1. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Low BPR turbofan/jet pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
1
■1. Which sort of power generator?
> Piston engine will be too much inertia to accelerate supersonic in a short time
> Piston engine will save fuel consumption, but its big size, then wider surface, will significantly impact the aircraft drag &
mass, implying more engine power
In fine as much fuel burn as gas generator as FB = SFC x PW
> Electrical engine, with batteries, in such a hot environment as afterburning jet engine shall not be the best reliability option
> The most intuitive choice is the gas generator
Small sizing
Low mass & inertia for good acceleration
■2. Fan thermodynamics
> Assume Mach 0.8 flight at sea level
> Assume some quite high fan pressure ratio at 2.0
> P2/T2 are also gas generator inlet conditions
Station Pt (Pa) Tt (K)
Ambiant Pamb/Tamb 100000 300 1bar, 27°C
Fan inlet P1/T1 142961 332 Pt=Pamb + 1/2 rho V² , Tt/Tamb=(Pt/Pamb)^((gamma-1)/gamma)
Fan outlet P2/T2 285922 413 FPR=2, if adiabatic : T2ad/T1=FPR^(0.4/1.4) , as efficiency 0.9 : (T2-T1) = (T2ad-T1)/0.9
Nozzle Ve (m/s) = 571 Ve = sqrt((P2-Pamb)/0.5rho), to determine rho : Ps=Pamb, Ts/T2=(Pamb/P2)^(0.4/1.4)
2. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Low BPR turbofan/jet pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
2
■3. Gas generator thermodynamics
> Gas generator first part is compressor
> Assuming ~25 OPR (overall pressure ration = Pcombustion/P1)
GG compressor shall have a 9 pressure ratio
> Choose the inlet turbine temperature
1450K enables uncooled turbine rotor
Cooled one could reach 1700K to 1900K
> Fuel/Air ratio : FAR = [ Cp_air x (T4-T3) ] / FHV ~ 2% << 14%
=> there is still enough oxygen for afterburning
■4. Fan turbine & primary nozzle
> Here we have to choose BPR to determine the fan turbine power.
T5-T6 = (BPR+1) x (T2-T1) / turbine_efficiency
> I will assume a 1 BPR
Station Pt (Pa) Tt (K)
GG inlet P2/T2 285922 413
Combustion inlet P3/T3 2573298 960 0.85 efficiency : (T2-T1) = (T2ad-T1)/0.85
Combustion outlet P4/T4 2521832 1800 T4 = 1450K for uncooled turbine (1700 to 1850K for cooled turbines) ; 2% pressure drop
HP Turbine outlet T5/P5 709704 1192 0.9 efficiency : (T4-T5) = (T3-T2)/0.9 ; T5ad = T4-0.9*(T4-T5) = T4-T3+T2
HP Turbine outlet T5/P5 709704 1192 0.9 efficiency : (T4-T5) = (T3-T2)/0.9 ; T5ad = T4-0.9*(T4-T5) = T4-T3+T2
LP turbine outlet T6/P6 426104 1013 0.9 efficiency : (T5-T6) = (T2-T1).(1+1)/0.9
Cold nozzle Ve (m/s) = 1119 Ve = sqrt((P6-Pamb)/0.5rho), to determine rho : Ps=Pamb, Ts/T6=(Pamb/P6)^(0.4/1.4)
3. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Low BPR turbofan/jet pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
3
■Specific thrust of this engine, M0.8 no afterburning
T/q = 1 / (1+BPR) x Ve_afterburning + BPR / (1+BPR) x Ve_fan – V0
T/q = 559.5 + 285.5 – 272 = 573 N/kg
Eta_prop = 2 x T x V / [ BPR/(BPR+1) Ve_fan² + 1/(BPR+1) VE_nozzle² -V0² ]
Eta_prop = 2 x T x 0.8 x 340 / [ 0.5 x 1119² + 0.5 x 571² - 272² ] ~ 44%
Station Pt (Pa) Tt (K)
Ambiant Pamb/Tamb
100000 300
Fan inlet P1/T1 142961 332
Fan outlet P2/T2 285922 413
Nozzle Ve (m/s) = 571
Station Pt (Pa) Tt (K)
GG inlet P2/T2 285922 413
Combustion inlet P3/T3
2573298 960
Combustion outlet P4/T4
2521832 1800
HP Turbine outlet T5/P5
709704 1192
LP turbine outlet T6/P6
426104 1013
Cold nozzle Ve (m/s) = 1119
cold 573
44%
M0.8
T/q (kN/kg)
Etaprop
4. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
4
■1. Sizing the propeller
2 formulas for Propeller choice :
> J = V0/(N.D) – speed coefficient
V0 = airplane speed (m/s)
N = propeller rotation speed (rev/s)
D = diameter (m)
> Ct = F/(rho.N².D4)
F = propeller traction (N)
Rho = air density (kg/m³)
N = propeller rotation speed (rev/s)
D = diameter (m)
2 specifications :
> Thrust
> Airplane speed
at key points, as cruise & take-off
5. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
5
■2. Find some propeller maps
Ct, Efficiency (h) characteristics function of J factor and propeller pitch
6. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
6
■3. Specification
As example (pure imagination), let’s take
> Cruise is 1kN traction at 100m/s (~200knts) @ 4500m, ISA
> Take-off is 5kN traction at 70m/s (~140knts) @ 0m, ISA
■4. Propeller diameter first guess
Choose propeller diameter
>D = V0/(N.J)
=> for a typical 2000RPM propeller, Diameter is here 3/J meters
>Let’s start with a 2m propeller, J=1.5
>Best efficiency is for 35° pitch,and then Ct = 0.06
7. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
7
■5. Propeller cruise pitch
Get necessary traction coefficient at cruise
for choosen J ratio
>Here, J = 1.5 => D = 2m
>Ct = F/(rho.N².D4) = 0.072
F = 1kN, D = 2m, N = 2000/60 rev/s
Rho = P0/(Rair.T0) = 0.78kg/m³
○ Rair = 287.05
○ P0 = 57.7kPa @ 4500m, ISA
○ T0 = 258.5K @4500m, ISA
>Pitch ~36°
■6. Control propeller efficiency
From Ct & J factors,
look for propeller efficiency for the dedicated pitch value
>Here, h ~ hmax
>J = 1.5 was a good choice for cruise operating point
8. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
8
■7. Propeller take-off pitch
Get necessary traction coefficient at take-off
>J = V/(N.D) = 1.1
V = 70m/s, D = 2m, N = 2000/60 rev/s
>Ct = F/(rho.N².D4) = 0.230
F = 5kN
Rho = P0/(Rair.T0) = 1.23kg/m³
○ Rair = 287.05
○ P0 = 101.3kPa @ 0m, ISA
○ T0 = 288.2K @ 0m, ISA
>! Ct > Ct max (~0.18) !
Speed or diameter is too low
9. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
9
■8. Adapt take-off rotation speed
A safer traction coefficient would be Ct = 0.15
>N² = F/(rho.Ct.D4) = 1693 rev/s
>=> N ~ 2470 RPM
We can increase take-off propeller speed by 25% vs. cruise
to reach the traction specification
>J factor value is now 0.84, & pitch is 32°
But efficiency is poor (~0.65)
To reach better efficiency at take-off, we need
>To decrease the pitch
>Or to increase the J factor
10. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
10
■9. Iterate on propeller sizing
To decrease take-off pitch, we need to decrease J factor
>Increase propeller diameter
Proportional to 1/J
>In the same time, it will decrease the needed Ct
Proportionnal to J4
Change cruise J factor from 1.5 to 1.4
(diameter reaches 2.1m)
>Cuise Ct coefficient changes from 0.72 to 0.055
>Take-off J factor moves from 0.84 to 0.78
>And associated Ct coeff. from 0.15 to 0.11
Resulting cruise pitch is 32° with still >.8 efficiency
And take-off pitch is now 25° only
and efficiency reaches 0.75
11. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
11
■10. Define engine power needed
Look for power coefficient for both cruise and take-off
Read the diagram using known J & pitch values from 9.
>Cruise : J = 1.4 & pitch = 32°
Cp value is ~0.09
>Take-off : J = 0.78 & pitch = 25°
Cp value is ~0.11
Then you get the propeller power thanks to the formula
PW = Cp.rho.N³.D6
Cruise power = 55kW
Take-off power = 206kW
12. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
12
■11. Which operating point is engine sizing point?
Available engine power is varying with altitude
>To compare all altitude powers we correct to 0m ISA conditions
𝑃𝑊
𝑐𝑜𝑟𝑟 =
𝑃𝑊 . 101325𝑃𝑎 . 288.15𝐾
𝑃0 . 𝑇0
In this example
>Take-off power of 206kW @ 0m, ISA leads to Pwcorr = 206kW
>Cruise power of 55kW @ 4500m, ISA leads to Pwcorr = 101kW
>Take-off power of 206kW is sizing the engine
13. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
13
■12. Last, find the engine !
206kW engine (276 horse power) is needed by the propeller
>Don’t forget to consider ~10% installation losses on the engine
>Looking for 300shp engine
For such power, solution will probably be turbine engine
But some piston engine would still be available
Seems one solution exists
14. This document and the information therein are the property of Safran. They must not be copied or communicated to a third party without the prior written authorization of Safran
Turboprop pre-design
Safran name of the activity / Date / Department (menu "Insert / Header and footer")
14
■13. And very last, find the propeller !
Available manufacturers are depending the size & power
>For such power, solution could be found by MT-Propellers or Hartzell for example
>You can check your pre-design
2700RPM @ 350 HP
○ We got 2500 for 300 HP
○ Not so bad
78”” diameter ~1.98m
○ We got 2.1m
○ Not so bad, still
Here is a possible solution