SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 32
Baixar para ler offline
AUTO M OT I V E



Multi-Channel Sales Approach
for Premium Autos: Raising Cost
Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales
Editorial


               The automotive industry in 2009 is without any doubt in the middle of one of
               the most serious crises it has ever experienced. The slump in sales, imminent
               insolvencies and significant excess capacity all combine to make it clear that
               revolutionary changes in this sector are on the agenda.

               One of the areas where such change is “waiting to happen” is automotive retail.
               The structures and business models for automotive marketing and sales have
               remained somewhat static, despite the rising heterogeneity and complexity of
               the buyers. A spate of developments indicate that the prerequisites for change
               are already present in the market, including target groups which do not feel
               properly addressed, low margins on the side of the dealer, high sales costs on
               the side of the manufacturer and an increase in intra-brand competition.
               Companies who introduce radical innovations within the distribution system
               can break out of this stagnation, and generate lasting competitive advantages
               for themselves.

               To guide this re-orientation in the automotive industry, we can take a look at
               other branches where radical change in the sales channels has already taken
               place. Following the example of these branches, we want to show in this
               study how the establishment of a multi-channel sales approach, with a clear
               and segmented sharing out of activities between the OEM and the dealers,
               is a strategy option for working markets comprehensively and efficiently.
               The complexity of customers’ requirements for purchasing cars can be met by
               managing an integrated range of sales channels matched to the diversity of
               customer segments. Many automotive companies have untapped potential in
               the market which could be exploited as a result of such an approach, which
               would then create a clear competitive advantage for them.

               With this study KPMG hopes to make a stimulating, if not provocative,
               contribution to the dialogue within the auto industry over changes in marketing
               and sales. I wish you good reading.



               Dieter Becker
               Managing Partner
               Global Head of Automotive




            © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                      ,
            with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
            member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                 ,
            have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
            International.
Table of Contents


                Executive Summary ..............................................................................................2

                Introduction ...........................................................................................................4



                Part I: Empirical Analysis.......................................................................................5

                     1 Twelve sales channels ......................................................................................6

                     2 Prospects for success and further development of sales channels...............11



                Part II: Evaluation and Scenarios........................................................................13

                     3 Suboptimal integration of the sales channels ................................................14

                     4 What a multi-channel sales approach needs to do .........................................16

                     5 Four scenarios ................................................................................................18



                Conclusion: Raising Cost Effectiveness.............................................................28




                © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                          ,
                with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                     ,
                have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                International.
2 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales




Executive Summary


                                      To address the wide range of individual                                            Scenario 1 – Retail trade
                                      preferences amongst car buyers regard-
                                      ing the purchase process, this study                                               In the business-to-consumer segment,
                                      has identified twelve separate sales                                               the manufacturer focuses predominantly
                                      channels:                                                                          on the brand image, whereas the other
                                                                                                                         elements of the purchase process are
                                        1 Sponsoring                                                                     looked after by the dealer. In short, the
                                                                                                                         manufacturer focuses on marketing for
                                        2 Factory sales                                                                  the end users, the dealer focuses on
                                                                                                                         sales. In contrast, business customers
                                        3 Customer contact in the context                                                are serviced at nearly every stage by
                                          of servicing the auto                                                          the OEM. This business model is above
                                                                                                                         all prominent in the markets for food
                                        4 Dealerships                                                                    and household articles.

                                        5 Cooperations with non-auto brands
                                          such as fashion or electronics                                                 Scenario 2 – Cultivating strong
                                                                                                                         brands
                                        6 Internet website of the OEM
                                                                                                                         As the owner of the brand name, the
                                        7 Internet website of the dealer                                                 manufacturer plays a central role when
                                                                                                                         it comes to cultivating the market for
                                        8 Automotive “shopping malls”                                                    new customers. The dealer profits to a
                                                                                                                         great extent from the image building
                                        9 Events                                                                         carried out by the manufacturer and his
                                                                                                                         efforts with respect to canvassing new
                                      10 City showrooms                                                                  customers. This gives the dealer the
                                                                                                                         space to concentrate above all on the
                                      11 Brokering from non-auto                                                         contact to existing customers and on
                                         companies, e.g. a jeweller                                                      improving the relations management
                                                                                                                         with respect to the customers already
                                      12 Recommendations from third                                                      known to him. It is often the case with
                                         parties for new customers                                                       products backed by strong brands,
                                                                                                                         such as fashion or upmarket consumer
                                      The authors of this study present four                                             electronics, that the manufacturer culti-
                                      scenarios for customer segmentation                                                vates the brand image and strongly
                                      and the corresponding structures/                                                  promotes the acquisition of new cus-
                                      allocation of activities between the                                               tomers. The dealer on the other hand
                                      OEM and the dealers in managing the                                                concentrates in this case primarily on
                                      twelve channels accordingly.                                                       customers who are already committed
                                                                                                                         to the brand.




                                      © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                                                ,
                                      with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                                      member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                                           ,
                                      have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                                      International.
3




Scenario 3 – Purchase process               The assessment of the success pro-                                                 Raising cost effectiveness
with or without personal sales              spects of the scenarios shows a clear
support                                     split on the one hand between OEMs                                                 The use of the internet as well as the
                                            and dealerships in Scenario 1, which                                               coordinated allocation of resources in
In this scenario, the manufacturer is       comes closest to the current arrange-                                              the sales channels, as provided for in
responsible for customers who need          ments in the auto market.                                                          each scenario, taken together result in
no personal support, while the dealer                                                                                          an increase in cost effectiveness. Ulti-
can focus his resources on his specialty,   Scenario 2 on the other hand sees a                                                mately, the internet as a sales channel
i.e. exactly those customers who do         functional distinction between the OEM                                             is the most cost-efficient instrument
want such support. It is possible in this   and the dealerships. While OEMs handle                                             that can be employed to communicate
case to draw a parallel to the travel       the overall image as well as the link                                              relevant information and to handle sales
industry where the customers can            between specific product images and                                                processes. In the medium term, how-
decide whether they make their own          their target groups, the primary role                                              ever, it is not to be expected that all
bookings on the internet or make use        of the dealer is managing customer                                                 customers will make exclusive use of
of the personal assistance offered by       relations, sales and after-sales steps in                                          the internet as a sales channel. Thus,
a travel agency.                            the purchase process. Thus, Scenario 2                                             the segmented use of a range of sales
                                            seems to make the most sense for the                                               channels, in a clearly defined sales
                                            premium segment.                                                                   approach for manufacturer and dealer
Scenario 4 – Product-specific                                                                                                  alike, enables a systematic and cost-
added value in the automotive               Scenario 3 is the most radical departure                                           effective use of resources. Clearly
trade                                       from the current business models, and                                              defined fields of action, with the
                                            is based primarily on internal, i.e. cost,                                         elimination of redundancies and the
This scenario works on the premise that     considerations. Within the context of                                              exploitation of synergies, foster the
the OEM establishes a specific channel      Scenario 4, the OEMs would benefit                                                 development of specific competences
mix via which he processes all sales        from managing their own distribution                                               and serve to raise cost effectiveness
activities independently, i.e. without      channels along the lines of Scenario 3,                                            in a comprehensive manner.
incorporation of the dealer. Retail bank-   segmenting customers according to
ing, where the “producers” (i.e. the        the costs of managing them.
banks) manage directly their own sales
channels, is an example where product
knowledge is decisive for the genera-
tion of an added value in the sales pro-
cess for the customer. This scenario is
configured such that manufacturers in
the automotive industry employ exactly
their product knowledge in the same
way as retail banks do, to handle the
entire distribution on their own.




                                            © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                                                      ,
                                            with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                                            member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                                                 ,
                                            have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                                            International.
4 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales




                                                                                                                                                                     Introduction


                                                                                                                                                                                                           This study was prepared by KPMG             Structure of the study
                                                                                                                                                                                                           together with the International School
                                                                                                                                                                                                           of Management (Sebastian Waldorf,           In Part I, the empirical results of the
                                                                                                                                                                                                           assisted by Professor Dr Ralf A. Brickau)   study are presented. The twelve sales
                                                                                                                                                                                                           between January and April 2009. The         channels identified as a result of the
© 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated

member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG




                                                                                                                                                                                                           results are based on a combination of       interviews are described and evaluated.
with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other




                                                                                                                                                                                                           desk research and discussions with          In the second section of Part I, the
                                                                                                                                                                                                           experts. A total of eleven Managing         prospects for success in managing
                                                                                                                                                                                                           Directors of dealerships spread over        each individual channel are presented.
                                                                                                                                                                                                           the entire premium segment in Germany
                                                                                                                                                                                                           were interviewed. The empirical analy-      In Part II, KPMG evaluates the empiri-
                                                                                                                                                                                                           sis was rounded off by discussions          cal results. The suboptimal integration
                                                                                                                                                                                                           with experts from institutes and asso-      of channels is briefly touched upon
                                                                                                                                                                                                           ciations such as the Institute for          here. The statements arise in part from
                                                                                                                                                                                                           Automotive Business (IFA), Global           comments made in the interviews and
                                                                                                                                                                                                           Insight and the German Association of       in part from other market observations
                                                                                                                                                                                                           the Automotive Industry (VDA), as well      on the part of KPMG. In the second
                                                                                                                                                                                                           as an expert from AutoScout24.              section of Part II, the demands made
                                                                                                                                                                                                           Because of the different geographical       on an integrated multi-channel sales
                                                                                                                                                                                                           locations and dealership sizes within       approach are portrayed, derived from
                                                                     ,




                                                                                                                                                                                                           the German premium automotive mar-          the interview results and from the rele-
                                                                                                                                                                                                           ket, the dealers interviewed represent      vant literature. In the third section of
                                                                                                                                                                                                           an excellent cross-section for ensuring     Part II, KPMG presents four scenarios
                                                                                                                                                                                                           reliable results.                           for a multi-channel sales approach.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Although the structure of the scenarios
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       is taken from other consumer branches,
                          ,




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       the content is derived from the inter-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       views. This section is summed up with
International.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       a conclusion related to raising cost
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       effectiveness in the car trade.
Part I: Empirical Analysis




© 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                          ,
with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                     ,
have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
International.
6 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales




1 Twelve sales channels


                                                            These days, it is possible for a premium                                           such an event and can be approached
                                                            manufacturer to market his products                                                during its course. All-important is that
                                                            via different channels and in doing so,                                            the person who makes initial contact
                                                            to address his customers in a very indi-                                           with the customer is the one who will
                                                            vidual way. The following text presents                                            support him throughout the entire
                                                            a number of these possibilities and                                                purchase process and thus build up a
                                                            integrates them later in possible sales                                            bond. Christian Boe, Managing Director
                                                            scenarios. The figure below shows                                                  of the Porsche Centre in Mannheim,
                                                            what those interviewed said about                                                  sees above all considerable advantages
                                                            these channels during this study.                                                  in “sponsoring an event when your
                                                                                                                                               own staff is on the spot and is involved
                                                            The comments on the individual                                                     in the event themselves.  ”
                                                            channels were as follows:

                                                                                                                                               Factory sales
                                                            Sponsoring
                                                                                                                                               Factory sales constitute the purest
                                                            The sponsoring of events such as                                                   form of direct sales and are usually
                                                            large-scale sports meetings serves                                                 only applied as part of VIP sales pro-
                                                            above all to improve the image of a                                                grammes or in the used-car business.
                                                            company. Over and above this, pro-                                                 The discussions in the market have
                                                            spective customers can be invited to                                               shown, however, that these types of




Figure 1: Sales channels and their evaluation
                 Sponsoring                                   45 %                                                    9%                9%                                            36 %

               Factory sales                  27 %                                                 27 %                                                                     45 %

             Auto in service                                                                       82 %                                                                                                 18 %

                 Dealerships                                                                                91%                                                                                                   9%

Non-auto brand cooperations                                                                                 91%                                                                                                   9%

               Internet OEM                                                                        82 %                                                                                                 18 %

              Internet dealer                                           55 %                                                                     18 %                                          27 %

             Shopping malls                                                      64 %                                                                      9%                        18 %                         9%

                      Events                                                              73 %                                                                               9%                9%                 9%

               Public events                                  45 %                                                    9%                         18 %                                          27 %

              Closed events                                                               73 %                                                                               9%                         18 %

             City showrooms                                                               73 %                                                                                                 27 %

                  Brokerage                          36 %                                                                                                 64 %

          Recommendations              18 %                                                                                             82 %

  Positive     Neutral      Negative     No mention




                                                            © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                                                                      ,
                                                            with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                                                            member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                                                                 ,
                                                            have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                                                            International.
7




activities by manufacturers are viewed                                             everything in detail, whereas Roger
                                                                                                        ”
as strong competition. Wilfried Hallier,                                           Störzer, Managing Director of the
Managing Director of the Porsche                                                   Porsche Centre Nuremburg, adds that
Centre Hamburg North-West, com-                                                    “customers place the quality and the
ments that “what manufacturers are                                                 service offered by the salesperson
already practising today does not really                                           above the visual impression of the
help in a lot of sectors such as the                                               showroom. As far as the contact to
                                                                                               ”
used-car market.  ”                                                                the customer goes, Professor Willi Diez,
                                                                                   Head of the Institute of Automotive
                                                                                   Research, states that “selling via a
Customer contact while the auto is                                                 point of sale is these days somewhat
in service                                                                         outdated. A lot of customers really
                                                                                   want to be approached in a completely
The time that the customer spends in                                               different way than via the classic car
the dealership waiting for his car to be                                           showroom. But there are naturally also
                                                                                               ”
serviced, or any other form of contact                                             other opinions: an important element
with the customer in the context of                                                here is without doubt the test drive,
servicing his or her car, can be made                                              which Roland Klement, Managing
much better use of to actively approach                                            Director of the Porsche Centre at
the customer and to initiate a subse-                                              Stuttgart Airport, still sees “as being
quent purchase process. Boe, for                                                   the best sales argument and thus
example, thinks that “making use of                                                essential.”
the service process to approach the
customer” is an option that is not yet
being exploited to a satisfactory                                                  Non-auto brand cooperations
degree.
                                                                                   With respect to contacting potential
                                                                                   customers, cooperating with firms from
Dealerships                                                                        outside the industry was repeatedly
                                                                                   broached in the discussions during this
The traditional car dealership in its cur-                                         study. Christoph Käding, Managing
rent form is designed to cover different                                           Director of Bach Premium Cars, says
process steps, namely customer rela-                                               that “joint ventures are perfectly feasible
tions, sales and service. Generally                                                and are gaining an increasing amount
speaking, it must also be ensured that                                             of attention, whereby it’s all about
the corporate image is communicated                                                developing a concept together with an
and represented at exactly this cus-                                               interesting partner. In this particular
                                                                                                       ”
tomer contact point. Manfred Seidel,                                               case, the joint activity was with the
Executive Director Sales Germany at                                                manufacturer of private yachts in his
AutoScout24, the used-car internet                                                 showroom in order to approach a com-
sales platform, says that “the dealer                                              mon clientele. Boe agrees and sees
must be in a position to serve both the                                            possibilities “in both directions, i.e.
internet-savvy customer as well as the                                             both in a car showroom, in order to
senior citizen who wants to be shown                                               increase the customer frequency, as




© 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                          ,
with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                     ,
have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
International.
8 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales




                                      well as on the partner’s premises. As
                                                                          ”                                              Internet dealers
                                      for gaining new customers in the pro-
                                      cess, Hallier says: “We invite the manu-                                           In comparison with manufacturers,
                                      facturers of premium brands to the                                                 dealers can display their products on
                                      Porsche Centre to present their prod-                                              their website in a targeted manner and
                                      ucts on our premises, and we acquire                                               can initiate the sales process there
                                      new customers for ourselves in this                                                and then, and can also communicate
                                      way. By the same token, Störzer says:
                                          ”                                                                              directly with a customer. The internet
                                      “Joint ventures with other premium                                                 is absolutely ideal for the used-car
                                      products are great provided that the                                               business, and will become increasingly
                                      partner is the right one. I can also                                               important in the future. Peter Kraft,
                                      envisage exhibiting our brand in the                                               Managing Director of the Porsche
                                      showrooms of another premium brand.   ”                                            Centre in Lörrach, says that there are
                                                                                                                         two sides to this coin: “On the one
                                                                                                                         hand, I can take an exotic car in part
                                      Internet OEM                                                                       payment because the marketplace
                                                                                                                         for this car is the world. But on the
                                      The website of an OEM today serves                                                 other hand, the best-price shopper
                                      mainly to convey the image, whereas                                                need not buy in his immediate vicinity,
                                      the acquisition of customer contacts                                               but can rather purchase anywhere he
                                      and their transmission via this medium                                             likes. Sascha Heiden, Senior Market
                                                                                                                              ”
                                      will play a much greater role in the                                               Analyst at Global Insight, also says
                                      future. In this context, Seidel says that                                          that “the internet will in future become
                                      “the internet will become the lead                                                 an increasingly important sales channel
                                      channel to the dealer in the future.”                                              above all in the used-car trade. ”
                                      Jürgen Niemuth, Managing Director
                                      of the Porsche Centre Munich South,
                                      makes a fundamental observation in                                                 Automotive “shopping malls”
                                      this context: “Internet has changed so
                                      many things. Even before coming to                                                 The spatial positioning of different
                                      the car showroom, the customer                                                     brands at one location is generally seen
                                      informs himself thoroughly. And when                                               as being positive, provided that the
                                      he gets there, he usually only wants                                               overall presentation has an exclusive
                                      to know how much the car costs and                                                 flair. Splinter, Managing Director of
                                      how soon he can have it. People simply                                             the Porsche Centre Berlin-Potsdam,
                                      have so many more possibilities with                                               for example, feels that “consolidating
                                      the internet. For our part, however, this                                          different brands makes sense because
                                      trend means that we are often deprived                                             the presence of the right brands makes
                                      of the opportunity of having a real                                                it possible to generate a higher cus-
                                      sales discussion. ”                                                                tomer flow. Störzer sees the advantage
                                                                                                                                      ”
                                                                                                                         above all in the fact that “the customer
                                                                                                                         can get a good overall idea of the
                                                                                                                         entire market without having to go
                                                                                                                         far, whereas there were some other
                                                                                                                             ”




                                      © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                                                ,
                                      with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                                      member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                                           ,
                                      have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                                      International.
9




interview partners who rejected such                                               parties serves primarily to enhance the
models on principle.                                                               image of the company as well as to
                                                                                   generate initial contacts. Professor Diez
                                                                                   says: “One has to go to the customer
Events                                                                             these days and not the other way
                                                                                   around. It is immensely important to
With regard to the possibility of using                                            present oneself at highly frequented
events within the sales system, a                                                  locations and to try to go wherever
distinction must be made between                                                   there is traffic rather than trying to
public events, those organised by third                                            generate the traffic oneself. A road
parties and closed events. Whereas                                                 show in the centre of town, for example,
public events include, for instance, the                                           is a good way to create a point of
presentation of cars in city centres,                                              interest, whereby such an event must
those organised by third parties can be                                            always provide the possibility of taking
exhibitions and sports events. Closed                                              a test drive.
                                                                                               ”
events usually take place in the car
showroom itself or on the premises                                                 Closed events
of a joint venture partner. In a further                                           Closed events serve more to cultivate
step, according to Käding, “the events                                             customer relationships and thus customer
are split into two groups, namely those                                            loyalty, although once the customer
that concentrate on acquiring new                                                  leads have been reliably qualified, there
customers and those that serve to                                                  is nothing standing in the way of a
enhance the loyalty of existing custom-                                            successful contact to new customers
ers. Boe confirms the effectiveness
    ”                                                                              via closed events. For Hallier “these
of such events, because “to my mind,                                               events are above all an important topic
selling is no different to customer rela-                                          because we frequently attempt to
tions management. Whoever succeeds                                                 acquire new customers at them. Peer
                                                                                                                    ”
in creating a good atmosphere will find                                            Kraack, Head of Sales Porsche Centre
it easier to make a sale. Hallier adds
                          ”                                                        Limburg, says that “open driving days
that “above all, themed concepts are                                               are encouraged because an extremely
important in order to create a bond                                                high rate – higher than that known from
with customers. As mentioned earlier,
                  ”                                                                normal test drives – can be achieved in
there is also the possibility of cooperat-                                         terms of making sales.  ”
ing with other companies. “What is
new is that we are hitching up to other
premium brands and that we are trying                                              City showrooms
to make contact with the target group
via these joint activities.
                          ”                                                        The positioning of showrooms in
                                                                                   downtown areas encountered a wide
Public events and those organised                                                  range of reactions by those who took
by third parties                                                                   part in the study. Whereas some of
The organisation of public events or                                               those interviewed argue against a
the integration of one’s own presen-                                               concept that is restricted purely to the
tation in an event organised by third                                              presentation of vehicles and Boe




© 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                          ,
with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                     ,
have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
International.
10 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales




questions the cost efficiency, Störzer      Brokerage                                                                          Recommendations
sees this concept as being very effec-
tive, although “these lighthouse projects   The concept of brokerage is that firms                                             Comparable with the concept of bro-
should only be seen as a lead channel       from other sectors refer their customers                                           kerage are recommendations, where a
to the car showrooms; the business          to the dealership or the manufacturer                                              third party gives a potential customer
must remain with the local dealer. ”        and receive a quid pro quo in return.                                              the opportunity of taking a test drive,
He also says, “In principle, I would like   Splinter believes that “there should be                                            for example, in order to bring him into
to see such a showroom in every large       a concept which provides for brokering                                             contact with the brand, thereby upgrad-
city, although this is not something the    customers on a commission basis.                                                   ing his own products or services in the
dealers can shoulder but is rather the      Conceivable here would be a coopera-                                               process. Or an existing customer could
responsibility of the manufacturers. ”      tion with upmarket jewellers, for exam-                                            recommend a friend as a potential
Other interviewees also see a clear         ple. Boe, too, sees the possibility of
                                                ”                                                                              customer in return for, e.g., a branded
benefit, but one that is nonetheless        cooperating with “exclusive travel                                                 present. Kraack sees “such ’tickets-for-
countered by high costs. But when it        agencies who function as independent                                               a-friend’ concepts as an innovation
comes specifically to “the introduction     brokers.”                                                                          which can be judged as extremely
of new products” and “the acquisition                                                                                          promising in cooperation with selected
of new customers” everybody can
                     ,                                                                                                         partners.”
see a clear advantage.




                                            © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                                                      ,
                                            with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                                            member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                                                 ,
                                            have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                                            International.
11




2 Prospects for success and further development
  of sales channels

                The automotive trade is currently at a                                             customer relations and sales and service.
                point at which the companies need to                                               The sales approach must at all costs be
                take fundamental structural decisions                                              supplemented by further channels,
                in order to secure their competitive                                               because although this business model
                positions in the long term. Today’s busi-                                          may form the core of the sales activities,
                ness model and the 12 channels identi-                                             the customer does not necessarily
                fied in this study reveal a host of areas                                          want to visit the car showroom in all
                where the potential for optimisation is                                            phases of the purchasing decision pro-
                present, in particular for generating                                              cess, but may well expect an active
                new customer contacts, lead manage-                                                approach in a different environment.
                ment and the used-car business. Under
                the premise that the “experience” when                                             As far as contact to potential customers
                buying a car must still primarily originate                                        goes, the topic of cooperating with
                from the product itself, the test drive                                            companies external to the industry
                is still one of the most important ele-                                            was raised repeatedly during the course
                ments of the sales process, whereby                                                of the study and was assigned a
                open driving days and road shows are                                               correspondingly high success potential.
                also gaining importance.                                                           In this connection, the potential for
                                                                                                   brokerage and recommendations can
                With regard to service, it is clear that                                           also be rated highly.
                customer demands have risen markedly
                and the time that the customer spends                                              Besides an increase in activities asso-
                at, or at least in contact with, the service                                       ciated with used cars, the internet will
                unit should be used more intensively                                               play a major role in the future above all
                for communication. In this connection,                                             in the acquisition of customer contacts
                it is furthermore clear that a shared                                              and their direct transmission to the
                location for sales and service has                                                 relevant sales units. In the medium
                advantages.                                                                        term, however, and at least for the
                                                                                                   major part of the target group amongst
                The start of a customer relationship can                                           private customers, the internet will not
                take place anything up to two years                                                establish itself as the sales channel.
                before the actual sale. At the moment,                                             This is, however, conceivable in the
                however, the customer is barely being                                              domain of business customers.
                taken notice of at this time, meaning
                that the possibility of an early bond to                                           The significance of events is on the
                the brand is not being exploited.                                                  rise, and will continue into the future.
                                                                                                   Already today, events display a high
                The traditional car showroom in its cur-                                           effectiveness when they are properly
                rent form is designed primarily to cover                                           organised, because they build on the




                © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                          ,
                with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                     ,
                have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                International.
12 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales




                                      point that “sales” is basically nothing                                            The scenarios presented later in this
                                      more than pure relations management.                                               study use exactly these insights and
                                      Whoever is capable of creating a good                                              show how an OEM together with a
                                      atmosphere will have success in this                                               dealer can work the market in the future.
                                      area.                                                                              They can segment the customers
                                                                                                                         accordingly and combine the channels
                                      One overall aim is to present oneself at                                           in order to increase the effectiveness
                                      highly frequented locations and to use                                             and thus the profitability within the
                                      the traffic that is already available instead                                      entire sales system, and increase
                                      of expending one’s own resources to                                                customer satisfaction at the same time.
                                      generate exactly that. In this context,
                                      public events are viewed positively,
                                      without any clear statements being
                                      made on their sustainability as a sales
                                      channel. The views on showrooms in
                                      highly frequented regions vary, because
                                      in spite of a principled endorsement,
                                      the cost aspect constitutes a strong
                                      counterargument.




                                      © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                                                ,
                                      with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                                      member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                                           ,
                                      have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                                      International.
Part II Evaluation and Scenarios




© 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                          ,
with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                     ,
have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
International.
14 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales




3 Suboptimal integration of sales channels


                                                        The current positioning and manage-                                                • A closely meshed coordination
                                                        ment of sales channels is shown in the                                               between the channels or between
                                                        table below.                                                                         the phases in the buying process
                                                                                                                                             does not always take place. This
                                                        Drawing on its own experience within                                                 has several aspects:
                                                        the market, KPMG advances the follow-
                                                        ing statements:                                                                         – In the dealerships, it is often the
                                                                                                                                                  case that customer contact while
                                                        • There are many overlaps in the chan-                                                    the auto is in service is not always
                                                          nels operated by the manufacturers                                                      managed properly as a further
                                                          and dealers. This redundant use of                                                      sales contact, e.g. the salesperson
                                                          resources is inefficient.                                                               does not always greet the cus-
                                                                                                                                                  tomer personally when he brings
                                                        • The channels are not directed                                                           his car in for a service, or the
                                                          systematically towards a specific                                                       service contact is not used as a
                                                          phase in the buying process, but                                                        chance to collect the thoughts of
                                                          rather are broadly designed to serve                                                    the customer about purchasing
                                                          several purposes. This means that                                                       the next car. Another example of
                                                          the channels are not focused on                                                         a lack of coordination within the
                                                          achieving clearly targeted objectives                                                   dealership is, customer contacts
                                                          in the sales process. With an orien-                                                    from dealer events are not always
                                                          tation towards vague and diversified                                                    followed up properly within the
                                                          objectives, the effectiveness of the                                                    customer relationship manage-
                                                          channels necessarily suffers as a                                                       ment system (CRM).
                                                          result.




Figure 2: Sales channel management in the premium auto market today


                Image                     First contact                           Further contacts                                         Sales                                         Service

                                           Sponsoring                                                                                 Factory sales                                  Auto in service

                                                                                                               Dealership

                                 Non-auto brand cooperations

                                                                                    Internet dealer

                                          Internet OEM

                                                                                Auto shopping malls

                                          Public events

                                                                                     Closed events

                        City showrooms

                                           Brokerage

                                      Recommendations

Performed by:     OEM   Dealer     Both
                                                        © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                                                                  ,
                                                        with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                                                        member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                                                             ,
                                                        have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                                                        International.
15




     – On the manufacturer’s side, the                                                  – Above all, with regard to the
       contact details of prospective                                                     internet, with its potential for an
       customers generated from high-                                                     extremely low-cost support
       image events, the internet, or                                                     throughout the entire buying pro-
       city showrooms are not always                                                      cess, channel management is not
       recorded. This means that the                                                      optimally set up. On the websites
       link between activities promoting                                                  of both OEMs and dealers, the
       the image on one hand, and                                                         timing and quality of the response
       managing the initial contact to                                                    to a query is not always satis-
       the potential customer, is not                                                     factory. Even when the initial
       always handled properly.                                                           response is appropriate, often
                                                                                          there is no follow-up to support
     – The integration between OEMs                                                       the customer in moving forward
       and dealers is not always optimal.                                                 in his or her decision-making
       A good example of this is the                                                      process. Finally, the data which
       frequent lack of coordination in                                                   OEMs and dealers have on their
       lead management: Initial contacts                                                  websites, or which they have
       generated by the OEM are often                                                     gathered via their websites –
       either not recorded at all, or not                                                 e.g. product and customer infor-
       passed on optimally – the right                                                    mation – is shared only to a limited
       information at the right time to                                                   extent between the OEMs and
       the right person – to the dealer                                                   the dealers. Yet combining this
       for personal contact. In the other                                                 information would make the data
       direction, the OEM is not informed                                                 yet more valuable to each party.
       by the dealer about the success
       rate of the leads passed on by
       the OEM; in this way, the OEM
       cannot assess the success of his
       own lead generation.




© 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                          ,
with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                     ,
have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
International.
16 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales




4 What a multi-channel sales approach
  needs to do

                                      The study has shown that a modern                                                  ments of exclusivity and allure, thus
                                      sales approach for a company in the                                                including an appeal to the emotional
                                      automotive premium segment should                                                  motive for making a purchase.
                                      be in the form of a multi-channel
                                      system in order to make use of the                                                 The design of the point of sale must
                                      resultant advantages and synergies.                                                always contribute towards cementing
                                      These include above all the chance of                                              the customer’s perception of the brand
                                      opening up new customer fields that                                                and the associated image. On account
                                      have not yet been accessed using the                                               of the upmarket target group, an
                                      present channels. Customer satisfac-                                               atmosphere should therefore be created
                                      tion – which forms a pivotal element                                               which centres on an intensive product
                                      of customer loyalty – can, for example,                                            experience and the opportunity of active
                                      be increased in a lasting manner by                                                participation in shaping the buying
                                      employing different sales channels,                                                process. In a nutshell, this means that
                                      because these can offer services that                                              the customer should encounter a
                                      are specifically tailored to the individual                                        powerful product and service expe-
                                      customer groups.                                                                   rience at every single interaction with
                                                                                                                         the brand.
                                      Ultimately, the success of a multi-
                                      channel system is greatly dependent                                                Professor Diez exhorts that “the expe-
                                      on achieving a good “channel fit” and                                              rience when buying a car must emanate
                                      on how the business relations and the                                              from the product itself. The image
                                                                                                                                                ”
                                      customer interfaces, the so-called                                                 plays a predominant role when acquiring
                                      “customer touchpoints” can be opti-                                                new customers, because it puts the
                                      mised. The term “channel fit” is under-                                            customer in a positive mood with
                                      stood here to mean the optimum coor-                                               regard to the brand.
                                      dination of the different sales channels,
                                      whereby the focus is above all on                                                  In order to support the customer
                                      preventing cannibalistic behaviour                                                 throughout the entire life cycle and
                                      between the different channels, coor-                                              establish a lasting relationship, the
                                      dinating the activities in the market,                                             active support of the customer – i.e.
                                      and assuring a smooth flow of relevant                                             customer relationship management
                                      information. In short, “channel fit”                                               (CRM) – will become even more impor-
                                      means a success-ful process integration                                            tant in the future in terms of recording
                                      between the channels.                                                              the wishes and preferences of the
                                                                                                                         customer as well as managing the
                                      The customer contact points must there-                                            actual contact with the customer.
                                      fore be positioned such that customers
                                      at different points in the buying process                                          The increasing heterogeneity of the
                                      are made aware of the company and                                                  target group leads to the necessity
                                      its product portfolio, and can also buy                                            of having a number of different sales
                                      the products featured in the portfolio.                                            channels, or at least sales formats
                                      The interfaces at which the customer                                               available if the individual demands in
                                      is made aware of the company should,                                               the market are to be paid due justice.
                                      for the premium segment, carry ele-                                                Boe says on this subject, “In the same




                                      © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                                                ,
                                      with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                                      member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                                           ,
                                      have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                                      International.
17




way as the manufacturers have tailored      With regard to the linking of sales                                                outlets for new cars and also for used
their individual products, I think that     channels, the flow of information                                                  cars, is rated very critically by the deal-
the car showrooms will also have to         between channels plays a crucial role.                                             ers in some cases. Judged positively
rethink along these lines, because the      This applies in particular to acquiring                                            by many, but not really established as
customer is becoming more and               new customers and thus to lead                                                     yet, are the so-called automotive “shop-
more individual. And the products must      management. The customer data                                                      ping malls” The same applies to bro-
                                                                                                                                           .
be placed accordingly using a number        captured and stored in anyone of the                                               kerage and recommendations, which
of different channels.”                     channels must be managed and relayed                                               may already be a feature of sales
                                            in such a way that an optimum contact                                              systems, but are nonetheless not
A simplified segmentation already           to and support of prospective custom-                                              systematically implemented. The
exists in the car trade which divides       ers is made possible in all channels and                                           internet is currently one of the most
the customers basically into premium        in all phases of the purchase decision.                                            important instruments in the automotive
and non-premium customers. This             The diversity of sales channels demand-                                            trade, and its potential is by no means
distinction is taken into consideration     ed today is above all a result of the                                              exhausted. In addition to the above-
when setting up the channels. In a          need to generate initial contacts and to                                           mentioned optimisation potential in
similar way, different customer groups      qualify these accordingly. The acquisi-                                            lead management, exploiting all the
are addressed at events with a focus        tion of new customers harbours huge                                                technical possibilities which the internet
on either new customer acquisition or       optimisation potential and is one of                                               has to offer for the presentation of
building the relation with existing         the key tasks of the automotive trade.                                             vehicles is another area where more
customers. A fundamental observation        Splinter underlines this with his state-                                           could be done. Seidel says, “In my
can, however, be made that segmenting       ment that “ways must be found of                                                   opinion, the technical possibilities
is applied primarily in product develop-    approaching customers such that the                                                already available on the internet – for
ment and is still being neglected in        effectiveness of acquiring new cus-                                                example, those that permit the visuali-
sales. Professor Diez explains: “The        tomers can be increased.    ”                                                      sation of vehicles plus their fittings –
segmenting of product offers is helpful                                                                                        are being made far too little use of for
for the strategic orientation of product    The current status of multi-channel                                                the presentation of vehicles.   ”
policy, but this segmentation of products   sales in the premium auto segment
is totally unsuitable for marketing.”       may be summed up as follows. The
The messages to segmented customer          sales channels identified in this study
groups must be much more than simply        are all being implemented to some
the product features of the correspond-     degree within the automotive trade.
ing cars.                                   On the one hand, there is a high level
                                            of innovation to be observed, and on
Hand in hand with the use of different      the other hand, few channels are
channels, it is necessary to establish      systematically and consistently imple-
clear-cut structures which do justice to    mented across the market or within a
the increase in complexity amongst          given brand. This highly differentiated
customers. The different channels within    picture of a channel applies particularly
this structure must be coordinated          to channels shared by the OEMs and
and cross-linked such that the conflict     the dealers: sponsoring, non-auto brand
potential within an organisation is kept    cooperations, events and the internet.
low on the one hand, and that the           Above all in these channels, the
customer is supported in a comprehen-       management of leads is not optimally
sive and satisfactory manner on the         coordinated. The channel operated by
other hand.                                 the manufacturer alone, i.e. factory




                                            © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
                                                                      ,
                                            with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other
                                            member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International
                                                                                                                 ,
                                            have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG
                                            International.
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos
20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Chap016 customer retention
Chap016 customer retentionChap016 customer retention
Chap016 customer retentionHee Young Shin
 
Economics slides
Economics slidesEconomics slides
Economics slidesmokotedi
 
Investor Presentation of BMW Group 2009
Investor Presentation of BMW Group 2009Investor Presentation of BMW Group 2009
Investor Presentation of BMW Group 2009investorrelation
 
Insites on Customer Experience
Insites on Customer ExperienceInsites on Customer Experience
Insites on Customer ExperienceDominique Poncin
 
marketing mix of global business
marketing mix of global businessmarketing mix of global business
marketing mix of global businessYasir Chowdhary
 
Managing marketing in business
Managing marketing in businessManaging marketing in business
Managing marketing in businessprachimba
 
Channel design decisions mba notes world
Channel design decisions   mba notes worldChannel design decisions   mba notes world
Channel design decisions mba notes worldShah Nawaz Ansari
 
Brand Finance Global 500 2011
Brand Finance Global 500 2011Brand Finance Global 500 2011
Brand Finance Global 500 2011Nguyen Huy Toan
 
Gig case study
Gig case studyGig case study
Gig case studymleger24
 
Infosys – Block Exemption Regulation Automotive
Infosys – Block Exemption Regulation AutomotiveInfosys – Block Exemption Regulation Automotive
Infosys – Block Exemption Regulation AutomotiveInfosys
 
Principle of management
Principle of managementPrinciple of management
Principle of managementHardik Kanada
 
100901 NDR Raymond James e BTG - eua
100901   NDR Raymond James e BTG - eua100901   NDR Raymond James e BTG - eua
100901 NDR Raymond James e BTG - euaMultiplus
 
Chap002 the character of business marketing
Chap002 the character of business marketingChap002 the character of business marketing
Chap002 the character of business marketingHee Young Shin
 
Marketing Channels and Supply Chain Management
Marketing Channels and Supply Chain ManagementMarketing Channels and Supply Chain Management
Marketing Channels and Supply Chain Managementmandalina landy
 

Mais procurados (20)

Chap016 customer retention
Chap016 customer retentionChap016 customer retention
Chap016 customer retention
 
Economics slides
Economics slidesEconomics slides
Economics slides
 
Investor Presentation of BMW Group 2009
Investor Presentation of BMW Group 2009Investor Presentation of BMW Group 2009
Investor Presentation of BMW Group 2009
 
Ch08
Ch08Ch08
Ch08
 
Channels
ChannelsChannels
Channels
 
Insites on Customer Experience
Insites on Customer ExperienceInsites on Customer Experience
Insites on Customer Experience
 
marketing mix of global business
marketing mix of global businessmarketing mix of global business
marketing mix of global business
 
Pbm phase 2
Pbm phase 2Pbm phase 2
Pbm phase 2
 
Marketing Channel Structure and Functions
Marketing Channel Structure and FunctionsMarketing Channel Structure and Functions
Marketing Channel Structure and Functions
 
Managing marketing in business
Managing marketing in businessManaging marketing in business
Managing marketing in business
 
Channel design decisions mba notes world
Channel design decisions   mba notes worldChannel design decisions   mba notes world
Channel design decisions mba notes world
 
Automotive now oct-2010
Automotive now oct-2010Automotive now oct-2010
Automotive now oct-2010
 
Brand Finance Global 500 2011
Brand Finance Global 500 2011Brand Finance Global 500 2011
Brand Finance Global 500 2011
 
Gig case study
Gig case studyGig case study
Gig case study
 
Infosys – Block Exemption Regulation Automotive
Infosys – Block Exemption Regulation AutomotiveInfosys – Block Exemption Regulation Automotive
Infosys – Block Exemption Regulation Automotive
 
Principle of management
Principle of managementPrinciple of management
Principle of management
 
P&g
P&gP&g
P&g
 
100901 NDR Raymond James e BTG - eua
100901   NDR Raymond James e BTG - eua100901   NDR Raymond James e BTG - eua
100901 NDR Raymond James e BTG - eua
 
Chap002 the character of business marketing
Chap002 the character of business marketingChap002 the character of business marketing
Chap002 the character of business marketing
 
Marketing Channels and Supply Chain Management
Marketing Channels and Supply Chain ManagementMarketing Channels and Supply Chain Management
Marketing Channels and Supply Chain Management
 

Semelhante a 20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos

Automotive Aftersales - New Agression
Automotive Aftersales - New AgressionAutomotive Aftersales - New Agression
Automotive Aftersales - New AgressionNovoally Software
 
Automotive Retail Network 2014 Study - The Next Challenge Of The US Auto Indu...
Automotive Retail Network 2014 Study - The Next Challenge Of The US Auto Indu...Automotive Retail Network 2014 Study - The Next Challenge Of The US Auto Indu...
Automotive Retail Network 2014 Study - The Next Challenge Of The US Auto Indu...SL Ecommerce and ReviewsReputation.com
 
Dealer Forecasting & Evaluation Presentation
Dealer Forecasting & Evaluation PresentationDealer Forecasting & Evaluation Presentation
Dealer Forecasting & Evaluation PresentationMarkALeeser
 
Repair shop business plan
Repair shop business plan Repair shop business plan
Repair shop business plan icuevort
 
Wphab2bintgxs101707 090314225022-phpapp01
Wphab2bintgxs101707 090314225022-phpapp01Wphab2bintgxs101707 090314225022-phpapp01
Wphab2bintgxs101707 090314225022-phpapp01Shubhashish Biswas
 
Brand valuation hp
Brand valuation hpBrand valuation hp
Brand valuation hpgakarerakesh
 
Aftermarket Automotive Brand Strategies 2013 by Rahul Guhathakurta
Aftermarket Automotive Brand Strategies 2013 by Rahul GuhathakurtaAftermarket Automotive Brand Strategies 2013 by Rahul Guhathakurta
Aftermarket Automotive Brand Strategies 2013 by Rahul GuhathakurtaRahul Guhathakurta
 
DemandTec eBook: Total Trade Optimization
DemandTec eBook: Total Trade OptimizationDemandTec eBook: Total Trade Optimization
DemandTec eBook: Total Trade OptimizationIBM DemandTec
 
Business Function Administration.pptx
Business Function Administration.pptxBusiness Function Administration.pptx
Business Function Administration.pptxShivani. Naik
 
Case Analysis Of Capsim
Case Analysis Of CapsimCase Analysis Of Capsim
Case Analysis Of CapsimGina Alfaro
 
1703257 PAPER Effect of Branding on Consumer Buying Behaviour in Bharat Ford ...
1703257 PAPER Effect of Branding on Consumer Buying Behaviour in Bharat Ford ...1703257 PAPER Effect of Branding on Consumer Buying Behaviour in Bharat Ford ...
1703257 PAPER Effect of Branding on Consumer Buying Behaviour in Bharat Ford ...DR BHADRAPPA HARALAYYA
 
Week 8, Special Topics in Marketing was derived from Princip.docx
Week 8, Special Topics in Marketing was derived from Princip.docxWeek 8, Special Topics in Marketing was derived from Princip.docx
Week 8, Special Topics in Marketing was derived from Princip.docxphilipnelson29183
 
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a ThreatMarch 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a ThreatJohn Edmunds
 
Writer mak1 sample_3
Writer mak1 sample_3Writer mak1 sample_3
Writer mak1 sample_3Saad Qammar
 
Next Level Crm
Next Level CrmNext Level Crm
Next Level CrmNext Level
 
How to make sense of the abm technology landscape
How to make sense of the abm technology landscapeHow to make sense of the abm technology landscape
How to make sense of the abm technology landscapeEngagio
 

Semelhante a 20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos (20)

Ecom newsletter 13062012
Ecom newsletter 13062012Ecom newsletter 13062012
Ecom newsletter 13062012
 
Automotive Aftersales - New Agression
Automotive Aftersales - New AgressionAutomotive Aftersales - New Agression
Automotive Aftersales - New Agression
 
Automotive Retail Network 2014 Study - The Next Challenge Of The US Auto Indu...
Automotive Retail Network 2014 Study - The Next Challenge Of The US Auto Indu...Automotive Retail Network 2014 Study - The Next Challenge Of The US Auto Indu...
Automotive Retail Network 2014 Study - The Next Challenge Of The US Auto Indu...
 
Dealer Forecasting & Evaluation Presentation
Dealer Forecasting & Evaluation PresentationDealer Forecasting & Evaluation Presentation
Dealer Forecasting & Evaluation Presentation
 
Repair shop business plan
Repair shop business plan Repair shop business plan
Repair shop business plan
 
Wphab2bintgxs101707 090314225022-phpapp01
Wphab2bintgxs101707 090314225022-phpapp01Wphab2bintgxs101707 090314225022-phpapp01
Wphab2bintgxs101707 090314225022-phpapp01
 
HP Brand Valuation
HP Brand ValuationHP Brand Valuation
HP Brand Valuation
 
Brand valuation hp
Brand valuation hpBrand valuation hp
Brand valuation hp
 
Aftermarket Automotive Brand Strategies 2013 by Rahul Guhathakurta
Aftermarket Automotive Brand Strategies 2013 by Rahul GuhathakurtaAftermarket Automotive Brand Strategies 2013 by Rahul Guhathakurta
Aftermarket Automotive Brand Strategies 2013 by Rahul Guhathakurta
 
DemandTec eBook: Total Trade Optimization
DemandTec eBook: Total Trade OptimizationDemandTec eBook: Total Trade Optimization
DemandTec eBook: Total Trade Optimization
 
Business Function Administration.pptx
Business Function Administration.pptxBusiness Function Administration.pptx
Business Function Administration.pptx
 
Wipro case
Wipro caseWipro case
Wipro case
 
Case Analysis Of Capsim
Case Analysis Of CapsimCase Analysis Of Capsim
Case Analysis Of Capsim
 
1703257 PAPER Effect of Branding on Consumer Buying Behaviour in Bharat Ford ...
1703257 PAPER Effect of Branding on Consumer Buying Behaviour in Bharat Ford ...1703257 PAPER Effect of Branding on Consumer Buying Behaviour in Bharat Ford ...
1703257 PAPER Effect of Branding on Consumer Buying Behaviour in Bharat Ford ...
 
Week 8, Special Topics in Marketing was derived from Princip.docx
Week 8, Special Topics in Marketing was derived from Princip.docxWeek 8, Special Topics in Marketing was derived from Princip.docx
Week 8, Special Topics in Marketing was derived from Princip.docx
 
M3 En 03 2009 Selected Projects
M3 En 03 2009 Selected ProjectsM3 En 03 2009 Selected Projects
M3 En 03 2009 Selected Projects
 
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a ThreatMarch 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
 
Writer mak1 sample_3
Writer mak1 sample_3Writer mak1 sample_3
Writer mak1 sample_3
 
Next Level Crm
Next Level CrmNext Level Crm
Next Level Crm
 
How to make sense of the abm technology landscape
How to make sense of the abm technology landscapeHow to make sense of the abm technology landscape
How to make sense of the abm technology landscape
 

Mais de rollerballrohit8

Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierUnderstanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierrollerballrohit8
 
Revenue recognition-auto-industry
Revenue recognition-auto-industryRevenue recognition-auto-industry
Revenue recognition-auto-industryrollerballrohit8
 
Non prime-auto-underwriting
Non prime-auto-underwritingNon prime-auto-underwriting
Non prime-auto-underwritingrollerballrohit8
 
Electricvehicles austrianclimateresearch
Electricvehicles austrianclimateresearchElectricvehicles austrianclimateresearch
Electricvehicles austrianclimateresearchrollerballrohit8
 
Report auto component_market
Report auto component_marketReport auto component_market
Report auto component_marketrollerballrohit8
 
Asean automotive market final
Asean automotive market finalAsean automotive market final
Asean automotive market finalrollerballrohit8
 
Adopting electric-vehicles
Adopting electric-vehiclesAdopting electric-vehicles
Adopting electric-vehiclesrollerballrohit8
 
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierUnderstanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierrollerballrohit8
 
Kpmg's global_auto_executive_survey_2010
Kpmg's global_auto_executive_survey_2010Kpmg's global_auto_executive_survey_2010
Kpmg's global_auto_executive_survey_2010rollerballrohit8
 
New markets-cost-insight-opportunity
New markets-cost-insight-opportunityNew markets-cost-insight-opportunity
New markets-cost-insight-opportunityrollerballrohit8
 

Mais de rollerballrohit8 (12)

Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierUnderstanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
 
Revenue recognition-auto-industry
Revenue recognition-auto-industryRevenue recognition-auto-industry
Revenue recognition-auto-industry
 
Non prime-auto-underwriting
Non prime-auto-underwritingNon prime-auto-underwriting
Non prime-auto-underwriting
 
Electricvehicles austrianclimateresearch
Electricvehicles austrianclimateresearchElectricvehicles austrianclimateresearch
Electricvehicles austrianclimateresearch
 
Report auto component_market
Report auto component_marketReport auto component_market
Report auto component_market
 
Asean automotive market final
Asean automotive market finalAsean automotive market final
Asean automotive market final
 
Adopting electric-vehicles
Adopting electric-vehiclesAdopting electric-vehicles
Adopting electric-vehicles
 
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierUnderstanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
 
Momentum auto exec-2009
Momentum auto exec-2009Momentum auto exec-2009
Momentum auto exec-2009
 
Kpmg's global_auto_executive_survey_2010
Kpmg's global_auto_executive_survey_2010Kpmg's global_auto_executive_survey_2010
Kpmg's global_auto_executive_survey_2010
 
Global auto-survey-2010
Global auto-survey-2010Global auto-survey-2010
Global auto-survey-2010
 
New markets-cost-insight-opportunity
New markets-cost-insight-opportunityNew markets-cost-insight-opportunity
New markets-cost-insight-opportunity
 

20100201 multi channel sales approach for premium autos

  • 1. AUTO M OT I V E Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales
  • 2. Editorial The automotive industry in 2009 is without any doubt in the middle of one of the most serious crises it has ever experienced. The slump in sales, imminent insolvencies and significant excess capacity all combine to make it clear that revolutionary changes in this sector are on the agenda. One of the areas where such change is “waiting to happen” is automotive retail. The structures and business models for automotive marketing and sales have remained somewhat static, despite the rising heterogeneity and complexity of the buyers. A spate of developments indicate that the prerequisites for change are already present in the market, including target groups which do not feel properly addressed, low margins on the side of the dealer, high sales costs on the side of the manufacturer and an increase in intra-brand competition. Companies who introduce radical innovations within the distribution system can break out of this stagnation, and generate lasting competitive advantages for themselves. To guide this re-orientation in the automotive industry, we can take a look at other branches where radical change in the sales channels has already taken place. Following the example of these branches, we want to show in this study how the establishment of a multi-channel sales approach, with a clear and segmented sharing out of activities between the OEM and the dealers, is a strategy option for working markets comprehensively and efficiently. The complexity of customers’ requirements for purchasing cars can be met by managing an integrated range of sales channels matched to the diversity of customer segments. Many automotive companies have untapped potential in the market which could be exploited as a result of such an approach, which would then create a clear competitive advantage for them. With this study KPMG hopes to make a stimulating, if not provocative, contribution to the dialogue within the auto industry over changes in marketing and sales. I wish you good reading. Dieter Becker Managing Partner Global Head of Automotive © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 3. Table of Contents Executive Summary ..............................................................................................2 Introduction ...........................................................................................................4 Part I: Empirical Analysis.......................................................................................5 1 Twelve sales channels ......................................................................................6 2 Prospects for success and further development of sales channels...............11 Part II: Evaluation and Scenarios........................................................................13 3 Suboptimal integration of the sales channels ................................................14 4 What a multi-channel sales approach needs to do .........................................16 5 Four scenarios ................................................................................................18 Conclusion: Raising Cost Effectiveness.............................................................28 © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 4. 2 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales Executive Summary To address the wide range of individual Scenario 1 – Retail trade preferences amongst car buyers regard- ing the purchase process, this study In the business-to-consumer segment, has identified twelve separate sales the manufacturer focuses predominantly channels: on the brand image, whereas the other elements of the purchase process are 1 Sponsoring looked after by the dealer. In short, the manufacturer focuses on marketing for 2 Factory sales the end users, the dealer focuses on sales. In contrast, business customers 3 Customer contact in the context are serviced at nearly every stage by of servicing the auto the OEM. This business model is above all prominent in the markets for food 4 Dealerships and household articles. 5 Cooperations with non-auto brands such as fashion or electronics Scenario 2 – Cultivating strong brands 6 Internet website of the OEM As the owner of the brand name, the 7 Internet website of the dealer manufacturer plays a central role when it comes to cultivating the market for 8 Automotive “shopping malls” new customers. The dealer profits to a great extent from the image building 9 Events carried out by the manufacturer and his efforts with respect to canvassing new 10 City showrooms customers. This gives the dealer the space to concentrate above all on the 11 Brokering from non-auto contact to existing customers and on companies, e.g. a jeweller improving the relations management with respect to the customers already 12 Recommendations from third known to him. It is often the case with parties for new customers products backed by strong brands, such as fashion or upmarket consumer The authors of this study present four electronics, that the manufacturer culti- scenarios for customer segmentation vates the brand image and strongly and the corresponding structures/ promotes the acquisition of new cus- allocation of activities between the tomers. The dealer on the other hand OEM and the dealers in managing the concentrates in this case primarily on twelve channels accordingly. customers who are already committed to the brand. © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 5. 3 Scenario 3 – Purchase process The assessment of the success pro- Raising cost effectiveness with or without personal sales spects of the scenarios shows a clear support split on the one hand between OEMs The use of the internet as well as the and dealerships in Scenario 1, which coordinated allocation of resources in In this scenario, the manufacturer is comes closest to the current arrange- the sales channels, as provided for in responsible for customers who need ments in the auto market. each scenario, taken together result in no personal support, while the dealer an increase in cost effectiveness. Ulti- can focus his resources on his specialty, Scenario 2 on the other hand sees a mately, the internet as a sales channel i.e. exactly those customers who do functional distinction between the OEM is the most cost-efficient instrument want such support. It is possible in this and the dealerships. While OEMs handle that can be employed to communicate case to draw a parallel to the travel the overall image as well as the link relevant information and to handle sales industry where the customers can between specific product images and processes. In the medium term, how- decide whether they make their own their target groups, the primary role ever, it is not to be expected that all bookings on the internet or make use of the dealer is managing customer customers will make exclusive use of of the personal assistance offered by relations, sales and after-sales steps in the internet as a sales channel. Thus, a travel agency. the purchase process. Thus, Scenario 2 the segmented use of a range of sales seems to make the most sense for the channels, in a clearly defined sales premium segment. approach for manufacturer and dealer Scenario 4 – Product-specific alike, enables a systematic and cost- added value in the automotive Scenario 3 is the most radical departure effective use of resources. Clearly trade from the current business models, and defined fields of action, with the is based primarily on internal, i.e. cost, elimination of redundancies and the This scenario works on the premise that considerations. Within the context of exploitation of synergies, foster the the OEM establishes a specific channel Scenario 4, the OEMs would benefit development of specific competences mix via which he processes all sales from managing their own distribution and serve to raise cost effectiveness activities independently, i.e. without channels along the lines of Scenario 3, in a comprehensive manner. incorporation of the dealer. Retail bank- segmenting customers according to ing, where the “producers” (i.e. the the costs of managing them. banks) manage directly their own sales channels, is an example where product knowledge is decisive for the genera- tion of an added value in the sales pro- cess for the customer. This scenario is configured such that manufacturers in the automotive industry employ exactly their product knowledge in the same way as retail banks do, to handle the entire distribution on their own. © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 6. 4 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales Introduction This study was prepared by KPMG Structure of the study together with the International School of Management (Sebastian Waldorf, In Part I, the empirical results of the assisted by Professor Dr Ralf A. Brickau) study are presented. The twelve sales between January and April 2009. The channels identified as a result of the © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG results are based on a combination of interviews are described and evaluated. with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other desk research and discussions with In the second section of Part I, the experts. A total of eleven Managing prospects for success in managing Directors of dealerships spread over each individual channel are presented. the entire premium segment in Germany were interviewed. The empirical analy- In Part II, KPMG evaluates the empiri- sis was rounded off by discussions cal results. The suboptimal integration with experts from institutes and asso- of channels is briefly touched upon ciations such as the Institute for here. The statements arise in part from Automotive Business (IFA), Global comments made in the interviews and Insight and the German Association of in part from other market observations the Automotive Industry (VDA), as well on the part of KPMG. In the second as an expert from AutoScout24. section of Part II, the demands made Because of the different geographical on an integrated multi-channel sales locations and dealership sizes within approach are portrayed, derived from , the German premium automotive mar- the interview results and from the rele- ket, the dealers interviewed represent vant literature. In the third section of an excellent cross-section for ensuring Part II, KPMG presents four scenarios reliable results. for a multi-channel sales approach. Although the structure of the scenarios is taken from other consumer branches, , the content is derived from the inter- views. This section is summed up with International. a conclusion related to raising cost effectiveness in the car trade.
  • 7. Part I: Empirical Analysis © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 8. 6 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales 1 Twelve sales channels These days, it is possible for a premium such an event and can be approached manufacturer to market his products during its course. All-important is that via different channels and in doing so, the person who makes initial contact to address his customers in a very indi- with the customer is the one who will vidual way. The following text presents support him throughout the entire a number of these possibilities and purchase process and thus build up a integrates them later in possible sales bond. Christian Boe, Managing Director scenarios. The figure below shows of the Porsche Centre in Mannheim, what those interviewed said about sees above all considerable advantages these channels during this study. in “sponsoring an event when your own staff is on the spot and is involved The comments on the individual in the event themselves. ” channels were as follows: Factory sales Sponsoring Factory sales constitute the purest The sponsoring of events such as form of direct sales and are usually large-scale sports meetings serves only applied as part of VIP sales pro- above all to improve the image of a grammes or in the used-car business. company. Over and above this, pro- The discussions in the market have spective customers can be invited to shown, however, that these types of Figure 1: Sales channels and their evaluation Sponsoring 45 % 9% 9% 36 % Factory sales 27 % 27 % 45 % Auto in service 82 % 18 % Dealerships 91% 9% Non-auto brand cooperations 91% 9% Internet OEM 82 % 18 % Internet dealer 55 % 18 % 27 % Shopping malls 64 % 9% 18 % 9% Events 73 % 9% 9% 9% Public events 45 % 9% 18 % 27 % Closed events 73 % 9% 18 % City showrooms 73 % 27 % Brokerage 36 % 64 % Recommendations 18 % 82 % Positive Neutral Negative No mention © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 9. 7 activities by manufacturers are viewed everything in detail, whereas Roger ” as strong competition. Wilfried Hallier, Störzer, Managing Director of the Managing Director of the Porsche Porsche Centre Nuremburg, adds that Centre Hamburg North-West, com- “customers place the quality and the ments that “what manufacturers are service offered by the salesperson already practising today does not really above the visual impression of the help in a lot of sectors such as the showroom. As far as the contact to ” used-car market. ” the customer goes, Professor Willi Diez, Head of the Institute of Automotive Research, states that “selling via a Customer contact while the auto is point of sale is these days somewhat in service outdated. A lot of customers really want to be approached in a completely The time that the customer spends in different way than via the classic car the dealership waiting for his car to be showroom. But there are naturally also ” serviced, or any other form of contact other opinions: an important element with the customer in the context of here is without doubt the test drive, servicing his or her car, can be made which Roland Klement, Managing much better use of to actively approach Director of the Porsche Centre at the customer and to initiate a subse- Stuttgart Airport, still sees “as being quent purchase process. Boe, for the best sales argument and thus example, thinks that “making use of essential.” the service process to approach the customer” is an option that is not yet being exploited to a satisfactory Non-auto brand cooperations degree. With respect to contacting potential customers, cooperating with firms from Dealerships outside the industry was repeatedly broached in the discussions during this The traditional car dealership in its cur- study. Christoph Käding, Managing rent form is designed to cover different Director of Bach Premium Cars, says process steps, namely customer rela- that “joint ventures are perfectly feasible tions, sales and service. Generally and are gaining an increasing amount speaking, it must also be ensured that of attention, whereby it’s all about the corporate image is communicated developing a concept together with an and represented at exactly this cus- interesting partner. In this particular ” tomer contact point. Manfred Seidel, case, the joint activity was with the Executive Director Sales Germany at manufacturer of private yachts in his AutoScout24, the used-car internet showroom in order to approach a com- sales platform, says that “the dealer mon clientele. Boe agrees and sees must be in a position to serve both the possibilities “in both directions, i.e. internet-savvy customer as well as the both in a car showroom, in order to senior citizen who wants to be shown increase the customer frequency, as © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 10. 8 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales well as on the partner’s premises. As ” Internet dealers for gaining new customers in the pro- cess, Hallier says: “We invite the manu- In comparison with manufacturers, facturers of premium brands to the dealers can display their products on Porsche Centre to present their prod- their website in a targeted manner and ucts on our premises, and we acquire can initiate the sales process there new customers for ourselves in this and then, and can also communicate way. By the same token, Störzer says: ” directly with a customer. The internet “Joint ventures with other premium is absolutely ideal for the used-car products are great provided that the business, and will become increasingly partner is the right one. I can also important in the future. Peter Kraft, envisage exhibiting our brand in the Managing Director of the Porsche showrooms of another premium brand. ” Centre in Lörrach, says that there are two sides to this coin: “On the one hand, I can take an exotic car in part Internet OEM payment because the marketplace for this car is the world. But on the The website of an OEM today serves other hand, the best-price shopper mainly to convey the image, whereas need not buy in his immediate vicinity, the acquisition of customer contacts but can rather purchase anywhere he and their transmission via this medium likes. Sascha Heiden, Senior Market ” will play a much greater role in the Analyst at Global Insight, also says future. In this context, Seidel says that that “the internet will in future become “the internet will become the lead an increasingly important sales channel channel to the dealer in the future.” above all in the used-car trade. ” Jürgen Niemuth, Managing Director of the Porsche Centre Munich South, makes a fundamental observation in Automotive “shopping malls” this context: “Internet has changed so many things. Even before coming to The spatial positioning of different the car showroom, the customer brands at one location is generally seen informs himself thoroughly. And when as being positive, provided that the he gets there, he usually only wants overall presentation has an exclusive to know how much the car costs and flair. Splinter, Managing Director of how soon he can have it. People simply the Porsche Centre Berlin-Potsdam, have so many more possibilities with for example, feels that “consolidating the internet. For our part, however, this different brands makes sense because trend means that we are often deprived the presence of the right brands makes of the opportunity of having a real it possible to generate a higher cus- sales discussion. ” tomer flow. Störzer sees the advantage ” above all in the fact that “the customer can get a good overall idea of the entire market without having to go far, whereas there were some other ” © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 11. 9 interview partners who rejected such parties serves primarily to enhance the models on principle. image of the company as well as to generate initial contacts. Professor Diez says: “One has to go to the customer Events these days and not the other way around. It is immensely important to With regard to the possibility of using present oneself at highly frequented events within the sales system, a locations and to try to go wherever distinction must be made between there is traffic rather than trying to public events, those organised by third generate the traffic oneself. A road parties and closed events. Whereas show in the centre of town, for example, public events include, for instance, the is a good way to create a point of presentation of cars in city centres, interest, whereby such an event must those organised by third parties can be always provide the possibility of taking exhibitions and sports events. Closed a test drive. ” events usually take place in the car showroom itself or on the premises Closed events of a joint venture partner. In a further Closed events serve more to cultivate step, according to Käding, “the events customer relationships and thus customer are split into two groups, namely those loyalty, although once the customer that concentrate on acquiring new leads have been reliably qualified, there customers and those that serve to is nothing standing in the way of a enhance the loyalty of existing custom- successful contact to new customers ers. Boe confirms the effectiveness ” via closed events. For Hallier “these of such events, because “to my mind, events are above all an important topic selling is no different to customer rela- because we frequently attempt to tions management. Whoever succeeds acquire new customers at them. Peer ” in creating a good atmosphere will find Kraack, Head of Sales Porsche Centre it easier to make a sale. Hallier adds ” Limburg, says that “open driving days that “above all, themed concepts are are encouraged because an extremely important in order to create a bond high rate – higher than that known from with customers. As mentioned earlier, ” normal test drives – can be achieved in there is also the possibility of cooperat- terms of making sales. ” ing with other companies. “What is new is that we are hitching up to other premium brands and that we are trying City showrooms to make contact with the target group via these joint activities. ” The positioning of showrooms in downtown areas encountered a wide Public events and those organised range of reactions by those who took by third parties part in the study. Whereas some of The organisation of public events or those interviewed argue against a the integration of one’s own presen- concept that is restricted purely to the tation in an event organised by third presentation of vehicles and Boe © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 12. 10 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales questions the cost efficiency, Störzer Brokerage Recommendations sees this concept as being very effec- tive, although “these lighthouse projects The concept of brokerage is that firms Comparable with the concept of bro- should only be seen as a lead channel from other sectors refer their customers kerage are recommendations, where a to the car showrooms; the business to the dealership or the manufacturer third party gives a potential customer must remain with the local dealer. ” and receive a quid pro quo in return. the opportunity of taking a test drive, He also says, “In principle, I would like Splinter believes that “there should be for example, in order to bring him into to see such a showroom in every large a concept which provides for brokering contact with the brand, thereby upgrad- city, although this is not something the customers on a commission basis. ing his own products or services in the dealers can shoulder but is rather the Conceivable here would be a coopera- process. Or an existing customer could responsibility of the manufacturers. ” tion with upmarket jewellers, for exam- recommend a friend as a potential Other interviewees also see a clear ple. Boe, too, sees the possibility of ” customer in return for, e.g., a branded benefit, but one that is nonetheless cooperating with “exclusive travel present. Kraack sees “such ’tickets-for- countered by high costs. But when it agencies who function as independent a-friend’ concepts as an innovation comes specifically to “the introduction brokers.” which can be judged as extremely of new products” and “the acquisition promising in cooperation with selected of new customers” everybody can , partners.” see a clear advantage. © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 13. 11 2 Prospects for success and further development of sales channels The automotive trade is currently at a customer relations and sales and service. point at which the companies need to The sales approach must at all costs be take fundamental structural decisions supplemented by further channels, in order to secure their competitive because although this business model positions in the long term. Today’s busi- may form the core of the sales activities, ness model and the 12 channels identi- the customer does not necessarily fied in this study reveal a host of areas want to visit the car showroom in all where the potential for optimisation is phases of the purchasing decision pro- present, in particular for generating cess, but may well expect an active new customer contacts, lead manage- approach in a different environment. ment and the used-car business. Under the premise that the “experience” when As far as contact to potential customers buying a car must still primarily originate goes, the topic of cooperating with from the product itself, the test drive companies external to the industry is still one of the most important ele- was raised repeatedly during the course ments of the sales process, whereby of the study and was assigned a open driving days and road shows are correspondingly high success potential. also gaining importance. In this connection, the potential for brokerage and recommendations can With regard to service, it is clear that also be rated highly. customer demands have risen markedly and the time that the customer spends Besides an increase in activities asso- at, or at least in contact with, the service ciated with used cars, the internet will unit should be used more intensively play a major role in the future above all for communication. In this connection, in the acquisition of customer contacts it is furthermore clear that a shared and their direct transmission to the location for sales and service has relevant sales units. In the medium advantages. term, however, and at least for the major part of the target group amongst The start of a customer relationship can private customers, the internet will not take place anything up to two years establish itself as the sales channel. before the actual sale. At the moment, This is, however, conceivable in the however, the customer is barely being domain of business customers. taken notice of at this time, meaning that the possibility of an early bond to The significance of events is on the the brand is not being exploited. rise, and will continue into the future. Already today, events display a high The traditional car showroom in its cur- effectiveness when they are properly rent form is designed primarily to cover organised, because they build on the © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 14. 12 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales point that “sales” is basically nothing The scenarios presented later in this more than pure relations management. study use exactly these insights and Whoever is capable of creating a good show how an OEM together with a atmosphere will have success in this dealer can work the market in the future. area. They can segment the customers accordingly and combine the channels One overall aim is to present oneself at in order to increase the effectiveness highly frequented locations and to use and thus the profitability within the the traffic that is already available instead entire sales system, and increase of expending one’s own resources to customer satisfaction at the same time. generate exactly that. In this context, public events are viewed positively, without any clear statements being made on their sustainability as a sales channel. The views on showrooms in highly frequented regions vary, because in spite of a principled endorsement, the cost aspect constitutes a strong counterargument. © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 15. Part II Evaluation and Scenarios © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 16. 14 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales 3 Suboptimal integration of sales channels The current positioning and manage- • A closely meshed coordination ment of sales channels is shown in the between the channels or between table below. the phases in the buying process does not always take place. This Drawing on its own experience within has several aspects: the market, KPMG advances the follow- ing statements: – In the dealerships, it is often the case that customer contact while • There are many overlaps in the chan- the auto is in service is not always nels operated by the manufacturers managed properly as a further and dealers. This redundant use of sales contact, e.g. the salesperson resources is inefficient. does not always greet the cus- tomer personally when he brings • The channels are not directed his car in for a service, or the systematically towards a specific service contact is not used as a phase in the buying process, but chance to collect the thoughts of rather are broadly designed to serve the customer about purchasing several purposes. This means that the next car. Another example of the channels are not focused on a lack of coordination within the achieving clearly targeted objectives dealership is, customer contacts in the sales process. With an orien- from dealer events are not always tation towards vague and diversified followed up properly within the objectives, the effectiveness of the customer relationship manage- channels necessarily suffers as a ment system (CRM). result. Figure 2: Sales channel management in the premium auto market today Image First contact Further contacts Sales Service Sponsoring Factory sales Auto in service Dealership Non-auto brand cooperations Internet dealer Internet OEM Auto shopping malls Public events Closed events City showrooms Brokerage Recommendations Performed by: OEM Dealer Both © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 17. 15 – On the manufacturer’s side, the – Above all, with regard to the contact details of prospective internet, with its potential for an customers generated from high- extremely low-cost support image events, the internet, or throughout the entire buying pro- city showrooms are not always cess, channel management is not recorded. This means that the optimally set up. On the websites link between activities promoting of both OEMs and dealers, the the image on one hand, and timing and quality of the response managing the initial contact to to a query is not always satis- the potential customer, is not factory. Even when the initial always handled properly. response is appropriate, often there is no follow-up to support – The integration between OEMs the customer in moving forward and dealers is not always optimal. in his or her decision-making A good example of this is the process. Finally, the data which frequent lack of coordination in OEMs and dealers have on their lead management: Initial contacts websites, or which they have generated by the OEM are often gathered via their websites – either not recorded at all, or not e.g. product and customer infor- passed on optimally – the right mation – is shared only to a limited information at the right time to extent between the OEMs and the right person – to the dealer the dealers. Yet combining this for personal contact. In the other information would make the data direction, the OEM is not informed yet more valuable to each party. by the dealer about the success rate of the leads passed on by the OEM; in this way, the OEM cannot assess the success of his own lead generation. © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 18. 16 Multi-Channel Sales Approach for Premium Autos: Raising Cost Effectiveness in Marketing and Sales 4 What a multi-channel sales approach needs to do The study has shown that a modern ments of exclusivity and allure, thus sales approach for a company in the including an appeal to the emotional automotive premium segment should motive for making a purchase. be in the form of a multi-channel system in order to make use of the The design of the point of sale must resultant advantages and synergies. always contribute towards cementing These include above all the chance of the customer’s perception of the brand opening up new customer fields that and the associated image. On account have not yet been accessed using the of the upmarket target group, an present channels. Customer satisfac- atmosphere should therefore be created tion – which forms a pivotal element which centres on an intensive product of customer loyalty – can, for example, experience and the opportunity of active be increased in a lasting manner by participation in shaping the buying employing different sales channels, process. In a nutshell, this means that because these can offer services that the customer should encounter a are specifically tailored to the individual powerful product and service expe- customer groups. rience at every single interaction with the brand. Ultimately, the success of a multi- channel system is greatly dependent Professor Diez exhorts that “the expe- on achieving a good “channel fit” and rience when buying a car must emanate on how the business relations and the from the product itself. The image ” customer interfaces, the so-called plays a predominant role when acquiring “customer touchpoints” can be opti- new customers, because it puts the mised. The term “channel fit” is under- customer in a positive mood with stood here to mean the optimum coor- regard to the brand. dination of the different sales channels, whereby the focus is above all on In order to support the customer preventing cannibalistic behaviour throughout the entire life cycle and between the different channels, coor- establish a lasting relationship, the dinating the activities in the market, active support of the customer – i.e. and assuring a smooth flow of relevant customer relationship management information. In short, “channel fit” (CRM) – will become even more impor- means a success-ful process integration tant in the future in terms of recording between the channels. the wishes and preferences of the customer as well as managing the The customer contact points must there- actual contact with the customer. fore be positioned such that customers at different points in the buying process The increasing heterogeneity of the are made aware of the company and target group leads to the necessity its product portfolio, and can also buy of having a number of different sales the products featured in the portfolio. channels, or at least sales formats The interfaces at which the customer available if the individual demands in is made aware of the company should, the market are to be paid due justice. for the premium segment, carry ele- Boe says on this subject, “In the same © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.
  • 19. 17 way as the manufacturers have tailored With regard to the linking of sales outlets for new cars and also for used their individual products, I think that channels, the flow of information cars, is rated very critically by the deal- the car showrooms will also have to between channels plays a crucial role. ers in some cases. Judged positively rethink along these lines, because the This applies in particular to acquiring by many, but not really established as customer is becoming more and new customers and thus to lead yet, are the so-called automotive “shop- more individual. And the products must management. The customer data ping malls” The same applies to bro- . be placed accordingly using a number captured and stored in anyone of the kerage and recommendations, which of different channels.” channels must be managed and relayed may already be a feature of sales in such a way that an optimum contact systems, but are nonetheless not A simplified segmentation already to and support of prospective custom- systematically implemented. The exists in the car trade which divides ers is made possible in all channels and internet is currently one of the most the customers basically into premium in all phases of the purchase decision. important instruments in the automotive and non-premium customers. This The diversity of sales channels demand- trade, and its potential is by no means distinction is taken into consideration ed today is above all a result of the exhausted. In addition to the above- when setting up the channels. In a need to generate initial contacts and to mentioned optimisation potential in similar way, different customer groups qualify these accordingly. The acquisi- lead management, exploiting all the are addressed at events with a focus tion of new customers harbours huge technical possibilities which the internet on either new customer acquisition or optimisation potential and is one of has to offer for the presentation of building the relation with existing the key tasks of the automotive trade. vehicles is another area where more customers. A fundamental observation Splinter underlines this with his state- could be done. Seidel says, “In my can, however, be made that segmenting ment that “ways must be found of opinion, the technical possibilities is applied primarily in product develop- approaching customers such that the already available on the internet – for ment and is still being neglected in effectiveness of acquiring new cus- example, those that permit the visuali- sales. Professor Diez explains: “The tomers can be increased. ” sation of vehicles plus their fittings – segmenting of product offers is helpful are being made far too little use of for for the strategic orientation of product The current status of multi-channel the presentation of vehicles. ” policy, but this segmentation of products sales in the premium auto segment is totally unsuitable for marketing.” may be summed up as follows. The The messages to segmented customer sales channels identified in this study groups must be much more than simply are all being implemented to some the product features of the correspond- degree within the automotive trade. ing cars. On the one hand, there is a high level of innovation to be observed, and on Hand in hand with the use of different the other hand, few channels are channels, it is necessary to establish systematically and consistently imple- clear-cut structures which do justice to mented across the market or within a the increase in complexity amongst given brand. This highly differentiated customers. The different channels within picture of a channel applies particularly this structure must be coordinated to channels shared by the OEMs and and cross-linked such that the conflict the dealers: sponsoring, non-auto brand potential within an organisation is kept cooperations, events and the internet. low on the one hand, and that the Above all in these channels, the customer is supported in a comprehen- management of leads is not optimally sive and satisfactory manner on the coordinated. The channel operated by other hand. the manufacturer alone, i.e. factory © 2009 KPMG Europe LLP a UK limited liability partnership, is a holding company of a number ofmembers of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated , with KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative. KPMG Europe LLP and KPMG International provide no client services. No KPMG Europe LLP subsidiary or other member firm has any authority to obligate or bind KPMG Europe LLP KPMG International or any other member firm vis-à-vis third parties, nor does KPMG International , have any such authority to obligate or bind any member firm. All rights reserved. Printed in Germany. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.