SNS 2017 - Patent ductus arteriosus - news and views on diagnosis and management
1. Patent Ductus Arteriosus
- news and views on diagnosis and management
STEFAN JOHANSSON, MD PhD
Sachs Children’s Hospital
Karolinska institutet
Stockholm, Sweden
7. ”Despite…research and clinical experience with thousands of
infants over nearly 6 decades, there is still uncertainty and
controversy about the significance, evaluation, and management
of patent ductus arteriosus in preterm infants…”
AAP Committee on Fetus and Newborn.
Pediatrics Dec 2015. doi: 10.1542/peds.2015-3730
11. PDA – common clinical problem
0
20
40
60
80
100
22 w 23 w 24 w 25 w 26 w
PDA rate (%)
EXPRESS study (all live-born infants <27 weeks in Sweden 2004-2007)
EXPRESS Group. Acta Paediatrica 2010;99:978.
12. PDA – what is it?
☞ ”hemodynamically significant PDA”
• patophysiological consequences counts!
13. PDA – what it is really?
Clinical symtoms/signs
• murmur
• bounding pulses
• sBP >> dBP
• hypotension
• feeding intolerance
Echocardiographic signs
• patency of the duct
• left-right shunt
• large left atrium
• diastolic ”steal”
• diastolic flow in LPA
14. PDA – how is it defined?
let’s read Methods in papers
15. PDA – how is it defined?
• ”diastolic flow easily detectable… main
pulmonary artery”
• ”diastolic backflow in the aorta immediately
beneath the ductus”
• ”LA-to-Ao-ratio >1.6”
van Overmeire. New Engl J Med 2000;343:674
16. PDA – how is it defined?
• ”left to right ductal shunting”
• ”increased LA-to-Ao-ratio”
• ”failure to wean from mechanical ventilation”
• ”PDA defined as the ICD code for PDA”
Richards. Pediatrics 2009;124:e287
Gudmundsdottir. Neonatology 2015:107:87
17. PDA – is there a definition?
Zonnenberg. Acta Paediatrica 2012;101:247
26. Indomethacin prophylaxis and BPD
999 ELBW infants
49% had PDA after placebo21% had PDA after indo
Schmidt. J Pediatr 2006;148:730
41% developed BPD45% developed BPD
27. Mandatory closure vs. no Tx
• Observational study of two time periods with
– mandatory treatment (indomethacin or surgery)
– fluid restriction only
• In total 178 infants born at 23-26 weeks
• BPD rate lower with non-Tx (58 vs. 38%)
• No other differences in other morbidities
Sung. J Pediatr 2016;177:66
28. Should PDAs be treated at all?
Benitz. Arch Dis Child FN Ed 2012;97:F80
29. I am still a Believer!
We have…
• plausible associations
• a heterogeneous patient population
(no clearly defined high-risk group)
We need…
• larger observational studies
• larger randomized trials, also with placebo
31. Medical treatment of PDA
• Ibuprofen or indomethacin
• Due to lower risk of NEC and transient renal
insufficiency, ibuprofen is ”drug of choice”
• Enteral and iv ibuprofen ”appears” as effective
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2015 Feb 18;(2):CD003481
32. ”What about paracetamol?”
• The jury is still out!
• 2 RCT and 14 observational studies
• Methodological quality judged as ”poor”
• Several studies ongoing / planned.
Terrin. Arch Dis Child FN Ed. 2016;101:F127
34. Early ductal shunting
• First hours of life:
– large shunt volumes
– most pronounced
hemodynamic impact
Kluckow. Early Hum Dev 2005;81:429
35. Early targeted treatment
• 164 infants <29 weeks, echo within 12 hours
• 92 with PDA – indomethacin or placebo
• fewer with pulmonary hemorraghe (2 vs 21%)
• no effect on mortality or cranial ultrasound
but trend towards fewer IVH (4 vs 12%)
Kluckow. Arch Dis Child FN Ed. 2014;99:F99
36. Early diagnosis
• Screening before 3 days compared to
indicated echo later
– 605 ”paired” infants <29 weeks
– lower mortality (14 vs 18%), aOR 0.62
– fewer lung bleedings (6 vs 9%)
– no risk differences in NEC, BPD, CNS-lesions
Roze. JAMA 2015;313:2441
38. Current protocol in Stockholm
Echocardiography day 1-3
• < 27 weeks
• all preterm infants on mechanical ventilation
Echocardiography upon “clinical suspicion”
• preterms > 5-7 days on CPAP and “high” FiO2
• clinical signs
39. Our treatment options
• Ibuprofen if <14 days of age
• Surgery may be considered if:
– infant is ”stuck” on invasive ventilation
– late relapse
– heart failure and/or severe lung disease
40. Conservative strategy
In well infants on CPAP we wait and see!
• Repeated echo’s
• Wean CPAP slowly
• Fluid restriction at 160 ml/kg/d
42. Conclusions
• There is no universal PDA definition but…
use echocardiography to set your diagnosis
• You can close the PDA but…
noone knows exactly why you should
• Early management might have benefits but…
”more research is needed”