The slideshow traces the development of CALL, distinguishes between digital immigrants and natives, describes the advantages and pitfalls of IT + ELT and suggests a new role for the ELTs using IT. Takeaways suggest moderation in IT use and saving the best of older tried and true techniques to go with the newer technology-based approaches.
1. ELT + IT: CALL for a Balance
Happiness is not a matter of intensity but of balance,
order, rhythm and harmony.
Thomas Merton
2. 10 Questions to Consider
1. Who are the digital natives and are they
getting restless?
2. How does ELT + IT help ELLs attain 21st
century literacy?
3. How does ELT + IT improve language
learning?
4. What are some of the pitfalls of ELT + IT?
5. Are there any “angels” to help us with ELT
+ IT?
2
3. 10 Questions to Consider
6. How can teachers prepare for ELT + IT?
7. Do our D.N. students really need our IT
guidance?
8. What is the teacher’s role in the ELT + IT
classroom?
9. What really makes a successful ELT?
10. What can you take away from this
presentation?
3
4. Who are the digital natives?
Joe Morelock – Canby, Oregon School District
4
5. Who are the digital natives?
People born into technology (after 1980)
How many of you are digital natives?
– Never used a typewriter
– Don’t check your watch for the time
– Spent 5K hrs reading but 10K hrs video games
by college graduation
5
6. Who are the digital immigrants?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/schlaus/926911366/ 6
7. Who are the digital immigrants?
We adopt technology but have a digital
immigrant “accent”
– Wear wristwatches (to tell time, not just for
fashion)
– Remember waiting for photos to be “developed”
– Still buy CDs for some of our music!
7
9. Why are D.N.s getting restless?
DI assumptions about learning don’t
match DN assumptions.
DNs can’t use their digital information
tools in the classroom.
DNs don’t feel the classroom
experience prepares them for global
environment.
9
11. Questions to consider:
Do the students in the video remind you of
your students? Why? Why not?
Do DNs really learn differently? Can DNs
actually multitask efficiently?
Should the DN students learn the old ways
or should their DI teachers learn the new?
Is there any middle ground?
11
12. What skills must ELLs possess?
21st century literacy skills (Warschauer)
– Academic Literacy - competencies
related to academic work.
– Not new to us
» Summarizing
» Critical Reading
» Researching
12
13. What skills must ELLs possess?
21st century literacy skills (Warschauer)
– Digital Literacy - Competencies related to creation
and use of digital materials
» Computer Literacy
» Information Literacy
» Multimedia Literacy
» Computer Mediated Communication Literacy
13
14. Why do our students need to attain
this new literacy?
“Technological Know-How
is a Job Requirement”
– Daniel Gulati, Harvard Business
Review, March 2012
http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2012/03/technological_know-
how_is_a_job_requirement.html?awid=6493846415991042466-3271
14
15. Is there another reason?
“In our Information Age
twenty-first century society,
knowledge is the coin of the
realm and the ability to
think critically is a
prerequisite for democratic
participation.” Panama government in session
http://www.panama1.com/gobierno.php
Cummins, Brown and Sayers: Literacy,Technology,
and Diversity. 2007, p. vi
15
16. And yet another?
National borders becoming
less important
Globalization allows access
to playing field
More opportunities but more
competition
Digitally literate citizens
will have the edge!
http://www.thomaslfriedman.com/bookshelf/the-world-is-
flat 16
17. How does ELT + IT improve language learning?
Authenticity (unlimited access to authentic materials,
communication and publishing)
Literacy (read, write, communicate, research & publish on
Internet = 21st century literacy)
Interaction (key to acquiring fluency; Internet provides
stimulus and opportunity)
Vitality (flexible, modern medium; provides opportunity
for meaningful, relevant work)
Empowerment (mastery allows teachers and students to
become lifelong learners).
Internet for English Teaching, Warschauer, Shetzer & Meloni, TESOL, 2000.
17
18. What is Web 2.0? How is it used in ELT?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F1IRkqbUoXY
18
19. Web 2.0 supports the 21st century model
Warschauer in “The Death of Cyberspace and the Rebirth of CALL”
http://www.gse.uci.edu/faculty/markw/cyberspace.html
19
20. What about the pitfalls of ELT + IT?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/theta444/12372029/
20
21. What about the pitfalls of ELT + IT?
Time, time, time
– Learning new
tools/techniques
– Keeping up with
changes
– Technology
addiction
http://www.flickr.com/photos/thenandagain/26288869/
21
22. What about the pitfalls of ELT + IT?
David Pogue, New York Times, Feb 15, 2012
writes:
“OMG! Did you see Brad Pitt’s post on Digglr last
night?”
“No, I was too busy cruising Cr.us.ta.ce.an. What
did he say?”
“OMG, it was all over Regurgtatr!”
Have you ever had the sinking feeling that the
online world is moving so fast that you’ll never
22
catch up?
23. Every year, there’s another hot new online service,
another drain into which to pour your time.
Question: Once you’re on Facebook and Twitter and
Foursquare and Google Plus and Tumblr and
LinkedIn and Instagram and Reddit and Path —
when, exactly, do you have time left over for a life?
Well, never mind. Incredibly, yet another free site
has become white-hot popular, because it’s found yet
another purpose not quite served by anyone else . . .
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/16/technology/personaltech/reviewing-pinterest-the-newest-
social-media-site.html?_r=1&nl=technology&emc=cta2 23
24. What about the pitfalls of ELT + IT?
Are you drowning in information?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/will-lion/2595497078/ 24
25. What about the pitfalls of ELT + IT?
Are you getting “blurry-eyed?”
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/ 25
26. What about the pitfalls of ELT + IT?
Internet Safety
http://www.cskcst.com/ 26
27. What about the pitfalls of ELT + IT?
Distraction and loss of f2f interaction.
27
http://www.flickr.com/photos/theqspeaks/4944690645/
28. What about the pitfalls of ELT + IT?
"The ties we form through
the Internet are not, in the
end, the ties that bind.
But they are the ties that
preoccupy. . .” p. 280
Sherry Turkle, MIT technology and
society specialist.
http://alonetogetherbook.com/
28
29. Pitfall - Digital Divide
Lack of
connectivity
Lack of teacher
training
Lack of teacher
networking
http://www.olpcnews.com/countries/peru/the_achilles_heel_of_the_peru_deployment.html 29
30. Are there any “Angels” to help us?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/alicepopkorn/3616617104/ 30
31. Are there any “Angels” to help us?
(Mavens)
http://www.teachertrainingvideos.com/
31
32. Are there any “Angels” to help us?
(Mavens)
32
http://nikpeachey.blogspot.com/
33. Are there any “Angels” to help us?
(Web Sites)
http://elllo.org/ 33
34. Are there any “Angels” to help us?
(Web Sites)
http://www.ted.com/talks 34
35. Are there any “Angels” to help us?
(Tools)
http://www.diigo.com/index 35
36. Can you tell me about more “angel” resources?
You will find them here:
http://tinyurl.com/6qd8j9b
http://www.flickr.com/photos/alicepopkorn/3616617104/ 36
37. Self-education
– Get familiar with the TESOL technology
standards + vignettes
– Subscribe to CALL-IS VSL (Virtual Software
List)
– Subscribe to blogs/sites by Stannard, Peachey,
Ferlazzo
– Join social networks like Classroom 2.0, EFL
2.0, PETsNet (Victor Hugo)
– Attend professional conferences!
38. TESOL EVO Sessions 2012
(free and need not be TESOL member)
•Becoming a Webhead
•TESOL-Drama
•Digital Storytelling-Young Ls
•Digital Tools with a Purpose
•PLEs and PLNs
•Gamification
http://evosessions.pbworks.com/w/page/10708567/FrontPage
38
41. Do DN students really need IT guidance?
http://www.radpic.com/you_werent_downloaded.html 41
42. An ELL without ELT guidance:
Mayday! Mayday! Mayday!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSdxqIBfEAw 42
43. Do DN students really need guidance?
43
http://youtu.be/lpvgfmEU2Ck
44. Do DN students really need guidance?
Teachers
are the
critical lin
k!
44
http://www.flickr.com/photos/myklroventine/3400039523/
45. What is the role of the teacher in IT + ELT?
The Player-Coach
http://www.flickr.com/photos/zenmama/2126257888/ 45
46. The Player Coach
Leads the team but also participates
Has the same stake in success as the players
Applies expertise in setting goals and objectives
Designs meaningful practice to support improvement
Knows the strengths and weaknesses of the players
Strives to motivate all players
Assesses performance and gives constructive advice
Establishes an emotional bond with the players
46
47. What Makes a Successful ELT?
Inspiration
Enthusiasm
Professional competence
Attention to affective development of student
Tolerance, patience, warmth, sensibility and open-
mindedness
ROBINETT, B.W. (1977): «Characteristics of an Effective Second
Language Teacher» in M. Burt, H. DULAY and M. FINOCCHIARO
(eds.) (1977): Viewpoints on English as a Second Language. New
York: Regents Publishing Co. 47
49. “A Tech-Happy Professor Reboots After
Hearing His Teaching Advice Isn’t Working”
“I implemented your idea,
and it just didn’t work. The
students thought it was
chaos.” (Wesch colleague)
“It doesn’t matter what
method you use. . . you
must focus on . . . the bond
between teacher and
student.” (Wesch)
Michael Wesch
http://chronicle.com/article/A-Tech-Happy-Professor-Reboots/130741/ 49
50. Final Takeaways for ELT + IT
Technology is our ally, but not a silver bullet!
Technology can make a good teacher better, but
cannot make a bad teacher good!
Every old technology was once new. New is not
necessarily good. Old is not necessarily bad.
Beware, computers can serve as “digital cocaine”
both for digital natives and digital immigrants.
Everything in moderation. Strive for balance when
doing ELT + IT.
50
51. Use IT wisely! Be yourself in the classroom!
Enjoy your teaching!
Embrace your families and friends!
51
Editor's Notes
Usually have one photo. Today have two.
NEXT
Me! 1987 – My Mac Plus. No hard drive. Save work on 800 kb disk. This PPT slide would fill the disk. Cost = $2,500 !!
Don’t use email. Don’t visit Web sites. Maybe don’t own a computer. Dying breed? Can digital dinosaurs still be good teachers? YES! More on that later.
DNs used to receiving info rapidly, like to multi-task, parallel process, Prefer multimedia to text. Random to linear Outside classroom use cell phone, mp3 players, iPads, laptops. Facebook, Twitter, listen to music while work. DNs see wired world around them and don’t see class as relevant
Cultural anthropologist, award winning professor at Kansas State U., studies effects of new media in global society. Uses collaborative technology heavily in his teaching. We’ll come back to Michael Wesch later in the presentation. Might surprise you.
Whether we are DNs or Dis, we teachers must ask some important questions.
Computer literacy – pushing the right button. Swiping the right way on a touch screen (DNs good at this! Better than us DI)! Information literacy – find, read or view, save or throw away, if save how to find it again, evaluate for credibility Multimedia literacy – how to create digital material (blogs, wikis, podcasts) Computer Mediated literacy – how to engage in the social media arena. (not just email anymore: social networks, videoconferencing, etc.
To be competitive in the workplace. And not just for technology jobs – for all jobs including marketing, finance, management. Employers want workers who can use digital tools to collaborate, problem solve, and create. World economy now is a buyers market. Employers can choose to be picky.
Yes, Citizens must be informed for democracy to work. As of 2010, more Am’s got their news from Internet than from newspaper or radio.
Yes, in a flat world, Americans don’t just compete against Americans. Peruvians against Peruvians There is a global marketplace for BOTH collaboration AND competition!
SO DNs want to study with tech. tools. 21 st century literacy demands it too. Are there also reasons to have ELT + IT from a language learning perspective? YES! ELT + IT can make the classroom come ALIVE!
And what form is ELT + IT taking in the 21st century? Web 2.0 is the catchword. How many of you are using blogs, wikis and podcasts in your teaching? Let’s take about 5 minutes to hear from Graham Stanley, EFL teacher and trainer in Spain.
So, with Web 2.0 focus has moved toward information sharing, content creation. Look at a timeline from the 1970’s up to the 21 st century. Web 2.0 supports current teachings on CALL and second language learning
So, we have looked at several of the benefits of integrating tech. into language teaching. Are there no downsides? Of course, and many apply to tech. use in general, not just ELT
David Pogue, my favorite tech. writer. I rely on him to tell me about the newest sites and impact on society. Is there an addiction to the Internet and new Web 2.0 tools? Here is what he wrote.
Attitudes like this hint at the next pitfall – information overload!
How many identify with this?
Just some of the Web 2.0 tools. Learn about these and next month will be a new batch! Want more overload stats? Three billion Google searches every day. Sit down to watch Youtube, you’ll be finished in 412.3 years . 43 million hours spent on Facebook globally every day.– http://thefuturebuzz.com/2009/01/12/social-media-web-20-internet-numbers-stats/
Student privacy/ pornography/cyberbullying some concerns. Teachers and parents need to develop strategies to help young people be safe. Nancy Willard, expert from my home town has excellent Web site. Book + free materials
Personal digital devices can be a learning tool, but can also be a distraction to learning. Overuse can also lead to a loss of personal interaction Who do you think these teenagers are texting? “See http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/21/technology/21brain.html?pagewanted=all
Continue quote: We text each other at family dinners, while we jog, while we drive, as we push our children on swings in the park. We don't want to intrude on each other, so instead we constantly intrude on each other, but not in "real time." . . . We go online because we are busy but end up spending more time with technology and less with each other. We defend connectivity as a way to be close, even as we effectively hide from each other."
One laptop per child program. 300,000 laptops XO ($200 each or less) Getting Internet and establishing teacher networks is key to bringing rural kids along.
So, we have looked at the advantages of IT + ELT – they are many. We’ve looked at the Pitfalls too – they are many. Are there any angels to help us as we meet the challenges? Yes, I have time for only a few. You will see more in the presentations later in the day.
A maven (also mavin ) is a trusted expert in a particular field, who seeks to pass knowledge on to others. Russel Stannard is an ELT + IT maven. Teacher Training Videos - well over a hundred. Videos show you how to use the best ELT tools
Nik Peachey has 6 or more blogs/Web sites. Full of practical how to use Web resources in the classroom Very readable, practical. Includes lots of video. Look for the tags at the side of his blog pages – easy to search what you need.
ELLLO – favorite listening site on the Web. 100’s of activities with audio and video of native speakers of English. Permission to download audio files. Play them in the classroom without Internet. Students can listen on their mp3 players. Search for content to fit your lessons.
Videos of talks on Technology, Entertainment and Design (now includes much broader content). I believe in content-based teaching. Students don’t wake up eager to study English for English sake. They want to use English to learn interesting things and communicate for real purposes. Great content by great thinkers. Videos are subtitled. Spanish and English. Video content helps with comprehension
Really helps with information overload. Join Diigo bookmark with the click of a button on your browser. Add tags (descriptive words) so you can easily your collection. Can add highlighting or notes to Web pages. That’s how I prepared for this plenary Can form groups so students can collectively research and bookmark resources.
Here you will find many great resources with links to TTV videos and Nik Peachey blogs so you can learn to use the tools and see how they can be used in classes. Feel free to copy it now if you like.
TESOL tech standards – clear goals and objectives. A set of standards for teachers, students and administrators. CALL IS – a database of useful resources submitted by ELTs from around the world. Searchable, up to date. Constantly growing.
Offered once a year (just finished) Lead by ELT + IT leaders in the profession Hands-on learning based on best practices. The Best!
Excellent series of online courses last several weeks. Building Teaching Skills through the Interactive Web is one course. Apply through the Embassy, English Language Office.
3 week online course that I teach Have trained 100s of teachers over the years and it’s my privilege to do so. Mix of ELTs from around the world come together to create a learning community. Very hands-on,-- challenging but doable! with scholarships provided by the ELO.
So, now let’s turn to what I consider the most important aspect of this presentation – the role of the teacher. A first question to ask is “do our DN students” really need us? I say yes!! As Tom March, a long time leader in IT in education says, “The Internet can be an embarrassment of riches” without a qualified teacher to lead!
So let’s look at a couple of examples, which I hope you will enjoy, to see why our students truly do need us! How about preteaching some key vocabulary. Might have really helped in this situation. German coast guard employee using his Egnlish to help someone in trouble.
Another example which I hope you will enjoy – has to do with PowerPoint which we know and love (or hate)! Is knowing how to push the right buttons enough to make an effective PPT presentation?
We know that the Internet is a treasure trove of resources. It provides unparalleled ability to collaborate BUT universal access does not guarantee success. What is the critical link?
So I hope you will agree that our digital students do need us. Teachers are the critical links in providing effective integration of technology. My model is the “player-coach.” Bill Russell – Boston Celtics NBA basketball team – 11 championships in his 13 years. One of greatest players ever. 1966-69 accepted job as coach.
Let’s consider qualities the successful player coach must have. Let’s consider tasks the successful player coach must perform. Does this makes sense to you? Does this apply to our teaching?
As a DI who is getting older all the time, I decided to go back 40 years for some insight into qualities of a successful ELT. This is what I found.
In Exploring Web 2.0, teachers I work with complete a Wiki activity. Collaborate to answer question: What qualities make a successful ELT. Here are the results, displayed beautifully using Wordle, a Web 2.0 tool. What stands out for you?
2012 Chronicle of Higher Education Wesch still believes that technology enhances the classroom. But recognizes that everyone cannot teach the same way. He compliments a great lecturer at his institution who does not use tech. at all. Important: bond + present material interesting/organized way
So, what would I like to leave you with today. Here is a laundry list of some major points that I wanted to make