SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 40
Baixar para ler offline
UNDERSTANDING THE
DIVERSITY OF MORAL
BELIEFS:
CULTURAL RELATIVISM
Exercise-- Culture Clash
 What are some examples Rachels gives of
culture clash? Explain what makes them
unique, odd or different.
 With your group, brainstorm at least two
other examples of differing moral codes,
customs, or behaviors. Explain what
makes them unique, odd or different.
Cultural Relativism
 “Different cultures have different moral codes” often is
used as a key to understanding morality. Proponents
argue that there is not as universal truth in ethics; there
are only the various cultural codes and nothing more.
The customs of different societies is all that exist.
 Proponents would argue that customs can not be judged
as correct or incorrect.
 Our own code of ethics has no special status; it is merely
one among many
Tightening the Definition– The focus here is on whether or
not one culture can judge another; the focus is not on
whether or not one individual can judge another.
Cultural Relativism
Challenges our ordinary belief in the
objectivity and universality of moral truths--
 It says in effect that there is no such thing
as a universal truth or ethical standard
that can be applied.
 Refutes ethnocentrism-- Your own code
of ethics offers nothing special and is no
better than that of another culture.
Sounds appealing…
Cultural Relatvism
Response…
Discuss this video with your group and record
some of the points that come up.
Consider:
1) Should this practice be illegal? Can it be
deemed morally wrong?
2) Can you compare this practice with
cosmetic surgery?
3) What points made by members of the panel
stood out to you the most and why? What is
your reaction?
REVIEW
What is cultural relativism?
How does it challenge traditional
beliefs?
Some Conflicting Approaches
 Moral Realism (aka Moral Objectivism): There are
objective moral facts. Therefore, ethics is
somewhat like science: Its task is to discover (not
decide) what these moral facts are.
 Ethical Absolutists: There is a single standard
ethical standard; that standard is usually their own.
 Ethical (cultural or moral) Relativists: Each
culture as an island unto itself, right in its own
world, and they deny any overarching standard
with which conflicting cultures (not individuals) can
be judged.
 Ethical Pluralists: Cultures can legitimately pass
judgments on one another, but encourages us to
listen to what other cultures say about us as well
What happens when something that is
legally and morally permissible in one
culture is illegal and immoral in another?
 Female circumcision or genital
mutilation
 Marriage of underage girls
 Infanticide
 Polygamy
 Slavery
Conflicting Approaches
 Moral Realist– Try to examine the situation
and context to discover the moral “facts.”
 Ethical relativist—Each culture is right unto
itself, so such practices would be morally
permissible in some countries and morally
wrong in the US.
 Ethical absolutists—There is a single moral
truth in terms of which all cultures and
individuals are to be judged.
 Pluralists—Try to find some middle ground
(in some situations this practice may make
sense, less judgmental)
Different moral codes
 Reminder-- Different cultures have
different moral codes. What is right within
one group maybe abhorrent to another.
 Treatment of the dead
 Polygamy
 Sharing of wives among Eskimos
 Infanticide
What is our reaction to
“strange or different”
customs?
 Label them as backward, uneducated, or
primitive.
 Label them heathens…
 Discriminate or harass them.
 Convert them to “our” custom or thought.
correlates with imperialist approaches…
William Graham Sumner
 First professorship in sociology at Yale College
 Credited with coining the term “ethnocentrism”
 Anti-Imperialist
“’The right way’ is the way which the ancestors used
and which has been handed down. The tradition is its
own warrant. It is not held subject to verification by
experience. The notion of right is in the folkways.”
 This line of thought has probably persuaded more people
to be skeptical about ethics than any other single
statement.
“If we assume that our ethical ideas will
be shared by all people at all times,
we are merely naïve.”
Consider ethical ideas in our society
may have changed over the years…
 Divorce, Living together, Sex outside of marriage
Interracial marriage, Same sex marriages, Sex
education
 Gambling, casinos, internet poker
 Internet dating
 Women in the workforce, women in the army,
women working in “masculine” jobs
 Spanking/punishment of children
 Acceptance of cremation for the dead
 Animal welfare, Recognizing that animals have
certain rights
 Natural resource protection
 Taming “mother nature” vs. “living with nature”
Claims of Cultural Relativists
1. Different societies have different moral
codes.
2. The moral code of a society determines
what is right within that society.
3. There is no objective standard that can be
used to judge one societies code as better
than another.
4. The moral code of our society offers
nothing special.
5. There is no universal truth in ethics…
6. It is arrogant to judge the conduct of other
The Cultural Differences
Argument
A theory about the
nature of morality
At the heart of the
Cultural Relativism
is the form of their
argument.
The Cultural Differences
Argument
Premises:
1. Different cultures have different moral codes.
2. Therefore, there are no objective truth in morality.
Right and wrong are only matters of opinion, and
opinions vary from culture to culture.
This is cultural differences argument--They argue
from facts about differences between cultural outlooks to
making conclusions about the status of morality
How is this a logical fallacy? In other words, how is it
logically unsound?
The Unsoundness of the Cultural
Differences Argument
The trouble is that the conclusion does not
follow from the premise—that is even if the
premise is true, the conclusion might be false.
– logical fallacy is called non sequitur
WHY? The premise concerns what people
believe; some believe one way and others
believe another, but the conclusion concerns
what really is the case.
• Just because two cultures believe differently
does inherently mean that one belief cannot
Example
The Greeks believed it was wrong to eat the
dead.
The Callatians believed it was right.
Does it follow, from the mere fact that
they disagreed, that there is no
objective truth in the matter?
No, it does not follow—it could be objectively
right or wrong that one or the other was
simply mistaken.
The Fatal Flaw of the Cultural
Difference Argument
It attempts to derive a substantive
conclusion about a subject from the mere
fact that people disagree about it.
Caution: This is a simple point of logic. This
does not necessarily mean that the
conclusion is false, the logic is that the
conclusion does not follow from the premise.
The Consequences of
Accepting Cultural Relativism
1) We could no longer say that custom of other
societies are morally inferior to others. (This is
one of the main points of Cultural Relativism.)
+ We would have to stop condemning other
societies merely because they are
different.
- Tolerance towards slavery, anti Semitism,
hatred towards ethnic groups, or minorities,
child porn, sex slave trade
• If we took the cultural relativism seriously, we would
have to regard these behaviors as immune from
criticism as long as they are considered morally
acceptable within the practicing culture.
If we accept Cultural
Relativism
2) We could decide whether actions are right or
wrong just by consulting the standards of our
society.
In Colonial America slavery was OK, women
were not allowed to vote or own property,
primogeniture was practiced, etc.; therefore,
these things were right.
(+) deciding what is right or wrong in a situation
is easier
If we accept Cultural
Relativism
3) The idea of moral progress is called into doubt.
Progress implies doing things better, but cultural
relativism rejects making judgments about past
eras.
Reform movements such as rights for women
and minorities that implies modern society is
better is a judgment that is impossible to make.
Problems with Cultural
Relativism
1. No blame of other cultures for “wrong” or “evil”
deeds. Are cultures morally infallible?
2. No criticism of our own culture
3. No idea of moral progress
4. In a relativist society the view of the majority
rules. Is this fair?
5. Is tolerance a universal value, in which case
relativism is paradoxical?
7. Don’t we all instinctively believe that some
things are universally right and wrong?
The Result?
Many reject the cultural relativism arguments--
1. It makes sense to condemn some practices
wherever they occur.
2. It makes sense to acknowledge that our
society while imperfect has made moral
progress.
3. Because Cultural Relativism implies these
judgments make no sense, the argument goes,
it cannot be right.
There is Less Disagreement Than it
Seems (Across Cultures)
There are differences across societies, but
the differences are often over-stated. In fact,
there are some values that can be seen as
relatively universal because they are
necessary for societies to function.
 Need to explore not particular practices or
values, but the belief systems or
circumstances that lie behind the
practices.
 The differences are often in the belief
Source of Customs
Beliefs—religious beliefs
Physical circumstances of the society
Even if customs differ, there may be less
disagreement on basic values
Example: Eskimos infanticide
“drastic measures are sometimes needed to
ensure the family’s survival…The Eskimos
values are not all that different than our own. It is
only that life forces upon them choices that we
do not have to make.”
Universal(ish) Values in
Societies
1. Value of protecting the young
2. Truth telling
3. Prohibition of murder
What would the consequence be of not having
these values?
“There are some moral rules that all societies
must have in common, because those rules
are necessary for society to exist.”
Other universal values or moral
rules
 Prohibition against incest
 Personal responsibility
 The proper role of government is to take
care of its citizens
 Everyone should serve their country
 Everyone should obey the law
To judge or not to judge…
In 1996 a 17 year old girl from Togo a West
African country arrived in the US and asked
for asylum to avoid “ excision”, a practice
referred to as “female circumcision” or
“female genital mutilation”. According to the
WHO, the practice is widespread in 26
African countries and 2 million girls are
excised each year.
Reaction in the New York Times,
encouraged the idea that excision was a
Cultural Point: Young girls often look forward to
this because it a acceptance into adulthood; it
is an accepted practice in many villages.
Consequences of excision: painful, results in
permanent loss of sexual pleasure,
hemorrhage, tetanus, septicemia, death,
chronic infections, hinder walking, chronic
pain
Note: There are no apparent no social benefits,
nor is there a religious factor.
Rationale for the Practice
1) Women are incapable of sexual pleasure
and less likely to be promiscuous.
2) Fewer unwanted pregnancies in unmarried
women
3) Women will be more faithful to their
husbands and focused on their children.
4) Un-excised women are viewed as unclean
and immature.
5)Arguments for this practice is that it benefits
men, women, families and children.
What problem do you see here with the
Is excision harmful or helpful?
Cultural Relativists would conclude that
excision has been practiced for centuries and
we should not intervene and change ancient
ways.
We may ask whether a practice promotes
or hinders the welfare of the people who
lives are affected by it. And as a corollary,
is there an alternative set of social
arrangements that would do a better job of
promoting their welfare. If so, we may
Reluctance to Criticize
1) Many thoughtful people have been reluctant to
criticize what many view as a barbaric practice
because:
Interfering with the social customs of other
people. (Europeans and Americans have been
criticized for destroying other cultures, Native
Americans)
2) Acceptance of strange practices (tolerance)
toward others.
3) Reluctance to criticize other societies-- do not
want to express contempt
Lessons From Cultural
Relativism
While it rests on invalid argument, it is
still an appealing theory…
Two important lessons 
Lesson 1
It warns us about the dangers of assuming
that our preferences are based upon some
absolute rational standard. They are not.
Many of our practices are merely particular to
our society and it is easy to forget this.
There are many matters that we tend to think
of in terms of objective right or wrong, that are
really nothing more than social conventions.

Examples of social conventions we tend think of as
“right” or “wrong” that are really nothing more than
social conventions:
 Women covering their breasts
 Separate restrooms for men and women
 Men opening the door for women
 No shoes, no shirt, no service
 Fathers giving their daughters away in wedding
ceremony
 Wearing a wedding band on the fourth finger of
the left hand
 Swearing, drinking, gambling, etc.
Lesson 2
Keep an open mind—
Maybe our feelings about practices, values
and beliefs are merely social conventions.
Example: gender bias
Maybe our feelings are not necessarily
perceptions of the truth…they may be
nothing more than cultural conditioning.
Claims of Cultural Relativists
1. Different societies have different moral codes.
2. The moral code of a society determines what is
right within that society.
3. There is no objective standard that can be used
to judge one societies code as better than
another.
4. The moral code of our society offers nothing
special.
5. There is no universal truth in ethics…
6. It is arrogant to judge the conduct of other
societies; we should adopt an attitude of
tolerance.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Elements of Culture
Elements of CultureElements of Culture
Elements of CultureJoey Valdriz
 
Lesson 2 topic 1
Lesson 2   topic 1Lesson 2   topic 1
Lesson 2 topic 1chumce02
 
CHAPTER 1C SENSES OF THE SELF.pptx
CHAPTER 1C SENSES OF THE SELF.pptxCHAPTER 1C SENSES OF THE SELF.pptx
CHAPTER 1C SENSES OF THE SELF.pptxChristianneVentura
 
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4Jojean de la Cruz
 
Chapter 6: Utilitarianism
Chapter 6: UtilitarianismChapter 6: Utilitarianism
Chapter 6: Utilitarianismdborcoman
 
Social, Political, and Cultural behavior and Phenomena
Social, Political, and Cultural behavior and PhenomenaSocial, Political, and Cultural behavior and Phenomena
Social, Political, and Cultural behavior and PhenomenaMiss Chey
 
UCSP Chapter B - defining culture and society from the perspectives of anthro...
UCSP Chapter B - defining culture and society from the perspectives of anthro...UCSP Chapter B - defining culture and society from the perspectives of anthro...
UCSP Chapter B - defining culture and society from the perspectives of anthro...Eman Bustamante
 
Moral Framework for Ethics
Moral Framework for EthicsMoral Framework for Ethics
Moral Framework for EthicsSinbad Konick
 
Religion: For or Against Globalization
Religion: For or Against GlobalizationReligion: For or Against Globalization
Religion: For or Against GlobalizationKylaAquino5
 
Globalizationppt
GlobalizationpptGlobalizationppt
GlobalizationpptEdz Gapuz
 
Human Rights, Dignity and the Common Good
Human Rights, Dignity and the Common GoodHuman Rights, Dignity and the Common Good
Human Rights, Dignity and the Common GoodDanica Lyra Ortiz
 
The effects of globalization
The effects of globalizationThe effects of globalization
The effects of globalizationYouheng Sim
 
Globalization Theory Revised1
Globalization Theory Revised1Globalization Theory Revised1
Globalization Theory Revised1Khenddro Low
 
The structures of globalization
The structures of globalizationThe structures of globalization
The structures of globalizationKeithCeremonia
 
Social, Political and Cultural Behavior and Phenomena
Social, Political and Cultural Behavior and PhenomenaSocial, Political and Cultural Behavior and Phenomena
Social, Political and Cultural Behavior and PhenomenaConan Rogador
 

Mais procurados (20)

Elements of Culture
Elements of CultureElements of Culture
Elements of Culture
 
Lesson 2 topic 1
Lesson 2   topic 1Lesson 2   topic 1
Lesson 2 topic 1
 
CHAPTER 1C SENSES OF THE SELF.pptx
CHAPTER 1C SENSES OF THE SELF.pptxCHAPTER 1C SENSES OF THE SELF.pptx
CHAPTER 1C SENSES OF THE SELF.pptx
 
Characteristics of culture - UCSP - Grade 11
Characteristics of culture - UCSP - Grade 11Characteristics of culture - UCSP - Grade 11
Characteristics of culture - UCSP - Grade 11
 
Utilitarianism
UtilitarianismUtilitarianism
Utilitarianism
 
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
 
Chapter 6: Utilitarianism
Chapter 6: UtilitarianismChapter 6: Utilitarianism
Chapter 6: Utilitarianism
 
Social, Political, and Cultural behavior and Phenomena
Social, Political, and Cultural behavior and PhenomenaSocial, Political, and Cultural behavior and Phenomena
Social, Political, and Cultural behavior and Phenomena
 
UCSP Chapter B - defining culture and society from the perspectives of anthro...
UCSP Chapter B - defining culture and society from the perspectives of anthro...UCSP Chapter B - defining culture and society from the perspectives of anthro...
UCSP Chapter B - defining culture and society from the perspectives of anthro...
 
Moral Framework for Ethics
Moral Framework for EthicsMoral Framework for Ethics
Moral Framework for Ethics
 
Religion: For or Against Globalization
Religion: For or Against GlobalizationReligion: For or Against Globalization
Religion: For or Against Globalization
 
Globalizationppt
GlobalizationpptGlobalizationppt
Globalizationppt
 
Human Rights, Dignity and the Common Good
Human Rights, Dignity and the Common GoodHuman Rights, Dignity and the Common Good
Human Rights, Dignity and the Common Good
 
Moral dilemmas
Moral dilemmasMoral dilemmas
Moral dilemmas
 
The effects of globalization
The effects of globalizationThe effects of globalization
The effects of globalization
 
Globalization Theory Revised1
Globalization Theory Revised1Globalization Theory Revised1
Globalization Theory Revised1
 
Soc 451, 1st class
Soc 451, 1st classSoc 451, 1st class
Soc 451, 1st class
 
The structures of globalization
The structures of globalizationThe structures of globalization
The structures of globalization
 
Social, Political and Cultural Behavior and Phenomena
Social, Political and Cultural Behavior and PhenomenaSocial, Political and Cultural Behavior and Phenomena
Social, Political and Cultural Behavior and Phenomena
 
Defining Culture
Defining CultureDefining Culture
Defining Culture
 

Destaque

Moral Relativism
Moral RelativismMoral Relativism
Moral Relativismrvigliotti
 
Chapter 2: Ethical Relativism
Chapter 2: Ethical RelativismChapter 2: Ethical Relativism
Chapter 2: Ethical Relativismdborcoman
 
04 moral relavitism_b
04 moral relavitism_b04 moral relavitism_b
04 moral relavitism_bSisyphosstone
 
Ethics moral relativism
Ethics moral relativismEthics moral relativism
Ethics moral relativismRaeAnneSmith
 
Ethnocentrism and relativism
Ethnocentrism and relativismEthnocentrism and relativism
Ethnocentrism and relativismJed Lim
 
Ethnocentrism
EthnocentrismEthnocentrism
EthnocentrismPatra1963
 
PHI 204 - Ethical Issues in Health Care: Casuistry, Cultural Relativism
PHI 204 - Ethical Issues in Health Care: Casuistry, Cultural RelativismPHI 204 - Ethical Issues in Health Care: Casuistry, Cultural Relativism
PHI 204 - Ethical Issues in Health Care: Casuistry, Cultural Relativismdotcom YOGA
 
Limits of Enlightment Rationality and Cultural Relativism
Limits of Enlightment Rationality and Cultural RelativismLimits of Enlightment Rationality and Cultural Relativism
Limits of Enlightment Rationality and Cultural RelativismDominik Lukes
 
It is not our culture Human Rights Culture in Guyana and the Caribbean
It is not our culture Human Rights Culture in Guyana and the CaribbeanIt is not our culture Human Rights Culture in Guyana and the Caribbean
It is not our culture Human Rights Culture in Guyana and the CaribbeanVidyaratha Kissoon
 
Cultural anthropology part 1
Cultural anthropology part 1Cultural anthropology part 1
Cultural anthropology part 1Mike Berry
 
Common Ground: Conversations Between Atheists, Humanists, and Religious Belie...
Common Ground: Conversations Between Atheists, Humanists, and Religious Belie...Common Ground: Conversations Between Atheists, Humanists, and Religious Belie...
Common Ground: Conversations Between Atheists, Humanists, and Religious Belie...Fr. Carl Chudy
 
Kantian Condemnation of Commerce in Organs
Kantian Condemnation of Commerce in OrgansKantian Condemnation of Commerce in Organs
Kantian Condemnation of Commerce in OrgansMia Eaker
 
Inquiry Project Assignment Presentation
Inquiry Project Assignment PresentationInquiry Project Assignment Presentation
Inquiry Project Assignment PresentationMia Eaker
 

Destaque (20)

Cultural relativism
Cultural relativismCultural relativism
Cultural relativism
 
Ethnocentrism
EthnocentrismEthnocentrism
Ethnocentrism
 
Moral Relativism
Moral RelativismMoral Relativism
Moral Relativism
 
What is Moral Relativism?
What is Moral Relativism?What is Moral Relativism?
What is Moral Relativism?
 
Chapter 2: Ethical Relativism
Chapter 2: Ethical RelativismChapter 2: Ethical Relativism
Chapter 2: Ethical Relativism
 
Ethnocentrism & Ethnorelativism
Ethnocentrism & EthnorelativismEthnocentrism & Ethnorelativism
Ethnocentrism & Ethnorelativism
 
04 moral relavitism_b
04 moral relavitism_b04 moral relavitism_b
04 moral relavitism_b
 
04 moral relativism
04 moral relativism04 moral relativism
04 moral relativism
 
Ethics moral relativism
Ethics moral relativismEthics moral relativism
Ethics moral relativism
 
Culture shock1
Culture shock1Culture shock1
Culture shock1
 
Ethnocentrism and relativism
Ethnocentrism and relativismEthnocentrism and relativism
Ethnocentrism and relativism
 
Ethnocentrism
EthnocentrismEthnocentrism
Ethnocentrism
 
Ethnocentrism
EthnocentrismEthnocentrism
Ethnocentrism
 
PHI 204 - Ethical Issues in Health Care: Casuistry, Cultural Relativism
PHI 204 - Ethical Issues in Health Care: Casuistry, Cultural RelativismPHI 204 - Ethical Issues in Health Care: Casuistry, Cultural Relativism
PHI 204 - Ethical Issues in Health Care: Casuistry, Cultural Relativism
 
Limits of Enlightment Rationality and Cultural Relativism
Limits of Enlightment Rationality and Cultural RelativismLimits of Enlightment Rationality and Cultural Relativism
Limits of Enlightment Rationality and Cultural Relativism
 
It is not our culture Human Rights Culture in Guyana and the Caribbean
It is not our culture Human Rights Culture in Guyana and the CaribbeanIt is not our culture Human Rights Culture in Guyana and the Caribbean
It is not our culture Human Rights Culture in Guyana and the Caribbean
 
Cultural anthropology part 1
Cultural anthropology part 1Cultural anthropology part 1
Cultural anthropology part 1
 
Common Ground: Conversations Between Atheists, Humanists, and Religious Belie...
Common Ground: Conversations Between Atheists, Humanists, and Religious Belie...Common Ground: Conversations Between Atheists, Humanists, and Religious Belie...
Common Ground: Conversations Between Atheists, Humanists, and Religious Belie...
 
Kantian Condemnation of Commerce in Organs
Kantian Condemnation of Commerce in OrgansKantian Condemnation of Commerce in Organs
Kantian Condemnation of Commerce in Organs
 
Inquiry Project Assignment Presentation
Inquiry Project Assignment PresentationInquiry Project Assignment Presentation
Inquiry Project Assignment Presentation
 

Semelhante a Cultural Relatvism

Week 9 Cultural Relativism.pptx
Week 9 Cultural Relativism.pptxWeek 9 Cultural Relativism.pptx
Week 9 Cultural Relativism.pptxArvinCruz19
 
What Does Moral Relativism Means
What Does Moral Relativism MeansWhat Does Moral Relativism Means
What Does Moral Relativism MeansMandy Cross
 
Phil21 wk4 relativism
Phil21 wk4 relativism Phil21 wk4 relativism
Phil21 wk4 relativism twiggypiggy
 
Moral Relativism In The Dark Knight
Moral Relativism In The Dark KnightMoral Relativism In The Dark Knight
Moral Relativism In The Dark KnightWhitney Turner
 
Cultural Litivism Vs. Ethical Relativism
Cultural Litivism Vs. Ethical RelativismCultural Litivism Vs. Ethical Relativism
Cultural Litivism Vs. Ethical RelativismJulie May
 
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And AbsolutismDifference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And AbsolutismKarrie Garcia
 
Subjectivism and Cultural relativism-1.pdf
Subjectivism and Cultural relativism-1.pdfSubjectivism and Cultural relativism-1.pdf
Subjectivism and Cultural relativism-1.pdfMphow Parvo
 
Cons Of Cultural Relativism
Cons Of Cultural RelativismCons Of Cultural Relativism
Cons Of Cultural RelativismMichelle Wilson
 
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command TheoryCultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command TheoryJennifer Campbell
 

Semelhante a Cultural Relatvism (20)

Week 9 Cultural Relativism.pptx
Week 9 Cultural Relativism.pptxWeek 9 Cultural Relativism.pptx
Week 9 Cultural Relativism.pptx
 
Cultural Relativism And Racial Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism And Racial Relativism EssayCultural Relativism And Racial Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism And Racial Relativism Essay
 
What Does Moral Relativism Means
What Does Moral Relativism MeansWhat Does Moral Relativism Means
What Does Moral Relativism Means
 
Moral Relativism Defended Summary
Moral Relativism Defended SummaryMoral Relativism Defended Summary
Moral Relativism Defended Summary
 
Phil21 wk4 relativism
Phil21 wk4 relativism Phil21 wk4 relativism
Phil21 wk4 relativism
 
Moral Relativism In The Dark Knight
Moral Relativism In The Dark KnightMoral Relativism In The Dark Knight
Moral Relativism In The Dark Knight
 
Moral Relativism
Moral RelativismMoral Relativism
Moral Relativism
 
Cultural Litivism Vs. Ethical Relativism
Cultural Litivism Vs. Ethical RelativismCultural Litivism Vs. Ethical Relativism
Cultural Litivism Vs. Ethical Relativism
 
A Basis For Morality Essay
A Basis For Morality EssayA Basis For Morality Essay
A Basis For Morality Essay
 
Ethical Relativism And Moral Relativism
Ethical Relativism And Moral RelativismEthical Relativism And Moral Relativism
Ethical Relativism And Moral Relativism
 
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And AbsolutismDifference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
 
UCSP-Q2.pptx
UCSP-Q2.pptxUCSP-Q2.pptx
UCSP-Q2.pptx
 
Moral Relativism Essay
Moral Relativism EssayMoral Relativism Essay
Moral Relativism Essay
 
Subjectivism and Cultural relativism-1.pdf
Subjectivism and Cultural relativism-1.pdfSubjectivism and Cultural relativism-1.pdf
Subjectivism and Cultural relativism-1.pdf
 
Cons Of Cultural Relativism
Cons Of Cultural RelativismCons Of Cultural Relativism
Cons Of Cultural Relativism
 
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command TheoryCultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
 
Cultural Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism EssayCultural Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism Essay
 
Moral Relativism Research Paper
Moral Relativism Research PaperMoral Relativism Research Paper
Moral Relativism Research Paper
 
Cultural Relativism
Cultural RelativismCultural Relativism
Cultural Relativism
 
Chapter 2
Chapter 2Chapter 2
Chapter 2
 

Mais de Mia Eaker

Integrating Outside Material1104
Integrating Outside Material1104Integrating Outside Material1104
Integrating Outside Material1104Mia Eaker
 
KeyConcepts&Inquiry
KeyConcepts&InquiryKeyConcepts&Inquiry
KeyConcepts&InquiryMia Eaker
 
Research Strategies & Your Inquiry
Research Strategies & Your InquiryResearch Strategies & Your Inquiry
Research Strategies & Your InquiryMia Eaker
 
Digital Essay Intro & Brainstorming
Digital Essay Intro & BrainstormingDigital Essay Intro & Brainstorming
Digital Essay Intro & BrainstormingMia Eaker
 
Search Sentences
Search SentencesSearch Sentences
Search SentencesMia Eaker
 
Plagiarism, Academic Conventions, & Annotated Bibs
Plagiarism, Academic Conventions, & Annotated BibsPlagiarism, Academic Conventions, & Annotated Bibs
Plagiarism, Academic Conventions, & Annotated BibsMia Eaker
 
Research Methods
Research MethodsResearch Methods
Research MethodsMia Eaker
 
Preliminary Research Strategies Spring 2017
Preliminary Research Strategies Spring 2017Preliminary Research Strategies Spring 2017
Preliminary Research Strategies Spring 2017Mia Eaker
 
Inquiry Spring 2016
Inquiry Spring 2016Inquiry Spring 2016
Inquiry Spring 2016Mia Eaker
 
Integrating Outside Material
Integrating Outside MaterialIntegrating Outside Material
Integrating Outside MaterialMia Eaker
 
Plagiarism&Paraphrasing
Plagiarism&ParaphrasingPlagiarism&Paraphrasing
Plagiarism&ParaphrasingMia Eaker
 
Focusing your LOI
Focusing your LOIFocusing your LOI
Focusing your LOIMia Eaker
 
Logicalfallacies
LogicalfallaciesLogicalfallacies
LogicalfallaciesMia Eaker
 
Mc cormick -_violent_video_games
Mc cormick -_violent_video_gamesMc cormick -_violent_video_games
Mc cormick -_violent_video_gamesMia Eaker
 
Artificial intelligence and ethics
Artificial intelligence and ethicsArtificial intelligence and ethics
Artificial intelligence and ethicsMia Eaker
 
Final examstudyguide
Final examstudyguideFinal examstudyguide
Final examstudyguideMia Eaker
 
Are Computer Hacker Break-ins Ethical -- Spafford
Are Computer Hacker Break-ins Ethical -- SpaffordAre Computer Hacker Break-ins Ethical -- Spafford
Are Computer Hacker Break-ins Ethical -- SpaffordMia Eaker
 
Deontology intro
Deontology introDeontology intro
Deontology introMia Eaker
 
MLA1103Fall2014
MLA1103Fall2014MLA1103Fall2014
MLA1103Fall2014Mia Eaker
 

Mais de Mia Eaker (20)

Integrating Outside Material1104
Integrating Outside Material1104Integrating Outside Material1104
Integrating Outside Material1104
 
KeyConcepts&Inquiry
KeyConcepts&InquiryKeyConcepts&Inquiry
KeyConcepts&Inquiry
 
Research Strategies & Your Inquiry
Research Strategies & Your InquiryResearch Strategies & Your Inquiry
Research Strategies & Your Inquiry
 
Digital Essay Intro & Brainstorming
Digital Essay Intro & BrainstormingDigital Essay Intro & Brainstorming
Digital Essay Intro & Brainstorming
 
Search Sentences
Search SentencesSearch Sentences
Search Sentences
 
Plagiarism, Academic Conventions, & Annotated Bibs
Plagiarism, Academic Conventions, & Annotated BibsPlagiarism, Academic Conventions, & Annotated Bibs
Plagiarism, Academic Conventions, & Annotated Bibs
 
Research Methods
Research MethodsResearch Methods
Research Methods
 
Preliminary Research Strategies Spring 2017
Preliminary Research Strategies Spring 2017Preliminary Research Strategies Spring 2017
Preliminary Research Strategies Spring 2017
 
Inquiry Spring 2016
Inquiry Spring 2016Inquiry Spring 2016
Inquiry Spring 2016
 
Integrating Outside Material
Integrating Outside MaterialIntegrating Outside Material
Integrating Outside Material
 
Plagiarism&Paraphrasing
Plagiarism&ParaphrasingPlagiarism&Paraphrasing
Plagiarism&Paraphrasing
 
Focusing your LOI
Focusing your LOIFocusing your LOI
Focusing your LOI
 
Inquiry1104
Inquiry1104Inquiry1104
Inquiry1104
 
Logicalfallacies
LogicalfallaciesLogicalfallacies
Logicalfallacies
 
Mc cormick -_violent_video_games
Mc cormick -_violent_video_gamesMc cormick -_violent_video_games
Mc cormick -_violent_video_games
 
Artificial intelligence and ethics
Artificial intelligence and ethicsArtificial intelligence and ethics
Artificial intelligence and ethics
 
Final examstudyguide
Final examstudyguideFinal examstudyguide
Final examstudyguide
 
Are Computer Hacker Break-ins Ethical -- Spafford
Are Computer Hacker Break-ins Ethical -- SpaffordAre Computer Hacker Break-ins Ethical -- Spafford
Are Computer Hacker Break-ins Ethical -- Spafford
 
Deontology intro
Deontology introDeontology intro
Deontology intro
 
MLA1103Fall2014
MLA1103Fall2014MLA1103Fall2014
MLA1103Fall2014
 

Último

BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
2024.03.16 How to write better quality materials for your learners ELTABB San...
2024.03.16 How to write better quality materials for your learners ELTABB San...2024.03.16 How to write better quality materials for your learners ELTABB San...
2024.03.16 How to write better quality materials for your learners ELTABB San...Sandy Millin
 
Research Methodology and Tips on Better Research
Research Methodology and Tips on Better ResearchResearch Methodology and Tips on Better Research
Research Methodology and Tips on Better ResearchRushdi Shams
 
Metabolism of lipoproteins & its disorders(Chylomicron & VLDL & LDL).pptx
Metabolism of  lipoproteins & its disorders(Chylomicron & VLDL & LDL).pptxMetabolism of  lipoproteins & its disorders(Chylomicron & VLDL & LDL).pptx
Metabolism of lipoproteins & its disorders(Chylomicron & VLDL & LDL).pptxDr. Santhosh Kumar. N
 
25 CHUYÊN ĐỀ ÔN THI TỐT NGHIỆP THPT 2023 – BÀI TẬP PHÁT TRIỂN TỪ ĐỀ MINH HỌA...
25 CHUYÊN ĐỀ ÔN THI TỐT NGHIỆP THPT 2023 – BÀI TẬP PHÁT TRIỂN TỪ ĐỀ MINH HỌA...25 CHUYÊN ĐỀ ÔN THI TỐT NGHIỆP THPT 2023 – BÀI TẬP PHÁT TRIỂN TỪ ĐỀ MINH HỌA...
25 CHUYÊN ĐỀ ÔN THI TỐT NGHIỆP THPT 2023 – BÀI TẬP PHÁT TRIỂN TỪ ĐỀ MINH HỌA...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptxmary850239
 
Quantitative research methodology and survey design
Quantitative research methodology and survey designQuantitative research methodology and survey design
Quantitative research methodology and survey designBalelaBoru
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
Riti theory by Vamana Indian poetics.pptx
Riti theory by Vamana Indian poetics.pptxRiti theory by Vamana Indian poetics.pptx
Riti theory by Vamana Indian poetics.pptxDhatriParmar
 
Pharmacology chapter No 7 full notes.pdf
Pharmacology chapter No 7 full notes.pdfPharmacology chapter No 7 full notes.pdf
Pharmacology chapter No 7 full notes.pdfSumit Tiwari
 
Awards Presentation 2024 - March 12 2024
Awards Presentation 2024 - March 12 2024Awards Presentation 2024 - March 12 2024
Awards Presentation 2024 - March 12 2024bsellato
 
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study Jitendra bhargav
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study  Jitendra bhargavPOST ENCEPHALITIS case study  Jitendra bhargav
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study Jitendra bhargavJitendra Bhargav
 
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptxAlamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptxDhatriParmar
 
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptxmary850239
 
DNA and RNA , Structure, Functions, Types, difference, Similarities, Protein ...
DNA and RNA , Structure, Functions, Types, difference, Similarities, Protein ...DNA and RNA , Structure, Functions, Types, difference, Similarities, Protein ...
DNA and RNA , Structure, Functions, Types, difference, Similarities, Protein ...AKSHAYMAGAR17
 
Certification Study Group - Professional ML Engineer Session 3 (Machine Learn...
Certification Study Group - Professional ML Engineer Session 3 (Machine Learn...Certification Study Group - Professional ML Engineer Session 3 (Machine Learn...
Certification Study Group - Professional ML Engineer Session 3 (Machine Learn...gdgsurrey
 
The OERs: Transforming Education for Sustainable Future by Dr. Sarita Anand
The OERs: Transforming Education for Sustainable Future by Dr. Sarita AnandThe OERs: Transforming Education for Sustainable Future by Dr. Sarita Anand
The OERs: Transforming Education for Sustainable Future by Dr. Sarita AnandDr. Sarita Anand
 
The First National K12 TUG March 6 2024.pdf
The First National K12 TUG March 6 2024.pdfThe First National K12 TUG March 6 2024.pdf
The First National K12 TUG March 6 2024.pdfdogden2
 

Último (20)

BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
 
2024.03.16 How to write better quality materials for your learners ELTABB San...
2024.03.16 How to write better quality materials for your learners ELTABB San...2024.03.16 How to write better quality materials for your learners ELTABB San...
2024.03.16 How to write better quality materials for your learners ELTABB San...
 
Research Methodology and Tips on Better Research
Research Methodology and Tips on Better ResearchResearch Methodology and Tips on Better Research
Research Methodology and Tips on Better Research
 
Metabolism of lipoproteins & its disorders(Chylomicron & VLDL & LDL).pptx
Metabolism of  lipoproteins & its disorders(Chylomicron & VLDL & LDL).pptxMetabolism of  lipoproteins & its disorders(Chylomicron & VLDL & LDL).pptx
Metabolism of lipoproteins & its disorders(Chylomicron & VLDL & LDL).pptx
 
25 CHUYÊN ĐỀ ÔN THI TỐT NGHIỆP THPT 2023 – BÀI TẬP PHÁT TRIỂN TỪ ĐỀ MINH HỌA...
25 CHUYÊN ĐỀ ÔN THI TỐT NGHIỆP THPT 2023 – BÀI TẬP PHÁT TRIỂN TỪ ĐỀ MINH HỌA...25 CHUYÊN ĐỀ ÔN THI TỐT NGHIỆP THPT 2023 – BÀI TẬP PHÁT TRIỂN TỪ ĐỀ MINH HỌA...
25 CHUYÊN ĐỀ ÔN THI TỐT NGHIỆP THPT 2023 – BÀI TẬP PHÁT TRIỂN TỪ ĐỀ MINH HỌA...
 
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
 
Quantitative research methodology and survey design
Quantitative research methodology and survey designQuantitative research methodology and survey design
Quantitative research methodology and survey design
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
 
Riti theory by Vamana Indian poetics.pptx
Riti theory by Vamana Indian poetics.pptxRiti theory by Vamana Indian poetics.pptx
Riti theory by Vamana Indian poetics.pptx
 
Pharmacology chapter No 7 full notes.pdf
Pharmacology chapter No 7 full notes.pdfPharmacology chapter No 7 full notes.pdf
Pharmacology chapter No 7 full notes.pdf
 
Awards Presentation 2024 - March 12 2024
Awards Presentation 2024 - March 12 2024Awards Presentation 2024 - March 12 2024
Awards Presentation 2024 - March 12 2024
 
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study Jitendra bhargav
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study  Jitendra bhargavPOST ENCEPHALITIS case study  Jitendra bhargav
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study Jitendra bhargav
 
Problems on Mean,Mode,Median Standard Deviation
Problems on Mean,Mode,Median Standard DeviationProblems on Mean,Mode,Median Standard Deviation
Problems on Mean,Mode,Median Standard Deviation
 
Least Significance Difference:Biostatics and Research Methodology
Least Significance Difference:Biostatics and Research MethodologyLeast Significance Difference:Biostatics and Research Methodology
Least Significance Difference:Biostatics and Research Methodology
 
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptxAlamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
 
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
 
DNA and RNA , Structure, Functions, Types, difference, Similarities, Protein ...
DNA and RNA , Structure, Functions, Types, difference, Similarities, Protein ...DNA and RNA , Structure, Functions, Types, difference, Similarities, Protein ...
DNA and RNA , Structure, Functions, Types, difference, Similarities, Protein ...
 
Certification Study Group - Professional ML Engineer Session 3 (Machine Learn...
Certification Study Group - Professional ML Engineer Session 3 (Machine Learn...Certification Study Group - Professional ML Engineer Session 3 (Machine Learn...
Certification Study Group - Professional ML Engineer Session 3 (Machine Learn...
 
The OERs: Transforming Education for Sustainable Future by Dr. Sarita Anand
The OERs: Transforming Education for Sustainable Future by Dr. Sarita AnandThe OERs: Transforming Education for Sustainable Future by Dr. Sarita Anand
The OERs: Transforming Education for Sustainable Future by Dr. Sarita Anand
 
The First National K12 TUG March 6 2024.pdf
The First National K12 TUG March 6 2024.pdfThe First National K12 TUG March 6 2024.pdf
The First National K12 TUG March 6 2024.pdf
 

Cultural Relatvism

  • 1. UNDERSTANDING THE DIVERSITY OF MORAL BELIEFS: CULTURAL RELATIVISM
  • 2. Exercise-- Culture Clash  What are some examples Rachels gives of culture clash? Explain what makes them unique, odd or different.  With your group, brainstorm at least two other examples of differing moral codes, customs, or behaviors. Explain what makes them unique, odd or different.
  • 3. Cultural Relativism  “Different cultures have different moral codes” often is used as a key to understanding morality. Proponents argue that there is not as universal truth in ethics; there are only the various cultural codes and nothing more. The customs of different societies is all that exist.  Proponents would argue that customs can not be judged as correct or incorrect.  Our own code of ethics has no special status; it is merely one among many Tightening the Definition– The focus here is on whether or not one culture can judge another; the focus is not on whether or not one individual can judge another.
  • 4. Cultural Relativism Challenges our ordinary belief in the objectivity and universality of moral truths--  It says in effect that there is no such thing as a universal truth or ethical standard that can be applied.  Refutes ethnocentrism-- Your own code of ethics offers nothing special and is no better than that of another culture. Sounds appealing…
  • 6. Response… Discuss this video with your group and record some of the points that come up. Consider: 1) Should this practice be illegal? Can it be deemed morally wrong? 2) Can you compare this practice with cosmetic surgery? 3) What points made by members of the panel stood out to you the most and why? What is your reaction?
  • 7. REVIEW What is cultural relativism? How does it challenge traditional beliefs?
  • 8. Some Conflicting Approaches  Moral Realism (aka Moral Objectivism): There are objective moral facts. Therefore, ethics is somewhat like science: Its task is to discover (not decide) what these moral facts are.  Ethical Absolutists: There is a single standard ethical standard; that standard is usually their own.  Ethical (cultural or moral) Relativists: Each culture as an island unto itself, right in its own world, and they deny any overarching standard with which conflicting cultures (not individuals) can be judged.  Ethical Pluralists: Cultures can legitimately pass judgments on one another, but encourages us to listen to what other cultures say about us as well
  • 9. What happens when something that is legally and morally permissible in one culture is illegal and immoral in another?  Female circumcision or genital mutilation  Marriage of underage girls  Infanticide  Polygamy  Slavery
  • 10. Conflicting Approaches  Moral Realist– Try to examine the situation and context to discover the moral “facts.”  Ethical relativist—Each culture is right unto itself, so such practices would be morally permissible in some countries and morally wrong in the US.  Ethical absolutists—There is a single moral truth in terms of which all cultures and individuals are to be judged.  Pluralists—Try to find some middle ground (in some situations this practice may make sense, less judgmental)
  • 11. Different moral codes  Reminder-- Different cultures have different moral codes. What is right within one group maybe abhorrent to another.  Treatment of the dead  Polygamy  Sharing of wives among Eskimos  Infanticide
  • 12. What is our reaction to “strange or different” customs?  Label them as backward, uneducated, or primitive.  Label them heathens…  Discriminate or harass them.  Convert them to “our” custom or thought. correlates with imperialist approaches…
  • 13. William Graham Sumner  First professorship in sociology at Yale College  Credited with coining the term “ethnocentrism”  Anti-Imperialist “’The right way’ is the way which the ancestors used and which has been handed down. The tradition is its own warrant. It is not held subject to verification by experience. The notion of right is in the folkways.”  This line of thought has probably persuaded more people to be skeptical about ethics than any other single statement.
  • 14. “If we assume that our ethical ideas will be shared by all people at all times, we are merely naïve.” Consider ethical ideas in our society may have changed over the years…
  • 15.  Divorce, Living together, Sex outside of marriage Interracial marriage, Same sex marriages, Sex education  Gambling, casinos, internet poker  Internet dating  Women in the workforce, women in the army, women working in “masculine” jobs  Spanking/punishment of children  Acceptance of cremation for the dead  Animal welfare, Recognizing that animals have certain rights  Natural resource protection  Taming “mother nature” vs. “living with nature”
  • 16. Claims of Cultural Relativists 1. Different societies have different moral codes. 2. The moral code of a society determines what is right within that society. 3. There is no objective standard that can be used to judge one societies code as better than another. 4. The moral code of our society offers nothing special. 5. There is no universal truth in ethics… 6. It is arrogant to judge the conduct of other
  • 17. The Cultural Differences Argument A theory about the nature of morality At the heart of the Cultural Relativism is the form of their argument.
  • 18. The Cultural Differences Argument Premises: 1. Different cultures have different moral codes. 2. Therefore, there are no objective truth in morality. Right and wrong are only matters of opinion, and opinions vary from culture to culture. This is cultural differences argument--They argue from facts about differences between cultural outlooks to making conclusions about the status of morality How is this a logical fallacy? In other words, how is it logically unsound?
  • 19. The Unsoundness of the Cultural Differences Argument The trouble is that the conclusion does not follow from the premise—that is even if the premise is true, the conclusion might be false. – logical fallacy is called non sequitur WHY? The premise concerns what people believe; some believe one way and others believe another, but the conclusion concerns what really is the case. • Just because two cultures believe differently does inherently mean that one belief cannot
  • 20. Example The Greeks believed it was wrong to eat the dead. The Callatians believed it was right. Does it follow, from the mere fact that they disagreed, that there is no objective truth in the matter? No, it does not follow—it could be objectively right or wrong that one or the other was simply mistaken.
  • 21. The Fatal Flaw of the Cultural Difference Argument It attempts to derive a substantive conclusion about a subject from the mere fact that people disagree about it. Caution: This is a simple point of logic. This does not necessarily mean that the conclusion is false, the logic is that the conclusion does not follow from the premise.
  • 22. The Consequences of Accepting Cultural Relativism 1) We could no longer say that custom of other societies are morally inferior to others. (This is one of the main points of Cultural Relativism.) + We would have to stop condemning other societies merely because they are different. - Tolerance towards slavery, anti Semitism, hatred towards ethnic groups, or minorities, child porn, sex slave trade • If we took the cultural relativism seriously, we would have to regard these behaviors as immune from criticism as long as they are considered morally acceptable within the practicing culture.
  • 23. If we accept Cultural Relativism 2) We could decide whether actions are right or wrong just by consulting the standards of our society. In Colonial America slavery was OK, women were not allowed to vote or own property, primogeniture was practiced, etc.; therefore, these things were right. (+) deciding what is right or wrong in a situation is easier
  • 24. If we accept Cultural Relativism 3) The idea of moral progress is called into doubt. Progress implies doing things better, but cultural relativism rejects making judgments about past eras. Reform movements such as rights for women and minorities that implies modern society is better is a judgment that is impossible to make.
  • 25. Problems with Cultural Relativism 1. No blame of other cultures for “wrong” or “evil” deeds. Are cultures morally infallible? 2. No criticism of our own culture 3. No idea of moral progress 4. In a relativist society the view of the majority rules. Is this fair? 5. Is tolerance a universal value, in which case relativism is paradoxical? 7. Don’t we all instinctively believe that some things are universally right and wrong?
  • 26. The Result? Many reject the cultural relativism arguments-- 1. It makes sense to condemn some practices wherever they occur. 2. It makes sense to acknowledge that our society while imperfect has made moral progress. 3. Because Cultural Relativism implies these judgments make no sense, the argument goes, it cannot be right.
  • 27. There is Less Disagreement Than it Seems (Across Cultures) There are differences across societies, but the differences are often over-stated. In fact, there are some values that can be seen as relatively universal because they are necessary for societies to function.  Need to explore not particular practices or values, but the belief systems or circumstances that lie behind the practices.  The differences are often in the belief
  • 28. Source of Customs Beliefs—religious beliefs Physical circumstances of the society Even if customs differ, there may be less disagreement on basic values Example: Eskimos infanticide “drastic measures are sometimes needed to ensure the family’s survival…The Eskimos values are not all that different than our own. It is only that life forces upon them choices that we do not have to make.”
  • 29. Universal(ish) Values in Societies 1. Value of protecting the young 2. Truth telling 3. Prohibition of murder What would the consequence be of not having these values? “There are some moral rules that all societies must have in common, because those rules are necessary for society to exist.”
  • 30. Other universal values or moral rules  Prohibition against incest  Personal responsibility  The proper role of government is to take care of its citizens  Everyone should serve their country  Everyone should obey the law
  • 31. To judge or not to judge… In 1996 a 17 year old girl from Togo a West African country arrived in the US and asked for asylum to avoid “ excision”, a practice referred to as “female circumcision” or “female genital mutilation”. According to the WHO, the practice is widespread in 26 African countries and 2 million girls are excised each year. Reaction in the New York Times, encouraged the idea that excision was a
  • 32. Cultural Point: Young girls often look forward to this because it a acceptance into adulthood; it is an accepted practice in many villages. Consequences of excision: painful, results in permanent loss of sexual pleasure, hemorrhage, tetanus, septicemia, death, chronic infections, hinder walking, chronic pain Note: There are no apparent no social benefits, nor is there a religious factor.
  • 33. Rationale for the Practice 1) Women are incapable of sexual pleasure and less likely to be promiscuous. 2) Fewer unwanted pregnancies in unmarried women 3) Women will be more faithful to their husbands and focused on their children. 4) Un-excised women are viewed as unclean and immature. 5)Arguments for this practice is that it benefits men, women, families and children. What problem do you see here with the
  • 34. Is excision harmful or helpful? Cultural Relativists would conclude that excision has been practiced for centuries and we should not intervene and change ancient ways. We may ask whether a practice promotes or hinders the welfare of the people who lives are affected by it. And as a corollary, is there an alternative set of social arrangements that would do a better job of promoting their welfare. If so, we may
  • 35. Reluctance to Criticize 1) Many thoughtful people have been reluctant to criticize what many view as a barbaric practice because: Interfering with the social customs of other people. (Europeans and Americans have been criticized for destroying other cultures, Native Americans) 2) Acceptance of strange practices (tolerance) toward others. 3) Reluctance to criticize other societies-- do not want to express contempt
  • 36. Lessons From Cultural Relativism While it rests on invalid argument, it is still an appealing theory… Two important lessons 
  • 37. Lesson 1 It warns us about the dangers of assuming that our preferences are based upon some absolute rational standard. They are not. Many of our practices are merely particular to our society and it is easy to forget this. There are many matters that we tend to think of in terms of objective right or wrong, that are really nothing more than social conventions. 
  • 38. Examples of social conventions we tend think of as “right” or “wrong” that are really nothing more than social conventions:  Women covering their breasts  Separate restrooms for men and women  Men opening the door for women  No shoes, no shirt, no service  Fathers giving their daughters away in wedding ceremony  Wearing a wedding band on the fourth finger of the left hand  Swearing, drinking, gambling, etc.
  • 39. Lesson 2 Keep an open mind— Maybe our feelings about practices, values and beliefs are merely social conventions. Example: gender bias Maybe our feelings are not necessarily perceptions of the truth…they may be nothing more than cultural conditioning.
  • 40. Claims of Cultural Relativists 1. Different societies have different moral codes. 2. The moral code of a society determines what is right within that society. 3. There is no objective standard that can be used to judge one societies code as better than another. 4. The moral code of our society offers nothing special. 5. There is no universal truth in ethics… 6. It is arrogant to judge the conduct of other societies; we should adopt an attitude of tolerance.