SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 133
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.




                 Patent Technology Evaluation and Evidence-of-Use Investigation

                                                         for

                                               US Patent 5662768

                                       Assignee: LSI Logic Corporation

                Title: “High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device”


                                        File date: September 21, 1995
                                        Issue date September 2, 1997

                                          Report Date: June 20, 2010
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                               Table of Contents                                                     Page #
Patent Technology Evaluation and Evidence-of-Use Investigation                                                          1
Table of Contents and Figures                                                                                         2-3
Introduction/Objective                                                                                                  4
Summary of Final Results                                                                                              4-7
Patent Technology Evaluation                                                                                         8 - 17
Introduction/Objective
Summary of Results                                                                                                      9
Discussion                                                                                                           10 - 17
Evidence of Use Study - Part 1: Focused Citation Analysis                                                            18 - 24
Introduction/Objective                                                                                                 19
Summary of Results                                                                                                     20
Discussion                                                                                                           21 - 24
Evidence of Use Study - Part 2: Technology Claim Diagrams                                                           25 - 168
Introduction/Objective                                                                                                 26
Summary of Results                                                                                                     26
Discussion                                                                                                          27 - 168
Evidence-of-Use Study - Part 3: Patent Technology Utilization Research and Analysis                                169 - 188
Introduction/Objective                                                                                              170 - 171
Summary of Results                                                                                                  172 - 175
Discussion                                                                                                          176 - 188
References and Patent Links                                                                                         189 - 191
                                                                                                                                2
        IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                              List of Figures                                                     Figures #
Preferred Embodiments of Invention                                                                                     1
Second Embodiment of Invention                                                                                         2
Third Embodiment of Invention                                                                                          3
Independent Claims Analysis – Claims 1, 15, 20                                                                         4
Independent Claims Analysis – Claims 24, 27, 33                                                                        5
Patent Groups reviewed and analyzed                                                                                    6
Final Working Group Assignees                                                                                          7
Table illustrating the top Groups 1 - 3 References                                                                     8
Chart illustrating the top Groups 1 - 3 References                                                                     9
Chart illustrating the top Groups 1 - 2 References                                                                    10
Technology Claim Diagrams                                                                                          11 - 151




      IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606                  3
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.


                                                Introduction/Objective

A Patent Technology Evaluation and Evidence-of-Use Investigation was performed on US Patent 5662768 titled
“High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device” (1) The patent had a filing date of September 21,
1995 and an issue date of September 2, 1997. The assignee was identified as LSI Logic Corporation.

The objective of this project was to extract and evaluate the technical elements of the invention, attempt to
determine which manufacturers and/or products might incorporate aspects of the invention, and provide
documentation of the similarities. Results and conclusions are not a legal opinion.

                                               Summary of Final Results

• US Patent 5662768 (‘768) describes a process for forming trenches having “high surface-area sidewalls with
undulating profiles”. (1)
• Claims 1 and 20 are the broadest claims.
• Embodiments are included for both general trench structures (such as isolation) and trench memory
capacitors.
• Ten different Assignees were found to have patents on structures and/or processes that appeared to have
multiple similar elements to claims of the ‘768 claims. These include Chartered Semiconductor,, Infineon
Technologies AG, International Business Machines Corp, Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba, Micron Semiconductor,
Nanya Technology Corporation, Samsung Electronics, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, United
Microelectronics Corp., and Vanguard Semiconductor. Some of these cited the ‘768 as prior art.
• Diagrams and text descriptions of current products from some of the Final Working Group patent Assignees
appeared to show similarities to multiple elements of the ‘768 patent claims. Detailed cross-section images of
actual parts and description of trench manufacturing processes may be required to compare claim elements
to real-world product features.

          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             4
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                LAM Research, Applied Materials, or Silicon Genesis

Although their equipment is used by other manufacturers to fabricate a variety of semiconductor products,
neither LAM Research, Applied Materials, or Silicon Genesis fabricates their own trench or stacked DRAMs so
no further research was performed on these Assignees.

                                               Chartered Semiconductor

Chartered Semiconductor is now a part of GlobalFoundries, who do not appear to currently utilize trench
eDRAMs modules or any other trench-based memory technology.

                                               Chartered Semiconductor

Chartered Semiconductor is now part of GlobalFoundries, who do not appear to currently utilize trench
eDRAMs modules or any other trench-based memory technology.

                                                         Infineon

Infineon uses a deep trench capacitor-based DRAM cell with a “bottle-shaped” trench and hemispherical
silicon grains (HSG) to extend the effective surface area. This may be similar to the elements of Claim 20 and
others.

                                        International Business Machines Corp.

IBM currently integrates a “bottle-shaped” embedded DRAM capacitor in their SOI-based processes. This may
be similar to the elements of Claims 1, 20 and others.


       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606                5
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                               Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba

Toshiba currently manufacturers a “bottle-shaped” trench capacitor embedded DRAM memory cell. This may
have similarities to Claims 1, 20 and others.

                                                   Micron Technology

Micron Semiconductor currently manufacturers only stacked capacitor DRAM memories.

                                            Nanya Technology Corporation

Nanya has used Qimonda trench (bottle-shaped) capacitor DRAM technology in the past , but is converting its
capacity over to Micron Technology Inc. stacked-capacitor DRAM technology. The Qimonda devices may have
similarities to Claim 20 and others.

                                                   Inotera Memories

Nanya and Micron Technology have a “Joint Technology Development Agreement” called Inotera Memories
Inc. which currently has a deep trench capacitor DRAM (at 90nm – 75nm) but is converting to stacked-
capacitor DRAM technologies at 50nm.

                                             Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd

Samsung currently utilizes Metal-Insulator-Metal (MIM) capacitor technology for DRAM cells. However, their
Sphere-shaped Recess Channel Array Transistor (S-RACT) has some elements similar to Claim 20 of the ‘768
patent. Trench cross -section images of actual products would help determine if elements of Claims 1 and 20
are similar.

       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606                6
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.


                                  Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company

TSMC does not provide any embedded trench capacitor DRAM cells.

                                        United Microelectronics Corporation

UMC has internally developed a trench capacitor 1-transistor, 1-capacitor bit cell high-density eDRAM
memory solution called URAM for System-on-Chip (SoC) applications. This may have similarities to Claims 1,
20 and others.

                                                 Vanguard Technology

Vanguard has no current trench or stacked stand-alone DRAM or Embedded DRAM manufactured products




      IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606                7
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.




                                   Patent Technology Evaluation

                                            US Patent 5662768

                                  Assignee: LSI Logic Corporation

     Title: “High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device”


                                   File date: September 21, 1995
                                   Issue date September 2, 1997




     IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606               8
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.


                                                Introduction/Objective

As requested, US Patent 5662768 was reviewed and analyzed in detail to understand the key technical aspects
and claimed elements of the invention, including:

•Background of the invention
•Problem the invention solves
•How the invention solves the problem
•Equipment/ Gases/Chemicals/Etch Chemistry and materials used
•Applicable products (as defined in the patent)
•Different embodiments
•Elements of the independent claims
                                             Summary of Results

• US Patent 5662768 (‘768) describes a process for forming trenches having high surface-area sidewalls with
undulating profiles. (1)
• Embodiments are included for both general trench structures and trench memory capacitors.
• Independent claims 1 and 20 appear to define a trench only, and do not appear to have a trench capacitor
limitation.
• Independent claims 15, 24, 27, and 33 appear to be limited to trench capacitors.
• Independent Claims 1 and 20 appear to be the broadest, possibly having elements similar to a variety of
trench structures including interlayer vias, stacked capacitors, bottle-shaped trenches, and SRCAT (spherical
recessed access transistors) DRAM select transistors.




     IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606                  9
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.



                                             Patent Technology Evaluation

US Patent 5662768 was reviewed and analyzed in detail to understand the key technical aspects and claimed
elements of the invention.

Background of the Invention

The invention relates generally to methods of forming high-surface area trenches through a “substrate having
chemically distinct strata” in silicon wafers during fabrication of integrated circuits. Trenches may form
electrical isolation between MOS devices, or may serve as trench capacitors in dynamic random access
memories. (1)

Problem the Invention Solves

At the time of the application, the available “trench-forming techniques have not yet proved able to reliably
attain submicron trenches of the depth to width ratios necessary to reach the 64 megabit requirements”. (1)

How the Invention Solves the Problem

This invention provides a process for forming trenches having “nonlinear, high surface-area sidewalls” that
“provide more capacitance per unit depth than comparable straight-walled trenches”. (1) Nonlinear trench
sidewalls may have “rounded and/or undulating profiles, and may be formed by “nonlinear dopant
concentration profiles in a substrate beneath a region where the trench is to be formed, and then subjecting
the regions to a selective etching to remove material in highly-doped areas so the “trench sidewalls mirror the
dopant concentration profile”. (1)


          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             10
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

Summarized From Patent USP 5662768 (1)

Equipment/ Gases/Chemicals/Etch Chemistry

•Ion implantation with impurities such as germanium, oxygen (O 2 ), or argon.
•Anisotropic etching to form the trench, such as reactive ion etching or selective sputter etching using
conventional plasma reactors.
•CF 4 and O 2 , with higher O 2 concentrations providing more preference for silicon etching.
•The residual germanium regions are then oxidized by exposing the trench to an oxidizing environment to
form germanium oxides (e.g., GeO 2 and/or GeO).
•Oxygen ions using conventional ion implantation apparatus. The implanted oxygen will form some silicon
oxide (in a silicon substrate), but not necessarily a stoichiometric SiO 2 .
•Wet chemistry etch using potassium hydroxide (KOH).

Applicable Materials

•Substrates and layers of silicon, oxides, glasses, or other dielectrics.

Applicable Products

•Trench Storage Capacitor Dynamic Random Access Memories (DRAMs)
•Interlayer or interlevel vias
•Trench isolation

Trench Shapes

•Globe or hour-glass shape, triangular and other polygonal shapes.

          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             11
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

Embodiments of Invention (1)

The various embodiments of the invention were extracted from the patent Description to illustrate details of
the patent claims (Figures 1 – 3). The three embodiments included etched trenches with horizontal impurity
regions, rounded bottoms, and integrated circuits containing transistor devices and trench capacitor
structures with the inventive features.

                 Excerpt from Patent                                              Applicable Diagram

“In a preferred embodiment, prior to the step of the                                        (1)
providing the impurity regions, the method includes a
step of forming a first mask which exposes a region
on the top surface of the substrate.                                                                Etched
                                                                                                    Trench
The impurities are then introduced through the
exposed region to form the impurity regions (by, for
example, ion implantation).

Thus, the exposed region approximately defines the
impurity regions' sizes. After the impurities have
been introduced, the exposed region is preferably
narrowed by providing spacers to define the etchant
access region.                                                                                             Etched
                                                                                                          impurity
Thereafter, the trench is etched by, for example,                                                         regions
reactive ion etching through the etchant access
region.” (1)
                      Figure 1. Details of Preferred Embodiment from USP5662768.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             12
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.


                  Excerpt from Patent                                              Applicable Diagram

“In another aspect, the present invention provides a                                         (1)
semiconductor chip which can be characterized as
including (1) a semiconductor substrate having an
upper surface; and (2) a trench provided in the
substrate and having one or more sidewalls.
The trench includes, in turn, (i) a neck region of a                                 Neck                       Etched
defined first width located at the upper surface of the                             Region                      Trench
semiconductor substrate, and (ii) a body region
located below said neck region in the semiconductor
substrate, with the body region having at least one
nonlinear region of a second defined width which is
greater than the first defined width.

In preferred embodiments, the sidewalls will have
undulating or rounded shapes.
The trenches meeting the above criteria can be used
in trench capacitors which have a conformal dielectric                       Rounded
layer on the sidewalls, and an electrically conductive                         Body
                                                                              Region
material (e.g., polysilicon) provided interior to the
trench and adjacent to the conformal dielectric layer.
In this design, the semiconductor substrate and the
electrically conductive material form plates of a
trench capacitor.” (1)

                           Figure 2. Details of a Second Aspect from USP5662768.
          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             13
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.



                 Excerpt from Patent                                              Applicable Diagram

“A third aspect of the invention provides an
integrated circuit incorporating active devices and
trench capacitors in a semiconductor substrate.

The integrated circuit may be characterized as
including the following: (1) a plurality of trench
capacitors each having an insulated storage plate
within a trench in the semiconductor substrate; and
(2) a plurality of active devices arranged in a                              No Diagrams of Third Aspect
predefined circuit configuration with at least some of
the plurality of trench capacitors.

In such integrated circuits, at least some of the trench
capacitors are provided in trenches having (i) a neck
region of a defined first width located at the upper
surface of the semiconductor substrate, and (ii) a
body region located below said neck and having at
least one nonlinear region of a second defined width
which is greater than the first defined width.” (1)



                               Figure 3. Details of a Third Aspect from USP5662768.



         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             14
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.


Independent Claims Analysis (1)

All independent claims were analyzed and summarized to extract the key elements and understand each
limitations. A Summary of the concepts for each independent claim are shown below.


        Summary of Claim 1                         Summary of Claim 15                    Summary of Claim 20 elements
           elements                                    element
-    Method of etching trench in           -    Method of forming trench              -     Semiconductor chip
     substrate                                  capacitor in substrate                -     Semiconductor substrate
-    One or more impurity regions          -    One or more impurity regions          -     Trench with one or more
     laterally extending over a first           laterally extending over a first            sidewalls
     width                                      width                                 -     Neck region of first width
-    Etchant access region                 -    Etchant access region                 -     Body region with at least one
     narrower than first width                  narrower than first width                   nonlinear region of a second
-    One or more trench sidewalls          -    One or more trench sidewalls                width greater than said first
     of substantially nonlinear                 of substantially nonlinear                  width
     shape                                      shape


(Note: Claim summaries are provided only to assist in understanding the general aspects of the claims. They
are not meant to be and should not be used as a legal interpretation of the claim language or to determine
possible legal claims associated with the patent).


                     Figure 4. Summary of Independent Claims 1, 15, and 20 from USP5662768.
           IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             15
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

        Summary of Claim 24                     Summary of Claim 27                   Summary of Claim 33 elements
            elements                                elements
-    Semiconductor memory chip             -     Integrated circuit with         -    Digital system
-    Semiconductor substrate                     active devices and trench       -    Plurality of semiconductor
-    Trench having one or more                   capacitors                           integrated circuits
     sidewalls                             -     Semiconductor substrate         -    Incorporating active devices and
-    Neck region of a first width          -     Plurality of trench                  trench capacitors in a
-    Body region of with at least                capacitors with an                   semiconductor substrate
     one nonlinear region of a                   insulated storage plate         -    Plurality of integrated circuits
     second width greater than said        -     Plurality of active devices     -    Each including a plurality of trench
     first width                                 in a circuit configuration           capacitors with an insulated
-    Electrically conductive                     with at least one of the             storage plate within each trench
     material interior to said                   trench capacitors               -    Plurality of active devices arranged
     trench whereby substrate and          -     At least some of the                 in a circuit configuration with at
     conductive material form                    trench capacitors are in             least one of the trench capacitors
     plates of a trench capacitor                trenches that                   -    At least some of the trench
                                           -     Have a neck region of a              capacitors are in trenches that
                                                 first width                     -    Have a neck region of a first width
                                           -     A body region of with at        -    A body region of with at least one
                                                 least one nonlinear                  nonlinear region of a second width
                                                 region of a second width             greater than said first width
                                                 greater than said first
                                                 width



                  Figure 5. Summary of Independent Claims 24, 27, and 33 from USP5662768.
           IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             16
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                           Non-Patent Literature References

                                                 Introduction/Objective

Non-patent Literature References in USP5662768 include three reports from Integrated Circuit Engineering
(ICE) Corporation (highlighted in red below). These reports contained structural analysis of general fabrication
process and detailed analysis of the memory cell on 16-Mbit and 64-Mbit DRAMs. The author of this sample
Patent Technology Evaluation Report, David York, was Manager of Laboratory Services at ICE Corp during this
period of time, and the referenced analyses was performed under his direction. Contact IC Microanalysis LLC
for more information. Copies of these reports may be available for purchase from Chipworks in Ottawa,
Canada.

Other References from US Patent 5662768 (1)


•Carter, B.J., Holland, J.P., Peltzer, E., Richardson, B., Bogle, E., Nguyen, H.T., Melaku, Y., Gates, D., and Ben-Dor,
M., "Transformer Coupled Plasma Etch for the Fabrication of Sub-half Micron Structures", Abstract #967, Lam
Research Corporation, Fremont, CA, 1992.
•Singer, Peter, "Electrostatic Chucks in Wafer Processing", pp. 57-64, Semiconductor International, Apr. 1995.
•"Texas Instruments TMX416100DZ 16-Megabit DRAM", Integrated Circuit Engineering Corporation, Report
No. SUB 918-03, pp. 1-18, Aug. 1991.
•"Hitachi HM51W64800J7 64 MBit DRAM", Integrated Circuit Engineering Corporation, Report No. SUB 9407-
04, pp. 1-12, Jul. 1994.
"Hitachi HM5116100J8 16-Megabit DRAM", Integrated Circuit Engineering Corporation, Report No. SUB 9204-
02, pp. 1-18, Apr. 1992.



          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             17
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.




                                      Evidence of Use Investigation

                                    Part 1: Focused Citation Analysis

                                              US Patent 5662768

                                     Assignee: LSI Logic Corporation

           Title: “High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device”


                                      File date: September 21, 1995
                                      Issue date September 2, 1997




     IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606               18
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.



                        Evidence-of-Use Investigation - Part 1: Focused Citation Analysis

                                                Introduction/Objective

A Focused Citation Analysis was requested and performed in order to locate other patented products that
might have multiple similar elements to those claimed in the ‘768 patent, potentially indicating which
manufacturers (Assignees) might incorporate elements of the ‘768 in their products.

The resulting Patents and Assignees formed a Final Working Group which was used for the Patent Technology
Utilization Research and Analysis to locate possible current product use.

The following Patent Groups were reviewed and analyzed (Figure 6):

Group 1: USP 5662768 prior art patent citations (1)
Group 2: Patents citing USP 5662768 as prior art (1)
Group 3: Patents citing Groups 1 and 2 patents as prior art (and filed after the file date of the ‘768)
Group 4: Patents citing Group 3 patents as prior art (and filed after the file date of the ‘768)

Patents within these groups that had “some” similar structures and processes were subjected to a more
detailed examination and analysis.

Patents from the “some similar elements” group that had “multiple similar elements” then formed the Final
Working Group. Some of the patents in the final group directly cited the ‘768 as prior art.




       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606               19
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.


                                                  Summary of Results

Ten different Assignees were found to have patents on structures and/or process that appeared to have
multiple similar elements to claims of the ‘768 claims (Figure 7). These include Chartered Semiconductor,
Infineon Technologies AG, International Business Machines Corp, Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba, Micron
Semiconductor, Nanya Technology Corporation, Samsung Electronics, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing
Company, United Microelectronics Corp., and Vanguard Semiconductor. The assignees included
semiconductor manufacturers, foundries, and equipment manufacturers.

Figures 8 and 9 show the top Group 1 – 3 Assignees by number of referenced patents. Figure 10 shows the top
Group 1 – 2 Assignees by number of referenced patents. Seven patents from a variety of Assignees had
diagrams that appeared to incorporate elements from multiple independent claims of the ‘768 patent (Figure
7). Eighteen patents from a variety of Assignees had diagrams that appeared to incorporate elements from
Claims 1 and 20 (shown as an example) of the ‘768 patent. Technology Claim Diagrams (Figures 11 - 151)
illustrate the similarities in detail.


    (Group 4)                  (Group 3)
   Patents that               Patents that
                                                          (Group 2)
    Reference                  Reference                                                                   (Group 1)
                                                        Patents that
    Group 3 as               Groups 1 and                                                                  ‘768 Prior
                                                         Reference               ‘768 Patent
     Prior Art               2 as Prior Art                                                               Art Citations
                                                        ‘768 as Prior
    And Filed                  And Filed                                                                   (Primary)
                                                             Art
  After ‘768 File            After ‘768 File
       Date                       Date

                                  Figure 6. Patent groups reviewed and analyzed.

          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             20
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                     Patent Assignee                               US Patent #       Applicable Independent Claims
             Chartered Semiconductor Inc.                           6,313,008                   1, 15, and 20
                                                                    7,250,669
               Infineon Technologies AG                             6,426,254                     1 and 20
    International Business Machines Corporation                     5,153,813            1, 15, 20, 24, 27, and 33
    International Business Machines Corporation                     6,696,344                     1 and 20
    International Business Machines Corporation                     6,936,522                     1 and 20
                Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba                            5,629,226               1, 15, 20, 24, and 27
                Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba                            6,600,189                     1 and 20
                 Micron Technology, Inc.                            6,518,615                     1 and 20
            Nanya Technology Corporation                            6,716,757                     1 and 20
                                                                    6,800,535
                                                                    6,664,161
             Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.                          6,809,363                 1, 15, 20, and 24
              Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd                          7,633,117                     1 and 20
   Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company                       6,624,018                     1 and 20
             United Microelectronics Corp.                          5,449,630                 1, 15, 20, and 24
 Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation                   5,943,581               1, 15, 20, 24, and 27
 Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation                   5,976,945                     1 and 20
     Figure 7. Final Working Group Assignee, similar patents, and applicable claims of patent ‘768.

       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             21
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.




                     Top Assignees                                      Patent Citations              Patent Citations
                                                                          Groups 1, 2                     Group 3
                   Applied Materials                                            0                            141

                Micron Semiconductor                                            5                            102

                     LAM Research                                               0                               96

              Silicon Genesis Corporation                                       0                               45

                           IBM                                                  1                               41

                    Intel Corporation                                           5                               0

                         Toshiba                                                4                               0

                           IBM                                                  1                               0

                        Vanguard                                                1                               0

                          UMC                                                   1                               0

               Chartered Semiconductor                                          1                               0



       Figure 8. Table illustrating the top Groups 1 - 3 References for USP5662768 by Assignee.
       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             22
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.




                  Tokyo Electron, Ltd.          19


          Silicon Genesis, Corporation                45


         Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.         12
                                                                                                         Advanced Micro Devices, Inc.
              Micron Technology, Inc.                           102                                      Applied Materials, Inc.
                                                                                                         Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation
            Lam Research Corporation                            96                                       Innovative Silicon, S.A.
                                                                                                         International Business Machines, Corp.
             Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba          12
                                                                                                         Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba
                                                                                                         Lam Research Corporation
International Business Machines, Corp.               41
                                                                                                         Micron Technology, Inc.

                                                20                                                       Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
                Innovative Silicon, S.A.
                                                                                                         Silicon Genesis, Corporation

  Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation          17                                                        Tokyo Electron, Ltd.


                Applied Materials, Inc.                                   141


         Advanced Micro Devices, Inc.          12


                                           0         20    40        60     80   100   120   140   160



                    Figure 9. Chart illustrating the top Groups 1 - 3 References for USP5662768 by Assignee.

           IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606                              23
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.



     Vanguard International Semiconductor…            1                                                Advanced Micro Devices, Inc.

              United Microelectronics Corp.           1
                                                                                                       AmberWave Systems Corporation

      Texas Instruments - Acer Incorporated           1
                                                                                                       Elpida Memory, Inc.
                     STMicroelectronics S.A.          1
                                                                                                       Hynix Semiconductor Inc.
                 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft           1
                                                                                                       Intel Corporation
                  Renesas Technology Corp.            1

                    Micron Technology, Inc.                               5                            International Business Machines Corporation


      Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd.        1                                                Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba

                   Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba                          4
                                                                                                       Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd.

International Business Machines Corporation           1
                                                                                                       Micron Technology, Inc.
                           Intel Corporation                              5
                                                                                                       Renesas Technology Corp.
                   Hynix Semiconductor Inc.           1
                                                                                                       Siemens Aktiengesellschaft
                        Elpida Memory, Inc.           1

          AmberWave Systems Corporation               1                                                STMicroelectronics S.A.

               Advanced Micro Devices, Inc.           1                                                Texas Instruments - Acer Incorporated

                                                 0   0.5   1   1.5   2   2.5   3   3.5   4   4.5   5


                Figure 10. Chart illustrating the Groups 1 and 2 Patent References for USP5662768 by Assignee.

           IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606                                 24
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.




                                     Evidence of Use Investigation

                                 Part 2: Technology Claim Diagrams

                                             US Patent 5662768

                                    Assignee: LSI Logic Corporation

          Title: “High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device”


                                     File date: September 21, 1995
                                     Issue date September 2, 1997




     IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606               25
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.


                        Evidence-of-Use Investigation - Part 2: Technology Claim Diagrams

                                                Introduction/Objective

Technology Claim Diagrams were requested and compiled in order to illustrate the similarities between the
‘768 patent claims and diagrams from the Final Working Group patents. These are detailed on pages 11 – 151.

                                                  Summary of Results

Seven patents from a variety of Assignees had diagrams that appeared to incorporate elements from multiple
independent claims of the ‘768 patent (Figure 7). Eighteen patents (eleven additional) from a variety of
Assignees had diagrams that appeared to incorporate elements from Claim 20 of the ‘768 patent. Assignees
included include Chartered Semiconductor, Infineon Technologies AG, International Business Machines Corp,
Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba, Micron Semiconductor, Nanya Technology Corporation, Samsung Electronics, Taiwan
Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, United Microelectronics Corp., and Vanguard Semiconductor.
Patented structures included trench capacitors, trench isolation, interlayer vias, and stacked capacitors.

Some of the Assignees in the Final Working Group cite the ‘768 patent as prior art, indicating their inventions
incorporate some aspects of the ‘768 invention. So it is possible that some of the products manufactured by
the Assignees after the issue date of the ‘768 patent might also contain claimed aspects of the ‘768 patent.




       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606                26
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.




                              Pages 27 – 85 are currently unavailable.




    IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                              US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 1




Claim 1. A method of etching a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method
comprising the following steps:

providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said
substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a
vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear;

defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one
or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; and

providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch said trench such that said trench
has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical
concentration profile. (1)




                              Figure 70. Claim 1 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .

         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             86
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

             US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation



       (1) top surface

                                                                                            (1) trench in a substrate




 (1) trench has one or
   more sidewalls of
substantially nonlinear
shape corresponding to
      said vertical
 concentration profile




Figure 71. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             87
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

              US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation




   (1) etchant access
   region of specified
    second width …
  narrower than said
  specified first width



(1) one or more impurity
    regions … laterally
  extending over a first
          width
                                                                                   (1) vertical
                                                                                  concentration
                                                                                     profile




 Figure 72. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             88
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                               US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 15



Claim 15. A method of forming a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method
comprising the following steps:

providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said
substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a
vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear;

defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one
or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width;

providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch a trench such that said trench has
one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical
concentration profile; and

forming a dielectric layer on said one or more sidewalls. (1)




                              Figure 73. Claim 15 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             89
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

             US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation



    (15) top surface

                                                                                              (15) trench in a substrate




 (15) trench has one or
    more sidewalls of
substantially nonlinear
shape corresponding to
       said vertical
  concentration profile




Figure 74. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             90
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

             US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation




 (15) etchant access
  region of specified
   second width …
 narrower than said
 specified first width


 (15) one or more
impurity regions …
laterally extending
 over a first width
                                                                                  (15) vertical
                                                                                 concentration
                                                                                     profile




Figure 75. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             91
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

             US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation




                                                                                                   (15) dielectric layer




Figure 76. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             92
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 20




Claim 20. A semiconductor chip comprising:

a semiconductor substrate having an upper surface; and

a trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls, said trench including,

a neck region of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and

a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said body
region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width.
(1)




                               Figure 77. Claim 20 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .

          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             93
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation




                                                                                         (20) upper surface
  (20) semiconductor chip


   (20) neck region of a
   first width located at                                                                  (20) trench provided in said
     said upper surface                                                                    substrate and having one or
                                                                                                  more sidewalls

  (20) body region has at
least one nonlinear region                                                                   (20) body region
of a second width which is                                                                  located below said
   greater than said first                                                                      neck region
           width




   Figure 78. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
            IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             94
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

              US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation




  (20) neck
region of a
first width
 located at
                                                                                             (20) body region has at
said upper
                                                                                               least one nonlinear
   surface
                                                                                                region of a second
                                                                                              width which is greater
                                                                                               than said first width




Figure 79. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             95
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                               US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 24


Claim 24. A semiconductor memory chip comprising:

a semiconductor substrate having an upper surface;

a trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls, said trench including,

a neck region of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and

a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said
body region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first
width; and

an electrically conductive material provided interior to said trench and adjacent to said
conformal dielectric layer *, whereby said semiconductor substrate and said electrically
conductive material form plates of a trench capacitor.


              * Note: “said conformal dielectric layer” identified in dependent claim 23, but not in Claim 24




                              Figure 80. Claim 24 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             96
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

             US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation

                                                               (24) semiconductor memory chip



                    The novel DRAM cell structure and method for making a high-
                    density array of DRAM cells having these novel buried reservoir
                    capacitors is described in detail.

                    The DRAM cells are formed using N-channel field effect
                    transistors (N-FETs) as the access transistors in each of the
                    memory cells formed in and on an epitaxial layer over the buried
                    reservoir capacitors.




Figure 81. Patent language from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606            97
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

             US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation



       (24) upper surface




                                                                                        (24) trench provided in said
                                                                                        substrate and having one or
                                                                                               more sidewalls

                                                                                          (24) body region
                                                                                         located below said
                                                                                             neck region




Figure 82. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             98
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

              US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation




  (24) neck
region of a
first width
 located at
                                                                                             (24) body region has at
said upper
                                                                                               least one nonlinear
   surface
                                                                                                region of a second
                                                                                              width which is greater
                                                                                               than said first width




Figure 83. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             99
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

               US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation




    (24) electrically
  conductive material
provided interior to said
         trench                                                                                      (24) conformal
                                                                                                     dielectric layer




  Figure 84. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
           IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             100
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

         US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation



Claim 27. An integrated circuit incorporating active devices and trench capacitors in a
semiconductor substrate having a top surface, the integrated circuit comprising:

a plurality of trench capacitors each having an insulated storage plate within a trench in the
semiconductor substrate; and

a plurality of active devices arranged in a circuit configuration with at least some of said plurality
of trench capacitors,

wherein at least some of the trench capacitors are provided in trenches having (i) a neck region
of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and (ii) a body
region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said body region
has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width. (1)




                               Figure 85. Claim 27 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .

           IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606            101
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                 US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation

                                                                                         (27) integrated circuit
                                                                                    incorporating active devices and
(27) plurality of trench capacitors
                                                                                           trench capacitors

                        The novel DRAM cell structure and method for making a high-
                        density array of DRAM cells having these novel buried reservoir
                        capacitors is described in detail.

                        The DRAM cells are formed using N-channel field effect
                        transistors (N-FETs) as the access transistors in each of the
                        memory cells formed in and on an epitaxial layer over the buried
                        reservoir capacitors.


           (27) plurality of active devices arranged in a circuit
                               configuration




    Figure 86. Patent language from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
              IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606            102
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

             US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation



         (27) top surface




                                                                                          (27) body region
                                                                                         located below said
                                                                                             neck region




Figure 87. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             103
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

              US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation




  (27) neck
region of a
first width
 located at
                                                                                             (27) body region has at
said upper
                                                                                               least one nonlinear
   surface
                                                                                                region of a second
                                                                                              width which is greater
                                                                                               than said first width




Figure 88. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             104
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

               US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation




                                                                                           (27) integrated circuit
                                                                                      incorporating active devices and
                                                                                             trench capacitors
    (27) electrically
  conductive material
provided interior to said
         trench




                                                                                                  (27) insulated storage
                                                                                                   plate within a trench


                                                       (27) at least some of the
                                                    trench capacitors are provided
                                                              in trenches


  Figure 89. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation.
          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              105
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                  US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 1




Claim 1. A method of etching a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method
comprising the following steps:

providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said
substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a
vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear;

defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one
or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; and

providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch said trench such that said trench
has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical
concentration profile. (1)




                              Figure 90. Claim 1 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .

        IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              106
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.




               (1) top surface


                                                                                            (1) trench in a substrate




 (1) trench has one or
   more sidewalls of
substantially nonlinear
shape corresponding to
      said vertical
 concentration profile


   Figure 91. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
        IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             107
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

               US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.



    (1) etchant access
    region of specified
     second width …
   narrower than said
   specified first width




  (1) one or more impurity
      regions … laterally
    extending over a first
            width



                                                                     (1) vertical
                                                                    concentration
                                                                       profile

 Figure 92. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             108
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 15



Claim 15. A method of forming a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method
comprising the following steps:

providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said
substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a
vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear;

defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one
or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width;

providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch a trench such that said trench has
one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical
concentration profile; and

forming a dielectric layer on said one or more sidewalls. (1)




                              Figure 93. Claim 15 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             109
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.




               (15) top surface


                                                                                           (15) trench in a substrate




 (15) trench has one or
    more sidewalls of
substantially nonlinear
shape corresponding to
       said vertical
  concentration profile



   Figure 94. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
        IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             110
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

               US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.



   (15) etchant access
    region of specified
     second width …
   narrower than said
   specified first width




     (15) one or more
    impurity regions …
laterally extending over a
         first width



                                                                     (15) vertical
                                                                    concentration
                                                                        profile

 Figure 95. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             111
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

               US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.




                        The hole is filled with a insulating material to form a
                        balloon shaped shallow trench isolation (STI) region. The
                        substrate has active areas between said balloon shaped
                        shallow trench isolation (STI) regions.

                             (15) dielectric layer




 Figure 96. Patent language from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             112
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic, Inc. - Claim 20




Claim 20. A semiconductor chip comprising:

a semiconductor substrate having an upper surface; and

a trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls, said trench including,

a neck region of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and

a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said body
region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width.
(1)




                              Figure 97. Claim 20 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .

         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             113
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

               US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.




      As shown in FIG. 1, a barrier layer 1418 is formed over a substrate 10.
      The substrate may be a conventional Si substrate or a SIO substrate or
      any substrate using in semiconductor manufacturing.



                  (20) semiconductor chip




 Figure 98. Patent language from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
        IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606            114
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                 US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.




             (20) upper surface




       (20) neck region of a                                                            (20) trench provided in said
       first width located at                                                           substrate and having one or
         said upper surface                                                                    more sidewalls



  (20) body region has at                                                                  (20) body region
least one nonlinear region                                                                located below said
of a second width which is                                                                    neck region
   greater than said first
           width




   Figure 99. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             115
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

               US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.



                                                                                                   (20) trench provided
               (20) neck region of a                                                               in said substrate and
               first width located at                                                               having one or more
                 said upper surface                                                                       sidewalls



                                                                                                    (20) body region
                                                                                                   located below said
                                                                                                       neck region




                     (20) body region has at
                   least one nonlinear region
                   of a second width which is
                      greater than said first
                              width

Figure 100. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             116
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

               US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.




  (20) neck
region of a
first width
 located at
said upper
   surface                                                                               (20) body region has at
                                                                                           least one nonlinear
                                                                                            region of a second
                                                                                          width which is greater
                                                                                           than said first width




Figure 101. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
      IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              117
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                             US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic, Inc. – Claim 1




Claim 1. A method of etching a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method
comprising the following steps:

providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said
substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a
vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear;

defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one
or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; and

providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch said trench such that said trench
has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical
concentration profile. (1)




                              Figure 102. Claim 1 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .

         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             118
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

        US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG)




(1) top surface



     (1) vertical
    concentration
       profile


                                                                               (1) etchant access
 (1) one or more                                                               region of specified
impurity regions                                                                second width …
    … laterally                                                               narrower than said
extending over a                                                              specified first width
    first width


     Figure 103. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              119
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

    US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG)


                                                                                    (1) trench in a substrate




                                                                                        (1) trench has one or
                                                                                          more sidewalls of
                                                                                       substantially nonlinear
                                                                                       shape corresponding to
                                                                                             said vertical
                                                                                        concentration profile


Figure 104. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
      IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              120
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 15



Claim 15. A method of forming a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method
comprising the following steps:

providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said
substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a
vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear;

defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one
or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width;

providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch a trench such that said trench has
one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical
concentration profile; and

forming a dielectric layer* on said one or more sidewalls. (1)


                                                                                                      * Not present


                              Figure 105. Claim 15 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             121
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

       US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG)




 (15) top surface


                                                                             (15) vertical
                                                                            concentration
                                                                                profile


                                                                                 (15) etchant access
                                                                                  region of specified
                                                                                   second width …
 (15) one or more
                                                                                 narrower than said
impurity regions …
                                                                                 specified first width
laterally extending
 over a first width


    Figure 106. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              122
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

    US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG)


                                                                                      (15) trench in a substrate


(15) dielectric
  layer (not
   present)                                                                                 (15) trench has one or
                                                                                               more sidewalls of
                                                                                           substantially nonlinear
                                                                                           shape corresponding to
                                                                                                  said vertical
                                                                                             concentration profile




Figure 107. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
      IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              123
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic, Inc. - Claim 20




Claim 20. A semiconductor chip comprising:

a semiconductor substrate having an upper surface; and

a trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls, said trench including,

a neck region of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and

a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said body
region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width.
(1)




                              Figure 108. Claim 20 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .

         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             124
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

      US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG)



(20) upper surface
                                                                              (20) semiconductor chip




                                                                              (20) trench provided in said
                                                                              substrate and having one or
                                                                                     more sidewalls




   Figure 109. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
        IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              125
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

    US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG)

      (20) neck
    region of a                                                                          (20) body region
    first width                                                                         located below said
     located at                                                                             neck region
    said upper
       surface
                                                                                        (20) body region has at
                                                                                          least one nonlinear
                                                                                           region of a second
                                                                                         width which is greater
                                                                                          than said first width




Figure 110. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc.
      IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              126
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                             US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic, Inc. – Claim 1




Claim 1. A method of etching a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method
comprising the following steps:

providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said
substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a
vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear;

defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one
or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; and

providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch said trench such that said trench
has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical
concentration profile. (1)




                              Figure 111. Claim 1 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .

         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             127
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

        US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR)




(1) top surface




          Figure 112. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
       IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             128
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

           US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR)

 (1) etchant access
 region of specified
  second width …
narrower than said                                                                     (1) trench in a substrate
specified first width

                                                                                            (1) trench has one or
  (1) one or more                                                                             more sidewalls of
impurity regions …                                                                         substantially nonlinear
laterally extending                                                                        shape corresponding to
 over a first width                                                                              said vertical
                                                                                            concentration profile




             Figure 113. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             129
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                 US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR)



As shown in FIG. 4 , the top section 54 having a small diameter is mounted on the base
section 52 having a large diameter, so the storage electrode layer 50 has the
geometrically stable structure. That is, the bottom of the storage electrode layer 50 is
larger than an inlet thereof.

Referring to FIG. 6 , impurities such as Ar or N 2 are implanted into the insulating
layer 56 in order to increase the etching rate when the cleaning process is carried out.

   (1) etchant access
                                                                                           (1) vertical
   region of specified
                                                                                          concentration
    second width …
                                                                                             profile
  narrower than said
  specified first width




             Figure 114. Patent language from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
          IC Microanalysis LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              130
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

                                 US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 15


Claim 15. A method of forming a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method
comprising the following steps:

providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said
substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a
vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear;

defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one
or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width;

providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch a trench such that said trench has
one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical
concentration profile; and

forming a dielectric layer* on said one or more sidewalls. (1)


                                                                              * dielectric layer (not present)


                               Figure 115. Claim 15 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 .
          IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             131
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

          US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR)




(15) top surface




            Figure 116. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
         IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             132
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

            US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR)

 (15) etchant access                                                                (15) trench in a substrate
  region of specified
   second width …
 narrower than said                                                                        (15) trench has one or
 specified first width                                                                        more sidewalls of
                                                                                          substantially nonlinear
                                                                                          shape corresponding to
 (15) one or more                                                                                said vertical
impurity regions …                                                                          concentration profile
laterally extending
 over a first width




                                                                                                    (15) dielectric
                                                                                                      layer (not
                                                                                                       present)

              Figure 117. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
           IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606             133
This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement.

               US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR)



As shown in FIG. 4 , the top section 54 having a small diameter is mounted on the base
section 52 having a large diameter, so the storage electrode layer 50 has the
geometrically stable structure. That is, the bottom of the storage electrode layer 50 is
larger than an inlet thereof.

Referring to FIG. 6 , impurities such as Ar or N 2 are implanted into the insulating
layer 56 in order to increase the etching rate when the cleaning process is carried out.

(15) etchant access
                                                                                          (15) vertical
 region of specified
                                                                                         concentration
  second width …
                                                                                             profile
narrower than said
specified first width




             Figure 118. Patent language from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
          IC Microanalysis LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606              134
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report
Patent Technology Evaluation Report

More Related Content

What's hot

とあるセキュリティ会社のIoTセキュリティチームの日常(ErrataはDescription参照)
とあるセキュリティ会社のIoTセキュリティチームの日常(ErrataはDescription参照)とあるセキュリティ会社のIoTセキュリティチームの日常(ErrataはDescription参照)
とあるセキュリティ会社のIoTセキュリティチームの日常(ErrataはDescription参照)Tatsuya (達也) Katsuhara (勝原)
 
LiBRA 07.2020 / ITソリューション塾・第34期・AI
LiBRA 07.2020 / ITソリューション塾・第34期・AILiBRA 07.2020 / ITソリューション塾・第34期・AI
LiBRA 07.2020 / ITソリューション塾・第34期・AIMasanori Saito
 
使ってみて気づいた AGPL ライセンスの メリット・デメリット
使ってみて気づいた AGPL ライセンスの メリット・デメリット使ってみて気づいた AGPL ライセンスの メリット・デメリット
使ってみて気づいた AGPL ライセンスの メリット・デメリットFumito Mizuno
 
那些年、我們還沒學會就已經過時的那些技術
那些年、我們還沒學會就已經過時的那些技術那些年、我們還沒學會就已經過時的那些技術
那些年、我們還沒學會就已經過時的那些技術鍾誠 陳鍾誠
 
21世紀で最もセクシーな職業!?「データサイエンティスト」の実像に迫る
21世紀で最もセクシーな職業!?「データサイエンティスト」の実像に迫る21世紀で最もセクシーな職業!?「データサイエンティスト」の実像に迫る
21世紀で最もセクシーな職業!?「データサイエンティスト」の実像に迫るTakashi J OZAKI
 
區塊鏈 (比特幣背後的關鍵技術) -- 十分鐘系列
區塊鏈  (比特幣背後的關鍵技術)   -- 十分鐘系列區塊鏈  (比特幣背後的關鍵技術)   -- 十分鐘系列
區塊鏈 (比特幣背後的關鍵技術) -- 十分鐘系列鍾誠 陳鍾誠
 
Elasticsearch as a Distributed System
Elasticsearch as a Distributed SystemElasticsearch as a Distributed System
Elasticsearch as a Distributed SystemSatoyuki Tsukano
 
最新業界事情から見るデータサイエンティストの「実像」
最新業界事情から見るデータサイエンティストの「実像」最新業界事情から見るデータサイエンティストの「実像」
最新業界事情から見るデータサイエンティストの「実像」Takashi J OZAKI
 
オープンソースライセンスの基礎と実務
オープンソースライセンスの基礎と実務オープンソースライセンスの基礎と実務
オープンソースライセンスの基礎と実務Yutaka Kachi
 
用十分鐘看懂 《近代科學發展史》
用十分鐘看懂  《近代科學發展史》用十分鐘看懂  《近代科學發展史》
用十分鐘看懂 《近代科學發展史》鍾誠 陳鍾誠
 
Logstashを愛して5年、370ページを超えるガチ本を書いてしまった男の話.
Logstashを愛して5年、370ページを超えるガチ本を書いてしまった男の話.Logstashを愛して5年、370ページを超えるガチ本を書いてしまった男の話.
Logstashを愛して5年、370ページを超えるガチ本を書いてしまった男の話.Hibino Hisashi
 
用十分鐘 學會《資料結構、演算法和計算理論》
用十分鐘  學會《資料結構、演算法和計算理論》用十分鐘  學會《資料結構、演算法和計算理論》
用十分鐘 學會《資料結構、演算法和計算理論》鍾誠 陳鍾誠
 
#FTMA15 第三回課題 鬼コースサーベイ
#FTMA15 第三回課題 鬼コースサーベイ#FTMA15 第三回課題 鬼コースサーベイ
#FTMA15 第三回課題 鬼コースサーベイYoichi Ochiai
 
時系列パーソナル・データの プライバシー
時系列パーソナル・データのプライバシー時系列パーソナル・データのプライバシー
時系列パーソナル・データの プライバシーHiroshi Nakagawa
 
鯨物語~Dockerコンテナとオーケストレーションの理解
鯨物語~Dockerコンテナとオーケストレーションの理解鯨物語~Dockerコンテナとオーケストレーションの理解
鯨物語~Dockerコンテナとオーケストレーションの理解Masahito Zembutsu
 
用十分鐘了解 《大學老師到底是一個甚麼樣的工作》?
用十分鐘了解 《大學老師到底是一個甚麼樣的工作》?用十分鐘了解 《大學老師到底是一個甚麼樣的工作》?
用十分鐘了解 《大學老師到底是一個甚麼樣的工作》?鍾誠 陳鍾誠
 
Can increasing input dimensionality improve deep reinforcement learning?
Can increasing input dimensionality improve deep reinforcement learning?Can increasing input dimensionality improve deep reinforcement learning?
Can increasing input dimensionality improve deep reinforcement learning?harmonylab
 

What's hot (20)

とあるセキュリティ会社のIoTセキュリティチームの日常(ErrataはDescription参照)
とあるセキュリティ会社のIoTセキュリティチームの日常(ErrataはDescription参照)とあるセキュリティ会社のIoTセキュリティチームの日常(ErrataはDescription参照)
とあるセキュリティ会社のIoTセキュリティチームの日常(ErrataはDescription参照)
 
LiBRA 07.2020 / ITソリューション塾・第34期・AI
LiBRA 07.2020 / ITソリューション塾・第34期・AILiBRA 07.2020 / ITソリューション塾・第34期・AI
LiBRA 07.2020 / ITソリューション塾・第34期・AI
 
人工知能概論 14
人工知能概論 14人工知能概論 14
人工知能概論 14
 
使ってみて気づいた AGPL ライセンスの メリット・デメリット
使ってみて気づいた AGPL ライセンスの メリット・デメリット使ってみて気づいた AGPL ライセンスの メリット・デメリット
使ってみて気づいた AGPL ライセンスの メリット・デメリット
 
ACDPub.pptx
ACDPub.pptxACDPub.pptx
ACDPub.pptx
 
那些年、我們還沒學會就已經過時的那些技術
那些年、我們還沒學會就已經過時的那些技術那些年、我們還沒學會就已經過時的那些技術
那些年、我們還沒學會就已經過時的那些技術
 
21世紀で最もセクシーな職業!?「データサイエンティスト」の実像に迫る
21世紀で最もセクシーな職業!?「データサイエンティスト」の実像に迫る21世紀で最もセクシーな職業!?「データサイエンティスト」の実像に迫る
21世紀で最もセクシーな職業!?「データサイエンティスト」の実像に迫る
 
區塊鏈 (比特幣背後的關鍵技術) -- 十分鐘系列
區塊鏈  (比特幣背後的關鍵技術)   -- 十分鐘系列區塊鏈  (比特幣背後的關鍵技術)   -- 十分鐘系列
區塊鏈 (比特幣背後的關鍵技術) -- 十分鐘系列
 
Elasticsearch as a Distributed System
Elasticsearch as a Distributed SystemElasticsearch as a Distributed System
Elasticsearch as a Distributed System
 
最新業界事情から見るデータサイエンティストの「実像」
最新業界事情から見るデータサイエンティストの「実像」最新業界事情から見るデータサイエンティストの「実像」
最新業界事情から見るデータサイエンティストの「実像」
 
オープンソースライセンスの基礎と実務
オープンソースライセンスの基礎と実務オープンソースライセンスの基礎と実務
オープンソースライセンスの基礎と実務
 
用十分鐘看懂 《近代科學發展史》
用十分鐘看懂  《近代科學發展史》用十分鐘看懂  《近代科學發展史》
用十分鐘看懂 《近代科學發展史》
 
Logstashを愛して5年、370ページを超えるガチ本を書いてしまった男の話.
Logstashを愛して5年、370ページを超えるガチ本を書いてしまった男の話.Logstashを愛して5年、370ページを超えるガチ本を書いてしまった男の話.
Logstashを愛して5年、370ページを超えるガチ本を書いてしまった男の話.
 
用十分鐘 學會《資料結構、演算法和計算理論》
用十分鐘  學會《資料結構、演算法和計算理論》用十分鐘  學會《資料結構、演算法和計算理論》
用十分鐘 學會《資料結構、演算法和計算理論》
 
#FTMA15 第三回課題 鬼コースサーベイ
#FTMA15 第三回課題 鬼コースサーベイ#FTMA15 第三回課題 鬼コースサーベイ
#FTMA15 第三回課題 鬼コースサーベイ
 
時系列パーソナル・データの プライバシー
時系列パーソナル・データのプライバシー時系列パーソナル・データのプライバシー
時系列パーソナル・データの プライバシー
 
鯨物語~Dockerコンテナとオーケストレーションの理解
鯨物語~Dockerコンテナとオーケストレーションの理解鯨物語~Dockerコンテナとオーケストレーションの理解
鯨物語~Dockerコンテナとオーケストレーションの理解
 
用十分鐘了解 《大學老師到底是一個甚麼樣的工作》?
用十分鐘了解 《大學老師到底是一個甚麼樣的工作》?用十分鐘了解 《大學老師到底是一個甚麼樣的工作》?
用十分鐘了解 《大學老師到底是一個甚麼樣的工作》?
 
論文の速読法
論文の速読法論文の速読法
論文の速読法
 
Can increasing input dimensionality improve deep reinforcement learning?
Can increasing input dimensionality improve deep reinforcement learning?Can increasing input dimensionality improve deep reinforcement learning?
Can increasing input dimensionality improve deep reinforcement learning?
 

Viewers also liked

2014 Student Information Systems Market Trends Report Sample
2014 Student Information Systems Market Trends Report Sample2014 Student Information Systems Market Trends Report Sample
2014 Student Information Systems Market Trends Report SampleThe Tambellini Group
 
Report format
Report formatReport format
Report formatzirram
 
Writing a Report (Tips and Sample of Reports)
Writing a Report (Tips and Sample of Reports)Writing a Report (Tips and Sample of Reports)
Writing a Report (Tips and Sample of Reports)Po Po Tun
 
A Fighter’s Lines Revision
A Fighter’s Lines RevisionA Fighter’s Lines Revision
A Fighter’s Lines RevisionPo Po Tun
 
Report On Business Communication
Report On Business CommunicationReport On Business Communication
Report On Business CommunicationRoshni Rox
 
Organisational Communication
Organisational CommunicationOrganisational Communication
Organisational CommunicationRajiv Bajaj
 
Sample Report Writing For Marketers
Sample Report Writing For MarketersSample Report Writing For Marketers
Sample Report Writing For MarketersNoha76
 
Top 10 patent interview questions with answers
Top 10 patent interview questions with answersTop 10 patent interview questions with answers
Top 10 patent interview questions with answerstaylorrhiannon07
 
Sample Report Format
Sample Report FormatSample Report Format
Sample Report Formatvikram singh
 
How to write a report
How to write a reportHow to write a report
How to write a reportsergeiG
 
Report writing
Report writingReport writing
Report writingimporterss
 
Paper I , communication assignment.
Paper   I , communication assignment.Paper   I , communication assignment.
Paper I , communication assignment.Deepen Upadhyay
 
REPORT WRITING:TYPES, FORMAT, STRUCTURE AND RELEVANCE
REPORT WRITING:TYPES, FORMAT, STRUCTURE AND RELEVANCEREPORT WRITING:TYPES, FORMAT, STRUCTURE AND RELEVANCE
REPORT WRITING:TYPES, FORMAT, STRUCTURE AND RELEVANCETulika Paul
 
Process of communication
Process of communicationProcess of communication
Process of communicationSweetp999
 
Definition and types of research
Definition and types of researchDefinition and types of research
Definition and types of researchfadifm
 
Report Writing - Introduction section
Report Writing - Introduction sectionReport Writing - Introduction section
Report Writing - Introduction sectionSherrie Lee
 

Viewers also liked (18)

2014 Student Information Systems Market Trends Report Sample
2014 Student Information Systems Market Trends Report Sample2014 Student Information Systems Market Trends Report Sample
2014 Student Information Systems Market Trends Report Sample
 
Report format
Report formatReport format
Report format
 
Writing a Report (Tips and Sample of Reports)
Writing a Report (Tips and Sample of Reports)Writing a Report (Tips and Sample of Reports)
Writing a Report (Tips and Sample of Reports)
 
A Fighter’s Lines Revision
A Fighter’s Lines RevisionA Fighter’s Lines Revision
A Fighter’s Lines Revision
 
Report On Business Communication
Report On Business CommunicationReport On Business Communication
Report On Business Communication
 
Business communication assignment
Business communication assignmentBusiness communication assignment
Business communication assignment
 
Organisational Communication
Organisational CommunicationOrganisational Communication
Organisational Communication
 
Sample Report Writing For Marketers
Sample Report Writing For MarketersSample Report Writing For Marketers
Sample Report Writing For Marketers
 
Top 10 patent interview questions with answers
Top 10 patent interview questions with answersTop 10 patent interview questions with answers
Top 10 patent interview questions with answers
 
Sample Report Format
Sample Report FormatSample Report Format
Sample Report Format
 
How to write a report
How to write a reportHow to write a report
How to write a report
 
Report writing
Report writingReport writing
Report writing
 
Paper I , communication assignment.
Paper   I , communication assignment.Paper   I , communication assignment.
Paper I , communication assignment.
 
REPORT WRITING:TYPES, FORMAT, STRUCTURE AND RELEVANCE
REPORT WRITING:TYPES, FORMAT, STRUCTURE AND RELEVANCEREPORT WRITING:TYPES, FORMAT, STRUCTURE AND RELEVANCE
REPORT WRITING:TYPES, FORMAT, STRUCTURE AND RELEVANCE
 
Process of communication
Process of communicationProcess of communication
Process of communication
 
Definition and types of research
Definition and types of researchDefinition and types of research
Definition and types of research
 
Report Writing - Introduction section
Report Writing - Introduction sectionReport Writing - Introduction section
Report Writing - Introduction section
 
Types of Research
Types of ResearchTypes of Research
Types of Research
 

Similar to Patent Technology Evaluation Report

Data Science Application in Business Portfolio & Risk Management
Data Science Application in Business Portfolio & Risk ManagementData Science Application in Business Portfolio & Risk Management
Data Science Application in Business Portfolio & Risk ManagementData Science Thailand
 
How to proactively manage your MEMS IP (or any IP for that matter), by Sergio...
How to proactively manage your MEMS IP (or any IP for that matter), by Sergio...How to proactively manage your MEMS IP (or any IP for that matter), by Sergio...
How to proactively manage your MEMS IP (or any IP for that matter), by Sergio...Fides Sales
 
Technology scouting in Questel Orbit
Technology scouting in Questel OrbitTechnology scouting in Questel Orbit
Technology scouting in Questel OrbitNurjahan M
 
The Technology Radar - a Tool of Technology Intelligence and Innovation Strategy
The Technology Radar - a Tool of Technology Intelligence and Innovation StrategyThe Technology Radar - a Tool of Technology Intelligence and Innovation Strategy
The Technology Radar - a Tool of Technology Intelligence and Innovation StrategyRené Rohrbeck
 
IntelliSemantc - Second generation semantic technologies for patents
IntelliSemantc - Second generation semantic technologies for patentsIntelliSemantc - Second generation semantic technologies for patents
IntelliSemantc - Second generation semantic technologies for patentsAlberto Ciaramella
 
Patent Search: An important new test bed for IR
Patent Search: An important new test bed for IRPatent Search: An important new test bed for IR
Patent Search: An important new test bed for IRGiovanna Roda
 
Innovation screening top view assessment - novocus legal llp
Innovation screening   top view assessment - novocus legal llpInnovation screening   top view assessment - novocus legal llp
Innovation screening top view assessment - novocus legal llpRuchica Kumar
 
Intellectual Property Management: a TRIZ-based approach to manage innovatio...
Intellectual Property Management: a TRIZ-based approach to   manage innovatio...Intellectual Property Management: a TRIZ-based approach to   manage innovatio...
Intellectual Property Management: a TRIZ-based approach to manage innovatio...Roberto Nani
 
Commercialization Options for a set of Wireless Patents
Commercialization Options for a set of Wireless PatentsCommercialization Options for a set of Wireless Patents
Commercialization Options for a set of Wireless PatentsShanmukha S. Potti
 
Anna university syllabus for mechanical engg 8th sem www.annaunivedu.org
Anna university syllabus for mechanical engg 8th sem   www.annaunivedu.orgAnna university syllabus for mechanical engg 8th sem   www.annaunivedu.org
Anna university syllabus for mechanical engg 8th sem www.annaunivedu.organnaunivedu
 
Consumer Physics SCiO Molecular Sensor Patent-to-Product Mapping Sample
Consumer Physics SCiO Molecular Sensor Patent-to-Product Mapping SampleConsumer Physics SCiO Molecular Sensor Patent-to-Product Mapping Sample
Consumer Physics SCiO Molecular Sensor Patent-to-Product Mapping SampleKnowmade
 
Internet of Things (IoT) Strategic Patent Development and Monetization 1Q 2016
Internet of Things (IoT) Strategic Patent Development and Monetization 1Q 2016Internet of Things (IoT) Strategic Patent Development and Monetization 1Q 2016
Internet of Things (IoT) Strategic Patent Development and Monetization 1Q 2016Alex G. Lee, Ph.D. Esq. CLP
 
Market for next generation aircraft propulsion systems
Market for next generation aircraft propulsion systemsMarket for next generation aircraft propulsion systems
Market for next generation aircraft propulsion systemssidbisresearch
 
Second generation semantic technologies for patent analysis
Second generation semantic technologies for patent analysisSecond generation semantic technologies for patent analysis
Second generation semantic technologies for patent analysisIntelliSemantic
 
Training on IP Management to enhance Intellectual Capital
Training on IP Management to enhance Intellectual CapitalTraining on IP Management to enhance Intellectual Capital
Training on IP Management to enhance Intellectual CapitalH.P. Lem
 
The Metrics Cards. A Balanced Set of Measures ISO/IEC 15504 compliant
The Metrics Cards. A Balanced Set of Measures ISO/IEC 15504 compliantThe Metrics Cards. A Balanced Set of Measures ISO/IEC 15504 compliant
The Metrics Cards. A Balanced Set of Measures ISO/IEC 15504 compliantLuigi Buglione
 
Bismuth Nanoparticles - Technology Overview - Ruchica Kumar
Bismuth Nanoparticles - Technology Overview - Ruchica KumarBismuth Nanoparticles - Technology Overview - Ruchica Kumar
Bismuth Nanoparticles - Technology Overview - Ruchica KumarRuchica Kumar
 
II-SDV 2012 Expert System Driven Insights into Patent Quality and Competitive...
II-SDV 2012 Expert System Driven Insights into Patent Quality and Competitive...II-SDV 2012 Expert System Driven Insights into Patent Quality and Competitive...
II-SDV 2012 Expert System Driven Insights into Patent Quality and Competitive...Dr. Haxel Consult
 
CambridgeIP Webinar: Developing a fact Based IP Strategy
CambridgeIP Webinar: Developing a fact Based IP StrategyCambridgeIP Webinar: Developing a fact Based IP Strategy
CambridgeIP Webinar: Developing a fact Based IP StrategyCambridgeIP Ltd
 

Similar to Patent Technology Evaluation Report (20)

Data Science Application in Business Portfolio & Risk Management
Data Science Application in Business Portfolio & Risk ManagementData Science Application in Business Portfolio & Risk Management
Data Science Application in Business Portfolio & Risk Management
 
How to proactively manage your MEMS IP (or any IP for that matter), by Sergio...
How to proactively manage your MEMS IP (or any IP for that matter), by Sergio...How to proactively manage your MEMS IP (or any IP for that matter), by Sergio...
How to proactively manage your MEMS IP (or any IP for that matter), by Sergio...
 
Technology scouting in Questel Orbit
Technology scouting in Questel OrbitTechnology scouting in Questel Orbit
Technology scouting in Questel Orbit
 
The Technology Radar - a Tool of Technology Intelligence and Innovation Strategy
The Technology Radar - a Tool of Technology Intelligence and Innovation StrategyThe Technology Radar - a Tool of Technology Intelligence and Innovation Strategy
The Technology Radar - a Tool of Technology Intelligence and Innovation Strategy
 
Internet das Coisas
Internet das CoisasInternet das Coisas
Internet das Coisas
 
IntelliSemantc - Second generation semantic technologies for patents
IntelliSemantc - Second generation semantic technologies for patentsIntelliSemantc - Second generation semantic technologies for patents
IntelliSemantc - Second generation semantic technologies for patents
 
Patent Search: An important new test bed for IR
Patent Search: An important new test bed for IRPatent Search: An important new test bed for IR
Patent Search: An important new test bed for IR
 
Innovation screening top view assessment - novocus legal llp
Innovation screening   top view assessment - novocus legal llpInnovation screening   top view assessment - novocus legal llp
Innovation screening top view assessment - novocus legal llp
 
Intellectual Property Management: a TRIZ-based approach to manage innovatio...
Intellectual Property Management: a TRIZ-based approach to   manage innovatio...Intellectual Property Management: a TRIZ-based approach to   manage innovatio...
Intellectual Property Management: a TRIZ-based approach to manage innovatio...
 
Commercialization Options for a set of Wireless Patents
Commercialization Options for a set of Wireless PatentsCommercialization Options for a set of Wireless Patents
Commercialization Options for a set of Wireless Patents
 
Anna university syllabus for mechanical engg 8th sem www.annaunivedu.org
Anna university syllabus for mechanical engg 8th sem   www.annaunivedu.orgAnna university syllabus for mechanical engg 8th sem   www.annaunivedu.org
Anna university syllabus for mechanical engg 8th sem www.annaunivedu.org
 
Consumer Physics SCiO Molecular Sensor Patent-to-Product Mapping Sample
Consumer Physics SCiO Molecular Sensor Patent-to-Product Mapping SampleConsumer Physics SCiO Molecular Sensor Patent-to-Product Mapping Sample
Consumer Physics SCiO Molecular Sensor Patent-to-Product Mapping Sample
 
Internet of Things (IoT) Strategic Patent Development and Monetization 1Q 2016
Internet of Things (IoT) Strategic Patent Development and Monetization 1Q 2016Internet of Things (IoT) Strategic Patent Development and Monetization 1Q 2016
Internet of Things (IoT) Strategic Patent Development and Monetization 1Q 2016
 
Market for next generation aircraft propulsion systems
Market for next generation aircraft propulsion systemsMarket for next generation aircraft propulsion systems
Market for next generation aircraft propulsion systems
 
Second generation semantic technologies for patent analysis
Second generation semantic technologies for patent analysisSecond generation semantic technologies for patent analysis
Second generation semantic technologies for patent analysis
 
Training on IP Management to enhance Intellectual Capital
Training on IP Management to enhance Intellectual CapitalTraining on IP Management to enhance Intellectual Capital
Training on IP Management to enhance Intellectual Capital
 
The Metrics Cards. A Balanced Set of Measures ISO/IEC 15504 compliant
The Metrics Cards. A Balanced Set of Measures ISO/IEC 15504 compliantThe Metrics Cards. A Balanced Set of Measures ISO/IEC 15504 compliant
The Metrics Cards. A Balanced Set of Measures ISO/IEC 15504 compliant
 
Bismuth Nanoparticles - Technology Overview - Ruchica Kumar
Bismuth Nanoparticles - Technology Overview - Ruchica KumarBismuth Nanoparticles - Technology Overview - Ruchica Kumar
Bismuth Nanoparticles - Technology Overview - Ruchica Kumar
 
II-SDV 2012 Expert System Driven Insights into Patent Quality and Competitive...
II-SDV 2012 Expert System Driven Insights into Patent Quality and Competitive...II-SDV 2012 Expert System Driven Insights into Patent Quality and Competitive...
II-SDV 2012 Expert System Driven Insights into Patent Quality and Competitive...
 
CambridgeIP Webinar: Developing a fact Based IP Strategy
CambridgeIP Webinar: Developing a fact Based IP StrategyCambridgeIP Webinar: Developing a fact Based IP Strategy
CambridgeIP Webinar: Developing a fact Based IP Strategy
 

Recently uploaded

Factors to Consider When Choosing Accounts Payable Services Providers.pptx
Factors to Consider When Choosing Accounts Payable Services Providers.pptxFactors to Consider When Choosing Accounts Payable Services Providers.pptx
Factors to Consider When Choosing Accounts Payable Services Providers.pptxKatpro Technologies
 
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps ScriptAutomating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Scriptwesley chun
 
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024The Digital Insurer
 
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)wesley chun
 
The Codex of Business Writing Software for Real-World Solutions 2.pptx
The Codex of Business Writing Software for Real-World Solutions 2.pptxThe Codex of Business Writing Software for Real-World Solutions 2.pptx
The Codex of Business Writing Software for Real-World Solutions 2.pptxMalak Abu Hammad
 
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine KG and Vector search for enhanced R...
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine  KG and Vector search for  enhanced R...Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine  KG and Vector search for  enhanced R...
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine KG and Vector search for enhanced R...Neo4j
 
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024The Digital Insurer
 
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024Rafal Los
 
Raspberry Pi 5: Challenges and Solutions in Bringing up an OpenGL/Vulkan Driv...
Raspberry Pi 5: Challenges and Solutions in Bringing up an OpenGL/Vulkan Driv...Raspberry Pi 5: Challenges and Solutions in Bringing up an OpenGL/Vulkan Driv...
Raspberry Pi 5: Challenges and Solutions in Bringing up an OpenGL/Vulkan Driv...Igalia
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI SolutionsIAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI SolutionsEnterprise Knowledge
 
A Year of the Servo Reboot: Where Are We Now?
A Year of the Servo Reboot: Where Are We Now?A Year of the Servo Reboot: Where Are We Now?
A Year of the Servo Reboot: Where Are We Now?Igalia
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerThousandEyes
 
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdfBoost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdfsudhanshuwaghmare1
 
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘RTylerCroy
 
Advantages of Hiring UIUX Design Service Providers for Your Business
Advantages of Hiring UIUX Design Service Providers for Your BusinessAdvantages of Hiring UIUX Design Service Providers for Your Business
Advantages of Hiring UIUX Design Service Providers for Your BusinessPixlogix Infotech
 
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationFrom Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationSafe Software
 
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)Gabriella Davis
 
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonData Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonAnna Loughnan Colquhoun
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Factors to Consider When Choosing Accounts Payable Services Providers.pptx
Factors to Consider When Choosing Accounts Payable Services Providers.pptxFactors to Consider When Choosing Accounts Payable Services Providers.pptx
Factors to Consider When Choosing Accounts Payable Services Providers.pptx
 
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps ScriptAutomating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
 
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
 
The Codex of Business Writing Software for Real-World Solutions 2.pptx
The Codex of Business Writing Software for Real-World Solutions 2.pptxThe Codex of Business Writing Software for Real-World Solutions 2.pptx
The Codex of Business Writing Software for Real-World Solutions 2.pptx
 
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine KG and Vector search for enhanced R...
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine  KG and Vector search for  enhanced R...Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine  KG and Vector search for  enhanced R...
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine KG and Vector search for enhanced R...
 
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
 
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
 
Raspberry Pi 5: Challenges and Solutions in Bringing up an OpenGL/Vulkan Driv...
Raspberry Pi 5: Challenges and Solutions in Bringing up an OpenGL/Vulkan Driv...Raspberry Pi 5: Challenges and Solutions in Bringing up an OpenGL/Vulkan Driv...
Raspberry Pi 5: Challenges and Solutions in Bringing up an OpenGL/Vulkan Driv...
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
 
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI SolutionsIAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
 
A Year of the Servo Reboot: Where Are We Now?
A Year of the Servo Reboot: Where Are We Now?A Year of the Servo Reboot: Where Are We Now?
A Year of the Servo Reboot: Where Are We Now?
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
 
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdfBoost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
 
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
 
Advantages of Hiring UIUX Design Service Providers for Your Business
Advantages of Hiring UIUX Design Service Providers for Your BusinessAdvantages of Hiring UIUX Design Service Providers for Your Business
Advantages of Hiring UIUX Design Service Providers for Your Business
 
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationFrom Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
 
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
A Domino Admins Adventures (Engage 2024)
 
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonData Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
 

Patent Technology Evaluation Report

  • 1. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Patent Technology Evaluation and Evidence-of-Use Investigation for US Patent 5662768 Assignee: LSI Logic Corporation Title: “High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device” File date: September 21, 1995 Issue date September 2, 1997 Report Date: June 20, 2010
  • 2. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Table of Contents Page # Patent Technology Evaluation and Evidence-of-Use Investigation 1 Table of Contents and Figures 2-3 Introduction/Objective 4 Summary of Final Results 4-7 Patent Technology Evaluation 8 - 17 Introduction/Objective Summary of Results 9 Discussion 10 - 17 Evidence of Use Study - Part 1: Focused Citation Analysis 18 - 24 Introduction/Objective 19 Summary of Results 20 Discussion 21 - 24 Evidence of Use Study - Part 2: Technology Claim Diagrams 25 - 168 Introduction/Objective 26 Summary of Results 26 Discussion 27 - 168 Evidence-of-Use Study - Part 3: Patent Technology Utilization Research and Analysis 169 - 188 Introduction/Objective 170 - 171 Summary of Results 172 - 175 Discussion 176 - 188 References and Patent Links 189 - 191 2 IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606
  • 3. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. List of Figures Figures # Preferred Embodiments of Invention 1 Second Embodiment of Invention 2 Third Embodiment of Invention 3 Independent Claims Analysis – Claims 1, 15, 20 4 Independent Claims Analysis – Claims 24, 27, 33 5 Patent Groups reviewed and analyzed 6 Final Working Group Assignees 7 Table illustrating the top Groups 1 - 3 References 8 Chart illustrating the top Groups 1 - 3 References 9 Chart illustrating the top Groups 1 - 2 References 10 Technology Claim Diagrams 11 - 151 IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 3
  • 4. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Introduction/Objective A Patent Technology Evaluation and Evidence-of-Use Investigation was performed on US Patent 5662768 titled “High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device” (1) The patent had a filing date of September 21, 1995 and an issue date of September 2, 1997. The assignee was identified as LSI Logic Corporation. The objective of this project was to extract and evaluate the technical elements of the invention, attempt to determine which manufacturers and/or products might incorporate aspects of the invention, and provide documentation of the similarities. Results and conclusions are not a legal opinion. Summary of Final Results • US Patent 5662768 (‘768) describes a process for forming trenches having “high surface-area sidewalls with undulating profiles”. (1) • Claims 1 and 20 are the broadest claims. • Embodiments are included for both general trench structures (such as isolation) and trench memory capacitors. • Ten different Assignees were found to have patents on structures and/or processes that appeared to have multiple similar elements to claims of the ‘768 claims. These include Chartered Semiconductor,, Infineon Technologies AG, International Business Machines Corp, Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba, Micron Semiconductor, Nanya Technology Corporation, Samsung Electronics, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, United Microelectronics Corp., and Vanguard Semiconductor. Some of these cited the ‘768 as prior art. • Diagrams and text descriptions of current products from some of the Final Working Group patent Assignees appeared to show similarities to multiple elements of the ‘768 patent claims. Detailed cross-section images of actual parts and description of trench manufacturing processes may be required to compare claim elements to real-world product features. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 4
  • 5. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. LAM Research, Applied Materials, or Silicon Genesis Although their equipment is used by other manufacturers to fabricate a variety of semiconductor products, neither LAM Research, Applied Materials, or Silicon Genesis fabricates their own trench or stacked DRAMs so no further research was performed on these Assignees. Chartered Semiconductor Chartered Semiconductor is now a part of GlobalFoundries, who do not appear to currently utilize trench eDRAMs modules or any other trench-based memory technology. Chartered Semiconductor Chartered Semiconductor is now part of GlobalFoundries, who do not appear to currently utilize trench eDRAMs modules or any other trench-based memory technology. Infineon Infineon uses a deep trench capacitor-based DRAM cell with a “bottle-shaped” trench and hemispherical silicon grains (HSG) to extend the effective surface area. This may be similar to the elements of Claim 20 and others. International Business Machines Corp. IBM currently integrates a “bottle-shaped” embedded DRAM capacitor in their SOI-based processes. This may be similar to the elements of Claims 1, 20 and others. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 5
  • 6. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba Toshiba currently manufacturers a “bottle-shaped” trench capacitor embedded DRAM memory cell. This may have similarities to Claims 1, 20 and others. Micron Technology Micron Semiconductor currently manufacturers only stacked capacitor DRAM memories. Nanya Technology Corporation Nanya has used Qimonda trench (bottle-shaped) capacitor DRAM technology in the past , but is converting its capacity over to Micron Technology Inc. stacked-capacitor DRAM technology. The Qimonda devices may have similarities to Claim 20 and others. Inotera Memories Nanya and Micron Technology have a “Joint Technology Development Agreement” called Inotera Memories Inc. which currently has a deep trench capacitor DRAM (at 90nm – 75nm) but is converting to stacked- capacitor DRAM technologies at 50nm. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd Samsung currently utilizes Metal-Insulator-Metal (MIM) capacitor technology for DRAM cells. However, their Sphere-shaped Recess Channel Array Transistor (S-RACT) has some elements similar to Claim 20 of the ‘768 patent. Trench cross -section images of actual products would help determine if elements of Claims 1 and 20 are similar. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 6
  • 7. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company TSMC does not provide any embedded trench capacitor DRAM cells. United Microelectronics Corporation UMC has internally developed a trench capacitor 1-transistor, 1-capacitor bit cell high-density eDRAM memory solution called URAM for System-on-Chip (SoC) applications. This may have similarities to Claims 1, 20 and others. Vanguard Technology Vanguard has no current trench or stacked stand-alone DRAM or Embedded DRAM manufactured products IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 7
  • 8. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Patent Technology Evaluation US Patent 5662768 Assignee: LSI Logic Corporation Title: “High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device” File date: September 21, 1995 Issue date September 2, 1997 IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 8
  • 9. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Introduction/Objective As requested, US Patent 5662768 was reviewed and analyzed in detail to understand the key technical aspects and claimed elements of the invention, including: •Background of the invention •Problem the invention solves •How the invention solves the problem •Equipment/ Gases/Chemicals/Etch Chemistry and materials used •Applicable products (as defined in the patent) •Different embodiments •Elements of the independent claims Summary of Results • US Patent 5662768 (‘768) describes a process for forming trenches having high surface-area sidewalls with undulating profiles. (1) • Embodiments are included for both general trench structures and trench memory capacitors. • Independent claims 1 and 20 appear to define a trench only, and do not appear to have a trench capacitor limitation. • Independent claims 15, 24, 27, and 33 appear to be limited to trench capacitors. • Independent Claims 1 and 20 appear to be the broadest, possibly having elements similar to a variety of trench structures including interlayer vias, stacked capacitors, bottle-shaped trenches, and SRCAT (spherical recessed access transistors) DRAM select transistors. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 9
  • 10. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Patent Technology Evaluation US Patent 5662768 was reviewed and analyzed in detail to understand the key technical aspects and claimed elements of the invention. Background of the Invention The invention relates generally to methods of forming high-surface area trenches through a “substrate having chemically distinct strata” in silicon wafers during fabrication of integrated circuits. Trenches may form electrical isolation between MOS devices, or may serve as trench capacitors in dynamic random access memories. (1) Problem the Invention Solves At the time of the application, the available “trench-forming techniques have not yet proved able to reliably attain submicron trenches of the depth to width ratios necessary to reach the 64 megabit requirements”. (1) How the Invention Solves the Problem This invention provides a process for forming trenches having “nonlinear, high surface-area sidewalls” that “provide more capacitance per unit depth than comparable straight-walled trenches”. (1) Nonlinear trench sidewalls may have “rounded and/or undulating profiles, and may be formed by “nonlinear dopant concentration profiles in a substrate beneath a region where the trench is to be formed, and then subjecting the regions to a selective etching to remove material in highly-doped areas so the “trench sidewalls mirror the dopant concentration profile”. (1) IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 10
  • 11. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Summarized From Patent USP 5662768 (1) Equipment/ Gases/Chemicals/Etch Chemistry •Ion implantation with impurities such as germanium, oxygen (O 2 ), or argon. •Anisotropic etching to form the trench, such as reactive ion etching or selective sputter etching using conventional plasma reactors. •CF 4 and O 2 , with higher O 2 concentrations providing more preference for silicon etching. •The residual germanium regions are then oxidized by exposing the trench to an oxidizing environment to form germanium oxides (e.g., GeO 2 and/or GeO). •Oxygen ions using conventional ion implantation apparatus. The implanted oxygen will form some silicon oxide (in a silicon substrate), but not necessarily a stoichiometric SiO 2 . •Wet chemistry etch using potassium hydroxide (KOH). Applicable Materials •Substrates and layers of silicon, oxides, glasses, or other dielectrics. Applicable Products •Trench Storage Capacitor Dynamic Random Access Memories (DRAMs) •Interlayer or interlevel vias •Trench isolation Trench Shapes •Globe or hour-glass shape, triangular and other polygonal shapes. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 11
  • 12. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Embodiments of Invention (1) The various embodiments of the invention were extracted from the patent Description to illustrate details of the patent claims (Figures 1 – 3). The three embodiments included etched trenches with horizontal impurity regions, rounded bottoms, and integrated circuits containing transistor devices and trench capacitor structures with the inventive features. Excerpt from Patent Applicable Diagram “In a preferred embodiment, prior to the step of the (1) providing the impurity regions, the method includes a step of forming a first mask which exposes a region on the top surface of the substrate. Etched Trench The impurities are then introduced through the exposed region to form the impurity regions (by, for example, ion implantation). Thus, the exposed region approximately defines the impurity regions' sizes. After the impurities have been introduced, the exposed region is preferably narrowed by providing spacers to define the etchant access region. Etched impurity Thereafter, the trench is etched by, for example, regions reactive ion etching through the etchant access region.” (1) Figure 1. Details of Preferred Embodiment from USP5662768. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 12
  • 13. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Excerpt from Patent Applicable Diagram “In another aspect, the present invention provides a (1) semiconductor chip which can be characterized as including (1) a semiconductor substrate having an upper surface; and (2) a trench provided in the substrate and having one or more sidewalls. The trench includes, in turn, (i) a neck region of a Neck Etched defined first width located at the upper surface of the Region Trench semiconductor substrate, and (ii) a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, with the body region having at least one nonlinear region of a second defined width which is greater than the first defined width. In preferred embodiments, the sidewalls will have undulating or rounded shapes. The trenches meeting the above criteria can be used in trench capacitors which have a conformal dielectric Rounded layer on the sidewalls, and an electrically conductive Body Region material (e.g., polysilicon) provided interior to the trench and adjacent to the conformal dielectric layer. In this design, the semiconductor substrate and the electrically conductive material form plates of a trench capacitor.” (1) Figure 2. Details of a Second Aspect from USP5662768. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 13
  • 14. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Excerpt from Patent Applicable Diagram “A third aspect of the invention provides an integrated circuit incorporating active devices and trench capacitors in a semiconductor substrate. The integrated circuit may be characterized as including the following: (1) a plurality of trench capacitors each having an insulated storage plate within a trench in the semiconductor substrate; and (2) a plurality of active devices arranged in a No Diagrams of Third Aspect predefined circuit configuration with at least some of the plurality of trench capacitors. In such integrated circuits, at least some of the trench capacitors are provided in trenches having (i) a neck region of a defined first width located at the upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and (ii) a body region located below said neck and having at least one nonlinear region of a second defined width which is greater than the first defined width.” (1) Figure 3. Details of a Third Aspect from USP5662768. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 14
  • 15. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Independent Claims Analysis (1) All independent claims were analyzed and summarized to extract the key elements and understand each limitations. A Summary of the concepts for each independent claim are shown below. Summary of Claim 1 Summary of Claim 15 Summary of Claim 20 elements elements element - Method of etching trench in - Method of forming trench - Semiconductor chip substrate capacitor in substrate - Semiconductor substrate - One or more impurity regions - One or more impurity regions - Trench with one or more laterally extending over a first laterally extending over a first sidewalls width width - Neck region of first width - Etchant access region - Etchant access region - Body region with at least one narrower than first width narrower than first width nonlinear region of a second - One or more trench sidewalls - One or more trench sidewalls width greater than said first of substantially nonlinear of substantially nonlinear width shape shape (Note: Claim summaries are provided only to assist in understanding the general aspects of the claims. They are not meant to be and should not be used as a legal interpretation of the claim language or to determine possible legal claims associated with the patent). Figure 4. Summary of Independent Claims 1, 15, and 20 from USP5662768. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 15
  • 16. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Summary of Claim 24 Summary of Claim 27 Summary of Claim 33 elements elements elements - Semiconductor memory chip - Integrated circuit with - Digital system - Semiconductor substrate active devices and trench - Plurality of semiconductor - Trench having one or more capacitors integrated circuits sidewalls - Semiconductor substrate - Incorporating active devices and - Neck region of a first width - Plurality of trench trench capacitors in a - Body region of with at least capacitors with an semiconductor substrate one nonlinear region of a insulated storage plate - Plurality of integrated circuits second width greater than said - Plurality of active devices - Each including a plurality of trench first width in a circuit configuration capacitors with an insulated - Electrically conductive with at least one of the storage plate within each trench material interior to said trench capacitors - Plurality of active devices arranged trench whereby substrate and - At least some of the in a circuit configuration with at conductive material form trench capacitors are in least one of the trench capacitors plates of a trench capacitor trenches that - At least some of the trench - Have a neck region of a capacitors are in trenches that first width - Have a neck region of a first width - A body region of with at - A body region of with at least one least one nonlinear nonlinear region of a second width region of a second width greater than said first width greater than said first width Figure 5. Summary of Independent Claims 24, 27, and 33 from USP5662768. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 16
  • 17. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Non-Patent Literature References Introduction/Objective Non-patent Literature References in USP5662768 include three reports from Integrated Circuit Engineering (ICE) Corporation (highlighted in red below). These reports contained structural analysis of general fabrication process and detailed analysis of the memory cell on 16-Mbit and 64-Mbit DRAMs. The author of this sample Patent Technology Evaluation Report, David York, was Manager of Laboratory Services at ICE Corp during this period of time, and the referenced analyses was performed under his direction. Contact IC Microanalysis LLC for more information. Copies of these reports may be available for purchase from Chipworks in Ottawa, Canada. Other References from US Patent 5662768 (1) •Carter, B.J., Holland, J.P., Peltzer, E., Richardson, B., Bogle, E., Nguyen, H.T., Melaku, Y., Gates, D., and Ben-Dor, M., "Transformer Coupled Plasma Etch for the Fabrication of Sub-half Micron Structures", Abstract #967, Lam Research Corporation, Fremont, CA, 1992. •Singer, Peter, "Electrostatic Chucks in Wafer Processing", pp. 57-64, Semiconductor International, Apr. 1995. •"Texas Instruments TMX416100DZ 16-Megabit DRAM", Integrated Circuit Engineering Corporation, Report No. SUB 918-03, pp. 1-18, Aug. 1991. •"Hitachi HM51W64800J7 64 MBit DRAM", Integrated Circuit Engineering Corporation, Report No. SUB 9407- 04, pp. 1-12, Jul. 1994. "Hitachi HM5116100J8 16-Megabit DRAM", Integrated Circuit Engineering Corporation, Report No. SUB 9204- 02, pp. 1-18, Apr. 1992. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 17
  • 18. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Evidence of Use Investigation Part 1: Focused Citation Analysis US Patent 5662768 Assignee: LSI Logic Corporation Title: “High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device” File date: September 21, 1995 Issue date September 2, 1997 IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 18
  • 19. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Evidence-of-Use Investigation - Part 1: Focused Citation Analysis Introduction/Objective A Focused Citation Analysis was requested and performed in order to locate other patented products that might have multiple similar elements to those claimed in the ‘768 patent, potentially indicating which manufacturers (Assignees) might incorporate elements of the ‘768 in their products. The resulting Patents and Assignees formed a Final Working Group which was used for the Patent Technology Utilization Research and Analysis to locate possible current product use. The following Patent Groups were reviewed and analyzed (Figure 6): Group 1: USP 5662768 prior art patent citations (1) Group 2: Patents citing USP 5662768 as prior art (1) Group 3: Patents citing Groups 1 and 2 patents as prior art (and filed after the file date of the ‘768) Group 4: Patents citing Group 3 patents as prior art (and filed after the file date of the ‘768) Patents within these groups that had “some” similar structures and processes were subjected to a more detailed examination and analysis. Patents from the “some similar elements” group that had “multiple similar elements” then formed the Final Working Group. Some of the patents in the final group directly cited the ‘768 as prior art. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 19
  • 20. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Summary of Results Ten different Assignees were found to have patents on structures and/or process that appeared to have multiple similar elements to claims of the ‘768 claims (Figure 7). These include Chartered Semiconductor, Infineon Technologies AG, International Business Machines Corp, Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba, Micron Semiconductor, Nanya Technology Corporation, Samsung Electronics, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, United Microelectronics Corp., and Vanguard Semiconductor. The assignees included semiconductor manufacturers, foundries, and equipment manufacturers. Figures 8 and 9 show the top Group 1 – 3 Assignees by number of referenced patents. Figure 10 shows the top Group 1 – 2 Assignees by number of referenced patents. Seven patents from a variety of Assignees had diagrams that appeared to incorporate elements from multiple independent claims of the ‘768 patent (Figure 7). Eighteen patents from a variety of Assignees had diagrams that appeared to incorporate elements from Claims 1 and 20 (shown as an example) of the ‘768 patent. Technology Claim Diagrams (Figures 11 - 151) illustrate the similarities in detail. (Group 4) (Group 3) Patents that Patents that (Group 2) Reference Reference (Group 1) Patents that Group 3 as Groups 1 and ‘768 Prior Reference ‘768 Patent Prior Art 2 as Prior Art Art Citations ‘768 as Prior And Filed And Filed (Primary) Art After ‘768 File After ‘768 File Date Date Figure 6. Patent groups reviewed and analyzed. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 20
  • 21. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Patent Assignee US Patent # Applicable Independent Claims Chartered Semiconductor Inc. 6,313,008 1, 15, and 20 7,250,669 Infineon Technologies AG 6,426,254 1 and 20 International Business Machines Corporation 5,153,813 1, 15, 20, 24, 27, and 33 International Business Machines Corporation 6,696,344 1 and 20 International Business Machines Corporation 6,936,522 1 and 20 Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba 5,629,226 1, 15, 20, 24, and 27 Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba 6,600,189 1 and 20 Micron Technology, Inc. 6,518,615 1 and 20 Nanya Technology Corporation 6,716,757 1 and 20 6,800,535 6,664,161 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. 6,809,363 1, 15, 20, and 24 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd 7,633,117 1 and 20 Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company 6,624,018 1 and 20 United Microelectronics Corp. 5,449,630 1, 15, 20, and 24 Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation 5,943,581 1, 15, 20, 24, and 27 Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation 5,976,945 1 and 20 Figure 7. Final Working Group Assignee, similar patents, and applicable claims of patent ‘768. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 21
  • 22. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Top Assignees Patent Citations Patent Citations Groups 1, 2 Group 3 Applied Materials 0 141 Micron Semiconductor 5 102 LAM Research 0 96 Silicon Genesis Corporation 0 45 IBM 1 41 Intel Corporation 5 0 Toshiba 4 0 IBM 1 0 Vanguard 1 0 UMC 1 0 Chartered Semiconductor 1 0 Figure 8. Table illustrating the top Groups 1 - 3 References for USP5662768 by Assignee. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 22
  • 23. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Tokyo Electron, Ltd. 19 Silicon Genesis, Corporation 45 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. 12 Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. Micron Technology, Inc. 102 Applied Materials, Inc. Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Lam Research Corporation 96 Innovative Silicon, S.A. International Business Machines, Corp. Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba 12 Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba Lam Research Corporation International Business Machines, Corp. 41 Micron Technology, Inc. 20 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Innovative Silicon, S.A. Silicon Genesis, Corporation Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation 17 Tokyo Electron, Ltd. Applied Materials, Inc. 141 Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. 12 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 Figure 9. Chart illustrating the top Groups 1 - 3 References for USP5662768 by Assignee. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 23
  • 24. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Vanguard International Semiconductor… 1 Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. United Microelectronics Corp. 1 AmberWave Systems Corporation Texas Instruments - Acer Incorporated 1 Elpida Memory, Inc. STMicroelectronics S.A. 1 Hynix Semiconductor Inc. Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 1 Intel Corporation Renesas Technology Corp. 1 Micron Technology, Inc. 5 International Business Machines Corporation Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd. 1 Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba 4 Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd. International Business Machines Corporation 1 Micron Technology, Inc. Intel Corporation 5 Renesas Technology Corp. Hynix Semiconductor Inc. 1 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft Elpida Memory, Inc. 1 AmberWave Systems Corporation 1 STMicroelectronics S.A. Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. 1 Texas Instruments - Acer Incorporated 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 Figure 10. Chart illustrating the Groups 1 and 2 Patent References for USP5662768 by Assignee. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 24
  • 25. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Evidence of Use Investigation Part 2: Technology Claim Diagrams US Patent 5662768 Assignee: LSI Logic Corporation Title: “High surface area trenches for an integrated circuit device” File date: September 21, 1995 Issue date September 2, 1997 IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 25
  • 26. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Evidence-of-Use Investigation - Part 2: Technology Claim Diagrams Introduction/Objective Technology Claim Diagrams were requested and compiled in order to illustrate the similarities between the ‘768 patent claims and diagrams from the Final Working Group patents. These are detailed on pages 11 – 151. Summary of Results Seven patents from a variety of Assignees had diagrams that appeared to incorporate elements from multiple independent claims of the ‘768 patent (Figure 7). Eighteen patents (eleven additional) from a variety of Assignees had diagrams that appeared to incorporate elements from Claim 20 of the ‘768 patent. Assignees included include Chartered Semiconductor, Infineon Technologies AG, International Business Machines Corp, Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba, Micron Semiconductor, Nanya Technology Corporation, Samsung Electronics, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, United Microelectronics Corp., and Vanguard Semiconductor. Patented structures included trench capacitors, trench isolation, interlayer vias, and stacked capacitors. Some of the Assignees in the Final Working Group cite the ‘768 patent as prior art, indicating their inventions incorporate some aspects of the ‘768 invention. So it is possible that some of the products manufactured by the Assignees after the issue date of the ‘768 patent might also contain claimed aspects of the ‘768 patent. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 26
  • 27. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. Pages 27 – 85 are currently unavailable. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606
  • 28. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 1 Claim 1. A method of etching a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method comprising the following steps: providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear; defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; and providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch said trench such that said trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile. (1) Figure 70. Claim 1 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 86
  • 29. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (1) top surface (1) trench in a substrate (1) trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile Figure 71. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 87
  • 30. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (1) etchant access region of specified second width … narrower than said specified first width (1) one or more impurity regions … laterally extending over a first width (1) vertical concentration profile Figure 72. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 88
  • 31. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 15 Claim 15. A method of forming a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method comprising the following steps: providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear; defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch a trench such that said trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile; and forming a dielectric layer on said one or more sidewalls. (1) Figure 73. Claim 15 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 89
  • 32. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (15) top surface (15) trench in a substrate (15) trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile Figure 74. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 90
  • 33. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (15) etchant access region of specified second width … narrower than said specified first width (15) one or more impurity regions … laterally extending over a first width (15) vertical concentration profile Figure 75. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 91
  • 34. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (15) dielectric layer Figure 76. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 92
  • 35. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 20 Claim 20. A semiconductor chip comprising: a semiconductor substrate having an upper surface; and a trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls, said trench including, a neck region of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said body region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width. (1) Figure 77. Claim 20 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 93
  • 36. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (20) upper surface (20) semiconductor chip (20) neck region of a first width located at (20) trench provided in said said upper surface substrate and having one or more sidewalls (20) body region has at least one nonlinear region (20) body region of a second width which is located below said greater than said first neck region width Figure 78. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 94
  • 37. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (20) neck region of a first width located at (20) body region has at said upper least one nonlinear surface region of a second width which is greater than said first width Figure 79. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 95
  • 38. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 24 Claim 24. A semiconductor memory chip comprising: a semiconductor substrate having an upper surface; a trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls, said trench including, a neck region of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said body region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width; and an electrically conductive material provided interior to said trench and adjacent to said conformal dielectric layer *, whereby said semiconductor substrate and said electrically conductive material form plates of a trench capacitor. * Note: “said conformal dielectric layer” identified in dependent claim 23, but not in Claim 24 Figure 80. Claim 24 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 96
  • 39. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (24) semiconductor memory chip The novel DRAM cell structure and method for making a high- density array of DRAM cells having these novel buried reservoir capacitors is described in detail. The DRAM cells are formed using N-channel field effect transistors (N-FETs) as the access transistors in each of the memory cells formed in and on an epitaxial layer over the buried reservoir capacitors. Figure 81. Patent language from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 97
  • 40. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (24) upper surface (24) trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls (24) body region located below said neck region Figure 82. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 98
  • 41. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (24) neck region of a first width located at (24) body region has at said upper least one nonlinear surface region of a second width which is greater than said first width Figure 83. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 99
  • 42. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (24) electrically conductive material provided interior to said trench (24) conformal dielectric layer Figure 84. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 100
  • 43. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation Claim 27. An integrated circuit incorporating active devices and trench capacitors in a semiconductor substrate having a top surface, the integrated circuit comprising: a plurality of trench capacitors each having an insulated storage plate within a trench in the semiconductor substrate; and a plurality of active devices arranged in a circuit configuration with at least some of said plurality of trench capacitors, wherein at least some of the trench capacitors are provided in trenches having (i) a neck region of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and (ii) a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said body region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width. (1) Figure 85. Claim 27 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 101
  • 44. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (27) integrated circuit incorporating active devices and (27) plurality of trench capacitors trench capacitors The novel DRAM cell structure and method for making a high- density array of DRAM cells having these novel buried reservoir capacitors is described in detail. The DRAM cells are formed using N-channel field effect transistors (N-FETs) as the access transistors in each of the memory cells formed in and on an epitaxial layer over the buried reservoir capacitors. (27) plurality of active devices arranged in a circuit configuration Figure 86. Patent language from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 102
  • 45. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (27) top surface (27) body region located below said neck region Figure 87. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 103
  • 46. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (27) neck region of a first width located at (27) body region has at said upper least one nonlinear surface region of a second width which is greater than said first width Figure 88. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 104
  • 47. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation (27) integrated circuit incorporating active devices and trench capacitors (27) electrically conductive material provided interior to said trench (27) insulated storage plate within a trench (27) at least some of the trench capacitors are provided in trenches Figure 89. Patent diagrams from US Patent 5943581 - Vanguard International Semiconductor Corporation. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 105
  • 48. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 1 Claim 1. A method of etching a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method comprising the following steps: providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear; defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; and providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch said trench such that said trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile. (1) Figure 90. Claim 1 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 106
  • 49. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. (1) top surface (1) trench in a substrate (1) trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile Figure 91. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 107
  • 50. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. (1) etchant access region of specified second width … narrower than said specified first width (1) one or more impurity regions … laterally extending over a first width (1) vertical concentration profile Figure 92. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 108
  • 51. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 15 Claim 15. A method of forming a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method comprising the following steps: providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear; defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch a trench such that said trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile; and forming a dielectric layer on said one or more sidewalls. (1) Figure 93. Claim 15 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 109
  • 52. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. (15) top surface (15) trench in a substrate (15) trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile Figure 94. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 110
  • 53. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. (15) etchant access region of specified second width … narrower than said specified first width (15) one or more impurity regions … laterally extending over a first width (15) vertical concentration profile Figure 95. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 111
  • 54. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. The hole is filled with a insulating material to form a balloon shaped shallow trench isolation (STI) region. The substrate has active areas between said balloon shaped shallow trench isolation (STI) regions. (15) dielectric layer Figure 96. Patent language from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 112
  • 55. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic, Inc. - Claim 20 Claim 20. A semiconductor chip comprising: a semiconductor substrate having an upper surface; and a trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls, said trench including, a neck region of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said body region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width. (1) Figure 97. Claim 20 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 113
  • 56. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. As shown in FIG. 1, a barrier layer 1418 is formed over a substrate 10. The substrate may be a conventional Si substrate or a SIO substrate or any substrate using in semiconductor manufacturing. (20) semiconductor chip Figure 98. Patent language from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 114
  • 57. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. (20) upper surface (20) neck region of a (20) trench provided in said first width located at substrate and having one or said upper surface more sidewalls (20) body region has at (20) body region least one nonlinear region located below said of a second width which is neck region greater than said first width Figure 99. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 115
  • 58. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. (20) trench provided (20) neck region of a in said substrate and first width located at having one or more said upper surface sidewalls (20) body region located below said neck region (20) body region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width Figure 100. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 116
  • 59. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. (20) neck region of a first width located at said upper surface (20) body region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width Figure 101. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6313008 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 117
  • 60. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic, Inc. – Claim 1 Claim 1. A method of etching a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method comprising the following steps: providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear; defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; and providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch said trench such that said trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile. (1) Figure 102. Claim 1 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 118
  • 61. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG) (1) top surface (1) vertical concentration profile (1) etchant access (1) one or more region of specified impurity regions second width … … laterally narrower than said extending over a specified first width first width Figure 103. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 119
  • 62. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG) (1) trench in a substrate (1) trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile Figure 104. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 120
  • 63. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 15 Claim 15. A method of forming a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method comprising the following steps: providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear; defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch a trench such that said trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile; and forming a dielectric layer* on said one or more sidewalls. (1) * Not present Figure 105. Claim 15 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 121
  • 64. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG) (15) top surface (15) vertical concentration profile (15) etchant access region of specified second width … (15) one or more narrower than said impurity regions … specified first width laterally extending over a first width Figure 106. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 122
  • 65. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG) (15) trench in a substrate (15) dielectric layer (not present) (15) trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile Figure 107. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 123
  • 66. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic, Inc. - Claim 20 Claim 20. A semiconductor chip comprising: a semiconductor substrate having an upper surface; and a trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls, said trench including, a neck region of a first width located at said upper surface of the semiconductor substrate, and a body region located below said neck region in the semiconductor substrate, wherein said body region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width. (1) Figure 108. Claim 20 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 124
  • 67. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG) (20) upper surface (20) semiconductor chip (20) trench provided in said substrate and having one or more sidewalls Figure 109. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 125
  • 68. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Ltd. (Singapore, SG) (20) neck region of a (20) body region first width located below said located at neck region said upper surface (20) body region has at least one nonlinear region of a second width which is greater than said first width Figure 110. Patent diagrams from US Patent 7250669 - Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing Inc. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 126
  • 69. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 – LSI Logic, Inc. – Claim 1 Claim 1. A method of etching a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method comprising the following steps: providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear; defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; and providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch said trench such that said trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile. (1) Figure 111. Claim 1 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 127
  • 70. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR) (1) top surface Figure 112. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 128
  • 71. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR) (1) etchant access region of specified second width … narrower than said (1) trench in a substrate specified first width (1) trench has one or (1) one or more more sidewalls of impurity regions … substantially nonlinear laterally extending shape corresponding to over a first width said vertical concentration profile Figure 113. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 129
  • 72. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR) As shown in FIG. 4 , the top section 54 having a small diameter is mounted on the base section 52 having a large diameter, so the storage electrode layer 50 has the geometrically stable structure. That is, the bottom of the storage electrode layer 50 is larger than an inlet thereof. Referring to FIG. 6 , impurities such as Ar or N 2 are implanted into the insulating layer 56 in order to increase the etching rate when the cleaning process is carried out. (1) etchant access (1) vertical region of specified concentration second width … profile narrower than said specified first width Figure 114. Patent language from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. IC Microanalysis LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 130
  • 73. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 5662768 - LSI Logic Inc. – Claim 15 Claim 15. A method of forming a trench in a substrate having a top surface, the method comprising the following steps: providing one or more impurity regions in the substrate beneath the top surface of said substrate, said one or more impurity regions laterally extending over a first width and defining a vertical concentration profile which is substantially nonlinear; defining an etchant access region of specified second width on said top surface above the one or more impurity regions, said second width being narrower than said specified first width; providing etchant through said etchant access region to etch a trench such that said trench has one or more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to said vertical concentration profile; and forming a dielectric layer* on said one or more sidewalls. (1) * dielectric layer (not present) Figure 115. Claim 15 from LSI Logic, Inc. US Patent 5662768 . IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 131
  • 74. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR) (15) top surface Figure 116. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 132
  • 75. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR) (15) etchant access (15) trench in a substrate region of specified second width … narrower than said (15) trench has one or specified first width more sidewalls of substantially nonlinear shape corresponding to (15) one or more said vertical impurity regions … concentration profile laterally extending over a first width (15) dielectric layer (not present) Figure 117. Patent diagrams from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. IC Microanalysis, LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 133
  • 76. This “Sample Report” is not provided for, or intended to be, legal evidence of patent infringement or non-infringement. US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Suwon, KR) As shown in FIG. 4 , the top section 54 having a small diameter is mounted on the base section 52 having a large diameter, so the storage electrode layer 50 has the geometrically stable structure. That is, the bottom of the storage electrode layer 50 is larger than an inlet thereof. Referring to FIG. 6 , impurities such as Ar or N 2 are implanted into the insulating layer 56 in order to increase the etching rate when the cleaning process is carried out. (15) etchant access (15) vertical region of specified concentration second width … profile narrower than said specified first width Figure 118. Patent language from US Patent 6809363 - Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. IC Microanalysis LLC - www.icmicroanalysis.com - Email: icmicroanalysis@cox.net - Phone: 602-828-2606 134