SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 13
Law and Sausages: How Not to Legislate for The Digital Economy  Lilian Edwards Professor of Internet Law Sheffield University [email_address] Pangloss: http://blogscript.blogspot.com/ @lilianedwards on Twitter
After Bismark.. ,[object Object]
Copyright and “3 strikes” laws ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
1 st  issue: Substantive problems with the DEBill ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
“ Technical measures” ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Website blocking clause ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Meanwhile elsewhere in the forest.. "trapped in a second tier of citizenship, denied what I increasingly think of as a fundamental freedom in the modern world: to be part of the internet and technology revolution". Gordon Brown, March 2010
2 nd  issue: Democratic deficit? L Whitty, 3r Reading HL on lobbying _ I regret to say that during the course of our consideration of the Bill, we have seen one of the worst examples in my memory of the political parties being captured by a producer interest. That applies not only to the Government and the bringing forward of the Bill, but to the opposition Front Benches as well. ..  despite a few ameliorations, this is still a bad Bill. It is bad for the digital rights holders to press their interests in this way, when there are alternatives, and it is bad for the Government to risk alienation of a very significant part of the population by enforcing these measures .
Grassroots opposition to #debill ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Results
The new sousveillance?
The future for representational democracy? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Positive aspects? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Impact of Trade Agreements on IP
Impact of Trade Agreements on IPImpact of Trade Agreements on IP
Impact of Trade Agreements on IPCarolina Rossini
 
Ecommerce legal exchange beijing
Ecommerce legal exchange beijingEcommerce legal exchange beijing
Ecommerce legal exchange beijingInternet Law Center
 
Internet Law 2014 - Presentation at CalBar IP Institute
Internet Law 2014 - Presentation at CalBar IP InstituteInternet Law 2014 - Presentation at CalBar IP Institute
Internet Law 2014 - Presentation at CalBar IP InstituteInternet Law Center
 
Washington and the IT Industry
Washington and the IT IndustryWashington and the IT Industry
Washington and the IT IndustryCompTIA
 
2017 Legal Update on Digital Accessibility Cases with Lainey Feingold
2017 Legal Update on Digital Accessibility Cases with Lainey Feingold2017 Legal Update on Digital Accessibility Cases with Lainey Feingold
2017 Legal Update on Digital Accessibility Cases with Lainey Feingold3Play Media
 
Legal issues uniform commercial code for ecommerce
Legal issues uniform commercial code for ecommerceLegal issues uniform commercial code for ecommerce
Legal issues uniform commercial code for ecommerceMukul kale
 
Legal contexts of digital media & internet governance
Legal contexts of digital media & internet governanceLegal contexts of digital media & internet governance
Legal contexts of digital media & internet governanceCheldy S, Elumba-Pableo
 
American Government Wk 6 Unit 2 Project Amending The Constitution
American  Government  Wk 6  Unit 2  Project    Amending The  ConstitutionAmerican  Government  Wk 6  Unit 2  Project    Amending The  Constitution
American Government Wk 6 Unit 2 Project Amending The ConstitutionSee
 
International politics in the age of the internet
International politics in the age of the internetInternational politics in the age of the internet
International politics in the age of the internetJeffrey Hart
 
Digital Accessibility and Structured Negotiation for #A11yTO MeetUP
Digital Accessibility and Structured Negotiation for #A11yTO MeetUPDigital Accessibility and Structured Negotiation for #A11yTO MeetUP
Digital Accessibility and Structured Negotiation for #A11yTO MeetUPLainey Feingold
 
Unraveling intermediary liability
Unraveling intermediary liabilityUnraveling intermediary liability
Unraveling intermediary liabilityEmily Laidlaw
 
Copyright economy updated
Copyright economy updatedCopyright economy updated
Copyright economy updatedJyrki Kasvi
 
Wealth Of Networks Info Intellectual P
Wealth Of Networks Info Intellectual PWealth Of Networks Info Intellectual P
Wealth Of Networks Info Intellectual Prleslein
 

Mais procurados (20)

Impact of Trade Agreements on IP
Impact of Trade Agreements on IPImpact of Trade Agreements on IP
Impact of Trade Agreements on IP
 
Ecommerce legal exchange beijing
Ecommerce legal exchange beijingEcommerce legal exchange beijing
Ecommerce legal exchange beijing
 
Techinnovation
TechinnovationTechinnovation
Techinnovation
 
Internet Law 2014 - Presentation at CalBar IP Institute
Internet Law 2014 - Presentation at CalBar IP InstituteInternet Law 2014 - Presentation at CalBar IP Institute
Internet Law 2014 - Presentation at CalBar IP Institute
 
Washington and the IT Industry
Washington and the IT IndustryWashington and the IT Industry
Washington and the IT Industry
 
2017 Legal Update on Digital Accessibility Cases with Lainey Feingold
2017 Legal Update on Digital Accessibility Cases with Lainey Feingold2017 Legal Update on Digital Accessibility Cases with Lainey Feingold
2017 Legal Update on Digital Accessibility Cases with Lainey Feingold
 
Legal issues uniform commercial code for ecommerce
Legal issues uniform commercial code for ecommerceLegal issues uniform commercial code for ecommerce
Legal issues uniform commercial code for ecommerce
 
Washington's Privacy Tango
Washington's Privacy TangoWashington's Privacy Tango
Washington's Privacy Tango
 
Isa12a
Isa12aIsa12a
Isa12a
 
Legal contexts of digital media & internet governance
Legal contexts of digital media & internet governanceLegal contexts of digital media & internet governance
Legal contexts of digital media & internet governance
 
American Government Wk 6 Unit 2 Project Amending The Constitution
American  Government  Wk 6  Unit 2  Project    Amending The  ConstitutionAmerican  Government  Wk 6  Unit 2  Project    Amending The  Constitution
American Government Wk 6 Unit 2 Project Amending The Constitution
 
Amazon Tax Wars
Amazon Tax WarsAmazon Tax Wars
Amazon Tax Wars
 
International politics in the age of the internet
International politics in the age of the internetInternational politics in the age of the internet
International politics in the age of the internet
 
Net neutrality
Net neutralityNet neutrality
Net neutrality
 
SOPA
SOPASOPA
SOPA
 
Digital Accessibility and Structured Negotiation for #A11yTO MeetUP
Digital Accessibility and Structured Negotiation for #A11yTO MeetUPDigital Accessibility and Structured Negotiation for #A11yTO MeetUP
Digital Accessibility and Structured Negotiation for #A11yTO MeetUP
 
Unraveling intermediary liability
Unraveling intermediary liabilityUnraveling intermediary liability
Unraveling intermediary liability
 
Copyright economy updated
Copyright economy updatedCopyright economy updated
Copyright economy updated
 
Rkcsi2012
Rkcsi2012Rkcsi2012
Rkcsi2012
 
Wealth Of Networks Info Intellectual P
Wealth Of Networks Info Intellectual PWealth Of Networks Info Intellectual P
Wealth Of Networks Info Intellectual P
 

Destaque

Destaque (9)

Igf oecd
Igf oecdIgf oecd
Igf oecd
 
Death And The Web
Death And The WebDeath And The Web
Death And The Web
 
Privacy and care robots
Privacy and care robotsPrivacy and care robots
Privacy and care robots
 
Ratemylegalrisknew
RatemylegalrisknewRatemylegalrisknew
Ratemylegalrisknew
 
Sible 09
Sible 09Sible 09
Sible 09
 
شخصيتي
شخصيتيشخصيتي
شخصيتي
 
Digital Lives Full Vn
Digital Lives Full VnDigital Lives Full Vn
Digital Lives Full Vn
 
Social media, surveillance and censorship
Social media, surveillance  and censorshipSocial media, surveillance  and censorship
Social media, surveillance and censorship
 
شخصيتي
شخصيتيشخصيتي
شخصيتي
 

Semelhante a Deb Act Talk April 2010

Dea dangerous downloaders act
Dea dangerous downloaders actDea dangerous downloaders act
Dea dangerous downloaders actrcorrigan
 
Anti social networking v 2
Anti social networking v 2Anti social networking v 2
Anti social networking v 2lilianedwards
 
#DEBIll: The Conspiracy Of Copyright
#DEBIll: The Conspiracy Of Copyright#DEBIll: The Conspiracy Of Copyright
#DEBIll: The Conspiracy Of Copyrightguest6b6037
 
2600 v20 n2 (summer 2003)
2600 v20 n2 (summer 2003)2600 v20 n2 (summer 2003)
2600 v20 n2 (summer 2003)Felipe Prado
 
The Brazilian Civil Rights Framework for the Internet (Marco Civil da Interne...
The Brazilian Civil Rights Framework for the Internet (Marco Civil da Interne...The Brazilian Civil Rights Framework for the Internet (Marco Civil da Interne...
The Brazilian Civil Rights Framework for the Internet (Marco Civil da Interne...Samuel Barros
 
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)Adam Thierer
 
Essay 3 annotated bibliography rough draft 18 july 2012
Essay 3 annotated bibliography rough draft 18 july 2012Essay 3 annotated bibliography rough draft 18 july 2012
Essay 3 annotated bibliography rough draft 18 july 2012rclambert
 
Freedom or Control in Virtual Worlds
Freedom or Control in Virtual WorldsFreedom or Control in Virtual Worlds
Freedom or Control in Virtual WorldsJyrki Kasvi
 
Pepsi Conclusion Essays. Online assignment writing service.
Pepsi Conclusion Essays. Online assignment writing service.Pepsi Conclusion Essays. Online assignment writing service.
Pepsi Conclusion Essays. Online assignment writing service.Kimi Allen
 
Technology evolves so fast
Technology evolves so fast Technology evolves so fast
Technology evolves so fast Jyrki Kasvi
 
Will the Internet Be Bad for Democracy Eli M. NoamProfessor a.docx
Will the Internet Be Bad for Democracy Eli M. NoamProfessor a.docxWill the Internet Be Bad for Democracy Eli M. NoamProfessor a.docx
Will the Internet Be Bad for Democracy Eli M. NoamProfessor a.docxalanfhall8953
 
Great Expectations: After the vote - citizens online, e-democracy in governan...
Great Expectations: After the vote - citizens online, e-democracy in governan...Great Expectations: After the vote - citizens online, e-democracy in governan...
Great Expectations: After the vote - citizens online, e-democracy in governan...Steven Clift
 
The Future of Net Neutrality: What's at stake for Canadians
The Future of Net Neutrality: What's at stake for CanadiansThe Future of Net Neutrality: What's at stake for Canadians
The Future of Net Neutrality: What's at stake for CanadiansCybera Inc.
 
E pets in_bristol_17 march 2011
E pets in_bristol_17 march 2011E pets in_bristol_17 march 2011
E pets in_bristol_17 march 2011Fraser Henderson
 

Semelhante a Deb Act Talk April 2010 (16)

Dea dangerous downloaders act
Dea dangerous downloaders actDea dangerous downloaders act
Dea dangerous downloaders act
 
Anti social networking v 2
Anti social networking v 2Anti social networking v 2
Anti social networking v 2
 
#DEBIll: The Conspiracy Of Copyright
#DEBIll: The Conspiracy Of Copyright#DEBIll: The Conspiracy Of Copyright
#DEBIll: The Conspiracy Of Copyright
 
2600 v20 n2 (summer 2003)
2600 v20 n2 (summer 2003)2600 v20 n2 (summer 2003)
2600 v20 n2 (summer 2003)
 
The Brazilian Civil Rights Framework for the Internet (Marco Civil da Interne...
The Brazilian Civil Rights Framework for the Internet (Marco Civil da Interne...The Brazilian Civil Rights Framework for the Internet (Marco Civil da Interne...
The Brazilian Civil Rights Framework for the Internet (Marco Civil da Interne...
 
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
 
Net Neutrality 03
Net Neutrality 03Net Neutrality 03
Net Neutrality 03
 
Essay 3 annotated bibliography rough draft 18 july 2012
Essay 3 annotated bibliography rough draft 18 july 2012Essay 3 annotated bibliography rough draft 18 july 2012
Essay 3 annotated bibliography rough draft 18 july 2012
 
Freedom or Control in Virtual Worlds
Freedom or Control in Virtual WorldsFreedom or Control in Virtual Worlds
Freedom or Control in Virtual Worlds
 
Pepsi Conclusion Essays. Online assignment writing service.
Pepsi Conclusion Essays. Online assignment writing service.Pepsi Conclusion Essays. Online assignment writing service.
Pepsi Conclusion Essays. Online assignment writing service.
 
Technology evolves so fast
Technology evolves so fast Technology evolves so fast
Technology evolves so fast
 
Will the Internet Be Bad for Democracy Eli M. NoamProfessor a.docx
Will the Internet Be Bad for Democracy Eli M. NoamProfessor a.docxWill the Internet Be Bad for Democracy Eli M. NoamProfessor a.docx
Will the Internet Be Bad for Democracy Eli M. NoamProfessor a.docx
 
Great Expectations: After the vote - citizens online, e-democracy in governan...
Great Expectations: After the vote - citizens online, e-democracy in governan...Great Expectations: After the vote - citizens online, e-democracy in governan...
Great Expectations: After the vote - citizens online, e-democracy in governan...
 
The Future of Net Neutrality: What's at stake for Canadians
The Future of Net Neutrality: What's at stake for CanadiansThe Future of Net Neutrality: What's at stake for Canadians
The Future of Net Neutrality: What's at stake for Canadians
 
E pets in_bristol_17 march 2011
E pets in_bristol_17 march 2011E pets in_bristol_17 march 2011
E pets in_bristol_17 march 2011
 
Reboot11 Elvira Berlingieri
Reboot11 Elvira BerlingieriReboot11 Elvira Berlingieri
Reboot11 Elvira Berlingieri
 

Deb Act Talk April 2010

  • 1. Law and Sausages: How Not to Legislate for The Digital Economy Lilian Edwards Professor of Internet Law Sheffield University [email_address] Pangloss: http://blogscript.blogspot.com/ @lilianedwards on Twitter
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7. Meanwhile elsewhere in the forest.. "trapped in a second tier of citizenship, denied what I increasingly think of as a fundamental freedom in the modern world: to be part of the internet and technology revolution". Gordon Brown, March 2010
  • 8. 2 nd issue: Democratic deficit? L Whitty, 3r Reading HL on lobbying _ I regret to say that during the course of our consideration of the Bill, we have seen one of the worst examples in my memory of the political parties being captured by a producer interest. That applies not only to the Government and the bringing forward of the Bill, but to the opposition Front Benches as well. .. despite a few ameliorations, this is still a bad Bill. It is bad for the digital rights holders to press their interests in this way, when there are alternatives, and it is bad for the Government to risk alienation of a very significant part of the population by enforcing these measures .
  • 9.
  • 12.
  • 13.

Notas do Editor

  1. Debilitate – theyworkfor thebpi.org didyourmvote.co.uk?
  2. DrWho quote - Democracy will become a participatory process for more than wonks – not a blank cheque for 5 years action