Systematic project “Training, which meets the requirements of state-of-the-art technological branches of industry, based on dual education”

1. Dual
Education
Москва
Directive “Young Professionals”
Systematic project “Training, which meets
the requirements of state-of-the-art
technological branches of industry,
based on dual education”
Moscow, 2014

2. Dual
AGENCY OF
STRATEGIC
INITIATIVES
Education
Dual
Education
Project Partners
Project Partners
Ministry of Education
Ministry of Economic
Ministry of Work and
Ministry of Finance
Russo-Germanic
Ministry of Trade
Chamber of
Chelyabinsk Tube
and Science of the
Development of the
Social Security of the
of the Russian
Chamber of
and Industry of the
Commerce of the
Works
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Federation
Commerce
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
World Bank
**McKinsey Global Institute, “An effective Russia: productivity as a fundament of growth”, 2009 г.
McKinsey Global Institute, «Эффективная Россия: производительность как фундамент роста», 2009
2
2

3. Dual
Education
The effects of introducing dual education
An increase in the attractiveness of Russian regions for investment thanks
to training, which meets the requirements of state-of-the-art technological
branches of industry, based on dual education
The redistribution of the funding of cooperative programmes for staff retraining
to the benefit of state education system – the training of staff
A significant growth in the qualifications of staff and an increase in the prestige
of professions as a result of the development of new forms of education
3

4. Dual
Education
Aims of the introduction
of the system of dual education
The completion of the training programme taking into account real economic demands
for qualified staff in order to increase the attractiveness of regions for investment
The development of professional standards for current professions in business
The development and modernisation of educational programmes in accordance
with the demands of professional standards
A change to the mandatory requirements of an organisation and of the contents
of educational programmes
The development of a mechanism of independent evaluation of the qualifications
of staff
The optimisation of taxation in order to attract businesses to finance the training
of staff
4

5. Dual
Education
The necessary systematic changes at every
stage of the training
The current situation in Russia
A better practice
A booking is made by the government through
distributing budgetary places in educational
establishments without taking into account the
needs of companies in the region
The selection of students only on their general
knowledge (EGE) and state (total) certification,
from 2013 accepted by application
A booking is made by a company 5-10 years in
advance. It is discussed by the Board of Directors with the current state of staff and growth
perspectives in mind
Active career guidance for schoolchildren, from
the youngest classes (primary school), the selection of school leavers also on their level of
technical reasoning. The demographics of the
region and country are taken into account
The formulation of a booking for enrolment and training, enrolment, enrolment
of students
In the framework of the state educational standard, the opportunities for reorientation in the
Russian system of secondary professional education are quite wide
The formulation
of a booking for
enrolment and
training, enrolment,
enrolment of
students
The formulation of
a booking for enrolment and training,
enrolment, enrolment of students
The company compiles the educational programme. The company has a wide range of
opportunities for the distribution of resources
between disciplines in the framework of one
specialty
5

6. Dual
Education
The necessary systematic changes at every
stage of the training
The current situation in Russia
A better practice
Education is cut off from production.
Minimal time is given to practical work at the
firm. Academic classes and professional training are completely separate
Maximal orientation towards production.
A large number of the practical classes take
place in the educational centre and workshops
of the company
The system of class work, preserved from Soviet times, is changing, it is not at all orientated
at the future work of students
(it is an accreditation indicator, budget money is
set aside for extra-curricular work)
Teachers are experienced production
workers.
Academic education is separated from professional education and, as a rule, takes place on
a separate day
Organisation of the
process of study
Extra-curricular and
pedagogical work
From the very beginning directed work takes
place on the development of creative skills,
responsibility, team work and leadership
6

7. Dual
Education
The necessary systematic changes at every
stage of the training
The current situation in Russia
A better practice
The aimless admission of students.
The number of students is not planned, nor is the
direction of the training, nor any specialisation in
a field of work. For economic expedience, all
educational establishments strive to take on
as many students as possible,paying no attention
to their personal qualities and capabilities and the
requirements of the firm. The minimum number of
practical classes. The location of training is not
at all related to the future work placement.
Tutorship in the workshops is either
completely lacking or very poor
The enrolment of students onto the course is done
with a clear understanding of where he will be
working, practical work during the training is
completely orientated at training and adapting
the student to a concrete working environment
in a certain work-group (shift). In workshops the
leadership of the tutor is honourable and relevant.
The training is high quality. After finishing the
course, the student remains in the field of his
training
College leavers do not have career growth
of any planned or regular nature. Much relies on
the personal qualities of the school leaver and
coincidences of circumstance
Practical work,
tutorship, work
placement
Professional
development and
growth
Every school leaver, who has gone through professional training, has opportunities for professional
and career growth. The fundamental criteria for
evaluation are the high quality execution of operations, the tutorship, and the increase in the professional standard. Training with the aim of receiving the title of master.
7

8. Dual
Education
A roadmap of the realisation of the project
september
july
november
october
august
The signing of a multi-lateral agreement with the “pilot”
regions
july
1.5.
june
The conducting of a competition for the selection of four
“pilot” regions
may
1.4.
april
The development of criteria for the selection of four
“pilot” regions
march
1.3.
february
The preparation of an analytical presentation with
examples of the best international practices
january
1.2.
2016
The creation of working groups
december
1.1
november
The preparation stage 2013, 2014, 2016
october
1.
august
Plan of measures taken in the development
of the system of dual education
july
№.
2014
september
2013
07 08 09 10 11 12 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 07
8

9. Dual
Education
A roadmap of the realisation of the project
2.1.
2.2.
2.3.
2.4.
2.5.
2.6.
november
ноябрь
july
october
september
august
july
june
may
april
2016
march
february
january
december
november
Realisation
october
2.
2014
september
Plan of measures taken in the development
of the system of dual education
july
№.
august
2013
07 08 09 10 11 12 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 07
Organisation of the development of professional
standards
The development and modernisation of available
educational programmes
The creation of a material-technical basis for the
realisation of pilot projects
The realisation of measures taken to increase the
qualifications of production and teaching staff
The organisation of enrolment, monitoring of teaching
and teaching of specialists in the educational
programmes prepared in the framework of the pilot
programmes
The awarding of the status “federal innovation platform”
to professional educational organisations,
taking part in the realisation of the pilot projects
9

10. Dual
Education
A roadmap of the realisation of the project
2013
july
november
october
september
august
july
june
may
april
march
february
january
The preparation of recommendations for the perfection
of the system of management of professional
education
december
3.2.
2016
The analysis of the realisation of the pilot projects and
the preparation of recommendations for legislative
and procedural changes
november
3.1.
october
Final stage
september
3.
august
Plan of measures taken in the development
of the system of dual education
july
№.
2014
07 08 09 10 11 12 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 07
10

11. Dual
Education
The training of staff
in dual education in 2014
10 regions have been chosen for the training of staff
in dual education in 2014
23 regions applied. The conclusions of the competition selection for the training
of staff on the basis of dual education reveal that the following regions were chosen:
Kaluzhskaya oblast
Ulyanovskaya oblast
Krasnoyarsky krai
Permsky krai
Yaroslavskaya oblast
Apart from this, the competition commission decided to award the status of “mentor region” to Kaluzhskaya and
Sverdlovskaya oblasts as regions which already have experience of dual education and which will be able to offer
methodical support to the regions, which are just beginning to train their staff according to the new model of education.
Four more regions, which were not victorious, but which presented high-quality applications, were awarded the status
of “finalists”. They were Sverdlovskaya oblast, the Republic of Tatarstan, Volgogradskaya oblast, Moskovskaya oblast and
Nizhegorodskaya oblast. The Agency of Strategic Initiatives hopes to come to special agreements with these regions
on the Agency’s conduct of a process of approbation of the dual education model in these regions. Besides the
abovementioned regions, outside of the competition, the status of “special project ASI” was awarded to Primorsky krai,
and Samarskaya oblast was awarded the status “special project of the Russo-German Chamber of Commerce”.
11

12. Dual
Education
Table of the evaluation of regions’ applications to take part in the
pilot project for the introduction of elements of dual education
Region
Average
mark
Belgorodskaya oblast
3,0
Samarskaya oblast
3,0
Region Sakha
2,8
Tamborskaya oblast
2,2
3,6
Kostromskaya oblast
2,0
3,6
Penzenskaya oblast
2,0
Ryazanskaya oblast
2,0
Primorsky krai
2,0
Average
mark
Kaluzhskaya oblast
4,8
Ulyanovskaya oblast
3,8
Krasnoyarsky krai
3,6
Permsky krai
Ярославская область
mentor
region
winner
Region
mentor
region
3,6
Republic of Tatarstan
3,5
Leningradskaya oblast
1,8
Volgogradskaya oblast
3,5
Republic of Marij-El
1,6
Moskovskaya oblast
3,2
Republic of Buryatia
1,6
Republic of Bashkiria
1,4
Nizhegorodskaya oblast
3,1
Republic of Kalmykia
1,0
Регион - ментор
finalist
Sverdlovskaya oblast
12

13. Dual
Education
Kaluga Region
Automotive Cluster
Volkswagen Group Rus OOO
Benteller Automotive OOO
Continental Kaluga OOO
Calibrix Rus OOO
GAOY SPO [State Autonomous Educational Establishment for Secondary
Vocational Education] of Kaluga Region Kaluga College of Information
Technologies and Management;
GBOY SPO [State Budget-funded Educational Establishment for Secondary
Vocational Education] of Kaluga Region
Kaluga State Mechanical Engineering College;
GBOY SPO of Kaluga Region
Kaluga Polytechnical College
Ministry of Education and Science of Kaluga Region
Ministry of Economic Development of Kaluga Region
Ministry of Labour, Employment and Human Resources Policy of Kaluga Region
13

14. Dual
Education
Ulyanovsk Region
Aviation Construction
Nuclear-Innovation Cluster
ZAO Aviastar-SP,
OAO Utyos,
OAO State Scientific Centre - Research Institute
for Atomic Reactors
(OAO GNC NII AR),
Strategic partner - OOO DMG Rusland.
DMG Trainings Academy
OGBOU SPO [Regional State Budget-funded Educational
Establishment for Secondary Vocational Education]
Ulyanovsk Aviation College;
OGBOU SPO Ulyanovsk Technical College;
OGBOU SPO Ulyanovsk Technical School for Device Building;
Dmitrovgrad Technical Engineering Institute, a branch of
the FGAOY VPO [Federal State Autonomous Educational
Establishment for Higher Vocational Education] MEPHI National
Research Nuclear University.
Ministry of Education and Science of Ulyanovsk Region
OOO Ulyanovsk Aviation Cluster
14

15. Dual
Education
Perm Krai
Mechanical Engineering
OOO RusTurboMash
The leading shareholder of the business is Siemens AG
OAO Perm Motor Works
OOO Krasnokamsk Mechanical Repair Works
GBOU SPO Perm Technical School for Industrial
and Information Technologies
GBPOU [State Budget-funded Vocational Educational
Establishment] West Urals Technical School
GBOU SPO A.D. Shvetsov Perm Aviation Technical School
GBOU SPO Krasnokamsk Technical School for Pulp and Paper
DMG Rusland plans to open a certified secondary specialist education teacher training centre at the Krasnokamsk Pulp and Paper
Technical School, to focus on DMG technologies
Perm Krai Government
Ministry of Education and Science of Perm Krai
Ministry of Industry,Business and Trade of Perm Krai
Perm Chamber of Commerce and Industry
15

16. Dual
Education
Krasnoyarsk Krai
Mechanical Engineering
OAO Krasnoyarks Machine-Building Plant
OAO Academician M.F. Reshetnev Satellite
Information Systems;
OAO Radiosvyaz Science and Production Enterprise;
OAO Geofizika Central Design Bureau.
Sosnovobor Automechanical Technical School,
Krasnoyarsk Technical School for Industrial Service,
Krasnoyarsk Radioelectronics, Economics and Management College
Siberian Federal University
Siberian State Aerospace University
Strategic partner - OOO DMG Rusland. DMG Trainings Academy
Ministry of Education and Science of Krasnoyarsk Krai
Ministry of Industry and Trade,
Ministry of Investment and Innovation,
Agency for Labour and Employment
Union of Mechanical Engineers
16

17. Dual
Education
Yaroslavl Region
Modern Pharmaceuticals Industry and Innovative Medicine Cluster
R-Pharm Closed Joint-Stock Company
Chemical Engineering Lyceum
Gas Turbine and Power Machinery Cluster
Saturn Scientific-Production Association,
Open Joint-Stock Company
Energy
Yaroslavl Generating Company, an open joint-stock
company
Yaroslavl Industrial and Economics College
Rybinsk Industrial and Economics Technical School; Yaroslavl
Automechanical Technical School
GOU NPO YO [State Educational Institution for Scientific and Production
Education of Yaroslavl Region] Professional Lyceum No. 21
Partner member - Bertelsmann Distribution Centre (limited liability company), a subsidiary of Arvato AG, a division of the Bertelsmann AG
concern, Germany
Yaroslavl Region Government
Department of Education, Yaroslavl Region
Yaroslavl Regional Division of the Russian
national public organisation DELOVAYA ROSSIYA
17

18. Dual
Education
Sverdlovsk Region
Metallurgy
Mechanical Engineering
Energy
Pervouralsk New Pipe Plant
(part of the Chelyabinsk Pipe-Rolling Plant),
OAO Seversky Pipe Works
(part of TMK),
OAO Sinarsky Pipe Works (part of TMK)
GAOU SPO SO [State Autonomous Educational Establishment for
Secondary Vocational Education of Sverdlovsk Region] Pervouralsk
Metallurgy College
GBOU SPO SO [State Budget-funded Educational Establishment for
Secondary Vocational Education of Sverdlovsk Region] V.I. Nazarov
Polevskoy Multiple- Discpline Technical School
GAOU SPO SO [State Autonomous Educational Establishment for
Secondary Vocational Education of Sverdlovsk Region] Urals Technical
School for Metallurgy and Mechanical Engineering
Ministry of General and Vocational Education
of Sverdlovsk Region
18

19. Dual
Education
Tatarstan Republic
Mechanical Engineering
Mechanical Engineering complex of the Tatarstan
Republic, comprised of 17 enterprises
Kazan National Research Technical University - KAI (KNRTU-KAI)
and its structural divisions, implementing the secondary vocational
education programmes (Technical School, IT College)
8 branches of KNRTU-KAI in all major cities of the Tatarstan Republic
Aviastroenie [Aviation Engineering] Regional Industry Resource Centre
of KNRTU-KAI, comprised of 20 vocational educational establishments
Ministry of Education and Science
of Tatarstan Republic
19

20. Dual
Education
Volgograd Region
Energy
OOO Volgodeminoil Joint Venture
OAO MRSK South [Regional Distribution Network
Company] - Vogogradenergo
Defence Industry
OAO Barrikady Production Association
OAO Titan Central Design Bureau, Federal Scientific
and Production Centre
Mechanical Engineering
OAO Voltair-Prom
OAO Volzhsky Pipe Rolling Plant
OAO Volgogradneftemash
OOO Volgograd Specialist Mechanical Engineering Plant
ZAO SUCCESS (metal structures)
Volgograd Technical School for Energy and Communication
Volgograd Energy College
Volgograd Professional Technical College
Volgograd College for Management and New Technologies
Volga Industrial Engineering Technical School
Volga Mechanical Engineering Technical School
N. Serdyukov Volgograd Technical School for Oil and Gas
Mechanical Engineering
Volgograd Industrial Technical School
Professional College No. 26
Chemical Industry, Petrochemistry
OOO LUKOIL-Volgogradneftepererabotka
OOO EvroKhim-VolgaKalii
ZAO Gazpromkhimvolokno
OAO Caustic
Vernadsky Volgograd Polytechnical College
Zhirnovsky Petroleum Technical College
Professional College No. 1
Ministry of Education and Youth Policy
Ministry of Economics, Foreign Economic Relations and Investment of Volgograd Region
Ministry of Industry and Trade of Volgograd Region
Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of Volgograd Region
Volgograd Chamber
of Commerce and Industry
20

21. Dual
Education
Moscow Region
Defence Industry
14 enterprises of the Defence Industry in
Moscow Region
12 vocational educational organisations
Ministry of Education of Moscow Region
21

22. Dual
Education
Nizhniy Novgorod Region
Mechanical engineering and metals processing
OAO Gorkovsky Automobile Works
(Volkswagen Group Rus)
OAO Pavlovsky Avtobus
OOO Liebherr-Aerospace Nizhniy Novgorod
GBOU SPO Nizhniy Novgorod Automechanical Technical School
GBOU SPO Nizhniy Novgorod Industrial College
GBOU SPO I.I. Lepse Pavlovsky Automechanical Technical School
GBOU SPO Dzerzhinsky Technical College
Construction Industry of Nizhniy Novgorod Region
OOO KNAUF GIPS Dzerzhinsk
(KNAUF)
Power Supply and Automation
Power Supply
and Automation
GBOU SPO Nizhniy Novgorod Technical School for Industry Technologies,
GBOU SPO Dzerzhinsky Industrial and Commercial Technical School
GBOU SPO Dzerzhinsky Technical College,
GBOU SPO Dzerzhinsky Industrial and Commercial Technical School
GBOU DPO [Additional Vocational Education] Nizhniy Novgorod Scientific
and Information Centre
Chemical Industry
OOO Trosifol
(Trosifol)
GBOU SPO Borsky Provincial College
Ministry of Education of Nizhniy Novgorod Region
The Nizhniy Novgorod Association of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs
22

23. Dual
Dual
Education
AGENCY OF
STRATEGIC
INITIATIVES
Education
Contact details for the winning regions
Contact details for the winning regions
Калужская
Kaluzhskaya
область
oblast
Государственное автономное образовательное учреждение среднего
Autonomous state educational estabпрофессионального professional
lishment for secondary образования
Калужской области «Калужский
education of Kaluzhskaya oblast “Kaluколледж информационных
zhsky College of information technology
технологий и управления»
and management”
Координатор проекта:
Никитин Алексей Валерьевич
Project Coordinator:
тел.: +7 (4842) 59-71-05
Nikitin Aleksei Valerievich
e-mail: kkitiu@rambler.ru
Tel: +7 (4842) 59-71-05
Email: kkitiu@rambler.ru
Ульяновская
Ulyanovskaya
область
oblast
Министерство образования
Пермский
Permsky
край
krai торговоПермская
и науки Ульяновской science of
Ministry of education and области
Ulyanovskaya oblast
Координатор проекта:
промышленная палата
Perm Chamber of Trade and Industry
Уба Coordinator:
Project Екатерина
Владимировна
Uba Ekaterina
тел.: +7 (8422) 41-79-27
Vladimirovna
e-mail: edu@ulgov.ru
Tel: +7 (8422) 41-79-27
Координатор проекта:
Project Coordinator:
Данилевич Ольга
Danilevich Olga
Владимировна
Vladimirovna
тел.: +7 (4852) 32-06-05
Tel: +7 (4852) 32-06-05
e-mail: permtpp@permtpp.ru
Email: permtpp@permtpp.ru
Email: edu@ulgov.ru
Красноярский
Krasnoyarsky
край
krai
Министерство образования
Республика
Republic of
Татарстан
Tatarstan образования
Министерство
Свердловская
Sverdlovskaya
область
oblast
Министерство общего и
и науки education and science
Ministry of Красноярского края of
Координатор
Krasnoyarsky krai проекта:
и науки Республики Татарстан
Ministry of education and science of the
Координатор проекта:
Republic of Tatarstan
профессионального образования
Ministry of general and professional
Свердловской области
education of Sverdlovskaya oblast
Project Coordinator:
тел.: +7 (391) 211-94-06
Nikitina Olga Nikolaevna
e-mail: mon@krao.ru
Tel: +7 (391) 211-94-06
Email: mon@krao.ru
Project Coordinator:
тел.: +7 (843) 292-92-12
Fattahov Engel Navapovich
e-mail: eтпуl.fattahov@tatar.ru
Tel: +7 (843) 292-92-12
Email: emnyl.fattahov@tatar.ru
Project Coordinator:
Пахомов Алексей
Pakhomov Aleksei Aleksandrovich
Александрович
Tel: +7 (343) 371-20-08
тел.: +7 (343) 371-20-08
Email: info@minobraz.ru
Никитина Ольга Николаевна
Фаттахов Энгель Навапович
Координатор проекта:
e-mail: info@minobraz.ru
23
15

24. Dual
Dual
AGENCY OF
STRATEGIC
INITIATIVES
Education
Education
Contact details for the winning regions
Contact details for the winning regions
Yaroslavskaya
oblast
Volgogradskaya
oblast
Yaroslav regional department for Social
organisation “Delovaya Russia”
Ministry of education and youth politics
of Volgogradskaya oblast
Project Coordinator:
Korolev Vladimir
Valerievich
Tel: +7 (4852) 32-06-05
Email: info@yardeloros.ru
Project Coordinator:
Korotkov Aleksandr
Mikhailovich
Tel: +7 (8442) 30-86-00
Email: education@volganet.ru
Moskovskaya
oblast
Nizhegorodskaya
oblast
Ministry of education of Moskovskaya
oblast
Ministry of education of Nizhegorodskaya oblast
Project Coordinator:
Kokunova Marianna Yurievna
Tel: +7 (498) 602-11-11
Email: minorbr@mosreg.ru
Project Coordinator:
Naumov Sergei Vasilievich
Tel: +7 (831) 433-24-51
Email: official@obr.kreml.nnov.ru
24
16

25. Dual
Education
Contact details of the ASI team
Ext: +7 (495) 690-91-29
Email: bb.belkov@asi.ru
av.doskanova@asi.ru
Find out more about the work of
the directive “Young professionals”
on the ASI website and Facebook
page, from presentations on SlideShare and the video on YouTube
http://www.asi.ru/molprof/
https://www.facebook.com/ASIYoungProf
25

26. Dual
AGENCY OF
STRATEGIC
INITIATIVES
Education
Dual
Education
Special thanks go to
Special thanks go to
VALERIJ FADEEV
MARAT BIMATOV
DMITIRII PESKOV
General Director of the magazine “Expert”,
Director of the Institute of Public designing,
Chairman of the Commission of the Public
Chamber of the Russian Federation for
economic development and enterprise
Chairman of the Board of Directors, President
of Perm Chamber of Trade and Industry,
member of the Board of Directors of TPP
Russia
Head of the directive “Young professionals” at
the Agency of Strategic Initiatives
KIRILL VASILIEV
BORIS VINOGRADOV
YULIA KHANZHINA
World Bank, specialist in educational projects
Head research fellow of the Expert-analysis
centre of the Ministry of education and science
of Russia and Honoured scientific worker of
Russia
Deputy Director of the Department for strategic development of the Ministry of trade and
industry of Russia
VLADIMIR GORLOV
TIMOFEI ZAJTSEV
NIKITA PONOMARENKO
Associate professor at the sub-faculty of
economic and social geography of Russia in the
geography faculty of Lomonosov Moscow State
University
Head specialist of the office of work relations
of the Department of labour payment, work
relations and social partnership
Ministry of economic development, deputy
director of the Department of economics, social
development and priority programmes
NATALIA ZOLOTAREVA
TATIANA KOZHEVNIKOVA
MIKHAIL KHARMS
Director of the Department of state politics
in the field of staff training and further
professional education at the Ministry of
education and science
Group CTPZ, ARKLI KAPITAL, Director for
organisational development
Chairman of the Board of Directors of the
Russo-German Chamber of Internal Commerce
18
26