This Keynote presentation at the 2012 Ontario Association of Social Work annual conference outlines the "digital communication power tools" for social workers and other practitioners. Speakers' notes can be toggled on or off. This file provides the Speakers Notes that accompany the slides.
Digital Communication Power Tools: Speakers Notes version
1. The Digital Communication Power Tools
Transforming Social Work Today
Ontario Association of Social Workers
Provincial Conference
November 10, 2012
Marilyn Herie PhD RSW
Invited Keynote presentation:
http://www.oasw.org/public/membership‐benefits/oasw‐conference‐2012.aspx
1
2. Marilyn Herie PhD RSW
Dr. Herie is Director of the TEACH Project, a
University of Toronto, Faculty of Medicine Certificate
Program in Cessation Counselling at the Centre for
Addiction and Mental Health, where she
incorporates distributed learning and social media in
reaching professionals from across Canada and from
over 15 disciplines. As well as being Director of the
University of Toronto's Collaborative Program in
Addiction Studies, Dr. Herie has engaged in research
and education focused on online clinical education in
social work and has taught a Masters‐level online
addictions MSW course for nearly 10 years.
http://ca.linkedin.com/pub/marilyn‐herie/39/161/945
2
3. Looking forward with a hurricane at our back
The subtitle of this talk – it is not whether to adopt or get on board with these digital
tools – it is how we will participate
This is already a reality for our profession, and the momentum is building.
7. social media collaboration e-therapy
I will focus on three general areas
8. Learning Objectives
1. Identify the digital tools that best fit your
professional objectives and needs
2. Anticipate upcoming trends and implications
for your practice
3. Access resources and tips for using these
tools to their full potential
And these three areas will address the above learning objectives.
8
12. social media collaboration e-therapy
Take a couple of minutes and reflect on what you are ALREADY doing in these three
areas
13. social media collaboration e-therapy
• Facebook • Webinar, web conference
• LinkedIn • Screenr, Vimeo
• Twitter • Online course
• YouTube • Wikis
• Wordpress, Blogger • Google+
• Pintrest, Tumblr • Twitterchat
• Stumbleupon • E‐therapy
• Reddit • Other?
What is your experience? How do these examples fit? What is missing from this list?
15. Technology Acceptance Model (TAM):
Ease of use and usefulness will predict an individual’s attitudes
towards, intention to use, and acceptance of the technology
Perceived
Usefulness
External Behaviour
Attitude Intention to use
Factors
Perceived
Ease of Use
Technology
Use
McGowan et al., 2012. Understanding the Factors That Influence the Adoption and
Meaningful Use of Social Media by Physicians to Share Medical Information. Journal
of Medical Internet Research.
I like to start with a theoretical framework, and TAM hypothesizes that time may not
be the most important predictor of technology acceptance/use by practitioners.
15
16. “It appears that the frequency of social media usage is influenced
primarily by positive attitudes toward the technology, perceiving that
the technology is easy to use, and perceiving the technology to be
useful to achieve better performance outcomes. Conversely,
factors found to be nonsignificant included
demographic variables typically perceived as
important, such as years since graduation (a proxy for age),
gender, patients seen per week (a proxy for how busy a
physician is), and type of specialty. This finding is consistent
with other studies, which have shown practice-related characteristics
to be unassociated with use of Internet-based communication
technologies.”
McGowan et al., 2012. Understanding the Factors That Influence the Adoption and
Meaningful Use of Social Media by Physicians to Share Medical Information. Journal
of Medical Internet Research.
In other words, OLD and BUSY practitioners are just as likely to use technology.
My goal in this presentation is to demystify and demonstrate the utility of some key
applications for clinical practitioners (ease of use + utility)
16
17. Personal Learning Networks (PLNs)
“A PLN is a system for lifelong learning”
Social Microblogging Social
Bookmarking Networking
News
Wikis Aggregators
Backchanelling
of conferences Professional
Profiles
Webinars Blogs
http://edudemic.com/2012/10/build-personal-learning-network/
And to consider how all of these fit together synergistically to comprise your very own
PLN
http://educateria.com/2012/10/24/personal‐learning‐networks‐plns/
17
24. 1. Choose a random person in the
audience
2. Ask their name
3. Google them
4. How many hits?
5. What comes up?
Or…when was the last time you searched yourself online?
Was there anything that surprised you in response to this activity?
25. The Paradox of Online Identity
The question is: Who controls it?
The paradox is this:
We hold ourselves back from participating in social media in order to better manage
our online identity; yet by not participating we lose control over ways of presenting
ourselves online
The majority of people already have some type of online identity regardless of personal
preference.
27. Use the Security Settings
• Be judicious
• But remember that you are probably more
visible than you think
• Do an online search of yourself – regularly
• Ask an expert (teenager) for help!
But, determine your own individual privacy threshold, and take steps to ensure that
you understand and use the security settings among the various tools/applications.
28. • Facebook • Slideshare
• LinkedIn • Pinterest
• Google+ • Stumbleupon
• Twitter • Screenr
• YouTube
Let’s look at these select applications, keeping in mind that this represents only a
fraction of what is out there.
29. JOURNAL OF CONTINUING EDUCATION IN THE HEALTH PROFESSIONS,
31(3):215–219, 2011
Medicine and Medical education are frontrunners in research and publications on
social media applications
32. A 15 year old’s perspective…
• Facebook:
“There’s a lot of ads but it’s really good”
• LinkedIn:
“Nobody uses LinkedIn in unless you have, like, a job”
• Google+:
“nobody has Google+”
• Twitter:
“It’s good for keeping track of things”
Interesting how these statements in fact capture an essential element within each
application.
33. A 15 year old’s perspective…
• Facebook:
“There’s a lot of ads but it’s really good”
• LinkedIn:
“Nobody uses LinkedIn in unless you have, like, a job”
• Google+:
“nobody has Google+”
• Twitter:
“It’s good for keeping track of things”
Including much chatter on the Internet about the extent to which Google+ has as much
adoption and traffic/sharing as promos suggest?
Graphic from:
http://mashable.com/2012/08/08/infographic‐google‐plus‐ghost‐town/
35. What’s right for you? Are you….
Looking for a job or
wanting to
network/collaborate with
other professionals?
Wanting to share
information, invite
feedback/contributions,
and follow others?
Wanting to push out
links/short reflections
and follow others?
How do I decide? Here are some suggestions.
41. Profile
Everything
about you in
160 characters
or less
So…if you’re not already on Twitter, you need to craft a profile of no more than 160
characters.
43. Quick Twitter Tips
• # (hashtag): categorizes tweets – there is a
taxonomy of hashtags, or you can create your
own (www.hashtags.org)
• @MarilynHerie: Twitter handle – how your
Tweets will appear
• 140 characters max
• If sending a link, make it into a “Tiny URL”
Twitter is especially good for sharing links to interesting/important/entertaining
content to others in your network. TinyURL is an example of a free online application
to shorten the URL so that it can fit in the 140 character limit of a tweet (see next
slide).
45. Twitter Practice
• What is something
that is unique to
me?
• What is something
I have experienced
that others may
identify with?
http://kellyburstow.com/2011/10/how-to-write-a-twitter-bio/
Here are some key questions to get you started writing (or revising) your Twitter bio.
46. Twitter Practice
• Turn to the person
behind you
• If you’re on Twitter:
– Share your handle and bio
– Who do you follow and
why?
• If you’re not on Twitter:
– What would you say
about yourself in your
brief bio?
– Practice writing a “Tweet”
about this session
53. Create Video Content To…
• Share research findings
• Demonstrate clinical skills
• Hear from stakeholders, guest experts, etc.
• Disseminate talks or presentations
• Video Blogging (Vlogging)
But YouTube is so much more than cat/music/etc videos. Here are some suggested
applications to consider in using this powerful dissemination and communication tool
at a professional or organization level.
60. • Facebook • Pinterest
• LinkedIn • Stumbleupon
• Google+ • Slideshare
• Twitter • Screenr
• YouTube
Now let’s look briefly at some other interesting social media applications
75. What blog names have others used?
How did you decide?
Do an online search for examples of blog names, or ask others about names they’ve
used or considered.
79. Template
Title
Description
Banner Image
Optional Picture
http://educateria.com/
I have chosen Wordpress for my blog. This slide illustrates the different components
that you can populate once you sign up and get started.
80. Post Title
Categories/Tags
http://educateria.com/ Subtitle
89. Take‐Home Messages
• You might be online even if it’s not “you”
• Consider a “placeholder” with some content
across platforms, especially if you/your
organization’s name is not unique
• Don’t assume you/your organization’s name is
unique
• Even if you don’t use a platform, someone
else might be searching for you on it
So here are some thoughts to consider, even if you aren’t sure that a particular
platform is for you.
Especially as an organization, it may make sense to have a presence across platforms.
90. How do I decide?
1. Do I want to install, configure, and host my blog myself, or
would I rather rely on a hosted service?
2. Do I want to create my own blog theme, or am I satisfied
with using or customizing an existing theme?
3. Do I want to be able to install custom plug‐ins or am I
satisfied with the functionality that is built‐in to the
platform I choose?
4. Will I be writing more long‐form posts or posting cool things
I find online? Or do I need to be able to do both?
5. Do I want others to be able to comment on my post and
interact with my content in a social way, or do I just want to
be able to have a place to post my writing where people
can read it and nobody can bother me?
6. Am I willing to pay for this blogging platform?
http://lifehacker.com/5878847/which-blogging-platform-should-i-use
This article at Lifehacker.com gives some great questions and suggestions to help you
to decide which blogging platform is a good fit for your objectives and style.
96. Who has presented
a webinar as a
speaker/facilitator?
What have you learned from your own experiences facilitating or participating in
webinars or web/video conferences?
These valuable experiences about the process yield some important “best practice”
tips.
99. Six Webinar Tips
1. It might not be a webinar
2. I like text chat better than voice
3. Prime participants to participate
4. You can’t do it all
5. Ready for your close‐up
6. Less text more pictures
http://educateria.com/2012/10/02/quick-tips-for-faclitating-webinars/
Here are some tips from my blog post on facilitating webinars:
It might not be a webinar: Sometimes network connections fail, either at your end or
for participants. Send out a complete slide deck ahead of time and have a
teleconference line just in case.
I like text chat better than voice: In webinars, text chat is really seamless, especially
with large groups (e.g., 100 or more). Encourage people to chat with each‐other as
well as the facilitator throughout the webinar. This brings me to two more points:
Prime participants to participate: Most people regard online, text‐based
communication as more an act of publishing than as an act of speech. This
cognition tends to constrain spontaneous conversation, so I ask participants to
write down at least one question ahead of time. That way people are “primed” to
participate, and once the ice is broken the group can really take off.
You can’t do it all: With lots of sidebar chat it’s pretty much impossible to present AND
read comments/questions at the same time. Having a moderator to help cue the
presenter with key questions or pauses is essential.
Ready for your close‐up: Built‐in computer webcams tend not to give the most
flattering angle. Use a separate webcam for better camera postioning, add extra
light, and talk to the camera. Participants want to feel connected to the facilitator.
Less text more pictures: If text‐heavy presentations are boring in person, they are even
more deadly by webinar. (Plus, disengaged participants will toggle back and forth
between a boring webinar and another, more interesting, website). Keep people
engaged with well‐designed content and activities.
109. E‐Therapy
• 1st provision of behavioural health services
delivered from a distance…
1959
Considerations for the provision of e-therapy, SAMHSA, 2009
This earliest documented telepsychiatry intervention was from the Nebraska
psychiatric institute – where a television link used to provide consultation to patients.
111. http://www.ocswssw.org/docs/newslettereng_fall2011-rev5-final-
ya.pdf?LanguageID=EN-US
The Ontario College of Social Workers and Social Service Workers (OCSWSSW) has also
written about social media and e‐therapy in their “Practice Notes” series, highlighting
some important ideas and things to consider.
112. Clinical Social Work Journal, published online Feb 2012
And this recent article by Mishna et al. is a wonderful example of the power of
qualitative research to hone in on thematic observations and issues that are of
paramount relevance to clinical practice. Highly recommended reading for ALL
practitioners, regardless of discipline and level of interest in social media and e‐
therapy.
Because a take‐home message from this research is that we are all affected – and will
be increasingly affected – by our patients’ and our own uptake of these tools and
applications.
113. “It Just Crept In”
• Client‐driven practice
• Pandora’s Box
• Ethical gray zone
• Permeable boundaries
Mishna et. al., 2012
These are the four themes that stood out from the research that Mishna et al.
conducted. Again, a must‐read!
114. http://store.samhsa.gov/product/Considerations-for-the-Provision-of-E-
Therapy/SMA09-4450
This publication by SAMHSA – available for free download – is also relevant across
disciplines and specialties, and provides a rich discussion of logistical, ethical and
practice issues relating to the provision of e‐therapy.
115. What is e‐therapy?
“The use of electronic media and information
technologies to provide services for
participants in different locations”
Considerations for the provision of e-therapy, SAMHSA, 2009
What is e‐therapy? Here is a working definition from the SAMHSA document.
116. Applications
• Psychoeducation
• General counselling
• Self‐help
• CBT
Considerations for the provision of e-therapy, SAMHSA, 2009
How can e‐therapy be applied?
Across a range of practice approaches, including self‐help.
117. For diverse issues, including…
• Substance dependence treatment
• Panic disorder
• Public speaking anxiety
• Agoraphobia
• Eating disorders
• Depression
Considerations for the provision of e-therapy, SAMHSA, 2009
For what kinds of issues?
Again, e‐therapy has been used and evaluated across a range of presenting issues.
118. E‐Therapy Platforms
Text-Based Non-Text-
Based
Synchronous Internet Telephone
Messaging (IM) Video-conference
Online Chat Web-conference
Text message
Asynchronous Email Fax
Discussion board/ Video
Online forum Voice recording
Comments on
blogs, vlogs
I have roughly divided e‐therapy applications into this 2 x 2 table. Note that there is
some overlap across some of the categories, and e‐therapy may use numerous
communication strategies that encompass both synchronous (real‐time) and
asynchronous (not at the same time) communication/counselling styles and methods.
119. Pros and Cons of E‐Therapy
• Accessibility • Digital divide
• Cost • Confidentiality
• Continuity of care • Technology failures
• Demand • Communication barriers
• Stigma of accessing (e.g., linguistic
community resources competence,
• Privacy communication norms)
• Emergencies/crises
Considerations for the provision of e-therapy, SAMHSA, 2009
These pros and cons are explained in more detail in the SAMHSA document, and are
merely highlighted here.
121. Small comparison study of online vs face-to-face
manualized group CBT counselling for clients with
disordered eating
“Significant improvements on all outcome variables were
observed and maintained at follow-up in both groups”
Take home message: Brief group CBT therapy
appears to be adaptable to an online, synchronous
(chat room/discussion board) delivery context
122.
123. Small, self-selected sample of online therapy consumers
“Exceeding expectations and despite low power, results
on the composite scale and goal subscale of the WAI
were significantly higher than those from the
representative sample of face-to-face clients”
Take home message: Participants corresponding
with therapists using more than one online modality
demonstrated stronger working alliance
124.
125. Meta-analysis of 56 studies published between 1998-
2010
“Direct comparisons favour FTFIs over CDIs although
the incremental effect is small”
Take home message: Research needs to go
beyond simple efficacy evaluations and investigate
specific intervention components and their
applications in CDIs
126. Research Issues
• Small sample sizes
• High dropout
• Lack of comparison groups
• Diversity of delivery modes
• Lack of standardized interventions
Considerations for the provision of e-therapy, SAMHSA, 2009
Overall, however, research – especially high‐quality research – is lacking in this area.
Therefore, proceed with caution, recognizing that evidence‐informed approaches are
less developed for e‐therapy at this time.
127. Ethical, Legal and Regulatory Issues
• Confidentiality:
– Records can be breached/not easily deleted
– Client forwards correspondence to third party
• May favour more affluent, literate, educated
• How do we know it works? Outcomes?
• Foremost clinical decision is whether to provide
treatment
• Jurisdictional issues
• Scope of practice
• Which region’s regulations take precedence?
Considerations for the provision of e-therapy, SAMHSA, 2009
Practitioners also need to consider numerous ethical and regulatory issues that may
not be clearly defined, and can impact professional practice.
128. Informed Consent
• Treatment process/procedures
• Benefits and risks
• Actions taken to prevent risks
• Procedures for emergencies
• Confidentiality and safeguards
And finally, it’s important to note that informed consent on the part of clients needs to
address these general areas – and in the case of e‐therapy, to outline the specific and
unique actions and procedures that will apply to virtual counselling contexts.
132. Every ceiling, when reached,
becomes a floor.
‐ Aldous Huxley
And, of course, as you reach proficiency in anything, that becomes the foundation to
take it to the next level.
133. Summary
Utility and ease of use are better predictors of uptake than
time, age or specialty
You likely already have an online identity – social media
can help you further control and define it + establish PLNs
Social media tools go far beyond vehicles for corporate
communication
Online collaboration and discussion (blogging, micro-
blogging, wikis, etc.) can further reflective practice and
knowledge sharing/exchange
People – clients, students, peers and others – are already
driving change
Some disciplines (for example Medicine) are ahead of the
curve in adoption, evaluation and research
The collaborative and systems orientation of social work
may be a natural fit with these new and emerging
technologies
In summary…here is an overview of key points.