Synthetic Pyrethroids are widely used insecticides with wide range from applications apart from agricultural, like household insecticides, veterinary use and medicinal use. Presentation here covers every possible aspect right from discovery to most recent development in the field of Pyrethroids.
2. TABLE OF CONTENTS
Synthetic Pyrethroids – Discovery, Classification and Structures
o Novelty of synthetic pyrethroids
Synthesis Process
o Application of synthetic pyrethroids
Mode of action
o Mechanism of metabolism
Recent developments
o Current market
4. DISCOVERY
Pyrethroids insecticides are synthetic analogues of the naturally occurring insecticidal pyrethrins found in
extract of Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium.
J. J. Schleier & R. K. Peterson, Green Trends in Insect Control, Ch. 3, Royal Society of Chemistry, 2011, 94-13
5. TIMELINE AND CLASSIFICATION
• Hermann Staudinger and Leopold Ruzicka in the 1920sPyrethrins
• Schechter in 1949
• First non-natural pyrethroids, Allenthrin
1st Generation
• Further classified as Type1- Permethrin,
1973 Type2- Cypermethrin, 1974
2nd Generation
Dr. Bhupinder Khambay, Pyrethroids Insecticides, Pesticide Outlook,13,2002,49-54
8. STEREOCHEMISTRY- TYPE I
The 1R conformations about the cyclopropane ring are considerably more toxic than the 1S isomers.
Cis isomers
Trans isomers
9. STEREOCHEMISTRY- TYPE II
Pyrethroid Product Isomers Stereo-
chemistry
Cypermethrin Alpha 2 (1R)-cis, αS
(1S)-cis, αR
Beta 4 (1R)-cis, αS
(1S)-cis, αR
(1R)-trans, αS
(1S)-trans, αR
Cyhalothrin Lambda 2 (1R)-cis, αS
(1S)-cis, αR
Super 1 (1R)-cis, αS
Type II
All type II pyrethroids possess an additional chiral
center at the α-C with the α S conformation
considerably more toxic towards insects when
compared to the α R conformation.
*
*
*
Table: Examples of commercial product based on isomers
i. Pyrethroids, Agrochemicals Analysis Technical Note, Coresta March 2014
ii. Dr. Bhupinder Khambay, Pyrethroids Insecticides, Pesticide Outlook,13,2002,49-54
13. TOXICITY TO NON-TARGET INSECTS
Fish
Bee
i. Noritada Matsuo & Tatsuya Mori, Pyrethroids:From Chrysanthemumto Modern Industrial Insecticide, 2012, Ch.1
i. F. Antwi, V. P. Reddy, Toxicology effects of pyrethroids on non-target aquatic insects, Environmental Toxicology and Pharmacology, September 2015
Pyrethroids
LC50 Value
Carp(ppm/48 h) Daphnid(ppm/3 h)
Silafluofen >100 7.66
Etofenprox 5 40
Cycloprothrin 8 >10
Fenvalerate 0.00075 0.3
Permethrin 0.043 >10
Cyfluthrin 0.012 0.94
Tralomethrin 0.008 0.22
Fluvalinate 0.00048 0.298
Pyrethroid
Acute Oral
LD50
(μg a.i./bee )
Acute Contact
LD50 (μg
a.i./bee )
Bifenthrin 0.01 0.002
Cypermethrin 0.03 0.02
Deltamethrin 0.08 0.001
Permethrin 0.03 0.1
14. TOXICITY TO HUMANS
Technical Report, Louise Hénault-Ethier, Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment, 2016
Acute toxicity Chronic toxicity
Eye irritation Change in immunity
Mouth Ulcer Potential carcinogenicity
Irritation in nasal cavity Non-specific symptoms
Tremors Thyroid inactivity
Paraesthesia & Cutaneous
reactions
Estrogenic & anti-androgenic
activities
Coma, convulsions & Death Neurotoxicity
15. TOXICITY TO HUMANS – CASE STUDIES
Case study 1
In a single case report, a 28-year-
old man who applied some 1.5g
permethrin in cream from neck
to toe and did not wash for
about 10 hours developed severe
torticollis and inability to tilt his
head to the left. This persisted
unchanged for 24 hours and no
cause other than the pesticide
was identified.
Case study 2
Of 12 workers who
sprayed
lambda Cyhalothrin
indoors,11
complained of
nasal irritation and six
of throat irritation.
Case study 3
A 45-year-old man died 3 hours
after eating beans and cheese
prepared using Cypermethrin 10%
instead of oil. He developed
symptoms within a few minutes,
including prolonged vomiting,
tenesmus, diarrhea, convulsions,
coma.
Death followed respiratory arrest.
A. Vale, Poisoning due to Pyrethroids, Toxicological Reviews, February, 2005
16. TOXICITY TO ENVIRONMENT
Noritada Matsuo & Tatsuya Mori, Pyrethroids:From Chrysanthemumto Modern Industrial Insecticide, 2012, Ch.1
Isomerization
Homolytic cleavage
17. SYNERGISTS
Synergists are typically non toxic compounds at the dosage applied, but which enhance the toxicity
of the active pesticide ingredients.
Methylenedioxyphenyl synergists, such as piperonyl butoxide, are thought to suppress primarily
oxidative detoxification by inhibiting enzymatic action of CYP enzyme within the insect.
C. Pasa, L. Arlian, M. Morgan, R. Gunning, L. Rossiter, D. Holt, S. Walton, S. Beckham, J. McCarthy, Synergists in Pyrethroid-Resistant
Scabies Mites, PLOS journal of neglected tropical diseases, January 2009, Volume 3, Issue 1
Treatment Sensitive mites Resistant mites
Permethrin 4 15
Permethrin + PBO 4 4
Permethrin + DEF 3.5 6
Permethrin + DEM 2 3
19. SYNTHESIS OF CHRYSANTHEMIC ACID
Trans-chrysanthemic acid
First industrial process and its still used with better catalysts giving specifically 1R isomer which
has more insecticidal activity.
Professor Dr. Bernd Schaefer, Natural Products in the Chemical Industry, Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2014, 704-723
20. ISOMERIZATION OF CHRYSANTHEMIC ACID
Thionyl chloride
Lewis acid,150° to 170° C
Cis : Trans = 45:55
Cis : Trans = 18.8:81.2
Cis : Trans ratio in the product depends on Lewis acid we use.
Process for isomerization of a cyclopropane carboxylic acid, US 4008268 A, Sumitomo Chemical Company, 15 Feb 1977
21. MECHANISM OF ISOMERIZATION
Dr. Klaus Naumann, Chemistry of Plant Protection, Ch. - Synthetic Pyrethroid Insecticides: Chemistry and Patents, 1990
22. GETTING 1R ISOMER
i. MeOH, H2O
ii. Acid hydrolysis
A process for the production of 1r pyrethroid esters, WO 2003053905 A1, Syngenta Limited, Jul 3, 2003
Major
product
23. SYNTHESIS OF GAMMA CYHALOTHRIN
Three step synthesis:-
Chlorinating acid derivative
Esterification
Epimerizing the diastereoisomeric mixture
PRODUCTION PROCESS OF GAMMA-CYHALOTHRIN, Indian Patents: 219118, SYNGENTA LIMITED, Publication Date 06-Jun-2008
http://www.allindianpatents.com/patents/219118-production-process-of-gamma-cyhalothrin
(S)- α -cyano-3-phenoxybenzyl (Z)-(1R,3R)-3-(2-chloro-3,3,3-trifluoro-1-propenyl)-2,2-
dimethylcyclopropanecarboxylate
26. EPIMERIZING THE DIASTEREOISOMERIC MIXTURE
Diastereoisomeric mixture of Cyhalothrin isomers
Solvent, -10°C to 10°C Source of cyanide / tertiary amine / a
seed of gamma-Cyhalothrin
gamma-Cyhalothrin and a diastereomer ratio of 95:5.
Second and third step can be done in a single reactor without any isolation but we
need to compromise with yield.
PRODUCTION PROCESS OF GAMMA-CYHALOTHRIN, Indian Patents: 219118, SYNGENTA LIMITED, Publication Date 06-Jun-2008
http://www.allindianpatents.com/patents/219118-production-process-of-gamma-cyhalothrin
33. SYMPTOMS
Mammalian intoxication by type I pyrethroids causes symptoms characterized by tremor i.e. T-class,
exaggerated startle response, and hyperexcitability.
Intoxication by type II pyrethroids results in burrowing and pawing behavior, followed by salivation and
coarse tremor, which evolves into choreoathetosis (involuntary movement and writhing). This second
type of poisoning is referred to as CS-class.
Some pyrethroids, such as fenpropathrin and cyphenothrin can result in symptoms from both T and CS-
class, thus are called TS-class.
i. E. Wakeling, A. Neal & W. Atchison, Pesticides-Advances in Chemical and Botanical Pesticides, Ch. 3
ii. Technical Report, Louise Hénault-Ethier, Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment, 2016
34. RESISTANCE TO PYRETHROIDS
A major contributory factor is that pyrethroids exhibit cross-resistance to DDT, which is
thought to act at the same binding site on the voltage-gated sodium channel.
Resistance
Increased detoxification Target site Insensitivity
Dr. Bhupinder Khambay, Pyrethroids Insecticides, Pesticide Outlook,13,2002,49-54
37. ESTER HYDROLYSIS
Hideo Kaneko, Pyrethroids: Mammalian Metabolism and Toxicity, J. Agric. Food Chem. 2011,59,2786–2791
Trans isomer
Cis isomer
38. OXIDATION
i. Hideo Kaneko, Pyrethroids: Mammalian Metabolism and Toxicity, J. Agric. Food Chem. 2011,59,2786–2791
ii. Junshi Miyamoto, Degradation, Metabolism and Toxicity of Synthetic Pyrethroids, EHP, 1976, vol. 14,15-28
(1RS, trans)- tetramethrin
Deltamethrin
(1R, trans)- resmethrin
(1R, tans)- phenothrin
39. HYDROPHILIC CONJUGATION
Thiocynates conjugates
Sulfonic acid conjugates
Kaneko, H. Pyrethroid chemistry and metabolism, Hayes’ Handbook of Pesticide Toxicology, 3rd ed., 2010; Ch.76.
Hydrophilic conjugates are often found as glucuronides, sulfates, or amino acid conjugates. But
in few pyrethroids other conjugates are also formed like
43. DISCOVERY OF SILAFLUOFEN
High insecticidal activity and low mammalian toxicity, this compound features low fish toxicity,
chemical stability under sunlight, in the soil and under alkaline environments.
Acute oral toxicity for rat (LD50): >5,000 mg/kg
Acute dermal toxicity for rat (LD50): >5,000 mg/kg
Fish toxicity for carp (LC50 after 48 hours): >100 ppm
Y. Katsuda, Y. Minamite, and C. Vongkaluang, Development of Silafluofen-Based Termiticides in Japan and Thailand, December 2011
44. DISCOVERY OF METOFLUTHRIN
N. MATSUO, K. UJIHARA, Y. SHONO, T. IWASAKI, M. SUGANO, Discovery and Development of a Novel Pyrethroid Insecticide Metofluthrin
(SumiOne®, Eminence®), SUMITOMO KAGAKU, vol. 2005-II.
Compound Recovery rate(%)
Metofluthrin 98.2
Empenthrin 82.7
d - Allenthrin 6.9
Prallenthrin 11.2
Photo stability
Compound Culex pipiens
Adese
albopictus
Metofluthrin 0.0015 0.00047
d - Allenthrin 0.038 0.023
Prallenthrin 0.0056 0.0050
D-tetramethrin 0.0096 0.0036
permethrin 0.0028 0.0012
LD50 (μg/ female adult)
45. PROPERTIES OF METOFLUTHRIN
N. MATSUO, K. UJIHARA, Y. SHONO, T. IWASAKI, M. SUGANO, Discovery and Development of a Novel Pyrethroid Insecticide Metofluthrin
(SumiOne®, Eminence®), SUMITOMO KAGAKU, vol. 2005-II.
Efficacy
Acute toxicity to mammals
Species Route Lethal dose
Rat Oral >2000 mg/kg
Rat Dermal >2000 mg/kg
Rat Inhalation
Male: 1960 mg/m3
Female: 1080 mg/m3
Dog Oral >2000 mg/kg
Compound Conc. (%w/w) No. of mosquitoes
Pretreatment After treatment
Reduction
%
Metofluthrin 0.005 210 18 93
Transfluthrin 0.03 187 26 88
d - Allenthrin 0.3 188 27 88
47. CURRENT MARKET
Pyrethroids account for up to 17% of global insecticide sales – a market worth more than $7Bn each
year.
Extermination
Vegetal Farming
Domestic
Animal Farming
Technical Report, Louise Hénault-Ethier, Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment, 2016
http://www.foodsecurity.ac.uk/research/impact/pyrethroids.html
48. PROBLEMS FACED BY PYRETHROIDS
• Cancellation of Fenvalerate and
Esfenvalerate
Problem 1
• Increase in resistanceProblem 2
• Least commercial researchProblem 3
J. J. Schleier & R. K. Peterson, Green Trends in Insect Control, Ch. 3, Royal Society of Chemistry, 2011, 94-13
49. ALTERNATIVES TO PYRETHROIDS
Silicon dioxide provides an effective and safer control against household and pet animal
pests.
Bollcure – a biopesticides can be used on cotton.
Biopesticides derived from vegetable oil can be used in grain
protection.
Alternative to Pyrethroids are Biopesticides
A. Singh, A. Khare, A. P. Singh, Use of Vegetable Oils as Biopesticide in Grain Protection, J. of Fertilizers & Pesticides, January 25, 2012