Book Review: Language Planning and Education- Gibson Ferguson
1. BOOK REVIEW
LANGUAGE PLANNING AND EDUCATION
Reviewer
Rajan Poudel
M Phil (ELE)
Kathmandu University, Nepal
Rajan_pashupati@yahoo.com
0977-9842071479
2. ABOUT THE BOOK
Book: Language Planning and Education
Author: Gibson Ferguson
Europe, North America, Africa, and Asia
The global spread of English
Date of Publication: 2006
Publication: Edinburgh University Press
City: Edinburgh
3. BACKGROUND
Focuses on educational aspects of
language planning
Consists of seven chapters, followed by a
brief chapter with discussion questions and
further reading suggestions.
Claims that language planning/language
policy is an interdisciplinary field with a very
wide scope, geographically as well as
conceptually through this book.
4. CHAPTER ONE
THE DISCIPLINE OF LANGUAGE PLANNING: A HISTORICAL
OVERVIEW
establishes the language planning is one of the pertinent
issues in academia,
talks about the sudden rebirth of language planning and
policy at the beginning of the twenty first century,
provides a historical overview of developments within
the discipline over the last fifty years,
views the ideological reorientations in the discipline
includes a widening scope like top-down policy and
bottom-up processes,
Finally, this chapter discusses the language planning is
a more interdisciplinary approach that takes account of
political, social, economic and ideological dimensions.
5. CHAPTER TWO
THE PRACTICE OF LANGUAGE PLANNING: AN OVERVIEW OF KEY
CONCEPTS
introduces more constructivist view of nations as
imagined communities and national standard
languages as ideological constructs
discusses the key concepts of the discipline;
corpus and status planning,
standardization,
codification and
linguistic purism.
6. CHAPTER THREE
EDUCATIONAL AND POLITICAL DIMENSIONS OF BILINGUAL
EDUCATION: THE CASE OF THE UNITED STATES
analyses the debate concerning the schooling of
language minority students in the US
gives information about different bilingual
education, political aspects, debate within the out of
school and socio-political context.
examines the major arguments based on national
unity and social justice,
concludes that the debate is not about language but
about contrasting understandings of the nature of
society and its identity.
7. CHAPTER FOUR
MINORITY LANGUAGES AND LANGUAGE REVITALIZATION
is related with the situation of minority languages in
Europe after the 1992
deals with the topics of language endangerment
and revitalization
lists out the sociological and sociolinguistic causes
of language death,
critically discusses the arguments for the
preservation of global linguistic diversity especially
ecology of language and identity arguments
Socio-political, and economic factors causes the
revival of language
8. CHAPTER FIVE
THE GLOBAL SPREAD OF ENGLISH: CAUSE, AGENCY, EFFECTS AND
POLICY RESPONSES
focuses on causes and effects of the global spread of English,
considering the impacts on other languages, cultures, and
inequalities
concentrates on an emergent theme like language policy
alone cannot contain the spread of English
issue of globalization of English and with its causes and
effects are also discussed
deconstructs Phillipson (2003) linguistic imperialism thesis as
a top-down theory of language spread which ignores the ways
in which English has been appropriated and denies agency to
speakers in the periphery.
his final assessment is “it is simple, unsatisfactory explanation
for the ongoing spread of English as a global lingua franca”
9. CHAPTER SIX
NEW ENGLISHES AND TEACHING MODELS: THE
CONTINUING DEBATE
discusses about New Englishes and norms and
models for English language teaching in the age of
global English
addresses the issues of intelligibility, identity,
practicality and acceptability, and reaches on the
conclusion
talks the distinction between spoken and written
language
evokes for alternative teaching models of English to
educate the local varieties
10. CHAPTER SEVEN
LANGUAGE EDUCATION POLICY AND THE MEDIUM OF
INSTRUCTION ISSUE IN POST-COLONIAL AFRICA
returns to the issue: the medium of instruction, and
specifically the role of pupils’ home languages in
the educational process
discusses the choice of instructional medium is the
key issue in language planning in education.
claims that it is also a highly controversial one for
the use of English and other former colonial
languages to be restricted in favor of a greater role
for particular national languages
Finally, he seems in favor of bilingual education,
medium of instruction in the bilingual country.
11. CRITICAL WRAPPING UP
criticizes to the process of globalization,
tries to empower the ethnic, minority languages
encourages the minorities and rationalizes to preserve the
cultural treasures which are the assets of human beings
one of the best book: language planning and policy
provides contextual examples which thoroughly visualizes
the particular context specific scenario.
12. MY RECOMMENDATION
It helps to minimize the current
hot and fire debate of
“Medium of instruction either
English or mother tongue” in
educational scenario or Nepali
academia