1. Spencer woke up in Toby’s bed, it was dark outside. She turned around,
but Toby wasn’t in bed. She grabbed her phone from the desk. ONE
NEW MESSAGE flickered in bright white letters. The light hurt her eyes.
Shocking truth –A
Spencer had no idea what the message meant, but she was sure she
would find out soon enough. She jumped off the bed, still wearing the
dark blue dress. She slowly walked downstairs. There was a light on in
the living room. There were 2 voices.
‘’ You need to stop seeing Spencer ‘’ Jenna said with her creepy voice.
‘’ You can’t tell me what to do Jenna. And what if I did, what’s in it for
you? ‘’ Toby asked.
‘’ I will have you for just myself ‘’ Spencer peeked from the corner and
she saw Jenna laughing. She accidentally dropped her phone.
‘’ Ah, someone is very curious. Spencer. ‘’ Jenna said. Spencer
appeared from behind the corner.
‘’ Stop seeing Toby ‘’ Jenna said. Spencer looked at her and could see
her own reflection in her black glasses.
‘’ What if I don’t? Are you going to kill me like you killed Alison? ‘’
The grin on Jenna’s face dissapeared.
‘’ I did not kill that bitch, she deserved what over come her. ‘’ Jenna said
she practically spit into Spencer’s face.
‘’ You can fool everyone else, but not me. ‘’ Spencer almost yelled.
Jenna passed Spencer and they heard her slam the door.
‘’ Come here ‘’ Toby said and hugged her tight.
‘’ Wake up! ‘’ Spencer heard 3 voices saying. She slowly opened her
eyes, she was in her own bed now.
Emily, Hanna and Aria were standing in her room.
They each put them papers on her bed.
‘’ What is that? ‘’ Spencer asked and yawned.
She looked through the papers. ‘’ I think it’s some kind of a game. ‘’
Emily said and showed her the paper she got from A.
‘’ 1- Once you’re in you can’t go back. 2- Don’t you dare to lie.
3- Don’t forget you’re in this together, if one of you gets hurt all of you
get hurt. 4- Be ready to learn the shocking truth. 5- Let the game begin.’’
Spencer read. They all shared a look. Hanna’s phone beeped.
‘’ The game has begun liars, make sure nobody follows or sees you.
Check the front door. –A ‘’ Hanna read out loud. ‘’ I’ll be right back ‘’ She
finished. Hanna walked the room out. ‘’ I don’t want to play this game! ‘’
Emily whispered. Scared that someone in the house would hear her.
‘’ We are in. We can’t go back ‘’ Aria replied. Just a minute later Hanna
was back with a bag of pills in her hand.
‘’ Make sure they sleep -A ‘’ Hanna read and showed them the bag.

2. Spencer’s phone vibrated in her hand.
‘’ Don’t tell Toby what you’re going to do. You know what I’m capable of.
–A ‘’ Spencer read. Spencer looked at Hanna, who was still looking at
the pills. ‘’ Are we supposed to give Melissa these? ‘’ Aria asked. Emily
nodded. ‘’ No! We don’t even know what it is. For all we know it could
be drugs! ‘’ Spencer added.
‘’ We have no choice ‘’ Aria replied. Spencer grabbed the pills out of
Hanna’s hand and she walked downstairs. The others followed her.
Spencer took a plate and a knife. She placed one pill on the place and
cut it into little pieces. Aria poured coffee in a glass. Spencer put the
little pieces of pill in the coffee. ‘’ Let the game begin ‘’ Spencer quoted.
‘’ Is she sleeping? ‘’ Emily asked when Spencer finally came downstairs.
Spencer nodded her head. ‘’ Toby’s turn ‘’ Aria said. She knew exactly
how bad it hurt her. The person she’d never lied to, she didn’t want to lie
to, but it was the only option. ‘’ I can’t do it. ‘’ Spencer whispered. She
was trying so hard not to cry. Hanna put her arm around Spencer.
‘’ I know it hurts. I really do. But do you prefer him to get hurt? ‘’
Spencer shook her head. ‘’ I’ll do it. ‘’ Hanna said.
Spencer looked out of the window. Waiting for Hanna to come
back from Toby’s. She had been there for over an hour. ‘’ I wonder what
we’ll find out. ‘’ Aria said. Just then the Cavanaugh’s door opened.
Hanna walked her way over to the Hastings’. ‘’ Is he OK? ‘’ Spencer
asked. ‘’ I checked he’s sleeping. ‘’ Spencer sat down on the couch and
put her hand in fron of her face. ‘’ It’s going to be allright, Spence ‘’
Emily tried to comfort her. They heard Aria’s phone ringing.
‘’ Now you have to go to the Hastings’ barn and find Ian’s camera. Good
luck, bitches. –A ‘’ Aria read out loud. ‘’ I’ve looked a thousand times
through his stuff, I never found a camera. ‘’ Spencer said confused.
‘’ Come on let’s just go ‘’ Hanna replied.
Nothing. They couldn’t find anything. Spencer knew this barn, they
looked everywhere. The camera wasn’t there. Aria walked over a carpet
and the floor cracked. ‘’ Look ‘’ Aria said and moved the carpet. It was
something like a secret doorway. She pulled the iron handle.
‘’ Found it! ‘’ Aria yelled. The camera was covered in dust. Emily opened
the camera. There was nothing they hadn’t seen before. The video
when Ian and Alison were at the kissing rock, and some videos of Ian
trying to sing, which he really couldn’t do. But then they saw the church,
where Ian tried to kill Spencer. There were police cars everywhere.
Someone put Ian down on the ground. The camera was focused on his
face. Suddenly his eyes opened and he laughed. Then all what they
saw was black. ‘’ Oh my god! ‘’ Hanna gasped. ‘’ Next Emily’s phone
beeped. ‘’ Last task liars. Visit Ian Thomas in Rosewood Memorial. –A’’
Emily read. ‘’ Oh no. It’s dark outside. I am not going to a graveyard! ‘’
Aria yelled. ‘’ We have to Aria. ‘’ Emily responded.
‘’ You ready? ‘’ Hanna asked before they entered the graveyard. They

3. all nodded their heads. ‘’ Where’s Ian’s grave? ‘’ Aria whispered.
‘’ Look! ‘’ Spencer said. ALISON DILAURENTIS was written in beautiful
letters. They all stared at her grave. There were roses and they were
new. Jason was visiting her every day and brought roses.
‘’ You know, she was a real bitch. But sometimes I miss her ‘’ Hanna
almost cried. ‘’ Yeah, she was the best frenemy. ‘’ Emily added.
‘’ Guys, ‘’ Aria said and pointed to Ian’s grave. They ran towards it.
‘’ Holy crap! ‘’ Hanna yelled. The grave was open and empty.
‘’ What the hell, this can’t be! ‘’ Emily added.
‘’ Ian’s alive? ‘’ Spencer’s voice was shaking.
Hanna grabbed her phone from her pocket.
‘’ the shocking truth. Now close the grave ‘’ -A
Spencer’s whole body was covered in dirt. They had to close the grave,
they had no choice. A would trick them again and the police would now
we were there. And again they would be murder suspects, not just in
Alison’s investigation also in Ian’s. ‘’ Toby ‘’ she whispered. Spencer ran
over to the Cavanaugh’s. She was lucky Jenna wasn’t home or his
parents. He was sleeping on the couch, in peace. She lay down next to
him and put her arm around Toby. ‘’ I am so sorry ‘’ Spencer whispered.
Cold fingers were stroking her cheek. She knew she was in
heaven. Nobody had touched her that gentle. Her eyes slowly opened.
‘’ Good morning ‘’ Spencer said and yawned. Toby smiled.
‘’ I have to ask you something. ‘’ Toby said. His ocean blue eyes bore
into her soul. ‘’ Why did Hanna put sleeping pills into my coffee? ‘’
Spencer froze. How did he know that Hanna put pills into his coffee?
She didn’t know what to say. ‘’ Did you know that? ‘’ Spencer couldn’t lie
again. She slowly nodded her head. ‘’ Why? Why did you do that? ‘’
Toby asked confused. Her body temperature went up in seconds.
‘’ Spencer, don’t lie to me. ‘’ She was tried not to have eye contact with
him, because she knew she would break if she did. But lying wasn’t the
choice. ‘’ A made me do it. ‘’ Her voice was shaking. ‘’ A made you do
it? ‘’ Toby said. ‘’ They made us play a game. I couldn’t tell anyone, not
even you. If I wouldn’t put those pills in your coffee they would hurt
you.’’ Spencer looked down at the ground. ‘’ How could you not tell me?
Spencer, we’re supposed to be open to each other. What game? ‘’
‘’ Ian is probably not dead. ‘’ Spencer said just loud enough that Toby
could hear it. ‘’ What? What do you mean Ian is alive? ‘’
‘’ A made us go to his grave, it was open and empty. ‘’
‘’ How could you not tell me? You keep lying to me and you put sleeping
pills into my coffee! ‘’ Spencer’s eyes filled with tears.
‘’ Why don’t you trust me? ‘’ The last sentence made her cry. She did
trust him, with all her heart. ‘’ You don’t understand. I trust you. I trust
you more than anyone. I love you. What if someone threatened you to
hurt me? You would have done the same! ‘’ Toby sat down on the
couch and put his hand in front of his face. He sighed. ‘’ You’re right. I’m

4. sorry. But you have to promise me, no matter what you will tell me. I
have to protect you not the other way around. ‘’ Spencer put her head
on his shoulder. She kissed his neck. ‘’ I promise ‘’ she whispered into
his ear. ‘’ I think you should get a shower ‘’ Toby laughed.
‘’ Mind if I take one here? ‘’ Spencer asked. ‘’ Not at all. ‘’
Spencer took his hand and stood up. He knew exactly what she meant.
She walked towards the living room and stopped before they entered it.
Spencer pressed her lips against Toby’s. They walked into the
bathroom, still kissing. Toby opened the water. She slowly pulled his
shirt off. She threw it somewhere outside. Toby unbuttoned her wet shirt
and let it fall down her back. He went through her hair with his fingers.
Toby pushed Spencer’s body against the white tiles. The tiles were ice
cold against her hot skin. Toby kissed her neck. Spencer placed her
hand on his chest. His abs were like stone.
‘’ I can’t believe that Ian is… ‘’ Emily began. ‘’ alive? ‘’ Hanna finished
her sentence. ‘’ He isn’t, come one guys. A is messing with us ‘’ Aria
whispered the last part. Spencer had just a bad habit, biting her nails
every time she’s nevous. ‘’ I know someone who maybe could help us. ‘’
Spencer added to the conversation. She could only think of one person.
Jason DiLaurentis.
Spencer was standing in front of the big house. She could
obviously not ask if Ian wasn’t dead or not, it wouldn’t make any sense if
he wasn’t A. She took a deep breath and walked up the DiLaurentis’
porch. She streched her arm out and knocked on the wooden door.
Just a second later the door opened. ‘’ Spencer, ‘’ his voice sounded
surprised. Yeah, he was not the only one. Spencer would have never
thought that she would ask Jason for a favor. ‘’ Glad you came, come
on in ‘’ He said and moved his body so Spencer could come in.
‘’ Thanks ‘’ Spencer smiled.
‘’ I have to ask you something ‘’
‘’ Sure, anything ‘’ Jason replied. How would she even begin? What
should she ask first? About N.A.T or Ian?
‘’ What was the N.A.T club? ‘’ That sentence slipped out of her mouth.
Jason’s face turned red. He sat down on the couch and rubed his hands
together. ‘’ We, Ian, Garret and I used to spy on girls. Trust me I am not
proud of that. ‘’ Spencer was surprised at how honest he was.
‘’ We kind of fell apart, though. I really can’t believe Ian is dead. He was
like my best budd. ‘’ Spencer was actually feeling sorry for him. He
wasn’t a creep, Jason was just misunderstood. Just like Toby. Now she
couldn’t imagine living without him.
‘’ Do you really think he’s dead? ‘’ Spencer asked. She sounded crazy.
‘’ You found his body right? How could he be alive? ‘’ He was right.
They had found his body. He was dead, he wasn’t breathing nothing.
‘’ Garett? ‘’ Spencer asked. ‘’ what happened to him? ‘’

5. Jason sighed. ‘’ Well, he wanted to continue. Still spying on girls when
they were changing and stuff. But Ian and I thought that it was stupid,
we kinda grew up. ‘’ He sounded so sad. Spencer phone vibrated in her
pocket. Melissa had texted her.
Come home –Melissa
‘’ Something wrong? ‘’ Jason asked.
‘’ It’s just Melissa, she wants me to come home. ‘’ Spencer stood up.
‘’ Thank you ‘’ She said. ‘’ You’re welcome. You can by anytime. ‘’
Spencer walked out of the house and went to the Hastings just across.
‘’ Melissa? I’m home. ‘’ Spencer yelled when she walked the house in.
‘’ Melissa are you here? ‘’ She clearly wasn’t, but why did she text her to
come home? Spencer walked to the living room and put her scarf and
bag on the couch. The ground began to creak, the thing was Spencer
wasn’t walking. ‘’ Melissa? ‘’ Spencer said once again. ‘’ Toby? ‘’
Nobody answered. Spencer walked to the kitchen to get coffee as
usual. She looked up and saw a man, black hair, brown eyes, tall.
Wearing a blue shirt with a black jacket and jeans. Her heart stopped
beating, she couldn’t believe what she was seeing. ‘’ Miss me? ‘’ The
heavy voice said. ‘’ You’re not dead. ‘’ Spencer’s voice was shaking.
Her hands were shaking. She barely could stand on her legs. ‘’ But you
already knew that. ‘’ Ian slowly walked towards Spencer. Every step he
set forward Spencer set a step backwards. ‘’ What do you want? ‘’
Spencer tried to sound confident but she failed every single time. ‘’ You
can’t tell anyone, that I am alive. And I wanted to make sure that you
won’t ‘’ Ian took a knife from the drawer. ‘’ There’s one way to make
sure you won’t ‘’ He looked at the knife and smiled. ‘’ Ian, don’t please. ‘’
Spencer almost cried. ‘’ I am sorry, Spencer. I have no other choice. ‘’
Spencer turned around and ran the stairs up, but Ian grabbed her leg.
She fell down on the stairs. She tried to kick him with her free leg. But
she was too weak. ‘’ Let go off me! ‘’ Spencer yelled. Ian slid her
between his legs.
‘’ What the hell are you doing? ‘’ Spencer yelled again. ‘’ I’ve been
waiting to do this for a long time ‘’ Ian kissed her neck. ‘’ Are you crazy?
Stop it! ‘’ She used all her energy. At last she succeeded and kicked in
his stomach with her leg. He fell down the stairs. Spencer ran the stairs
up, to her room. She locked the door and ran through her hair with her
fingers. She felt in her pockets, but then she realized that her phone
was in her bag, which was on the couch downstairs. She looked
through the keyhole. Ian wasn’t there. Maybe he was gone. She had to
try to get her phone, though. She slowly unlocked the door, so he
wouldn’t hear her. Her heart was beating so fast that it probably could
break a rib. He wasn’t standing in the hall, he wasn’t on the ground
downstairs. Maybe he was gone. She slowly walked downstairs to the

6. living room. She grabbed her bag and searched for her phone. But then
she felt a warm hand on her shoulder. Spencer abruptly turned around.
Her face was just inches away from Ian’s. She held her breath and
walked backwards. Her feet hit the table. ‘’ What do you want from
me?’’ Spencer's voice was shaking. Ian walked closer to her, Spencer had
nowhere to go. " Nobody can save you " He whispered. There was a huge
grin on his face. He pressed his lips against hers. ' No!" Spencer yelled and
punched him in his face. He pushed Spencer on the ground, but when he did
the knife cut Spencer's wrist. Blood drops fell on the ground. He grabbed her
both hands with one. He looked at her and smiled. Her wrist was hurting
badly. The blood dropped of Ian's arm on the floor. Ian started kissing her
neck and jaws. " Stop it, please " Spencer cried. He started unbuttoning her
shirt. " Spencer Hastings commited suicide " Ian said and cut her other wrist.
Spencer yelled out of pain. " Stop! " The whole floor was covered in blood.
Everything became dark. He threw her shirt somewhere in the living room. He
continued kissing her neck. She couldn't do anything, she was too weak. But
then there was light. Toby. He grabbed Ian and punched him. Her belly her
whole body was covered in her own blood. She heard someone running
away, probably Ian. She heard Toby talking on the phone.
" Spencer! " Toby yelled. Even when she was dying his voice, his thouch, his
eyes made her question what in hell she did to deserve him. Her eyes were
closing slowly. " Stay with me! Spencer, don't leave me!" He yelled. He
grabbed a towel from the kitchen and pressed it against her wrists to stop the
bleeding. " Keep your eyes open. " His hands were covered in her blood, but
he didn't care. He had to save her. Last words before everything went dark
came out of her mouth. " I love you "