SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 22
That Was Then, But This is Now:
The Evolution of Distressed Debt &
      Turnaround Investing
    iiBIG’s “2007 Distressed & Turnaround
              Investment Forum”
             September 24-25, 2007
        The Flamingo in Las Vegas, NV.
Track A: Issues in the Financial/Capital Markets
Water Tower Capital, LLC
Water Tower Capital, LLC is a specialty investment banking firm that
provides advise to clients in the areas of Corporate Recovery Services,
Valuations, Fairness Opinions, Litigation Consulting and M&A.
Examples of recent Water Tower Capital corporate recovery assignments
are listed below:




                                                                          2
F. John Stark, III, Managing Principal



•   John Stark, has been both an investor and an advisor in the distressed debt
    market for the past two decades. He has been Managing Principal of Water
    Tower Capital since 2001.
•   From 1990 to 2000, Mr. Stark was an Executive Vice President and
    General Counsel of the Special Investments Group of PPM America, where
    he managed $900 million in three distressed securities funds, a $1.5 Billion
    Commercial Finance Portfolio, and a $1 Billion workout portfolio.
•   Mr. Stark has an AB from Wabash College and a JD from Vanderbilt
    University School of Law.
                                                                             3
I. That Was Then
I. That Was Then:
                    Defining Distressed Debt
Traditional Definitions
•   Debt that trades at > 1,000 bps yield to worst;
•   Debt that is trading flat, i.e., w/o coupon;
•   Debt that is in default.


Distressed Debt Strategies
•   Trading vs. Control
•   Hedge Fund vs. Private Equity
•   Domestic vs. International

                                                      5
I. That Was Then:
                    Defining Distressed Debt
•   As shown below, the two most significant peaks in the distressed market occurred
    within 12 months of the years 1990 and 2000;
•   The distressed market continues to evolve, but the central issue is still, “when we
    will see the next significant peak in defaults?”




                                                                                          6
I. That Was Then: 1990
               Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs
             Liquidity Drivers          CDO / Structured Product Evolution
•Asset-Liability mismatch caused        • CDOs, CBOs, CMOs, and CLOs
S&L’s to be forced sellers of High        were structured very conservatively.
Yield/Junk Bonds & HLT’s;               • Leverage was low;
•Demise of Drexel;
                                        • Permitted CDO Collateral Consisted
•Few Distressed Debt Funds
                                          of:
•No Term B Lenders;
              Market Factors
•Repatriation of Kuwait ended the
shooting war with Iraq;
                                                      Bank Loans
•Interest rates were relatively high;
                                                       High Yield
•Relatively Strong $;
•Oil Prices were $30/barrel;
•Unemployment was high;
•Good Companies with Bad Balance
                                                                                 7
Sheets.
I. That Was Then: 2000
              Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs
             Liquidity Drivers            CDO / Structured Product Evolution
•Implosion of the .com and telecom        • CDOs, CBOs, CMOs, and CLOs
credits;                                    were structured much more
•9/11 paralyzed the consumer and            aggressively.
spawned “interest free’ auto loans;       • Leverage increased significantly;
•Proliferation of Distressed Debt Funds
                                          • Permitted Collateral Consisted of:
and CDOs as “buyers;”
                                                                     2000
•Emergence of the Term B Lenders;
                                                                 Bank Loans
         Market Factors vs. 1990              1990
                                                                  High Yield
                                           Bank Loans
•Shooting war with Iraq had no
                                                               Distressed Debt
                                            High Yield
discernable end in sight;
                                                                  ABS, MBS
•Interest rates were lower;                                    Emerging Mkts
• $ was weaker;                                                     Mezz.
•Oil Prices were higher;                                            Equity
•Unemployment was lower;
                                                                                 8
•Bad Companies & Balance Sheets.
II. This is Now.
II. This is Now: 2007
             Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs
             Liquidity Drivers            CDOs begat SFOCs SIVs, & SIV-lites
•“Interest free” auto loans lead to the
demise of the auto suppliers;
                                                         2007
•Term B Lenders postponed the                         Sub Prime
inevitable spike in defaults;                      CDOs of CDOs
•Distressed Debt Funds remain buyers,              RMBS, CMBS
but the Sub Prime crisis has frozen the              Bank Loans
                                                      High Yield
new issue CDO market.
                                                   Distressed Debt
    Market Factors vs. 1990 & 2000
                                                      ABS, MBS
•Shooting war with Iraq has no
                                                   Emerging Mkts
discernable end in sight;
                                                        Mezz.
•Inverted Yield curve is the “norm”;                    Equity
• $ is weaker;
•Oil Prices are even higher;
•Unemployment is lower;
                                                                               10
•Bad Companies & Balance Sheets.
II. This is Now: 2007
            Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs
Market Factors {What is a SFOC, SIV, or SIV-lite and why should we care?}

•Structured Investment Vehicles “{SIV’s”} are a subset of the structured
financial operating companies in the credit arbitrage market;

    •Moody’s and S&P have rated SIV structures that have >$350 billion in
    assets under management;

•“SIV-lites” focus on residential mortgage backed securities {“RMBS”} and
they are estimated to hold as much as $12 billion in RMBS paper, comprising
>90% of their holdings, versus a SIV with <25% exposure.

    •The SIV-lite structure permits higher advance rates and greater leverage
    than a SIV or a CDO would have.
                                                                                11
II. This is Now: 2007
Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs




                                   12
II. This is Now: 2007
           Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs
Long-Dead, Cash Flow CDOs Can Continue to Live On, See circa 2000 CDO




                                                                  13
II. This is Now: 2007
           Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs
Long-Dead, Cash Flow CDOs Can Continue to Live On, See circa 2000 CDO




                                                                  14
II. This is Now: 2007
            Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs
 In contrast, the $1trillion of “market value” CDOs, SIVs and SIV-lites may be
 forced to start selling collateral.
•On August 28th, Rhinebridge SIV announced that it had sold $176 million of
securities, or around 7%, to meet liquidity requirements;
 •Not since the “1998 Russian Flu,” has a 'conventional' SIV admitted that asset
 sales have been necessary in order to manage liquidity;
 •SIV triggers normally work in the following order: Restricted Investment;
 Restricted Funding; and Enforcement and the fall from grace can be very quick,
 usually only 3 to 5 business days are given to cure a breach at each stage.
•Rhinebridge is only 6 months old and was built on a capital model that allowed
for investment in riskier paper, as Moody's itself acknowledged in its new issue
report earlier this year.


                                                                                   15
II. This is Now: 2007
           Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs
In contrast, the $1trillion of “market value” CDOs, SIVs and SIV-lites may be
    forced to start selling collateral.

•   Two Additional traditional ABCP conduits have had problems with
        rolling CP:          Titan Securitization & CentreStar

•   One Additional SIV has announced its intention to liquidate
                      Cheyne Finance breached its capital loss test and entered
                      Enforcement.

•   One Additional SIV/SIV-Lite
    Kestrel Funding has entered into Restricted Operations stage implying
         it can not purchase further assets.

                                                                                  16
III. Conclusions
III. Conclusions
                     Market Factors vs. 1990 & 2000
•With the CP market in gridlock and structured finance & bank paper
trading at sub-par prices, more SIVs are likely to come under pressure.

    •According to a recent Deutsche Bank research report, given the
    financing squeeze for almost any type of structured finance investor,
    the demand backdrop for asset-backed product will remain
    extremely weak for the foreseeable future.
    •Secondary prices seem to reflect this shrinkage in the investor base,
    with for example AAA UK prime mortgages trading at spreads of
    30 bps and BBB non-conforming RMBS at spreads> 200 bps.

•Spreads are therefore firmly back to 2001 levels, as is arguably the
depth of the investor base.

                                                                             18
III. Conclusions
                    Market Factors vs. 1990 and 2000
•A significant percentage of structured products’ buyers have been
leveraging illiquidity risk through the repo and ABS CP markets, which
could result in an asset / liability mismatch similar to the 1990 era S&L’s

•The lack of new CDO issuance will spill over in to the leveraged loan
market as there will be fewer buyers;

•If the $1 trillion of “market value” CDOs become “forced sellers,” this
will adversely affect all debt markets and create buying opportunities.

•The presence of structured vehicles in corporate workouts will
complicate the process as their options for conversion of debt to equity
are limited.

                                                                              19
III. Conclusions
The amount of $’s allocated to Distressed Debt continues to rise.




                                                                    20
III. Conclusions
                                That was Then             This is Now

Category                 1990               2000             2007
Precipitant          S&L implosion      Telcom & 9/11     Sub Prime?
Type of BK             Free Fall         Pre Arranged    Pre Arranged
                                                         2nd Lien Debt
Fulcrum Security        Bonds             Bank Debt
% Recovery on            60%                15%               ?
Bonds
Capital Structure     Very simple       Simple/CDOs     Complex/SFOCs
of Issuer
# of $’s allocated       Few                Many          Too many?
to Dist. Debt



                                                                         21
Panelists

F. John Stark III, Managing Principal,
Water Tower Capital, LLC, Chicago, IL, Phone: 312-373-8001,
Email: john@watertowercapital.com

David Yu, Director - Distressed Investments Unit
MetLife, NY, NY, Phone: 973-355-4581,
Email: dyu@metlife.com

Robert A. Guy, Jr. Waller Lansden Dortch & Davis, LLP
Nashville, TN Phone: 615 850-8933
E-mail: bobby.guy@wallerlaw.com                           22

More Related Content

What's hot

Goldman sachs mortgage report
Goldman sachs mortgage reportGoldman sachs mortgage report
Goldman sachs mortgage reportRexTrade
 
2008 Stock Market Disaster Revised September 2012 For Slideshare
2008 Stock Market Disaster  Revised September 2012 For Slideshare2008 Stock Market Disaster  Revised September 2012 For Slideshare
2008 Stock Market Disaster Revised September 2012 For SlideshareJoe Collins
 
Where has all the Liquidity Gone?
Where has all the Liquidity Gone?Where has all the Liquidity Gone?
Where has all the Liquidity Gone?berberblues
 
Cis Properties Llc Private Placement Info
Cis Properties Llc Private Placement InfoCis Properties Llc Private Placement Info
Cis Properties Llc Private Placement Infoguest09269
 
The Evolution of Mortgage Brokering in BC
The Evolution of Mortgage Brokering in BCThe Evolution of Mortgage Brokering in BC
The Evolution of Mortgage Brokering in BCBC Notaries
 
History and overview of securitization
History and overview of securitizationHistory and overview of securitization
History and overview of securitizationsugeladi
 
jimmy stepanian | Real estate commercial financing ideas | Jim stepanian |
jimmy stepanian | Real estate commercial financing ideas | Jim stepanian |jimmy stepanian | Real estate commercial financing ideas | Jim stepanian |
jimmy stepanian | Real estate commercial financing ideas | Jim stepanian |Jimmy Stepanian
 
Karl miller energy profile
Karl miller energy profileKarl miller energy profile
Karl miller energy profileKW Miller
 
freddie mac Investor Presentation – Freddie Mac Update
freddie mac Investor Presentation – Freddie Mac Update freddie mac Investor Presentation – Freddie Mac Update
freddie mac Investor Presentation – Freddie Mac Update finance6
 
External Meeting for Proposed Rule 79 FR 59898 (May 12, 2015 with William J. ...
External Meeting for Proposed Rule 79 FR 59898 (May 12, 2015 with William J. ...External Meeting for Proposed Rule 79 FR 59898 (May 12, 2015 with William J. ...
External Meeting for Proposed Rule 79 FR 59898 (May 12, 2015 with William J. ...William J. Harrington
 
The Credit Crisis
The Credit CrisisThe Credit Crisis
The Credit Crisislazzerir
 
metlife Sterne, Agee & Leach Financial Services Symposium Presentation (repl...
metlife 	Sterne, Agee & Leach Financial Services Symposium Presentation (repl...metlife 	Sterne, Agee & Leach Financial Services Symposium Presentation (repl...
metlife Sterne, Agee & Leach Financial Services Symposium Presentation (repl...finance5
 
How To Navigate
How To NavigateHow To Navigate
How To NavigateMCDFS
 

What's hot (17)

Goldman sachs mortgage report
Goldman sachs mortgage reportGoldman sachs mortgage report
Goldman sachs mortgage report
 
2008 Stock Market Disaster Revised September 2012 For Slideshare
2008 Stock Market Disaster  Revised September 2012 For Slideshare2008 Stock Market Disaster  Revised September 2012 For Slideshare
2008 Stock Market Disaster Revised September 2012 For Slideshare
 
Where has all the Liquidity Gone?
Where has all the Liquidity Gone?Where has all the Liquidity Gone?
Where has all the Liquidity Gone?
 
Cis Properties Llc Private Placement Info
Cis Properties Llc Private Placement InfoCis Properties Llc Private Placement Info
Cis Properties Llc Private Placement Info
 
The Evolution of Mortgage Brokering in BC
The Evolution of Mortgage Brokering in BCThe Evolution of Mortgage Brokering in BC
The Evolution of Mortgage Brokering in BC
 
Chap020
Chap020Chap020
Chap020
 
History and overview of securitization
History and overview of securitizationHistory and overview of securitization
History and overview of securitization
 
Credit defaultswaps
Credit defaultswapsCredit defaultswaps
Credit defaultswaps
 
jimmy stepanian | Real estate commercial financing ideas | Jim stepanian |
jimmy stepanian | Real estate commercial financing ideas | Jim stepanian |jimmy stepanian | Real estate commercial financing ideas | Jim stepanian |
jimmy stepanian | Real estate commercial financing ideas | Jim stepanian |
 
Karl miller energy profile
Karl miller energy profileKarl miller energy profile
Karl miller energy profile
 
freddie mac Investor Presentation – Freddie Mac Update
freddie mac Investor Presentation – Freddie Mac Update freddie mac Investor Presentation – Freddie Mac Update
freddie mac Investor Presentation – Freddie Mac Update
 
External Meeting for Proposed Rule 79 FR 59898 (May 12, 2015 with William J. ...
External Meeting for Proposed Rule 79 FR 59898 (May 12, 2015 with William J. ...External Meeting for Proposed Rule 79 FR 59898 (May 12, 2015 with William J. ...
External Meeting for Proposed Rule 79 FR 59898 (May 12, 2015 with William J. ...
 
Chap019
Chap019Chap019
Chap019
 
The Credit Crisis
The Credit CrisisThe Credit Crisis
The Credit Crisis
 
metlife Sterne, Agee & Leach Financial Services Symposium Presentation (repl...
metlife 	Sterne, Agee & Leach Financial Services Symposium Presentation (repl...metlife 	Sterne, Agee & Leach Financial Services Symposium Presentation (repl...
metlife Sterne, Agee & Leach Financial Services Symposium Presentation (repl...
 
How To Navigate
How To NavigateHow To Navigate
How To Navigate
 
Freddie Mac Annual Report 2007
Freddie Mac Annual Report 2007Freddie Mac Annual Report 2007
Freddie Mac Annual Report 2007
 

Similar to Outlook for the Distressed Debt Market 2007

Bank of America Corporation acquires Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. Presentation
Bank of America Corporation acquires Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. PresentationBank of America Corporation acquires Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. Presentation
Bank of America Corporation acquires Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. PresentationQuarterlyEarningsReports3
 
The Global Financial Crisis V3
The Global Financial Crisis V3The Global Financial Crisis V3
The Global Financial Crisis V3Jay Prakash
 
GMAC Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Sanjiv Khattri.
GMAC Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Sanjiv Khattri.GMAC Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Sanjiv Khattri.
GMAC Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Sanjiv Khattri.finance8
 
CIT Presentation
CIT PresentationCIT Presentation
CIT Presentationfinance28
 
Regulating Credit Default Swaps Preview For Press
Regulating Credit Default Swaps Preview For PressRegulating Credit Default Swaps Preview For Press
Regulating Credit Default Swaps Preview For Presscatelong
 
Deciphering the 2007/8 Liquidity and Credit Crunch
Deciphering the 2007/8 Liquidity and Credit CrunchDeciphering the 2007/8 Liquidity and Credit Crunch
Deciphering the 2007/8 Liquidity and Credit Crunchdr.interest
 
10 Min Market Conditions Talk
10 Min Market Conditions Talk10 Min Market Conditions Talk
10 Min Market Conditions TalkLisa Brugman
 
Ir bonds crash october
Ir bonds crash octoberIr bonds crash october
Ir bonds crash octoberguest29842e03
 
Basel iii a comprehensive regulatory response february 2011
Basel iii a comprehensive regulatory response february 2011Basel iii a comprehensive regulatory response february 2011
Basel iii a comprehensive regulatory response february 2011Maan Barazi
 
High Yiled Bonds And Beyond
High Yiled Bonds And BeyondHigh Yiled Bonds And Beyond
High Yiled Bonds And Beyondchinhegde
 
A tale of two hedge funds
A tale of two hedge fundsA tale of two hedge funds
A tale of two hedge fundsManju Natarajan
 
A tale of two hedge funds
A tale of two hedge fundsA tale of two hedge funds
A tale of two hedge fundsManju Natarajan
 
Presentation on banking
Presentation on bankingPresentation on banking
Presentation on bankingAtul Gupta
 
Subprime Under Ethics 980105 [Compatibility Mode]
Subprime Under Ethics 980105 [Compatibility Mode]Subprime Under Ethics 980105 [Compatibility Mode]
Subprime Under Ethics 980105 [Compatibility Mode]MBA_Community
 
SVB collapse F1.pptx
SVB collapse F1.pptxSVB collapse F1.pptx
SVB collapse F1.pptxkritiprasad5
 
6th Western Borrowers N Investors Mezz Loans And Distress Debt 26 March09
6th Western Borrowers N Investors Mezz Loans And Distress Debt 26 March096th Western Borrowers N Investors Mezz Loans And Distress Debt 26 March09
6th Western Borrowers N Investors Mezz Loans And Distress Debt 26 March09spodvin
 
California and Southwest Distressed Real Estate: How Much Debt is in Distress...
California and Southwest Distressed Real Estate: How Much Debt is in Distress...California and Southwest Distressed Real Estate: How Much Debt is in Distress...
California and Southwest Distressed Real Estate: How Much Debt is in Distress...Ryan Slack
 

Similar to Outlook for the Distressed Debt Market 2007 (20)

Bank of America Corporation acquires Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. Presentation
Bank of America Corporation acquires Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. PresentationBank of America Corporation acquires Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. Presentation
Bank of America Corporation acquires Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. Presentation
 
The Global Financial Crisis V3
The Global Financial Crisis V3The Global Financial Crisis V3
The Global Financial Crisis V3
 
GMAC Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Sanjiv Khattri.
GMAC Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Sanjiv Khattri.GMAC Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Sanjiv Khattri.
GMAC Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Sanjiv Khattri.
 
CIT Presentation
CIT PresentationCIT Presentation
CIT Presentation
 
Regulating Credit Default Swaps Preview For Press
Regulating Credit Default Swaps Preview For PressRegulating Credit Default Swaps Preview For Press
Regulating Credit Default Swaps Preview For Press
 
Deciphering the 2007/8 Liquidity and Credit Crunch
Deciphering the 2007/8 Liquidity and Credit CrunchDeciphering the 2007/8 Liquidity and Credit Crunch
Deciphering the 2007/8 Liquidity and Credit Crunch
 
10 Min Market Conditions Talk
10 Min Market Conditions Talk10 Min Market Conditions Talk
10 Min Market Conditions Talk
 
Ir bonds crash october
Ir bonds crash octoberIr bonds crash october
Ir bonds crash october
 
Basel iii a comprehensive regulatory response february 2011
Basel iii a comprehensive regulatory response february 2011Basel iii a comprehensive regulatory response february 2011
Basel iii a comprehensive regulatory response february 2011
 
High Yiled Bonds And Beyond
High Yiled Bonds And BeyondHigh Yiled Bonds And Beyond
High Yiled Bonds And Beyond
 
A tale of two hedge funds
A tale of two hedge fundsA tale of two hedge funds
A tale of two hedge funds
 
A tale of two hedge funds
A tale of two hedge fundsA tale of two hedge funds
A tale of two hedge funds
 
Presentation on banking
Presentation on bankingPresentation on banking
Presentation on banking
 
Subprime Under Ethics 980105 [Compatibility Mode]
Subprime Under Ethics 980105 [Compatibility Mode]Subprime Under Ethics 980105 [Compatibility Mode]
Subprime Under Ethics 980105 [Compatibility Mode]
 
US Financial Crisis
US Financial CrisisUS Financial Crisis
US Financial Crisis
 
PACE - BBVA
PACE - BBVAPACE - BBVA
PACE - BBVA
 
SVB collapse F1.pptx
SVB collapse F1.pptxSVB collapse F1.pptx
SVB collapse F1.pptx
 
6th Western Borrowers N Investors Mezz Loans And Distress Debt 26 March09
6th Western Borrowers N Investors Mezz Loans And Distress Debt 26 March096th Western Borrowers N Investors Mezz Loans And Distress Debt 26 March09
6th Western Borrowers N Investors Mezz Loans And Distress Debt 26 March09
 
The Canary in the Coal Mine-July 2016 RMA
The Canary in the Coal Mine-July 2016 RMAThe Canary in the Coal Mine-July 2016 RMA
The Canary in the Coal Mine-July 2016 RMA
 
California and Southwest Distressed Real Estate: How Much Debt is in Distress...
California and Southwest Distressed Real Estate: How Much Debt is in Distress...California and Southwest Distressed Real Estate: How Much Debt is in Distress...
California and Southwest Distressed Real Estate: How Much Debt is in Distress...
 

Outlook for the Distressed Debt Market 2007

  • 1. That Was Then, But This is Now: The Evolution of Distressed Debt & Turnaround Investing iiBIG’s “2007 Distressed & Turnaround Investment Forum” September 24-25, 2007 The Flamingo in Las Vegas, NV. Track A: Issues in the Financial/Capital Markets
  • 2. Water Tower Capital, LLC Water Tower Capital, LLC is a specialty investment banking firm that provides advise to clients in the areas of Corporate Recovery Services, Valuations, Fairness Opinions, Litigation Consulting and M&A. Examples of recent Water Tower Capital corporate recovery assignments are listed below: 2
  • 3. F. John Stark, III, Managing Principal • John Stark, has been both an investor and an advisor in the distressed debt market for the past two decades. He has been Managing Principal of Water Tower Capital since 2001. • From 1990 to 2000, Mr. Stark was an Executive Vice President and General Counsel of the Special Investments Group of PPM America, where he managed $900 million in three distressed securities funds, a $1.5 Billion Commercial Finance Portfolio, and a $1 Billion workout portfolio. • Mr. Stark has an AB from Wabash College and a JD from Vanderbilt University School of Law. 3
  • 4. I. That Was Then
  • 5. I. That Was Then: Defining Distressed Debt Traditional Definitions • Debt that trades at > 1,000 bps yield to worst; • Debt that is trading flat, i.e., w/o coupon; • Debt that is in default. Distressed Debt Strategies • Trading vs. Control • Hedge Fund vs. Private Equity • Domestic vs. International 5
  • 6. I. That Was Then: Defining Distressed Debt • As shown below, the two most significant peaks in the distressed market occurred within 12 months of the years 1990 and 2000; • The distressed market continues to evolve, but the central issue is still, “when we will see the next significant peak in defaults?” 6
  • 7. I. That Was Then: 1990 Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs Liquidity Drivers CDO / Structured Product Evolution •Asset-Liability mismatch caused • CDOs, CBOs, CMOs, and CLOs S&L’s to be forced sellers of High were structured very conservatively. Yield/Junk Bonds & HLT’s; • Leverage was low; •Demise of Drexel; • Permitted CDO Collateral Consisted •Few Distressed Debt Funds of: •No Term B Lenders; Market Factors •Repatriation of Kuwait ended the shooting war with Iraq; Bank Loans •Interest rates were relatively high; High Yield •Relatively Strong $; •Oil Prices were $30/barrel; •Unemployment was high; •Good Companies with Bad Balance 7 Sheets.
  • 8. I. That Was Then: 2000 Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs Liquidity Drivers CDO / Structured Product Evolution •Implosion of the .com and telecom • CDOs, CBOs, CMOs, and CLOs credits; were structured much more •9/11 paralyzed the consumer and aggressively. spawned “interest free’ auto loans; • Leverage increased significantly; •Proliferation of Distressed Debt Funds • Permitted Collateral Consisted of: and CDOs as “buyers;” 2000 •Emergence of the Term B Lenders; Bank Loans Market Factors vs. 1990 1990 High Yield Bank Loans •Shooting war with Iraq had no Distressed Debt High Yield discernable end in sight; ABS, MBS •Interest rates were lower; Emerging Mkts • $ was weaker; Mezz. •Oil Prices were higher; Equity •Unemployment was lower; 8 •Bad Companies & Balance Sheets.
  • 9. II. This is Now.
  • 10. II. This is Now: 2007 Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs Liquidity Drivers CDOs begat SFOCs SIVs, & SIV-lites •“Interest free” auto loans lead to the demise of the auto suppliers; 2007 •Term B Lenders postponed the Sub Prime inevitable spike in defaults; CDOs of CDOs •Distressed Debt Funds remain buyers, RMBS, CMBS but the Sub Prime crisis has frozen the Bank Loans High Yield new issue CDO market. Distressed Debt Market Factors vs. 1990 & 2000 ABS, MBS •Shooting war with Iraq has no Emerging Mkts discernable end in sight; Mezz. •Inverted Yield curve is the “norm”; Equity • $ is weaker; •Oil Prices are even higher; •Unemployment is lower; 10 •Bad Companies & Balance Sheets.
  • 11. II. This is Now: 2007 Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs Market Factors {What is a SFOC, SIV, or SIV-lite and why should we care?} •Structured Investment Vehicles “{SIV’s”} are a subset of the structured financial operating companies in the credit arbitrage market; •Moody’s and S&P have rated SIV structures that have >$350 billion in assets under management; •“SIV-lites” focus on residential mortgage backed securities {“RMBS”} and they are estimated to hold as much as $12 billion in RMBS paper, comprising >90% of their holdings, versus a SIV with <25% exposure. •The SIV-lite structure permits higher advance rates and greater leverage than a SIV or a CDO would have. 11
  • 12. II. This is Now: 2007 Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs 12
  • 13. II. This is Now: 2007 Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs Long-Dead, Cash Flow CDOs Can Continue to Live On, See circa 2000 CDO 13
  • 14. II. This is Now: 2007 Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs Long-Dead, Cash Flow CDOs Can Continue to Live On, See circa 2000 CDO 14
  • 15. II. This is Now: 2007 Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs In contrast, the $1trillion of “market value” CDOs, SIVs and SIV-lites may be forced to start selling collateral. •On August 28th, Rhinebridge SIV announced that it had sold $176 million of securities, or around 7%, to meet liquidity requirements; •Not since the “1998 Russian Flu,” has a 'conventional' SIV admitted that asset sales have been necessary in order to manage liquidity; •SIV triggers normally work in the following order: Restricted Investment; Restricted Funding; and Enforcement and the fall from grace can be very quick, usually only 3 to 5 business days are given to cure a breach at each stage. •Rhinebridge is only 6 months old and was built on a capital model that allowed for investment in riskier paper, as Moody's itself acknowledged in its new issue report earlier this year. 15
  • 16. II. This is Now: 2007 Liquidity, Market Factors & CDOs In contrast, the $1trillion of “market value” CDOs, SIVs and SIV-lites may be forced to start selling collateral. • Two Additional traditional ABCP conduits have had problems with rolling CP: Titan Securitization & CentreStar • One Additional SIV has announced its intention to liquidate Cheyne Finance breached its capital loss test and entered Enforcement. • One Additional SIV/SIV-Lite Kestrel Funding has entered into Restricted Operations stage implying it can not purchase further assets. 16
  • 18. III. Conclusions Market Factors vs. 1990 & 2000 •With the CP market in gridlock and structured finance & bank paper trading at sub-par prices, more SIVs are likely to come under pressure. •According to a recent Deutsche Bank research report, given the financing squeeze for almost any type of structured finance investor, the demand backdrop for asset-backed product will remain extremely weak for the foreseeable future. •Secondary prices seem to reflect this shrinkage in the investor base, with for example AAA UK prime mortgages trading at spreads of 30 bps and BBB non-conforming RMBS at spreads> 200 bps. •Spreads are therefore firmly back to 2001 levels, as is arguably the depth of the investor base. 18
  • 19. III. Conclusions Market Factors vs. 1990 and 2000 •A significant percentage of structured products’ buyers have been leveraging illiquidity risk through the repo and ABS CP markets, which could result in an asset / liability mismatch similar to the 1990 era S&L’s •The lack of new CDO issuance will spill over in to the leveraged loan market as there will be fewer buyers; •If the $1 trillion of “market value” CDOs become “forced sellers,” this will adversely affect all debt markets and create buying opportunities. •The presence of structured vehicles in corporate workouts will complicate the process as their options for conversion of debt to equity are limited. 19
  • 20. III. Conclusions The amount of $’s allocated to Distressed Debt continues to rise. 20
  • 21. III. Conclusions That was Then This is Now Category 1990 2000 2007 Precipitant S&L implosion Telcom & 9/11 Sub Prime? Type of BK Free Fall Pre Arranged Pre Arranged 2nd Lien Debt Fulcrum Security Bonds Bank Debt % Recovery on 60% 15% ? Bonds Capital Structure Very simple Simple/CDOs Complex/SFOCs of Issuer # of $’s allocated Few Many Too many? to Dist. Debt 21
  • 22. Panelists F. John Stark III, Managing Principal, Water Tower Capital, LLC, Chicago, IL, Phone: 312-373-8001, Email: john@watertowercapital.com David Yu, Director - Distressed Investments Unit MetLife, NY, NY, Phone: 973-355-4581, Email: dyu@metlife.com Robert A. Guy, Jr. Waller Lansden Dortch & Davis, LLP Nashville, TN Phone: 615 850-8933 E-mail: bobby.guy@wallerlaw.com 22