selection) or estimated using “Quasi – Newton” techniques. The later
method is NOT recommended due to its unstable inversion behavior and the
insecure results that may produce.
Weighting DC data can be done by taking into consideration the “DC error”
bounds (see STEP 3), the values of Jacobian matrix (“Jacobian values”)
and/or the differences between the observed and the calculated dispersion
curves (“Robust Inversion”) in any combination of the three. The selection
of the later, corresponds to the minimization of the sum of absolute differences
between the observed and the calculated dispersion curves (Norm L1) using
the Iteratively Re-weighted Least Squares (IRLS) method.
Five types of constraints can be applied: (1) Smoothing, (2) Damping and (3)
Blocky (a modified smoothing constraint which MAY highlights sharp
boundaries), as well as the combination of (4) Smoothing and Damping or (5)
Damping and Blocky.
The default inversion parameters are: “T - H” Jacobian calculation, “Robust
inversion” weight and “Bloky” constraint.
CONVERGENCE CRITERIA
The selection of “Optimizing RMS” radio button optimizes the inversion
process by calculating the optimum Lagrangean multiplier in each iteration
using internal sub-iterations. This forces inversion to the reduction of RMS
error in each iteration and stops the process when no further RMS reduction
can be achieved. It should be deactivated only when the inversion stops at the
first few iterations and the RMS error remains high.
“Max Iteration” is the maximum number of iterations in case that the
following convergence criteria are not satisfied. It can be set up to 200. Its
default value, when “Optimizing RMS” is activated, is 30. 100 otherwise.
“Min % RMS Error” is the main (desired) stopping criterion. Inversion
process stops when the percentile root mean square error between the
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik13
observed and the calculated dispersion curves is lower than the selected
value. Takes values from 0.1 to 99.9 %.
By pressing “AND” button the “Max Vs correction for RMS satisfied
(m/s)” box is activated and another stopping criterion is added to the
previous one (RMS). Namely, inversion process stops when the RMS error is
lower than its limit AND the maximum model correction (in m/s) is lower than
the selected value (default 1 m/s).
The last convergence criterion “Min Vs correction for RMS NOT
satisfied (m/s)” prevents the inversion to converge very slowly. The
process stops when the maximum model correction (in m/s) is lower than the
selected value (default 0.01 m/s).
Default values are shown on the figure above.
When the user presses “OK” button, kriSIS performs check to the imported model
parameters. Some warning messages may appear on the screen related to the
maximum depth of investigation and the correction of Vp or Poisson’s ratio
values.
By minimizing (not necessary) all prompted windows the user is able to observe
on the command window information about the inversion process (Iteration No,
RMS error, Damping, Smoothing and/or Blocky factors, and the maximum value
of model correction – DVs(max)).
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik14
5. On the fifth step the user is able to observe the final inversion results and
save or discard them.
To save the inversion results, press “Save”. To discard the inversion result,
press “Clear”. To return to the previous step press “Back”.
IMPORTANT: The displayed inversion results concern the Vs profile, which gives
the smallest RMS error.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik15
By pressing “Back” button, the window of the 4th
step is appeared.
By pressing “Clear” button, the inversion results are discarded.
By pressing “Save” button, a dialog box is prompted where the user can
specify the directory and the filename for the inversion results to be saved. It
takes some time to save the inversion results because the forward problem
(dispersion curve calculation) is solved to calculate all possible dispersion
curves (fundamental and higher modes) of the final model, which appeared
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik16
within the specified (on Step 2) frequency – phase velocity window. A warning
message may also appear when the dispersion curves is not possible to be
calculated for the complete frequency range.
The inversion results are saved in a folder named by the given filename and
placed in the specified location. These results consist of:
ACDC_IN.dat is a text file containing the observed DC, initial model
parameters, inversion parameters and convergence criteria.
ACDC_JAC.txt is a text file containing the Jacobian matrix of each
iteration.
ACDC_OUT.txt is a text file containing the inversion history (observed
and calculated DC, DC misfit and corresponding RMS error, intermediate
Vs profiles and their adjustments and Lagrangean multipliers).
ACDC_RES.txt is a text file containing the resolution and covariance
matrices for each iteration.
‘Filename’.RDC is a MATLAB file (struct array) containing information
about the observed DCs and the transformed seismic data in the
frequency – phase velocity damain.
‘Filename’.VSD is a MATLAB file (double array) containing information
about the final model.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik17
‘Filename’_1-TRACES.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile)
displaying the seismic traces.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik18
‘Filename’_1-DC.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile) displaying the
distribution of seismic energy in frequency – phase velocity domain, the
observed DC and the calculated ones (black dashed curves).
‘Filename’_3-RES-SNS-SGM.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile)
displaying the values of Resolution matrix, the sensitivity (%) of each
model layer Vs value and the corresponding model bounds (standard
deviation of Vs values deduced from Covariance matrix).
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik19
‘Filename’_4-RMS_DISTR.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile)
displaying (a) the number of samples distributed to the RMS error (%)
levels, (b) the distribution of RMS error (%) vs the sample number and (c)
the contribution (%) of the RMS error vs the frequency range.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik20
‘Filename’_5-RMS.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile) displaying the
RMS error vs iterations and the current Lagrangean multiplier.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik21
‘Filename’_6-RES.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile), which
displays the calculated DC fit on the observed one and the corresponding
RMS error (%) as well as the initial and final Vs depth profile.
‘Filename’_OUT.xls is a tab delimited text file containing information
about the observed and calculated DC (of the best iteration), the initial
and final (best) model, the inversion parameters, convergence criteria
and RMS error for each iteration (see further down).
Either save or discard the inversion results, the processing can be repeated
(“Continue”) with the same or another data set (seismic record or DC).
Otherwise, the processing is terminated by pressing “Cancel”.
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik22
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik23
Example of ‘Filename’_OUT.xls file
Filename : SS1_S
No of modes : 2
Fundamental : 50
No Freq DCobs DCcalc DC error
1 5 198 202.704 26
2 5.2 195 198.552 25
3 5.4 193 194.84 25
4 5.6 190 191.528 23
5 5.8 189 188.57 23
6 6 187 185.917 22
7 6.2 186 183.523 22
8 6.4 183 181.347 20
9 6.6 181 179.352 19
10 6.8 180 177.508 19
11 7 178 175.789 19
12 7.2 175 174.172 17
13 7.4 173 172.638 16
14 7.6 171 171.172 15
15 7.8 169 169.76 14
16 8 168 168.393 14
17 8.2 167 167.06 13
18 8.4 166 165.757 13
19 8.6 165 164.478 12
20 8.8 164 163.218 12
21 9 163 161.978 12
22 9.2 162 160.754 12
23 9.4 161 159.546 12
24 9.6 160 158.355 12
25 9.8 158 157.182 12
26 10 155 156.027 11
27 10.2 153 154.891 11
28 10.4 151 153.776 10
29 10.6 150 152.682 10
30 10.8 149 151.61 9
31 11 148 150.561 8
32 11.2 148 149.534 9
33 11.4 147 148.53 8
34 11.6 147 147.548 8
35 11.8 146 146.589 8
36 12 145 145.651 9
37 12.2 144 144.735 9
38 12.4 143 143.84 9
39 12.6 142 142.965 9
40 12.8 141 142.11 8
41 13 141 141.274 8
42 13.2 140 140.458 7
43 13.4 139 139.661 7
44 13.6 139 138.882 7
45 13.8 138 138.123 6
46 14 138 137.382 6
47 14.2 138 136.661 6
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik24
48 14.4 137 135.958 6
49 14.6 136 135.276 6
50 14.8 134 134.614 4
Higher mode 1: 64
No Freq DCobs DCcalc DC error
1 8.2 280 270.38 34
2 8.4 274 268.108 32
3 8.6 269 265.722 31
4 8.8 264 263.229 30
5 9 259 260.639 29
6 9.2 254 257.967 28
7 9.4 250 255.23 27
8 9.6 247 252.449 26
9 9.8 245 249.647 26
10 10 244 246.85 25
11 10.2 243 244.082 25
12 10.4 241 241.369 23
13 10.6 240 238.733 23
14 10.8 238 236.194 21
15 11 236 233.768 20
16 11.2 234 231.464 19
17 11.4 231 229.29 17
18 11.6 229 227.248 17
19 11.8 227 225.336 16
20 12 225 223.551 16
21 12.2 222 221.887 15
22 12.4 221 220.336 15
23 12.6 219 218.892 14
24 12.8 218 217.544 14
25 13 217 216.285 14
26 13.2 216 215.107 14
27 13.4 216 214.001 14
28 13.6 216 212.96 13
29 13.8 215 211.977 13
30 14 214 211.044 12
31 14.2 212 210.155 12
32 14.4 210 209.304 11
33 14.6 209 208.484 11
34 14.8 208 207.691 11
35 15 207 206.92 11
36 15.2 206 206.164 11
37 15.4 205 205.42 11
38 15.6 205 204.682 11
39 15.8 204 203.947 11
40 16 204 203.21 10
41 16.2 203 202.468 10
42 16.4 202 201.716 10
43 16.6 201 200.953 10
44 16.8 201 200.175 9
45 17 200 199.382 9
46 17.2 199 198.571 9
47 17.4 198 197.744 10
kriSIS v1.04
made by gkritik25
48 17.6 197 196.9 10
49 17.8 197 196.041 10
50 18 196 195.171 10
51 18.2 196 194.292 9
52 18.4 195 193.409 9
53 18.6 194 192.526 10
54 18.8 193 191.647 10
55 19 192 190.778 10
56 19.2 190 189.921 10
57 19.4 189 189.082 10
58 19.6 188 188.262 10
59 19.8 187 187.466 10
60 20 187 186.695 9
61 20.2 186 185.951 9
62 20.4 185 185.235 9
63 20.6 184 184.547 10
64 20.8 183 183.889 10
Iteration % RMS error
0 6.77E+01
1 3.21E+01
2 3.79E+00
3 2.50E+00
4 2.07E+00
5 1.46E+00
6 9.18E-01
Model layers: 20
Thickness (m) Depth (m) Poisson's ratio Density (gr/cm^3) Vp (m/s) Vs (m/s) σ (m/s)
0.10 0.10 0.4 1.742 210.600 85.977 14.784
0.20 0.30 0.4 1.742 210.624 85.987 11.032
0.30 0.60 0.4 1.755 277.084 113.119 10.920
0.39 0.99 0.4 1.766 330.973 135.119 11.971
0.49 1.48 0.4 1.778 387.615 158.243 10.429
0.59 2.07 0.4 1.774 372.472 152.061 7.441
0.69 2.76 0.4 1.751 255.332 104.239 5.613
0.79 3.55 0.4 1.756 281.628 114.974 5.915
0.89 4.44 0.4 1.798 490.542 200.263 6.445
0.99 5.43 0.4 1.802 512.002 209.024 5.706
1.09 6.52 0.4 1.777 384.379 156.922 6.415
1.18 7.70 0.4 1.773 364.195 148.682 5.424
1.28 8.98 0.4 1.798 487.806 199.146 7.663
1.38 10.36 0.4 1.812 558.420 227.974 7.433
1.48 11.84 0.4 1.813 565.881 231.020 6.861
1.58 13.42 0.4 1.804 521.254 212.801 7.078
1.68 15.10 0.4 1.791 454.589 185.585 7.039
1.78 16.88 0.4 1.785 422.615 172.532 6.529
1.88 18.76 0.4 1.802 508.073 207.420 7.600
0 18.76 0.4 1.847 735.202 300.145 2.895

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

SW POA 2014 - Deck Facilitador - Ricardo Moraes
SW POA 2014 - Deck Facilitador - Ricardo MoraesSW POA 2014 - Deck Facilitador - Ricardo Moraes
SW POA 2014 - Deck Facilitador - Ricardo MoraesRicardo Moraes
 
Ejercicios de grafos y digrafos
Ejercicios de grafos y digrafosEjercicios de grafos y digrafos
Ejercicios de grafos y digrafosVictor Perez
 
14º Torneio de Natal Salesianos/Moche 2014 calendário
14º Torneio de Natal Salesianos/Moche  2014   calendário14º Torneio de Natal Salesianos/Moche  2014   calendário
14º Torneio de Natal Salesianos/Moche 2014 calendáriojpms
 
45 5 ludwig von mises
45 5 ludwig von mises45 5 ludwig von mises
45 5 ludwig von misesSergio Cuevas
 
La didactica del lenguaje
La didactica del lenguajeLa didactica del lenguaje
La didactica del lenguajecarmenzaurrego
 
LEI 6496
LEI 6496LEI 6496
LEI 6496ejfelix
 
Generaciones de los ordenadores
Generaciones de los ordenadoresGeneraciones de los ordenadores
Generaciones de los ordenadores20134div
 
Delitos informaticos (1)
Delitos informaticos (1)Delitos informaticos (1)
Delitos informaticos (1)vaalzatem
 
Nuevo documento de microsoft word
Nuevo documento de microsoft wordNuevo documento de microsoft word
Nuevo documento de microsoft wordoshirot
 
Serviços Colaborativos com uso das TICs em Bibliotecas
Serviços Colaborativos com uso das TICs em BibliotecasServiços Colaborativos com uso das TICs em Bibliotecas
Serviços Colaborativos com uso das TICs em BibliotecasJuliana Gulka
 
Presentación xz
Presentación  xzPresentación  xz
Presentación xzzamora123
 
Alicia y mariia
Alicia y mariiaAlicia y mariia
Alicia y mariia07rubiaa
 
Presentacio cas fent_historia_2_0
Presentacio cas fent_historia_2_0Presentacio cas fent_historia_2_0
Presentacio cas fent_historia_2_0goller77
 

Destaque (20)

Gabinete
GabineteGabinete
Gabinete
 
F32
F32F32
F32
 
MÉJICO CRISTERO.- Antonio Rius Fascius-
MÉJICO CRISTERO.- Antonio Rius Fascius-MÉJICO CRISTERO.- Antonio Rius Fascius-
MÉJICO CRISTERO.- Antonio Rius Fascius-
 
SW POA 2014 - Deck Facilitador - Ricardo Moraes
SW POA 2014 - Deck Facilitador - Ricardo MoraesSW POA 2014 - Deck Facilitador - Ricardo Moraes
SW POA 2014 - Deck Facilitador - Ricardo Moraes
 
Ejercicios de grafos y digrafos
Ejercicios de grafos y digrafosEjercicios de grafos y digrafos
Ejercicios de grafos y digrafos
 
14º Torneio de Natal Salesianos/Moche 2014 calendário
14º Torneio de Natal Salesianos/Moche  2014   calendário14º Torneio de Natal Salesianos/Moche  2014   calendário
14º Torneio de Natal Salesianos/Moche 2014 calendário
 
BIMachine - Conhecendo a Plataforma
BIMachine - Conhecendo a PlataformaBIMachine - Conhecendo a Plataforma
BIMachine - Conhecendo a Plataforma
 
45 5 ludwig von mises
45 5 ludwig von mises45 5 ludwig von mises
45 5 ludwig von mises
 
Fichas e figuras
Fichas e  figurasFichas e  figuras
Fichas e figuras
 
La didactica del lenguaje
La didactica del lenguajeLa didactica del lenguaje
La didactica del lenguaje
 
reglas de netiqueta
reglas de netiquetareglas de netiqueta
reglas de netiqueta
 
LEI 6496
LEI 6496LEI 6496
LEI 6496
 
Generaciones de los ordenadores
Generaciones de los ordenadoresGeneraciones de los ordenadores
Generaciones de los ordenadores
 
Delitos informaticos (1)
Delitos informaticos (1)Delitos informaticos (1)
Delitos informaticos (1)
 
Nuevo documento de microsoft word
Nuevo documento de microsoft wordNuevo documento de microsoft word
Nuevo documento de microsoft word
 
Serviços Colaborativos com uso das TICs em Bibliotecas
Serviços Colaborativos com uso das TICs em BibliotecasServiços Colaborativos com uso das TICs em Bibliotecas
Serviços Colaborativos com uso das TICs em Bibliotecas
 
Diego uci
Diego uciDiego uci
Diego uci
 
Presentación xz
Presentación  xzPresentación  xz
Presentación xz
 
Alicia y mariia
Alicia y mariiaAlicia y mariia
Alicia y mariia
 
Presentacio cas fent_historia_2_0
Presentacio cas fent_historia_2_0Presentacio cas fent_historia_2_0
Presentacio cas fent_historia_2_0
 

Semelhante a kriSIS_Users_Manual_V1.1

Utilização do SGeMS
Utilização do SGeMSUtilização do SGeMS
Utilização do SGeMSAlex Ramires
 
Dips 7.0 whats_new_quick_start_guide
Dips 7.0 whats_new_quick_start_guideDips 7.0 whats_new_quick_start_guide
Dips 7.0 whats_new_quick_start_guideJoaoManuelLucamba
 
Solar cell Modeling with Scaps 1-D
Solar cell Modeling with Scaps 1-D Solar cell Modeling with Scaps 1-D
Solar cell Modeling with Scaps 1-D shubham mishra
 
Creating watershed using SRTM DEM
Creating watershed using SRTM DEMCreating watershed using SRTM DEM
Creating watershed using SRTM DEMbajajngadat
 
3D Analyst - Watershed from SRTM
3D Analyst - Watershed from SRTM3D Analyst - Watershed from SRTM
3D Analyst - Watershed from SRTMHartanto Sanjaya
 
Jgrass-NewAge: Kriging component
Jgrass-NewAge: Kriging componentJgrass-NewAge: Kriging component
Jgrass-NewAge: Kriging componentNiccolò Tubini
 
[Point] pipe stress analysis by computer-caesar ii
[Point] pipe stress analysis by computer-caesar ii[Point] pipe stress analysis by computer-caesar ii
[Point] pipe stress analysis by computer-caesar iiLuis Luis
 
Dahlquist et-al bosc-ismb_2016_poster
Dahlquist et-al bosc-ismb_2016_posterDahlquist et-al bosc-ismb_2016_poster
Dahlquist et-al bosc-ismb_2016_posterGRNsight
 
Fluent and Gambit Workshop
Fluent and Gambit WorkshopFluent and Gambit Workshop
Fluent and Gambit Workshopkhalid_nitt
 
Bt0064 logic design2
Bt0064 logic design2Bt0064 logic design2
Bt0064 logic design2Techglyphs
 
Introduction to Grad-CAM (complete version)
Introduction to Grad-CAM (complete version)Introduction to Grad-CAM (complete version)
Introduction to Grad-CAM (complete version)Hsing-chuan Hsieh
 
Cro v2
Cro v2Cro v2
Cro v2yibta
 
Introduction to Support Vector Machines
Introduction to Support Vector MachinesIntroduction to Support Vector Machines
Introduction to Support Vector MachinesSilicon Mentor
 

Semelhante a kriSIS_Users_Manual_V1.1 (20)

AllPosters
AllPostersAllPosters
AllPosters
 
Patchantenna
PatchantennaPatchantenna
Patchantenna
 
Tutorial ads
Tutorial adsTutorial ads
Tutorial ads
 
Utilização do SGeMS
Utilização do SGeMSUtilização do SGeMS
Utilização do SGeMS
 
Tutorial_01_Quick_Start.pdf
Tutorial_01_Quick_Start.pdfTutorial_01_Quick_Start.pdf
Tutorial_01_Quick_Start.pdf
 
Dips 7.0 whats_new_quick_start_guide
Dips 7.0 whats_new_quick_start_guideDips 7.0 whats_new_quick_start_guide
Dips 7.0 whats_new_quick_start_guide
 
Solar cell Modeling with Scaps 1-D
Solar cell Modeling with Scaps 1-D Solar cell Modeling with Scaps 1-D
Solar cell Modeling with Scaps 1-D
 
Creating watershed using SRTM DEM
Creating watershed using SRTM DEMCreating watershed using SRTM DEM
Creating watershed using SRTM DEM
 
3D Analyst - Watershed from SRTM
3D Analyst - Watershed from SRTM3D Analyst - Watershed from SRTM
3D Analyst - Watershed from SRTM
 
Jgrass-NewAge: Kriging component
Jgrass-NewAge: Kriging componentJgrass-NewAge: Kriging component
Jgrass-NewAge: Kriging component
 
[Point] pipe stress analysis by computer-caesar ii
[Point] pipe stress analysis by computer-caesar ii[Point] pipe stress analysis by computer-caesar ii
[Point] pipe stress analysis by computer-caesar ii
 
Dahlquist et-al bosc-ismb_2016_poster
Dahlquist et-al bosc-ismb_2016_posterDahlquist et-al bosc-ismb_2016_poster
Dahlquist et-al bosc-ismb_2016_poster
 
Tutorial 2
Tutorial 2Tutorial 2
Tutorial 2
 
Fluent and Gambit Workshop
Fluent and Gambit WorkshopFluent and Gambit Workshop
Fluent and Gambit Workshop
 
Bt0064 logic design2
Bt0064 logic design2Bt0064 logic design2
Bt0064 logic design2
 
3D Analyst - Lab
3D Analyst - Lab3D Analyst - Lab
3D Analyst - Lab
 
Introduction to Grad-CAM (complete version)
Introduction to Grad-CAM (complete version)Introduction to Grad-CAM (complete version)
Introduction to Grad-CAM (complete version)
 
3D Analyst Lab 1
3D Analyst Lab 13D Analyst Lab 1
3D Analyst Lab 1
 
Cro v2
Cro v2Cro v2
Cro v2
 
Introduction to Support Vector Machines
Introduction to Support Vector MachinesIntroduction to Support Vector Machines
Introduction to Support Vector Machines
 

kriSIS_Users_Manual_V1.1

  • 1. TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY OF CRETE DEPARTMENT OF MINERAL RESOURCES ENGINEERING APPLIED GEOPHYSICS LAB 73 100 CHANIA TEL: (+30-28210) 37670 - Fax: (+30-28210) 69554 – e-mail: gkritik@mred.tuc.gr USERS’ MANUAL FOR kriSIS v1.04 Open Source Matlab™ Algorithms for Analysis of Surface Waves Programmed by g. kritikakis Manual v. 1.1 July 2010
  • 2. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik2 USERS’ MANUAL FOR kriSIS v1.04 kriSIS OPEN SOURCE ALGORITHMS HAVE BEEN TESTED IN MATLAB™ 6.5 RUNNING ON WINDOWS XP sp2 AND ARE DISTRIBUTED FOR FREE "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTIES AS TO PERFORMANCE OR MERCHANTABILITY OR ANY OTHER WARRANTIES WHETHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED. NO WARRANTY OF FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE IS OFFERED. Consult the installation guide before running kriSIS v1.04. Run the command “kriSIS_auto” on the command window to launch the application. For further documentation press “help kriSIS_auto“ on the command window. The MASW data processing is competed to 5 steps: 1. The first step includes reading SGY seismic files or importing a dispersion curve. To proceed with the first step, press “Continue”. To terminate the process press “Cancel”. IMPORTANT: The byte of binary SGY data must be 32-Bit Floating Point ordered as “Most Significant Byte First”. To create SGY file from a Matlab array use the command DATA2SGY(data,dt,offset).
  • 3. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik3 Dispersion curves can be imported either by an *.RDC file (from previously processed data) or just a (stored as *.mat file) 3-column ([frequency phase velocity dispersion curve error]) MATLAB table. IMPORTANT: The selection of this kind of date bypasses the steps 2 and 3. 2. The second step includes the transformation of seismic data from Time- Distance domain to Frequency-Phase velocity domain where the dispersion curves will be shown among the local energy maxima. To proceed with the second step, press “Continue”. To terminate the process, press “Cancel”. To return to the previous step press “Back”.
  • 4. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik4 The kriSIS uses the available from file headers information to set up “Shot Geometry” parameters. IMPORTANT: All that matters is the relative position of the seismic source compare to the geophones. It is also correct, for example, to insert as Source Coordinate 0.00, and first Receiver Coordinate 7.5, instead of –7.5 and 0.0, respectively. If the geophones were placed in irregular intervals along seismic line, the user can edit geophone offsets individually by pressing the “Get from Headers / Set Irregular Group Intervals” button. If you set on (default option) the “Normalize amplitudes of original (t,x) data” radio button, the amplitudes of seismic traces will be normalized (before the wavefield transformation) to revert the seismic energy loss due to geometrical spreading.
  • 5. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik5 Phase velocity – Frequency domain window is selected by setting the minimum and maximum values of phase velocity and frequency as well as their increment. Normally, the default values are adequate to image the dispersion curve of the most seismic records. The user can refine the window afterwards using the “Back” option. 3. The third step includes the selection of fundamental and higher mode dispersion curves from the local energy maxima. To proceed with the third step, press “Continue”. To terminate the process, press “Cancel”. To return to the previous step press “Back”.
  • 6. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik6 There is an option to import dispersion curves (DCs) from adjacent seismic records as a guide DCs for easier selection. Dispersion curves can be imported either by an *.RDC file (from previously processed data) or just a (stored as *.mat file) 3-column ([frequency phase velocity dispersion curve error]) MATLAB table. Fundamental DC selection is performed by surrounding the white crosses (which correspond to the local maxima along frequency) using a polygon. LEFT mouse key sets a point of the polygon on the image, DELETE button deletes previously set points and RIGHT mouse key is used to terminate the selection. IMPORTANT: Usually the fundamental dispersion curve is appeared at lower frequencies and phase velocities than higher modes. Make sure that the first DC you select corresponds to the fundamental one.
  • 7. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik7 In MATLAB 6.5, the selected crosses are automatically highlighted with magenta squares and an estimation of the DC standard deviation is calculated (bounds). DC standard deviation is calculated along each frequency by the determination of the difference between the phase velocity, which corresponds to selected DC point and the phase velocity of a point with energy equal to 63% of the corresponding energy of selected DC point. IMPORTANT: In MATLAB 7.5 (R2007b) the polygon selection must be verified by pressing RIGHT mouse button and selecting the option “Create Mask”
  • 8. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik8 Afterwards, kriSIS prompts a window to request if the user intends to select the next higher mode. IMPORTANT: You cannot neglect the selection of a higher mode in order to proceed with the selection of the next one. Thus, higher modes must be selected sequentially. Higher mode selection is repeated (up to 9 modes including fundamental) unless the user terminates DC selection by pressing “NO” button.
  • 9. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik9 4. The forth step includes the selection of initial model, inversion parameters and convergence criteria. To proceed with the forth step, press “Continue”. To terminate the process, press “Cancel”. To return to the previous step press “Back”. MODEL PARAMETERS kriSIS_auto creates automatically an initial model parameters based on the values of fundamental dispersion curve. In this case, the “No of Layers“ is affected from the selection of DC to initial model transformation mode (“Coarse“, “Medium“, “Fine“). IMPORTANT: Usually, only the low depth layers are split when the user increases the level of layering (i.e. to Fine). The default value is “Coarse“. The first layer is common to get greater thickness than the second, third, etc.
  • 10. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik10 The user can modify the “No of Layers“ from 2 to 35, either by writing the number in the box, or using the up and down arrows. In this case, the DC to initial model transformation mode is turned automatically to “Variable“ layer thickness and the model layers receive gradually increased thickness as the depth increases. Maximum investigation depth is correlated to the greatest observed wavelength (λ=VR/f) with “λ / depth ratio”. This ratio can be modified from 1 to 3. However, by pressing the “OR” button, the user can define the maximum depth. In this case “λ / depth ratio” is deactivated. IMPORTANT: Extreme values of depth (compared to the proposed) may lead to erroneous solutions or unstable inversion. The model layers can also be equal by pressing the “Equal” radio button. Initial model can be imported by reading the best iteration from an “ACDC_OUT.txt” export file of a previously processed record or DC file (see saved files further down). By pressing “Default”, the model parameters are set according to the values: “Medium“ layering calculated from DC and “λ / depth ratio = 2.0” All table elements are adjustable apart from depth (Z) values, which are calculated from layers Thickness. Either Vp, or Poisson’s ratio (ν) value of each layer must be fixed during the inversion. Fixing value equal to 1 means that the model parameter of the corresponding layer is free to change during the inversion. Fixing value equal to 0 means the opposite. IMPORTANT: Any a-priory information can be retained during the inversion by fixing the appropriate values. IMPORTANT: Vp, ν and density (ρ) ARE NOT inverted. They just change values every iteration according to the fixed values (Vp or ν) and the values of Vs. Fixing all values of Vp, Poisson’s ratio or density can be done by selecting the corresponding check box (“fix all Vp”, “fix all Pois”, “fix all ρ”). The values of all Poisson’s ratios can also be edited by setting its value to the “all Pois” box.
  • 11. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik11 Poisson’s ratio values is calculated from the Vs and Vp values according to the formula: 1 15.0 2 2 −⎟ ⎠ ⎞ ⎜ ⎝ ⎛ −⎟ ⎠ ⎞ ⎜ ⎝ ⎛ ⋅ = Vs Vp Vs Vp ν , while density is calculated from: ρ = 0.0002·Vp + 1.7 (g/cm3 )
  • 12. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik12 INVERSION PARAMETERS The values of Jacobian matrix can be calculated numerically from Thomson- Haskell method using Ridder’s discrete differentiation technique (“T – H” selection) or estimated using “Quasi – Newton” techniques. The later method is NOT recommended due to its unstable inversion behavior and the insecure results that may produce. Weighting DC data can be done by taking into consideration the “DC error” bounds (see STEP 3), the values of Jacobian matrix (“Jacobian values”) and/or the differences between the observed and the calculated dispersion curves (“Robust Inversion”) in any combination of the three. The selection of the later, corresponds to the minimization of the sum of absolute differences between the observed and the calculated dispersion curves (Norm L1) using the Iteratively Re-weighted Least Squares (IRLS) method. Five types of constraints can be applied: (1) Smoothing, (2) Damping and (3) Blocky (a modified smoothing constraint which MAY highlights sharp boundaries), as well as the combination of (4) Smoothing and Damping or (5) Damping and Blocky. The default inversion parameters are: “T - H” Jacobian calculation, “Robust inversion” weight and “Bloky” constraint. CONVERGENCE CRITERIA The selection of “Optimizing RMS” radio button optimizes the inversion process by calculating the optimum Lagrangean multiplier in each iteration using internal sub-iterations. This forces inversion to the reduction of RMS error in each iteration and stops the process when no further RMS reduction can be achieved. It should be deactivated only when the inversion stops at the first few iterations and the RMS error remains high. “Max Iteration” is the maximum number of iterations in case that the following convergence criteria are not satisfied. It can be set up to 200. Its default value, when “Optimizing RMS” is activated, is 30. 100 otherwise. “Min % RMS Error” is the main (desired) stopping criterion. Inversion process stops when the percentile root mean square error between the
  • 13. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik13 observed and the calculated dispersion curves is lower than the selected value. Takes values from 0.1 to 99.9 %. By pressing “AND” button the “Max Vs correction for RMS satisfied (m/s)” box is activated and another stopping criterion is added to the previous one (RMS). Namely, inversion process stops when the RMS error is lower than its limit AND the maximum model correction (in m/s) is lower than the selected value (default 1 m/s). The last convergence criterion “Min Vs correction for RMS NOT satisfied (m/s)” prevents the inversion to converge very slowly. The process stops when the maximum model correction (in m/s) is lower than the selected value (default 0.01 m/s). Default values are shown on the figure above. When the user presses “OK” button, kriSIS performs check to the imported model parameters. Some warning messages may appear on the screen related to the maximum depth of investigation and the correction of Vp or Poisson’s ratio values. By minimizing (not necessary) all prompted windows the user is able to observe on the command window information about the inversion process (Iteration No, RMS error, Damping, Smoothing and/or Blocky factors, and the maximum value of model correction – DVs(max)).
  • 14. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik14 5. On the fifth step the user is able to observe the final inversion results and save or discard them. To save the inversion results, press “Save”. To discard the inversion result, press “Clear”. To return to the previous step press “Back”. IMPORTANT: The displayed inversion results concern the Vs profile, which gives the smallest RMS error.
  • 15. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik15 By pressing “Back” button, the window of the 4th step is appeared. By pressing “Clear” button, the inversion results are discarded. By pressing “Save” button, a dialog box is prompted where the user can specify the directory and the filename for the inversion results to be saved. It takes some time to save the inversion results because the forward problem (dispersion curve calculation) is solved to calculate all possible dispersion curves (fundamental and higher modes) of the final model, which appeared
  • 16. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik16 within the specified (on Step 2) frequency – phase velocity window. A warning message may also appear when the dispersion curves is not possible to be calculated for the complete frequency range. The inversion results are saved in a folder named by the given filename and placed in the specified location. These results consist of: ACDC_IN.dat is a text file containing the observed DC, initial model parameters, inversion parameters and convergence criteria. ACDC_JAC.txt is a text file containing the Jacobian matrix of each iteration. ACDC_OUT.txt is a text file containing the inversion history (observed and calculated DC, DC misfit and corresponding RMS error, intermediate Vs profiles and their adjustments and Lagrangean multipliers). ACDC_RES.txt is a text file containing the resolution and covariance matrices for each iteration. ‘Filename’.RDC is a MATLAB file (struct array) containing information about the observed DCs and the transformed seismic data in the frequency – phase velocity damain. ‘Filename’.VSD is a MATLAB file (double array) containing information about the final model.
  • 17. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik17 ‘Filename’_1-TRACES.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile) displaying the seismic traces.
  • 18. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik18 ‘Filename’_1-DC.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile) displaying the distribution of seismic energy in frequency – phase velocity domain, the observed DC and the calculated ones (black dashed curves). ‘Filename’_3-RES-SNS-SGM.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile) displaying the values of Resolution matrix, the sensitivity (%) of each model layer Vs value and the corresponding model bounds (standard deviation of Vs values deduced from Covariance matrix).
  • 19. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik19 ‘Filename’_4-RMS_DISTR.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile) displaying (a) the number of samples distributed to the RMS error (%) levels, (b) the distribution of RMS error (%) vs the sample number and (c) the contribution (%) of the RMS error vs the frequency range.
  • 20. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik20 ‘Filename’_5-RMS.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile) displaying the RMS error vs iterations and the current Lagrangean multiplier.
  • 21. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik21 ‘Filename’_6-RES.emf is a picture file (Enhanced Metafile), which displays the calculated DC fit on the observed one and the corresponding RMS error (%) as well as the initial and final Vs depth profile. ‘Filename’_OUT.xls is a tab delimited text file containing information about the observed and calculated DC (of the best iteration), the initial and final (best) model, the inversion parameters, convergence criteria and RMS error for each iteration (see further down). Either save or discard the inversion results, the processing can be repeated (“Continue”) with the same or another data set (seismic record or DC). Otherwise, the processing is terminated by pressing “Cancel”.
  • 22. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik22
  • 23. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik23 Example of ‘Filename’_OUT.xls file Filename : SS1_S No of modes : 2 Fundamental : 50 No Freq DCobs DCcalc DC error 1 5 198 202.704 26 2 5.2 195 198.552 25 3 5.4 193 194.84 25 4 5.6 190 191.528 23 5 5.8 189 188.57 23 6 6 187 185.917 22 7 6.2 186 183.523 22 8 6.4 183 181.347 20 9 6.6 181 179.352 19 10 6.8 180 177.508 19 11 7 178 175.789 19 12 7.2 175 174.172 17 13 7.4 173 172.638 16 14 7.6 171 171.172 15 15 7.8 169 169.76 14 16 8 168 168.393 14 17 8.2 167 167.06 13 18 8.4 166 165.757 13 19 8.6 165 164.478 12 20 8.8 164 163.218 12 21 9 163 161.978 12 22 9.2 162 160.754 12 23 9.4 161 159.546 12 24 9.6 160 158.355 12 25 9.8 158 157.182 12 26 10 155 156.027 11 27 10.2 153 154.891 11 28 10.4 151 153.776 10 29 10.6 150 152.682 10 30 10.8 149 151.61 9 31 11 148 150.561 8 32 11.2 148 149.534 9 33 11.4 147 148.53 8 34 11.6 147 147.548 8 35 11.8 146 146.589 8 36 12 145 145.651 9 37 12.2 144 144.735 9 38 12.4 143 143.84 9 39 12.6 142 142.965 9 40 12.8 141 142.11 8 41 13 141 141.274 8 42 13.2 140 140.458 7 43 13.4 139 139.661 7 44 13.6 139 138.882 7 45 13.8 138 138.123 6 46 14 138 137.382 6 47 14.2 138 136.661 6
  • 24. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik24 48 14.4 137 135.958 6 49 14.6 136 135.276 6 50 14.8 134 134.614 4 Higher mode 1: 64 No Freq DCobs DCcalc DC error 1 8.2 280 270.38 34 2 8.4 274 268.108 32 3 8.6 269 265.722 31 4 8.8 264 263.229 30 5 9 259 260.639 29 6 9.2 254 257.967 28 7 9.4 250 255.23 27 8 9.6 247 252.449 26 9 9.8 245 249.647 26 10 10 244 246.85 25 11 10.2 243 244.082 25 12 10.4 241 241.369 23 13 10.6 240 238.733 23 14 10.8 238 236.194 21 15 11 236 233.768 20 16 11.2 234 231.464 19 17 11.4 231 229.29 17 18 11.6 229 227.248 17 19 11.8 227 225.336 16 20 12 225 223.551 16 21 12.2 222 221.887 15 22 12.4 221 220.336 15 23 12.6 219 218.892 14 24 12.8 218 217.544 14 25 13 217 216.285 14 26 13.2 216 215.107 14 27 13.4 216 214.001 14 28 13.6 216 212.96 13 29 13.8 215 211.977 13 30 14 214 211.044 12 31 14.2 212 210.155 12 32 14.4 210 209.304 11 33 14.6 209 208.484 11 34 14.8 208 207.691 11 35 15 207 206.92 11 36 15.2 206 206.164 11 37 15.4 205 205.42 11 38 15.6 205 204.682 11 39 15.8 204 203.947 11 40 16 204 203.21 10 41 16.2 203 202.468 10 42 16.4 202 201.716 10 43 16.6 201 200.953 10 44 16.8 201 200.175 9 45 17 200 199.382 9 46 17.2 199 198.571 9 47 17.4 198 197.744 10
  • 25. kriSIS v1.04 made by gkritik25 48 17.6 197 196.9 10 49 17.8 197 196.041 10 50 18 196 195.171 10 51 18.2 196 194.292 9 52 18.4 195 193.409 9 53 18.6 194 192.526 10 54 18.8 193 191.647 10 55 19 192 190.778 10 56 19.2 190 189.921 10 57 19.4 189 189.082 10 58 19.6 188 188.262 10 59 19.8 187 187.466 10 60 20 187 186.695 9 61 20.2 186 185.951 9 62 20.4 185 185.235 9 63 20.6 184 184.547 10 64 20.8 183 183.889 10 Iteration % RMS error 0 6.77E+01 1 3.21E+01 2 3.79E+00 3 2.50E+00 4 2.07E+00 5 1.46E+00 6 9.18E-01 Model layers: 20 Thickness (m) Depth (m) Poisson's ratio Density (gr/cm^3) Vp (m/s) Vs (m/s) σ (m/s) 0.10 0.10 0.4 1.742 210.600 85.977 14.784 0.20 0.30 0.4 1.742 210.624 85.987 11.032 0.30 0.60 0.4 1.755 277.084 113.119 10.920 0.39 0.99 0.4 1.766 330.973 135.119 11.971 0.49 1.48 0.4 1.778 387.615 158.243 10.429 0.59 2.07 0.4 1.774 372.472 152.061 7.441 0.69 2.76 0.4 1.751 255.332 104.239 5.613 0.79 3.55 0.4 1.756 281.628 114.974 5.915 0.89 4.44 0.4 1.798 490.542 200.263 6.445 0.99 5.43 0.4 1.802 512.002 209.024 5.706 1.09 6.52 0.4 1.777 384.379 156.922 6.415 1.18 7.70 0.4 1.773 364.195 148.682 5.424 1.28 8.98 0.4 1.798 487.806 199.146 7.663 1.38 10.36 0.4 1.812 558.420 227.974 7.433 1.48 11.84 0.4 1.813 565.881 231.020 6.861 1.58 13.42 0.4 1.804 521.254 212.801 7.078 1.68 15.10 0.4 1.791 454.589 185.585 7.039 1.78 16.88 0.4 1.785 422.615 172.532 6.529 1.88 18.76 0.4 1.802 508.073 207.420 7.600 0 18.76 0.4 1.847 735.202 300.145 2.895