Presentation at the 2016 UAE ORCID Workshop held at the American University of Sharjah (6 March 2016)

1. +
The Power of ORCID with
Metrics
Philip Purnell
Director – Research Services
American University of Sharjah, UAE
March, 2016

2. +
Citation impact
Who are you?

3. +
Citation impact
Who are you?

4. +
Citation impact
Journal Impact Factor
2014 Journal
Impact Factor
201420132012
Source paper – published in 2014
Cited reference – published in 2013 or 2012
Citations
All
Previous
Years
2011 2015

5. +
Citation impact
Journal Impact Factor
There are many uncited papers
published in even the highest
impact factor journals …

6. +
Citation impact
Journal Impact Factor
… and conversely many highly
cited papers in low impact factor
journals

7. +
Citation impact
Appropriate level of aggregation

8. +
Citation impact
University rankings
n AUS citations 2010 – 2015 / Global citations 2010 – 2015
n AUS papers 2010 – 2014 / Global papers 2010 - 2014

9. +
Citation impact
Individual researchers
Paper 1 6
Paper 2 4
Paper 3 4
Paper 4 3
Paper 5 1
Paper 6 1
Paper 7 1
Paper 8 0
Paper 9 0
Paper 10 0
Total Cita)ons 20
Cita)ons per Paper 2
Paper 1 200
Paper 2 6
Paper 3 4
Paper 4 4
Paper 5 3
Paper 6 1
Paper 7 1
Paper 8 1
Paper 9 0
Paper 10 0
Paper 11 0
Total Cita)ons 220
Cita)ons per Paper 20

10. +
Citation impact
Individual researchers

11. +
Citation impact
Individual researchers
11
Jorge E. Hirsch

12. +
Citation impact
Individual researchers
Paper 1 6
Paper 2 4
Paper 3 4
Paper 4 3
Paper 5 1
Paper 6 1
Paper 7 1
Paper 8 0
Paper 9 0
Paper 10 0
Total Cita)ons 20
Cita)ons per Paper 2
H-Index 3
Paper 1 200
Paper 2 6
Paper 3 4
Paper 4 4
Paper 5 3
Paper 6 1
Paper 7 1
Paper 8 1
Paper 9 0
Paper 10 0
Paper 11 0
Total Cita)ons 220
Cita)ons per Paper 20
H-Index 4

13. +
Citation impact
Individual researchers
Jorge E. Hirsch

14. +
Normalised article-level indicators
14
What is the impact of
this paper?

15. +
Normalised article-level indicators
15
Finding a suitable benchmark …
… normalised for subject category
(field), publication year, document
type

16. +
Normalised article-level indicators
16

17. +
Normalised article-level indicators
17
Journal expected citations = 10.48
Journal Normalised Citation Impact
= 20 / 10.48 = 1.91

18. +
Normalised article-level indicators
This paper has received
45/16.74 = 2.69 times the
expected citations for this
subject category
This paper has received
45/21.48 = 2.09 times the
expected citations for this
journal
Integrative &
Complementary Medicine
articles from 2005 have
been cited 16.74 times
Articles published
in this journal from
2005 have been
cited 21.48 times

19. +
Normalised article-level indicators
Researcher indicators
Computer
Science
Medicine

20. +
Bibliometric Indicators
Desired a:ribute Indicator InCites SciVal CWTS
Produc5vity
Number of outputs in a defined 5me
period
Web of Science Documents Scholarly Output P
Influence
Cita5ons accrued to a body of papers in a
defined 5me period
Times Cited Cita5on Count TCS
Influence
Propor5on of papers that have been cited
at least once
% Document Cited
Impact Average cita5ons per paper Cita5on Impact Cita5ons Per Publica5on MCS
Influence and impact Healthy propor5on of cited papers h-index h-index
Impact normalised by field
Mean cita5on average divided by field
mean
Category Normalized
Cita5on Impact
Field-Weighted Cita5on
Impact
MNCS
Impact normalised by journal
Mean cita5on average divided by journal
mean
Journal Normalized Cita5on
Impact
MNJS
Journal impact Ra5o of cita5ons to size of journal Journal Impact Factor SNIP
High impact papers
Papers cited in top 10% for their field and
5me period
% Documents in Top 10% Outputs in Top Percen5les PP(Top10%)
Notable papers
Papers cited in top 1% for their field and
5me period
% Documents in Top 1% Outputs in Top Percen5les PP(Top1%)
Notable papers
Papers cited in top 1% for their field and
5me period
% Highly Cited Papers Outputs in Top Percen5les
Outstanding papers
Papers cited in top 0.1% for their field and
5me period
% Hot Papers Outputs in Top Percen5les
Interna5onal collabora5on
Propor5on of papers that feature a co-
author from another country
% Interna5onal
Collabora5ons
Collabora5on Impact
Industry collabora5on
Propor5on of academic papers that
feature an industry co-author
% Industry Collabora5ons
Academic-Corporate
Collabora5on Impact

21. +
Citation impact
Research groups
Researcher A
AUS
Immunology dept
ORCID:
0123-1234-2345-3456
Researcher B
UAE Univ
Immunology dept
ORCID:
0011-2233-4455-6677
Researcher D
Qatar Univ
Immunology dept
ORCID:
1122-3344-5566-7788
Researcher F
AUS
Immunology dept
ORCID:
2233-4455-6677-8899
Researcher E
UAE Univ
Immunology dept
ORCID:
2345-3456-4567-5678
Researcher C
AUS
Biochemistry dept
ORCID:
1234-2345-3456-4567

22. +
Citation impact
Who are you?