HE ARO MĀTANGA KAUPAPA
The focus topics for Specialist Practice
SPORT AND POSITIVEYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
Ponder this statement:
‘Sport can either be an enabler of positive youth development
or a disabler of positive youth development. It is true that,
through sport, young people can achieve optimal physical
development; but this doesn’t mean that sport, in itself, is a
positive enabler, it takes something more for this to happen’
(per.comm Fiona Beals, July 2017)
What is this strange person talking about?
Do you agree/disagree – why – continuum?
Discuss, discuss, discuss
SPORT AND POSITIVEYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
According to Lerner (2002) PositiveYouth Development involves two key
concepts:
Plasticity (the ability to adapt and change over one’s life)
Context (all development occurs in social, cultural and physical contexts)
In order to be effective sports programmes need to think about how they create
contexts for positive youth development to occur, and through this context,
resources to ensure that young people have the opportunity to learn skills that will
enable plasticity
SPORT AND POSITIVEYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
When both context and plasticity (perhaps not worded that way) have been
purposively planned for, sport can:
Build self-esteem
Help youth to learn how to control emotions
Enable youth to learn to set goals, and achieve them
Create a space to learn social skills
Cross over into other areas – education, family, community, physical health
Arden’s story
Specific research into developmental assets have shown that sport enables the
development of positive identity, empowerment and support (Holt & Neely, 2011)
THE IMPORTANCE OF CONTEXT
Family
Sport
Community
Think: Cultural Capital (Bourdieu)
Think: Mesosystems (Bronfenbrenner)
Think: Examples
Think: Pros/Cons
SPORT AND POSITIVEYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
Can sport make a difference in the lives of young people when the balance is
right?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pwBXs2B2ZbI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-UewgQMuBc
Reflections
Think DevelopmentalAssets
Think 5+1 Cs
ThinkCircle of Courage
ThinkWhareTapaWha
Think – how she is so successful but still a teen
RESILIENCE AND POSITIVEYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
Research into resilience came as a response to the focus on risk, prevention
programmes and youth development
Resilience technically is a person’s ability to adapt and bring about positive
outcomes in their life despite experiencing vulnerability and risk
IE, the ability to bounce back
The presence of protective factors
Internal
External
Resilience is multi-dimensional: biopsychosocial (and spiritual)
Resilience can be cultivated
RESILIENCE AND POSITIVEYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
Resilience is cultivated through
Bonding – initial relationships of significance
Competence – cognitive, emotional, self, behaviourial & social
Optimism – the space of the spiritual
Environment – home, school, community
Culture
Humour – deeper reflection
RESILIENCE AND POSITIVEYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
Conditionality Resilience as a forerunner Resilience as a follower
Sufficient Constituent
Asset building
Inclusiveness
Concomitant
Solution-focused
Necessary Determinant
Courage
Problem Avoidance
Indicator
Adaptation
Competence
Probabilistic Contributor
Developmental systems
Derivative
Self-regulation
Spurious Collateral due to effect
Citizenship
Collateral due to cause
Control
RESILIENCE AND POSITIVEYOUTH
DEVELOPMENT
Conditionality Resilience as a forerunner Resilience as a follower
Sufficient Constituent
Asset building
Inclusiveness
Concomitant
Solution-focused
Necessary Determinant
Courage
Problem Avoidance
Indicator
Adaptation
Competence
Probabilistic Contributor
Developmental systems
Derivative
Self-regulation
Spurious Collateral due to effect
Citizenship
Collateral due to cause
Control
RESILIENCE – HOW IT HELPS
PositiveYouth Development can contribute to the development of resilience by:
Enabling conditions for the learning of coping strategies when confronted with stress
This builds competence and leads to character-development
However, stress is not always bad and not all adversity is the same
Lessons from education programmes
Aim to be holistic in building character and identity
One condition for resilience is the presence of relationships
ABL provides ideal conditions for resilience through Challenge by Choice and pushing
beyond the comfort zone
Thing ‘whole-school’ ie broader groups (school + community + family not
school/community/family)
RESILIENCE – INTHE LIFE OF A CELEBRITY
What were the adverse events faced by this celebrity in her childhood?
What are the protective factors in her life – internal/external?
How was resilience developed through an holistic approach to development?
How did Everlean Parton create a PositiveYouth Development environment for her
children?
How did that resilience contribute to the development of PYD attributes within Dolly as a
young person and later as an adult?ThinkCircle of Courage, 5+1Cs, 40 Developmental
Assets
Use the video to explain how the pain of the past can still live with even if you are resilient
Use the story of Dolly to explain how PYD and resilience are different concepts but can
contribute to each other
http://www.etv.org.nz/programme.php?id=77518
MINDFULNESS –WHAT IS IT
“the self-regulation of attention so that it is maintained on immediate experience
… an orientation that is characterized by curiosity, openness and acceptance”
(Bishop et.al cited in Felver, Doerner, Jones, Kaye, & Merrell, 2013, p.532)
Focus by choice and eliminate by choice
Be open, aware and non-judgmental – accept and acknowledge your experience and
reality
If you have an acceptance and understanding of who you are in the moment,
then you can start to regulate yourself
It is not mediation and it is not a form of religion
MINDFULNESS –WHERE IS IT USED
Stress Reduction
Breathing
Scanning
Stretching
CBT
Stopping
Scanning
Acknowledging
Addressing
Soles of the Feet (grounding)
Pausing
Focusing
Shifting
Acceptance and CommitmentTherapy (ACT)
Establishing goals
Redirecting
Intensive
Targeted
Universal
INNERKIDS
An example of mindfulness that can
align with PYD concepts of 5+1 Cs and
circle of courage
Is about:
Attention (focus through stillness),
Balance (seeing and reframing) and
Compassion (caring and connecting)
http://www.innerkids.com/
YOURTURN:THE LINEAGE PROJECT
Go to: http://www.lineageproject.org/ and do a general search forThe Lineage
Project (nb – facebook includes one on one interviews with youth
Find out as much as possible about their programs:
What do they do?
What are the effects of the programs?
How can these programs demonstrate concepts of PositiveYouth Development:
Think 40 Developmental Assets
Circle of Courage
5 + 1 Cs
YOURTURN: PAUSE, BREATHE, SMILE
Go to: https://mindfulnesseducation.nz/what-is-pause-breathe-smile/
Find out as much as possible about their programs:
What do they do?
What are the effects of the programs?
How can these programs demonstrate concepts of PositiveYouth Development:
Think 40 Developmental Assets
Circle of Courage
5 + 1 Cs
FINDING SOME ROOMTO BREATHE
Watch the movie, Room to Breathe
What worked/didn’t work?
What level was it on – intensive/targeted/universal?
What needs to happen to make it work better – using your understanding of
40 Developmental Assets
Circle of Courage
5 + 1 Cs
CBT AND POSITIVEYOUTH DEVELOPMENT
Cognitive BehavourialTherapy
Identified as one evidence-based approach to youth development
Especially for:
Autism-spectrum issues
Depression
Anxiety
Attention (ADHD)
Behavour
Trauma reaction
Substance abuse
CBT AND POSITIVEYOUTH DEVELOPMENT
Thoughts
Behaviours
Emotions
Psychosocial
response
Result –
good/bad
CBT AND POSITIVEYOUTH DEVELOPMENT
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qG2SwE_6uVM
Learning – we adapt to our environments from our experiences
Associative learning – linking things together as you develop, grow and learn
Palov andWatson
Unconditioned stimulus = natural response
Unconditioned stimulus + Neutral stimulus = natural response
Neutral stimulus becomes conditioned stimulus = natural response
Skinner
Operant conditioning – reward and punishment
Shaping through positive and negative reinforcement
The extinction problem
Shaping through intermittent reinforcement
YOURTURN
How can our thoughts and emotions be attached to classical and/or operant
conditioning?
THE CONNECTION BETWEENTHOUGHTS
AND BEHAVIOURS
Experiences give us expectations of treatment
Expectations can result in our behaviours to situations in which we have either
had classical conditioning or operant conditioning in the past
Those behaviours can result in our expected outcome from others or even from
the situation
SIMPLY SEEN HERE …
Potential
ActionResult
Belief
Situation
Bad grade
Self
Bad student
World
Stupid class
Future
I’m a failure
Beck’s Cognitive
Triad
CBT & POSITIVEYOUTH DEVELOPMENT
CBT is often used to address ‘expectations’ (beliefs) and change these
It empowers the young person to identify ‘triggers’ (the conditioned stimulus)
which trigger the expectation of failure, the need for violence, anxiety etc
It enables the young person to perform a reality check on the trigger
Pause, breathe and re-think
It encourages the young person to then choice another reaction or form of
behavior
It can be used on behaviours that harm oneself or behaviours that harm others
It can enable us to empower youth to identify assets and work with assets
Situation
Bad grade
Self
Bad student
World
Stupid class
Future
I’m a failure
Beck’s Cognitive
Triad
Antecedents • Bad grade
Beliefs • Bad student
Consequences • Less effort
Disputing
Thoughts
• Difficult test
• Lots failed
Effective
thought
• Hard test
• I can do
better
Ellis – ABCDE Model
YOURTURN
Look at http://www.therapistaid.com/therapy-worksheets/cbt/adolescents
Find out as much as possible regarding their worksheets:
What do they do?
What are the effects of the programs?
How can these programs demonstrate concepts of PositiveYouth Development:
Think 40 Developmental Assets
Circle of Courage
5 + 1 Cs
YOURTURN
Look at https://www.sparx.org.nz/
Find out as much as possible regarding this website:
What do they do?
What are the effects of the programs?
How can these programs demonstrate concepts of PositiveYouth Development:
Think 40 Developmental Assets
Circle of Courage
5 + 1 Cs
YOURTURN
Look at http://www.brave-online.com/
Find out as much as possible regarding this website:
What do they do?
What are the effects of the programs?
How can these programs demonstrate concepts of PositiveYouth Development:
Think 40 Developmental Assets
Circle of Courage
5 + 1 Cs
CBT WITHTHE BALD GUY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u3k7lykTWTk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u3k7lykTWTk
How do you see CBT in action in these two clips
Notas do Editor
Sufficient
Resilience is a key part of positive youth development – ie PYD can be defined through resilience
Constituent
The idea that all young have assets that can be built to enhance resilience
The idea that creating social environments that allow a young person to below will naturally build resilience
Concomitant
Resilience will result if the youth encounters and overcomes developmental tasks and problems – resilience arises from the solutions found
Necessary
Resilience here can predict positive youth development, not define it; they are two separate concepts that can be brought together
Determinant
Courage is built through settings that are based on the circle of courage and as such resilience can be established
Resilience is best developed in environments that remove problems which stop learning and growth
Indicator
Adapting to developmental tasks and problems can develop skills of competence, which in turn, develop resilience
Probabilistic
Resilience can contribute to positive youth development
Contributor
Resilience can only occur if a setting aligns the strengths of the youth and the assets of the community; if this happens then resilience is constituent if it doesn’t then there is no guarantee that resilience will be built
Derivative
If a young person develops confidence to engage in proactive actions (ie self-regulates) then resilience may be developed; but one has to realise that the choices open for these young people are limited; hence there is a real need to develop confidence in small steps
Spurious
Collateral
Resilience will only develop in the context of positive youth development if the effect is positive
So if a youth is actively able to engage in their community (effective youth participation) and this is supported by the community then resilience may develop
Cause
Resilience and PYD do not have a relationship
If a young person is able to maintain some control over the situation/event and control the resources available they will develop coping skills this would appear to address both resilience and positive youth development, but the relationship between the two isn’t really there
Both are seen as differing concepts
This is good – they are both conceptually different
Youth development can then be analysed through its own indicators such as 5+1Cs but at the same time resilience is not seen as dependent on the development of the 5+1Cs
Understands the multi-dimensional aspect to youth development
This also acknowledges that problems must be present for resilience to be developed – ie it is no use seeing asset building and inclusiveness as building resilience when they may not if a problem is not present
Also acknowledges the problem with the Circle of Courage which is a PYD tool that sees itself as primarily building resilience