SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 20
C H A P T E R
                                 13
                   Reality of Consent



Necessity never made a good
           bargain.

   Benjamin Franklin, 1735




                                    13-1
Learning Objectives

• Explain five doctrines that permit
  people to avoid their contracts
  because of the absence of real
  consent and identify elements:
  –   Misrepresentation
  –   Fraud
  –   Mistake
  –   Duress, and
  –   Undue influence
                                       13-2
Effect of The Five Doctrines

• Contracts induced by mistake, fraud,
  misrepresentation, duress, or undue
  influence are generally considered to
  be voidable
  – Person claiming non-consent has power
    to rescind (cancel) the contract
  – Person claiming non-consent must not act
    in a manner to ratify (affirm) the contract


                                                  13-3
Misrepresentation or Fraud?

• A misrepresentation is a false statement
  and may be negligent (innocent) or
  fraudulent (made with knowledge of
  falsity and intent to deceive)
  – Either way, injured party may void
    (rescind) the contract
• A person who commits fraud may be
  liable in tort for damages, including
  punitive damages

                                             13-4
Elements

• Innocent or fraudulent misrepresentation:
  – Defendant made an untrue assertion of fact
     • Includes active concealment or non-
       disclosure
  – Fact asserted was material or was fraudulent
     • Fact is material if likely to play significant role
       in inducing reasonable person to enter the
       contract
  – Complaining party entered the contract
    because of reliance on the assertion

                                                             13-5
Elements (cont.)
• Reliance of
  complainant was
  reasonable
  – Reliance means that
    person entered the
    contract because of
    belief in the assertion
• Fifth element for fraud:
  – Injury

                                13-6
13-7
Timothy v. Keetch
• Facts:
  – Defendants wanted to start a therapeutic
    horse ranch as business venture, borrowed
    $102,000 from MSF and pledged a stallion they
    bought as collateral for the loan
     • Financing statement filed in UCC database
  – Plaintiffs agreed to loan Defendants money,
    relying upon Defendants’ offer of the stallion as
    loan collateral and statement of ownership



                                                        13-8
Timothy v. Keetch
• Issue: Is it reasonable to rely on representation
  that an asset is owned “free and clear” when
  public record check would show otherwise
• Holding: plaintiff may justifiably rely on positive
  assertions of fact without independent
  Investigation since nothing in the transaction
  suggested anything that would “serve as a
  warning” that they were being deceived
   – Affirmed in favor of plaintiffs



                                                        13-9
Mistake in Contracts

• A mistake is a belief about a fact that
  is not in accord with the truth
  – Mistake must relate to facts as they
    exist at the time the contract is created
  – Mistake not due to other party’s
    statements
• Mutual mistakes may be remedied by
  reformation

                                            13-10
Mistake in Contracts
• A unilateral mistake will not render a
  contract unenforceable unless unequal
  bargaining position existed
  – Sumerel v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company in
    which plaintiffs attempted to exploit
    defendants’ mathematical or clerical error
    and failed




                                                   13-11
Duress
• Duress is wrongful threat or
  act that coerces a person
  to enter or modify contract
   – Physical, emotional, or
     economic harm
• Given duress, victim must
  have no reasonable
  choice but to enter the
  contract
   – Cabot Corp. v AVX Corp.

                                 13-12
Cabot Corporation v.
             AVX Corporation
• Facts:
  – After long negotiation of a long-term supply
    contract, parties disputed whether contract
    was valid and binding (Cabot’s claim) or void
    due to economic duress (AVX’s claim)
• The Law:
  – To establish economic duress, party must show
    he has been the victim of a wrongful or
    unlawful act or threat, and such act or threat
    must be one which deprives the victim of
    unfettered will

                                                    13-13
Cabot Corporation v.
         AVX Corporation
• Law Applied to Facts:
 – AVX and Cabot are sophisticated and
   substantial commercial parties represented
   by highly competent counsel
 – Cabot was in stronger position than AVX, but
   “hard bargaining is not unlawful”
 – No evidence of coercion, but there is
   evidence of AVX’s ratification
• Holding:
 – Judgment affirmed in favor of Cabot

                                              13-14
Undue Influence
• Undue influence involves
  wrongful pressure exerted
  on a person during the
  bargaining process
• Unlike duress, pressure is
  exerted through persuasion
  rather than coercion
• Key is the weakness of the
  person “persuaded”


                               13-15
13-16
Test Your Knowledge
• True=A, False = B
  – A contract signed under duress or
    undue influence is simply void.
  – A misrepresentation may be negligent
    (innocent) or fraudulent.
  – Mutual mistakes may be remedied by
    reformation
  – Duress and undue influence have the
    same meaning
                                           13-17
Test Your Knowledge
• Multiple Choice
  – Elements of innocent misrepresentation:

     a) False assertion
     b) Knowingly made to induce a person
        to enter a contract
     c) Reasonable reliance on the assertion
        by complainant
     d) All of the above
     e) Both (a) and (c), but not (b)
                                               13-18
Test Your Knowledge
• Multiple Choice
  – A unilateral mistake will not render a
    contract void unless:
     a) Substantial difference between
        contract and market price
     b) Fundamental error occurred
     c) An unequal bargaining position
        existed

                                             13-19
Thought Question
• Your landlord tells you
  that you will be evicted
  from your apartment or
  your rent must increase
  by $50 per month
  because your neighbors
  complain about your
  dog. If you agree to the
  increase, would the
  contract be void or
  voidable under the
  theory of duress?
                             13-20

More Related Content

What's hot

Chapter 18 – Performance and Remedies
Chapter 18 – Performance and RemediesChapter 18 – Performance and Remedies
Chapter 18 – Performance and Remedies
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 9 – Introduction to Contracts
Chapter 9 – Introduction to ContractsChapter 9 – Introduction to Contracts
Chapter 9 – Introduction to Contracts
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 17 – Rights of Third Parties
Chapter 17 – Rights of Third PartiesChapter 17 – Rights of Third Parties
Chapter 17 – Rights of Third Parties
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 10 – The Agreement: Offer
Chapter 10 – The Agreement:  OfferChapter 10 – The Agreement:  Offer
Chapter 10 – The Agreement: Offer
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 14 – Capacity to Contract
Chapter 14 – Capacity to ContractChapter 14 – Capacity to Contract
Chapter 14 – Capacity to Contract
UAF_BA330
 
BUS 115 Chap008 offer acceptance mutual assent
BUS 115 Chap008   offer acceptance mutual assentBUS 115 Chap008   offer acceptance mutual assent
BUS 115 Chap008 offer acceptance mutual assent
neogenesis6
 
BUS 115 Chap011 written contracts
BUS 115 Chap011   written contractsBUS 115 Chap011   written contracts
BUS 115 Chap011 written contracts
neogenesis6
 
BUS 115 Chap010 capacity and legality
BUS 115 Chap010   capacity and legalityBUS 115 Chap010   capacity and legality
BUS 115 Chap010 capacity and legality
neogenesis6
 
Lecture 14 misrepresentations
Lecture 14 misrepresentationsLecture 14 misrepresentations
Lecture 14 misrepresentations
fatima d
 

What's hot (20)

Chapter 18 – Performance and Remedies
Chapter 18 – Performance and RemediesChapter 18 – Performance and Remedies
Chapter 18 – Performance and Remedies
 
Chapter 16 – Writing
Chapter 16 – WritingChapter 16 – Writing
Chapter 16 – Writing
 
Chapter 9 – Introduction to Contracts
Chapter 9 – Introduction to ContractsChapter 9 – Introduction to Contracts
Chapter 9 – Introduction to Contracts
 
Chapter 17 – Rights of Third Parties
Chapter 17 – Rights of Third PartiesChapter 17 – Rights of Third Parties
Chapter 17 – Rights of Third Parties
 
Chapter 15 – Illegality
Chapter 15 – IllegalityChapter 15 – Illegality
Chapter 15 – Illegality
 
Chapter 18 – Performance and Remedies
Chapter 18 – Performance and RemediesChapter 18 – Performance and Remedies
Chapter 18 – Performance and Remedies
 
Chapter 9 – Introduction to Contracts
Chapter 9 – Introduction to ContractsChapter 9 – Introduction to Contracts
Chapter 9 – Introduction to Contracts
 
Chapter 10 – The Agreement: Offer
Chapter 10 – The Agreement:  OfferChapter 10 – The Agreement:  Offer
Chapter 10 – The Agreement: Offer
 
Chapter 17 – Rights of Third Parties
Chapter 17 – Rights of Third PartiesChapter 17 – Rights of Third Parties
Chapter 17 – Rights of Third Parties
 
Chapter 14 – Capacity to Contract
Chapter 14 – Capacity to ContractChapter 14 – Capacity to Contract
Chapter 14 – Capacity to Contract
 
Contracts capacity business law
Contracts capacity business law Contracts capacity business law
Contracts capacity business law
 
BUS 115 Chap008 offer acceptance mutual assent
BUS 115 Chap008   offer acceptance mutual assentBUS 115 Chap008   offer acceptance mutual assent
BUS 115 Chap008 offer acceptance mutual assent
 
BUS 115 Chap011 written contracts
BUS 115 Chap011   written contractsBUS 115 Chap011   written contracts
BUS 115 Chap011 written contracts
 
Performance Bonds - 11 December 2009
Performance Bonds - 11 December 2009Performance Bonds - 11 December 2009
Performance Bonds - 11 December 2009
 
BUS 115 Chap010 capacity and legality
BUS 115 Chap010   capacity and legalityBUS 115 Chap010   capacity and legality
BUS 115 Chap010 capacity and legality
 
Chapter 14 – Capacity to Contract
Chapter 14 – Capacity to ContractChapter 14 – Capacity to Contract
Chapter 14 – Capacity to Contract
 
Law and ethics 4 contractual capacity, consideration and contents
Law and ethics 4   contractual capacity, consideration and contents Law and ethics 4   contractual capacity, consideration and contents
Law and ethics 4 contractual capacity, consideration and contents
 
Lecture 14 misrepresentations
Lecture 14 misrepresentationsLecture 14 misrepresentations
Lecture 14 misrepresentations
 
Introduction to Contract Law
Introduction to Contract LawIntroduction to Contract Law
Introduction to Contract Law
 
Term of contract, Exemption clauses
Term of contract, Exemption clausesTerm of contract, Exemption clauses
Term of contract, Exemption clauses
 

Viewers also liked

Chapter 52 – Environmental Regulation
Chapter 52 – Environmental RegulationChapter 52 – Environmental Regulation
Chapter 52 – Environmental Regulation
UAF_BA330
 
D'Agostino v Federal Ins Co , 969 F. Supp. 2d 116 (D. Mass. 2013)
D'Agostino v Federal Ins Co , 969 F. Supp. 2d 116 (D. Mass. 2013)D'Agostino v Federal Ins Co , 969 F. Supp. 2d 116 (D. Mass. 2013)
D'Agostino v Federal Ins Co , 969 F. Supp. 2d 116 (D. Mass. 2013)
Richard Goren
 
Chapter 28 – Introduction to Credit and Secured Transactions
Chapter 28 – Introduction to Credit and Secured TransactionsChapter 28 – Introduction to Credit and Secured Transactions
Chapter 28 – Introduction to Credit and Secured Transactions
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales ContractsChapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 34 – Checks and Electronic Transfers
Chapter 34 – Checks and Electronic TransfersChapter 34 – Checks and Electronic Transfers
Chapter 34 – Checks and Electronic Transfers
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 21 – Performance of Sales Contracts
Chapter 21 – Performance of Sales ContractsChapter 21 – Performance of Sales Contracts
Chapter 21 – Performance of Sales Contracts
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 37 – Introduction to Forms of Business and Formation of Partnerships
Chapter 37 – Introduction to Forms of Business and Formation of PartnershipsChapter 37 – Introduction to Forms of Business and Formation of Partnerships
Chapter 37 – Introduction to Forms of Business and Formation of Partnerships
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 31 – Negotiable Instruments
Chapter 31 – Negotiable InstrumentsChapter 31 – Negotiable Instruments
Chapter 31 – Negotiable Instruments
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 30 – Bankruptcy
Chapter 30 – BankruptcyChapter 30 – Bankruptcy
Chapter 30 – Bankruptcy
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 1 - The Nature of Law
Chapter 1 - The Nature of LawChapter 1 - The Nature of Law
Chapter 1 - The Nature of Law
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 38 – Operation of Partnerships and Related Forms
Chapter 38 – Operation of Partnerships and Related FormsChapter 38 – Operation of Partnerships and Related Forms
Chapter 38 – Operation of Partnerships and Related Forms
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 33 – Liability of Parties
Chapter 33 – Liability of PartiesChapter 33 – Liability of Parties
Chapter 33 – Liability of Parties
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 40 – Limited Liability Companies, Limited Partnerships, and Limited L...
Chapter 40 – Limited Liability Companies, Limited Partnerships, and Limited L...Chapter 40 – Limited Liability Companies, Limited Partnerships, and Limited L...
Chapter 40 – Limited Liability Companies, Limited Partnerships, and Limited L...
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 20 – Product Liability
Chapter 20 – Product LiabilityChapter 20 – Product Liability
Chapter 20 – Product Liability
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 32 – Negotiation and Holder in Due Course
Chapter 32 – Negotiation and Holder in Due CourseChapter 32 – Negotiation and Holder in Due Course
Chapter 32 – Negotiation and Holder in Due Course
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 4 - Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility, Corporate Gover...
Chapter 4 - Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility, Corporate Gover...Chapter 4 - Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility, Corporate Gover...
Chapter 4 - Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility, Corporate Gover...
UAF_BA330
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Chapter 52 – Environmental Regulation
Chapter 52 – Environmental RegulationChapter 52 – Environmental Regulation
Chapter 52 – Environmental Regulation
 
D'Agostino v Federal Ins Co , 969 F. Supp. 2d 116 (D. Mass. 2013)
D'Agostino v Federal Ins Co , 969 F. Supp. 2d 116 (D. Mass. 2013)D'Agostino v Federal Ins Co , 969 F. Supp. 2d 116 (D. Mass. 2013)
D'Agostino v Federal Ins Co , 969 F. Supp. 2d 116 (D. Mass. 2013)
 
Chapter 28 – Introduction to Credit and Secured Transactions
Chapter 28 – Introduction to Credit and Secured TransactionsChapter 28 – Introduction to Credit and Secured Transactions
Chapter 28 – Introduction to Credit and Secured Transactions
 
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales ContractsChapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
 
Chapter 34 – Checks and Electronic Transfers
Chapter 34 – Checks and Electronic TransfersChapter 34 – Checks and Electronic Transfers
Chapter 34 – Checks and Electronic Transfers
 
Chapter 21 – Performance of Sales Contracts
Chapter 21 – Performance of Sales ContractsChapter 21 – Performance of Sales Contracts
Chapter 21 – Performance of Sales Contracts
 
Chapter 37 – Introduction to Forms of Business and Formation of Partnerships
Chapter 37 – Introduction to Forms of Business and Formation of PartnershipsChapter 37 – Introduction to Forms of Business and Formation of Partnerships
Chapter 37 – Introduction to Forms of Business and Formation of Partnerships
 
Chapter 31 – Negotiable Instruments
Chapter 31 – Negotiable InstrumentsChapter 31 – Negotiable Instruments
Chapter 31 – Negotiable Instruments
 
Chapter 30 – Bankruptcy
Chapter 30 – BankruptcyChapter 30 – Bankruptcy
Chapter 30 – Bankruptcy
 
Chapter 1 - The Nature of Law
Chapter 1 - The Nature of LawChapter 1 - The Nature of Law
Chapter 1 - The Nature of Law
 
Chapter 38 – Operation of Partnerships and Related Forms
Chapter 38 – Operation of Partnerships and Related FormsChapter 38 – Operation of Partnerships and Related Forms
Chapter 38 – Operation of Partnerships and Related Forms
 
Chapter 33 – Liability of Parties
Chapter 33 – Liability of PartiesChapter 33 – Liability of Parties
Chapter 33 – Liability of Parties
 
Chapter 40 – Limited Liability Companies, Limited Partnerships, and Limited L...
Chapter 40 – Limited Liability Companies, Limited Partnerships, and Limited L...Chapter 40 – Limited Liability Companies, Limited Partnerships, and Limited L...
Chapter 40 – Limited Liability Companies, Limited Partnerships, and Limited L...
 
Chapter 20 – Product Liability
Chapter 20 – Product LiabilityChapter 20 – Product Liability
Chapter 20 – Product Liability
 
Chapter 32 – Negotiation and Holder in Due Course
Chapter 32 – Negotiation and Holder in Due CourseChapter 32 – Negotiation and Holder in Due Course
Chapter 32 – Negotiation and Holder in Due Course
 
Chapter 4 - Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility, Corporate Gover...
Chapter 4 - Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility, Corporate Gover...Chapter 4 - Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility, Corporate Gover...
Chapter 4 - Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility, Corporate Gover...
 

Similar to Chapter 13 – Reality of Consent

BUS 115 Chap009 consideration and cyberpayments
BUS 115 Chap009   consideration and cyberpaymentsBUS 115 Chap009   consideration and cyberpayments
BUS 115 Chap009 consideration and cyberpayments
neogenesis6
 
Elements of a Contract.pdf
Elements of a Contract.pdfElements of a Contract.pdf
Elements of a Contract.pdf
Top4Hit
 
T1, 2021 business law lecture week 6 - law of torts - negligence 2
T1, 2021 business law   lecture week 6 - law of torts - negligence 2T1, 2021 business law   lecture week 6 - law of torts - negligence 2
T1, 2021 business law lecture week 6 - law of torts - negligence 2
markmagner
 

Similar to Chapter 13 – Reality of Consent (20)

Fraud in Contract
Fraud in ContractFraud in Contract
Fraud in Contract
 
indian contract act
indian contract actindian contract act
indian contract act
 
BUS 115 Chap009 consideration and cyberpayments
BUS 115 Chap009   consideration and cyberpaymentsBUS 115 Chap009   consideration and cyberpayments
BUS 115 Chap009 consideration and cyberpayments
 
Elements of a Contract.pdf
Elements of a Contract.pdfElements of a Contract.pdf
Elements of a Contract.pdf
 
Capacity & Consent in contract
Capacity & Consent in contract Capacity & Consent in contract
Capacity & Consent in contract
 
Misrepresentation and Fraud
Misrepresentation and FraudMisrepresentation and Fraud
Misrepresentation and Fraud
 
T1, 2021 business law lecture 4 - contracts 3
T1, 2021 business law   lecture 4 - contracts 3T1, 2021 business law   lecture 4 - contracts 3
T1, 2021 business law lecture 4 - contracts 3
 
Consideration and valid consideration
Consideration and valid considerationConsideration and valid consideration
Consideration and valid consideration
 
T1, 2021 business law lecture week 6 - law of torts - negligence 2
T1, 2021 business law   lecture week 6 - law of torts - negligence 2T1, 2021 business law   lecture week 6 - law of torts - negligence 2
T1, 2021 business law lecture week 6 - law of torts - negligence 2
 
Contract ppt
Contract pptContract ppt
Contract ppt
 
Contract ppt
Contract pptContract ppt
Contract ppt
 
Vitiating Elements in Formation of Contract: Duress and Undue Influence
Vitiating Elements in Formation of Contract: Duress and Undue InfluenceVitiating Elements in Formation of Contract: Duress and Undue Influence
Vitiating Elements in Formation of Contract: Duress and Undue Influence
 
Freeconsent 121216080205-phpapp02
Freeconsent 121216080205-phpapp02Freeconsent 121216080205-phpapp02
Freeconsent 121216080205-phpapp02
 
Freeconsent 121216080205-phpapp02-1
Freeconsent 121216080205-phpapp02-1Freeconsent 121216080205-phpapp02-1
Freeconsent 121216080205-phpapp02-1
 
COMMERCIAL LAW
COMMERCIAL LAW COMMERCIAL LAW
COMMERCIAL LAW
 
Contract+i
Contract+iContract+i
Contract+i
 
Indian contract act
Indian contract actIndian contract act
Indian contract act
 
b.law 4.pptx
b.law 4.pptxb.law 4.pptx
b.law 4.pptx
 
CONTRACT- UNDUE INFLUENCE AND MISREPRESENTATION.pptx
CONTRACT- UNDUE INFLUENCE AND MISREPRESENTATION.pptxCONTRACT- UNDUE INFLUENCE AND MISREPRESENTATION.pptx
CONTRACT- UNDUE INFLUENCE AND MISREPRESENTATION.pptx
 
Void agreement / contract ppt
Void agreement / contract pptVoid agreement / contract ppt
Void agreement / contract ppt
 

More from UAF_BA330

Chapter 51 – Employment Law
Chapter 51 – Employment LawChapter 51 – Employment Law
Chapter 51 – Employment Law
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 48 – The Federal Trade Commission Act and Consumer Protection Laws
Chapter 48 – The Federal Trade Commission Act and Consumer Protection LawsChapter 48 – The Federal Trade Commission Act and Consumer Protection Laws
Chapter 48 – The Federal Trade Commission Act and Consumer Protection Laws
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 43 – Management of Corporations
Chapter 43 – Management of CorporationsChapter 43 – Management of Corporations
Chapter 43 – Management of Corporations
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 42 – Organization and Financial Structure of Corporations
Chapter 42 – Organization and Financial Structure of CorporationsChapter 42 – Organization and Financial Structure of Corporations
Chapter 42 – Organization and Financial Structure of Corporations
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 41 – History and Nature of Corporations
Chapter 41 – History and Nature of CorporationsChapter 41 – History and Nature of Corporations
Chapter 41 – History and Nature of Corporations
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 39 – Partners’ Dissociation and Partnerships’ Dissolution and Winding Up
Chapter 39 – Partners’ Dissociation and Partnerships’ Dissolution and Winding UpChapter 39 – Partners’ Dissociation and Partnerships’ Dissolution and Winding Up
Chapter 39 – Partners’ Dissociation and Partnerships’ Dissolution and Winding Up
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 36 – Third-Party Relations of the Principal and the Agent
Chapter 36 – Third-Party Relations of the Principal and the AgentChapter 36 – Third-Party Relations of the Principal and the Agent
Chapter 36 – Third-Party Relations of the Principal and the Agent
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 35 – The Agency Relationship
Chapter 35 – The Agency RelationshipChapter 35 – The Agency Relationship
Chapter 35 – The Agency Relationship
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 27 – Insurance Law
Chapter 27 – Insurance LawChapter 27 – Insurance Law
Chapter 27 – Insurance Law
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 24 – Real Property
Chapter 24 – Real PropertyChapter 24 – Real Property
Chapter 24 – Real Property
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 22 – Remedies for Breach of Sales Contracts
Chapter 22 – Remedies for Breach of Sales ContractsChapter 22 – Remedies for Breach of Sales Contracts
Chapter 22 – Remedies for Breach of Sales Contracts
UAF_BA330
 
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales ContractsChapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
UAF_BA330
 

More from UAF_BA330 (12)

Chapter 51 – Employment Law
Chapter 51 – Employment LawChapter 51 – Employment Law
Chapter 51 – Employment Law
 
Chapter 48 – The Federal Trade Commission Act and Consumer Protection Laws
Chapter 48 – The Federal Trade Commission Act and Consumer Protection LawsChapter 48 – The Federal Trade Commission Act and Consumer Protection Laws
Chapter 48 – The Federal Trade Commission Act and Consumer Protection Laws
 
Chapter 43 – Management of Corporations
Chapter 43 – Management of CorporationsChapter 43 – Management of Corporations
Chapter 43 – Management of Corporations
 
Chapter 42 – Organization and Financial Structure of Corporations
Chapter 42 – Organization and Financial Structure of CorporationsChapter 42 – Organization and Financial Structure of Corporations
Chapter 42 – Organization and Financial Structure of Corporations
 
Chapter 41 – History and Nature of Corporations
Chapter 41 – History and Nature of CorporationsChapter 41 – History and Nature of Corporations
Chapter 41 – History and Nature of Corporations
 
Chapter 39 – Partners’ Dissociation and Partnerships’ Dissolution and Winding Up
Chapter 39 – Partners’ Dissociation and Partnerships’ Dissolution and Winding UpChapter 39 – Partners’ Dissociation and Partnerships’ Dissolution and Winding Up
Chapter 39 – Partners’ Dissociation and Partnerships’ Dissolution and Winding Up
 
Chapter 36 – Third-Party Relations of the Principal and the Agent
Chapter 36 – Third-Party Relations of the Principal and the AgentChapter 36 – Third-Party Relations of the Principal and the Agent
Chapter 36 – Third-Party Relations of the Principal and the Agent
 
Chapter 35 – The Agency Relationship
Chapter 35 – The Agency RelationshipChapter 35 – The Agency Relationship
Chapter 35 – The Agency Relationship
 
Chapter 27 – Insurance Law
Chapter 27 – Insurance LawChapter 27 – Insurance Law
Chapter 27 – Insurance Law
 
Chapter 24 – Real Property
Chapter 24 – Real PropertyChapter 24 – Real Property
Chapter 24 – Real Property
 
Chapter 22 – Remedies for Breach of Sales Contracts
Chapter 22 – Remedies for Breach of Sales ContractsChapter 22 – Remedies for Breach of Sales Contracts
Chapter 22 – Remedies for Breach of Sales Contracts
 
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales ContractsChapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
Chapter 19 – Formation of Terms of Sales Contracts
 

Recently uploaded

Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
ZurliaSoop
 
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functionsSalient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
KarakKing
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Jamworks pilot and AI at Jisc (20/03/2024)
Jamworks pilot and AI at Jisc (20/03/2024)Jamworks pilot and AI at Jisc (20/03/2024)
Jamworks pilot and AI at Jisc (20/03/2024)
 
Interdisciplinary_Insights_Data_Collection_Methods.pptx
Interdisciplinary_Insights_Data_Collection_Methods.pptxInterdisciplinary_Insights_Data_Collection_Methods.pptx
Interdisciplinary_Insights_Data_Collection_Methods.pptx
 
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning PresentationSOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
 
Plant propagation: Sexual and Asexual propapagation.pptx
Plant propagation: Sexual and Asexual propapagation.pptxPlant propagation: Sexual and Asexual propapagation.pptx
Plant propagation: Sexual and Asexual propapagation.pptx
 
Unit 3 Emotional Intelligence and Spiritual Intelligence.pdf
Unit 3 Emotional Intelligence and Spiritual Intelligence.pdfUnit 3 Emotional Intelligence and Spiritual Intelligence.pdf
Unit 3 Emotional Intelligence and Spiritual Intelligence.pdf
 
On_Translating_a_Tamil_Poem_by_A_K_Ramanujan.pptx
On_Translating_a_Tamil_Poem_by_A_K_Ramanujan.pptxOn_Translating_a_Tamil_Poem_by_A_K_Ramanujan.pptx
On_Translating_a_Tamil_Poem_by_A_K_Ramanujan.pptx
 
NO1 Top Black Magic Specialist In Lahore Black magic In Pakistan Kala Ilam Ex...
NO1 Top Black Magic Specialist In Lahore Black magic In Pakistan Kala Ilam Ex...NO1 Top Black Magic Specialist In Lahore Black magic In Pakistan Kala Ilam Ex...
NO1 Top Black Magic Specialist In Lahore Black magic In Pakistan Kala Ilam Ex...
 
TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...
TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...
TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...
 
Understanding Accommodations and Modifications
Understanding  Accommodations and ModificationsUnderstanding  Accommodations and Modifications
Understanding Accommodations and Modifications
 
COMMUNICATING NEGATIVE NEWS - APPROACHES .pptx
COMMUNICATING NEGATIVE NEWS - APPROACHES .pptxCOMMUNICATING NEGATIVE NEWS - APPROACHES .pptx
COMMUNICATING NEGATIVE NEWS - APPROACHES .pptx
 
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
 
Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...
Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...
Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...
 
latest AZ-104 Exam Questions and Answers
latest AZ-104 Exam Questions and Answerslatest AZ-104 Exam Questions and Answers
latest AZ-104 Exam Questions and Answers
 
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan FellowsOn National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
 
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
 
80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...
80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...
80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...
 
21st_Century_Skills_Framework_Final_Presentation_2.pptx
21st_Century_Skills_Framework_Final_Presentation_2.pptx21st_Century_Skills_Framework_Final_Presentation_2.pptx
21st_Century_Skills_Framework_Final_Presentation_2.pptx
 
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functionsSalient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
 
Single or Multiple melodic lines structure
Single or Multiple melodic lines structureSingle or Multiple melodic lines structure
Single or Multiple melodic lines structure
 

Chapter 13 – Reality of Consent

  • 1. C H A P T E R 13 Reality of Consent Necessity never made a good bargain. Benjamin Franklin, 1735 13-1
  • 2. Learning Objectives • Explain five doctrines that permit people to avoid their contracts because of the absence of real consent and identify elements: – Misrepresentation – Fraud – Mistake – Duress, and – Undue influence 13-2
  • 3. Effect of The Five Doctrines • Contracts induced by mistake, fraud, misrepresentation, duress, or undue influence are generally considered to be voidable – Person claiming non-consent has power to rescind (cancel) the contract – Person claiming non-consent must not act in a manner to ratify (affirm) the contract 13-3
  • 4. Misrepresentation or Fraud? • A misrepresentation is a false statement and may be negligent (innocent) or fraudulent (made with knowledge of falsity and intent to deceive) – Either way, injured party may void (rescind) the contract • A person who commits fraud may be liable in tort for damages, including punitive damages 13-4
  • 5. Elements • Innocent or fraudulent misrepresentation: – Defendant made an untrue assertion of fact • Includes active concealment or non- disclosure – Fact asserted was material or was fraudulent • Fact is material if likely to play significant role in inducing reasonable person to enter the contract – Complaining party entered the contract because of reliance on the assertion 13-5
  • 6. Elements (cont.) • Reliance of complainant was reasonable – Reliance means that person entered the contract because of belief in the assertion • Fifth element for fraud: – Injury 13-6
  • 8. Timothy v. Keetch • Facts: – Defendants wanted to start a therapeutic horse ranch as business venture, borrowed $102,000 from MSF and pledged a stallion they bought as collateral for the loan • Financing statement filed in UCC database – Plaintiffs agreed to loan Defendants money, relying upon Defendants’ offer of the stallion as loan collateral and statement of ownership 13-8
  • 9. Timothy v. Keetch • Issue: Is it reasonable to rely on representation that an asset is owned “free and clear” when public record check would show otherwise • Holding: plaintiff may justifiably rely on positive assertions of fact without independent Investigation since nothing in the transaction suggested anything that would “serve as a warning” that they were being deceived – Affirmed in favor of plaintiffs 13-9
  • 10. Mistake in Contracts • A mistake is a belief about a fact that is not in accord with the truth – Mistake must relate to facts as they exist at the time the contract is created – Mistake not due to other party’s statements • Mutual mistakes may be remedied by reformation 13-10
  • 11. Mistake in Contracts • A unilateral mistake will not render a contract unenforceable unless unequal bargaining position existed – Sumerel v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company in which plaintiffs attempted to exploit defendants’ mathematical or clerical error and failed 13-11
  • 12. Duress • Duress is wrongful threat or act that coerces a person to enter or modify contract – Physical, emotional, or economic harm • Given duress, victim must have no reasonable choice but to enter the contract – Cabot Corp. v AVX Corp. 13-12
  • 13. Cabot Corporation v. AVX Corporation • Facts: – After long negotiation of a long-term supply contract, parties disputed whether contract was valid and binding (Cabot’s claim) or void due to economic duress (AVX’s claim) • The Law: – To establish economic duress, party must show he has been the victim of a wrongful or unlawful act or threat, and such act or threat must be one which deprives the victim of unfettered will 13-13
  • 14. Cabot Corporation v. AVX Corporation • Law Applied to Facts: – AVX and Cabot are sophisticated and substantial commercial parties represented by highly competent counsel – Cabot was in stronger position than AVX, but “hard bargaining is not unlawful” – No evidence of coercion, but there is evidence of AVX’s ratification • Holding: – Judgment affirmed in favor of Cabot 13-14
  • 15. Undue Influence • Undue influence involves wrongful pressure exerted on a person during the bargaining process • Unlike duress, pressure is exerted through persuasion rather than coercion • Key is the weakness of the person “persuaded” 13-15
  • 16. 13-16
  • 17. Test Your Knowledge • True=A, False = B – A contract signed under duress or undue influence is simply void. – A misrepresentation may be negligent (innocent) or fraudulent. – Mutual mistakes may be remedied by reformation – Duress and undue influence have the same meaning 13-17
  • 18. Test Your Knowledge • Multiple Choice – Elements of innocent misrepresentation: a) False assertion b) Knowingly made to induce a person to enter a contract c) Reasonable reliance on the assertion by complainant d) All of the above e) Both (a) and (c), but not (b) 13-18
  • 19. Test Your Knowledge • Multiple Choice – A unilateral mistake will not render a contract void unless: a) Substantial difference between contract and market price b) Fundamental error occurred c) An unequal bargaining position existed 13-19
  • 20. Thought Question • Your landlord tells you that you will be evicted from your apartment or your rent must increase by $50 per month because your neighbors complain about your dog. If you agree to the increase, would the contract be void or voidable under the theory of duress? 13-20

Editor's Notes

  1. Cabot Corporation v. AVX Corporation is a case example of ratification.
  2. Concealment example: if Summers offers his house for sale and paints the ceilings to conceal the fact that the roof leaks, his active concealment constitutes an assertion of fact Nondisclosure differs from concealment in that concealment involves the active hiding of a fact, while nondisclosure is the failure to volunteer information
  3. Problem with justifiable reliance element is identifying the extent to which the relying party is responsible for investigating the accuracy of the statement on which he relies. Section 172 of the Restatement, which provides that a relying party’s failure to discover facts before entering the contract does not make his reliance unjustifiable unless his fault was too extreme. Most courts place a greater degree of accountability on the person who makes the assertion rather than the person who relies on the assertion.
  4. The hyperlink is to the Circuit Court’s opinion on the Findlaw.com website. The photo is of a dun stallion (though a mustang rather than a Quarter Horse). The plaintiffs did some due diligence, checking status of ownership of the horse with the trainer and the American Quarter Horse Association, but did not check Uniform Commercial Code filings.
  5. Hyperlink is to the Colorado Supreme Court’s opinion in pdf. Court: “In short, the record demonstrates that Brooks did not seek an agreement through conscious ignorance. Rather, the record shows that he sought further dialogue because he knew of the discrepancy in the parties’ calculations. In our view, plaintiffs’ efforts to exploit Goodyear’s obvious mathematical or clerical error, thereby obtaining a windfall of over $550,000, were clearly inequitable. For these reasons, we hold that even if Brooks’s November 2, 2006, e-mail and charts could be characterized as an offer and that offer was accepted, Goodyear may properly avoid the resulting agreement on the facts presented here.”
  6. Reasonable Alternative Example: Barry, a traveling salesman, takes his car to Cheatum Motors for repair. Barry pays Cheatum the full amount previously agreed upon for the repair, but Cheatum refuses to return Barry’s car to him unless Barry agrees to pay substantially more than the contract price for the repairs. Because of his urgent need for the return of his car, Barry agrees to do this. In this case, Barry technically had the alternative of filing a legal action to recover his car. However, this would not be a reasonable alternative for someone who needs the car urgently because of the time, expense, and uncertainty involved in pursuing a lawsuit. Thus, Barry could avoid his agreement to pay more money under a theory of duress.
  7. AVX Corporation manufactures capacitors for electronic products. Tantalum, an elemental metal as rare in nature as uranium, is used in the manufacture of AVX’s products. Cabot Corporation is a major supplier of tantalum powder and wire and supplied AVX with tantalum products for many years. During volatile market, AVX purchased tantalum from Cabot at preferable prices without entering binding, long-term contracts. In 2000, a shortage of tantalum developed and In August 2000, Cabot notified all of its customers that, in the future, it proposed to commit its limited production capacity to those customers who were prepared to enter into binding, long-term supply contracts. Between August and November 2000, Cabot and AVX negotiated the terms of a binding, long-term supply contract. Both parties were represented by highly competent legal counsel throughout the process. Cabot and AVX memorialized the terms of a basic agreement to a binding, five-year contract, under which AVX would purchase specified quantities of tantalum powder and wire at stated prices. The prices agreed to were no higher than the then-current market prices for tantalum products. Cabot agreed to AVX’s demand of “most favored customer” protection. In addition, the parties agreed that the agreement would supersede all prior agreements (including the letters of intent) and released each other from all claims arising under any prior agreements. In July 2002, more than 20 months after the supply contract was negotiated, and more than 18 months after it was signed, AVX filed an action against Cabot in federal court. AVX alleged that the 2000 letters of intent were binding contracts and that the supply contract was void because it had been executed by AVX under economic duress. This action was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. Cabot then filed an action for a declaratory judgment, seeking a declaration that the supply contract was a valid and binding contract, and that the 2000 letters of intent were not binding contracts, and were, in any event, superseded by the supply contract. In its answer, AVX asserted economic duress with regard to the supply contract, and filed various counterclaims. Cabot filed a motion for partial summary judgment, which the trial court granted. AVX appealed.
  8. Court: “Even if we were to conclude that material facts regarding the existence of economic duress remain in dispute, Cabot nonetheless would be entitled to summary judgment because AVX ratified the contract by its actions. A contract that is voidable for duress may be ratified and affirmed. A party must complain promptly of coercive acts that allegedly forced it into the contract or the defense of duress is waived, and the contract ratified. The requirement that the party claiming duress disclaim the contract or release about which he is complaining promptly or be held to have forfeited his right to do so protects the stability and reliability of such agreements by denying the weaker party the “heads I win, tails you lose” option of waiting to see how the arrangement works out and then deciding whether to seek to undo it…. The supply agreement was executed in January 2001, and the first time AVX asserted duress was in July 2002. This lengthy period of silence is powerful (if not conclusive) evidence of ratification.” Lesson : If you’re going to complain about something, get to court and resolve the situation or forget it and move on!
  9. Undue influence is common in familial relationships with regard to wills and trusts.
  10. False. The contract is voidable at the option of the person pressured. True. True. False. Unlike duress, pressure is exerted through persuasion rather than coercion .
  11. The correct answer is (e). If the assertion was knowingly made, the misrepresentation would be fraudulent rather than innocent.
  12. The correct answer is (c).
  13. Good question since the answer may vary from state to state. Also, it might depend on whether the landlord knew about the dog and required a security deposit at the lease beginning. Most states, however, would hold that you have reasonable alternatives, thus duress has not occurred. Of course, this raises the issue of policy and lawmaking since laws in some states protect commercial interests (e.g., landlords) more than consumer interests (e.g., tenants).