SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 9
By Dongyan Wang
Summary of the reading
User-generated content: readers’ comments
Agenda-setting
Ethical decision making
Ethical frameworks of Aristotle and Mill
Discussion
 More communication opportunities in the digital
  public sphere
 The feature of leaving comments
 The case of animal experimentation in the reading
 The case study of Ye Shi Wen

 http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sports/olympics/london/s
   Readers’ comments in agenda-setting

 The feature of leaving comments
http://www.dailychilli.com/buzz/19055-namewee-threaten

 The against of leaving comments
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/olympics/news/944
  0248/Ye-Shiwen-16-year-olds-Olympic-swim-
  impossible-says-coach-John-Leonard.html



                                          10/02/12
   The case of “offensive video clip”

   http://www.dailychilli.com/buzz/19055-namewee-
    threatens-lin-dan-on-youtube




                                         10/02/12
   Based on your knowledge and previous
    experience;



   Based your habits, or consequences.
   Aristotle says moral virtues can be acquired by practice
    and habituation although it is hard to define a mean
    because of our natural tendencies;


   any virtue is a mean of tow vices, e.g. courage is a
    mean of rashness and cowardice, which is also called
    golden mean.



              (Aristotle, 2004 [Trans. Thomson]).

                                                10/02/12
   Consequences

   “Seek the greatest happiness for the greatest number”

   “acting ethically means making decisions and taking
    actions that benefit people by maximizing ‘good’ and
    minimizing ‘bad.’”

   (Thomas, 1985)



                                               10/02/12
   Do you think online users could engage with agenda-
    setting or the agenda-setting processes of established
    professional media in today's digital era? How and Why?


   Based on ethical frameworks of Aristotle and Mill, or other
    ethical principles, What should we keep in mind when we
    are making decisions on ethical issues or doing
    journalistic practice in the digital public sphere?

(All the examples of animal experimentation, doping and
  offensive video clip involve ethical issues. You can take
  them as examples )

More Related Content

What's hot (11)

How the ltt can support you
How the ltt can support youHow the ltt can support you
How the ltt can support you
 
1
11
1
 
Wheeler 2011 csap showcase birmingham
Wheeler 2011 csap showcase birminghamWheeler 2011 csap showcase birmingham
Wheeler 2011 csap showcase birmingham
 
Enterprise Reflective Blogs 31/02/2011
Enterprise Reflective Blogs 31/02/2011 Enterprise Reflective Blogs 31/02/2011
Enterprise Reflective Blogs 31/02/2011
 
Cities eat Cyborgs
Cities eat CyborgsCities eat Cyborgs
Cities eat Cyborgs
 
Jisc RSC Eastern e-Learning forum 14th March 2014 Eastern update
Jisc RSC Eastern e-Learning forum 14th March 2014 Eastern update Jisc RSC Eastern e-Learning forum 14th March 2014 Eastern update
Jisc RSC Eastern e-Learning forum 14th March 2014 Eastern update
 
819 info simplification final
819 info simplification   final819 info simplification   final
819 info simplification final
 
Hotcourses innovation day presentation
Hotcourses innovation day presentationHotcourses innovation day presentation
Hotcourses innovation day presentation
 
ThingsCon Lab - Intro and Overview
ThingsCon Lab - Intro and OverviewThingsCon Lab - Intro and Overview
ThingsCon Lab - Intro and Overview
 
Michael Barrett
Michael BarrettMichael Barrett
Michael Barrett
 
OSDC - Open and Accessible
OSDC - Open and AccessibleOSDC - Open and Accessible
OSDC - Open and Accessible
 

Viewers also liked

Cybercrimebill3rd reading-version-120329030422-phpapp01
Cybercrimebill3rd reading-version-120329030422-phpapp01Cybercrimebill3rd reading-version-120329030422-phpapp01
Cybercrimebill3rd reading-version-120329030422-phpapp01Baldwin Cruz
 
Yalini Suajani
Yalini SuajaniYalini Suajani
Yalini Suajanidipsiyer
 
Meghana Karthik
Meghana KarthikMeghana Karthik
Meghana Karthikdipsiyer
 
莎奉公仔
莎奉公仔莎奉公仔
莎奉公仔capiko
 
A Future With Hope
A Future With HopeA Future With Hope
A Future With HopeBTTE
 
Dos and donts of raising investment capital
Dos and donts of raising investment capitalDos and donts of raising investment capital
Dos and donts of raising investment capitalMark Mohler
 
This I Believe General Presentation
This I Believe General PresentationThis I Believe General Presentation
This I Believe General PresentationEmily Reddy
 

Viewers also liked (12)

Sulu
SuluSulu
Sulu
 
Cybercrimebill3rd reading-version-120329030422-phpapp01
Cybercrimebill3rd reading-version-120329030422-phpapp01Cybercrimebill3rd reading-version-120329030422-phpapp01
Cybercrimebill3rd reading-version-120329030422-phpapp01
 
PERIL LIBRARY
PERIL LIBRARYPERIL LIBRARY
PERIL LIBRARY
 
Yalini Suajani
Yalini SuajaniYalini Suajani
Yalini Suajani
 
England
England England
England
 
Meghana Karthik
Meghana KarthikMeghana Karthik
Meghana Karthik
 
Brazil
Brazil Brazil
Brazil
 
莎奉公仔
莎奉公仔莎奉公仔
莎奉公仔
 
A Future With Hope
A Future With HopeA Future With Hope
A Future With Hope
 
AQUASCRIPT BROCHURE
AQUASCRIPT BROCHUREAQUASCRIPT BROCHURE
AQUASCRIPT BROCHURE
 
Dos and donts of raising investment capital
Dos and donts of raising investment capitalDos and donts of raising investment capital
Dos and donts of raising investment capital
 
This I Believe General Presentation
This I Believe General PresentationThis I Believe General Presentation
This I Believe General Presentation
 

Similar to User generated content and ethicalconsideration in the digital public sphere-dongyan wang

Respond to at least two of your classmates’ posts. 1. After .docx
Respond to at least two of your classmates’ posts. 1. After .docxRespond to at least two of your classmates’ posts. 1. After .docx
Respond to at least two of your classmates’ posts. 1. After .docxdaynamckernon
 
Respond to these two classmates’ posts. 1. After reading thi.docx
Respond to these two classmates’ posts. 1. After reading thi.docxRespond to these two classmates’ posts. 1. After reading thi.docx
Respond to these two classmates’ posts. 1. After reading thi.docxdaynamckernon
 
Michael Edson: Prototyping the Smithsonian Commons
Michael Edson: Prototyping the Smithsonian CommonsMichael Edson: Prototyping the Smithsonian Commons
Michael Edson: Prototyping the Smithsonian CommonsMichael Edson
 
COSC372572 Topic1 Lect1-3 (ch04)_white.pdf
COSC372572 Topic1 Lect1-3 (ch04)_white.pdfCOSC372572 Topic1 Lect1-3 (ch04)_white.pdf
COSC372572 Topic1 Lect1-3 (ch04)_white.pdfManishKarki12
 
After reading this journal article regarding ethics of interne.docx
After reading this journal article regarding ethics of interne.docxAfter reading this journal article regarding ethics of interne.docx
After reading this journal article regarding ethics of interne.docxrosiecabaniss
 
The Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
The Evolution of Technology & EtiquetteThe Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
The Evolution of Technology & EtiquetteChristie Stelling
 
Engineering Ethics : The Social and Value Dimensions of Technology
Engineering Ethics : The Social and Value Dimensions of TechnologyEngineering Ethics : The Social and Value Dimensions of Technology
Engineering Ethics : The Social and Value Dimensions of TechnologyNurlatifa Haulaini
 
10 Looking ForwardMike HouseholderAssociated PressLea.docx
10 Looking ForwardMike HouseholderAssociated PressLea.docx10 Looking ForwardMike HouseholderAssociated PressLea.docx
10 Looking ForwardMike HouseholderAssociated PressLea.docxhyacinthshackley2629
 
A brave new world - Student surveillance in higher education - Revisited
A brave new world - Student surveillance in higher education - RevisitedA brave new world - Student surveillance in higher education - Revisited
A brave new world - Student surveillance in higher education - RevisitedUniversity of South Africa (Unisa)
 
How to teach data ethics in the digital age
How to teach data ethics in the digital ageHow to teach data ethics in the digital age
How to teach data ethics in the digital ageJisc
 
This assignment provides an opportunity to analyze a key IT-rela.docx
This assignment provides an opportunity to analyze a key IT-rela.docxThis assignment provides an opportunity to analyze a key IT-rela.docx
This assignment provides an opportunity to analyze a key IT-rela.docxchristalgrieg
 
The Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
The Evolution of Technology & EtiquetteThe Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
The Evolution of Technology & EtiquetteChristie Stelling
 
Philosophical Aspects of Big Data
Philosophical Aspects of Big DataPhilosophical Aspects of Big Data
Philosophical Aspects of Big DataNicolae Sfetcu
 
Media and Information Literacy (MIL) - Digital Citizenship, Netiquette, Digit...
Media and Information Literacy (MIL) - Digital Citizenship, Netiquette, Digit...Media and Information Literacy (MIL) - Digital Citizenship, Netiquette, Digit...
Media and Information Literacy (MIL) - Digital Citizenship, Netiquette, Digit...Arniel Ping
 
Participation Presentation Mitchell VSO 091009
Participation Presentation Mitchell VSO 091009Participation Presentation Mitchell VSO 091009
Participation Presentation Mitchell VSO 091009Ed Mitchell
 
Behavioural Meetup: Stuart Church on Darwin to Design
Behavioural Meetup: Stuart Church on Darwin to DesignBehavioural Meetup: Stuart Church on Darwin to Design
Behavioural Meetup: Stuart Church on Darwin to DesignPrime Decision
 
Green economy-and-ethical-challenges
Green economy-and-ethical-challengesGreen economy-and-ethical-challenges
Green economy-and-ethical-challengesjohnmikal
 
Data Science Salon: Are you sure you're an ethical technologist?: Build your ...
Data Science Salon: Are you sure you're an ethical technologist?: Build your ...Data Science Salon: Are you sure you're an ethical technologist?: Build your ...
Data Science Salon: Are you sure you're an ethical technologist?: Build your ...Formulatedby
 
Ehical and social issues
Ehical and social issuesEhical and social issues
Ehical and social issuesYashraj Chavda
 

Similar to User generated content and ethicalconsideration in the digital public sphere-dongyan wang (20)

Com354 week.7
Com354  week.7Com354  week.7
Com354 week.7
 
Respond to at least two of your classmates’ posts. 1. After .docx
Respond to at least two of your classmates’ posts. 1. After .docxRespond to at least two of your classmates’ posts. 1. After .docx
Respond to at least two of your classmates’ posts. 1. After .docx
 
Respond to these two classmates’ posts. 1. After reading thi.docx
Respond to these two classmates’ posts. 1. After reading thi.docxRespond to these two classmates’ posts. 1. After reading thi.docx
Respond to these two classmates’ posts. 1. After reading thi.docx
 
Michael Edson: Prototyping the Smithsonian Commons
Michael Edson: Prototyping the Smithsonian CommonsMichael Edson: Prototyping the Smithsonian Commons
Michael Edson: Prototyping the Smithsonian Commons
 
COSC372572 Topic1 Lect1-3 (ch04)_white.pdf
COSC372572 Topic1 Lect1-3 (ch04)_white.pdfCOSC372572 Topic1 Lect1-3 (ch04)_white.pdf
COSC372572 Topic1 Lect1-3 (ch04)_white.pdf
 
After reading this journal article regarding ethics of interne.docx
After reading this journal article regarding ethics of interne.docxAfter reading this journal article regarding ethics of interne.docx
After reading this journal article regarding ethics of interne.docx
 
The Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
The Evolution of Technology & EtiquetteThe Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
The Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
 
Engineering Ethics : The Social and Value Dimensions of Technology
Engineering Ethics : The Social and Value Dimensions of TechnologyEngineering Ethics : The Social and Value Dimensions of Technology
Engineering Ethics : The Social and Value Dimensions of Technology
 
10 Looking ForwardMike HouseholderAssociated PressLea.docx
10 Looking ForwardMike HouseholderAssociated PressLea.docx10 Looking ForwardMike HouseholderAssociated PressLea.docx
10 Looking ForwardMike HouseholderAssociated PressLea.docx
 
A brave new world - Student surveillance in higher education - Revisited
A brave new world - Student surveillance in higher education - RevisitedA brave new world - Student surveillance in higher education - Revisited
A brave new world - Student surveillance in higher education - Revisited
 
How to teach data ethics in the digital age
How to teach data ethics in the digital ageHow to teach data ethics in the digital age
How to teach data ethics in the digital age
 
This assignment provides an opportunity to analyze a key IT-rela.docx
This assignment provides an opportunity to analyze a key IT-rela.docxThis assignment provides an opportunity to analyze a key IT-rela.docx
This assignment provides an opportunity to analyze a key IT-rela.docx
 
The Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
The Evolution of Technology & EtiquetteThe Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
The Evolution of Technology & Etiquette
 
Philosophical Aspects of Big Data
Philosophical Aspects of Big DataPhilosophical Aspects of Big Data
Philosophical Aspects of Big Data
 
Media and Information Literacy (MIL) - Digital Citizenship, Netiquette, Digit...
Media and Information Literacy (MIL) - Digital Citizenship, Netiquette, Digit...Media and Information Literacy (MIL) - Digital Citizenship, Netiquette, Digit...
Media and Information Literacy (MIL) - Digital Citizenship, Netiquette, Digit...
 
Participation Presentation Mitchell VSO 091009
Participation Presentation Mitchell VSO 091009Participation Presentation Mitchell VSO 091009
Participation Presentation Mitchell VSO 091009
 
Behavioural Meetup: Stuart Church on Darwin to Design
Behavioural Meetup: Stuart Church on Darwin to DesignBehavioural Meetup: Stuart Church on Darwin to Design
Behavioural Meetup: Stuart Church on Darwin to Design
 
Green economy-and-ethical-challenges
Green economy-and-ethical-challengesGreen economy-and-ethical-challenges
Green economy-and-ethical-challenges
 
Data Science Salon: Are you sure you're an ethical technologist?: Build your ...
Data Science Salon: Are you sure you're an ethical technologist?: Build your ...Data Science Salon: Are you sure you're an ethical technologist?: Build your ...
Data Science Salon: Are you sure you're an ethical technologist?: Build your ...
 
Ehical and social issues
Ehical and social issuesEhical and social issues
Ehical and social issues
 

User generated content and ethicalconsideration in the digital public sphere-dongyan wang

  • 2. Summary of the reading User-generated content: readers’ comments Agenda-setting Ethical decision making Ethical frameworks of Aristotle and Mill Discussion
  • 3.  More communication opportunities in the digital public sphere  The feature of leaving comments  The case of animal experimentation in the reading  The case study of Ye Shi Wen  http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sports/olympics/london/s
  • 4. Readers’ comments in agenda-setting  The feature of leaving comments http://www.dailychilli.com/buzz/19055-namewee-threaten  The against of leaving comments http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/olympics/news/944 0248/Ye-Shiwen-16-year-olds-Olympic-swim- impossible-says-coach-John-Leonard.html 10/02/12
  • 5. The case of “offensive video clip”  http://www.dailychilli.com/buzz/19055-namewee- threatens-lin-dan-on-youtube 10/02/12
  • 6. Based on your knowledge and previous experience;  Based your habits, or consequences.
  • 7. Aristotle says moral virtues can be acquired by practice and habituation although it is hard to define a mean because of our natural tendencies;  any virtue is a mean of tow vices, e.g. courage is a mean of rashness and cowardice, which is also called golden mean. (Aristotle, 2004 [Trans. Thomson]). 10/02/12
  • 8. Consequences  “Seek the greatest happiness for the greatest number”  “acting ethically means making decisions and taking actions that benefit people by maximizing ‘good’ and minimizing ‘bad.’”  (Thomas, 1985) 10/02/12
  • 9. Do you think online users could engage with agenda- setting or the agenda-setting processes of established professional media in today's digital era? How and Why?  Based on ethical frameworks of Aristotle and Mill, or other ethical principles, What should we keep in mind when we are making decisions on ethical issues or doing journalistic practice in the digital public sphere? (All the examples of animal experimentation, doping and offensive video clip involve ethical issues. You can take them as examples )

Editor's Notes

  1. e