This program will present a new model of strategic planning for nonprofits that is designed to assist you in discovering and inventing new, creative ways of going about your work so you can make a breakthrough Mission Impact for those you serve. Learn what makes companies like Google so innovative and how you can use these same ideas in a nonprofit.
Unlocking Productivity and Personal Growth through the Importance-Urgency Matrix
2016-06-21 Breakthrough Strategy for Nonprofits
1. Thrive. Grow. Achieve.
June 21, 2016
Dr. Rob Sheehan, Robert H. Smith School of
Business at the University of Maryland
Breakthrough
Strategy for
Nonprofits
3. ABOUT
ROB SHEEHAN
*Robert H. Smith School of
Business, University of
Maryland
Academic Director, Executive MBA
Program
*Center for Philanthropy &
Nonprofit Leadership, UMD
*Sheehan Nonprofit Consulting
Strategy, Leadership, Teamwork 3
4. ABOUT
ROB SHEEHAN
Ph.D., The Ohio State University
College of Business
School of Public Policy &
Management
Organization Development,
Leadership, Organization
Effectiveness
Published Researcher
4
5. ABOUT
ROB SHEEHAN
CEO, 18 years, Two National
Nonprofits
AΣΦ Educational Foundation,
1981-1990
LeaderShape, Inc., 1992-2001
CFRE (Certified Fund Raising
Executive), 1986-2004
5
10. “INNOVATE
OR DIE”
“We’re in an environment
where its innovate or die.”
-Amelia Franck Meyer
CEO, Anu Family Services,
Hudson, WI
The Chronicle of Philanthropy
10
11. BREAKTHROUGH
STRATEGY
The intention of the Breakthrough
Strategy approach is to drive
higher levels of innovation and
creativity throughout an
organization to it increases its
Mission Impact.
11
12. DESIGN
FOR TODAY
To provide you with a “taste” of
the Breakthrough Strategy
approach
To demonstrate ideas on how you
can generate more innovation and
creativity in your organization
12
14. NEW PATTERNS
OF THOUGHT
“The problems we face cannot be
solved using the same patterns of
thought that were used to create
them.”
- Albert Einstein
14
15. BEING
UNREASONABLE
“The reasonable man adapts himself
to the world; the unreasonable one
persists in attempting to adapt the
world to himself. Therefore, all
progress depends on the
unreasonable man.”
- George Bernard Shaw
15
16. THE IMPORTANCE
OF LEADERSHIP
Nothing we discuss today can be
successfully utilized within an
organization without effective
quality leadership.
Ethical, Inclusive, Authentic,
Empowering
Contributes toward building a
more just, equitable and thriving
society
16
17. STRATEGY
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
Establish Mission Gap
Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Creating Vision
Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Setting Strategic Stretch Goals
Discern SWOTs
Create Strategy Narrative
17
18. THE BREAKTHROUGH
STRATEGY WORKBOOK
A guide for strategy development that
follows the Mission Impact process.
Multiple copies may be downloaded at
no cost from web site:
www.SheehanNonprofitConsulting.com
Other Sheehan articles may also be
downloaded at no cost (see pp. 30-31).
An example of the final output from a
strategy development process is
included on pp. 22 – 28.
18
21. “MISSION
GAP”
Imagine what the world would look
like if you were accomplishing your
mission 100%.
Compare that to the way the world
really looks like today.
The difference between the two is
your “Mission Gap.”
21
22. MERRILL COUNTY
LITERACY COUNCIL
Mission
To assure that all adults age 16 or
older in Merrill County are literate.
Mission Accomplishment Measure
The literacy rate in Merrill County, as
reported by county officials.
22
29. ASPIRATIONAL
VISIONING
Dream with no constraints
Create an Ideal “Future Picture” based
on what is Inspirational and Drives
Passion
Create New Internal Capabilities
Search Environment for Opportunity
29
30. DREAM
“Some men see things as they are and
say ‘why,’ I dream things that never
were and say ‘why not.’”
- George Bernard Shaw
30
31. CHANGING
THE WORLD
“Because the people who are crazy
enough to think they can change the
world are the ones who do.”
-Steve Jobs
31
32. DIVINE
MADNESS
“Let us build such a church that those who
come after us will think we were madmen’,
said the old canon of Seville . . . Perhaps
through every mind passes some such
thought, when it entertains the design of a
great and seemingly impossible action . . .
This divine madness enters more or less
into all our noblest undertakings.”
-Longfellow
32
34. STRATEGIC
INTENT
Companies that have risen to global
leadership over the past 20 years
invariably began with ambitions that were
all out of proportion to their resources and
capabilities. But they created an
obsession with winning at all levels of the
organization . . . We call this obsession
“strategic intent.”
- Hamel & Prahalad
34
35. CREATIVE
TENSION
“the gap between vision and current
reality is also a source of energy . . .
the gap is the source of creative
energy. We call this gap creative
tension.”
- Peter Senge
35
36. VISION
With your current environment in mind –
including your “mission gap” – think
about how you could make “quantum
leap” progress on your “mission gap” if
your organization existed in an “ideal
state.” Answer the question:
“If you could have it any way you wanted
it, what would your organization be
like?” Describe it in detail.
36
39. Why dream a vision that
can never come true?
39
40. VISION
Visions give us something to aspire to.
Visions can inspire others to help make
dreams come true.
Visions provide meaning to the “day to
day.”
40
44. LEADING
INNOVATION
“The role of a leader of innovation is
not to set a vision and motivate others
to follow it. It’s to create a community
that is willing and able to innovate.”
Collective Genius
Harvard Business Review, June, 2014
44
45. WHAT
FOLLOWERS WANT
“Constituents want visions of the future
that reflect their own aspirations.
They want to hear how their dreams
will come true and their hopes will be
fulfilled . . . The only visions that take
hold are shared visions . . . And you
will create them only when you listen
very, very closely to others,
appreciate their hopes, and attend to
their needs.”
-Kouzes & Posner, 2009
45
46. STRATEGY
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
✔ Establish Mission Gap
✔ Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Creating Vision
Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Setting Strategic Stretch Goals
Discern SWOTs
Create Strategy Narrative
46
54. ATTAINABLE
GOALS
What might be the downside of
setting goals that are reasonably
“Attainable?”
Goal research:
The more difficult the goal, the higher
the level of performance.
54
57. AGGRESSIVE
YET ACHIEVABLE
Allows you to maximize
performance, but with a higher
chance of failure
If you are a boss & you want to use
Aggressive goals, check your
rewards system. If you punish
failure, people will not want to be
aggressive. Reward “performance”
vs. goal accomplishment
57
59. ATTAINABLE
GOALS
Best when the priority is to
accurately predict performance of the
current system
Good for generating “quick wins”
Good for Learning Goals in new
domains
Good for a team that needs to build
confidence
59
60. AGGRESSIVE
GOALS
Best when the priority is to maximize
the performance of the current
system
Maximize intensity of effort
Maximize persistence
Performance vs Goal Attainment
must be rewarded
60
61. SMART
GOALS
Think of a goal that you are
currently working on and write
it so it fits the “SMART”
guidelines.
61
62. A NEW ‘A’
FOR SMART*
Specific
Measurable
*Almost Impossible
Relevant
Time-bound
*Rob Sheehan version
62
64. IMPOSSIBLE . . .
“Space travel is utter bilge.”
- Sir Richard Van Der Riet Wooley, The Astronomer
Royal, 1956
64
65. IMPOSSIBLE . . .
“While theoretically and technically
television may be feasible,
commercially and financially I
consider it an impossibility.”
- Lee Deforest, American Inventor (1873-1961)
65
66. IMPOSSIBLE . . .
“Well informed people know it is
impossible to transmit the voice
over wires and that were it
possible to do so, the thing
would be of no practical value.”
- The Boston Post, Editorial, 1865
66
67. IMPOSSIBLE . . .
“We must not be misled to our
own detriment to assume that
the untried machine can displace
the proved and tried horse.”
- Maj. Gen. John Kerr, U.S. Army (1878-1955)
67
68. IMPOSSIBLE . . .
“Rail travel at high speeds is not
possible because passengers,
unable to breathe, would die of
asphyxia.”
- Dionysius Lardner, English Scientist
(1793-1859)
68
69. BULLET TRAIN
THINKING
It used to take more than six hours to travel by
train from Tokyo to Osaka. If the Japanese
executives had said to their engineers: “I want you
to reduce the time to six hours,” the engineers
would have instinctively thought in terms of small
improvements, perhaps in the way they boarded
passengers and unloaded baggage. But instead,
the Japanese executives set out a challenge to
reduce the time of the journey to three and a half
hours. Faced with such an “impossible” goal, the
engineers and designers were forced to reexamine
the most fundamental assumptions governing rail
travel in Japan. The result of this reexamination was
the bullet train. (Jack Welch) 69
70. TRADITIONAL ANALYTICAL
GOALS
“This is a forecast of the result we should be
able to produce if we work hard at it.”
ASPIRATIONAL STRETCH
GOALS
“This is the very best result we can
imagine possible (1% chance) and we
have no idea how to make it happen.”
70
72. STRETCH
GOALS
You use stretch goals, they don’t use
you. They do not exist to dominate
you and stress you out. They exist
to give you something to shoot for, to
have fun trying to see if you can
make it.
72
73. STRETCH
GOALS
“The most fun game is one
you’ve never played and
your inventing as you go
along.”
Jerry Seinfeld
Fast Company, June 2014
73
74. STRETCH
GOALS
Fully achieving a stretch goal is not
the main focus of your attention.
You are interested in being creative,
progress, and learning.
74
75. THE MOON SHOT
vs CANCER
1961: President Kennedy sets the
goal to send a man to the moon and
return him safely by the end of the
decade.
1970: Congress passes a resolution
to cure cancer by 1976 as a fitting
celebration for the bicentennial.
75
76. STRETCH
GOALS
You need to create a “safe-fail”
situation with a stretch goal. You
can’t treat failure as an issue. You
have to play.
76
77. SAFE - FAIL
ENVIRONMENT
“‘The fastest way to succeed, IBM’s
Thomas Watson, Sr., once said, ‘is to
double your failure rate.’ In recent years,
more executives have embraced this point
of view, coming to understand that failure
is a prerequisite to invention. A business
cannot develop a breakthrough product or
process if it is not willing to encourage
risk-taking and learn from subsequent
mistakes.”
The Failure Tolerant Leader
Harvard Business Review, 2002 77
79. STRETCH
GOALS
You have to set your own boundaries
on resources you will use to achieve
the goal—including the amount of
time you spend on it. Make this all
part of the “game.” Otherwise, you
stress out and/or turn your 70 hour
weeks into 90 hour weeks.
79
81. STRETCH
GOALS
Since the prospects of failing at the
stretch goal are high and failure at
some goals can have real life
implications—when you set a stretch
goal, ask yourself “Am I willing to live
with the worst probable outcome?”
If not, don’t set it that high.
81
82. STRATEGIC
INTENT
“Creating stretch, a misfit between
resources and aspirations, is the
single most important task senior
management faces.”
-Gary Hamel & C.K. Prahalad
82
83. THE WALL
STREET JOURNAL
“Stretch is a concept that would have
produced smirks, if not laughter, in
the GE of three or four years ago,
because it essentially means using
dreams to set business targets – with
no real idea of how to get there . . . .
If you do know how to get there then
it is not a stretch target.”
-Jack Welch, March 8, 1994
83
84. START WITH
THE END IN MIND
*When brainstorming new ways to
go about accomplishing a goal,
“start with the end in mind.”
Imagine you have already
accomplished the goal and
discern what new ideas you
must have used to do that.
84
85. STRATEGIC STRETCH
GOALS
Set five Strategic Stretch Goals for
the next five years which:
Inspire you!!!
Would catapult your organization
toward your vision and help close your
Mission Gap most effectively
Meet the Almost Impossible SMART
criteria
85
86. CHALLENGES WITH
STRETCH GOALS
Everyone else operates on the
forecasting mindset so you have to
be careful about with whom you
share your stretch goals.
86
87. CHALLENGES WITH
STRETCH GOALS
You may fall back into the old
mindset and get stressed or feel bad
if you fail. Watch for that.
87
88. CHALLENGES WITH
STRETCH GOALS
The stretch goal approach does not
guarantee you good creativity. It will
unleash creativity, but some creative
ideas will sound good and not work.
You need to decide when to try it again
or differently or try something else.
88
89. The biggest challenge is
setting Strategic Stretch
Goals is overcoming the Fear
of Failure that has been bred
within us.
89
90. FAILURE
We need to transform our
relationship with failure in order to
leverage the aspirational mind-set
and the power of Almost Impossible
Goals.
What is your relationship with
failure?
90
91. YOU FAILURE!!!
“I am as worthless as the slugs
who creep in the crevices of
the deepest, darkest parts of
the ocean!”
91
93. Result:
Any accomplishment of positive
magnitude
Success:
Any accomplishment which meets or
exceeds its intended result
Failure:
To fall short of an intended result
93
100. 10X
THINKING
Larry Page lives by the gospel of 10x. Most
companies would be happy to improve a product by
10 percent. Not the CEO and cofounder of Google.
The way Page sees it, a 10 percent improvement
means that you’re basically doing the same thing as
everybody else. You probably won’t fail
spectacularly, but you are guaranteed not to
succeed wildly. That’s why Page expects his
employees to create products and services that are
10 times better than the competition. Thousand-
percent improvement requires rethinking
problems entirely, exploring the edges of what’s
technically possible, and having a lot more fun in
the process. (http://www.wired.com/business/2013/01/ff-qa-larry-page/all/)100
102. FAILURE WITH
STRETCH GOALS
“Look at our results!”
“What could we have done
differently?”
“I’m glad we went for it, but I wish
we had accomplished it 100%”
102
103. FAILURE AND
CREATIVE TENSION
“Mastery of creative tension transforms the
way one views ‘failure.’ Failure is, simply,
a shortfall, evidence of the gap between
vision and current reality. Failure is an
opportunity for learning . . . Failures are
not about our unworthiness or
powerlessness.”
- Peter Senge, The Fifth Discipline
103
104. FAILURE AND
INNOVATION
“Failure is just a part of the culture
of innovation. Accept it and grow
stronger.”
- Albert Yu, SVP, Intel Corp
104
105. “The only real stumbling block is
fear of failure. In cooking, you’ve
got to have a what-the-hell
attitude.”
-Julia Child
105
106. GETTING
SMARTER FASTER
“ . . . there’s no substitute for getting
smarter faster. And the way you get
smarter is to screw around
vigorously. Try stuff. See what
works. See what fails miserably.
Learn. Rinse. Repeat.”
- Tom Peters, Fast Company, December 2001
106
107. THE POWER
OF GOALS
*Free Article: The Power of Goals
*Read & Share the Link with others:
www.sheehannonprofitconsulting.
com/PowerOfGoals/
107
108. STRATEGY
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
✔ Establish Mission Gap
✔ Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Creating Vision
✔ Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Setting Strategic Stretch Goals
Discern SWOTs
Create Strategy Narrative
108
110. STRENGTHS &
WEAKNESSES
Better to use systematic tools rather
than just asking “what do you think
are our strengths & weaknesses?”
Use “systems thinking” as you
assess the organization.
110
111. VENTURE PHILANTHROPY PARTNERS
CAPACITY FRAMEWORK
ELEMENTS
Aspirations
Strategy
Organizational
Skills
Human
Resources
Systems and
Infrastructure
Organizational
Structure
Culture
111
113. YOUR
SWOTs
Given your vision and commitment to
achieve the strategic stretch goals,
what are the key strengths of your
organization?
Weaknesses?
Opportunities?
External threats?
113
114. STRATEGY
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
✔ Establish Mission Gap
✔ Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Creating Vision
✔ Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Setting Strategic Stretch Goals
✔ Discern SWOTs
Create Strategy Narrative
114
116. WHAT IS
STRATEGY?
Strategy is more than strategic
planning
Strategy is not just a collection of
goals and budget forecasts
Most organizations have plenty of
plans, but very little strategy
Strategy is an integrated and coherent
cause & effect performance story which
has a beginning, middle, and end.
116
117. WHAT IS
STRATEGY?
Strategy is an integrated and coherent
explanation of how an organization is
going to guide its performance in the
future.
117
118. NONPROFIT
STRATEGY
The purpose of having a strategy is
to guide the organization toward its
desired future.
Crafting strategy is a creative act, not
an analytical function. It is a process
of creating the organization’s desired
future, considering its current
situation, and designing a set of
actions which will catapult it forward.
118
119. NONPROFIT
STRATEGY
The “cause & effect performance story”
tells how you will get from “here to
there” while . . .
. . . Leveraging your Strengths,
Fortifying your Weaknesses, Seizing
your Opportunities, and Blocking
your Threats.
119
121. WHAT IS YOUR
STRATEGY “TUNE?”
A strategy does not tell you what
actions to take in the fourth week of
the second quarter of the third year
of the strategy any more than a jazz
tune tells musicians what exact notes
to play three-quarters through the
song. They know the tune to follow.
Everyone in the organization should
know the strategy as well as they
can recognize a popular tune. 121
122. STRATEGY
NARRATIVE
A Strategy Narrative is a three – four
paragraph summary explanation of
the organization’s strategy.
Most organizations – in all sectors
cannot articulate their strategy with a
simple coherent statement.
As you design strategy, remember to
think of the organization as a
“system” of funding, staff, programs.
122
123. STRATEGY
NARRATIVE
“Leaders of firms are mystified when what
they thought was a beautifully crafted
strategy is never implemented. . . .
They fail to appreciate the necessity of
having a simple, clear, succinct
strategy statement that everyone can
internalize and use as a guiding light for
making difficult choices.”
- D. J. Collins & M. G. Rukstad
Harvard Business Review, 2008
123
125. STRATEGY
DEVELOPMENT
Review each of your SWOTs and explain
what “Strategic Actions” you should take
regarding it.
A Strategic Action is one which will help
catapult the organization toward the
accomplish of the goals, vision, and mission.
Leverage your Strengths, Fortify your
Weaknesses, Seize your Opportunities, and
Block your Threats.
These build the “themes” of your Strategy
Narrative
125
127. EVALUATE WEAKNESSES
AND THREATS
Look at interactions of Weaknesses
and Threats for necessary “damage
control”
Evaluate all Weaknesses and Threats
Look at interactions of Weaknesses
and Threats with Strengths for possible
solutions
Fortify Weaknesses as necessary and
Block relevant Threats
127
128. LOOK FOR
LEVERAGE &
OPPORTUNITY
Focus on the Strategic Stretch Goals
What can you use from the current
reality and SWOTs to catapult
forward?
Look at interactions of Strengths and
Opportunities and other Strengths
and Opportunities for ideas
128
129. STRATEGY
NARRATIVE
A cause & effect performance story
with a beginning, middle, and end
The General speaks:
“First, we are going to…then
some of you will…which will
then allow others of us
to…and that will give us the
opening to…which will lead
us on to victory.”
129
133. STRATEGY
NARRATIVE
Make sure Weaknesses and Threats
are addressed first so organization is
stable enough to move forward
Be sure to have strong levers
Integrate and balance actions in
funding, staffing, programs/services
133
134. STRATEGY
DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
✔ Establish Mission Gap
✔ Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Creating Vision
✔ Adopt Aspirational Mindset for
Setting Strategic Stretch Goals
✔ Discern SWOTs
✔ Create Strategy Narrative
134
135. “SO WHAT”
MINUTE
What three things will you do during
the next week to apply some of the
ideas we have discussed today?
135
136. “SO WHAT”
MINUTE
Design a new strategic planning
process
Use the next staff meeting to
brainstorm a vision for your
organization “if you could have it any
way you wanted it.”
136
137. “SO WHAT”
MINUTE
Review all of your goals and make
sure they are SMART.
Distribute the VPP Organization
Capacity Assessment Tool to
everyone on staff to identify capacity
building opportunities.
Share your key learnings with others
at your next staff or Board meeting
137
138. THE BLOG
Check it out:
http://strategyleadershipmissionimpa
ct.blogspot.com/
Email me if you want on the
distribution list:
RobSheehan@aol.com
138
139. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH!!!
For your leadership!
For your commitment!!
For the difference you make!!!
139
140. Robert M. Sheehan, Jr., Ph.D.
Principal
Sheehan Nonprofit Consulting
301.523.1864
RobSheehan@aol.com
www.SheehanNonprofitConsulting.com
@SheehanImpact
FOR MORE
INFORMATION
140
141. THE SEVEN DEADLY SINS OF
NONPROFIT STRATEGY
#1: “It’s Just Sitting on the Shelf.” The
rest of the sins are not necessarily in
order of severity, but this is clearly #1
because it is so pervasive and
represents a huge waste of money and
time – from staff and volunteers. This
sin can be deadly, indeed, when board
members realize the hours they have
wasted – making strategic plans that are
never implemented. And for the
attorneys on your Board, those are
billable hours. 141
142. THE SEVEN DEADLY SINS OF
NONPROFIT STRATEGY
#2: Insular Mountaintop Planning. It
can be good for a strategy planning
group to go to the “mountains” to get
away from distractions to do work
together. But, before you go, gather
input regarding the organization’s future
from stakeholders – and check in with
them when you get back for more input
before you publish and laminate the
plan (Peter Block calls this error
“leadership by lamination”).
142
143. THE SEVEN DEADLY SINS OF
NONPROFIT STRATEGY
#3: Over-Emphasis on Fund-Raising.
“What?!?” “Impossible!” I can just hear
my fund-raising colleagues’ reaction. Of
course we frequently find new fund-
raising initiatives as a part of a new
strategy. The problem is that as these
efforts are highlighted, other important
aspects of a strategy are under-
emphasized – such as program
innovation, leadership succession,
strategic partnerships, and more.
143
144. THE SEVEN DEADLY SINS OF
NONPROFIT STRATEGY
#4: Too Rushed. Rather than rushing
(e.g., “We are doing our strategic plan at
an all day retreat two weeks from
Friday, are you available?”), it is wiser to
take the time to thoughtfully design and
implement a strategy development
process. Of course, it should not take
forever either. Taking the time can lead
to inspiring visions, innovative
strategies, and empowered
stakeholders – which produce higher
performance. 144
145. THE SEVEN DEADLY SINS OF
NONPROFIT STRATEGY
#5: Lots of Plans, No Strategy.
Strategic planning documents can
contain volumes of plans, activities, and
environmental analysis – but many don’t
include a real “strategy.” A true strategy
articulates the dynamic levers which will
catapult an organization toward its
desired future, as well as how its key
operational areas will interact to create a
cycle of higher performance.
145
146. THE SEVEN DEADLY SINS OF
NONPROFIT STRATEGY
#6: No Annual Review. No one can see
into the future when developing a
strategic plan! So, we make certain
measured assumptions about the future
– including changes in our internal and
external environments. An annual
review of assumptions and results is
important to keep the plan relevant.
You may not change your mission or
vision, but you may need to change
plans and activities.
146
147. THE SEVEN DEADLY SINS OF
NONPROFIT STRATEGY
#7: Not Ambitious Enough. A strategy
and its associated goals and plans
should be focused on a vision that is
big, bold, and inspiring. Many strategic
plans are based simply on an analytical
forecast of the way things are currently
headed. How dull. It was Goethe who
said “Dream no small dreams for they
have no power to move the hearts of
men” and Mandela who stated “Your
playing small does not serve the world.”
147