The Promise of Commons in the context of PES Markets : Learning of FES in India

International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
The Promise of Commons in the context
of PES Markets :
Learning of FES in India
Pranab R Choudhury
Promises of Commons :
Potential Economic (Green Market) Opportunities through a System Lens
From a Village Socio-Ecological System (Landscape mosaic)
Pasture
Forest
Farm
Wetlands
Supply
Chain
Economy
Value
Chain
Economy
Village
Landscape
Mosaic
of
Commons
&
Private
X
3
Production
phases

4
Eco-Opportunities
Streams
Community-Forest Relations/
Stewardship Practices –
Local mechanisms critical for global resilience
GLOCAL benefits (?)
Win-Win for Nature, Community & Market?
Value
Care, Co-
existence
Management
Traditional
Knowledge &
Practices
Governance
Institution,
Tenure,
Gender
Cultural,
Social,
recreational
provisions
Ecosystem
Services
(Carbon,
Biodiversity,
Water,
Nutrition)
Products
Food, NTFP,
Fuelwood,
Fodder,
Timber
Community
Wellbeing &
Commons
Resilience
Climate Action
(PES)
Bundled Ecosystem Products & Services
Global (Regulatory services) & Local
(Provisioning - Food and livelihoods products
& farm-services as well as other socio-
cultural services )
Meghalaya & Odisha :
Early Insights into System Thinking of Community, &
Potential Risks from Linear & Commodity approach
Bundled Eco-opportunities
• Forest as source of local food and
medicine
• Timber and Fuel wood
• NTFP – Hill broom for livelihoods
• Watershed and Nutrition services
• Forest Paths – social & recreational
spaces
• Reducing employment/ engagement
with forest
• Increasing extractive actions – stone
quarry, Private timber forests
Forest-People Relations
• Value : Care & Co-existence (view on
pests & wildlife damage in farm to
livestock grazing in forests)
• Governance : Hierarchical Landscape
to Village Tenure – Community-
Individual continuum
• Management : Forest-Pasture- Farm
(Horti-Paddy) continuum, Poh-Bun
system (Shifting Cultivation on Grass
lands), Ethno-silviculture
• Increasing tenure- individualisation,
knowledge erosion, weakening of
local governance
Project Intervention
• PES Scheme in Meghalaya – Copy
book forestry project premised
external knowledge and control –
limited FPIC, risking local
governance, management and value
systems
• JFM & CFR Management overlap in
Odisha : Project based approach
weakening local governance and
knowledge, while rights recognition
potentially reviving community value
For a Win- Win Option in PES-Ecosystem
Shift to System approach is Imperative
Carbon
Commodification :
Unbundling of Forest-
People relation;
limited scope of Co-
benefits or Carbon +
Colonial Market Structure &
Dynamics :
Risk to Community Tenure &
Governance, FPIC, fair share &
environmental Justice
Methodology focusing
More on Quality &
Integrity : Challenges
of Additionality for
Community
Colonisation to Communitisation
FPIC + (Project & methodology development, Monitoring, enhanced voice,
participation and share)
Commodification to Bundling
Co-benefits, Carbon+++
Reductionism to Holism
India’s Green Credit, Verra’s Nature Credit
Adding Socio-ecological lens to Science & Market based Approach
Enhancing Community Voice and Engagement of CSO in PES Market
Thanks!
Join us at….
1 de 6

Recomendados

The Promise of Commons in the context of PES Markets : Learning of FES in India por
The Promise of Commons in the context of PES Markets : Learning of FES in IndiaThe Promise of Commons in the context of PES Markets : Learning of FES in India
The Promise of Commons in the context of PES Markets : Learning of FES in IndiaInternational Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
16 visualizações7 slides
Fostering the social forestry program: Inclusive business models (IBMs) in co... por
Fostering the social forestry program: Inclusive business models (IBMs) in co...Fostering the social forestry program: Inclusive business models (IBMs) in co...
Fostering the social forestry program: Inclusive business models (IBMs) in co...CIFOR-ICRAF
812 visualizações14 slides
26 0930 3_cegorn_customary tenure recognition in vietnam por
26 0930 3_cegorn_customary tenure recognition in vietnam26 0930 3_cegorn_customary tenure recognition in vietnam
26 0930 3_cegorn_customary tenure recognition in vietnammrlgregion
63 visualizações9 slides
Kanel National Adaptation Plan Role Of Land Rights Keshav Kanel Oct 2008 por
Kanel National Adaptation Plan Role Of Land Rights Keshav Kanel Oct 2008Kanel National Adaptation Plan Role Of Land Rights Keshav Kanel Oct 2008
Kanel National Adaptation Plan Role Of Land Rights Keshav Kanel Oct 2008rightsandclimate
372 visualizações12 slides
Fao 02 por
Fao 02Fao 02
Fao 02JuNaid OoZz
336 visualizações17 slides
Improving the performance of farming systems through Agroecological intensifi... por
Improving the performance of farming systems through Agroecological intensifi...Improving the performance of farming systems through Agroecological intensifi...
Improving the performance of farming systems through Agroecological intensifi...FAO
829 visualizações15 slides

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Similar a The Promise of Commons in the context of PES Markets : Learning of FES in India

India, beyond the glittering economy: By Shreekanth Gupta por
India, beyond the glittering economy: By Shreekanth GuptaIndia, beyond the glittering economy: By Shreekanth Gupta
India, beyond the glittering economy: By Shreekanth Guptabmbks321
464 visualizações41 slides
Ecological Swaraj: Escaping the Globalised 'Development' Trap por
Ecological Swaraj: Escaping the Globalised 'Development' Trap  Ecological Swaraj: Escaping the Globalised 'Development' Trap
Ecological Swaraj: Escaping the Globalised 'Development' Trap Ashish Kothari
832 visualizações48 slides
The Amazon Eco-Regional Research Program por
The Amazon Eco-Regional Research ProgramThe Amazon Eco-Regional Research Program
The Amazon Eco-Regional Research ProgramCIAT
653 visualizações37 slides
West Africa Forest-Farm Interface Project (WAFFI): Enhancing smallholder food... por
West Africa Forest-Farm Interface Project (WAFFI): Enhancing smallholder food...West Africa Forest-Farm Interface Project (WAFFI): Enhancing smallholder food...
West Africa Forest-Farm Interface Project (WAFFI): Enhancing smallholder food...CIFOR-ICRAF
918 visualizações9 slides
Environment & Development, Bhagalpur (Bihar, India), 8.3.2016 por
Environment & Development, Bhagalpur (Bihar, India), 8.3.2016Environment & Development, Bhagalpur (Bihar, India), 8.3.2016
Environment & Development, Bhagalpur (Bihar, India), 8.3.2016Ashish Kothari
2.4K visualizações47 slides
Paper por
PaperPaper
PaperPawan kumar
157 visualizações10 slides

Similar a The Promise of Commons in the context of PES Markets : Learning of FES in India(20)

India, beyond the glittering economy: By Shreekanth Gupta por bmbks321
India, beyond the glittering economy: By Shreekanth GuptaIndia, beyond the glittering economy: By Shreekanth Gupta
India, beyond the glittering economy: By Shreekanth Gupta
bmbks321464 visualizações
Ecological Swaraj: Escaping the Globalised 'Development' Trap por Ashish Kothari
Ecological Swaraj: Escaping the Globalised 'Development' Trap  Ecological Swaraj: Escaping the Globalised 'Development' Trap
Ecological Swaraj: Escaping the Globalised 'Development' Trap
Ashish Kothari832 visualizações
The Amazon Eco-Regional Research Program por CIAT
The Amazon Eco-Regional Research ProgramThe Amazon Eco-Regional Research Program
The Amazon Eco-Regional Research Program
CIAT653 visualizações
West Africa Forest-Farm Interface Project (WAFFI): Enhancing smallholder food... por CIFOR-ICRAF
West Africa Forest-Farm Interface Project (WAFFI): Enhancing smallholder food...West Africa Forest-Farm Interface Project (WAFFI): Enhancing smallholder food...
West Africa Forest-Farm Interface Project (WAFFI): Enhancing smallholder food...
CIFOR-ICRAF918 visualizações
Environment & Development, Bhagalpur (Bihar, India), 8.3.2016 por Ashish Kothari
Environment & Development, Bhagalpur (Bihar, India), 8.3.2016Environment & Development, Bhagalpur (Bihar, India), 8.3.2016
Environment & Development, Bhagalpur (Bihar, India), 8.3.2016
Ashish Kothari2.4K visualizações
Paper por Pawan kumar
PaperPaper
Paper
Pawan kumar157 visualizações
Crop residue tradeoffs in crop-livestock systems: SLP project overview por ILRI
Crop residue tradeoffs in crop-livestock systems: SLP project overviewCrop residue tradeoffs in crop-livestock systems: SLP project overview
Crop residue tradeoffs in crop-livestock systems: SLP project overview
ILRI871 visualizações
Alternative Transformation Framework por Ashish Kothari
Alternative Transformation Framework Alternative Transformation Framework
Alternative Transformation Framework
Ashish Kothari408 visualizações
Obama singh 21st century initiative progress review 2 por Plymouth State University
Obama singh 21st century initiative progress review 2Obama singh 21st century initiative progress review 2
Obama singh 21st century initiative progress review 2
Plymouth State University614 visualizações
Governance arrangements, vulnerability and forest users in the Cameroon savannah por Verina Ingram
Governance arrangements, vulnerability and forest users in the Cameroon savannahGovernance arrangements, vulnerability and forest users in the Cameroon savannah
Governance arrangements, vulnerability and forest users in the Cameroon savannah
Verina Ingram499 visualizações
Collective tenure over commons por CIFOR-ICRAF
Collective tenure over commonsCollective tenure over commons
Collective tenure over commons
CIFOR-ICRAF906 visualizações
Forests sustaining agriculture: A systematic review of multi-functional lands... por CIFOR-ICRAF
Forests sustaining agriculture: A systematic review of multi-functional lands...Forests sustaining agriculture: A systematic review of multi-functional lands...
Forests sustaining agriculture: A systematic review of multi-functional lands...
CIFOR-ICRAF564 visualizações
Scientific approaches wle ciat_tnc por fredkizito
Scientific approaches wle ciat_tncScientific approaches wle ciat_tnc
Scientific approaches wle ciat_tnc
fredkizito364 visualizações
Bnl 1st pre-participatory-brs-9-11-09 por Maninder12
Bnl 1st pre-participatory-brs-9-11-09Bnl 1st pre-participatory-brs-9-11-09
Bnl 1st pre-participatory-brs-9-11-09
Maninder121K visualizações
India IFRI Report 2013 por rchalat
India IFRI Report 2013India IFRI Report 2013
India IFRI Report 2013
rchalat326 visualizações
community based natural resource management por Shravan Rajur
community based natural resource managementcommunity based natural resource management
community based natural resource management
Shravan Rajur18.7K visualizações
Social capital outcomes and sustainability of natural resource management lo... por World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
Social capital outcomes and sustainability of natural resource management  lo...Social capital outcomes and sustainability of natural resource management  lo...
Social capital outcomes and sustainability of natural resource management lo...
World Agroforestry (ICRAF)831 visualizações

Mais de International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)

Targeting in Development Projects: Approaches, challenges, and lessons learned por
Targeting in Development Projects: Approaches, challenges, and lessons learnedTargeting in Development Projects: Approaches, challenges, and lessons learned
Targeting in Development Projects: Approaches, challenges, and lessons learnedInternational Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
15 visualizações48 slides
Prevalence and Impact of Landmines on Ukrainian Agricultural Production por
Prevalence and Impact of Landmines on Ukrainian Agricultural ProductionPrevalence and Impact of Landmines on Ukrainian Agricultural Production
Prevalence and Impact of Landmines on Ukrainian Agricultural ProductionInternational Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
17 visualizações11 slides
Global Markets and the War in Ukraine por
Global Markets and  the War in UkraineGlobal Markets and  the War in Ukraine
Global Markets and the War in UkraineInternational Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
31 visualizações12 slides
Impact of the Russian Military Invasion on Ukraine’s Agriculture and Trade por
Impact of the Russian Military Invasion on Ukraine’s Agriculture and Trade Impact of the Russian Military Invasion on Ukraine’s Agriculture and Trade
Impact of the Russian Military Invasion on Ukraine’s Agriculture and Trade International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
50 visualizações14 slides
Mapping cropland extent over a complex landscape: An assessment of the best a... por
Mapping cropland extent over a complex landscape: An assessment of the best a...Mapping cropland extent over a complex landscape: An assessment of the best a...
Mapping cropland extent over a complex landscape: An assessment of the best a...International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
8 visualizações13 slides
Examples of remote sensing application in agriculture monitoring por
Examples of remote sensing application in agriculture monitoringExamples of remote sensing application in agriculture monitoring
Examples of remote sensing application in agriculture monitoringInternational Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
7 visualizações18 slides

Mais de International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)(20)

Último

Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ... por
Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ...Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ...
Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ...India Water Portal
13 visualizações16 slides
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A... por
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A...OECD CFE
7 visualizações19 slides
The National Security Framework of Spain por
The National Security Framework of SpainThe National Security Framework of Spain
The National Security Framework of SpainMiguel A. Amutio
33 visualizações32 slides
Atlas of Military Compensation por
Atlas of Military CompensationAtlas of Military Compensation
Atlas of Military CompensationCongressional Budget Office
675 visualizações5 slides
Job Posting - Fire Inspector, PT.pdf por
Job Posting - Fire Inspector, PT.pdfJob Posting - Fire Inspector, PT.pdf
Job Posting - Fire Inspector, PT.pdfNorthwestBOCA
15 visualizações1 slide
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections por
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCongressional Budget Office
254 visualizações22 slides

Último(20)

Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ... por India Water Portal
Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ...Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ...
Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ...
India Water Portal13 visualizações
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A... por OECD CFE
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A...
OECD CFE7 visualizações
The National Security Framework of Spain por Miguel A. Amutio
The National Security Framework of SpainThe National Security Framework of Spain
The National Security Framework of Spain
Miguel A. Amutio33 visualizações
Job Posting - Fire Inspector, PT.pdf por NorthwestBOCA
Job Posting - Fire Inspector, PT.pdfJob Posting - Fire Inspector, PT.pdf
Job Posting - Fire Inspector, PT.pdf
NorthwestBOCA15 visualizações
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections por Congressional Budget Office
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
Congressional Budget Office254 visualizações
Bankrolling Terrorism: The Secret Financing Power of the Al-Kuwari Clan in Al... por aljazeeramasoom
Bankrolling Terrorism: The Secret Financing Power of the Al-Kuwari Clan in Al...Bankrolling Terrorism: The Secret Financing Power of the Al-Kuwari Clan in Al...
Bankrolling Terrorism: The Secret Financing Power of the Al-Kuwari Clan in Al...
aljazeeramasoom5 visualizações
COP28: Example of Formation of Negotiated Texts: Global StockTake por Energy for One World
COP28: Example of  Formation of Negotiated Texts: Global StockTakeCOP28: Example of  Formation of Negotiated Texts: Global StockTake
COP28: Example of Formation of Negotiated Texts: Global StockTake
Energy for One World11 visualizações
Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS... por India Water Portal
Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS...Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS...
Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS...
India Water Portal22 visualizações
Ending Stagnation: A New Economic Strategy for Britain por ResolutionFoundation
Ending Stagnation: A New Economic Strategy for BritainEnding Stagnation: A New Economic Strategy for Britain
Ending Stagnation: A New Economic Strategy for Britain
ResolutionFoundation1.4K visualizações
University of Cambridge: COP28 briefing por Energy for One World
University of Cambridge: COP28 briefingUniversity of Cambridge: COP28 briefing
University of Cambridge: COP28 briefing
Energy for One World14 visualizações
MMF Newsletter Februar 2022.pdf por mmpcofficial
MMF Newsletter Februar 2022.pdfMMF Newsletter Februar 2022.pdf
MMF Newsletter Februar 2022.pdf
mmpcofficial7 visualizações
AABS project overview por WorldFish
AABS project overviewAABS project overview
AABS project overview
WorldFish38 visualizações
WMO Provisional State of the Global Climate 2023.pdf por Energy for One World
WMO Provisional State of the Global Climate 2023.pdfWMO Provisional State of the Global Climate 2023.pdf
WMO Provisional State of the Global Climate 2023.pdf
Energy for One World5 visualizações
WCAG 2.2 - An Overview of the New Accessibility Guidelines.pptx por AbilityNet
WCAG 2.2 - An Overview of the New Accessibility Guidelines.pptxWCAG 2.2 - An Overview of the New Accessibility Guidelines.pptx
WCAG 2.2 - An Overview of the New Accessibility Guidelines.pptx
AbilityNet72 visualizações

The Promise of Commons in the context of PES Markets : Learning of FES in India

  • 1. The Promise of Commons in the context of PES Markets : Learning of FES in India Pranab R Choudhury
  • 2. Promises of Commons : Potential Economic (Green Market) Opportunities through a System Lens From a Village Socio-Ecological System (Landscape mosaic) Pasture Forest Farm Wetlands Supply Chain Economy Value Chain Economy Village Landscape Mosaic of Commons & Private X 3 Production phases  4 Eco-Opportunities Streams
  • 3. Community-Forest Relations/ Stewardship Practices – Local mechanisms critical for global resilience GLOCAL benefits (?) Win-Win for Nature, Community & Market? Value Care, Co- existence Management Traditional Knowledge & Practices Governance Institution, Tenure, Gender Cultural, Social, recreational provisions Ecosystem Services (Carbon, Biodiversity, Water, Nutrition) Products Food, NTFP, Fuelwood, Fodder, Timber Community Wellbeing & Commons Resilience Climate Action (PES) Bundled Ecosystem Products & Services Global (Regulatory services) & Local (Provisioning - Food and livelihoods products & farm-services as well as other socio- cultural services )
  • 4. Meghalaya & Odisha : Early Insights into System Thinking of Community, & Potential Risks from Linear & Commodity approach Bundled Eco-opportunities • Forest as source of local food and medicine • Timber and Fuel wood • NTFP – Hill broom for livelihoods • Watershed and Nutrition services • Forest Paths – social & recreational spaces • Reducing employment/ engagement with forest • Increasing extractive actions – stone quarry, Private timber forests Forest-People Relations • Value : Care & Co-existence (view on pests & wildlife damage in farm to livestock grazing in forests) • Governance : Hierarchical Landscape to Village Tenure – Community- Individual continuum • Management : Forest-Pasture- Farm (Horti-Paddy) continuum, Poh-Bun system (Shifting Cultivation on Grass lands), Ethno-silviculture • Increasing tenure- individualisation, knowledge erosion, weakening of local governance Project Intervention • PES Scheme in Meghalaya – Copy book forestry project premised external knowledge and control – limited FPIC, risking local governance, management and value systems • JFM & CFR Management overlap in Odisha : Project based approach weakening local governance and knowledge, while rights recognition potentially reviving community value
  • 5. For a Win- Win Option in PES-Ecosystem Shift to System approach is Imperative Carbon Commodification : Unbundling of Forest- People relation; limited scope of Co- benefits or Carbon + Colonial Market Structure & Dynamics : Risk to Community Tenure & Governance, FPIC, fair share & environmental Justice Methodology focusing More on Quality & Integrity : Challenges of Additionality for Community Colonisation to Communitisation FPIC + (Project & methodology development, Monitoring, enhanced voice, participation and share) Commodification to Bundling Co-benefits, Carbon+++ Reductionism to Holism India’s Green Credit, Verra’s Nature Credit Adding Socio-ecological lens to Science & Market based Approach Enhancing Community Voice and Engagement of CSO in PES Market