1. Paid Content
Key Executives Mega-Conference
Matt Sokoloff, Reynolds Fellow
@MattSokoloff
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
2. Paid Content Building a
Marketing
for Local Paid Content
Your Product
News Product
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
3. Paid Content Model Adoption
•In 2012 nearly half of all newspapers
surveyed charge users for content.
Source: 2012 Daily Newspaper Publishers Annual Index,
Donald W. Reynolds Journalism Institute
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
4. Tipping Point for Paid Content
•Early estimates show that more than
half of the nations dailies require users
to pay for content as of today
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
5. Smaller Papers Lead the Way
Source: 2012 Daily Newspaper Publishers Annual Index, Donald W. Reynolds Journalism Institute
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
6. Most NP Groups Adopt Paid Models
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
7. Setting the Meter
Source: 2012 Daily Newspaper Publishers Annual Index, Donald W. Reynolds Journalism Institute
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
8. No Revenue Impact
•Page Views down but sometimes
recover
•Loss usually just remnant inventory
•Shifting sold inventory may have
been required
•Subscriptions easily make up any
difference
•No ones reported net revenue loss
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
9. Success?
•Immediate revenue needs
•Small percentage of active online
users are now subscribers (print)
•Necessary but not sufficient
•A digital paid content model
doesn’t mean you have a digital
product
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
10. Paid Content Building a
Marketing
for Local Paid Content
Your Product
News Product
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
11. Build a Digital Product
• Solve a problem and/or provide a real
benefit for your users
• Need to sell more than “All Access”
• Designate and remind users that your
content is unique
• Your newsroom isn’t representative
• Traffic doesn’t mean users will pay for it
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
12. What’s behind the wall?
• About 70% of surveyed sites are charging
for breaking news or wire stories
• Better off putting less behind the wall
but setting the meter lower
• Less than 15% charge for tablet or mobile
products
• People are more used to paying for
tablet and mobile products
Source: 2012 Daily Newspaper Publishers Annual Index,
Donald W. Reynolds Journalism Institute
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
13. Change from Page Views to Quality
•You may have lots of people on
your site but they might be the
wrong people
•Goals in the newsroom need to
change
•Build franchises and sub-brands that
you can monetize
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
14. Paid Content Matrix
Premium
Watchdog Obits
Columnist A
Community Local In Depth
News Coverage Local
Uniqueness
Columnist B Event Listings Sports
Classifieds Breaking News
Commodity
Photo Galleries
Weather
TV Listings Wire Stories
Low High
Interest
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
17. SiriusXM
• Paywall at zero
• Free Trials to get you hooked
• Premium/Exclusive content
• Commodity content with a benefit
• Tiered Pricing
• Aggressive marketing
• Understand the lifetime value of a
subscriber
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
18. Hulu+
• Show/Brand specific
• Other sites offer recent shows for free
• Hulu+
• Entire season
• All Devices
• Original Programing
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
19. Hulu+
Premium
Original Devices
Programing All Episodes
Uniqueness
Commodity
HD Recent Episodes
Low High
Interest
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
21. Premium
Consumer Reports
Ratings Guides
Uniqueness
Expert Reviews
Consumer News
Commodity
Low High
Interest
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
22. Subscription Based Sites
•ESPN Insider
•Netflix
•eHarmony
•WeightWatchers
•DailyBurn
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
23. Paid Content Building a
Marketing
for Local Paid Content
Your Product
News Product
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
24. Tiered Approach — Chicago Tribune
• Non-subscriber - Commodity
content
• DigitalLITE (free registration) -
Metered premium content
• DigitalPlus (paid) - Access to
all premium content, apps,
achieves, e-books, events
• Built a funnel to paid
subscriber
• Capturing e-mail on
prospects
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
25. E-Commerce Funnel
Branding/
Prospecting
Awareness
Consideration
Intent
Purchase
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
26. Awareness
• Drive to landing page
• On site messaging
• Icons for exclusive
content
• Designating paid users in
comments
• Promote content behind
the Pay Wall
• Paid online ads (monitor
CPA)
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
27. Consideration
• Drive to checkout
• Expressed
interest...convince them
to purchase
• Landing page MUST
match how they got there
• Ad creative
• Content type
• Online Display Re-
marketing
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
28. Landing Page
Optimization
•Tease content
•Benefits clearly
explained
•Signup ATF
•No navigation
•A/B test and track
everything
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
29. Intent
• Drive to purchase
• Make it easy
• Capture e-mail asap
• Test & Track cart abandonment
• Re-marketing and e-mail follow
up
• Lowest CPA
• Remind them what they are
getting
• Only as good as the weakest link
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
30. Smart Prospecting
•Drive new users to your site who will
eventually subscribe
•Market to lookalike purchasers
•Find users who don’t regularly visit
•Track everything
•Determine the best entry point
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
31. Metrics to track
•Lifetime Value of a Subscriber (LTV)
— Crucial number to determine how
much money you can spend
acquiring members
•Cost Per Acquisition (CPA) — Ensure
that CPA stays below LTV.
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
32. Metrics Cont.
• Conversion Rate
• Overall, landing page, traffic source,
marketing campaign, demographic
• Useful for
• Setting newsroom and marketing
goals
• Understanding what content to put
behind the wall
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
33. Invest in Technology, People & Ideas
• Technology — Build, buy or partner to test,
track and manage the relationship with
your customers
• People — Invest in people internally and
externally who are focused on growing
your digital subscription products
• Ideas — The fourth most serious threat to
newspapers according to publishers is lack
of resources to develop new products (only
after declining ad revenue, circulation,
print readership)
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
34. RJI’s Efforts
•Marketing Case Studies
•Paid Content Best Practices and
Guides
•Paid Content Research and
Database
•RJIOnline.org
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
35. Matt Sokoloff
SokoloffM@RJIOnline.org
@MattSokoloff
University of Missouri Missouri School of Journalism
Notas do Editor
Time based - Free for specific amount of time
Start as if you are building a new product...you are
Interest based on UVs Uniqueness based on Conversion Rate of landing pages Can dive in deeper Add dimension of Cost/ROI Potential
9 hours a month for free offer?
If they won ’ t give an e-mail to look at 5 stories/month would they ever pay?
sigup, subscribe free trial
Maybe people from facebook links never convert but twitter does
Increase LTV - e-mail offerings, phone call, publisher letter, test what works Decrease CPA - Understand what is effective eliminate what isn ’ t Think digital - Rack cards, newspaper inserts won ’ t cut it Conversion Rates should help set goals
Print vs. online advertising commission problem If everyone is focused on growing print subscribers then that ’ s what will happen