SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Download to read offline
Hotel Reviews: Whom Can You Trust? TripAdvisor vs.
Guidebooks
Traveling in the digital age, there is no shortage of people offering advice on which hotels to book
and which ones to avoid. But with this massive influx of information, who can you trust?
Is it better to go with an old-school, traditional guidebook that might only convey one person's
experience but is at least a trusted source? Or should travelers use a Web site that combines
hundreds of hotel guests' comments and experiences but leaves you to guess about these users are
and motivations?
There isn't a simple answer. Most travel experts say that both have their place and that savvy
travelers will use both. But there are some tricks to be aware of.
Stay Up to Date on the Latest Travel Trends from ABC News on Twitter
The granddaddy of user-generated online reviews is TripAdvisor.com, which now includes 25 million
reviews of more than 450,000 hotels in 70,000 locations around the world.
That's a lot of information, but it might not suit everyone's needs. A traveler from Australia who
rarely goes on vacation might have different standards than a road-warrior from Los Angeles, which
can color their impressions of a hotel or a city.
Sometimes people have gripes or might even be hotel owners posting about their own properties.
"My suggestion to consumers reading these is to look at the outliers -- which are either overly good
or excessively bad -- and eliminate them," said Bjorn Hanson, an associate professor of hospitality
and tourism management at New York University.
He said sometimes you just need to look out for the excessive wording to weed out reviews from the
"overly-angry, difficult guest."
Hanson also warned to be aware when there are five to 10 postings in a two-day period for a smaller
hotel.
"Consumers aren't that spontaneous," he warned.
Hotel Reviews Not Always Balanced
Josiah Mackenzie, who runs the blog Hotel Marketing Strategies, said the most helpful reviews are
balanced.
"It is not going to include obscure details that only a hotel owner might know, like the name of the
linen brand," he said.
Mackenzie predicts that someday soon there will be a split of reviews by business travelers for
business travelers and separate reviews for families.
While TripAdvisor might have the critical mass, other sites are getting in the hotel reviewing
business. Yelp.com offers user-generated reviews, and in Europe Qype.com is a popular review site.
Bain Capital recently invested $10 million in a new site, Oyster.com, which employs about 20
undercover reviewers, mostly former journalists, to rate hotels. Currently the site only reviews seven
destinations, but it promises to grow quickly. The reporters stay anonymously, follow a 65-page
manual and take vivid photos that accompany each review. It promises professional, unbiased
reviews, not a hodgepodge of random guest reviews.
But TripAdvisor spokesman Brooke Ferencsik said their site's random reviews are exactly what
make TripAdvisor so valuable. Most of the reviews are positive, he said, and the company has plenty
of tools in place to ensure that reviews are legitimate. Every post is screened by a human before
posting. Suspicious reviews are investigated and software detects automatic postings.
"We have tools in place that ensure for the legitimacy of our reviews," he said.
(The average rating on TripAdvisor is 3.8 out of 5.)

More Related Content

What's hot

TripAdvisor Reputation Management Presentation for CLA
TripAdvisor Reputation Management Presentation for CLATripAdvisor Reputation Management Presentation for CLA
TripAdvisor Reputation Management Presentation for CLABarbara Malmberg, PMP
 
TripAdvisor Nairobi Presentation 2015
TripAdvisor Nairobi Presentation 2015TripAdvisor Nairobi Presentation 2015
TripAdvisor Nairobi Presentation 2015E-Tourism Frontiers
 
Luxury Hotels
Luxury HotelsLuxury Hotels
Luxury HotelsKofo Are
 
ecsKerry19 Emily Ross eWoM Harnessing the power of reviews
ecsKerry19 Emily Ross eWoM Harnessing the power of reviewsecsKerry19 Emily Ross eWoM Harnessing the power of reviews
ecsKerry19 Emily Ross eWoM Harnessing the power of reviewseCommerce Summit
 
Google: Orbitz or Tripadvisor ?
Google: Orbitz or Tripadvisor ?Google: Orbitz or Tripadvisor ?
Google: Orbitz or Tripadvisor ?Merjerz
 
My Travel Club - A Business Plan
My Travel Club - A Business PlanMy Travel Club - A Business Plan
My Travel Club - A Business PlanJon Hussey
 
My Travel Club Business Plan
My Travel Club Business PlanMy Travel Club Business Plan
My Travel Club Business PlanJon Hussey
 
OTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept it
OTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept itOTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept it
OTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept itAlexandra Kyvik Ruiz
 
Præsentation fra TripAdvisor - Morgenmøde 29.1.14, Aarhus på TripAdvisor
Præsentation fra TripAdvisor - Morgenmøde 29.1.14, Aarhus på TripAdvisorPræsentation fra TripAdvisor - Morgenmøde 29.1.14, Aarhus på TripAdvisor
Præsentation fra TripAdvisor - Morgenmøde 29.1.14, Aarhus på TripAdvisorSeismoTourism
 
My Travel Club Business Plan
My Travel Club Business PlanMy Travel Club Business Plan
My Travel Club Business PlanJon Hussey
 
Travel Trends that Matter with Flip.to
Travel Trends that Matter with Flip.toTravel Trends that Matter with Flip.to
Travel Trends that Matter with Flip.toSteve Stevenson
 
Top 5 Hotel Superstar Storytellers of 2014
Top 5 Hotel Superstar Storytellers of 2014 Top 5 Hotel Superstar Storytellers of 2014
Top 5 Hotel Superstar Storytellers of 2014 Leonardo
 
How to grow adr and rev par by improving guest experience - WEBINAR
How to grow adr and rev par by improving guest experience - WEBINARHow to grow adr and rev par by improving guest experience - WEBINAR
How to grow adr and rev par by improving guest experience - WEBINARKePSLA
 
Hotel booking opportunities
Hotel booking opportunitiesHotel booking opportunities
Hotel booking opportunitiesakram75015
 
International Supply Chain, TripAdvisor
International Supply Chain, TripAdvisorInternational Supply Chain, TripAdvisor
International Supply Chain, TripAdvisorInternet World
 

What's hot (19)

TripAdvisor Reputation Management Presentation for CLA
TripAdvisor Reputation Management Presentation for CLATripAdvisor Reputation Management Presentation for CLA
TripAdvisor Reputation Management Presentation for CLA
 
TripAdvisor Nairobi Presentation 2015
TripAdvisor Nairobi Presentation 2015TripAdvisor Nairobi Presentation 2015
TripAdvisor Nairobi Presentation 2015
 
Trip Advisor
Trip AdvisorTrip Advisor
Trip Advisor
 
TripAdvisor ETAS15
TripAdvisor ETAS15TripAdvisor ETAS15
TripAdvisor ETAS15
 
Luxury Hotels
Luxury HotelsLuxury Hotels
Luxury Hotels
 
ecsKerry19 Emily Ross eWoM Harnessing the power of reviews
ecsKerry19 Emily Ross eWoM Harnessing the power of reviewsecsKerry19 Emily Ross eWoM Harnessing the power of reviews
ecsKerry19 Emily Ross eWoM Harnessing the power of reviews
 
Google: Orbitz or Tripadvisor ?
Google: Orbitz or Tripadvisor ?Google: Orbitz or Tripadvisor ?
Google: Orbitz or Tripadvisor ?
 
My Travel Club - A Business Plan
My Travel Club - A Business PlanMy Travel Club - A Business Plan
My Travel Club - A Business Plan
 
My Travel Club Business Plan
My Travel Club Business PlanMy Travel Club Business Plan
My Travel Club Business Plan
 
OTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept it
OTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept itOTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept it
OTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept it
 
Præsentation fra TripAdvisor - Morgenmøde 29.1.14, Aarhus på TripAdvisor
Præsentation fra TripAdvisor - Morgenmøde 29.1.14, Aarhus på TripAdvisorPræsentation fra TripAdvisor - Morgenmøde 29.1.14, Aarhus på TripAdvisor
Præsentation fra TripAdvisor - Morgenmøde 29.1.14, Aarhus på TripAdvisor
 
My Travel Club Business Plan
My Travel Club Business PlanMy Travel Club Business Plan
My Travel Club Business Plan
 
Travel Trends that Matter with Flip.to
Travel Trends that Matter with Flip.toTravel Trends that Matter with Flip.to
Travel Trends that Matter with Flip.to
 
Top 5 Hotel Superstar Storytellers of 2014
Top 5 Hotel Superstar Storytellers of 2014 Top 5 Hotel Superstar Storytellers of 2014
Top 5 Hotel Superstar Storytellers of 2014
 
How to grow adr and rev par by improving guest experience - WEBINAR
How to grow adr and rev par by improving guest experience - WEBINARHow to grow adr and rev par by improving guest experience - WEBINAR
How to grow adr and rev par by improving guest experience - WEBINAR
 
Hotel booking opportunities
Hotel booking opportunitiesHotel booking opportunities
Hotel booking opportunities
 
International Supply Chain, TripAdvisor
International Supply Chain, TripAdvisorInternational Supply Chain, TripAdvisor
International Supply Chain, TripAdvisor
 
GuestFlip
GuestFlipGuestFlip
GuestFlip
 
Tdhd
TdhdTdhd
Tdhd
 

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (10)

ESPAI DEL TUTOR AT14
ESPAI DEL TUTOR  AT14ESPAI DEL TUTOR  AT14
ESPAI DEL TUTOR AT14
 
Salida didáctica
Salida didácticaSalida didáctica
Salida didáctica
 
Flipped classsroom webinar slides- updated
Flipped classsroom   webinar slides- updatedFlipped classsroom   webinar slides- updated
Flipped classsroom webinar slides- updated
 
Pg3
Pg3Pg3
Pg3
 
Nike Air Mag
Nike Air MagNike Air Mag
Nike Air Mag
 
Vần tv 12.12
Vần tv 12.12Vần tv 12.12
Vần tv 12.12
 
AUB Legacy speech Sept 2010
AUB Legacy speech Sept 2010AUB Legacy speech Sept 2010
AUB Legacy speech Sept 2010
 
Glasgow for Business Week 2011
Glasgow for Business Week 2011Glasgow for Business Week 2011
Glasgow for Business Week 2011
 
6 10
6 106 10
6 10
 
Different kinds of_sentences
Different kinds of_sentencesDifferent kinds of_sentences
Different kinds of_sentences
 

Similar to Hotel Reviews: Whom Can You Trust? TripAdvisor vs. Guidebooks

Luxury Hotels
Luxury HotelsLuxury Hotels
Luxury HotelsKofo5Are
 
E-cornell - Hospitality New Media Project
E-cornell - Hospitality New Media ProjectE-cornell - Hospitality New Media Project
E-cornell - Hospitality New Media ProjectInci Malik
 
5 important US hotel and travel trends with the power to shape 2016
5 important US hotel and travel trends with the power to shape 20165 important US hotel and travel trends with the power to shape 2016
5 important US hotel and travel trends with the power to shape 2016SiteMinder
 
Chad Cirino_Int_Hos
Chad Cirino_Int_HosChad Cirino_Int_Hos
Chad Cirino_Int_HosChad Cirino
 
Hotel Trend Report 2020
Hotel Trend Report 2020Hotel Trend Report 2020
Hotel Trend Report 2020Gabriela Otto
 
Hotel Trend Report #hotel2020
Hotel Trend Report #hotel2020Hotel Trend Report #hotel2020
Hotel Trend Report #hotel2020Turistenístico
 
Implement a Sucessfull E-Distribution Strategy by Hopineo
Implement a Sucessfull E-Distribution Strategy by HopineoImplement a Sucessfull E-Distribution Strategy by Hopineo
Implement a Sucessfull E-Distribution Strategy by HopineoFlorie Thielin
 
How to Use Reviews to Craft Your Story and Drive Bookings
How to Use Reviews to Craft Your Story and Drive BookingsHow to Use Reviews to Craft Your Story and Drive Bookings
How to Use Reviews to Craft Your Story and Drive BookingsLeonardo
 
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyondTnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyondKevin May
 
HOTEL AND OTA RELATIONSHIP
HOTEL AND OTA RELATIONSHIP HOTEL AND OTA RELATIONSHIP
HOTEL AND OTA RELATIONSHIP CETRAD
 
Lifestyle brandsVisit businesstraveller.com30 JUNE 2015.docx
Lifestyle brandsVisit businesstraveller.com30  JUNE 2015.docxLifestyle brandsVisit businesstraveller.com30  JUNE 2015.docx
Lifestyle brandsVisit businesstraveller.com30 JUNE 2015.docxSHIVA101531
 
The Evolving Travel Shopping Journey: Searching for Travel Inspiration
The Evolving Travel Shopping Journey: Searching for Travel InspirationThe Evolving Travel Shopping Journey: Searching for Travel Inspiration
The Evolving Travel Shopping Journey: Searching for Travel InspirationLeonardo
 
Making Too Many Responses To Hotel Reviews Is Worse Than Offering No Response...
Making Too Many Responses To Hotel Reviews Is Worse Than Offering No Response...Making Too Many Responses To Hotel Reviews Is Worse Than Offering No Response...
Making Too Many Responses To Hotel Reviews Is Worse Than Offering No Response...Francesco Canzoniere
 
Chinese International Travel Monitor - Hotels.com
Chinese International Travel Monitor - Hotels.com Chinese International Travel Monitor - Hotels.com
Chinese International Travel Monitor - Hotels.com FormazioneTurismo
 
How To Attract Tourists from China
How To Attract Tourists from ChinaHow To Attract Tourists from China
How To Attract Tourists from ChinaSergey Gusarov
 
Crossroads Presentation
Crossroads PresentationCrossroads Presentation
Crossroads Presentationwrsonline
 
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyondTnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyondtnooz
 

Similar to Hotel Reviews: Whom Can You Trust? TripAdvisor vs. Guidebooks (20)

Luxury Hotels
Luxury HotelsLuxury Hotels
Luxury Hotels
 
E-cornell - Hospitality New Media Project
E-cornell - Hospitality New Media ProjectE-cornell - Hospitality New Media Project
E-cornell - Hospitality New Media Project
 
5 important US hotel and travel trends with the power to shape 2016
5 important US hotel and travel trends with the power to shape 20165 important US hotel and travel trends with the power to shape 2016
5 important US hotel and travel trends with the power to shape 2016
 
Tdhd
TdhdTdhd
Tdhd
 
Chad Cirino_Int_Hos
Chad Cirino_Int_HosChad Cirino_Int_Hos
Chad Cirino_Int_Hos
 
Hotel Trend Report 2020
Hotel Trend Report 2020Hotel Trend Report 2020
Hotel Trend Report 2020
 
Hotel Trend Report #hotel2020
Hotel Trend Report #hotel2020Hotel Trend Report #hotel2020
Hotel Trend Report #hotel2020
 
HOTEL TREND REPORT 2020
HOTEL TREND REPORT 2020HOTEL TREND REPORT 2020
HOTEL TREND REPORT 2020
 
Implement a Sucessfull E-Distribution Strategy by Hopineo
Implement a Sucessfull E-Distribution Strategy by HopineoImplement a Sucessfull E-Distribution Strategy by Hopineo
Implement a Sucessfull E-Distribution Strategy by Hopineo
 
How to Use Reviews to Craft Your Story and Drive Bookings
How to Use Reviews to Craft Your Story and Drive BookingsHow to Use Reviews to Craft Your Story and Drive Bookings
How to Use Reviews to Craft Your Story and Drive Bookings
 
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyondTnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
 
HOTEL AND OTA RELATIONSHIP
HOTEL AND OTA RELATIONSHIP HOTEL AND OTA RELATIONSHIP
HOTEL AND OTA RELATIONSHIP
 
Lifestyle brandsVisit businesstraveller.com30 JUNE 2015.docx
Lifestyle brandsVisit businesstraveller.com30  JUNE 2015.docxLifestyle brandsVisit businesstraveller.com30  JUNE 2015.docx
Lifestyle brandsVisit businesstraveller.com30 JUNE 2015.docx
 
The Evolving Travel Shopping Journey: Searching for Travel Inspiration
The Evolving Travel Shopping Journey: Searching for Travel InspirationThe Evolving Travel Shopping Journey: Searching for Travel Inspiration
The Evolving Travel Shopping Journey: Searching for Travel Inspiration
 
Online reputation thailand - pdf
Online reputation   thailand - pdfOnline reputation   thailand - pdf
Online reputation thailand - pdf
 
Making Too Many Responses To Hotel Reviews Is Worse Than Offering No Response...
Making Too Many Responses To Hotel Reviews Is Worse Than Offering No Response...Making Too Many Responses To Hotel Reviews Is Worse Than Offering No Response...
Making Too Many Responses To Hotel Reviews Is Worse Than Offering No Response...
 
Chinese International Travel Monitor - Hotels.com
Chinese International Travel Monitor - Hotels.com Chinese International Travel Monitor - Hotels.com
Chinese International Travel Monitor - Hotels.com
 
How To Attract Tourists from China
How To Attract Tourists from ChinaHow To Attract Tourists from China
How To Attract Tourists from China
 
Crossroads Presentation
Crossroads PresentationCrossroads Presentation
Crossroads Presentation
 
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyondTnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
Tnooz-TripAdvisor webinar - Reputation management and beyond
 

Hotel Reviews: Whom Can You Trust? TripAdvisor vs. Guidebooks

  • 1. Hotel Reviews: Whom Can You Trust? TripAdvisor vs. Guidebooks Traveling in the digital age, there is no shortage of people offering advice on which hotels to book and which ones to avoid. But with this massive influx of information, who can you trust? Is it better to go with an old-school, traditional guidebook that might only convey one person's experience but is at least a trusted source? Or should travelers use a Web site that combines hundreds of hotel guests' comments and experiences but leaves you to guess about these users are and motivations? There isn't a simple answer. Most travel experts say that both have their place and that savvy travelers will use both. But there are some tricks to be aware of. Stay Up to Date on the Latest Travel Trends from ABC News on Twitter The granddaddy of user-generated online reviews is TripAdvisor.com, which now includes 25 million reviews of more than 450,000 hotels in 70,000 locations around the world. That's a lot of information, but it might not suit everyone's needs. A traveler from Australia who rarely goes on vacation might have different standards than a road-warrior from Los Angeles, which can color their impressions of a hotel or a city. Sometimes people have gripes or might even be hotel owners posting about their own properties. "My suggestion to consumers reading these is to look at the outliers -- which are either overly good or excessively bad -- and eliminate them," said Bjorn Hanson, an associate professor of hospitality and tourism management at New York University. He said sometimes you just need to look out for the excessive wording to weed out reviews from the "overly-angry, difficult guest." Hanson also warned to be aware when there are five to 10 postings in a two-day period for a smaller hotel. "Consumers aren't that spontaneous," he warned. Hotel Reviews Not Always Balanced Josiah Mackenzie, who runs the blog Hotel Marketing Strategies, said the most helpful reviews are balanced. "It is not going to include obscure details that only a hotel owner might know, like the name of the linen brand," he said. Mackenzie predicts that someday soon there will be a split of reviews by business travelers for business travelers and separate reviews for families.
  • 2. While TripAdvisor might have the critical mass, other sites are getting in the hotel reviewing business. Yelp.com offers user-generated reviews, and in Europe Qype.com is a popular review site. Bain Capital recently invested $10 million in a new site, Oyster.com, which employs about 20 undercover reviewers, mostly former journalists, to rate hotels. Currently the site only reviews seven destinations, but it promises to grow quickly. The reporters stay anonymously, follow a 65-page manual and take vivid photos that accompany each review. It promises professional, unbiased reviews, not a hodgepodge of random guest reviews. But TripAdvisor spokesman Brooke Ferencsik said their site's random reviews are exactly what make TripAdvisor so valuable. Most of the reviews are positive, he said, and the company has plenty of tools in place to ensure that reviews are legitimate. Every post is screened by a human before posting. Suspicious reviews are investigated and software detects automatic postings. "We have tools in place that ensure for the legitimacy of our reviews," he said. (The average rating on TripAdvisor is 3.8 out of 5.)