An experimental study in using natural admixture as an alternative for chemic...
"gRPC vs REST: let the battle begin!" OSCON 2018 edition
1. gRPC vs REST: let the battle begin!
Alex Borysov @aiborisov
Mykyta Protsenko @mykyta_p
2. Who are we?
Mykyta Protsenko
Software Engineer @ Netflix
• passionate about all things scalable
• 18+ years in software engineering
• avid biker
• Author of Henka
Alex Borysov
Software Engineer @ Google
• large scale systems developer
• 12+ years in software engineering
• devoxx.org.ua PC member
• Active gRPC user
REST vs gRPC
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
6. I am getting frustrated by the number of people calling any
HTTP-based interface a REST API.
Roy Fielding
http://roy.gbiv.com/untangled/2008/rest-apis-must-be-hypertext-driven
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
11. What is gRPC?
A high performance, general purpose, feature-rich
RPC framework.
Part of Cloud Native Computing Foundation cncf.io
HTTP/2 and mobile first.
Open sourced version of Stubby RPC used in Google.
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
12. g in gRPC stands for
1.0 'gRPC'
1.1 'good'
1.2 'green'
1.3 'gentle'
. . .
1.11 'gorgeous'
1.12 'glorious'
1.13 'gloriosa'
1.14 'gladiolus'
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
https://github.com/grpc/grpc/blob/master/doc/g_stands_for.md
14. gRPC is not RMI
Maitainability
Ease of use
Performance
Scalability
L
e
s
s
o
n
s
Years of using Stubby
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
15. What is gRPC?
Abstractions and best practices on how to design
RPCs.
Default implementation(s) from Google.
Extension points to plug custom implementations and
modifications.
Supports 10+ programming languages
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
16. What is gRPC?
Abstractions and best practices on how to design
RPCs.
Default implementation(s) from Google.
Extension points to plug custom implementations and
modifications.
Supports 10+ programming languages, including JS!
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
23. Microservices?
How to draw an owl?
How to build microservices?
Draw some circles.
Take XYZ framework.
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
24. Microservices?
How to draw an owl?
How to build microservices?
Draw the REST of the owlDraw some circles.
Take XYZ framework.
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
Image by https://www.flickr.com/photos/centralasian/. See slide #177 for details.
25. Microservices?
How to draw an owl?
How to build microservices?
Draw the REST of the owl
Write your microservices!
Draw some circles.
Take XYZ framework.
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
Image by https://www.flickr.com/photos/centralasian/. See slide #177 for details.
41. A distributed system is one in which the failure of a
computer you didn't even know existed can render your own
computer unusable.
Leslie Lamport, 1987
https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Distribution.pdf
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
51. REST: Service
public class AggregatingService {
public AggregatedContent fetch(int id) {
...
return new AggregatedContent(...);
}
}
public class AggregatedContent {
private Integer id;
private String type;
private String content;
private Integer nextId;
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
52. REST: Service
public class AggregatingService {
public AggregatedContent fetch(int id) {
...
return new AggregatedContent(...);
}
}
public class AggregatedContent {
private Integer id;
private String type;
private String content;
private Integer nextId;
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
53. REST: Service
public class AggregatingService {
public AggregatedContent fetch(int id) {
...
return new AggregatedContent(...);
}
}
public class AggregatedContent {
private Integer id; // 115
private String type; // Pokemon
private String content; // Pikachu
private Integer nextId; // 116
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
54. REST: Service
public class AggregatingService {
public AggregatedContent fetch(int id) {
...
return new AggregatedContent(...);
}
}
public class AggregatedContent {
private Integer id; // 115
private String type; // Pokemon
private String content; // Pikachu
private Integer nextId; // 116
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
55. REST: Controller
@GetMapping(
value = "/content/{id}",
produces = "application/json")
public AggregatedContent aggregated(@PathVariable("id") int id) {
return aggregatingService.fetch(id);
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
56. REST: It’s All About Resources
@GetMapping(
value = "/content/{id}",
produces = "application/json")
public AggregatedContent aggregated(@PathVariable("id") int id) {
return aggregatingService.fetch(id);
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
70. Implement gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void get(AggregationRequest request,
StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
}
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
71. Implement gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void get(AggregationRequest request,
StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
}
}
Generated service class
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
72. Implement gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void get(AggregationRequest request,
StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
}
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
73. Implement gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void get(AggregationRequest request,
public interface StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver){{
void onNext(AggregationResponse response);
void onCompleted();
void onError(Throwable error);
}
}
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
74. Implement gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void get(AggregationRequest request,
StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
AggregationResponse response = AggregationResponse
.newBuilder()
.setId(request.getItemId())
.setContent("Ethereum")
.setType(ResponseType.CRYPTO)
.build();
responseObserver.onNext(response);
responseObserver.onCompleted();
}
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
75. Implement gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void get(AggregationRequest request,
StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
AggregationResponse response = AggregationResponse
.newBuilder()
.setId(request.getItemId())
.setContent("Ethereum")
.setType(ResponseType.CRYPTO)
.build();
responseObserver.onNext(response);
responseObserver.onCompleted();
}
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
85. Streaming gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
private final Collection<ContentServiceStub> contentStubs;
public AggregationService(Collection<ContentServiceStub> contentStubs) {
this.contentStubs = contentStubs;
}
...
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
86. Streaming gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void subscribe(AggregationRequest request,StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
contentStubs.forEach(stub -> { stub.subscribe(ContentRequest.getDefaultInstance(),
new StreamObserver<ContentResponse>() {
@Override
public void onNext(ContentResponse response) {
...
}
@Override
public void onError(Throwable error) {
responseObserver.onError(error);
}
@Override
public void onCompleted() {}
});
});
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
87. Streaming gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void subscribe(AggregationRequest request,StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
contentStubs.forEach(stub -> { stub.subscribe(ContentRequest.getDefaultInstance(),
new StreamObserver<ContentResponse>() {
@Override
public void onNext(ContentResponse response) {
...
}
@Override
public void onError(Throwable error) {
responseObserver.onError(error);
}
@Override
public void onCompleted() {}
});
});
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
88. Streaming gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void subscribe(AggregationRequest request,StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
contentStubs.forEach(stub -> { stub.subscribe(ContentRequest.getDefaultInstance(),
new StreamObserver<ContentResponse>() {
@Override
public void onNext(ContentResponse response) {
...
}
@Override
public void onError(Throwable error) {
responseObserver.onError(error);
}
@Override
public void onCompleted() {}
});
});
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
89. Streaming gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void subscribe(AggregationRequest request,StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
contentStubs.forEach(stub -> { stub.subscribe(ContentRequest.getDefaultInstance(),
new StreamObserver<ContentResponse>() {
@Override
public void onNext(ContentResponse response) {
...
}
@Override
public void onError(Throwable error) {
responseObserver.onError(error);
}
@Override
public void onCompleted() {}
});
});
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
90. Streaming gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void subscribe(AggregationRequest request,StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
contentStubs.forEach(stub -> { stub.subscribe(ContentRequest.getDefaultInstance(),
new StreamObserver<ContentResponse>() {
@Override
public void onNext(ContentResponse response) {
ResponseType type = typeForStub(stub);
int aggregationId = aggregationId(response.getId(), type);
AggregationResponse aggrResponse =
AggregationResponse.newBuilder()
.setContent(response.getContent()).setId(aggregationId).
.setType(type).build();
responseObserver.onNext(aggrResponse);
}
});
});
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
91. Streaming gRPC Service
public class AggregationService extends AggregationServiceImplBase {
@Override
public void subscribe(AggregationRequest request,StreamObserver<AggregationResponse> responseObserver) {
contentStubs.forEach(stub -> { stub.subscribe(ContentRequest.getDefaultInstance(),
new StreamObserver<ContentResponse>() {
@Override
public void onNext(ContentResponse response) {
ResponseType type = typeForStub(stub);
int aggregationId = aggregationId(response.getId(), type);
AggregationResponse aggrResponse =
AggregationResponse.newBuilder()
.setContent(response.getContent()).setId(aggregationId).
.setType(type).build();
responseObserver.onNext(aggrResponse);
}
});
});
}
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
116. Serverless
pay as you go
Func
Funcinput
...
Func
input
...
input
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
117. All about resources
IDL optional
Synchronous by default
Unary
Perfect fit for serverless
All about APIs
IDL centric
Asynchronous by nature
Streaming or Unary
Performance first
REST gRPC
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
174. All about resources
Synchronous and unary
Simplicity first
External fault-tolerance
Production ready
All about APIs
Async and streaming
Performance first
Built-in fault-tolerance
Production ready
REST gRPC
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
175. All about resources
Synchronous and unary
Simplicity first
External fault-tolerance
Production ready
All about APIs
Async and streaming
Performance first
Built-in fault-tolerance
Production ready
REST gRPC
Be pragmatic,
start with your problem!
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
177. Images Used
@aiborisov
@mykyta_p
Slides ##24, 25, 176: https://www.flickr.com/photos/centralasian/5229725173
● licenced by CC BY 2.0: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/
● changes were made
Slides ##13, 43: https://www.flickr.com/photos/dan4th/2295925353/
● licenced by CC BY 2.0: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/
● no changes were made
Slides ## 171,173: iStock.com/RichVintage
● https://www.istockphoto.com/legal/license-agreement
● no changes were made