1. RIO+20
UN Conference on
Sustainable Development
Michael Ewing,
Coordinator of the Environmental Pillar.
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 1

2. Contents
• Introduction- The urgency of the
crises facing us
• What is really meant by
Sustainable Development?
• What Ireland should bring to the
table
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 2

3. Introduction 1
Our society is entirely dependent on a clean and
healthy environment. Our economic system, which
is an invention of our society, must reflect this fact.
We can adapt our economic system and our society
model, but if we push the environment much
further it will be unable to provide us with the
many services that we need for our survival: clean
waters; a stable atmosphere; productive soils; and a
healthy biodiversity.
All of these natural services are in decline globally.
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 3

4. Introduction 2
Add to this is the following:
• The capacity to produce oil peaked in 2006 whilst
demand for energy continues to grow.
(International Energy Agency April 2011.)
• Food prices are rising rapidly, driven by the price
of oil and the impact of climate change (Tom Arnold
- Concern Worldwide, June 2011)
• The oceans are rapidly being depleted. (UNEP
2011)
• Industry is fast running out of raw materials (Neil
O’Leary - Ion Equity June 2011)
• Fresh-water supply world-wide is in crisis (Tom
Arnold - Concern Worldwide, June2011)
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 4

5. 1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 5

6. World
Population
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 6

7. Species on the verge of mass extinction
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 7

8. 1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 8

9. 1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 9

10. “The continuing success of human society depends fundamentally on
the preservation of the overall productivity, health and long term
sustainability of the eco-systems and environmental services that
underpin and supply many of the most basic
components of human welfare
such as healthy soils,
flourishing biodiversity,
clean waters and
a stable atmosphere
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 10

11. The Three Pillars of Sustainable
Development 1992
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 11

12. We are part of the environment
"The economy is, in the first instance, a
subsystem of human society ... which is itself, in
the second instance, a subsystem of the totality
of life on Earth (the biosphere). And no
subsystem can expand beyond the capacity of
the total system of which it is a part". For this
reason the next diagram, known as the Russian
Doll model, shows economy as a component of
society, both bounded by, and dependent upon,
the environment.
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 12

13. The Real Picture
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 13

14. “ No subsystem can expand
beyond the capacity of
the total system of which
it is a part”
- Jonathon Porritt
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 14

15. What Ever Happened to Agenda 21?
 There are 40 chapters in the Agenda 21, the visionary agreement that
came from Rio 1992, divided into four main sections.
 Section I: Social and Economic Dimensions
 which deals with combating poverty, changing consumption patterns,
promoting health, change population and sustainable settlement
 Section II: Conservation and Management of Resources for Development
 Includes Atmospheric protection combating deforestation, protecting
fragile environments, conservation of biological diversity (biodiversity)
and control of pollution
 Section III: Strengthening the Role of Major Groups
 Includes the roles of children and youth, women, NGOs, local authorities,
business and workers.
 Section IV: Means of Implementation
 Implementation includes science, technology transfer, education,
international institutions and financial mechanisms.
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 15

16. Making choices while we still can!
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 16

17. ‘THE BELIEF that private financial
markets can solve all our problems is
the witchcraft of our age.”
The bill for ignoring nature’s services may not be
affordable if we don’t start paying now, says
‘total capitalist’ and environmentalist Pavan
Sukhdev, a leading figure in the formulation of
Deutsche Bank’s global markets strategy in Asia
from the 1990s. (August 2011)
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 17

18. Environmental Pillar input
into Rio+20
Full submission at
http://environmentalpillar.ie/2011/09/27/625/
• What is this Green Economy?
• Essential parts of the Green Economy
• International Governance
• Governance in Ireland
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 18

19. Green Economy
• A green economy can be seen as one which is low
carbon, resource efficient and socially inclusive. Our
existing economic model and our current focus on it
will not deliver a green economy.
• The definition of a green economy proposed by the
UNEP and supported by the European Commission
does not represent a significant departure from the
current economic model which is driven by the over-
consumption of scarce natural resources.
• In a green economy market prices must adequately
reflect environmental costs, and fiscal policy must shift
taxation from work to resource consumption.
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 19

20. Green Economy
• A truly sustainable ‘green economy’ functions
within the limits of the planet, and ensures a fair
distribution of resources among all countries and
social groups - as well as between men and
women.
• We need an economy that provides incentives for
zero-waste, low-carbon economies that enhance
and restore the natural environment, while also
providing new ‘green’ livelihoods, employment
and entrepreneurial opportunities for women as
well as men.
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 20

21. Essential Parts of a Green Economy
• New Indicators for well-being
• Internalisation of external costs
• Planetary boundaries
• Sufficiency Instruments (caps on resource use)
• Precautionary Principle
• Independent Technology Assessment
• Financial Transaction Tax
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 21

22. International Governance For
Sustainability
• Establishment of a UN ombudsman for future
generations
• International Court for the Environment
• International Sustainable Development Council
• Reform of International Monetary Fund and
World Bank, regional development banks, and
other bodies such as the World Trade
Organisation
• Regional Conventions based on Principle 10 of
the Rio Declaration 1992
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 22

23. Principle 10 (P.10), of the ‘Rio
Declaration on Environment and
Development, 1992’, states:
“Environmental issues are best handled with the
participation of all concerned citizens, at the relevant
level. At the national level, each individual shall have
appropriate access to information concerning the
environment that is held by public authorities, including
information on hazardous materials and activities in their
communities, and the opportunity to participate in
decision-making processes. States shall facilitate and
encourage public awareness and participation by making
information widely available. Effective access to judicial
and administrative proceedings, including redress and
remedy, shall be provided”.
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 23

24. Ridder, Mostert, Wolters, (2005) Harmonising Collaborative Planning (HarmoniCOP);
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 24

25. Access to Justice
“The law, in its majestic equality,
forbids the rich, as well as the
poor, to sleep under the bridges,
to beg in the streets, and to steal
bread”. Anatole France (1844-
1924)
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 25

26. Governance in Ireland
• Ratify and fully implement the Aarhus
Convention
• Climate Change Act with legally enforceable
targets
• Amend the Constitution to provide for the
right to a clean and healthy environment
• Incorporate the principles of SD into the
National Reform Programme ( implementing
the Europe 2020 Strategy)
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 26

27. Governance in Ireland II
• Amended NESDO Act to rename the National
Economic and Social Council (NESC) as the
National Sustainable Development Council
• An inclusive, visionary National Sustainable
Development Strategy with measurable
targets for all Government Departments
• Support for the Development of SD Indicators
• Enforcement of Environmental Law
• Citizen Monitoring and Enforcement
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 27

28. Governance in Ireland III
• Support for the Biodiversity Forum
• Ramsar Committee - Wetlands
• Local Agenda 21
– Include Environment in the TORs of CDBs
– Empower Community Forums
– Renew and implement Local Agenda 21 Plans
– Appoint and support Local Agenda 21 Officers
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 28

29. Thank You
Go Raibh Maith Agaibh
www.environmentalpillar.ie
1 November 2011 environmentalpillar.ie 29