Sami Niemelä led a two hour workshop on designing discreetness and provided a summary of the key discussions. The workshop focused on reframing common technologies and experiences, like vending machines, cars, and public screens, to be more discreet and privacy-focused. Participants discussed approaches like turning a merchant thing into self-cleaning nanotech clothing, a car UI into a self-driving car experience, and a vending machine into a 3D printing closet. The goal was to start from understanding user behavior and problems, rather than technology, to develop more discreet and meaningful solutions.
2. www.nordkapp.fi
@Nordkapp
First, a bit of where I’m coming from. In brief I’ve done things on and for the web since 1996, mobile 2000. I’ve been
a freelancer, worked at Nokia Design with a team of brilliant 2005-07 and since 2007 I’ve been the creative director
of Nordkapp, a design firm I also co-founded.
www.nordkapp.fi
@Nordkapp
3. www.nordkapp.fi
@Nordkapp
Nordkapp is a design agency working in strategic consulting, design services and product and service development.
We do the usual things like business strategy and product design, digital service design, UX, IxD, information design
and so forth.
For the past year or so we’ve also been figuring out product development, mostly in the form of connecting ideas,
corporations, people and money to each other. It’s a work in progress and has been very interesting.
At the office, we do
mainly two things:
!
1— Consulting & Design Services
!
2— Product development
4. One of the reasons I’m here is probably this piece of work on urban screens. First we did a piece of design fiction for
Helsinki’s World Design Capital year 2012 called Urbanflow Helsinki, then an actual prototype last summer running on
the streets of Helsinki.
http://helsinki.urbanflow.io
5. We also try to figure
out internet of things.
!
Lofi stuff like this we made w/
@teppo is quite useful on trying
to get your head around on how
people would actually react on
physical things talking back at you?
!
Slow WIP at #invisiblethings
@NKLabs
!
6. About discreetness— by dictionary definition it is “intentionally unobtrusive”
Not a smart puppy at all, but more the holy grail of digital service design — the butler. The steward Alan talked about.
I actually think smart puppy is not a good analogy at all. Puppies tend to be quite excited, and I am not sure if I want
my tech to be excited all the time…
7. We are here
we all here are the innovators, and everything
is very very early still.
8. There are a lot of things — software, cars,
anything— talking back to us.
!
A large majority of these seem
like the design part just happened.
They are accidental things, which are
not really considered at all.
This is a picture of a rental VW car which has
nothing wrong really. But it is still shouting
things at me, and I have no idea why.
9. We try to solve most problems by
putting screens everywhere.
!
Tesla seems to be one of the first well designed
instances of “big ass touch screens in places”
but I’m still not convinced this should be the
be-all-end-all of car UIs.
!
There is more to this, we can do better.
10. At the same time, there’s a lot of technology
out there looking for its purpose.
!
To riff on Alexandro’s (@iotwatch) point earlier
today it seems to be mostly done by white
males, for white males.
!
It’s still the “because we can”-tech.
11. A lot of wearables have a problem
with battery life.
!
I really loved my Pebble Steel for the first five
weeks until I forgot my charger cable home.
And here we are.
12. mobile first › behaviour first
So we need to approach things not mobile first but behavior first. Think how things behave and talk back to us.
Mobile first is just a technological lens to approach a tiny part of a problem which is really more about understanding
how people behave and then design for that.
!
13. Context &
Simplicity over
complexity.
Things like context and simplicity matter more than even. Say what you say about Glass, but there is something quite magical about information
hovering in front of your eyes. The hardware may not quite be there yet, but that is just a matter of time.
!
UI example; Eaze (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wu7tMD3ufKI)
14. Language
matters
speech recognition is getting pretty
good already. But so far it’s a lot about
predefined pattern recognition and
matching — what we really need to do
next is to design the software behind the
magic.
15. Looks to me we’ve been here
before haven’t we?
16. Behaviour
matters
This is what I mean by not smart puppies — things seem quite easily way too excited
like this example of my first go with Nike Fuelband. This was the first Facebook
update on the first day I used the thing. Best. Day. Ever, right?
17. www.nordkapp.fi
@Nordkapp
So here’s the thing —I believe the key on cracking this is do things for humans first, then services, software and
hardware. Not the other way around. This is pretty visible for example on how corporations approach #iot; they all
look it at based on their own history because that is what they understand. But instead you should start from empathy
and real problems, do the rest afterwards.
Human factors Services Software Hardware
18. The best examples of discreetness
out there tend to be startups &
individual things.
!
Corporations are just learning this.
!
Things like Shine which resembles more
jewelry than a wearable sensor
!
http://www.misfitwearables.com
19. Moves, a Finnish app
recently bought by Facebook
has near-magical algorithms
figuring out what you do,
where and so forth.
!
!
http://moves-app.com
20. iZettle, the Swedish payment terminal.
I really like their card reader and how it
is done. it is a very discreet, almost
silent blank object.
!
http://izettle.com
21. Aether Cone is an intelligent speaker which
learns from how you use it. There’s a lovely
physical interface and it also understands
voice commands.
!
!
http://aether.com
22. Then there’s this more conceptual side.
Massimo Banzi of Arduino fame talked about
hardware as poetry, and that’s what I think
things like this Twitter cuckoo clock by BERG
are really are like. Beautiful, discreet things.
!
!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=Haq4oP3B4rE
23. The Good Night Lamp is a perfect
example of discreet thing tapping into
something that is everyday and
turning it into a meaningful
experience.
!
http://goodnightlamp.com
24. Based on Android Wear, Google is also getting
this. I haven’t used one yet but based on the
video they seem to be the first ones who get
the role of a wrist device with a screen in it. In
the video there’s this scene where a girl opens
up a garage door with a simple voice
command. That’s how things should work.
!
http://www.android.com/wear/
!
25. So based on this, we had yesterday good
25-30 people discussing, sketching out and
reframing a few familiar everyday
experiences.
26. “How could we make ______ more discreet?”
The question we asked was “how could we make this (blank) more discreet?”. We had six starting points where there
are either screens or very in-your-face tech. Vending machines, atms, cars UI, public screens, merchants and
wearables.
27. I like frameworks. I like em because they help you to focus your thinking and go past the blank paper syndrome really
fast.
For this, we had a this simple privacy framework we’ve used in our projects, few triggers on how it works and of
course when is it for — now or few years out.
Reframing:
!
What: private → personal → shared → common → public
!
How: (haptics + screens + touch + voice + other) = 100%
!
When: Now → next year → three → five years or more
!
28. And this is what happened in 60 mins or so, in five groups. We got a merchant thing turned into a self cleaning
nanotech clothing, a car UI to self driving car experience — what do you do when there’s barely any driving to be
done? Do we need public screens when we can replace it with a smartphone and a sensor network? There was a
vending machine turned into a 3D printing closet in your home or at a public place, and a public screen turned into a
discreet transport ticketing being basically invisible unless you were cheating by not paying.
!
Awesome stuff in such a short time. I really enjoyed thinking out loud and making sense of this with other people and
then sketching out the experiences really quick and dirty through reframing.
from a…
merchant thing to self cleaning clothing
car UI to self driving car experience
public screens to smartphone + sensor network
vending machine to 3D printing closet
public screen to discreet transport ticketing
29. www.nordkapp.fi
@Nordkapp
Awesome stuff in such a short time. I really
enjoyed thinking out loud and making sense
of this with other people and then sketching
out the experiences really quick and dirty
through reframing.
!
THANK YOU!
!
I am at @samin on Twitter.