The document discusses the unruly nature of the tongue and how it often disobeys orders and says things unintentionally. It argues that debates are examples where speakers can skillfully modify and "vandalize" their opponent's points to use the ideas against themselves. This is done through rhetorical techniques like rephrasing the ideas with ironic twists or graffiti-like modifications. The document suggests that good communication allows for some degree of "vandalism" through sense-making rather than just insisting on political correctness.
12. An opportunity to “rock out like you’ve
been paid to disturb the peace.”
Anis Mojgani
13. Should every conversation unravel like
a thread on 4Chan? No.
But, there are ways we can modify the ‘cooperative principle’
14. Make your contribution such as it is
required, at the stage at which it occurs, by
the accepted purpose or direction of the
talk exchange in which you are engaged.
“”
Paul Grice
15. There are ways to subvert the accepted
purpose of a conversation or the intended
meaning of a person’s words.
17. ALEXANDER CHUNG
I listened carefully to the debate:
“The Catholic church is force for good.”
John Onayekan
For Against
Ann Widdecombe
Christopher Hitchens
Stephen Fry
VERSUS
18. ALEXANDER CHUNG
I was most compelled when a speaker
served an opponent’s point back to them
after defacing it with some light graffiti.
I visualized a few examples
19. ALEXANDER CHUNG
26% of health institutions
that treat HIV are run by
the Catholic church.
John Onayekan
21. ALEXANDER CHUNG
View of the church as
dominated by hierarchy.
a
clutch
of hysterical
& sinister
VIRGINS
who are the only owners of
THE TRUTH
Followers & Victims
Christopher Hitchens’
22. ALEXANDER CHUNG
the
is not about
PRIESTS
its about a
in costume
LARGER
CHURCH
Community
View of the church as a
global community.
John Onayekan’s
23. ALEXANDER CHUNG
It’s a severe crisis. We need to
apply the most loving pastoral care
to these victims.
“
Joseph Ratzinger on the
institutionalization of rape in
Catholic churches :
24. ALEXANDER CHUNG
It’s a severe crisis. We need to
apply the most loving pastoral care
to these victims.
“
I’m sorry, haven’t they already had that?
Christopher Hitchens
25. In all these examples, it’s clear how the
speaker uses an idea against itself.
26. Kind of like that guy
who fucks with the
subway ads.