SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 25
How Great KM’ers are Innovation
“Conveners”
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
1
February 17, 2015
Kate Pugh, Columbia University and
AlignConsulting
kp2462@columbia.edu
Smarter Innovation (20 articles on innovation)
http://www.alignconsultinginc.com/boo
ks/smarter-innovation (For reduced US
pricing, e-versions, educational copies
dsmallwood@ark-group.com)
Ideas
• Innovation leadership
• Research: Innovation microprocesses
• Building an innovation competency
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
2
Innovation
• An innovation is some economic entity– an
object, a service -- that solves a problem
systemically, and that persists over time because
it interacts.
• It can be internal to the organization, or
external, generating revenue or societal impact.
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
3
Innovation leadership failures
• Language
• Process
• Practice
• Reflection
• Politics
• “Walk the talk”
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
4
Claude Legrand, “How Leaders can Close the Innovation Gap” Ivy business Journal, 2011
References: TJ Elliot, “Escaping Gravitiy, in Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014.
Why knowledge practitioners?
• “Label” for connections
• (Co)generate solutions
• Mobilize partners
• Keep the pulse
• Cross the boundaries
• Model the way
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
5
• Language
• Process
• Practice
• Reflection
• Politics
• “Walk the talk”
We’re often the first to see opportunities
• Virtualization
• Participation
• Datafication
• Benchmarking/
Aggregation
• Sensor integration
• Everywhere
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
6
We lead knowledge-driven strategies
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
7
Knowledge’s
Fundamental
value…
Knowledge-
enabled strategy
Knowledge-based
strategy
Knowledge-driven
strategy
Makes us more
effective
Helps us to win Is the reason
customers choose us
Is informed
by strategy Informs or shapes strategy
KM...
“Fit” the
strategy.
ID’d with specific
competitive moves
and capability
enhancements.
At the front line in
the form of
knowledge services
or smart products.
Knowledge
activities and
platforms …
Source Stewart and Pugh:, “Knowledge is the Business” (Ark Group, 2013)
At the front line...
Knowledge practice landscape
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
8
Revenue or external impact
Productivity
CollaborationInformation Mgt.
Mostly explicit K to
tacit
Mostly Tacit K to
explicit
Knowledge
Driven
Knowledge-
based,
Knowledge
Enabled
At the front line...
Knowledge practice landscape (cont’d)
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
9
Revenue or external impact
Productivity
CollaborationInformation Mgt.
Doc and Content
Mgt., Analytics,
metadata & findability
Team/ecosystem
collaboration, enterprise
social media, networks
Knowledge-driven
products, e.g., FitBit,
Google Nest, Angie’s
List
External communities,
social media marketing,
global knowledge
networks
Knowledge product types
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
10
Distilled
Instilled
Embodied
Nonprofit knowledge products
AlignConsulting KM
Introduction
11
Distilled
Embodied
Instilled
All
Innovation leaders’ strategy questions
1. Where do we compete?
2. How do we win?
3. How do we sustain
competitive advantage?
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
12
(Source: IKNS “Strategy Sequence” discussion)
How we win and sustain
• Make barriers to entry, via patents, reputation,
relationships
• Make switching costs for customers, via design-
ins, relationships, competitive price
• Be proactive, anticipate, deliver just in time for
customer loyalty
• Partner, manage the ecosystem
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
13
Innovation is a team sport
• The ability to come up with a novel, valuable,
and non-obvious idea is often necessary, but it’s
never sufficient to guarantee success…
[I]nnovation is about connecting, not inventing.
No idea will make a difference without building
around it the networks that will support it as it
grows, and the network partners with which it
will ultimately flourish.
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
14
See : Hargadon, Andy, “What is Innovation?” (Blog Post, 12/5/2010)
http://andrewhargadon.typepad.com/my_weblog/2010/12/what-is-innovation.html
Five
Innovation
Dimensions
for Smarter
Innovation
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
15
Where do we
compete?
How do we win?
How do we
sustain
competitive
advantage?
Five
Innovation
Dimensions
for Smarter
Innovation
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
16
Where do we
compete?
How do we win?
How do we
sustain
competitive
advantage?
1. Bridging
2. Social and
operational
integration
3. Capability
validation
4. Market and industry assessment
6. Innovation
ecology
5. Commer-
cialization
1. Bridging
• Making sense of an idea
translated from one domain to the
next.
• Quirky (GE Open
collaborative community)
• Broadli (Generosity app and
social capital on LinkedIn)
• Motorola Solutions (4
discussion disciplines for
virtual innovation – integrity,
courtesy, inclusion,
translation in Jive)
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
17
Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
Discussion disciplines can drive innovation
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
18
Skifstad and Pugh, “Beyond Netiquette: Discussion /Discipline Drives Innovation” (In Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014).
Discussion discipline Description Benefits
1. Integrity Use true voice, research
views, Ask questions that
propel
Primarily
tonal; builds
community
and social
capital.
2. Courtesy Respect others and forum.
3. Inclusion Broaden the perspective.
Explain terms, call others in.
Primarily
content-
related; drives
innovation.
4. Translation Summarize/use insights
generated, and help others
with summarizations.
2. Social and operational integration
• Socialization and refinement of a
new idea across a network of
employees and/or collaboration
partners.
• MonitorDeloitte ([SME]
“thoughts in progress”)
• BAE / Lockheed Martin
(Knowledge Continuity for
succession planning); Knowledge
Jam)
• Change Agents Worldwide
(virtual networked org that
“swarm” challenges)
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
19
Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
3. Capabilities validation
• Validating the organization’s and
individuals’ capabilities and
readiness to pursue the innovation.
• Columbia Information and
Knowledge Strategy
(Findability framework)
• Company Body (human-
modeled sustainability)
• Columbia/Emory/ Deloitte
study (Risks of sharing in
turbulent markets)
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
20
Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
4. Market and industry exploration
• Using collaborative microprocesses
(and data) to determine whether
the market and industry are viable
and profitable.
• Perks Consulting (scores
“Corporates” acting like
entrepreneurs -- “scrum” for
commercialization)
• ARRIS (Motorola Mobility)
(risk selection, attitude,
structure which, in turn,
promote monetization models
in disruptive markets, gain an
innovation mindset, and up-
stack market awareness)
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
21
Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
5. Commercialization
• Considering practicalities of
pricing, positioning, promotion,
and production using collective
decision approaches.
• Bain & Co. (Loyalty Forum
for the Net Promoter Score
“program” not just “service”)
• TomorrowMakers (formerly
MGTaylor) (enables
consensus-building with
value prototyping, Design
Shop)
• 3M (sales knowledge
coverage models,
rationalization)
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
22
Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
• Organizational-level
– Shared language / metadata
– Consensus innovation “process”
– Sense making, benchmarking, systems
thinking
– “Open-space” v hyper-programmed
– Inter-co swaps, sabbaticals, laterals,
organizational mash-ups
– Mindfulness, physical space
• Individual-level
– Mastery
– Self-awareness
– Deep curiosity outside field/
boundary tracking
– Attracted to the foreign
– Comfort with ambiguity
– Nexus and convening skills
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
23
Team- or Community- level
−“Desire-to-know,” not “need-to-know”
−4 disciplines (integrity, courtesy, inclusion,
translation), other interaction tools such as
“Essays in two voices”
Convening an innovation ecology
Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
How great KM’ers are innovation
conveners
We lead by design
• Span industry,
functional, technical
opportunities
• Deliver knowledge
products (distilled,
instilled, or embodied)
• Position for competitive
advantage (internally and
externally)
We convene by temperament
• Focus on interactions
1. Bridging
2. Social integration
3. Capabilities validation
4. Market/industry assessment
5. Commercialization
• Build innovation ecology
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
24
Kate Pugh, Columbia University, AlignConsulting
•Kate has held leadership positions with Intel Corporation,
JPMorgan, and Fidelity. She is Academic Director of Columbia
University’s Information and Knowledge Strategy Masters
program, and is author of Sharing Hidden Know-How (Jossey-Bass,
2011) and Editor of Smarter Innovation (Ark Group, 2014).
•Sample clients include Athena Health, Clear Channel, The Gates
Foundation, Institute for Healthcare Improvement, Medtronic,
Mitokine Bioscience, Project Mgt Institute, Women’s World
Banking, and The World Bank.
How Great KM’ers are
Innovation “conveners”
25
•Kate has an MS/MBA from MIT Sloan, a BA in Economics from Williams College,
and certifications in Dialogue, Facilitation, Mediation, Project Mgt., and LEAN Six
Sigma.
•Kate has articles in Sloan Mgt. Review, Harvard Business Review, Ark Group, NASA Ask
Magazine, Huffington Post, Journal of Digital Media Management, Reuters Great Debate, and
Ivey Business Journal.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Component content 101 - Noz Urbina
Component content 101 - Noz UrbinaComponent content 101 - Noz Urbina
Component content 101 - Noz UrbinaNoz Urbina
 
Social Media
Social MediaSocial Media
Social Mediapsllc
 
Building muscles to improve innovation networks pugh skifstad may 2020 final (1)
Building muscles to improve innovation networks pugh skifstad may 2020 final (1)Building muscles to improve innovation networks pugh skifstad may 2020 final (1)
Building muscles to improve innovation networks pugh skifstad may 2020 final (1)Katrina (Kate) Pugh
 
Agility from First Principles
Agility from First PrinciplesAgility from First Principles
Agility from First PrinciplesTathagat Varma
 
PKM and Corporate Memory - a dichotomy?
PKM and Corporate Memory - a dichotomy?PKM and Corporate Memory - a dichotomy?
PKM and Corporate Memory - a dichotomy?Collabor8now Ltd
 
The power of crowd sourcing
The power of crowd sourcingThe power of crowd sourcing
The power of crowd sourcingPavan kumar
 
05 23-2018 - succeeding in the world of special librarianship final
05 23-2018 - succeeding in the world of special librarianship  final05 23-2018 - succeeding in the world of special librarianship  final
05 23-2018 - succeeding in the world of special librarianship finalStephen Abram
 
Communities of Practice - Challenges, Curiosity and Dragons
Communities of Practice - Challenges, Curiosity and Dragons Communities of Practice - Challenges, Curiosity and Dragons
Communities of Practice - Challenges, Curiosity and Dragons SIKM
 
Lecture 5 2011 2012 crowdsourcing and social media
Lecture 5 2011 2012 crowdsourcing and social mediaLecture 5 2011 2012 crowdsourcing and social media
Lecture 5 2011 2012 crowdsourcing and social mediaFrank Willems
 
Humanity over bureaucracy
Humanity over bureaucracyHumanity over bureaucracy
Humanity over bureaucracyLivework Studio
 
Developing a Coherent Social Strategy for Enterprise Innovation
Developing a Coherent Social Strategy for Enterprise InnovationDeveloping a Coherent Social Strategy for Enterprise Innovation
Developing a Coherent Social Strategy for Enterprise InnovationMindjet
 
Neuroentrepreneurship symposium 2015 Academy of Management
Neuroentrepreneurship symposium 2015 Academy of ManagementNeuroentrepreneurship symposium 2015 Academy of Management
Neuroentrepreneurship symposium 2015 Academy of ManagementNorris Krueger
 
The future of Agile in Organizations
The future of Agile in OrganizationsThe future of Agile in Organizations
The future of Agile in OrganizationsAdaptiveOrg Inc.
 
Ideas That Work: Extending the Success of Your Innovation Program
Ideas That Work: Extending the Success of Your Innovation ProgramIdeas That Work: Extending the Success of Your Innovation Program
Ideas That Work: Extending the Success of Your Innovation ProgramMindjet
 
Creating Collaborative Cultures
Creating Collaborative CulturesCreating Collaborative Cultures
Creating Collaborative CulturesBernice Moore, PhD
 
Getting $*it Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy (MCN2015)
Getting $*it Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy (MCN2015)Getting $*it Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy (MCN2015)
Getting $*it Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy (MCN2015)Jane Alexander
 
NHS IQ Thought Diversity hothouse event final slides
NHS IQ Thought Diversity hothouse event final slides NHS IQ Thought Diversity hothouse event final slides
NHS IQ Thought Diversity hothouse event final slides NHS Improving Quality
 

Mais procurados (20)

Component content 101 - Noz Urbina
Component content 101 - Noz UrbinaComponent content 101 - Noz Urbina
Component content 101 - Noz Urbina
 
Social Media
Social MediaSocial Media
Social Media
 
Building muscles to improve innovation networks pugh skifstad may 2020 final (1)
Building muscles to improve innovation networks pugh skifstad may 2020 final (1)Building muscles to improve innovation networks pugh skifstad may 2020 final (1)
Building muscles to improve innovation networks pugh skifstad may 2020 final (1)
 
Agility from First Principles
Agility from First PrinciplesAgility from First Principles
Agility from First Principles
 
PKM and Corporate Memory - a dichotomy?
PKM and Corporate Memory - a dichotomy?PKM and Corporate Memory - a dichotomy?
PKM and Corporate Memory - a dichotomy?
 
The power of crowd sourcing
The power of crowd sourcingThe power of crowd sourcing
The power of crowd sourcing
 
05 23-2018 - succeeding in the world of special librarianship final
05 23-2018 - succeeding in the world of special librarianship  final05 23-2018 - succeeding in the world of special librarianship  final
05 23-2018 - succeeding in the world of special librarianship final
 
Communities of Practice - Challenges, Curiosity and Dragons
Communities of Practice - Challenges, Curiosity and Dragons Communities of Practice - Challenges, Curiosity and Dragons
Communities of Practice - Challenges, Curiosity and Dragons
 
Innovation & Knowledge Management
Innovation & Knowledge ManagementInnovation & Knowledge Management
Innovation & Knowledge Management
 
Lecture 5 2011 2012 crowdsourcing and social media
Lecture 5 2011 2012 crowdsourcing and social mediaLecture 5 2011 2012 crowdsourcing and social media
Lecture 5 2011 2012 crowdsourcing and social media
 
Humanity over bureaucracy
Humanity over bureaucracyHumanity over bureaucracy
Humanity over bureaucracy
 
Digital Dimensions
Digital DimensionsDigital Dimensions
Digital Dimensions
 
How Change Happens
How Change HappensHow Change Happens
How Change Happens
 
Developing a Coherent Social Strategy for Enterprise Innovation
Developing a Coherent Social Strategy for Enterprise InnovationDeveloping a Coherent Social Strategy for Enterprise Innovation
Developing a Coherent Social Strategy for Enterprise Innovation
 
Neuroentrepreneurship symposium 2015 Academy of Management
Neuroentrepreneurship symposium 2015 Academy of ManagementNeuroentrepreneurship symposium 2015 Academy of Management
Neuroentrepreneurship symposium 2015 Academy of Management
 
The future of Agile in Organizations
The future of Agile in OrganizationsThe future of Agile in Organizations
The future of Agile in Organizations
 
Ideas That Work: Extending the Success of Your Innovation Program
Ideas That Work: Extending the Success of Your Innovation ProgramIdeas That Work: Extending the Success of Your Innovation Program
Ideas That Work: Extending the Success of Your Innovation Program
 
Creating Collaborative Cultures
Creating Collaborative CulturesCreating Collaborative Cultures
Creating Collaborative Cultures
 
Getting $*it Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy (MCN2015)
Getting $*it Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy (MCN2015)Getting $*it Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy (MCN2015)
Getting $*it Done: Implementing Your Digital Strategy (MCN2015)
 
NHS IQ Thought Diversity hothouse event final slides
NHS IQ Thought Diversity hothouse event final slides NHS IQ Thought Diversity hothouse event final slides
NHS IQ Thought Diversity hothouse event final slides
 

Semelhante a Pugh how great KMers are innovation conveners 150217

The powers of consortia: scaling capacity, learning, innovation and influence
The powers of consortia: scaling capacity, learning, innovation and influenceThe powers of consortia: scaling capacity, learning, innovation and influence
The powers of consortia: scaling capacity, learning, innovation and influencelisld
 
January15 2009 Pat Robinson Betterment
January15 2009 Pat Robinson BettermentJanuary15 2009 Pat Robinson Betterment
January15 2009 Pat Robinson Bettermentthmvmnt
 
Taking the next step: Building Organisational Co-design Capability
Taking the next step: Building Organisational Co-design CapabilityTaking the next step: Building Organisational Co-design Capability
Taking the next step: Building Organisational Co-design CapabilityPenny Hagen
 
Gateway to Agile: Product Discovery - Lean UX and Design Sprints
Gateway to Agile: Product Discovery - Lean UX and Design SprintsGateway to Agile: Product Discovery - Lean UX and Design Sprints
Gateway to Agile: Product Discovery - Lean UX and Design SprintsGervais Johnson, Advisor
 
Thinking entrepreneurially both internally and externally (dhcd, 12 6-17)
Thinking entrepreneurially both internally and externally (dhcd, 12 6-17)Thinking entrepreneurially both internally and externally (dhcd, 12 6-17)
Thinking entrepreneurially both internally and externally (dhcd, 12 6-17)Marty Kaszubowski
 
7 Steps for Open Innovation - Conferencia Crowdsourcing, Sao Paulo, Brazil
7 Steps for Open Innovation - Conferencia Crowdsourcing, Sao Paulo, Brazil7 Steps for Open Innovation - Conferencia Crowdsourcing, Sao Paulo, Brazil
7 Steps for Open Innovation - Conferencia Crowdsourcing, Sao Paulo, BrazilStefan Lindegaard
 
SilverStripe Developer Community: A Retrospective
SilverStripe Developer Community: A RetrospectiveSilverStripe Developer Community: A Retrospective
SilverStripe Developer Community: A RetrospectiveCam Findlay
 
Management of Innovation in R&D_Chehroudi_LinkedIn
Management of Innovation in R&D_Chehroudi_LinkedInManagement of Innovation in R&D_Chehroudi_LinkedIn
Management of Innovation in R&D_Chehroudi_LinkedInBruce Chehroudi
 
Leading to Innovation
Leading to InnovationLeading to Innovation
Leading to InnovationSaroj Behera
 
Leading to innovation
Leading to innovationLeading to innovation
Leading to innovationSAROJ BEHERA
 
Knowledge Management BSAS KT workshop
Knowledge Management BSAS KT workshopKnowledge Management BSAS KT workshop
Knowledge Management BSAS KT workshopSam Hoste
 
Sheila Corrall, University of Pittsburgh #RLUK14
Sheila Corrall, University of Pittsburgh #RLUK14Sheila Corrall, University of Pittsburgh #RLUK14
Sheila Corrall, University of Pittsburgh #RLUK14ResearchLibrariesUK
 
Ideation conference final
Ideation conference finalIdeation conference final
Ideation conference finalAvinash Singh
 

Semelhante a Pugh how great KMers are innovation conveners 150217 (20)

Knowledge manageability
Knowledge manageability Knowledge manageability
Knowledge manageability
 
The powers of consortia: scaling capacity, learning, innovation and influence
The powers of consortia: scaling capacity, learning, innovation and influenceThe powers of consortia: scaling capacity, learning, innovation and influence
The powers of consortia: scaling capacity, learning, innovation and influence
 
January15 2009 Pat Robinson Betterment
January15 2009 Pat Robinson BettermentJanuary15 2009 Pat Robinson Betterment
January15 2009 Pat Robinson Betterment
 
Innovation 2.10
Innovation 2.10Innovation 2.10
Innovation 2.10
 
Innovation 2 10
Innovation 2 10Innovation 2 10
Innovation 2 10
 
Ideas management
Ideas managementIdeas management
Ideas management
 
Taking the next step: Building Organisational Co-design Capability
Taking the next step: Building Organisational Co-design CapabilityTaking the next step: Building Organisational Co-design Capability
Taking the next step: Building Organisational Co-design Capability
 
Gateway to Agile: Product Discovery - Lean UX and Design Sprints
Gateway to Agile: Product Discovery - Lean UX and Design SprintsGateway to Agile: Product Discovery - Lean UX and Design Sprints
Gateway to Agile: Product Discovery - Lean UX and Design Sprints
 
Thinking entrepreneurially both internally and externally (dhcd, 12 6-17)
Thinking entrepreneurially both internally and externally (dhcd, 12 6-17)Thinking entrepreneurially both internally and externally (dhcd, 12 6-17)
Thinking entrepreneurially both internally and externally (dhcd, 12 6-17)
 
Be Relevant
Be RelevantBe Relevant
Be Relevant
 
7 Steps for Open Innovation - Conferencia Crowdsourcing, Sao Paulo, Brazil
7 Steps for Open Innovation - Conferencia Crowdsourcing, Sao Paulo, Brazil7 Steps for Open Innovation - Conferencia Crowdsourcing, Sao Paulo, Brazil
7 Steps for Open Innovation - Conferencia Crowdsourcing, Sao Paulo, Brazil
 
SilverStripe Developer Community: A Retrospective
SilverStripe Developer Community: A RetrospectiveSilverStripe Developer Community: A Retrospective
SilverStripe Developer Community: A Retrospective
 
Management of Innovation in R&D_Chehroudi_LinkedIn
Management of Innovation in R&D_Chehroudi_LinkedInManagement of Innovation in R&D_Chehroudi_LinkedIn
Management of Innovation in R&D_Chehroudi_LinkedIn
 
Leading to Innovation
Leading to InnovationLeading to Innovation
Leading to Innovation
 
Leading to innovation
Leading to innovationLeading to innovation
Leading to innovation
 
Knowledge Management BSAS KT workshop
Knowledge Management BSAS KT workshopKnowledge Management BSAS KT workshop
Knowledge Management BSAS KT workshop
 
Group5 ppt
Group5 pptGroup5 ppt
Group5 ppt
 
Ideavibes Presentation to RSA London
Ideavibes Presentation to RSA LondonIdeavibes Presentation to RSA London
Ideavibes Presentation to RSA London
 
Sheila Corrall, University of Pittsburgh #RLUK14
Sheila Corrall, University of Pittsburgh #RLUK14Sheila Corrall, University of Pittsburgh #RLUK14
Sheila Corrall, University of Pittsburgh #RLUK14
 
Ideation conference final
Ideation conference finalIdeation conference final
Ideation conference final
 

Mais de Katrina (Kate) Pugh

Sikm pugh sustainability conversations for impact snapshot 210420
Sikm pugh sustainability conversations for impact snapshot 210420Sikm pugh sustainability conversations for impact snapshot 210420
Sikm pugh sustainability conversations for impact snapshot 210420Katrina (Kate) Pugh
 
Midwest km pugh conversational ai and ai for conversation 190809
Midwest km pugh conversational ai and ai for conversation 190809Midwest km pugh conversational ai and ai for conversation 190809
Midwest km pugh conversational ai and ai for conversation 190809Katrina (Kate) Pugh
 
Pugh sikm leaders conversational ai 190618
Pugh sikm leaders conversational ai 190618Pugh sikm leaders conversational ai 190618
Pugh sikm leaders conversational ai 190618Katrina (Kate) Pugh
 
Being the convener for sikm 110816.v6
Being the convener for sikm 110816.v6Being the convener for sikm 110816.v6
Being the convener for sikm 110816.v6Katrina (Kate) Pugh
 
Knowledge jam for chicago km 110208
Knowledge jam for chicago km 110208Knowledge jam for chicago km 110208
Knowledge jam for chicago km 110208Katrina (Kate) Pugh
 
IT Offshoring with Intention (Pugh, Wadhera) 100406
IT Offshoring with Intention (Pugh, Wadhera) 100406IT Offshoring with Intention (Pugh, Wadhera) 100406
IT Offshoring with Intention (Pugh, Wadhera) 100406Katrina (Kate) Pugh
 
Sikm knowledge jam (katrina pugh) 100615
Sikm knowledge jam (katrina pugh) 100615Sikm knowledge jam (katrina pugh) 100615
Sikm knowledge jam (katrina pugh) 100615Katrina (Kate) Pugh
 

Mais de Katrina (Kate) Pugh (7)

Sikm pugh sustainability conversations for impact snapshot 210420
Sikm pugh sustainability conversations for impact snapshot 210420Sikm pugh sustainability conversations for impact snapshot 210420
Sikm pugh sustainability conversations for impact snapshot 210420
 
Midwest km pugh conversational ai and ai for conversation 190809
Midwest km pugh conversational ai and ai for conversation 190809Midwest km pugh conversational ai and ai for conversation 190809
Midwest km pugh conversational ai and ai for conversation 190809
 
Pugh sikm leaders conversational ai 190618
Pugh sikm leaders conversational ai 190618Pugh sikm leaders conversational ai 190618
Pugh sikm leaders conversational ai 190618
 
Being the convener for sikm 110816.v6
Being the convener for sikm 110816.v6Being the convener for sikm 110816.v6
Being the convener for sikm 110816.v6
 
Knowledge jam for chicago km 110208
Knowledge jam for chicago km 110208Knowledge jam for chicago km 110208
Knowledge jam for chicago km 110208
 
IT Offshoring with Intention (Pugh, Wadhera) 100406
IT Offshoring with Intention (Pugh, Wadhera) 100406IT Offshoring with Intention (Pugh, Wadhera) 100406
IT Offshoring with Intention (Pugh, Wadhera) 100406
 
Sikm knowledge jam (katrina pugh) 100615
Sikm knowledge jam (katrina pugh) 100615Sikm knowledge jam (katrina pugh) 100615
Sikm knowledge jam (katrina pugh) 100615
 

Último

Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Kirill Klimov
 
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Servicecallgirls2057
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfIntro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfpollardmorgan
 
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent ChirchirMarketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchirictsugar
 
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMintel Group
 
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxContemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxMarkAnthonyAurellano
 
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdfAPRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdfRbc Rbcua
 
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / NcrCall Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncrdollysharma2066
 
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailCase study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailAriel592675
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaoncallgirls2057
 
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...ictsugar
 
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03DallasHaselhorst
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Seta Wicaksana
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionMintel Group
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
PSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
PSCC - Capability Statement PresentationPSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
PSCC - Capability Statement PresentationAnamaria Contreras
 

Último (20)

Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
 
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
 
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
 
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfIntro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
 
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent ChirchirMarketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
 
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
 
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxContemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
 
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdfAPRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
 
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / NcrCall Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
Call Girls in DELHI Cantt, ( Call Me )-8377877756-Female Escort- In Delhi / Ncr
 
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailCase study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
 
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
 
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
 
PSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
PSCC - Capability Statement PresentationPSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
PSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
 

Pugh how great KMers are innovation conveners 150217

  • 1. How Great KM’ers are Innovation “Conveners” How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 1 February 17, 2015 Kate Pugh, Columbia University and AlignConsulting kp2462@columbia.edu Smarter Innovation (20 articles on innovation) http://www.alignconsultinginc.com/boo ks/smarter-innovation (For reduced US pricing, e-versions, educational copies dsmallwood@ark-group.com)
  • 2. Ideas • Innovation leadership • Research: Innovation microprocesses • Building an innovation competency How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 2
  • 3. Innovation • An innovation is some economic entity– an object, a service -- that solves a problem systemically, and that persists over time because it interacts. • It can be internal to the organization, or external, generating revenue or societal impact. How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 3
  • 4. Innovation leadership failures • Language • Process • Practice • Reflection • Politics • “Walk the talk” How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 4 Claude Legrand, “How Leaders can Close the Innovation Gap” Ivy business Journal, 2011 References: TJ Elliot, “Escaping Gravitiy, in Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014.
  • 5. Why knowledge practitioners? • “Label” for connections • (Co)generate solutions • Mobilize partners • Keep the pulse • Cross the boundaries • Model the way How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 5 • Language • Process • Practice • Reflection • Politics • “Walk the talk”
  • 6. We’re often the first to see opportunities • Virtualization • Participation • Datafication • Benchmarking/ Aggregation • Sensor integration • Everywhere How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 6
  • 7. We lead knowledge-driven strategies How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 7 Knowledge’s Fundamental value… Knowledge- enabled strategy Knowledge-based strategy Knowledge-driven strategy Makes us more effective Helps us to win Is the reason customers choose us Is informed by strategy Informs or shapes strategy KM... “Fit” the strategy. ID’d with specific competitive moves and capability enhancements. At the front line in the form of knowledge services or smart products. Knowledge activities and platforms … Source Stewart and Pugh:, “Knowledge is the Business” (Ark Group, 2013)
  • 8. At the front line... Knowledge practice landscape How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 8 Revenue or external impact Productivity CollaborationInformation Mgt. Mostly explicit K to tacit Mostly Tacit K to explicit Knowledge Driven Knowledge- based, Knowledge Enabled
  • 9. At the front line... Knowledge practice landscape (cont’d) How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 9 Revenue or external impact Productivity CollaborationInformation Mgt. Doc and Content Mgt., Analytics, metadata & findability Team/ecosystem collaboration, enterprise social media, networks Knowledge-driven products, e.g., FitBit, Google Nest, Angie’s List External communities, social media marketing, global knowledge networks
  • 10. Knowledge product types How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 10 Distilled Instilled Embodied
  • 11. Nonprofit knowledge products AlignConsulting KM Introduction 11 Distilled Embodied Instilled All
  • 12. Innovation leaders’ strategy questions 1. Where do we compete? 2. How do we win? 3. How do we sustain competitive advantage? How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 12 (Source: IKNS “Strategy Sequence” discussion)
  • 13. How we win and sustain • Make barriers to entry, via patents, reputation, relationships • Make switching costs for customers, via design- ins, relationships, competitive price • Be proactive, anticipate, deliver just in time for customer loyalty • Partner, manage the ecosystem How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 13
  • 14. Innovation is a team sport • The ability to come up with a novel, valuable, and non-obvious idea is often necessary, but it’s never sufficient to guarantee success… [I]nnovation is about connecting, not inventing. No idea will make a difference without building around it the networks that will support it as it grows, and the network partners with which it will ultimately flourish. How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 14 See : Hargadon, Andy, “What is Innovation?” (Blog Post, 12/5/2010) http://andrewhargadon.typepad.com/my_weblog/2010/12/what-is-innovation.html
  • 15. Five Innovation Dimensions for Smarter Innovation How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 15 Where do we compete? How do we win? How do we sustain competitive advantage?
  • 16. Five Innovation Dimensions for Smarter Innovation How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 16 Where do we compete? How do we win? How do we sustain competitive advantage? 1. Bridging 2. Social and operational integration 3. Capability validation 4. Market and industry assessment 6. Innovation ecology 5. Commer- cialization
  • 17. 1. Bridging • Making sense of an idea translated from one domain to the next. • Quirky (GE Open collaborative community) • Broadli (Generosity app and social capital on LinkedIn) • Motorola Solutions (4 discussion disciplines for virtual innovation – integrity, courtesy, inclusion, translation in Jive) How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 17 Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
  • 18. Discussion disciplines can drive innovation How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 18 Skifstad and Pugh, “Beyond Netiquette: Discussion /Discipline Drives Innovation” (In Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014). Discussion discipline Description Benefits 1. Integrity Use true voice, research views, Ask questions that propel Primarily tonal; builds community and social capital. 2. Courtesy Respect others and forum. 3. Inclusion Broaden the perspective. Explain terms, call others in. Primarily content- related; drives innovation. 4. Translation Summarize/use insights generated, and help others with summarizations.
  • 19. 2. Social and operational integration • Socialization and refinement of a new idea across a network of employees and/or collaboration partners. • MonitorDeloitte ([SME] “thoughts in progress”) • BAE / Lockheed Martin (Knowledge Continuity for succession planning); Knowledge Jam) • Change Agents Worldwide (virtual networked org that “swarm” challenges) How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 19 Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
  • 20. 3. Capabilities validation • Validating the organization’s and individuals’ capabilities and readiness to pursue the innovation. • Columbia Information and Knowledge Strategy (Findability framework) • Company Body (human- modeled sustainability) • Columbia/Emory/ Deloitte study (Risks of sharing in turbulent markets) How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 20 Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
  • 21. 4. Market and industry exploration • Using collaborative microprocesses (and data) to determine whether the market and industry are viable and profitable. • Perks Consulting (scores “Corporates” acting like entrepreneurs -- “scrum” for commercialization) • ARRIS (Motorola Mobility) (risk selection, attitude, structure which, in turn, promote monetization models in disruptive markets, gain an innovation mindset, and up- stack market awareness) How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 21 Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
  • 22. 5. Commercialization • Considering practicalities of pricing, positioning, promotion, and production using collective decision approaches. • Bain & Co. (Loyalty Forum for the Net Promoter Score “program” not just “service”) • TomorrowMakers (formerly MGTaylor) (enables consensus-building with value prototyping, Design Shop) • 3M (sales knowledge coverage models, rationalization) How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 22 Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
  • 23. • Organizational-level – Shared language / metadata – Consensus innovation “process” – Sense making, benchmarking, systems thinking – “Open-space” v hyper-programmed – Inter-co swaps, sabbaticals, laterals, organizational mash-ups – Mindfulness, physical space • Individual-level – Mastery – Self-awareness – Deep curiosity outside field/ boundary tracking – Attracted to the foreign – Comfort with ambiguity – Nexus and convening skills How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 23 Team- or Community- level −“Desire-to-know,” not “need-to-know” −4 disciplines (integrity, courtesy, inclusion, translation), other interaction tools such as “Essays in two voices” Convening an innovation ecology Smarter Innovation, Ark Group, 2014
  • 24. How great KM’ers are innovation conveners We lead by design • Span industry, functional, technical opportunities • Deliver knowledge products (distilled, instilled, or embodied) • Position for competitive advantage (internally and externally) We convene by temperament • Focus on interactions 1. Bridging 2. Social integration 3. Capabilities validation 4. Market/industry assessment 5. Commercialization • Build innovation ecology How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 24
  • 25. Kate Pugh, Columbia University, AlignConsulting •Kate has held leadership positions with Intel Corporation, JPMorgan, and Fidelity. She is Academic Director of Columbia University’s Information and Knowledge Strategy Masters program, and is author of Sharing Hidden Know-How (Jossey-Bass, 2011) and Editor of Smarter Innovation (Ark Group, 2014). •Sample clients include Athena Health, Clear Channel, The Gates Foundation, Institute for Healthcare Improvement, Medtronic, Mitokine Bioscience, Project Mgt Institute, Women’s World Banking, and The World Bank. How Great KM’ers are Innovation “conveners” 25 •Kate has an MS/MBA from MIT Sloan, a BA in Economics from Williams College, and certifications in Dialogue, Facilitation, Mediation, Project Mgt., and LEAN Six Sigma. •Kate has articles in Sloan Mgt. Review, Harvard Business Review, Ark Group, NASA Ask Magazine, Huffington Post, Journal of Digital Media Management, Reuters Great Debate, and Ivey Business Journal.

Notas do Editor

  1. Table 1: The knowledge strategy landscape. Knowledge -enabled strategy entails an hand off from planners to knowledge practitioners. Those approaches-- such as codifying best practices, maintaining repositories of key documents, and building expertise directories -- enable responsive and/or efficient operations. Greater opportunity arises out of integrating knowledge practices with strategic initiatives (knowledge-based) and taking knowledge to market (knowledge driven). Knowledge-Enabled : Knowledge managers, working behind the scenes, make the business more efficient, innovative and collaborative. KM activities and platform are not “straight out of the box” but are customised to fit the strategy. Knowledge-Based: Knowledge assets and capabilities are developed and actively used as part of the company’s competitive arsenal in direct support of its strategic moves. Knowledge-Driven: Knowledge is an essential part of the company’s customer value proposition – it is a significant part of what customers pay for, and dynamically serves them and differentiates the organization. At the front line in the form of knowledge services or smart products.
  2. If you look at it in slide show, it builds from the ideas of the knowledge approach to the k practice goal, and then elaborates on what those axes mean, and then gives examples.  Columbia conceptual graphic 2014
  3. If you look at it in slide show, it builds from the ideas of the knowledge approach to the k practice goal, and then elaborates on what those axes mean, and then gives examples. 
  4. Knowledge “products” Frameworks for services (e.g., World Bank) Research and dev. (e.g., Batelle, Mitre) Integrated services (e.g., Partners Healthcare) Autonomics (e.g., iPsoft) Education (e.g., MOOCs) Consulting (e.g., Strategy&, Monitor Deloitte, McKinsey)
  5. IHI – improvement map Pathfinder -“Feedback/feed-forward model” WWB - “Leadership Community” Strive - “Collective impact model”
  6. Hargadon: Google was not the first search engine; Amazon's Kindle followed a decade of electronic book readers; Apple's iPod was the thirteenth MP3 player on the market; Penicillin was discovered by a French medical student 30 years before Alexander Fleming (re)discovered it.  Even the light bulb was a 40 year-old idea when Edison successfully commercialized it. As technologies and markets converge, ideas about what's possible and valuable appear to many people at the same time.
  7. For example, using a crowd-sourcing process to integrate ideas across contexts. Examples: AirBNB merges auctions and the share economy. Wiser (NYT spinoff) merges news services with social curation.
  8. Some moves build community (moves we call “integrity” and “courtesy”), and others drive ideation (“inclusion” and “translation”). Integrity and translation are essential to initiation and closure, respectively, and inclusion and courtesy can propel each other forward toward innovative integrations of ideas and action proposals.
  9. For example, a division’s CoP discussing a product innovation; or a Pfizer Town Hall deliberating process improvement.
  10. For example, UPS’s introspection as it assessed its readiness to go from shipper to logistician.
  11. For example, Panera Bread sizing up competitive factors such as customer price sensitivity and mobility, while also contemplating retaliation scenarios by incumbents.
  12. For example, retailer debating re-pricing, rather than trimming menu to maintaining “one stop shop.”
  13. (ETS, Intel, Quimmco, 3M, ARRIS/Motorola Mobility, CAWW)