Hazard mitigation has increasingly become the responsibility of local decision makers who work with technical assistance providers to apply for federal funding. Understanding the disaster cycle: preparedness, response, recovery and mitigation; helps communities reduce risk from disaster. During this panel, the
importance of understanding the need to adopt both structural and non‐structural mitigation strategies will be covered.
Speakers: Jonathon Monken, Director, Illinois Emergency
Management Agency (IEMA); Rusty Tenton, State Hazard Mitigation
Office, Illinois Emergency Management Agency (IEMA); Ron Davis, State Hazard Mitigation Office, Illinois Emergency Management Agency (IEMA);
Foundation: Mary Ellen Chamberlin, President, RDA
Facilitator: Carrie McKillip, Community Development Educator,
University of Illinois Extension
1. How can Mitigation help us? Mitigation is the on-going effort to lessen the impact disasters have on people and property from natural or man-made disasters.
2. Use of Funding $150 million in mitigation funds over the last 16 years Almost 2 million dollars has been spent for plan development since 2004. Over 3500 homes have been bought in Illinois
3. Mitigation in Illinois Illinois has been a national leader in mitigation since 1993. The programs success nationwide established Federal guidance that seeks to better define our nations vulnerabilities. Hence the birth and importance of Mitigation Planning. After 2004, any recipient of Mitigation Funds, would be required to have a Mitigation plan in place first.
4. What does a Mitigation Plan do? In simplest terms: 1. Identifies risks that face your community; 2. Analyzes ways to mitigate risks; 3. Prioritize your mitigation activities.
5. History of Mitigation November 29th, 1993: The Mitigation Directorate was established. This directorate shifted the FEMA mission to breaking the cycle of disaster damage, reconstruction, and repeated damage. October 30th, 2000: The President signed the Disaster Mitigation Act of 2000 into law. This act established a pre-disaster mitigation program and set requirements in place for post disaster mitigation funding. March 2004: FEMA establishes guidance for approved mitigation plans. November 1st, 2004: The DMA2K requirements for post disaster project funding required that after November 1st, 2004, an approved Mitigation plan must be in place before funds can be disbursed for projects. July 1st 2008: Local mitigation planning guidance is re-written to include criteria for NFIP regulations as well as plan updates.
6. Rural Hazard Mitigation: Building Capacity and Partnerships Henderson County, Illinois and U of I Extension in Partnership for Recovery
8. The Situation 2008 Statewide average precipitation 11.4 inches above normal (second wettest year since 1895) 26 levees overtopped or breached along Mississippi between Rock Island, IL, and St, Louis, MO 25 Counties in Illinois declared Federal Disasters under FEMA 1771
10. The Situation Henderson County 2000 Census Estimate 8,213 2009 Population Estimates 7,354 Private non-farm employment decrease of 14.3% in the years 2000-2007 No significant manufacturing entity 378.81 square miles with 21.7 persons per square mile Source U.S. Census Bureau
11. The Situation June 10, 2008- Henderson Drainage District notified of Levee Decertification Process to begin June 14, 2008- The Village of Oquawka, Henderson County Seat, was evacuated due to breach in a levee along the Iowa River, which City Leaders felt would affect the flood waters in the already flooded Mississippi River June 15, 2008- In the predawn hours a levee just south of Gulfport, Illinois failed under record crests along the Mississippi River at the Burlington, Iowa Gauging Station
12. The Situation July 11, 2008 –Henderson County Drainage District breached Levees to help drain county still under water weeks after initial levee breach US 34 closed over 45 days, severely impacting the economy of both West Central Illinois and South Western Iowa Gas at over $4 per gallon, 2hr detour to bridges
13. The Situation Table 12*: IDOT Reported Transportation Losses by County (Information provided by IDOT May 21 and June 2, 2009(1) Declared County Traffic Impact Cost Adams $ 120,840.00 Hancock $ 509,950.00 Henderson $ 4,878,490.00 Jersey $ 48,370 .00 Mercer $ 58,500.00 Pike $ 402,725.00 Randolph $ 38,606.00 Other Entities $ 21,380.00 Total $ 6,078,861.00 *Source: LTRC Final Report, IL-DCEO
14. The Situation Table 21: Total Federal Assistance Provided to Illinois Counties Federal Assistance Provided 1. Adams $ 45,876,338 2. Henderson $ 34,721,504 3. Hancock $ 24,675,373 4. Lawrence $ 19,744,875 5. Pike $ 18,774,481 6. Madison $ 13,100,590 7. Mercer $ 13,016,323 8. Edgar $ 12,819,122 9. Winnebago $ 12,142,489 10. Rock Island $ 10,077,612 11. Douglas $ 10,020,595 12. Jasper $ 9,342,181 13. Greene $ 8,438,491 14. Coles $ 8,238,746 15. Whiteside $ 7,083,534 16. Clark $ 7,006,308 17. Randolph $ 6,275,889 18. Crawford $ 4,941,082 19. Calhoun $ 4,796,152 20. Jersey $ 3,902,159 21. St. Clair $ 3,739,968 22. Scott $ 3,739,466 23. Lake $ 3,300,176 24. Cumberland $ 3,083,116 25. Monroe $ 2,736,225 Other Entities $ 43,412,287 Total $ 335,005,082
15. The Situation Extension Illinois ResourceNet requested to help find funding Five calls to reach IEMA Mitigation office Few of Rural Counties in 1771 had FEMA Approved Mitigation Plans Pre-applications for buyouts and planning grants submitted for Henderson County August 21, 2008 U of I Extension Community Assessment and Development Services (CADS) contracted to HMP Facilitation in Hancock, Henderson, Mercer, and Pike Counties
16. Mitigation Planning Plans required by Disaster Mitigation Act of 2000 for any jurisdiction to access FEMA Mitigation Program Dollars Mitigation Grant Pre Disaster Mitigation Grant Repetitive Loss Program Severe Repetitive Loss Program
17. Mitigation Planning Funds for Mitigation Planning not released until July 2009 Normal 18 month process condensed to 7 months Meeting One- Organize to Plan Meeting Two- Jurisdictional Risk Assessment and Critical Facilities Identification Meeting Three-Public Engagement Plan and Mitigation Mission and Goals Meeting Four – Existing Plan Reviews and Mitigation Ideas by Jurisdiction Meeting Five- Jurisdictional Grid Development and Maintenance Plan Meeting Six – Draft Plan Review 100% Jurisdictional Participation
18. Mitigation Planning – Public Engagement Four Public Meetings throughout the County “Education Meets Planning” Mitigation Concepts Process Explanation Risk Assessment Grids Maps Request for Mitigation Ideas
19. Mitigation Planning- Public Engagement Focus Groups Ag and Natural Resource Health and Human Services Transportation Utilities Public Safety Government Business and Development Education
20. Mitigation Planning-Public Engagement 3199 Households in County 344 Surveys returned Multiple distribution sites Hard copy and online available Results show residents less than adequately prepared for disasters
21. Mitigation Planning-Lessons Learned Local Leadership/Champion Critical Wealth of Knowledge at local level if drawn out Extension seen as community partner rather than “contractor” Facilitate vs. Dictate Provide Committee with Research in Advance
22. Mitigation Planning-Plan Review and Adoption Solicit input from Committee “Selling” Final Product to Communities role of Steering Committee FEMA approval pending adoption-June 2010 Jurisdictions then pass resolution-Summer 2010 Final FEMA Approval- September 2010
23. Building Local Capacity Continue to work with Henderson County Community Recently (October 15) assisted application for “Midwest Disaster Fund” reimbursement of Public Assistance Match for selected FEMA Funded projects Worked with Local Officials and DCEO Contractor to submit application for $ 7.6M Buyout/Relocation Project for Henderson County Continuing work on prioritizing project from Mitigation Plan and funding plan
24. Building Local Capacity Facilitating Community Consensus Building “Hand Holding” One-on-One Technical Assistance Grant Writing Planning tools Public Communication Relationship Building (Internal and External)
25. Recent Outcomes October 30, 2010 Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity held a press conference in Gulfport, Illinois announcing the award of both Midwest Disaster Funding and Ike Funding (both CDBG) for Henderson County/Gulfport Recovery Funding includes portions of match reimbursements for FEMA Public Assistance Projects, 100% Buyout Projects, relocation incentives, and planning dollars for the relocation of Gulfport. Best Chance for recovery for Henderson County
26. Building Local Capacity Much yet to be done Once Recovery Funds expended, lots of projects that require little cost Extension providing coordination, education, and support to move projects forward Future issues include best practices volunteer documentation, early warning system investigation, watershed assessment, etc.
30. Illinois Environmental Protection Agency Mission: to safeguard environmental quality, consistent with the social and economic needs of the State, so as to protect health, welfare, property and the quality of life. Locations: Headquarters & Laboratory – Springfield 11 Field & Regional Offices: Champaign, Elk Grove, Moline, Rockford, Collinsville, LaSalle, Des Plaines, Springfield, Elgin, Marion, & Peoria History: First Earth Day – April 22, 1970 Illinois Environmental Protection Act – July 1, 1970 (first state) April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 30
36. Infrastructure Illinois Environmental Protection Agency Bureau of Water: Drinking Water Infrastructure Revolving Loan Program - The Public Water Supply Loan Program provides low interest loans to units of local government for the construction of community water supply facilities. These funds are awarded on a competitive basis with an annual pre-application deadline of March 31. Priority consideration is given to projects with compliance problems, financial hardship and small community water supplies. This year under the has received more than a billion dollars in request with funding available for around 81 million in projects. Our current interest rate is 1.25 percent. A portion of the loan is forgivable based on population demographics. New Funding Cycle Contact Info: Telephone No: (217) 782-2027 Fax No: (217) 785-1225 Illinois Environmental Protection Agency 1021 North Grand Avenue East P.O. Box 19276 Springfield, Illinois 62794-9276 April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 32
37. Wastewater Infrastructure Revolving Loan Program - The Water Pollution Control Loan Program provides low interest loans to units of local government for the construction of wastewater facilities. The loans are awarded with a maximum term of 20 years. The funds are awarded on a competitive basis with an annual pre-application deadline of March 31 to qualify to have your project considered for the next loan cycle. This year under the Agency has received more than 2 billion dollars in request with funding available for only 250 million in projects. New Funding Cycle Contact Info: Telephone No: (217) 782-2027 Fax No: (217) 785-1225 Illinois Environmental Protection Agency 1021 North Grand Avenue East P.O. Box 19276 Springfield, Illinois 62794-9276 April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 33 Infrastructure Illinois Environmental Protection Agency
38. April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 34 Infrastructure Illinois Environmental Protection Agency Illinois Green Infrastructure Grant Program for Stormwater Management (IGIG) Grants are available to local units of government and other organizations to implement green infrastructure best management practices to control stormwater runoff for water quality protection in Illinois. Projects must be located within a Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) or Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) area. Funds are limited to the implementation of projects to install best management practices (BMPs). The total amount of funding available under IGIG is approximately 5 million dollars annually. This is a reimbursement program. Grant recipients must perform the work, pay project costs, and submit invoice(s) (periodically throughout the project period) with supporting documentation before Illinois EPA will reimburse recipients for any approved costs. Under IGIG, the Illinois EPA will accept proposals for the following three program categories:
39. Infrastructure Illinois Environmental Protection Agency Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) Rehabilitation Category Maximum IGIG amount is $3,000,000 or 85 percent of the eligible project cost, whichever is lower. Minimum local match requirement is 15 percent. Illinois EPA anticipates awarding up to 10 of these grants per year Typical grant range is $300,000 - $3,000,000 of IGIG funds (total grant funds available $3 million) Project length ranges from 6-36 months Stormwater Retention and Infiltration Category Maximum IGIG amount is $750,000 or 75 percent of the eligible project cost, whichever is lower. Minimum local match requirement is 25 percent. Illinois EPA anticipates awarding up to 18 of these grants per year Typical grant range is $100,000 - $750,000 of IGIG funds (total grant funds available $1.8 million) Project length ranges from 6-36 months April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 35
40. Infrastructure Illinois Environmental Protection Agency Green Infrastructure Small Projects Category. Maximum IGIG amount is $75,000 or 75 percent of the eligible project cost, whichever is lower. Minimum local match requirement is 25 percent. Illinois EPA anticipates awarding up to 13 of these grants per year Typical grant range is $15,000 - $75,000 of IGIG funds (total grant funds available $200,000) Project length ranges from 6-24 months Applications are due Illinois EPA by December 15th. If December 15th is a Saturday or Sunday, the deadline becomes the prior Friday before 5:00 p.m. www.epa.state.il.us/water/financial-assistance/igig.html Contact the Watershed Management Section at (217) 782-3362 with questions April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 36
41. Non Point Source Pollution Prevention Grants are available to local units of government and other organizations to protect water quality in Illinois. Projects must address water quality issues relating directly to nonpoint source pollution. Funds can be used for the implementation of watershed management plans including the development of information/ education programs and for the installation of best management practices. Illinois EPA receives these funds through Section 319 of the Clean Water Act and administers the program within Illinois. The Maximum Federal funding available is 60 percent. The program period is two years unless otherwise approved. This is a reimbursement program. Applications are accepted June 1 through August 1. If August 1 is a Saturday or Sunday, the deadline becomes the prior Friday before 5 p.m.). Contact: Illinois Environmental Protection Agency Watershed Management Section #15 1021 North Grand Avenue East P.O. Box 19276 Springfield, Illinois 62794-9276 217/782-3362 http://www.epa.state.il.us (Bureau of Water>Financial Assistance April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 37
42. Bureau of Land: Municipal Brownfields Redevelopment Grant - The Office of Brownfields Assistance manages the Brownfields grant and loan programs and offers technical support to communities through the services of its Brownfields representatives. Brownfields representatives work directly with communities to explain cleanup options, regulatory programs and requirements and guide municipalities through the Brownfields cleanup and redevelopment process. The Municipal Brownfields Redevelopment Grant Program provides funding to local municipalities to investigate and clean up brownfields properties. Special provision for RERZ Brownfields Cleanup Revolving Loan Fund (Stipulated Grant) - The Illinois Brownfields Redevelopment Loan Program is a revolving low-interest loan program that provides funds to municipalities and the private sector for the environmental cleanup of Brownfields sites. Contact:Illinois Environmental Protection Agency Office of Brownfields Assistance #24 1021 North Grand Avenue East P.O. Box 19276 Springfield, Illinois 62794-9276 217/785-9407 http://www.epa.state.il.us (Land > Cleanup Programs > Brownfields Assistance) April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 38 Brownfield Cleanup State of Illinois
43. April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 39 Brownfield Cleanup State of Illinois Bureau of Land: Leaking Underground Storage Tank (LUST) - The Leaking Underground Storage Tank (LUST) Section oversees the remedial activities after a release from an underground storage tank has been reported to the Illinois Emergency Management Agency. Leaking UST Section staff review the technical adequacy of site classification and site investigation plans and reports, groundwater monitoring plans and reports, corrective action plans and reports, and associated budgets. This includes the development and evaluation of the appropriate remediation objectives for each site. Once the site has met its remediation objectives and program requirements, the Illinois EPA issues a No Further Remediation Letter for the leaking UST incident. Leaking UST staff also perform site visits, as needed. Section /LUST Fund – 217/782-6762 or (Toll Free) 1-888/299-9533
44. April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 40 Brownfield Cleanup State of Illinois Bureau of Land: Office of Site Evaluation – This office provides resources for time-critical removal actions and remediation of National Priorities List sites. Time critical removal actions are short-term emergency actions that may include disposal of tanks or drums of hazardous substances, excavation of contaminated soil or installation of security measures at a site. Immediate dangers are addressed first; and progressive steps are taken to evaluate whether a site remains a serious threat to public health or the environment. The Office of Site Evaluation's priorities are to: a) identify potential hazardous sites; b) identify need for emergency action; c) evaluate the backlog of sites on EPA's computerized inventory of potential hazardous substance release sites; and d) propose listing of appropriate sites on the National Priorities List. Tom Crause 217/524-1658
45. Pollution Prevention April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 41 Office of Pollution Prevention: Pollution Prevention On-Site Technical Assistance – Kevin Greene 217/785-0833 Green Illinois: Green Schools Program – Becky Lockart 217/524-9642 Contact: Illinois Environmental Protection Agency Office of Pollution Prevention #34 1021 North Grand Avenue East P.O. Box 19276 Springfield, Illinois 62794-9276 http://www.epa.state.il.us (Green Illinois)
46. April 28, 2011 IEPA Programs 42 Offices & Special Projects The Office of Community Relations encourages and facilitates communication between the public and the Illinois EPA. "Public" means individuals, communities, businesses and other organizations, that have an interest in the activities and decisions of Illinois EPA. The Office of Small Business works with small businesses in complying with environmental requirements. The Small Business Office develops and publishes information specifically for small businesses, opens up channels of communication with small business associations and organizations, responds to questions/concerns from small business owners, and acts as an advocate for the small business community within Illinois EPA.
125. Schuyler CountyLocal jurisdictions not participating in the NFIP are ineligible for PDM/FMA/RFC/SRL funding 13/102=12% DeKalb DuPage Whiteside Lee Kendall Will LaSalle Bureau RockIsland Henry Grundy Mercer Putnam Kankakee Stark Marshall Knox Livingston Henderson Warren Woodford Peoria Iroquois Fulton Ford Tazewell McLean McDonough Hancock Mason Vermilion De Witt Schuyler Logan Champaign Menard Adams Brown Cass Piatt Macon Sangamon Douglas Morgan Edgar Moultrie Scott Pike Christian Coles Shelby Greene Clark Cumberland Macoupin Montgomery Calhoun Jersey Fayette Effingham Crawford Jasper Bond Madison Clay Lawrence Richland Marion Clinton Wabash St.Clair Edwards Wayne Washington Jefferson Monroe White Perry Hamilton Randolph Franklin Jackson Gallatin Saline Williamson Hardin Johnson Pope Union Pulaski Massac Note: 11% of Illinois Counties have not started a plan (12 Counties) Alexander
Editor's Notes
Extension, through two separate programs, has been working with Henderson County, IL since July of 2008 in their long term recovery efforts. (show video). The video illustrates the situation, but also identified the programmatic aspects of IRN and CADS. Continuing to work with the County to implement the mitigation plan, as well as build local capacity.
Due to the rural nature of the county, leadership was stretched thin, simply dealing with immediate safety issues. The county was already economically depressed, so the flood aggravated an already difficult situation, and further eroded the population
In late July, when I first started going to Henderson County, the water was still standing in the fields.
While some losses were measurable, others were not. As can be seen by this chart, nearly 80% of the adverse transportation cost associate with FEMA 1771 were along US 34 in Henderson County.
As can be seen Here, Henderson County ranked second in the total amount of Federal Assistance Provided, while accounting for only a small fraction of the population
Any long term mitigation for Henderson County was delayed since they did not have a mitigation plan. For this reason, Extension worked with the county to quickly turn around a grant application for FEMA Funding, and actually facilitated the development of the plan.
During the planning process, we provided the historical weather data to the committee, and facilitated the discussion of risk assesment. We also looked and the Illinois Plan and shared how the state ranked the county for each natural Hazard. We also reviewed existing plans and pulled examples of mitigation goals from six differenct plans to share with the group as a starting point for the goal discussion.
These public meeting gave the community a chance to learn the process, submit ideas, and become engaged in the process.
Final Plan was submitted in late february, but FEMA Region 5 only has one person reviewing the plans, so it took a while to get approval pending adoption. Most jurisdictions adopted immediately, but last jusidiction in Henderson County adopted October 4, 2010. 100% adoption.
Keithsburg also flooded in 1993, but because of a substantial buyout project(80 homes), far fewer homes were flooded in 2008 flood. This is the kind of success that Henderson County, IL is hoping to achieve with the relocation of Gulfport (approximately 25 miles down river)