This document discusses various methods and equipment used for radiation dosimetry in radiotherapy. It describes phantoms that are used to simulate patient tissue, including water phantoms, slab phantoms made of tissue-equivalent materials, and anthropomorphic phantoms. It also discusses different radiation detection methods including ionization chambers, thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLD), semiconductor devices, radiographic film, and their uses and limitations in radiation dosimetry. Common dosimeters discussed include Farmer chambers, parallel-plate chambers, TLD crystals, diodes, and radiographic film.
2. Quick Question
A dose of 1Gy delivers a huge quantity of
energy to the patient - is it true or false?
3. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 3
Answer
FALSE – 1Gy = 1J/kg. Delivering this amount
of energy would raise the temperature of
tissue by less than 0.001oC. Even for a 100kg
person it is much less than the energy
consumed with a bowl of muesli – please note
the amount of energy in food is often listed on
the package.
4. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 4
2. The dosimetric environment
Phantoms
A phantom represents the radiation properties of
the patient and allows the introduction of a
radiation detector into this environment, a task that
would be difficult in a real patient.
A very important example is the scanning water
phantom.
Alternatively, the phantom can be made of slabs
of tissue mimicking material or even shaped as a
human body (anthropomorphic).
5. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 5
Scanning water
phantom
6. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 6
Slab phantoms
7. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 7
Tissue equivalent materials
Many specifically manufactured materials
such as solid water (previous slide), white
water, plastic water, …
Polystyrene (good for megavoltage beams,
not ideal for low energy photons)
Perspex (other names: PMMA, Plexiglas) -
tissue equivalent composition, but with higher
physical density - correction is necessary.
8. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 8
Anthropomorphic phantom
Whole body
phantom: ART
9. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 9
Allows placement of radiation detectors in
the phantom (shown here are TLDs)
Includes
inhomogeneities
10. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 10
RANDO
phantom
torso
CT slice
through lung
Head with
TLD holes
11. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 11
Pediatric phantom
12. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 12
Some remarks on phantoms
It is essential that they are tested prior to use
physical measurements - weight, dimensions
radiation measurements - CT scan, attenuation
checks
Cheaper alternatives can also be used
wax for shaping of humanoid phantoms
cork as lung equivalent
As long as their properties and limitations are
known - they are useful
13. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 13
3. Radiation effects and dosimetry
Radiation effect Dosimetric method
Ionization in gases Ionization chamber
Ionization in liquids Liquid filled ionization chamber
Ionization in solids Semiconductors
Diamond detectors
Luminescence Thermoluminescence dosimetry
Fluorescence Scintillators
Chemical transitions Radiographic film
Chemical dosimetry
NMR dosimetry
Heat Calorimetry
Biological effects Erythema
Chromosome damage
14. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 14
Principles of radiation detection
Ionization chamber
Geiger Mueller Counter
Thermoluminescence dosimetry
Film
Semiconductors
15. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 15
Detection of Ionization in Air
Adapted
from Collins
2001
Ion chamber
16. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 16
Detection of Ionization in Air
Adapted
from
Metcalfe
1998
17. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 17
Ionometric measurements
Ionization Chamber
200-400V
Measures exposure
which can be
converted to dose
not very sensitive
Geiger Counter
>700V
Every ionization
event is counted
Counter of events
not a dosimeter
very sensitive
18. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 18
Ionization Chambers
Thimble chambers
600cc chamber
19. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 19
Cross section through a Farmer type
chamber (from Metcalfe 1996)
20. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 20
Ionization Chambers
Farmer 0.6 cc
chamber and
electrometer
Most important
chamber in
radiotherapy
dosimetry
21. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 21
Electrometer
From the chamber
22. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 22
Ionization chambers
Relatively large volume for small signal
(1Gy produces approximately 36nC in
1cc of air)
To improve spatial resolution at least in
one dimension parallel plate type
chambers are used.
23. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 23
Parallel plate chambers
From Metcalfe et al 1996
24. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 24
Parallel Plate Ionization Chambers
Used for
low energy X Rays (< 60 KV)
Electrons of any energy but rated as the
preferred method for energies < 10 MeV
and essential for energies < 5 MeV
Many types available in different
materials and sizes
Often sold in combination with a suitable
slab phantom
25. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 25
Parallel Plate Ionization
Chambers - examples
Markus chamber
small
designed for
electrons
Holt chamber
robust
embedded in
polystyrene slab
26. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 26
Ionization chamber type survey
meters
not as sensitive as G-M devices but not affected by
pulsed beams such as occur with accelerators
because of the above,
this is the preferred
device around high
energy radiotherapy
accelerators
27. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 27
Geiger-Mueller Counter
Not a dosimeter - just a
counter of radiation events
Very sensitive
Light weight and convenient
to use
Suitable for miniaturization
28. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 28
Geiger-Mueller (G-M) Devices
Useful for
area monitoring
room monitoring
personnel
monitoring
Care required in regions of high dose
rate or pulsed beams as reading may
be inaccurate
29. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 29
Thermoluminescence
dosimetry (TLD)
Small crystals
Many different materials
Passive dosimeter - no cables required
Wide dosimetric range (Gy to 100s of
Gy)
Many different applications
30. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 30
Various TLD types
31. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 31
Simplified scheme of the TLD
process
32. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 32
TLD glow curves
33. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 33
Glow curves
Allow research
Are powerful QA tools - does the glow
curve look OK?
Can be used for further evaluation
May improve the accuracy through glow
curve deconvolution
34. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 34
The role of different dopants
35. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 35
Importance of thermal
treatment
Determines the arrangement of
impurities
sensitivity
fading
response to different radiation qualities
Maintain thermal treatment constant...
36. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 36
Dose
response of
LiF:Mg,Ti:
wide dosimetric
range
watch
supralinearity
37. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 37
Variation of TLD response with
radiation quality
38. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 38
Materials: oh what a choice...
LiF:Mg,Ti (the ‘gold‘ standard)
CaF2 (all natural, or with Mn, Dy or Tm)
CaSO4
BeO
Al2O3 :C (record sensitivity 1uGy)
LiF:Mg,Cu,P (the new star?)
39. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 39
TLD reader
photomultiplier based
planchet and hot N2 gas heating
available
40. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 40
Radiographic film
Reduction of silver halide to silver
Requires processing ---> problems with
reproducibility
Two dimensional dosimeter
High spatial resolution
High atomic number ---> variations of
response with radiation quality
41. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 41
Radiographic film
Cross section
Often prepacked
for ease of use
42. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 42
Film: dose response
Evaluation of film via
optical density
OD = log (I0 / I)
Densitometers are
commercially
available
43. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 43
Radiographic film dosimetry in
practice
Depends on excellent
processor QA
Commonly used for
demonstration of dose
distributions
Problems with
accuracy and
variations in response
with X Ray energy
44. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 44
Radiochromic film
New development
No developing
Not (very) light
sensitive
Better tissue
equivalence
Expensive
45. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 45
Semiconductor Devices
Diodes
MOSFET detectors
Diodes for water phantom
measurements
46. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 46
Diodes
From Metcalfe et al. 1996
Mostly used like
a photocell generating
a voltage proportional
to the dose received.
47. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 47
1. irradiation
2. Charge
carriers trapped
in Si substrate
3. Current
between source
and drain altered
48. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 48
Diodes and other Solid State
Devices
Advantages
direct reading
sensitive
small size
waterproofing
possible
Disadvantages
temperature
sensitive
sensitivity may
change --> re-
calibration necessary
regular QA
procedures need to
be followed
49. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 49
Summary of lecture
Ion chambers Semiconductors TLDs Film
Advantages Well understood,
accurate, variety of
forms available
Small, robust Small, no cables
required
Two dimensional,
ease of use
Disadvantages Large, high voltage
required
Temperature
dependence
Delayed readout,
complex handling
Not tissue
equivalent, not
very reproducible
Common use Reference
dosimetry, beam
scanning
Beam scanning, in
vivo dosimetry
Dose verification,
in vivo dosimetry
QA, assessment of
dose distributions
Comment Most common and
important
dosimetric
technique
New developments
(MOSFETs) may
increase utility
Also used for
dosimetric
intercomparisons
(audits)
New developments
(radiochromic
film) may increase
utility
50. Radiation Protection in Radiotherapy
Any question?
Part 2, lecture 2: Dosimetry and equipment 50