Leadership must change how they manage operations, which will require the right technology, and tech teams must change how they work with the organization to impact operations. This session will look at how to manage these shifts.
As nonprofits grow, spreadsheets and workarounds ease the growing pains, but at some point they just aren’t enough. The challenge only increases when a nonprofit waits too long to address the problem, building up an operations debt requiring massive changes. But not all hope is lost—it’s possible to plan for upcoming needs and implement systems before needing a major fix.
Nonprofits typically face these operational challenges one at time, implementing a solution for each problem. But this approach builds numerous disparate systems that create data silos, limiting access to information and forcing manual processes between teams. A more purposeful approach to policies, staff, systems, processes, and change management, as a collaboration between leadership, IT, and operations, is critical.
This session presents both the leadership and IT perspectives. Everyone can benefit from hearing how leadership sees these challenges versus how IT sees them. You will learn about initial steps you can take today to prepare for organizational growth tomorrow as a team effort.
Developer Data Modeling Mistakes: From Postgres to NoSQL
The Role of Technology in Managing the Operations of a Nonprofit #17ntc
1. The Role of Technology in Managing
the Operations of a Nonprofit
Kelly Bleach – American Foundation for the Blind
Peggy Duvette – NetSuite Social Impact (Oracle) – @PeggyDuvette
Steve Heye – NetSuite Social Impact (Oracle) @SteveHeye
HASHTAG #17NTCoperations Collaboration Notes Link: http://po.st/17NTCoperations
March 2017
4. Define Operations
We took a survey to see how people defined operations:
• Managing resources directed to programs – 0 votes
• Managing day to day activities of organization – 3 votes
• Administration of business practices to create efficiency – 0 votes
• All of the Above – 5 votes
• Managing resources directed to programs and Managing day to day
activities of organization – 2 votes
Write in vote for
“Transformation of resources to
meet mission, efficiently”
5. What is the purpose of Operations?
Strategy
Budget
Performance
Outcome
Driven -
What you
care about
has to be
articulated in
terms of
impact
Drive
Plan
Policy
Management
Data
Govern and
drive the
structure and
controls across
organization
Administrate
People
Process
Tools
Manage
activity across
organization
Manage
Legal
Reporting
Finance
Table Stakes –
CFOs of today
expect FP&A
(financial
planning &
analysis)
Comply
6. Peggy Duvette
Director of Social Impact
NetSuite – Oracle
• 15 years nonprofit tech
experience
• Wrote Chapter 6 in Nonprofit
Fundraising 101
• Previous job was ED of
WiserEarth
• Failed many times with tech
implementation
Kelly Kern Bleach, PMP
Chief Business Officer
American Foundation for the Blind
• 30+ years nonprofit operations
experience
• Oversees finance, facilities,
information technology,
web development,
& product fulfillment
• Certified PMP “for the fun of it”
Steve Heye
Solution Consultant Social Impact
NetSuite – Oracle
• 20 years nonprofit tech experience
• Wrote Chapter 1 in Managing
Technology to Meet Your Mission
• Previous job was Manager of
Technology at The Cara Program
• Taught Windows 3.1 at one of his
previous jobs
Perspective
IT & FinanceOperationsExecutive
7. Role of the Strategic Plan
Strategic
Plan
• Sets the
direction
Operating
Plan
• Outlines
“how”
Budget • Resources
available
Tools:
Policies
Procedures
Process
Systems
Mission-
Vision
Goals for
Depts.
9. Decide what to change
Things to review
• Processes
• Structure
• Governance
• Policies
• Systems
High Level Strategy
• Impact Analysis
• Balanced
Scorecard
• Gap Analysis
Simple Tools
• ROI
• Benefit Analysis
• Audit
• Assessment
10. Decide what to change - examples
Simple
Complex
Use Internal
Resources
Pro Bono or
Volunteer
(Taproot)
Consultant
External
Assessment
Audit
Intern
Fellowship
11. Bookkeeping System
OPERATIONS DEBT DATA
Work Around Spreadsheet
This other free tool we found
Work Around
Spreadsheet
Online Tool
Spreadsheet to pull
spreadsheets together
12. OPERATIONS DEBT DATA
2014
2014
Program Growth Operating Systems
2016
2015
2016
2015
As our programs
grow we adjust
and scale our
processes,
systems and
plans to manage
them.
But as our operations
reporting and tracking
needs grow we look for
work-arounds and push to
stay in the same system
as long as possible.
This leads to a major
project to replace it.
14. Modern Finance/ERP System
FINANCES – START SIMPLE BUT ON A
PLATFORM
Keep Records
• Track income and expense
• Simple lists
• Daily Transactions
Reporting
• Compliance
• Basic Statements
Starting simple in a cloud platform will allow you to scale,
even if you only use base functionality to start
15. MIND & MELODY – NETSUITE.ORG
GRANTEE
Bookkeeper Role
• Track income and expense
• Simple lists of daily transactions
Reporting
• Compliance
• Basic Statements
Tools
• Excel
http://www.mindandmelody.org/
Staff Overview
• No paid staff, 3 key leaders (tech savvy -
virtual team), volunteers are key
• Basic financial skills
Mind & Melody is a 501(c)(3) organization
focused on using music to improve the lives of
people experiencing dementia and other forms
of memory loss. We create and implement
interactive music programs at healthcare
facilities across Florida!
16. MIND & MELODY – THE CHALLENGE
Bookkeeper Role
• Track income and expense
• Simple lists
• Daily Transactions
Reporting
• Compliance
• Basic Statements
Tools
• Excel
Challenges:
• Limited analysis & depth of detail
• Not real time
• Lack of access & visibility to staff-board
• Isolated from other data
• Relies on manual processes
17. MIND & MELODY – THE SOLUTION
Financial Management
• Customizable Accounting
• Full budgeting process
Reporting
• Financial Statements
• Real time dashboards
Tools
• NetSuite
Benefits:
• Formal reports builds credibility for us, telling
our donors “This is not a side job”
• Stronger financial insight & understanding
• Allows collaboration for virtual team
• Ready to scale for org growth
18. AFB’s Continuing
Journey
2005: still used a DOS based
accounting system
2013: migrated order-processing
away from warehouse
2015: customized CRM to manage
donor database
2006: implemented MS Dynamics
Navision
2010: switched to NetSuite
accounting platform
2017: key relationships initiative
integrating vendors, customers, and
donors
19. Operations Systems Reality
• How do I convince management and board to invest?
• Where does the money come from?
• How do I invest in a system but not increase my overhead ratio?
• Where do we get the skills and tech to manage the system?
• Where do we find the time?
21. So what can we do?
Scale Operations
Continuously
Evaluate In-
House,
Outsourcing and
Automation
Balance
Sophistication
and Simplification
ChangeManagement
22. Evaluate In-House, Outsourcing and Automation
In-House
• Builds org
capacity
• Allows shared
roles
Outsource
• Deeper expertise
• Best Practices
Automation
• Scalable
• Dependable
• Limited expertise
• Single Point of
Failure
• Lose some control
• Cost
• Need to maintain
• Needs consistency
23. Examples In-House, Outsourcing and Automation
New Org Grows Expands
Human
Resources
Single Exec staff person
does multiple roles
Outsource payroll &
HR, hires office
manager
Hire HR team, buys HR
software, outsource
payroll
Technology Single Exec staff, free
hosted tools, volunteer
helps
One IT staff to keep
things running,
outsource rest
Tech team, automated
support tools &
integrated solutions
Finance Single Exec staff with
spreadsheets and an
outside accountant
Simple system with a
bookkeeper and
outside auditor
Integrated financial
management with CFO
Data Systems Excel, assortment of
free tools and maybe a
database
Multiple systems for
functional areas
Centralized data
analysis and business
intelligence
24. What does it look like on a day to day basis to
track your operations in a system?
youth programs which tracked
daily participation -- since the
strategic goal was to divert
youth during the high crime
after school hours -- the linkage
between recreation capacity &
strategic goals (crime reduction)
was fairly simple. - David Geilhufe
Client demographics in case
management system to measure if
demographic trends are consistent
with service delivery & funding
priorities. – Ken Montenegro
membership goals / tracked
via BI website - John Merritt
We track the number of each
type of client interaction, fee for
service revenues, types of clients
served, etc. - Cindy Leonard
A local Kids Museum measures daily visitor
stats and tracks their strategic growth goals.
They have POS system that's connected to their
membership system to correlated tracking of
members benefits – Birgit Pauli-Haack
We (an ESOP not a non-profit) track progress toward
strategic goals at our business unit level. We set annual
goals, but reevaluate quarterly based on changing
business objectives and environment. We don't have a
unified goal management system as a company but
delegate responsibility to each business unit and team to
operationalize their work. - Matthew Eshleman
70% of the survey respondents said they had been successful leadership team
(as a staff or board member of an NGO) to invest in an operational system
25. CONNECT DOLLARS TO OUTCOMES
WorldVision, 2016
Nonprofit
ERP like
NetSuite
• Real Time
• Link financials to outcomes
• Manage to the mission
That investment generates around
70 cents worth of grants and
donated goods.
So about 40 cents invested becomes
around 70 cents in care for children and
communities.
The bottom line?
Every $1 you donate = $1.30 in impact
175%
return
Development
Experts
Disaster
Readiness
Donated
Goods
Reliable
Systems
Fundraising &
Administration
26. Tools Avoid the stack of
individual solutions
(when possible, but look
to integrate back when
you can’t)
Find a platform
(like NetSuite) to
centralize your data and
operations
Operational Needs
• Project
Management
• Expense Reports
• Timesheets
• Budget
• Forecasting and
planning
• KPI – performance
reporting
27. So what does this solve
• More visibility to financials
• Track progress on goals and
impact
• Drive better strategic planning
and budgeting
• Save time and allocate
appropriately
• Stronger information for
Boards to drive high level
conversation
• Reducing the gap between the
Board and Operations
Operations
Dollars to
Outcomes
Data Informed
Decisions
Change
Management
Transparency
Increased
Sustainability
through Data
Informed
Decisions
Strengthen
donor
support
through
transparency
Increased
Program
Effectiveness
by tracking
dollars to
outcomes
Harmony
across
departments
through
Change
Management
28. Thank you, please take the survey!
• Session Specific Hashtag: #17NTCoperations
• Collaboration Notes Link: http://po.st/17NTCoperations
• Session Evaluations: http://nten.org/17ntc-evals/
Kelly Bleach
kbleach@afb.net
Peggy Duvette
pduvette@netsuite.com
Steve Heye
sheye@netsuite.com
29. The following slides are extra information we
didn’t have time to present but wanted to
share
30. So why don’t we think about this more?
Knowledge
• Expertise
• Skills
Fear
• Experience
• Risk
Status Quo
• History
• Comfort
No Urgency
• Not broken
• Hidden
32. Balance the Strategic and Operations
Figure 1: Stephen R. Covey's Time-Management Matrix from The 7 Habits of Highly
Effective People, New York: Simon & Schuster, 1989, p. 146.
Notas do Editor
Steve
Steve
Steve
Steve
Explain how legos are like operations:
-if we had set a budget, we could have worked to ensure there were enough blocks for all parts
-I also gave you no information about what we are going to use the car for- which is like a strategic plan
-and finally when we get ready to take our care toward our mission, we will need to plan the journey, which is our operating plan
Steve
Steve – Kelly - Peggy
This slide should be photos of the three presenters.
Do a poll of who is in the room. Do you most identify with leadership, operations or tech-financial?
Something about how leadership – board needs an organization overview
Fundraising needs donor-donation, revenue
Program needs outcomes
Finance needs to balance expenses against revenue
Tech needs to provide the systems
Peggy
In utopia you start fresh and have all of these elements, but in reality….
Road analogy – strategic plan is our destination-direction. Operating plan – the map, where you stop, gas used. Budget - spend
Kelly
You inherit.
We are all at different points in our planning process. Strategic plan-budget-goals already exists. We are all at different levels, size and expertise. So you have to tailor this to your org.
This is all about
Where you are
Understand your role
Where you want to be
How to get there
Simple gap analysis
Don’t get overwhelmed. Pick somewhere to start, refine your focus.
Kelly
Don’t get too stuck on identifying the negative, lose sight of adding benefit
Kelly, Peggy, Steve
Deloitte example
Taproot
WiserEarth
Fellowship
Intern
Consultant
Let me tackle one thing – don’t get overwhelmend
Ask the crowd for a few examples
steve
To illustrate this challenge other way, think about the systems we use to run our operations. Nonprofits will often settle for a bookkeeping system like QuickBooks or an Excel spreadsheet to manage their finances. Then over time as new needs arise beyond the bookkeeping system a workaround is added.
For Mind & Melody, they had to track background checks for volunteers, but the volunteers give the fee to the org and then they paid the company for the background check. But it was critical to track the flow of these funds. This simple process was one of a few requiring manual processes and were tough to report on.
For others it starts with a simple spreadsheet for allocations, grants or a donor list. Then another tool is added for online donations. Then another for online bill pay. Then another, then another. By this point though it gets harder and harder to leave the old systems, it is just too much work.
Add this to the facts that Nonprofit finances are complex, funds can’t be mixed which gets interesting with more revenue streams come or if there are earned revenues or grants.
Steve
The problem with the overhead myth in this example is the pressure for this to not invest a solution to address these issues, that would be an overhead waste. Many organizations focus their efforts, systems and budget on programs and mission, but may neglect their operations. Over time the scope and scale of the organization outpaces the operations, creating a large gap to be filled by a major project.
As this gap grows, no one wants to touch, move or mess with the accounting software out of fear of breaking it because of the related workarounds.
Steve
Steve
One of the premises behind why NetSuite started NetSuite.org and why many other technology companies have similar programs is to get powerful solutions in the hands of nonprofits early to allow them to start with a solid foundation.
But there are other barriers than price to adopting a solution which will allow scaling. These solutions require time and skills.
Steve
Lets look at Mind & Melody as an example. They were founded in 2014, are run by a small team and operate on a minimal budget. Volunteers are a key to their program. Acting as a smart, tech savvy team, the first couple years they pulled together spreadsheets and enough tools to build a solid starting point for the org. This org is like so many other orgs, operating on a small budget where even the IRS filling fee radically impacts the overhead ratio.
Steve
Even though they were stable and growing, they struggled to report their financials to their board in a meaningful way to build credibility and grow support. The orgs budget and financial activity was hard to present to their board and was easily misunderstood. The team had to spend time explaining and reviewing the reports each meeting. Most of the activity was focused on managing today and reviewing historical finances.
The team was aware of the challenges though and decided to act now while the org was still smaller and starting out.
Steve
For Mind & Melody, they decided with their tech-savvy staff, now was the time to move to NetSuite while their finances were simple.
When talked to Mind & Melody about what has changed since they moved to NetSuite, they said they finally feel like their financial and budget reports show that “this is not a side job” for them. The org is building credibility with financial transparency and has a stronger understanding of their funds. They feel like moving their financial management to the cloud has really setup their small, virtual team to scale and grow the org.
Kelly
Overview of org
What were the challenges?
Using an older finance system-went to dynamics
Due diligence in the selection
Where did you start?
How did you pick the next projects?
Where is it now?