SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 27
Outcomes of mini-open repair technique for Achilles tendon rupture  ,[object Object]
Other Authors:  Jessica M. Knight, DPM,Lowell Weil, Jr., DPM, Lowell Scott Weil, Sr., DPM, and Dusty Christensen, BS.,[object Object]
Overview Purpose Methods Statistical Analysis Procedure Results Discussion
Purpose There is a recent report favoring non-operative treatment for acute Achilles tendon ruptures1 The consensus in the literature favors operative treatment.
Purpose Most studies have shown surgical intervention produces few complications and less re-rupture Athletes regain ~50% of post-injury power after tendon repair.11 32% of NFL players do not return to sport
Purpose More recently, a single incision (mini-open) technique has been reported2-4. Our retrospective series aims to report outcomes using this mini-open technique over the last eight years.
Purpose RETROSPECTIVE CASE SERIES Level of evidence:  IV (Therapeutic)
Methods Reviewed the medical records for 40 consecutive patients who underwent an Achilles tendon repair between January 2002 and December 2009 There were 19 patients (19 cases) who underwent a mini-open technique. Followed for an average of 24.4 months (range 12 to 68 months).
Methods All patients were assessed clinically  Victorian Institute of Sports Assessment - Achilles (VISA-A) score5 Visual Analog Pain Scale (VAS) Any post-operative complications and re-ruptures was also recorded.
Statistical Analysis A paired student t-test was used to determine significance between pre-operative and post-operative outcomes with p < 0.01.
Procedure An incision is placed ~1cm proximal to palpable dell
Procedure Advance the jig with inner arms along the paratenon
Procedure Pass the guide pins with suture through the jig designated hole-design
Procedure Once all sutures have been passed through, slide jig out
Procedure Place jig into distal part of incision and repeat prior steps
Procedure With foot in maximum plantarflexion, hand-tie sutures on medial and lateral side at the same time.
Procedure Closure/casting The paratenon and skin is closed with absorbable suture.   A short leg cast at 20 degrees of equinus, and the patient is instructed to be non-weight bearing with crutch assistance.
Procedure Post-operative After two weeks post operative, the patient is transitioned into a walking boot.  The gradual reduction of equinus performed utilizing removable heel lifts.  Physical therapy exercises initiated upon removal of the short leg cast.
Results Demographics satisfaction All patients returned to their previous professional or sporting activities.  All patients reported either satisfied with outcome or very satisfied.  There were thirteen males and six female with an average age of 45.2 The average follow-up examination post-operatively was 24.4 months
Results Clinical outcomes The mean VISA-A score was 92 (range, 66  to 100 points).
Results VAS complications Average pre-operative score 5.5 Average post-operative score 0.9 Paired student t-test P < 0.01 Complications occurred in two patients (11%).   One patient obtained an stitch abscess that resolved with local wound care.   One patient had a re-rupture eight weeks post-operative after falling at a carwash.   This was re-repaired the mini-open technique.
Discussion Incidence of Achilles tendon ruptures 18 in 100,000 per year and are believed to be increasing in incidence6.   At this time, debate still exists over the best treatment for this condition in regards to non-operative care, mini-open repair,percutaneous repair, and open repair of the tendon rupture7.
Discussion Our series using the mini-open technique has allowed for minimal complications with a high clinical outcome.  We did not experience any incidence of sural nerve injury although this has been reported in the literature with both mini-open and percutaneous repair2, 8-10
Discussion strengths weaknesses Validated clinical outcome measurement scale (VISA-A) Standardized procedure Small sample size No pre-operative measurement other than VAS Assessor Bias
Discussion Although we add to the body of evidence that the mini-open repair technique is effective and safe for Achilles tendon ruptures, more study is needed We believe the benefits to the patient of lower morbidity, minimal minor complications, and high satisfaction are the strengths of this procedure.
References Willits K et al. Operative versus nonoperative treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures: a multicenter randomized trial using accelerated functional rehabilitation.  JBJS AM. 2010 Dec 1;92(17):2767-75. Epub 2010 Oct 29 Calder JDF, Saxby TS Early, active rehabilitation following mini-open repair of Achilles tendon rupture: a prospective study. Br J Sports Med 2005;39:857–859.  Assal M, Jung M, Stern R, Rippstein P, Delmi M, Hoffmeyer P Limited Open Repair of Achilles Tendon Ruptures : A Technique with a New Instrument and Findings of a Prospective Multicenter Study.  J. Bone Joint Surg. Am. 84:161-170, 2002.  Calder JDF, Saxby T.S. Independent Evaluation of a Recently Described Achilles Tendon Repair Technique. Foot Ankle Int. 27(2):93-6  Robinson JM et al. The VISA-A questionnaire: a valid and reliable index of the clinical severity of Achilles tendinopathy. Br J Sports Med 2001;35:335–341   Costa M.L., Macmillan K., Halliday D., Chester R., Shepstone L., Robinson A.H.N., Donell S.T. Randomised controlled trials of immediate weight-bearing mobilisation for rupture of the tendoAchillis.  J Bone Joint Surg [Br] 2006;88-B:69-77.  Chiodo C, Wilson M Current Concepts Review: Acute Ruptures of the Achilles Tendon. Foot Ankle Int. 27(4):305-13  Ma GWC, Griffith TG. Percutaneous repair of acute closed ruptured Achilles tendon. A new technique. ClinOrthop 1977;128:247–55.  Webb J, Moorjani N, Radford M. Anatomy of the sural nerve and its relation to the Achilles tendon. Foot Ankle Int 2000;21(6):475–7.  Lim J, Dalal R, Waseem M. Percutaneous vs. open repair of the ruptured Achilles tendon – a prospective randomised controlled study. Foot Ankle Int 2001;22(7):559–68.  Parekh SG et al. Epidemiology and outcomes of Achilles tendon ruptures in the National Football League. Foot Ankle Spec 2009 Dec;2(6):283-6. Epub 2009 Oct 13.
Thank You

More Related Content

What's hot

Relationship between extrinsic factors and the acromio humeral distance (1)
Relationship between extrinsic factors and the acromio humeral distance (1)Relationship between extrinsic factors and the acromio humeral distance (1)
Relationship between extrinsic factors and the acromio humeral distance (1)The Arm Clinic
 
Arthritis basics and managment copy
Arthritis basics and managment copyArthritis basics and managment copy
Arthritis basics and managment copyPuneet Monga
 
ACJ revision surgery for failed reconstructions and excisions
ACJ revision surgery for failed reconstructions and excisionsACJ revision surgery for failed reconstructions and excisions
ACJ revision surgery for failed reconstructions and excisionsLennard Funk
 
The overhead athlete
The overhead athleteThe overhead athlete
The overhead athletePuneet Monga
 
Acromioclavicular joint arthritis
Acromioclavicular joint arthritisAcromioclavicular joint arthritis
Acromioclavicular joint arthritisDr. Zubair Younis
 
Labral injuries and traumatic instability
Labral injuries and traumatic instabilityLabral injuries and traumatic instability
Labral injuries and traumatic instabilityPuneet Monga
 
Results of Mini-Open Latarjet Procedure in Failed in Arthroscopic Bankart Rep...
Results of Mini-Open Latarjet Procedure in Failed in Arthroscopic Bankart Rep...Results of Mini-Open Latarjet Procedure in Failed in Arthroscopic Bankart Rep...
Results of Mini-Open Latarjet Procedure in Failed in Arthroscopic Bankart Rep...TheRightDoctors
 
Meniscus Transplant and Replacement
Meniscus Transplant and ReplacementMeniscus Transplant and Replacement
Meniscus Transplant and Replacementsfkneerobot
 
Management of Primary Traumatic Shoulder Instability
Management of Primary Traumatic Shoulder InstabilityManagement of Primary Traumatic Shoulder Instability
Management of Primary Traumatic Shoulder Instabilitywashingtonortho
 
Shoulder Arthritis | Shoulder Instability | South Windsor, Rocky Hill, Glasto...
Shoulder Arthritis | Shoulder Instability | South Windsor, Rocky Hill, Glasto...Shoulder Arthritis | Shoulder Instability | South Windsor, Rocky Hill, Glasto...
Shoulder Arthritis | Shoulder Instability | South Windsor, Rocky Hill, Glasto...James Mazzara
 
Ac dislocation
Ac dislocationAc dislocation
Ac dislocationsukesh a n
 
Dorsal Anatomic Plantar Plate Repair
Dorsal Anatomic Plantar Plate RepairDorsal Anatomic Plantar Plate Repair
Dorsal Anatomic Plantar Plate RepairWenjay Sung
 
Tendon transfers around the shoulder
Tendon transfers around the shoulderTendon transfers around the shoulder
Tendon transfers around the shoulderPuneet Monga
 
Latarjet – the panacea for traumatic anterior shoulder
Latarjet – the panacea for traumatic anterior shoulderLatarjet – the panacea for traumatic anterior shoulder
Latarjet – the panacea for traumatic anterior shoulderJeremy Granville-Chapman
 
Distal biceps tendon rupture - by Hussain Algawahmed
Distal biceps tendon rupture - by Hussain AlgawahmedDistal biceps tendon rupture - by Hussain Algawahmed
Distal biceps tendon rupture - by Hussain AlgawahmedHussainAlgawahmedMBB
 
ΑΝΑΘΕΩΡΗΣΗ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΠΛΑΣΤΙΚΗΣ ΠΡΟΣΘΙΟΥ ΧΙΑΣΤΟΥ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΥ ΓΟΝΑΤΟΣ ΜΕ ΑΝΑΤΟΜΙΚΗ ...
ΑΝΑΘΕΩΡΗΣΗ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΠΛΑΣΤΙΚΗΣ ΠΡΟΣΘΙΟΥ ΧΙΑΣΤΟΥ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΥ ΓΟΝΑΤΟΣ ΜΕ ΑΝΑΤΟΜΙΚΗ ...ΑΝΑΘΕΩΡΗΣΗ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΠΛΑΣΤΙΚΗΣ ΠΡΟΣΘΙΟΥ ΧΙΑΣΤΟΥ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΥ ΓΟΝΑΤΟΣ ΜΕ ΑΝΑΤΟΜΙΚΗ ...
ΑΝΑΘΕΩΡΗΣΗ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΠΛΑΣΤΙΚΗΣ ΠΡΟΣΘΙΟΥ ΧΙΑΣΤΟΥ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΥ ΓΟΝΑΤΟΣ ΜΕ ΑΝΑΤΟΜΙΚΗ ...STAVROS ALEVROGIANNIS
 
U01 clavicle ac_sc_joints1
U01 clavicle ac_sc_joints1U01 clavicle ac_sc_joints1
U01 clavicle ac_sc_joints1drthuraikumar
 
Acromioclavicular joint injury Andrew Gardner NWULG
Acromioclavicular joint injury Andrew Gardner NWULGAcromioclavicular joint injury Andrew Gardner NWULG
Acromioclavicular joint injury Andrew Gardner NWULGLennard Funk
 
Total shoulder arthroplasty and reverse TSA - Hussain Algawahmed
Total shoulder arthroplasty and reverse TSA - Hussain AlgawahmedTotal shoulder arthroplasty and reverse TSA - Hussain Algawahmed
Total shoulder arthroplasty and reverse TSA - Hussain AlgawahmedHussainAlgawahmedMBB
 

What's hot (20)

Relationship between extrinsic factors and the acromio humeral distance (1)
Relationship between extrinsic factors and the acromio humeral distance (1)Relationship between extrinsic factors and the acromio humeral distance (1)
Relationship between extrinsic factors and the acromio humeral distance (1)
 
Arthritis basics and managment copy
Arthritis basics and managment copyArthritis basics and managment copy
Arthritis basics and managment copy
 
ACJ revision surgery for failed reconstructions and excisions
ACJ revision surgery for failed reconstructions and excisionsACJ revision surgery for failed reconstructions and excisions
ACJ revision surgery for failed reconstructions and excisions
 
The overhead athlete
The overhead athleteThe overhead athlete
The overhead athlete
 
Acromioclavicular joint arthritis
Acromioclavicular joint arthritisAcromioclavicular joint arthritis
Acromioclavicular joint arthritis
 
Labral injuries and traumatic instability
Labral injuries and traumatic instabilityLabral injuries and traumatic instability
Labral injuries and traumatic instability
 
Results of Mini-Open Latarjet Procedure in Failed in Arthroscopic Bankart Rep...
Results of Mini-Open Latarjet Procedure in Failed in Arthroscopic Bankart Rep...Results of Mini-Open Latarjet Procedure in Failed in Arthroscopic Bankart Rep...
Results of Mini-Open Latarjet Procedure in Failed in Arthroscopic Bankart Rep...
 
Meniscus Transplant and Replacement
Meniscus Transplant and ReplacementMeniscus Transplant and Replacement
Meniscus Transplant and Replacement
 
Acj injury
Acj injuryAcj injury
Acj injury
 
Management of Primary Traumatic Shoulder Instability
Management of Primary Traumatic Shoulder InstabilityManagement of Primary Traumatic Shoulder Instability
Management of Primary Traumatic Shoulder Instability
 
Shoulder Arthritis | Shoulder Instability | South Windsor, Rocky Hill, Glasto...
Shoulder Arthritis | Shoulder Instability | South Windsor, Rocky Hill, Glasto...Shoulder Arthritis | Shoulder Instability | South Windsor, Rocky Hill, Glasto...
Shoulder Arthritis | Shoulder Instability | South Windsor, Rocky Hill, Glasto...
 
Ac dislocation
Ac dislocationAc dislocation
Ac dislocation
 
Dorsal Anatomic Plantar Plate Repair
Dorsal Anatomic Plantar Plate RepairDorsal Anatomic Plantar Plate Repair
Dorsal Anatomic Plantar Plate Repair
 
Tendon transfers around the shoulder
Tendon transfers around the shoulderTendon transfers around the shoulder
Tendon transfers around the shoulder
 
Latarjet – the panacea for traumatic anterior shoulder
Latarjet – the panacea for traumatic anterior shoulderLatarjet – the panacea for traumatic anterior shoulder
Latarjet – the panacea for traumatic anterior shoulder
 
Distal biceps tendon rupture - by Hussain Algawahmed
Distal biceps tendon rupture - by Hussain AlgawahmedDistal biceps tendon rupture - by Hussain Algawahmed
Distal biceps tendon rupture - by Hussain Algawahmed
 
ΑΝΑΘΕΩΡΗΣΗ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΠΛΑΣΤΙΚΗΣ ΠΡΟΣΘΙΟΥ ΧΙΑΣΤΟΥ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΥ ΓΟΝΑΤΟΣ ΜΕ ΑΝΑΤΟΜΙΚΗ ...
ΑΝΑΘΕΩΡΗΣΗ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΠΛΑΣΤΙΚΗΣ ΠΡΟΣΘΙΟΥ ΧΙΑΣΤΟΥ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΥ ΓΟΝΑΤΟΣ ΜΕ ΑΝΑΤΟΜΙΚΗ ...ΑΝΑΘΕΩΡΗΣΗ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΠΛΑΣΤΙΚΗΣ ΠΡΟΣΘΙΟΥ ΧΙΑΣΤΟΥ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΥ ΓΟΝΑΤΟΣ ΜΕ ΑΝΑΤΟΜΙΚΗ ...
ΑΝΑΘΕΩΡΗΣΗ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΠΛΑΣΤΙΚΗΣ ΠΡΟΣΘΙΟΥ ΧΙΑΣΤΟΥ ΣΥΝΔΕΣΜΟΥ ΓΟΝΑΤΟΣ ΜΕ ΑΝΑΤΟΜΙΚΗ ...
 
U01 clavicle ac_sc_joints1
U01 clavicle ac_sc_joints1U01 clavicle ac_sc_joints1
U01 clavicle ac_sc_joints1
 
Acromioclavicular joint injury Andrew Gardner NWULG
Acromioclavicular joint injury Andrew Gardner NWULGAcromioclavicular joint injury Andrew Gardner NWULG
Acromioclavicular joint injury Andrew Gardner NWULG
 
Total shoulder arthroplasty and reverse TSA - Hussain Algawahmed
Total shoulder arthroplasty and reverse TSA - Hussain AlgawahmedTotal shoulder arthroplasty and reverse TSA - Hussain Algawahmed
Total shoulder arthroplasty and reverse TSA - Hussain Algawahmed
 

Viewers also liked

Arthroereisis Lecture
Arthroereisis LectureArthroereisis Lecture
Arthroereisis LectureLEDocDave
 
BroströM Procedure Presentation
BroströM Procedure PresentationBroströM Procedure Presentation
BroströM Procedure PresentationLEDocDave
 
Mangled extremity
Mangled extremityMangled extremity
Mangled extremityRohit Vikas
 
Arthroscopic Stablization Cherry Blossom Test 2009
Arthroscopic Stablization Cherry Blossom Test 2009Arthroscopic Stablization Cherry Blossom Test 2009
Arthroscopic Stablization Cherry Blossom Test 2009haydenmac
 
Initial Assessment And Management
Initial Assessment And ManagementInitial Assessment And Management
Initial Assessment And Managementkk 555888
 
Approach To Overuse Related Shoulder Injuries
Approach To Overuse Related Shoulder InjuriesApproach To Overuse Related Shoulder Injuries
Approach To Overuse Related Shoulder InjuriesMedicineAndHealthUSA
 
Clinical examination of elbow joint
Clinical examination of elbow jointClinical examination of elbow joint
Clinical examination of elbow jointvaruntandra
 
Surgical site infection
Surgical site infectionSurgical site infection
Surgical site infectionorthoprince
 
Clinical evaluation of spine
Clinical evaluation of spineClinical evaluation of spine
Clinical evaluation of spineorthoprince
 
Reflex sympathetic dystrophy (1)
Reflex sympathetic dystrophy  (1)Reflex sympathetic dystrophy  (1)
Reflex sympathetic dystrophy (1)orthoprince
 
Osteotomies around hip by dr rohit kumar
Osteotomies around hip by dr rohit kumarOsteotomies around hip by dr rohit kumar
Osteotomies around hip by dr rohit kumarDr Rohit Kumar
 
Orthotic Management of Charcot Marie Tooth
Orthotic Management of Charcot Marie ToothOrthotic Management of Charcot Marie Tooth
Orthotic Management of Charcot Marie Toothorthotist
 
Metanalysis Lecture
Metanalysis LectureMetanalysis Lecture
Metanalysis Lecturedrmomusa
 
Supracondylar fractures in_children
Supracondylar fractures in_childrenSupracondylar fractures in_children
Supracondylar fractures in_childrenAhmad Naufal
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Arthroereisis Lecture
Arthroereisis LectureArthroereisis Lecture
Arthroereisis Lecture
 
BroströM Procedure Presentation
BroströM Procedure PresentationBroströM Procedure Presentation
BroströM Procedure Presentation
 
Mangled extremity
Mangled extremityMangled extremity
Mangled extremity
 
Arthroscopic Stablization Cherry Blossom Test 2009
Arthroscopic Stablization Cherry Blossom Test 2009Arthroscopic Stablization Cherry Blossom Test 2009
Arthroscopic Stablization Cherry Blossom Test 2009
 
Initial Assessment And Management
Initial Assessment And ManagementInitial Assessment And Management
Initial Assessment And Management
 
Disorders of the hallux
Disorders of the halluxDisorders of the hallux
Disorders of the hallux
 
Approach To Overuse Related Shoulder Injuries
Approach To Overuse Related Shoulder InjuriesApproach To Overuse Related Shoulder Injuries
Approach To Overuse Related Shoulder Injuries
 
Spinal Injuries
Spinal InjuriesSpinal Injuries
Spinal Injuries
 
Rcd osteo
Rcd osteoRcd osteo
Rcd osteo
 
Gait analysis
Gait analysisGait analysis
Gait analysis
 
Clinical examination of elbow joint
Clinical examination of elbow jointClinical examination of elbow joint
Clinical examination of elbow joint
 
Surgical site infection
Surgical site infectionSurgical site infection
Surgical site infection
 
Clinical evaluation of spine
Clinical evaluation of spineClinical evaluation of spine
Clinical evaluation of spine
 
ABC1 - R.E. Coleman - Bone metastases
ABC1 - R.E. Coleman - Bone metastases ABC1 - R.E. Coleman - Bone metastases
ABC1 - R.E. Coleman - Bone metastases
 
Limb salvage
Limb salvageLimb salvage
Limb salvage
 
Reflex sympathetic dystrophy (1)
Reflex sympathetic dystrophy  (1)Reflex sympathetic dystrophy  (1)
Reflex sympathetic dystrophy (1)
 
Osteotomies around hip by dr rohit kumar
Osteotomies around hip by dr rohit kumarOsteotomies around hip by dr rohit kumar
Osteotomies around hip by dr rohit kumar
 
Orthotic Management of Charcot Marie Tooth
Orthotic Management of Charcot Marie ToothOrthotic Management of Charcot Marie Tooth
Orthotic Management of Charcot Marie Tooth
 
Metanalysis Lecture
Metanalysis LectureMetanalysis Lecture
Metanalysis Lecture
 
Supracondylar fractures in_children
Supracondylar fractures in_childrenSupracondylar fractures in_children
Supracondylar fractures in_children
 

Similar to Retrospective analysis on mini-open technique for Achilles tendon repair

Results of Mini-Open Technique
Results of Mini-Open TechniqueResults of Mini-Open Technique
Results of Mini-Open TechniqueWenjay Sung
 
No effect on functional outcome after repair pronator quadratus
No effect on functional outcome after repair pronator quadratus No effect on functional outcome after repair pronator quadratus
No effect on functional outcome after repair pronator quadratus Sufindc
 
5. PCL repair
5. PCL repair5. PCL repair
5. PCL repairdrajun
 
Arthroplasty: Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
Arthroplasty:  Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI Arthroplasty:  Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
Arthroplasty: Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI DR. D. P. SWAMI
 
Rotator cuff-repair-study
Rotator cuff-repair-studyRotator cuff-repair-study
Rotator cuff-repair-studySoulderPain
 
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...Dr.Avinash Rao Gundavarapu
 
Clinical efficacy of multiple prevention measures against infection following...
Clinical efficacy of multiple prevention measures against infection following...Clinical efficacy of multiple prevention measures against infection following...
Clinical efficacy of multiple prevention measures against infection following...Clinical Surgery Research Communications
 
11. Frozen shoulder and Hydroplasty
11.  Frozen shoulder and Hydroplasty11.  Frozen shoulder and Hydroplasty
11. Frozen shoulder and Hydroplastydrajun
 
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...Crimsonpublisherssmoaj
 
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...Crimsonpublisherssmoaj
 
Anotomic-Biological Reconstruction of Acromio-Clavicular Joint Injuries-Dr. U...
Anotomic-Biological Reconstruction of Acromio-Clavicular Joint Injuries-Dr. U...Anotomic-Biological Reconstruction of Acromio-Clavicular Joint Injuries-Dr. U...
Anotomic-Biological Reconstruction of Acromio-Clavicular Joint Injuries-Dr. U...TheRightDoctors
 
Journal Club Presentation
Journal Club PresentationJournal Club Presentation
Journal Club PresentationSyed Adil
 
Rotator cuff-repair-study
Rotator cuff-repair-studyRotator cuff-repair-study
Rotator cuff-repair-studySoulderPain
 
Short Term Analysis of Clinical, Functional Radiological Outcome of Total Kne...
Short Term Analysis of Clinical, Functional Radiological Outcome of Total Kne...Short Term Analysis of Clinical, Functional Radiological Outcome of Total Kne...
Short Term Analysis of Clinical, Functional Radiological Outcome of Total Kne...iosrjce
 
A Preliminary Report Of Outcomes In Arthroscopic Rotator Repair With Extracel...
A Preliminary Report Of Outcomes In Arthroscopic Rotator Repair With Extracel...A Preliminary Report Of Outcomes In Arthroscopic Rotator Repair With Extracel...
A Preliminary Report Of Outcomes In Arthroscopic Rotator Repair With Extracel...Professor M. A. Imam
 
Effectiveness of cpm and conventional physical therapy after total knee arthr...
Effectiveness of cpm and conventional physical therapy after total knee arthr...Effectiveness of cpm and conventional physical therapy after total knee arthr...
Effectiveness of cpm and conventional physical therapy after total knee arthr...FUAD HAZIME
 

Similar to Retrospective analysis on mini-open technique for Achilles tendon repair (20)

Results of Mini-Open Technique
Results of Mini-Open TechniqueResults of Mini-Open Technique
Results of Mini-Open Technique
 
No effect on functional outcome after repair pronator quadratus
No effect on functional outcome after repair pronator quadratus No effect on functional outcome after repair pronator quadratus
No effect on functional outcome after repair pronator quadratus
 
5. PCL repair
5. PCL repair5. PCL repair
5. PCL repair
 
Arthroplasty: Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
Arthroplasty:  Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI Arthroplasty:  Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
Arthroplasty: Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
 
Rotator cuff-repair-study
Rotator cuff-repair-studyRotator cuff-repair-study
Rotator cuff-repair-study
 
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
 
Clinical efficacy of multiple prevention measures against infection following...
Clinical efficacy of multiple prevention measures against infection following...Clinical efficacy of multiple prevention measures against infection following...
Clinical efficacy of multiple prevention measures against infection following...
 
Management of displaced_patella_fracture
Management of displaced_patella_fractureManagement of displaced_patella_fracture
Management of displaced_patella_fracture
 
11. Frozen shoulder and Hydroplasty
11.  Frozen shoulder and Hydroplasty11.  Frozen shoulder and Hydroplasty
11. Frozen shoulder and Hydroplasty
 
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
 
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
Comparison of Modified Kessler Technique versus Four Strand Cruciate Techniqu...
 
Anotomic-Biological Reconstruction of Acromio-Clavicular Joint Injuries-Dr. U...
Anotomic-Biological Reconstruction of Acromio-Clavicular Joint Injuries-Dr. U...Anotomic-Biological Reconstruction of Acromio-Clavicular Joint Injuries-Dr. U...
Anotomic-Biological Reconstruction of Acromio-Clavicular Joint Injuries-Dr. U...
 
Strabismus Surgeries for Cranial Nerve Palsies
Strabismus Surgeries for Cranial Nerve PalsiesStrabismus Surgeries for Cranial Nerve Palsies
Strabismus Surgeries for Cranial Nerve Palsies
 
Journal Club Presentation
Journal Club PresentationJournal Club Presentation
Journal Club Presentation
 
Rotator cuff-repair-study
Rotator cuff-repair-studyRotator cuff-repair-study
Rotator cuff-repair-study
 
Re-operation Rates After Combined ACL and Anterolateral Ligament Reconstruction
Re-operation Rates After Combined ACL and Anterolateral Ligament ReconstructionRe-operation Rates After Combined ACL and Anterolateral Ligament Reconstruction
Re-operation Rates After Combined ACL and Anterolateral Ligament Reconstruction
 
Short Term Analysis of Clinical, Functional Radiological Outcome of Total Kne...
Short Term Analysis of Clinical, Functional Radiological Outcome of Total Kne...Short Term Analysis of Clinical, Functional Radiological Outcome of Total Kne...
Short Term Analysis of Clinical, Functional Radiological Outcome of Total Kne...
 
A Preliminary Report Of Outcomes In Arthroscopic Rotator Repair With Extracel...
A Preliminary Report Of Outcomes In Arthroscopic Rotator Repair With Extracel...A Preliminary Report Of Outcomes In Arthroscopic Rotator Repair With Extracel...
A Preliminary Report Of Outcomes In Arthroscopic Rotator Repair With Extracel...
 
Ortho Journal Club 5 by Dr Saumya Agarwal
Ortho Journal Club 5 by Dr Saumya AgarwalOrtho Journal Club 5 by Dr Saumya Agarwal
Ortho Journal Club 5 by Dr Saumya Agarwal
 
Effectiveness of cpm and conventional physical therapy after total knee arthr...
Effectiveness of cpm and conventional physical therapy after total knee arthr...Effectiveness of cpm and conventional physical therapy after total knee arthr...
Effectiveness of cpm and conventional physical therapy after total knee arthr...
 

More from Wenjay Sung

Hammer Toe Correction Comparative Study
Hammer Toe Correction Comparative StudyHammer Toe Correction Comparative Study
Hammer Toe Correction Comparative StudyWenjay Sung
 
Prediction of Plantar Plate Injury using MRI
Prediction of Plantar Plate Injury using MRIPrediction of Plantar Plate Injury using MRI
Prediction of Plantar Plate Injury using MRIWenjay Sung
 
The consequences of complacency: managing the effects of unrecognized Charco...
The consequences of complacency:  managing the effects of unrecognized Charco...The consequences of complacency:  managing the effects of unrecognized Charco...
The consequences of complacency: managing the effects of unrecognized Charco...Wenjay Sung
 
Radiographic Analysis of Metatarsophalangeal joint Arthrodesis for Hallux Val...
Radiographic Analysis of Metatarsophalangeal joint Arthrodesis for Hallux Val...Radiographic Analysis of Metatarsophalangeal joint Arthrodesis for Hallux Val...
Radiographic Analysis of Metatarsophalangeal joint Arthrodesis for Hallux Val...Wenjay Sung
 
Case-control Study on 2nd Hammertoe Deformity Correction Techniques
Case-control Study on 2nd Hammertoe Deformity Correction TechniquesCase-control Study on 2nd Hammertoe Deformity Correction Techniques
Case-control Study on 2nd Hammertoe Deformity Correction TechniquesWenjay Sung
 
Anatomic Plantar Plate Repair
Anatomic Plantar Plate RepairAnatomic Plantar Plate Repair
Anatomic Plantar Plate RepairWenjay Sung
 

More from Wenjay Sung (6)

Hammer Toe Correction Comparative Study
Hammer Toe Correction Comparative StudyHammer Toe Correction Comparative Study
Hammer Toe Correction Comparative Study
 
Prediction of Plantar Plate Injury using MRI
Prediction of Plantar Plate Injury using MRIPrediction of Plantar Plate Injury using MRI
Prediction of Plantar Plate Injury using MRI
 
The consequences of complacency: managing the effects of unrecognized Charco...
The consequences of complacency:  managing the effects of unrecognized Charco...The consequences of complacency:  managing the effects of unrecognized Charco...
The consequences of complacency: managing the effects of unrecognized Charco...
 
Radiographic Analysis of Metatarsophalangeal joint Arthrodesis for Hallux Val...
Radiographic Analysis of Metatarsophalangeal joint Arthrodesis for Hallux Val...Radiographic Analysis of Metatarsophalangeal joint Arthrodesis for Hallux Val...
Radiographic Analysis of Metatarsophalangeal joint Arthrodesis for Hallux Val...
 
Case-control Study on 2nd Hammertoe Deformity Correction Techniques
Case-control Study on 2nd Hammertoe Deformity Correction TechniquesCase-control Study on 2nd Hammertoe Deformity Correction Techniques
Case-control Study on 2nd Hammertoe Deformity Correction Techniques
 
Anatomic Plantar Plate Repair
Anatomic Plantar Plate RepairAnatomic Plantar Plate Repair
Anatomic Plantar Plate Repair
 

Retrospective analysis on mini-open technique for Achilles tendon repair

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3. Overview Purpose Methods Statistical Analysis Procedure Results Discussion
  • 4. Purpose There is a recent report favoring non-operative treatment for acute Achilles tendon ruptures1 The consensus in the literature favors operative treatment.
  • 5. Purpose Most studies have shown surgical intervention produces few complications and less re-rupture Athletes regain ~50% of post-injury power after tendon repair.11 32% of NFL players do not return to sport
  • 6. Purpose More recently, a single incision (mini-open) technique has been reported2-4. Our retrospective series aims to report outcomes using this mini-open technique over the last eight years.
  • 7. Purpose RETROSPECTIVE CASE SERIES Level of evidence: IV (Therapeutic)
  • 8. Methods Reviewed the medical records for 40 consecutive patients who underwent an Achilles tendon repair between January 2002 and December 2009 There were 19 patients (19 cases) who underwent a mini-open technique. Followed for an average of 24.4 months (range 12 to 68 months).
  • 9. Methods All patients were assessed clinically Victorian Institute of Sports Assessment - Achilles (VISA-A) score5 Visual Analog Pain Scale (VAS) Any post-operative complications and re-ruptures was also recorded.
  • 10. Statistical Analysis A paired student t-test was used to determine significance between pre-operative and post-operative outcomes with p < 0.01.
  • 11. Procedure An incision is placed ~1cm proximal to palpable dell
  • 12. Procedure Advance the jig with inner arms along the paratenon
  • 13. Procedure Pass the guide pins with suture through the jig designated hole-design
  • 14. Procedure Once all sutures have been passed through, slide jig out
  • 15. Procedure Place jig into distal part of incision and repeat prior steps
  • 16. Procedure With foot in maximum plantarflexion, hand-tie sutures on medial and lateral side at the same time.
  • 17. Procedure Closure/casting The paratenon and skin is closed with absorbable suture. A short leg cast at 20 degrees of equinus, and the patient is instructed to be non-weight bearing with crutch assistance.
  • 18. Procedure Post-operative After two weeks post operative, the patient is transitioned into a walking boot. The gradual reduction of equinus performed utilizing removable heel lifts. Physical therapy exercises initiated upon removal of the short leg cast.
  • 19. Results Demographics satisfaction All patients returned to their previous professional or sporting activities. All patients reported either satisfied with outcome or very satisfied. There were thirteen males and six female with an average age of 45.2 The average follow-up examination post-operatively was 24.4 months
  • 20. Results Clinical outcomes The mean VISA-A score was 92 (range, 66 to 100 points).
  • 21. Results VAS complications Average pre-operative score 5.5 Average post-operative score 0.9 Paired student t-test P < 0.01 Complications occurred in two patients (11%). One patient obtained an stitch abscess that resolved with local wound care. One patient had a re-rupture eight weeks post-operative after falling at a carwash. This was re-repaired the mini-open technique.
  • 22. Discussion Incidence of Achilles tendon ruptures 18 in 100,000 per year and are believed to be increasing in incidence6. At this time, debate still exists over the best treatment for this condition in regards to non-operative care, mini-open repair,percutaneous repair, and open repair of the tendon rupture7.
  • 23. Discussion Our series using the mini-open technique has allowed for minimal complications with a high clinical outcome. We did not experience any incidence of sural nerve injury although this has been reported in the literature with both mini-open and percutaneous repair2, 8-10
  • 24. Discussion strengths weaknesses Validated clinical outcome measurement scale (VISA-A) Standardized procedure Small sample size No pre-operative measurement other than VAS Assessor Bias
  • 25. Discussion Although we add to the body of evidence that the mini-open repair technique is effective and safe for Achilles tendon ruptures, more study is needed We believe the benefits to the patient of lower morbidity, minimal minor complications, and high satisfaction are the strengths of this procedure.
  • 26. References Willits K et al. Operative versus nonoperative treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures: a multicenter randomized trial using accelerated functional rehabilitation. JBJS AM. 2010 Dec 1;92(17):2767-75. Epub 2010 Oct 29 Calder JDF, Saxby TS Early, active rehabilitation following mini-open repair of Achilles tendon rupture: a prospective study. Br J Sports Med 2005;39:857–859. Assal M, Jung M, Stern R, Rippstein P, Delmi M, Hoffmeyer P Limited Open Repair of Achilles Tendon Ruptures : A Technique with a New Instrument and Findings of a Prospective Multicenter Study. J. Bone Joint Surg. Am. 84:161-170, 2002. Calder JDF, Saxby T.S. Independent Evaluation of a Recently Described Achilles Tendon Repair Technique. Foot Ankle Int. 27(2):93-6 Robinson JM et al. The VISA-A questionnaire: a valid and reliable index of the clinical severity of Achilles tendinopathy. Br J Sports Med 2001;35:335–341 Costa M.L., Macmillan K., Halliday D., Chester R., Shepstone L., Robinson A.H.N., Donell S.T. Randomised controlled trials of immediate weight-bearing mobilisation for rupture of the tendoAchillis. J Bone Joint Surg [Br] 2006;88-B:69-77. Chiodo C, Wilson M Current Concepts Review: Acute Ruptures of the Achilles Tendon. Foot Ankle Int. 27(4):305-13 Ma GWC, Griffith TG. Percutaneous repair of acute closed ruptured Achilles tendon. A new technique. ClinOrthop 1977;128:247–55. Webb J, Moorjani N, Radford M. Anatomy of the sural nerve and its relation to the Achilles tendon. Foot Ankle Int 2000;21(6):475–7. Lim J, Dalal R, Waseem M. Percutaneous vs. open repair of the ruptured Achilles tendon – a prospective randomised controlled study. Foot Ankle Int 2001;22(7):559–68. Parekh SG et al. Epidemiology and outcomes of Achilles tendon ruptures in the National Football League. Foot Ankle Spec 2009 Dec;2(6):283-6. Epub 2009 Oct 13.