Students in higher education enter class with varying degrees of social media experience, skill, and comfort. Traditional age students that grew up with technology, often called “digital natives” (Prensky) use the Internet and social media with the same facility their instructors have navigating the Dewey Decimal system. However, these same students bring a sense of infallibility regarding online safety and privacy. Nontraditional-aged students possess diverse Internet-usage skill sets, but I have found them to be more aware of privacy issues. In three years of teaching social media, I have yet to meet a student who’s actually read Facebook’s privacy policy.