SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 12
Baixar para ler offline
Special Theme — Child Mortality



The evolution of child health programmes in
developing countries: from targeting diseases
to targeting people
Mariam Claeson1 & Ronald J. Waldman2



                   Mortality rates among children and the absolute number of children dying annually in developing countries have
                   declined considerably over the past few decades. However, the gains made have not been distributed evenly:
                   childhood mortality remains higher among poorer people and the gap between rich and poor has grown. Several poor
                   countries, and some poorer regions within countries, have experienced a levelling off of or even an increase in
                   childhood mortality over the past few years. Until now, two types of programmes — short-term, disease-specific
                   initiatives and more general programmes of primary health care — have contributed to the decline in mortality. Both
                   types of programme can contribute substantially to the strengthening of health systems and in enabling households
                   and communities to improve their health care. In order for them to do so, and in order to complete the unfinished
                   agenda of improving child health globally, new strategies are needed. On the one hand, greater emphasis should be
                   placed on promoting those household behaviours that are not dependent on the performance of health systems. On
                   the other hand, more attention should be paid to interventions that affect health at other stages of the life cycle while
                   efforts that have been made to develop interventions that can be used during childhood continue.

                   Keywords: child welfare; child health services, trends; communicable diseases, prevention and control; delivery of
                   health care; infant mortality, trends; models, theoretical.
                   Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78: 1234–1245.


               Voir page 1243 le resume en francais. En la pagina 1244 figura un resumen en espanol.
                                  ´   ´        ¸            ´                                   ˜


               Introduction                                                               50 countries the mortality for children under 5 years
                                                                                          was greater than 100 deaths per 1000 live births. In
               For the past 35 years, the steep decline in deaths                         12 countries (11 of them in Africa), one in every
               among infants and children has provided evidence of                        five children born alive did not survive to the age of
               an important success story in international develop-                       five years (1). Of the nearly 11 million children who
               ment. Mortality has declined steadily at an average of                     will die before their fifth birthday this year, 70% will
               about 1% per year. The absolute number of children                         die from a disease, a combination of a few diseases,
               under the age of 5 years dying has fallen from an                          or a condition for which safe and effective
               estimated 15 million in 1980 to about 11 million at the                    interventions are readily available in industrialized
               end of the 1990s (1). Remarkably, this decline has                         countries: acute respiratory infections, diarrhoea,
               occurred in the face of increased births, spreading                        measles, malaria, and malnutrition (2).
               resistance to commonly used antibiotics and anti-                                 Better access to basic health services —
               malarial drugs and, most menacingly, the growth of                         including vaccinations, oral rehydration therapy,
               the AIDS pandemic.                                                         and antibiotics for pneumonia — together with
                      A closer look at this favourable trend,                             improvements in social conditions — including
               however, reveals that progress has been distributed                        higher standards of living and smaller families living
               unevenly. Recently, the decline in mortality among                         on larger incomes — have been important factors in
               children under 5 years has stalled in a number of                          improving the survival rate of children. As deaths
               countries and in some the trend has reversed and                           among children under 5 years have declined in many
               mortality seems to be rising. In 1998, in more than                        developing countries, contributing to both demo-
                                                                                          graphic and epidemiological transitions, the propor-
               1
                                                                                          tional mortality accounted for by some conditions
                 Principal Public Health Specialist, Health, Nutrition, and Population,   has increased: this problem has been relatively
               Human Development Department, World Bank, Washington, DC,
               20433, USA (email: mclaeson@worldbank.org). Correspondence                 ignored by the international health community. For
               should be addressed to this author.                                        example, the greatest decline in childhood mortality
               2
                 Professor of Clinical Public Health and Director, Program on             rates has occurred among children in the post-
               Forced Migration and Health, Center for Population and Family Health,      neonatal period; this has led to a relative increase in
               Joseph L. Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University,            the importance of neonatal and perinatal mortality.
               New York, USA.
                                                                                          Also, gender-specific issues have emerged in some
               Ref. No. 00-0762


1234           #   World Health Organization 2000                                                  Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries

parts of the world, notably on the Indian subconti-        programmes must, when possible, promote com-
nent where girls aged between 1 month and 5 years          munity involvement while contributing to the on-
still experience considerably higher mortality and         going development and strengthening of national
morbidity than boys (3, 4). And, although this paper       health systems (6).
does not deal with it specifically, increases in deaths           Similarly, a debate over the degree to which the
from AIDS in Africa are already slowing or reversing       objectives of primary health care can be translated
these downward trends. Without a major assault on          into effective programmes resulted in the emergence
AIDS throughout local health systems and in the            of ‘‘selective primary health care’’ (7). This new
community, childhood mortality, whether from               strategy, which targeted the control of diseases
infection or from the increased risks associated with      identified as the most important contributors to
being orphaned, can be expected to increase in some        increased mortality, was intended to be more focused
parts of the world.                                        and more feasible. A number of specific, more
       In this paper, we examine the roots from which      vertical programmes (so named because of the self-
current child health programmes have grown, some of        contained way they appear on organizational charts
the causes behind the apparent slowing of progress in      and, more importantly, in budget lines of health
many parts of the world, and we suggest ways in which      ministries) were promoted to channel relatively
the nature of these programmes must change if              meagre resources into areas in which demonstrable
continued gains are to be made throughout the world.       success could be achieved in the medium-term.
                                                           Furthermore, the emphasis was clearly put on
                                                           programmes that would contribute to achieving
                                                           decreases in mortality among infants and children,
Trends and milestones                                      since children were considered to be the most
Global strategies for reducing childhood mortality         vulnerable segment of the population because they
have been of two basic types. The first were               have the highest rates of preventable death.
ambitious disease-specific, technologically depen-                The World Health Organization, for example,
dent strategies aimed at achieving dramatic, albeit        first developed the Expanded Programme on
narrow, successes in a relatively short time. The          Immunization and subsequently the Programme
notable failure of the most ambitious programme of         for the Control of Diarrhoeal Diseases. UNICEF
this type — the malaria eradication programme (not         chose four specific interventions on which to focus:
exclusively a child health programme, but one that         growth monitoring, oral rehydration therapy, breast-
was expected to make a major contribution to               feeding promotion, and immunization, known by the
reducing child mortality) launched in the 1950s and        acronym GOBI. It later added three more (food,
abandoned in the 1970s — contributed strongly to a         family planning, and female education). Bilateral
shift in thinking (5).                                     donors followed, channelling funds into what came
       The more people-centred, community-based            to be called ‘‘child survival’’ programmes; these
strategy typified by primary health care, with its goal    retained their roots in community-oriented, popula-
of health for all by the year 2000, was adopted by the     tion-based, primary health care, but at the same time
World Health Assembly in 1977. Primary health care         had the appeal of using relatively inexpensive medical
sought to broaden the focus of health services by          technologies to reach specific, stated objectives.
emphasizing programmatic areas instead of specific                Although the two strategies, at different ends
diseases. Accordingly, the provision of universal          of the intervention spectrum, have been able to
services for maternal and child health, family             coexist relatively peacefully, they have never quite
planning, improved water supplies, and environ-            coalesced. Currently, several attempts at rapproche-
mental sanitation became objectives; these were to be      ment are under way. For example, the multi-agency
achieved through an equitable distribution of              Roll Back Malaria movement includes components
resources, community involvement, an emphasis on           aimed at health systems and at the community.
prevention instead of clinic-based curative interven-      Reduced rates of morbidity and death from malaria, it
tions, and a multisectoral approach.                       suggests, should be viewed as markers of improved
       Neither strategic approach ever totally eclipsed    health systems. Similarly, the Integrated Management
the other. Although attempts to eradicate malaria          of Childhood Illness initiative explicitly incorporates
failed, the ensuing smallpox eradication programme         a component of community development; this
is probably the most successful large-scale public         programme evolved from selective primary health
health programme in history, with the last case of         care programmes that aimed to control diarrhoeal
smallpox acquired by human-to-human transmission           diseases and acute respiratory infections in childhood
having occurred in 1977. Important lessons have            by working with health workers and strengthening
been learnt from both the failed malaria eradication       health systems. Both of these efforts, and many
programme and the successful smallpox programme;           others currently being implemented (including the
these lessons have been applied to current attempts        poliomyelitis and dracunculiasis eradication pro-
to eradicate dracunculiasis and poliomyelitis, two         grammes) emphasize the need for community
programmes which are on the verge of success. To an        participation, for strong and effective partnerships
important degree, the appeal of these programmes is        between public and private sectors, for intersectoral
rooted in the acceptance that disease-specific             links, and the need to combine medical technology

Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)                                                               1235
Special Theme — Child Mortality

               with behavioural interventions. That is, they recog-        reviews influenced the direction of global efforts in
               nize these needs in rhetoric, if not in practice. This      preventing and controlling childhood acute respira-
               reflects current thinking as to how programmes to           tory infections and diarrhoea.
               improve children’s health should be implemented,                   In the 1990s, research priorities have evolved
               not necessarily how resources are being invested.           as efforts to develop a more integrated approach to
               Although emphasis on community-level interven-              case management both in the home and within the
               tions is generally recognized to be a desirable and         health system have intensified. The success of case-
               effective approach to implementing successful               management strategies depends only in part upon
               programmes, activities still tend to focus on improv-       the availability of services provided by trained health
               ing the delivery of services through an organized           care workers. Equally important, if not more so, are
               health system, rather than on effecting behavioural         the behaviours of the carer in the home and in the
               change.                                                     community. Case management in the home, care-
                                                                           seeking practices (including the extent to which
                                                                           available health services are used), and compliance
               The past: research and action                               with counselling provided by health workers all have
                                                                           an important impact on children’s health. Research
               The recognition that there were multiple technical          priorities have therefore focused increasingly on
               and operational challenges to the implementation of         promoting and maintaining household and commu-
               child health and nutrition programmes over the past         nity support for the home management of childhood
               20 years led to an evolution of research priorities (8).    illnesses (with appropriate referral when indicated)
               Before 1985, microbiological, epidemiological, im-          through interventions designed to encourage com-
               munological, and clinical research contributed to the       munication and change behaviour. Ethnographic
               development of both preventive and therapeutic              research, participatory rural appraisal, and other
               interventions for the control of common diseases in         qualitative methods have been the tools that have
               childhood. A prototypical example is the finding that       guided the development, local adaptation, and imple-
               treatment of acute, watery diarrhoea did not depend         mentation of many of these effective, community-
               on the etiological agent and that oral rehydration          level interventions (11).
               therapy with a single, standard solution is safe and               To a considerable extent, the progress in
               effective in almost all cases; this finding shaped global   reducing childhood mortality rates is the result of
               treatment policies for childhood diarrhoeal diseases.       efficient interactions between research, analysis,
               Similarly, the identification of Streptococcus pneumoniae   policy development, and programme evaluation.
               and Haemophilus influenzae as the leading bacterial         The cycle — which includes the dissemination of
               causes of mortality from pneumonia led to the               research findings, implementation of programmes
               development of a universal case-management strat-           based on those findings, and feedback regarding
               egy based on symptomatic diagnosis and standar-             successes and failures — has involved the research
               dized antibiotic treatment. After the development of        community, bilateral and international donors, health
               these technical approaches, research priorities shifted     ministries, and nongovernmental organizations in
               from focusing on incidence, etiology, and other             developed and developing countries. WHO has
               descriptive research to focusing on analytical research     played a critical part in the analysis and formulation
               that was directed at designing, monitoring, and             of policy and has provided guidance in implementing
               evaluating the impact of priority interventions.            and evaluating efforts in various countries.
                      For example, in the mid-1980s, the World
               Health Organization commissioned a review of
               research that might contribute to determining the
               potential effectiveness, feasibility, and cost of 18 sug-
                                                                           The present: new initiatives
               gested preventive interventions for childhood diar-         and programmatic approaches
               rhoea (9). The most promising were found to be              For much of the past few decades, the international
               promoting breastfeeding, improving water supplies,          health agenda has been dominated by strategies and
               modifying sanitation and hygiene behaviours, in-            programmes aimed at reducing mortality in child-
               creasing measles vaccination coverage and, after            hood. Reich proposes a number of reasons why this
               development of the appropriate technologies was             was the case. For one, it was important that children’s
               ensured, vaccinating against rotavirus infections and       health problems were being addressed by large,
               cholera. Similar reviews were done for the Pro-             influential organizations, including UNICEF, WHO,
               gramme on Acute Respiratory Infections in the 1990s         and public–private coalitions, such as the Task Force
               (10). This process identified eight potential interven-     for Child Survival and Development. They also had
               tions, each with the ability to prevent at least 5% of      symbolic power in the emotional appeal of being able
               deaths from pneumonia. These were vaccinating               to save children’s lives with simple, cheap interven-
               children against measles, S. pneumoniae, H. influenzae      tions. Also, with the exception of the infant formula
               type B, and respiratory syncytial virus; minimizing         industry, children’s health issues posed no competi-
               indoor air pollution; reducing the rates of children        tion to vested corporate interests. Additionally,
               born at low birth weight; and exclusively breastfeed-       science was on its side: the use of infant mortality
               ing until the child was aged 4–6 months. These              rates as a proxy for national health status and

1236                                                                              Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries

development called attention to the causes of early        supervision, monitoring, training, and supplying
deaths and to the interventions that could be aimed at     drugs or vaccines. Without the technical and
them. Finally, for the most part, the agenda setters —     programmatic support to which they have become
that is, the politicians — found that child health is a    accustomed, and which cannot be made available at
readily accepted cause that meets with little opposi-      the provincial or district level in most developing
tion when proposed as a subject for social investment      countries, child health services are at risk of levelling
(12). It should also be mentioned that childhood           off or even declining in both quantity and quality.
illnesses make a substantial contribution to the global           At the same time, child health programmes,
burden of disease (the Integrated Management of            especially vaccination programmes, have benefited
Childhood Illness strategy alone, at the time it was       from major new funding from non-traditional sources.
formulated, addressed conditions that accounted for        Although it seems as if some of the activities being
as much as 14% of disability-adjusted life years) (13),    pursued may be contradictory, the potential for each
and high mortality rates in children under 5 years of      activity to help reduce childhood mortality is evident. A
age are an important contributor to reduced life           few of the more prominent initiatives currently being
expectancy in developing countries.                        implemented around the world are discussed below.
       Recently, however, the primacy of child health
concerns has been challenged, although most
advocates of adolescent and adult health pro-              Vaccination strategies
grammes agree that it is not useful to promote
competition between intiatives that target other age       Vaccine-preventable diseases are responsible for a
groups and and those aimed at child health problems        significant proportion of the approximately 11 mil-
(14). Yet, unless careful attention is paid to             lion deaths that occur annually among children under
consolidating the gains made to date and to reversing      5 years of age (Table 1). Yet, nowhere is the contrast
emerging negative trends in some parts of the world,       between short-term disease-specific programmes
the gap in life expectancy between richer and poorer       and long-term developmental programmes more
nations, and between rich and poor within nations,         evident than in the area of childhood vaccination.
may continue to grow. Preventing this situation will       Two contemporary vaccination strategies have
require continued emphasis on controlling commu-           received massive support from both the public and
nicable diseases, especially those diseases that affect    private sectors. The highest profile public health
children disproportionately (15).                          programme is the initiative to eradicate poliomyelitis.
                                                           Supported by a 1988 resolution of the World Health
                                                           Assembly (16) and by a major coalition of interna-
                                                           tional agencies and private organizations, the drive to
Health sector reforms                                      eradicate poliomyelitis is a direct descendant of
Even if resources for child health are maintained at       previous eradication programmes. Based on a
current levels or increased, strategies will have to be    strategy of multiple national mass immunization days
adapted to current trends. Presently, many health          accompanied by intensified surveillance, poliomyeli-
activities in a large number of developing countries       tis has been eliminated from industrialized countries
are unfolding in an environment of health sector           and is on the verge of being eradicated worldwide.
reform. Donor support seems to have shifted from                  The concept of poliomyelitis eradication is
specific programmes to the development of leaner           laudable. If successful, it will rid the world of a disease
and potentially more efficient administrative and          which causes permanent disability and it will allow for
managerial structures. Typical features of most health     the cessation of the production, distribution, and
reform efforts are the decentralization of budgetary       administration of poliomyelitis vaccine. It will give
and, sometimes, programmatic authority to provin-          public health workers around the world a tangible
cial or district levels and the administrative integra-    success and, perhaps, provide strong motivation for
tion of centralized programmes. These reform               achieving comparable success in other health pro-
processes and sectorwide approaches can provide            grammes. However, poliomyelitis does not contribute
opportunities to identify priority problems and more       substantially to the global burden of disease, and its
cost-effective and affordable interventions. Addi-         eradication will not appreciably affect childhood
tionally, they may aid the development of sustainable      mortality rates. Furthermore, despite the heroic
health systems that are capable of devising local          mobilization efforts that have been undertaken for
solutions for local problems. However, there has           mass immunization days to be successful, eradication
been less emphasis put on maintaining the quality of       is ultimately dependent upon the ability of a health
the more traditional, technically dependent pro-           system to organize special campaigns for the delivery
grammes such as those dealing with childhood               of services. A strong partnership between commu-
diseases, including the Expanded Programme on              nities and the health system is a fundamental
Immunization, the Control of Diarrhoeal Diseases           requirement but, unless it is made an explicit goal,
programme, the Programme on Acute Respiratory              there is little transfer of responsibility to parents and
Infections, and nutrition. For example, decentraliza-      communities. So, in some countries, although im-
tion has often been accompanied by a reduction in          munization days have been successful, vaccination
support for essential programme activities such as         coverage with antigens other than those for polio-


Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)                                                                 1237
Special Theme — Child Mortality


 Table 1. Annual deaths due to vaccine-preventable diseases (21 )                       eradication initiative, the global alliance is a public–
                                                                                        private consortium whose principal members are
 Disease                                                     No. of preventable         WHO, UNICEF, the World Bank, national govern-
                                                               annual deaths            ments, public health and research institutions, the
                                                                                        Rockefeller Foundation, the International Federation
 Poliomyelitis                                                          720             of Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Associations, and
 Diphtheria                                                            5000             the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.
 Pertussis                                                          346 000                      The global alliance reports that although
 Measles                                                            888 000
                                                                                        children in developing countries are scheduled by
 Tetanus (including 215 000 neonatal deaths)                        410 000
                                                                                        their national immunization programmes to receive six
 Haemophilus influenzae type b                                      400 000
                                                                                        or seven antigens as part of their routine series of
 Hepatitis Ba                                                       900 000
                                                                                        vaccination, children in the wealthier countries in
 Yellow fevera                                                       30 000
 Total                                                            2 979 720             Europe and North America can expect to receive
                                                                                        protection against more than 10 vaccine-preventable
 a
     Most deaths do not occur in childhood.                                             diseases. This ‘‘vaccine gap’’ is another example of the
                                                                                        inequitable distribution of health services that con-
                                                                                        tributes to the growing difference in mortality between
                         myelitis, delivered through the routine health services,       rich and poor. Incorporating newer, safe, and effective
                         is declining. Additionally, it is apparent that those          vaccines into routine immunization programmes and
                         countries with the weakest health systems will be the          increasing coverage for all vaccines in a consistent and
                         last to achieve eradication. As a result, as the deadline      sustainable manner for all segments of the population
                         for eradication approaches, there will be increased            will require a long-term commitment to developing
                         pressure on these countries to focus only on the               and implementing programmes. Additionally, the
                         narrow goal of eradicating poliomyelitis and to                development and maintenance of the infrastructure
                         abandon the accompanying objectives related to                 required to support vaccination programmes will be
                         strengthening their health systems. Accordingly, there         important as new vaccines against diseases that are
                         is a real potential that the gap in the ability of countries   major contributors to both childhood and adult
                         to carry out other programmes that are dependent on            mortality, including malaria, AIDS, and tuberculosis,
                         their health systems, including those directed toward          are developed and marketed.
                         improving child health, will continue to grow.                        There is no obvious reason why both types of
                                 As the drive toward poliomyelitis eradication          programmes — shorter-term eradication initiatives and
                         nears its successful end, plans are being made to              longer-term developmental programmes — should not
                         embark upon a global initiative to eradicate measles.          coexist. If funding is available, if personnel and other
                         Unlike poliomyelitis, measles is an important cause of         non-monetary resources are sufficient to support both
                         childhood mortality, and its eradication would make            kinds of efforts as well as other programmes for which
                         an important contribution towards reducing child-              health ministries are responsible, and if demonstrable
                         hood mortality. Technical and programmatic argu-               benefits to the target populations can be shown,
                         ments have been advanced, both in favour of and                eradication programmes — which appeal to politicians,
                         against devoting major resources to eradicating                donors, and the public — could not only contribute to
                         measles. The potential operational, technical, epide-          reducing mortality but could also serve as a leading edge
                         miological, and financial problems that such a                 to prepare countries for longer-term programmes.
                         programme might face have been discussed (17, 18).             However, it might be important to make develop-
                                 While poliomyelitis eradication efforts have           mental goals more explicit in order to ensure that
                         been progressing, and while measles elimination is             eradication-type programmes are held accountable for
                         being pursued in several regions, vaccination coverage         their achievements in all countries, both richer and
                         with the standard six antigens of the WHO Expanded             poorer. This might be accomplished by setting longer-
                         Programme on Immunization has, in fact, fallen over            term goals — for example, by deciding what ought to
                         the past decade (19). UNICEF estimates that, despite           be achieved over the next 25 years — and allowing
                         the proclaimed success of its Universal Childhood              countries to pursue those globally agreed goals at their
                         Immunization programme efforts in the 1980s, which             own pace in accordance with their own priorities. The
                         sought to achieve 80% vaccination coverage with the            advent of public health endowments, such as the
                         antigens described in the WHO programme by the                 Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization, may
                         second half of the 1990s, 44 countries had measles             allow for longer-term planning, as the urgency to raise
                         vaccine coverage of less than 65% for children aged            funding for short-term programmes may be somewhat
                         1 year. Populous countries, such as Nigeria, are               alleviated in the future.
                         included in this category; India had an estimated
                         measles vaccine coverage of 67% (20). The new
                         Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunizations is              Case-management: the trend towards
                         responding to this negative trend and is a major
                         promoter of vaccination and immunization. The
                                                                                        integrating and packaging services
                         organization seeks to provide more vaccines to more            To conform to the changing characteristics of health
                         children in more countries (21). Like the poliomyelitis        ministries, which have undergone substantial reorga-

1238                                                                                            Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries

nization and reform, including a reduction in the           income is a contributing factor to ill-health and
emphasis on technical programmes, efforts have been         malnutrition, so are poor health, malnutrition, and
made to incorporate disease-control programmes in           large family size key determinants of poverty. In
more integrated and manageable packages of basic            targeting health interventions at poorer people, there
services. The Integrated Management of Childhood            are two formidable challenges: to lower the incidence
Illness programme is one example of this approach.          of outcomes associated with adverse health and poor
Developed jointly by WHO and UNICEF, this                   nutrition and to protect households against poten-
programme has been embraced by more than                    tially impoverishing effects when adverse outcomes
60 countries and has attracted support from a large         do occur.
number of donor agencies, including more than                       It is not only that poor people are in ill-health:
25 projects supported by the World Bank.                    ill-health causes poverty. In Voices of the poor, a recent
        The conditions included in the package include      World Bank study, ill-health emerged as one of the
major communicable diseases (pneumonia, diar-               principal reasons why households become poor and
rhoea, malaria, and measles). The package also              remain poor (23). Explanations are numerous: they
emphasizes addressing malnutrition, which has been          include the burden of health care expenditures
shown to contribute to more than half of all                incurred by caring for sick household members
childhood deaths (22). To a greater extent than many        (24), the lost income of the sick, and the lost income
earlier strategies, this package includes both treat-       of other household members who care for the sick.
ment and prevention interventions. In addition to           Nationally, although data relating the impact of
training health workers in standard case-management         health indicators to poverty rates are scarce, evidence
protocols for treating all five diseases, the package       is emerging about the impact of health on economic
urges the promotion of breastfeeding, improvements          growth. One study estimated that health and
in feeding practices, the use of micronutrient              demographic variables accounted for half of the
supplements, and vaccines.                                  difference in growth rates between Africa and the rest
        Even more importantly, the package calls            of the world from 1965 to 1990 (25).
attention to the need not only to train health                      Malnutrition is also known to be an important
professionals but also to strengthen existing health        determinant of poverty through its direct effects on
systems to ensure the availability of drugs and             loss of earnings: the chronically malnourished work
supplies and widespread access to them. Supervision,        less and earn less (26, 27). In addition, malnutrition
monitoring, and evaluation activities are also empha-       exerts indirect effects on health status, cognitive
sized. The third, and essential, component of the           development, and the productivity of workers.
package is the promotion of improved prevention             Numerous examples can be cited: non-breastfed
and care-seeking behaviours in the community and            babies have a 14-fold increased risk of dying from
the family.                                                 diarrhoea (28); iodine deficiency disorder has been
        Diseases that contribute directly to childhood      estimated to reduce intelligence quotient (IQ) by an
mortality are not the only subjects of these new            average of 13.5 points (29); and in Chile, iron-
initiatives. Increased attention is being paid to early     deficient children who were successfully treated
childhood development, emphasizing the psychologi-          performed 10–400% better on standardized tests
cal and intellectual growth of the child. Interventions     than anaemic children (30).
in childhood development are traditionally focused on               Improving health and nutrition especially
the family and community and are not delivered              among people living in poverty or close to poverty
through the health system. Nevertheless, certain            is thus likely to pay dividends by contributing to rises
aspects of the care of young children have recently         in household income and raising incomes will help
been added as an option in adapting the Integrated          lower mortality. Because of the gross health inequal-
Management of Childhood Illness package for                 ities between rich and poor both within and between
countries that want early childhood development to          countries it seems reasonable to encourage a change
be incorporated as an integral part of recovery from        in health programming. If mortality rates, especially
childhood illness. Similarly, just as early childhood       in childhood, are to be further reduced and stagnating
development programmes combine interventions in             or reversed trends are to be corrected, it may be more
nutrition, health, and psychology to achieve improved       important in the future to address the needs of
outcomes overall, recent interagency efforts (between       specific families and households rather than to
WHO, UNICEF, and the World Bank) combine the                emphasize the development of programmes aimed
teaching of life skills with the provision of appropriate   at specific diseases, wherever they might occur. This
health services at schools, including adequate water        people-oriented approach may be more difficult, and
and sanitation facilities.                                  it may entail the development and application of
                                                            sociological rather than biomedical research. But it is
                                                            increasingly clear that reducing poverty can be
The link between poverty and child                          achieved by introducing policies and applying
                                                            programmes that protect households from the
health outcomes                                             impoverishing effects of ill health, malnutrition, and
It is increasingly understood that the relation between     high fertility.
health and poverty is bi-directional. Just as low

Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)                                                                 1239
Special Theme — Child Mortality


               The future of child health efforts                             Box 1. A list of key household behaviours for
               in a changing political environment                            reducing childhood mortality (11 )

               To a certain extent, the easiest part of achieving lasting     Reproductive health behaviours
               reductions in childhood mortality has occurred in              Women of reproductive age should delay age of first
               some countries. In others, the strategies that have been       pregnancy, practise birth spacing, limit family size.
               used — strengthening health systems and training               Pregnant women should seek antenatal care at least twice
               health care providers in the appropriate use of safe,          during pregnancy.
               effective, affordable technologies — have been                 Women should take iron supplementation during
               inadequate or not sustainable. In these countries,             pregnancy.
               mortality rates have stagnated or are rising. In all cases,    Infant and child feeding practices
               further improvements will depend to a large extent on          Mothers should breastfeed their children exclusively
               what happens in the household and community and to             for about six months.
               what extent the health system is responsive and will           From six months mothers should give children appropriate
               play a supportive part. The promotion of a limited set         complementary feeding and continue to breastfeed for
               of household behaviours that have direct links to the          24 months (if testing positive for human immunodeficiency
               prevention and cure of common childhood illnesses              virus, current recommendations should be followed).
               needs to become the centrepiece of intensified activity
                                                                              Immunization practices
               (see Box 1). Since the ability and willingness of
                                                                              All infants should be taken for measles vaccination at nine
               families to adopt new behaviours are influenced by a           months of age.
               variety of factors, it will need to be determined locally      Infants should be taken for routine vaccinations even when
               how best to promote these behaviours. Factors                  sick.
               influencing the adoption of new behaviours include             Pregnant women and other women of childbearing age
               the household’s resources, attitudes in the community;         should seek tetanus toxoid vaccine at every opportunity.
               and the price, quality, and availability of services and
               goods such as food, energy, transport, water, and              Home health practices
                                                                              Prevention
               sanitation facilities.
                                                                              All children should sleep under insecticide-treated bednets
                      A graphical depiction of the relation between
                                                                              when indicated.
               the household or the community and the health
                                                                              Wash hands with soap at appropriate times.
               system is shown in Fig. 1 (31). The Pathway to                 All infants and children should consume enough vitamin A,
               Survival is a guide that distinguishes between                 by whatever means available.
               prevention behaviours, such as breastfeeding, that             All families should use iodized salt.
               can be implemented entirely in the home and those,
               such as vaccination, that require more direct support          Treatment
               from the health system. Similarly, it shows how the            Continue feeding and increase fluid intake during illness;
               management of childhood illness can also be carried            increase feeding after illness.
                                                                              Mix and administer oral rehydration salts, or an appropriate
               out in the home in many instances, with mothers
                                                                              home-available fluid, correctly.
               responsible for making the critical decision of when
                                                                              Administer treatment and medications according to
               external support is required. One of the most
                                                                              instruction.
               attractive features of the pathway is that it can be
               used as a quantitative tool for measuring problems in          Care-seeking practices
               home care, health care-seeking behaviour, the                  Seek appropriate care when an infant or child is recognized
               delivery of primary and secondary health care,                 as being sick.
               counselling patients, and the compliance of carers.
               In fact, a distribution of causes of death can be
               established on the basis of ‘‘social autopsies’’ taken        nutrition and population) sourcebook of the World Bank
               from mothers whose children have recently died.               includes the more distal role of government policies
               One study in the periurban area of El Alto, near La           and actions (Fig. 2). The Mosley–Chen framework
               Paz, the Republic of Bolivia, where childhood                 included both social and biological variables. It
               mortality was high, found that considerably more              assumed that all influences on childhood mortality
               than half of the deaths could be ascribed to                  at the individual, household, and community levels
               inadequate knowledge or incorrect behaviour, or               operate through a set of common mechanisms, such
               both, occurring in the household or community.                as maternal factors, environmental contamination,
               Findings such as these support the notion that further        nutrient deficiency, injury, and control over personal
               progress in child survival can only be made by making         illness; these were the more proximate determinants.
               greater investments in communities and families.              In the revised framework, the links between policy
                      A recent adaptation of the strategic framework         formulation and health outcomes have been made
               first presented by Mosley & Chen in 1984 adds an              more explicit. The revised framework includes health
               additional dimension to the Pathway for Survival              systems interventions and the promotion of appro-
               model (32). In addition to showing the relation               priate household and community behaviours as
               between the health system and the household and               essential intermediate steps between policy and
               community, the recent Poverty reduction strategy (health,     outcome. It recognizes that integrated packages of

1240                                                                                 Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries




Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)                                                               1241
Special Theme — Child Mortality

               interventions, such as the Integrated Management of        for a new generation), takes into account four basic
               Childhood Illness, the Integrated Management of            principles: that health interventions have a cumulative
               Pregnancy and Childbirth, school health pro-               impact — the costs and benefits of interventions later
               grammes, nutritional interventions, and control of         in life are partially dependent upon those that occurred
               both communicable diseases (such as HIV/AIDS,              earlier; that sustaining improved outcomes at any stage
               tuberculosis, and malaria) and noncommunicable             of the life cycle depends on interventions occurring
               diseases, constitute one set of influences on house-       during several stages; that interventions in one
               hold behaviours. Yet policies that determine the           generation can influence outcomes in later genera-
               availability of health services and the financing of       tions; and that clearly identifying the different stages of
               those services and others — such as food supply,           the life cycle facilitates the identification of risks for
               water, sanitation, and other related commodities and       both individuals and families.
               services — are equally important. Finally, it explicitly           Identifying the major risks to good health at
               recognizes that what happens in the household and          each stage of the life cycle allows appropriate
               community is the most proximate determinant of             interventions to be selected. These interventions
               favourable health outcomes (33).                           could be implemented either exclusively within the
                     Implicit in this approach to achieving good          health sector or, consistent with the modified
               health outcomes is the recognition that childhood          Mosley–Chen framework, through other mechan-
               mortality, for example, does not depend only on            isms for influencing household behaviours (34). The
               interventions in childhood. The health of mothers          notion that interventions throughout the life cycle
               and fathers, siblings, grandparents, and other house-      must be implemented to achieve the maximum
               hold members also influences the health of children.       reduction of deaths occurring in childhood will
               Similarly, interventions during childhood can have an      hopefully promote collaboration within the health
               important influence on health in adulthood. It is          sector and between sectors and help ensure that
               increasingly recognized that interventions in one          available resources are used more efficiently and
               generation can affect health outcomes in the next.         effectively.
               Ensuring adequate nutrition among girls during                     A discussion of current approaches to reducing
               childhood and adolescence, for example, can reduce         childhood mortality would not be complete without
               the incidence of low birth-weight babies, an               mentioning the legal dimensions of this effort. The
               important risk factor for early mortality.                 Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted by the
                     In order to account for these multiple and cross-    General Assembly of the United Nations in 1989 and
               cutting influences, and to organize them in a way that     subsequently ratified by all but a small number of
               can be easily translated into health programmes, the       countries, explicitly recognizes a child’s right to health
               World Bank and its partners have participated in the       and health services. Article 24 of the convention
               elaboration of a life cycle approach (Fig. 3). This        obligates all ratifying parties to ‘‘pursue full imple-
               framework, which includes interventions to be              mentation of this right and, in particular, [to] take
               implemented throughout life (and gives special             appropriate measures...to diminish infant and child
               consideration to the reproductive period for women,        mortality.’’ Guidance regarding implementation and
               which includes pregnancy and the start of a new cycle      monitoring of the actions called for by the convention
                                                                          has been developed and disseminated (35).


                                                                          Conclusions
                                                                          We have attempted to present briefly the traditions
                                                                          from which child survival efforts have developed, a
                                                                          concise description of some of the more prominent
                                                                          current initiatives and a few of the ideas being
                                                                          proposed for ensuring continued or resumed
                                                                          progress towards reducing childhood mortality.
                                                                          Although many of the technological tools necessary
                                                                          to address the principal biomedical causes of child-
                                                                          hood mortality in developing countries are available,
                                                                          they have been used in a patchy and inequitable
                                                                          fashion: access to health services and to these tools
                                                                          has been restricted for large parts of the population in
                                                                          many countries. It is increasingly recognized that the
                                                                          health of children is integrally related to poverty, and
                                                                          that there is a strong correlation between high
                                                                          mortality and poverty.
                                                                                 Perinatal, neonatal, and early childhood mor-
                                                                          tality have become relatively more important in areas
                                                                          where reductions in mortality have already been


1242                                                                              Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries

substantial. More effective technical interventions                     order for substantial new reductions in mortality to
and strategies for implementing them still need to be                   be made, disease-specific programmes and those that
developed for many of the potentially fatal conditions                  address the determinants of common causes of
that occur earlier in life. But technological advances                  mortality should be designed to complement each
notwithstanding, an increased emphasis on improv-                       other. Research into new technologies and into new
ing health behaviours in households and in commu-                       ways of influencing household behaviours should be
nities must occur if sustainable improvement in                         strongly and effectively managed, and solutions to
outcomes related to children’s health is to be                          problems of implementation should be disseminated,
achieved across all segments of society. Research,                      widely applied, and evaluated. Strategic approaches,
and especially social science research, can contribute                  such as the Pathway to Survival model, the modified
to the development of appropriate behavioural                           Mosley–Chen framework, and the life cycle ap-
interventions but only if the close collaboration                       proach, should be further developed to provide
between the research and the programmatic com-                          guidance to policy-makers, health service providers,
munities can be strengthened.                                           and community leaders. These approaches that are
      Poverty is an important contributing factor to                    more community-driven are necessary because the
childhood mortality, and economists and international                   pattern and trends of childhood mortality have
financial institutions are beginning to recognize that                  changed. Although impressive in some places, the
adverse health outcomes are an important contributor                    apparent reductions over the past 20 years sometimes
to poverty. Accordingly, it is important that strategies                mask the fact that the rate of decline has stalled for
aimed at reducing poverty take into account the                         many people and especially for those who are poor.
determinants of poor health outcomes at all stages of                   Improving children’s survival is an unfinished task,
the life cycle. The formulation of policies and                         but by using innovative multisectoral approaches that
programmes that use a broad range of interventions                      recognize that health outcomes can be influenced in
implemented in an integrated manner can result both                     ways that have not yet been adequately explored, and
in improved health and improved standards of living.                    especially by moving the centre of attention from the
      The future of child health programmes in                          health system to the household, additional gains can
developing countries depends upon bridging gaps. In                     be made rapidly and effectively. n


Resume
  ´    ´
L’evolution des programmes de sante infantile dans les pays en developpement :
   ´                                 ´                          ´
on cesse de cibler les maladies pour cibler les gens
Au cours des 30 dernieres annees, les taux de mortalite
                            `       ´                               ´   subsaharienne et en Asie du Sud-Est, compromet
chez les nourrissons et les enfants ont baisse dans       ´             serieusement la poursuite des progres.
                                                                          ´                                                   `
presque tous les pays. En outre, le nombre de deces             ´ `                Le present article examine les tendances observees
                                                                                            ´                                                   ´
d’enfants est passe d’environ 15 millions a environ
                        ´                               `               dans les programmes visant a promouvoir la sante des
                                                                                                                  `                           ´
11 millions, malgre une augmentation du nombre des
                     ´                                                  enfants au cours des dernieres decennies et avance des
                                                                                                              `         ´
naissances, une resistance croissante aux antibiotiques
                   ´                                                    propositions sur la meilleure facon de concevoir les
                                                                                                                          ¸
et antipaludiques courants et la propagation – difficile a          `   programmes futurs. Il passe en revue les differentes              ´
enrayer – du syndrome d’immunodeficience acquise
                                               ´                        approches adoptees dans le passe : les initiatives a court
                                                                                                 ´                      ´                  `
(SIDA) dans une grande partie du monde. Plusieurs                       terme et a objectifs etroits, dirigees contre des maladies
                                                                                        `               ´             ´
maladies et problemes de sante, dont les infections
                     `                 ´                                determinees, comme les premieres campagnes d’eradi-
                                                                           ´            ´                           `                        ´
respiratoires aigues, les maladies diarrheiques, le
                      ¨                               ´                 cation du paludisme (un echec) et de la variole (un
                                                                                                                ´
paludisme, la rougeole et la malnutrition, ont toujours                 succes), et les strategies de grande envergure, axees sur
                                                                                 `                    ´                                    ´
ete les principales causes d’une mortalite infantile
 ´ ´                                                  ´                 le developpement a long terme et sur les communautes,
                                                                               ´                     `                                           ´
elevee, bien qu’il existe contre chacun d’eux des
 ´ ´                                                                    comme les soins de sante primaires. Les programmes
                                                                                                            ´
interventions sans danger et efficaces.                                 modernes d’eradication de maladies telles que la
                                                                                               ´
       Nul ne peut garantir que les progres continueront.
                                                 `                      poliomye lite et la dracunculose et les strate gies
                                                                                      ´                                                       ´
D’abord, les succes enregistres a ce jour n’ont pas ete
                   `               ´ `                           ´ ´    « selectives » de soins de sante primaires, comme le
                                                                             ´                                        ´
uniformes. Beaucoup de pays pauvres et de regions           ´           programme de prise en charge integree des maladies de
                                                                                                                          ´ ´
pauvres de nombreux pays n’ont pas obtenu les memes           ˆ         l’enfant, essaient de combiner des elements de chacune
                                                                                                                            ´ ´
resultats que les pays prosperes. Ensuite, a mesure que
   ´                             `                  `                   de ces demarches.
                                                                                      ´
les taux de mortalite baissent, differentes affections
                          ´                  ´                                     Le role traditionnellement preponderant des
                                                                                            ˆ                                     ´     ´
jouent un role plus determinant : les maladies peri-
              ˆ                ´                                 ´      programmes de sante infantile semble s’amenuiser. Cela
                                                                                                         ´
natales et neonatales, contre lesquelles des interventions
            ´                                                           peut s’expliquer, entre autres, par le fait que le
appropriees pouvant etre appliquees sur une grande
          ´                  ˆ             ´                            mouvement de reforme du secteur de la sante s’est
                                                                                                   ´                                       ´
echelle n’ont pas encore ete mises au point, sont
 ´                                ´ ´                                   davantage preoccupe de considerations administratives
                                                                                              ´           ´           ´
desormais la cause d’une proportion plus elevee de deces
     ´                                             ´ ´          ´ `     et financieres que des programmes techniques ou
                                                                                          `
chez les enfants de moins de cinq ans. Les questions                    ensembles de programmes. La de centralisation a         ´
sexospecifiques doivent aussi etre abordees et la
        ´                                ˆ             ´                entraıˆne dans de nombreux pays une deterioration des
                                                                                    ´                                               ´ ´
propagation continue du SIDA, notamment en Afrique                      fonctions d’appui aux systemes de sante, telles que la
                                                                                                              `                      ´


Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)                                                                                             1243
Special Theme — Child Mortality

               formation et l’encadrement du personnel et le suivi et                   Quatre modeles sont examines. Le guide de la
                                                                                                     `                    ´
               l’evaluation des programmes. Toutefois, les strategies
                  ´                                                  ´         survie et une adaptation du cadre de Mosley-Chen
               techniques, comme celles qui sont appliquees dans le
                                                                  ´            illustrent la relation entre la communaute et le systeme
                                                                                                                                   ´        `
               cadre des programmes de vaccination et des initiatives          de sante, mais sous un angle different. La nouvelle
                                                                                           ´                               ´
               de prise en charge des cas, continuent de s’affiner pour        approche du cycle biologique decrit au moyen de
                                                                                                                       ´
               ameliorer la prestation des services, renforcer les
                      ´                                                        graphiques comment la sante de l’enfant depend des
                                                                                                                 ´                     ´
               systemes de sante et, par-dessus tout, favoriser la
                        `             ´                                        risques et des interventions sanitaires a des ages    `     ˆ
               participation communautaire.                                    differents et des influences entre generations. Enfin, il
                                                                                    ´                                    ´ ´
                          L’accent est mis de sormais sur la relation
                                             ´                                 est fait mention de la Convention relative aux droits de
               bidirectionnelle entre la pauvrete et la sante. De grandes
                                                 ´             ´               l’enfant, et notamment du droit a la sante et aux services
                                                                                                                     `           ´
               inegalites en matiere de sante existent entre riches et
                    ´       ´        `         ´                               de sante. ´
               pauvres, entre pays, au sein des pays et au sein des                     Bien que l’on dispose dans une large mesure des
               communaute s. A l’avenir, il peut e tre important
                                 ´                        ˆ                    outils technologiques permettant de reduire davantage
                                                                                                                               ´
               d’accorder plus d’attention aux menages et aux familles
                                                   ´                           la mortalite infantile, les strategies de mise en œuvre
                                                                                             ´                     ´
               dans lesquels, a cause de la pauvrete ou d’autres
                                   `                        ´                  doivent s’adapter au contexte local. La recherche en
               facteurs, les enfants sont davantage exposes au risque de
                                                             ´                 sciences sociales, qui vise a trouver des moyens
                                                                                                                   `
               mourir. Le message essentiel contenu dans cet article est       d’atteindre les communautes et les familles a haut
                                                                                                               ´                         `
               que la reduction de la mortalite infanto-juvenile pourrait
                            ´                  ´                ´              risque, en particulier celles dont l’acces aux services de
                                                                                                                             `
               bien dependre davantage de ce qui se passe dans les
                          ´                                                    sante est entrave par la pauvrete, devient de plus en plus
                                                                                      ´          ´                 ´
               communautes et les menages que de ce qui se passe a
                               ´          ´                             `      importante.
               l’interieur d’un systeme de sante.
                        ´               `        ´


               Resumen
               La evolucion de los programas de salud infantil en los paıses en desarrollo: el punto
                         ´                                              ´
               de mira se desplaza de las enfermedades a las personas
               Durante los 30 ultimos anos, las tasas de mortalidad de
                                  ´         ˜                                  pasado, a saber: iniciativas a corto plazo y con objetivos
               lactantes y ninos han disminuido en casi todos los paı´ses.
                             ˜                                                 muy concretos contra enfermedades especı´ficas, como
               Ademas, el numero de defunciones infantiles ha
                      ´           ´                                            las primeras iniciativas de erradicacion del paludismo (un
                                                                                                                           ´
               descendido de unos 15 millones a cerca de 11 millones           fracaso) y de la viruela (un exito), y estrategias amplias, a
                                                                                                               ´
               a pesar del aumento del numero de nacimientos, de
                                                 ´                             largo plazo, de desarrollo, orientadas hacia la comuni-
               la resistencia creciente a antibioticos y antipaludicos
                                                   ´                 ´         dad, como la de atencion primaria de salud. Los
                                                                                                                 ´
               comunes y de la propagacion relativamente incontrolada
                                               ´                               programas modernos de erradicacion de enfermedades
                                                                                                                           ´
               del SIDA en gran parte del mundo. Un numero limitado
                                                          ´                    como la poliomielitis y la dracunculosis y las estrategias
               de afecciones medicas, como las infecciones respiratorias
                                  ´                                            «selectivas» de atencion primaria, como la de lucha
                                                                                                           ´
               agudas, las enfermedades diarreicas, el paludismo, el           integrada contra las enfermedades de la infancia, tratan
               sarampion y la malnutricion, han constituido sistemati-
                        ´                     ´                          ´     de combinar diversos elementos de cada uno de esos
               camente las principales causas de mortalidad infantil           enfoques.
               pese a que existen intervenciones seguras y eficaces                   La importante funcion que han desempenado
                                                                                                                   ´                     ˜
               contra cada una de ellas.                                       tradicionalmente los programas de salud infantil parece
                      El progreso continuo no esta asegurado. Primero,
                                                     ´                         estar disminuyendo. Una de las razones podrı´a ser que el
               hasta la fecha el exito no ha sido uniforme. Muchos
                                    ´                                          impulso hacia la reforma del sector de la salud se ha
               paı´ses pobres, y zonas pobres de muchos paı´ses, no han        centrado mas en consideraciones administrativas y
                                                                                              ´
               conseguido resultados tan buenos como los mas ricos.
                                                                 ´             financieras que en programas o conjuntos de programas
               Ademas, a medida que disminuyen las tasas de
                      ´                                                        tecnicos. La descentralizacion ha dado lugar en muchos
                                                                                 ´                                ´
               mortalidad, otras afecciones adquieren mas importancia;
                                                          ´                    paı´ses a un deterioro de las funciones de apoyo a los
               la mortalidad perinatal y neonatal, para la cual todavı´a       sistemas, como la capacitacion, la supervision y la
                                                                                                                     ´               ´
               no se han desarrollado intervenciones que puedan                vigilancia y la evaluacion de los programas. Sin embargo,
                                                                                                         ´
               implantarse de forma generalizada, contribuye aun mas
                                                                   ´       ´   las estrategias tecnicas, como las de los programas de
                                                                                                  ´
               que antes al numero de defunciones de menores de
                                  ´                                            vacunacion y las iniciativas de gestion de casos, siguen
                                                                                          ´                                  ´
               5 anos. Tambien es necesario abordar las cuestiones
                    ˜           ´                                              evolucionando para mejorar la prestacion de servicios,
                                                                                                                               ´
               relacionadas con la paridad entre los sexos, y la               fortalecer los sistemas de salud y, lo que es mas            ´
               propagacio n continua del sı´ ndrome de inmuno-
                           ´                                                   importante, promover la participacion comunitaria.
                                                                                                                            ´
               deficiencia adquirida (SIDA), especialmente en el Africa´              Se destaca la relacionbidireccional entre la pobreza y
                                                                                                             ´
               subsahariana y en Asia Sudoriental, amenaza seriamente          la salud. Existen grandes desigualdades de salud entre ricos
               la continuidad de los progresos.                                y pobres, entre los paı´ses, dentro de los paı´ses y dentro de
                      En este artı´culo se examinan las tendencias de los      las comunidades. En el futuro quiza sea importante dirigir
                                                                                                                         ´
               programas de promocion de la salud de los ninos en los
                                         ´                     ˜               los esfuerzos hacia los hogares y familias en los que, debido
               ultimos decenios y se formulan sugerencias sobre la
                ´                                                              a la pobreza u otros factores, los ninos corren mayor peligro
                                                                                                                       ˜
               mejor manera de disenar programas en el futuro. Se
                                          ˜                                    de morir. El mensaje clave de este artı´culo es que los futuros
               analizan los diferentes enfoques adoptados en el                avances en la reduccion de la mortalidad de lactantes y
                                                                                                        ´


1244                                                                                   Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries

ninos bien pueden depender de lo que suceda en las
   ˜                                                                         la Convencion sobre los Derechos del Nino, que reconoce
                                                                                         ´                            ˜
comunidades y los hogares, y no tanto de lo que suceda en                    el derecho a la salud y a servicios de salud.
el sistema de salud.                                                                Aunque en gran medida se dispone de herra-
        Se examinan cuatro modelos. El modelo «La Vı´a                       mientas tecnologicas para seguir reduciendo la morta-
                                                                                             ´
de la Supervivencia» y una adaptacion del marco de
                                         ´                                   lidad infantil, es necesario adaptar las estrategias de
Mosley-Chen muestran la relacion entre la comunidad y
                                  ´                                          aplicacion a los contextos locales. Las investigaciones
                                                                                     ´
el sistema de salud, pero de forma diferente. El nuevo                       sociologicas encaminadas a identificar maneras de llegar
                                                                                   ´
enfoque del ciclo de vida ilustra graficamente la manera
                                    ´                                        a las comunidades y familias de alto riesgo, especial-
en que la salud de los ninos depende de los riesgos e
                           ˜                                                 mente aquellas cuyo acceso a los servicios de salud se
intervenciones sanitarios a distintas edades y de                            halla limitado por la pobreza, estan cobrando una
                                                                                                                    ´
influencias intergeneracionales. Por ultimo se menciona
                                       ´                                     importancia creciente.


References
 1. UNICEF. The state of the world’s children report 2000. New York,         18. Cutts FT, Henao-Restrepo A, Olive JM. Measles elimination:
    UNICEF, 2000: 83.                                                            progress and challenges. Vaccine, 1999, 17: 47–52.
 2. Tulloch J. Integrated approach to child health in developing             19. Vaccine preventable diseases monitoring system, global summary,
    countries. Lancet, 1999, 354: 16–20.                                         1999. Geneva, World Health Organization, 1999.
 3. Kurz KM, Johnson-Welch C. Gender bias in health care among               20. UNICEF. The state of the world’s children report 2000. New York,
    children 0–5 years: opportunities for child survival programs.               UNICEF, 2000: 92–95.
    Arlington, VA, United States Agency for International                    21. The Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization.
    Development, the BASICS Project, 1997.                                       A partnership for child health (available on the Internet at
 4. Claeson M et al. Reducing child mortality in India in the new                http://www.vaccinealliance.org).
    millennium, Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000,             22. Pelletier DL et al. The effects of malnutrition on child mortality
    78: 1192–1199.                                                               in developing countries. Bulletin of the World Health Organization,
 5. Newell KW. Selective primary health care: the counter revolution.            1995, 73: 443–448.
    Social Science and Medicine, 1988, 26: 903–906.                          23. Narayan et al. Voices of the poor: can anyone hear us?
 6. Aylward RB et al. Disease eradication initiatives and general                New York, Oxford University Press for the World Bank, 2000.
    health services: ensuring common principles lead to mutual               24. Ettling M et al. Economic impact of malaria in Malawian
    benefits. In: Dowdle WR, Hopkins DR, eds. The eradication                    households. Tropical Medicine and Parasitology, 1994,
    of infectious diseases. Chichester, UK, John Wiley, 1998: 61–74.             45: 74–79.
 7. Walsh JA, Warren KS. Selective primary health care: an interim           25. Bloom DE, Sachs JD. Geography, demography and economic
    strategy for disease control in developing countries. New England            growth in Africa. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1998,
    Journal of Medicine, 1979, 301: 967–974.                                     2: 207–295.
 8. The evolution of diarrhoeal and acute respiratory disease control        26. Levin H. A benefit–cost analysis of nutritional programs
    at WHO. Geneva, World Health Organization, Department                        for anemia reduction. World Bank Research Observer, 1986,
    of Child and Adolescent Health and Development, 1999                         1: 219–246.
    (WHO/CHS/CAH/99.12).                                                     27. McGuire JS, Austin JA. Beyond survival: children’s growth
 9. Feachem RG. Preventing diarrhoea: what are the policy                        for national development. New York, UNICEF, 1987.
    options. Health Policy and Planning, 1986, 1: 109–117.                   28. Feacham R, Koblinsky M. Interventions for the control of
10. Kirkwood BR. Potential interventions for the prevention                      diarrhoeal disease among young children: promotion of breast-
    of childhood pneumonia in developing countries: a systematic                 feeding. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 1984,
    review. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 1995,                     62: 271–291.
    73: 793–798.                                                             29. Bleichrodt N, Born MP. A meta-analysis of research on iodine
11. Murray J et al. Emphasis behaviors in maternal and child health:             and its relationship to cognitive development. In: Stanbury JB, ed.
    focusing on caretaker behaviors to develop maternal and child                The damaged brain of iodine deficiency: cognitive, behavioural,
    health programs in communities. Arlington, VA, United States                 neuromotor and educative aspects. New York, Cognizant
    Agency for International Development, the BASICS Project, 1997.              Communication, 1994: 195–200.
12. Reich MR. The politics of agenda setting in international health:        30. Walter TI et al. Iron deficiency anemia: adverse effects on infant
    child health versus adult health in developing countries. Journal            psychomotor development. Pediatrics, 1989, 8491: 7–17.
    of International Development, 1995, 7: 489–502.                          31. Waldman RJ et al. Overcoming remaining barriers: the pathway
13. World development report 1993 — Investing in health.                         to child survival. Arlington, VA, United States Agency for
    Washington, DC, Oxford University Press for the World Bank,                  International Development, the BASICS Project, 1996.
    1993.                                                                    32. Mosley WH, Chen LC, eds. Child survival: strategies for research.
14. Feachem RGA, Phillips MA, Bulatao RA. Introducing adult                      New York, Population Council, 1984 (Population and Develop-
    health. In: Feachem RGA et al, eds. The health of adults in                  ment Review, supplement vol. 10).
    the developing world. Washington, DC, The World Bank, 1992.              33. Health, nutrition, and population sourcebook for the poverty
15. Gwatkin DR, Guilot M. The burden of disease among the global                 reduction strategy paper. Washington, DC, Health Nutrition, and
    poor: current situation, future trends, and implications for strategy.       Population Division, The World Bank, 2000.
    Washington, DC, Human Development Network/Health,                        34. Simon J, Rosen S. The family health cycle: creating a context
    Nutrition, and Population, The World Bank, 2000.                             for maternal and child health (MCH) interventions. Paper
16. Global eradication of poliomyelitis by the year 2000. Resolution             Presented at World Bank Human Development Learning Week,
    WHA41.28, 41st World Health Assembly, May 1988. Handbook                     Washington, DC, 22 February 2000.
    of Resolutions and Decisions, Vol.III, 2nd ed. Geneva, World             35. Hodgkin R, Newell P, eds. Implementation handbook for
    Health Organization, 1990: 55–56.                                            the convention on the rights of the child. New York, UNICEF,
17. Omer MI. Measles: a disease that has to be eradicated. Annals                1998: 315–340.
    of Tropical Paediatrics, 1999, 19: 125–134.




Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)                                                                                               1245

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

BMC Public Health September 2016
BMC Public Health September 2016BMC Public Health September 2016
BMC Public Health September 2016Giorgi Pkhakadze
 
CHL5117 Final Assignment - V_Young
CHL5117 Final Assignment - V_YoungCHL5117 Final Assignment - V_Young
CHL5117 Final Assignment - V_YoungVanessa Pike (Young)
 
TO ANALYZE THE ROLE OF RURAL WOMAN'S TO ENSURE CHILD NUTRITION IN DISTRICT RA...
TO ANALYZE THE ROLE OF RURAL WOMAN'S TO ENSURE CHILD NUTRITION IN DISTRICT RA...TO ANALYZE THE ROLE OF RURAL WOMAN'S TO ENSURE CHILD NUTRITION IN DISTRICT RA...
TO ANALYZE THE ROLE OF RURAL WOMAN'S TO ENSURE CHILD NUTRITION IN DISTRICT RA...Hafiz Muhammad Zeeshan Raza
 
TPJ haiti article
TPJ haiti articleTPJ haiti article
TPJ haiti articleTom Judd
 
diarrhoea: why children are still dying & what can be done
diarrhoea: why children are still dying & what can be donediarrhoea: why children are still dying & what can be done
diarrhoea: why children are still dying & what can be doneChynthya Riiweuh
 
Health for the world’s adolescents
Health for the world’s adolescentsHealth for the world’s adolescents
Health for the world’s adolescentsilfattoquotidiano.it
 
Integrating Family Planning_Smith
Integrating Family Planning_SmithIntegrating Family Planning_Smith
Integrating Family Planning_SmithCORE Group
 
Presentation on the new 2013 child mortality estimates psalama91013
Presentation on the new 2013 child mortality estimates psalama91013Presentation on the new 2013 child mortality estimates psalama91013
Presentation on the new 2013 child mortality estimates psalama91013unicef_ethiopia
 
Ghia foundation strategy document v4.dec.17.2015 (ab)
Ghia foundation strategy document v4.dec.17.2015 (ab)Ghia foundation strategy document v4.dec.17.2015 (ab)
Ghia foundation strategy document v4.dec.17.2015 (ab)Ghia Foundation
 
Infant mortality rate
Infant mortality rateInfant mortality rate
Infant mortality rateshivujagga
 
Influence of Mothers’ Participation in Intra-Household Decision Making on Nut...
Influence of Mothers’ Participation in Intra-Household Decision Making on Nut...Influence of Mothers’ Participation in Intra-Household Decision Making on Nut...
Influence of Mothers’ Participation in Intra-Household Decision Making on Nut...Hudu Zakaria
 
Unicef 2009 State Of Women & Children Report
Unicef 2009 State Of Women & Children ReportUnicef 2009 State Of Women & Children Report
Unicef 2009 State Of Women & Children Reportsisterhood4humanity
 
Child Mortality among Teenage Mothers in OJU Metropolis
Child Mortality among Teenage Mothers in OJU MetropolisChild Mortality among Teenage Mothers in OJU Metropolis
Child Mortality among Teenage Mothers in OJU Metropolisiosrjce
 
Running head global health case study analysis1 global healt
Running head global health case study analysis1 global healtRunning head global health case study analysis1 global healt
Running head global health case study analysis1 global healtDIPESH30
 
South Sudan Case Study-FINAL 24Sep
South Sudan Case Study-FINAL 24SepSouth Sudan Case Study-FINAL 24Sep
South Sudan Case Study-FINAL 24SepJoy Toose
 

Mais procurados (20)

BMC Public Health September 2016
BMC Public Health September 2016BMC Public Health September 2016
BMC Public Health September 2016
 
CHL5117 Final Assignment - V_Young
CHL5117 Final Assignment - V_YoungCHL5117 Final Assignment - V_Young
CHL5117 Final Assignment - V_Young
 
TO ANALYZE THE ROLE OF RURAL WOMAN'S TO ENSURE CHILD NUTRITION IN DISTRICT RA...
TO ANALYZE THE ROLE OF RURAL WOMAN'S TO ENSURE CHILD NUTRITION IN DISTRICT RA...TO ANALYZE THE ROLE OF RURAL WOMAN'S TO ENSURE CHILD NUTRITION IN DISTRICT RA...
TO ANALYZE THE ROLE OF RURAL WOMAN'S TO ENSURE CHILD NUTRITION IN DISTRICT RA...
 
TPJ haiti article
TPJ haiti articleTPJ haiti article
TPJ haiti article
 
diarrhoea: why children are still dying & what can be done
diarrhoea: why children are still dying & what can be donediarrhoea: why children are still dying & what can be done
diarrhoea: why children are still dying & what can be done
 
Malnutrition
MalnutritionMalnutrition
Malnutrition
 
Health for the world’s adolescents
Health for the world’s adolescentsHealth for the world’s adolescents
Health for the world’s adolescents
 
Integrating Family Planning_Smith
Integrating Family Planning_SmithIntegrating Family Planning_Smith
Integrating Family Planning_Smith
 
Presentation on the new 2013 child mortality estimates psalama91013
Presentation on the new 2013 child mortality estimates psalama91013Presentation on the new 2013 child mortality estimates psalama91013
Presentation on the new 2013 child mortality estimates psalama91013
 
Ghia foundation strategy document v4.dec.17.2015 (ab)
Ghia foundation strategy document v4.dec.17.2015 (ab)Ghia foundation strategy document v4.dec.17.2015 (ab)
Ghia foundation strategy document v4.dec.17.2015 (ab)
 
Infant mortality rate
Infant mortality rateInfant mortality rate
Infant mortality rate
 
Jessica Fanzo
Jessica FanzoJessica Fanzo
Jessica Fanzo
 
Two Dimensions of Growth: Biology and Economics
Two Dimensions of Growth: Biology and EconomicsTwo Dimensions of Growth: Biology and Economics
Two Dimensions of Growth: Biology and Economics
 
Unicef 2012 Child mortality
Unicef 2012 Child mortalityUnicef 2012 Child mortality
Unicef 2012 Child mortality
 
Influence of Mothers’ Participation in Intra-Household Decision Making on Nut...
Influence of Mothers’ Participation in Intra-Household Decision Making on Nut...Influence of Mothers’ Participation in Intra-Household Decision Making on Nut...
Influence of Mothers’ Participation in Intra-Household Decision Making on Nut...
 
Unicef 2009 State Of Women & Children Report
Unicef 2009 State Of Women & Children ReportUnicef 2009 State Of Women & Children Report
Unicef 2009 State Of Women & Children Report
 
Child Mortality among Teenage Mothers in OJU Metropolis
Child Mortality among Teenage Mothers in OJU MetropolisChild Mortality among Teenage Mothers in OJU Metropolis
Child Mortality among Teenage Mothers in OJU Metropolis
 
Running head global health case study analysis1 global healt
Running head global health case study analysis1 global healtRunning head global health case study analysis1 global healt
Running head global health case study analysis1 global healt
 
South Sudan Case Study-FINAL 24Sep
South Sudan Case Study-FINAL 24SepSouth Sudan Case Study-FINAL 24Sep
South Sudan Case Study-FINAL 24Sep
 
Determinats of Child Mortality in Arba Minch Hospital
Determinats of Child Mortality in Arba Minch HospitalDeterminats of Child Mortality in Arba Minch Hospital
Determinats of Child Mortality in Arba Minch Hospital
 

Destaque

what is the best way to lose weight
what is the best way to lose weightwhat is the best way to lose weight
what is the best way to lose weightandy49morris
 
Untitled Presentation
Untitled PresentationUntitled Presentation
Untitled Presentationderek_olmos
 
Informe tecnico-instalaciones-deportivas-julio-2015-27
Informe tecnico-instalaciones-deportivas-julio-2015-27Informe tecnico-instalaciones-deportivas-julio-2015-27
Informe tecnico-instalaciones-deportivas-julio-2015-27Jordi Puig
 
Garanzia Giovani in Lombardia: una opportunità per la rete di Confcooperative...
Garanzia Giovani in Lombardia: una opportunità per la rete di Confcooperative...Garanzia Giovani in Lombardia: una opportunità per la rete di Confcooperative...
Garanzia Giovani in Lombardia: una opportunità per la rete di Confcooperative...Stefano Radaelli
 
Classism in the US part 1 by Derek o
Classism in the US part 1 by Derek oClassism in the US part 1 by Derek o
Classism in the US part 1 by Derek oderek_olmos
 
Gilde voor den haag 1.0
Gilde voor den haag 1.0Gilde voor den haag 1.0
Gilde voor den haag 1.0wdrieenhuizen
 
Naturalism nadia and teresita
Naturalism  nadia and teresitaNaturalism  nadia and teresita
Naturalism nadia and teresitawolfgal
 
Confine orientale presentazione cd
Confine orientale presentazione cdConfine orientale presentazione cd
Confine orientale presentazione cdirsml
 
Senarai peribahasa dalam buku teks tingkatan 4
Senarai peribahasa dalam buku teks tingkatan 4Senarai peribahasa dalam buku teks tingkatan 4
Senarai peribahasa dalam buku teks tingkatan 4Keymah Colonial
 
Planning workshop
Planning workshopPlanning workshop
Planning workshopLove Suzan
 
Nursing responsibility& accountability & employment issues
Nursing responsibility& accountability & employment issuesNursing responsibility& accountability & employment issues
Nursing responsibility& accountability & employment issuesLove Suzan
 

Destaque (19)

what is the best way to lose weight
what is the best way to lose weightwhat is the best way to lose weight
what is the best way to lose weight
 
Untitled Presentation
Untitled PresentationUntitled Presentation
Untitled Presentation
 
324 b cd01
324 b cd01324 b cd01
324 b cd01
 
Trabajo final
Trabajo finalTrabajo final
Trabajo final
 
Informe tecnico-instalaciones-deportivas-julio-2015-27
Informe tecnico-instalaciones-deportivas-julio-2015-27Informe tecnico-instalaciones-deportivas-julio-2015-27
Informe tecnico-instalaciones-deportivas-julio-2015-27
 
Garanzia Giovani in Lombardia: una opportunità per la rete di Confcooperative...
Garanzia Giovani in Lombardia: una opportunità per la rete di Confcooperative...Garanzia Giovani in Lombardia: una opportunità per la rete di Confcooperative...
Garanzia Giovani in Lombardia: una opportunità per la rete di Confcooperative...
 
Kometi
KometiKometi
Kometi
 
Classism in the US part 1 by Derek o
Classism in the US part 1 by Derek oClassism in the US part 1 by Derek o
Classism in the US part 1 by Derek o
 
Gilde voor den haag 1.0
Gilde voor den haag 1.0Gilde voor den haag 1.0
Gilde voor den haag 1.0
 
Marketing Extension Guide
Marketing Extension GuideMarketing Extension Guide
Marketing Extension Guide
 
Noise & Radiation
Noise &  RadiationNoise &  Radiation
Noise & Radiation
 
Naturalism nadia and teresita
Naturalism  nadia and teresitaNaturalism  nadia and teresita
Naturalism nadia and teresita
 
1774 ad01
1774 ad011774 ad01
1774 ad01
 
Wallwisher/Padlet
Wallwisher/PadletWallwisher/Padlet
Wallwisher/Padlet
 
Confine orientale presentazione cd
Confine orientale presentazione cdConfine orientale presentazione cd
Confine orientale presentazione cd
 
Senarai peribahasa dalam buku teks tingkatan 4
Senarai peribahasa dalam buku teks tingkatan 4Senarai peribahasa dalam buku teks tingkatan 4
Senarai peribahasa dalam buku teks tingkatan 4
 
Obesiti
ObesitiObesiti
Obesiti
 
Planning workshop
Planning workshopPlanning workshop
Planning workshop
 
Nursing responsibility& accountability & employment issues
Nursing responsibility& accountability & employment issuesNursing responsibility& accountability & employment issues
Nursing responsibility& accountability & employment issues
 

Semelhante a 78(10)1234

Childhood Mortality and Morbidity Presentation Slide.ppt
Childhood Mortality and Morbidity Presentation Slide.pptChildhood Mortality and Morbidity Presentation Slide.ppt
Childhood Mortality and Morbidity Presentation Slide.pptMotahar Alam
 
Informe de la OMS acerca de la salud de los adolescentes en el mundo - en inglés
Informe de la OMS acerca de la salud de los adolescentes en el mundo - en inglésInforme de la OMS acerca de la salud de los adolescentes en el mundo - en inglés
Informe de la OMS acerca de la salud de los adolescentes en el mundo - en inglésCristobal Buñuel
 
Health for the world’s adolescents
Health for the world’s adolescentsHealth for the world’s adolescents
Health for the world’s adolescentsBioeticared
 
[[INOSR ES 11(2)134-147 Evaluation of the Infant Mortality rate at Ishaka Adv...
[[INOSR ES 11(2)134-147 Evaluation of the Infant Mortality rate at Ishaka Adv...[[INOSR ES 11(2)134-147 Evaluation of the Infant Mortality rate at Ishaka Adv...
[[INOSR ES 11(2)134-147 Evaluation of the Infant Mortality rate at Ishaka Adv...PUBLISHERJOURNAL
 
Unfpa reproductive paper_20160120_online
Unfpa reproductive paper_20160120_onlineUnfpa reproductive paper_20160120_online
Unfpa reproductive paper_20160120_onlineWondmagegn4444
 
6Health and SafetyJupiterimagesStockbyteThinkstockLe.docx
6Health and SafetyJupiterimagesStockbyteThinkstockLe.docx6Health and SafetyJupiterimagesStockbyteThinkstockLe.docx
6Health and SafetyJupiterimagesStockbyteThinkstockLe.docxalinainglis
 
Infant Mortality Rate
Infant Mortality RateInfant Mortality Rate
Infant Mortality Rateaavi241
 
S9c1 chapter 1-facts and figures on health.
S9c1 chapter 1-facts and figures on health.S9c1 chapter 1-facts and figures on health.
S9c1 chapter 1-facts and figures on health.Shivu P
 
Running head MATERNAL, INFANT AND CHILD HEALTH .docx
Running head MATERNAL, INFANT AND CHILD HEALTH                   .docxRunning head MATERNAL, INFANT AND CHILD HEALTH                   .docx
Running head MATERNAL, INFANT AND CHILD HEALTH .docxcowinhelen
 
REPORT ON U5 CHILD HEALTH IN BD
REPORT ON U5 CHILD HEALTH IN BDREPORT ON U5 CHILD HEALTH IN BD
REPORT ON U5 CHILD HEALTH IN BDManuel Hasda
 
1. Select a health problem in your society (Saudi) 2. Write a para.pdf
1. Select a health problem in your society (Saudi) 2. Write a para.pdf1. Select a health problem in your society (Saudi) 2. Write a para.pdf
1. Select a health problem in your society (Saudi) 2. Write a para.pdfomarionmatzmcwill497
 
Infant mortality.pdf
Infant mortality.pdfInfant mortality.pdf
Infant mortality.pdfyeabek3
 
2018_Global_Nutrition_Report_Executive_Summary.pdf
2018_Global_Nutrition_Report_Executive_Summary.pdf2018_Global_Nutrition_Report_Executive_Summary.pdf
2018_Global_Nutrition_Report_Executive_Summary.pdfTaruliRohanaSinaga1
 
Brittany Hamlin Honor's Thesis
Brittany Hamlin Honor's ThesisBrittany Hamlin Honor's Thesis
Brittany Hamlin Honor's ThesisBrittany Hamlin
 
Child survival strategies 2019
Child survival strategies 2019Child survival strategies 2019
Child survival strategies 2019Omondi Larry
 

Semelhante a 78(10)1234 (20)

Childhood Mortality and Morbidity Presentation Slide.ppt
Childhood Mortality and Morbidity Presentation Slide.pptChildhood Mortality and Morbidity Presentation Slide.ppt
Childhood Mortality and Morbidity Presentation Slide.ppt
 
Informe de la OMS acerca de la salud de los adolescentes en el mundo - en inglés
Informe de la OMS acerca de la salud de los adolescentes en el mundo - en inglésInforme de la OMS acerca de la salud de los adolescentes en el mundo - en inglés
Informe de la OMS acerca de la salud de los adolescentes en el mundo - en inglés
 
WHO_FWC_MCA_14.05_eng.pdf
WHO_FWC_MCA_14.05_eng.pdfWHO_FWC_MCA_14.05_eng.pdf
WHO_FWC_MCA_14.05_eng.pdf
 
Health for the world’s adolescents
Health for the world’s adolescentsHealth for the world’s adolescents
Health for the world’s adolescents
 
[[INOSR ES 11(2)134-147 Evaluation of the Infant Mortality rate at Ishaka Adv...
[[INOSR ES 11(2)134-147 Evaluation of the Infant Mortality rate at Ishaka Adv...[[INOSR ES 11(2)134-147 Evaluation of the Infant Mortality rate at Ishaka Adv...
[[INOSR ES 11(2)134-147 Evaluation of the Infant Mortality rate at Ishaka Adv...
 
Unfpa reproductive paper_20160120_online
Unfpa reproductive paper_20160120_onlineUnfpa reproductive paper_20160120_online
Unfpa reproductive paper_20160120_online
 
6Health and SafetyJupiterimagesStockbyteThinkstockLe.docx
6Health and SafetyJupiterimagesStockbyteThinkstockLe.docx6Health and SafetyJupiterimagesStockbyteThinkstockLe.docx
6Health and SafetyJupiterimagesStockbyteThinkstockLe.docx
 
Infant Mortality Rate
Infant Mortality RateInfant Mortality Rate
Infant Mortality Rate
 
S9c1 chapter 1-facts and figures on health.
S9c1 chapter 1-facts and figures on health.S9c1 chapter 1-facts and figures on health.
S9c1 chapter 1-facts and figures on health.
 
09041994
0904199409041994
09041994
 
Running head MATERNAL, INFANT AND CHILD HEALTH .docx
Running head MATERNAL, INFANT AND CHILD HEALTH                   .docxRunning head MATERNAL, INFANT AND CHILD HEALTH                   .docx
Running head MATERNAL, INFANT AND CHILD HEALTH .docx
 
Malnutrition
MalnutritionMalnutrition
Malnutrition
 
REPORT ON U5 CHILD HEALTH IN BD
REPORT ON U5 CHILD HEALTH IN BDREPORT ON U5 CHILD HEALTH IN BD
REPORT ON U5 CHILD HEALTH IN BD
 
Progress in child well-being
Progress in child well-beingProgress in child well-being
Progress in child well-being
 
1. Select a health problem in your society (Saudi) 2. Write a para.pdf
1. Select a health problem in your society (Saudi) 2. Write a para.pdf1. Select a health problem in your society (Saudi) 2. Write a para.pdf
1. Select a health problem in your society (Saudi) 2. Write a para.pdf
 
Infant mortality.pdf
Infant mortality.pdfInfant mortality.pdf
Infant mortality.pdf
 
2018_Global_Nutrition_Report_Executive_Summary.pdf
2018_Global_Nutrition_Report_Executive_Summary.pdf2018_Global_Nutrition_Report_Executive_Summary.pdf
2018_Global_Nutrition_Report_Executive_Summary.pdf
 
Brittany Hamlin Honor's Thesis
Brittany Hamlin Honor's ThesisBrittany Hamlin Honor's Thesis
Brittany Hamlin Honor's Thesis
 
Child survival strategies 2019
Child survival strategies 2019Child survival strategies 2019
Child survival strategies 2019
 
Immunization CMMB Partnerships
Immunization CMMB PartnershipsImmunization CMMB Partnerships
Immunization CMMB Partnerships
 

Último

Presentació "Real-Life VR Integration for Mild Cognitive Impairment Rehabilit...
Presentació "Real-Life VR Integration for Mild Cognitive Impairment Rehabilit...Presentació "Real-Life VR Integration for Mild Cognitive Impairment Rehabilit...
Presentació "Real-Life VR Integration for Mild Cognitive Impairment Rehabilit...Badalona Serveis Assistencials
 
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAAjennyeacort
 
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy PlatformSee the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy PlatformKweku Zurek
 
Biomechanics- Shoulder Joint!!!!!!!!!!!!
Biomechanics- Shoulder Joint!!!!!!!!!!!!Biomechanics- Shoulder Joint!!!!!!!!!!!!
Biomechanics- Shoulder Joint!!!!!!!!!!!!ibtesaam huma
 
call girls in Connaught Place DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service ...
call girls in Connaught Place  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service ...call girls in Connaught Place  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service ...
call girls in Connaught Place DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service ...saminamagar
 
Case Report Peripartum Cardiomyopathy.pptx
Case Report Peripartum Cardiomyopathy.pptxCase Report Peripartum Cardiomyopathy.pptx
Case Report Peripartum Cardiomyopathy.pptxNiranjan Chavan
 
History and Development of Pharmacovigilence.pdf
History and Development of Pharmacovigilence.pdfHistory and Development of Pharmacovigilence.pdf
History and Development of Pharmacovigilence.pdfSasikiranMarri
 
Wessex Health Partners Wessex Integrated Care, Population Health, Research & ...
Wessex Health Partners Wessex Integrated Care, Population Health, Research & ...Wessex Health Partners Wessex Integrated Care, Population Health, Research & ...
Wessex Health Partners Wessex Integrated Care, Population Health, Research & ...Wessex Health Partners
 
Glomerular Filtration and determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
Glomerular Filtration and  determinants of glomerular filtration .pptxGlomerular Filtration and  determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
Glomerular Filtration and determinants of glomerular filtration .pptxDr.Nusrat Tariq
 
Primary headache and facial pain. (2024)
Primary headache and facial pain. (2024)Primary headache and facial pain. (2024)
Primary headache and facial pain. (2024)Mohamed Rizk Khodair
 
Hematology and Immunology - Leukocytes Functions
Hematology and Immunology - Leukocytes FunctionsHematology and Immunology - Leukocytes Functions
Hematology and Immunology - Leukocytes FunctionsMedicoseAcademics
 
Statistical modeling in pharmaceutical research and development.
Statistical modeling in pharmaceutical research and development.Statistical modeling in pharmaceutical research and development.
Statistical modeling in pharmaceutical research and development.ANJALI
 
call girls in Dwarka Sector 21 Metro DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Se...
call girls in Dwarka Sector 21 Metro DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Se...call girls in Dwarka Sector 21 Metro DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Se...
call girls in Dwarka Sector 21 Metro DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Se...saminamagar
 
Pharmaceutical Marketting: Unit-5, Pricing
Pharmaceutical Marketting: Unit-5, PricingPharmaceutical Marketting: Unit-5, Pricing
Pharmaceutical Marketting: Unit-5, PricingArunagarwal328757
 
call girls in munirka DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in munirka  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in munirka  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in munirka DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️saminamagar
 
PNEUMOTHORAX AND ITS MANAGEMENTS.pdf
PNEUMOTHORAX   AND  ITS  MANAGEMENTS.pdfPNEUMOTHORAX   AND  ITS  MANAGEMENTS.pdf
PNEUMOTHORAX AND ITS MANAGEMENTS.pdfDolisha Warbi
 
VarSeq 2.6.0: Advancing Pharmacogenomics and Genomic Analysis
VarSeq 2.6.0: Advancing Pharmacogenomics and Genomic AnalysisVarSeq 2.6.0: Advancing Pharmacogenomics and Genomic Analysis
VarSeq 2.6.0: Advancing Pharmacogenomics and Genomic AnalysisGolden Helix
 
PULMONARY EDEMA AND ITS MANAGEMENT.pdf
PULMONARY EDEMA AND  ITS  MANAGEMENT.pdfPULMONARY EDEMA AND  ITS  MANAGEMENT.pdf
PULMONARY EDEMA AND ITS MANAGEMENT.pdfDolisha Warbi
 
LUNG TUMORS AND ITS CLASSIFICATIONS.pdf
LUNG TUMORS AND ITS  CLASSIFICATIONS.pdfLUNG TUMORS AND ITS  CLASSIFICATIONS.pdf
LUNG TUMORS AND ITS CLASSIFICATIONS.pdfDolisha Warbi
 
Glomerular Filtration rate and its determinants.pptx
Glomerular Filtration rate and its determinants.pptxGlomerular Filtration rate and its determinants.pptx
Glomerular Filtration rate and its determinants.pptxDr.Nusrat Tariq
 

Último (20)

Presentació "Real-Life VR Integration for Mild Cognitive Impairment Rehabilit...
Presentació "Real-Life VR Integration for Mild Cognitive Impairment Rehabilit...Presentació "Real-Life VR Integration for Mild Cognitive Impairment Rehabilit...
Presentació "Real-Life VR Integration for Mild Cognitive Impairment Rehabilit...
 
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
97111 47426 Call Girls In Delhi MUNIRKAA
 
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy PlatformSee the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
 
Biomechanics- Shoulder Joint!!!!!!!!!!!!
Biomechanics- Shoulder Joint!!!!!!!!!!!!Biomechanics- Shoulder Joint!!!!!!!!!!!!
Biomechanics- Shoulder Joint!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
call girls in Connaught Place DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service ...
call girls in Connaught Place  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service ...call girls in Connaught Place  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service ...
call girls in Connaught Place DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service ...
 
Case Report Peripartum Cardiomyopathy.pptx
Case Report Peripartum Cardiomyopathy.pptxCase Report Peripartum Cardiomyopathy.pptx
Case Report Peripartum Cardiomyopathy.pptx
 
History and Development of Pharmacovigilence.pdf
History and Development of Pharmacovigilence.pdfHistory and Development of Pharmacovigilence.pdf
History and Development of Pharmacovigilence.pdf
 
Wessex Health Partners Wessex Integrated Care, Population Health, Research & ...
Wessex Health Partners Wessex Integrated Care, Population Health, Research & ...Wessex Health Partners Wessex Integrated Care, Population Health, Research & ...
Wessex Health Partners Wessex Integrated Care, Population Health, Research & ...
 
Glomerular Filtration and determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
Glomerular Filtration and  determinants of glomerular filtration .pptxGlomerular Filtration and  determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
Glomerular Filtration and determinants of glomerular filtration .pptx
 
Primary headache and facial pain. (2024)
Primary headache and facial pain. (2024)Primary headache and facial pain. (2024)
Primary headache and facial pain. (2024)
 
Hematology and Immunology - Leukocytes Functions
Hematology and Immunology - Leukocytes FunctionsHematology and Immunology - Leukocytes Functions
Hematology and Immunology - Leukocytes Functions
 
Statistical modeling in pharmaceutical research and development.
Statistical modeling in pharmaceutical research and development.Statistical modeling in pharmaceutical research and development.
Statistical modeling in pharmaceutical research and development.
 
call girls in Dwarka Sector 21 Metro DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Se...
call girls in Dwarka Sector 21 Metro DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Se...call girls in Dwarka Sector 21 Metro DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Se...
call girls in Dwarka Sector 21 Metro DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Se...
 
Pharmaceutical Marketting: Unit-5, Pricing
Pharmaceutical Marketting: Unit-5, PricingPharmaceutical Marketting: Unit-5, Pricing
Pharmaceutical Marketting: Unit-5, Pricing
 
call girls in munirka DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in munirka  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in munirka  DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in munirka DELHI 🔝 >༒9540349809 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
PNEUMOTHORAX AND ITS MANAGEMENTS.pdf
PNEUMOTHORAX   AND  ITS  MANAGEMENTS.pdfPNEUMOTHORAX   AND  ITS  MANAGEMENTS.pdf
PNEUMOTHORAX AND ITS MANAGEMENTS.pdf
 
VarSeq 2.6.0: Advancing Pharmacogenomics and Genomic Analysis
VarSeq 2.6.0: Advancing Pharmacogenomics and Genomic AnalysisVarSeq 2.6.0: Advancing Pharmacogenomics and Genomic Analysis
VarSeq 2.6.0: Advancing Pharmacogenomics and Genomic Analysis
 
PULMONARY EDEMA AND ITS MANAGEMENT.pdf
PULMONARY EDEMA AND  ITS  MANAGEMENT.pdfPULMONARY EDEMA AND  ITS  MANAGEMENT.pdf
PULMONARY EDEMA AND ITS MANAGEMENT.pdf
 
LUNG TUMORS AND ITS CLASSIFICATIONS.pdf
LUNG TUMORS AND ITS  CLASSIFICATIONS.pdfLUNG TUMORS AND ITS  CLASSIFICATIONS.pdf
LUNG TUMORS AND ITS CLASSIFICATIONS.pdf
 
Glomerular Filtration rate and its determinants.pptx
Glomerular Filtration rate and its determinants.pptxGlomerular Filtration rate and its determinants.pptx
Glomerular Filtration rate and its determinants.pptx
 

78(10)1234

  • 1. Special Theme — Child Mortality The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries: from targeting diseases to targeting people Mariam Claeson1 & Ronald J. Waldman2 Mortality rates among children and the absolute number of children dying annually in developing countries have declined considerably over the past few decades. However, the gains made have not been distributed evenly: childhood mortality remains higher among poorer people and the gap between rich and poor has grown. Several poor countries, and some poorer regions within countries, have experienced a levelling off of or even an increase in childhood mortality over the past few years. Until now, two types of programmes — short-term, disease-specific initiatives and more general programmes of primary health care — have contributed to the decline in mortality. Both types of programme can contribute substantially to the strengthening of health systems and in enabling households and communities to improve their health care. In order for them to do so, and in order to complete the unfinished agenda of improving child health globally, new strategies are needed. On the one hand, greater emphasis should be placed on promoting those household behaviours that are not dependent on the performance of health systems. On the other hand, more attention should be paid to interventions that affect health at other stages of the life cycle while efforts that have been made to develop interventions that can be used during childhood continue. Keywords: child welfare; child health services, trends; communicable diseases, prevention and control; delivery of health care; infant mortality, trends; models, theoretical. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78: 1234–1245. Voir page 1243 le resume en francais. En la pagina 1244 figura un resumen en espanol. ´ ´ ¸ ´ ˜ Introduction 50 countries the mortality for children under 5 years was greater than 100 deaths per 1000 live births. In For the past 35 years, the steep decline in deaths 12 countries (11 of them in Africa), one in every among infants and children has provided evidence of five children born alive did not survive to the age of an important success story in international develop- five years (1). Of the nearly 11 million children who ment. Mortality has declined steadily at an average of will die before their fifth birthday this year, 70% will about 1% per year. The absolute number of children die from a disease, a combination of a few diseases, under the age of 5 years dying has fallen from an or a condition for which safe and effective estimated 15 million in 1980 to about 11 million at the interventions are readily available in industrialized end of the 1990s (1). Remarkably, this decline has countries: acute respiratory infections, diarrhoea, occurred in the face of increased births, spreading measles, malaria, and malnutrition (2). resistance to commonly used antibiotics and anti- Better access to basic health services — malarial drugs and, most menacingly, the growth of including vaccinations, oral rehydration therapy, the AIDS pandemic. and antibiotics for pneumonia — together with A closer look at this favourable trend, improvements in social conditions — including however, reveals that progress has been distributed higher standards of living and smaller families living unevenly. Recently, the decline in mortality among on larger incomes — have been important factors in children under 5 years has stalled in a number of improving the survival rate of children. As deaths countries and in some the trend has reversed and among children under 5 years have declined in many mortality seems to be rising. In 1998, in more than developing countries, contributing to both demo- graphic and epidemiological transitions, the propor- 1 tional mortality accounted for by some conditions Principal Public Health Specialist, Health, Nutrition, and Population, has increased: this problem has been relatively Human Development Department, World Bank, Washington, DC, 20433, USA (email: mclaeson@worldbank.org). Correspondence ignored by the international health community. For should be addressed to this author. example, the greatest decline in childhood mortality 2 Professor of Clinical Public Health and Director, Program on rates has occurred among children in the post- Forced Migration and Health, Center for Population and Family Health, neonatal period; this has led to a relative increase in Joseph L. Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, the importance of neonatal and perinatal mortality. New York, USA. Also, gender-specific issues have emerged in some Ref. No. 00-0762 1234 # World Health Organization 2000 Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
  • 2. The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries parts of the world, notably on the Indian subconti- programmes must, when possible, promote com- nent where girls aged between 1 month and 5 years munity involvement while contributing to the on- still experience considerably higher mortality and going development and strengthening of national morbidity than boys (3, 4). And, although this paper health systems (6). does not deal with it specifically, increases in deaths Similarly, a debate over the degree to which the from AIDS in Africa are already slowing or reversing objectives of primary health care can be translated these downward trends. Without a major assault on into effective programmes resulted in the emergence AIDS throughout local health systems and in the of ‘‘selective primary health care’’ (7). This new community, childhood mortality, whether from strategy, which targeted the control of diseases infection or from the increased risks associated with identified as the most important contributors to being orphaned, can be expected to increase in some increased mortality, was intended to be more focused parts of the world. and more feasible. A number of specific, more In this paper, we examine the roots from which vertical programmes (so named because of the self- current child health programmes have grown, some of contained way they appear on organizational charts the causes behind the apparent slowing of progress in and, more importantly, in budget lines of health many parts of the world, and we suggest ways in which ministries) were promoted to channel relatively the nature of these programmes must change if meagre resources into areas in which demonstrable continued gains are to be made throughout the world. success could be achieved in the medium-term. Furthermore, the emphasis was clearly put on programmes that would contribute to achieving decreases in mortality among infants and children, Trends and milestones since children were considered to be the most Global strategies for reducing childhood mortality vulnerable segment of the population because they have been of two basic types. The first were have the highest rates of preventable death. ambitious disease-specific, technologically depen- The World Health Organization, for example, dent strategies aimed at achieving dramatic, albeit first developed the Expanded Programme on narrow, successes in a relatively short time. The Immunization and subsequently the Programme notable failure of the most ambitious programme of for the Control of Diarrhoeal Diseases. UNICEF this type — the malaria eradication programme (not chose four specific interventions on which to focus: exclusively a child health programme, but one that growth monitoring, oral rehydration therapy, breast- was expected to make a major contribution to feeding promotion, and immunization, known by the reducing child mortality) launched in the 1950s and acronym GOBI. It later added three more (food, abandoned in the 1970s — contributed strongly to a family planning, and female education). Bilateral shift in thinking (5). donors followed, channelling funds into what came The more people-centred, community-based to be called ‘‘child survival’’ programmes; these strategy typified by primary health care, with its goal retained their roots in community-oriented, popula- of health for all by the year 2000, was adopted by the tion-based, primary health care, but at the same time World Health Assembly in 1977. Primary health care had the appeal of using relatively inexpensive medical sought to broaden the focus of health services by technologies to reach specific, stated objectives. emphasizing programmatic areas instead of specific Although the two strategies, at different ends diseases. Accordingly, the provision of universal of the intervention spectrum, have been able to services for maternal and child health, family coexist relatively peacefully, they have never quite planning, improved water supplies, and environ- coalesced. Currently, several attempts at rapproche- mental sanitation became objectives; these were to be ment are under way. For example, the multi-agency achieved through an equitable distribution of Roll Back Malaria movement includes components resources, community involvement, an emphasis on aimed at health systems and at the community. prevention instead of clinic-based curative interven- Reduced rates of morbidity and death from malaria, it tions, and a multisectoral approach. suggests, should be viewed as markers of improved Neither strategic approach ever totally eclipsed health systems. Similarly, the Integrated Management the other. Although attempts to eradicate malaria of Childhood Illness initiative explicitly incorporates failed, the ensuing smallpox eradication programme a component of community development; this is probably the most successful large-scale public programme evolved from selective primary health health programme in history, with the last case of care programmes that aimed to control diarrhoeal smallpox acquired by human-to-human transmission diseases and acute respiratory infections in childhood having occurred in 1977. Important lessons have by working with health workers and strengthening been learnt from both the failed malaria eradication health systems. Both of these efforts, and many programme and the successful smallpox programme; others currently being implemented (including the these lessons have been applied to current attempts poliomyelitis and dracunculiasis eradication pro- to eradicate dracunculiasis and poliomyelitis, two grammes) emphasize the need for community programmes which are on the verge of success. To an participation, for strong and effective partnerships important degree, the appeal of these programmes is between public and private sectors, for intersectoral rooted in the acceptance that disease-specific links, and the need to combine medical technology Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10) 1235
  • 3. Special Theme — Child Mortality with behavioural interventions. That is, they recog- reviews influenced the direction of global efforts in nize these needs in rhetoric, if not in practice. This preventing and controlling childhood acute respira- reflects current thinking as to how programmes to tory infections and diarrhoea. improve children’s health should be implemented, In the 1990s, research priorities have evolved not necessarily how resources are being invested. as efforts to develop a more integrated approach to Although emphasis on community-level interven- case management both in the home and within the tions is generally recognized to be a desirable and health system have intensified. The success of case- effective approach to implementing successful management strategies depends only in part upon programmes, activities still tend to focus on improv- the availability of services provided by trained health ing the delivery of services through an organized care workers. Equally important, if not more so, are health system, rather than on effecting behavioural the behaviours of the carer in the home and in the change. community. Case management in the home, care- seeking practices (including the extent to which available health services are used), and compliance The past: research and action with counselling provided by health workers all have an important impact on children’s health. Research The recognition that there were multiple technical priorities have therefore focused increasingly on and operational challenges to the implementation of promoting and maintaining household and commu- child health and nutrition programmes over the past nity support for the home management of childhood 20 years led to an evolution of research priorities (8). illnesses (with appropriate referral when indicated) Before 1985, microbiological, epidemiological, im- through interventions designed to encourage com- munological, and clinical research contributed to the munication and change behaviour. Ethnographic development of both preventive and therapeutic research, participatory rural appraisal, and other interventions for the control of common diseases in qualitative methods have been the tools that have childhood. A prototypical example is the finding that guided the development, local adaptation, and imple- treatment of acute, watery diarrhoea did not depend mentation of many of these effective, community- on the etiological agent and that oral rehydration level interventions (11). therapy with a single, standard solution is safe and To a considerable extent, the progress in effective in almost all cases; this finding shaped global reducing childhood mortality rates is the result of treatment policies for childhood diarrhoeal diseases. efficient interactions between research, analysis, Similarly, the identification of Streptococcus pneumoniae policy development, and programme evaluation. and Haemophilus influenzae as the leading bacterial The cycle — which includes the dissemination of causes of mortality from pneumonia led to the research findings, implementation of programmes development of a universal case-management strat- based on those findings, and feedback regarding egy based on symptomatic diagnosis and standar- successes and failures — has involved the research dized antibiotic treatment. After the development of community, bilateral and international donors, health these technical approaches, research priorities shifted ministries, and nongovernmental organizations in from focusing on incidence, etiology, and other developed and developing countries. WHO has descriptive research to focusing on analytical research played a critical part in the analysis and formulation that was directed at designing, monitoring, and of policy and has provided guidance in implementing evaluating the impact of priority interventions. and evaluating efforts in various countries. For example, in the mid-1980s, the World Health Organization commissioned a review of research that might contribute to determining the potential effectiveness, feasibility, and cost of 18 sug- The present: new initiatives gested preventive interventions for childhood diar- and programmatic approaches rhoea (9). The most promising were found to be For much of the past few decades, the international promoting breastfeeding, improving water supplies, health agenda has been dominated by strategies and modifying sanitation and hygiene behaviours, in- programmes aimed at reducing mortality in child- creasing measles vaccination coverage and, after hood. Reich proposes a number of reasons why this development of the appropriate technologies was was the case. For one, it was important that children’s ensured, vaccinating against rotavirus infections and health problems were being addressed by large, cholera. Similar reviews were done for the Pro- influential organizations, including UNICEF, WHO, gramme on Acute Respiratory Infections in the 1990s and public–private coalitions, such as the Task Force (10). This process identified eight potential interven- for Child Survival and Development. They also had tions, each with the ability to prevent at least 5% of symbolic power in the emotional appeal of being able deaths from pneumonia. These were vaccinating to save children’s lives with simple, cheap interven- children against measles, S. pneumoniae, H. influenzae tions. Also, with the exception of the infant formula type B, and respiratory syncytial virus; minimizing industry, children’s health issues posed no competi- indoor air pollution; reducing the rates of children tion to vested corporate interests. Additionally, born at low birth weight; and exclusively breastfeed- science was on its side: the use of infant mortality ing until the child was aged 4–6 months. These rates as a proxy for national health status and 1236 Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
  • 4. The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries development called attention to the causes of early supervision, monitoring, training, and supplying deaths and to the interventions that could be aimed at drugs or vaccines. Without the technical and them. Finally, for the most part, the agenda setters — programmatic support to which they have become that is, the politicians — found that child health is a accustomed, and which cannot be made available at readily accepted cause that meets with little opposi- the provincial or district level in most developing tion when proposed as a subject for social investment countries, child health services are at risk of levelling (12). It should also be mentioned that childhood off or even declining in both quantity and quality. illnesses make a substantial contribution to the global At the same time, child health programmes, burden of disease (the Integrated Management of especially vaccination programmes, have benefited Childhood Illness strategy alone, at the time it was from major new funding from non-traditional sources. formulated, addressed conditions that accounted for Although it seems as if some of the activities being as much as 14% of disability-adjusted life years) (13), pursued may be contradictory, the potential for each and high mortality rates in children under 5 years of activity to help reduce childhood mortality is evident. A age are an important contributor to reduced life few of the more prominent initiatives currently being expectancy in developing countries. implemented around the world are discussed below. Recently, however, the primacy of child health concerns has been challenged, although most advocates of adolescent and adult health pro- Vaccination strategies grammes agree that it is not useful to promote competition between intiatives that target other age Vaccine-preventable diseases are responsible for a groups and and those aimed at child health problems significant proportion of the approximately 11 mil- (14). Yet, unless careful attention is paid to lion deaths that occur annually among children under consolidating the gains made to date and to reversing 5 years of age (Table 1). Yet, nowhere is the contrast emerging negative trends in some parts of the world, between short-term disease-specific programmes the gap in life expectancy between richer and poorer and long-term developmental programmes more nations, and between rich and poor within nations, evident than in the area of childhood vaccination. may continue to grow. Preventing this situation will Two contemporary vaccination strategies have require continued emphasis on controlling commu- received massive support from both the public and nicable diseases, especially those diseases that affect private sectors. The highest profile public health children disproportionately (15). programme is the initiative to eradicate poliomyelitis. Supported by a 1988 resolution of the World Health Assembly (16) and by a major coalition of interna- tional agencies and private organizations, the drive to Health sector reforms eradicate poliomyelitis is a direct descendant of Even if resources for child health are maintained at previous eradication programmes. Based on a current levels or increased, strategies will have to be strategy of multiple national mass immunization days adapted to current trends. Presently, many health accompanied by intensified surveillance, poliomyeli- activities in a large number of developing countries tis has been eliminated from industrialized countries are unfolding in an environment of health sector and is on the verge of being eradicated worldwide. reform. Donor support seems to have shifted from The concept of poliomyelitis eradication is specific programmes to the development of leaner laudable. If successful, it will rid the world of a disease and potentially more efficient administrative and which causes permanent disability and it will allow for managerial structures. Typical features of most health the cessation of the production, distribution, and reform efforts are the decentralization of budgetary administration of poliomyelitis vaccine. It will give and, sometimes, programmatic authority to provin- public health workers around the world a tangible cial or district levels and the administrative integra- success and, perhaps, provide strong motivation for tion of centralized programmes. These reform achieving comparable success in other health pro- processes and sectorwide approaches can provide grammes. However, poliomyelitis does not contribute opportunities to identify priority problems and more substantially to the global burden of disease, and its cost-effective and affordable interventions. Addi- eradication will not appreciably affect childhood tionally, they may aid the development of sustainable mortality rates. Furthermore, despite the heroic health systems that are capable of devising local mobilization efforts that have been undertaken for solutions for local problems. However, there has mass immunization days to be successful, eradication been less emphasis put on maintaining the quality of is ultimately dependent upon the ability of a health the more traditional, technically dependent pro- system to organize special campaigns for the delivery grammes such as those dealing with childhood of services. A strong partnership between commu- diseases, including the Expanded Programme on nities and the health system is a fundamental Immunization, the Control of Diarrhoeal Diseases requirement but, unless it is made an explicit goal, programme, the Programme on Acute Respiratory there is little transfer of responsibility to parents and Infections, and nutrition. For example, decentraliza- communities. So, in some countries, although im- tion has often been accompanied by a reduction in munization days have been successful, vaccination support for essential programme activities such as coverage with antigens other than those for polio- Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10) 1237
  • 5. Special Theme — Child Mortality Table 1. Annual deaths due to vaccine-preventable diseases (21 ) eradication initiative, the global alliance is a public– private consortium whose principal members are Disease No. of preventable WHO, UNICEF, the World Bank, national govern- annual deaths ments, public health and research institutions, the Rockefeller Foundation, the International Federation Poliomyelitis 720 of Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Associations, and Diphtheria 5000 the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. Pertussis 346 000 The global alliance reports that although Measles 888 000 children in developing countries are scheduled by Tetanus (including 215 000 neonatal deaths) 410 000 their national immunization programmes to receive six Haemophilus influenzae type b 400 000 or seven antigens as part of their routine series of Hepatitis Ba 900 000 vaccination, children in the wealthier countries in Yellow fevera 30 000 Total 2 979 720 Europe and North America can expect to receive protection against more than 10 vaccine-preventable a Most deaths do not occur in childhood. diseases. This ‘‘vaccine gap’’ is another example of the inequitable distribution of health services that con- tributes to the growing difference in mortality between myelitis, delivered through the routine health services, rich and poor. Incorporating newer, safe, and effective is declining. Additionally, it is apparent that those vaccines into routine immunization programmes and countries with the weakest health systems will be the increasing coverage for all vaccines in a consistent and last to achieve eradication. As a result, as the deadline sustainable manner for all segments of the population for eradication approaches, there will be increased will require a long-term commitment to developing pressure on these countries to focus only on the and implementing programmes. Additionally, the narrow goal of eradicating poliomyelitis and to development and maintenance of the infrastructure abandon the accompanying objectives related to required to support vaccination programmes will be strengthening their health systems. Accordingly, there important as new vaccines against diseases that are is a real potential that the gap in the ability of countries major contributors to both childhood and adult to carry out other programmes that are dependent on mortality, including malaria, AIDS, and tuberculosis, their health systems, including those directed toward are developed and marketed. improving child health, will continue to grow. There is no obvious reason why both types of As the drive toward poliomyelitis eradication programmes — shorter-term eradication initiatives and nears its successful end, plans are being made to longer-term developmental programmes — should not embark upon a global initiative to eradicate measles. coexist. If funding is available, if personnel and other Unlike poliomyelitis, measles is an important cause of non-monetary resources are sufficient to support both childhood mortality, and its eradication would make kinds of efforts as well as other programmes for which an important contribution towards reducing child- health ministries are responsible, and if demonstrable hood mortality. Technical and programmatic argu- benefits to the target populations can be shown, ments have been advanced, both in favour of and eradication programmes — which appeal to politicians, against devoting major resources to eradicating donors, and the public — could not only contribute to measles. The potential operational, technical, epide- reducing mortality but could also serve as a leading edge miological, and financial problems that such a to prepare countries for longer-term programmes. programme might face have been discussed (17, 18). However, it might be important to make develop- While poliomyelitis eradication efforts have mental goals more explicit in order to ensure that been progressing, and while measles elimination is eradication-type programmes are held accountable for being pursued in several regions, vaccination coverage their achievements in all countries, both richer and with the standard six antigens of the WHO Expanded poorer. This might be accomplished by setting longer- Programme on Immunization has, in fact, fallen over term goals — for example, by deciding what ought to the past decade (19). UNICEF estimates that, despite be achieved over the next 25 years — and allowing the proclaimed success of its Universal Childhood countries to pursue those globally agreed goals at their Immunization programme efforts in the 1980s, which own pace in accordance with their own priorities. The sought to achieve 80% vaccination coverage with the advent of public health endowments, such as the antigens described in the WHO programme by the Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization, may second half of the 1990s, 44 countries had measles allow for longer-term planning, as the urgency to raise vaccine coverage of less than 65% for children aged funding for short-term programmes may be somewhat 1 year. Populous countries, such as Nigeria, are alleviated in the future. included in this category; India had an estimated measles vaccine coverage of 67% (20). The new Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunizations is Case-management: the trend towards responding to this negative trend and is a major promoter of vaccination and immunization. The integrating and packaging services organization seeks to provide more vaccines to more To conform to the changing characteristics of health children in more countries (21). Like the poliomyelitis ministries, which have undergone substantial reorga- 1238 Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
  • 6. The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries nization and reform, including a reduction in the income is a contributing factor to ill-health and emphasis on technical programmes, efforts have been malnutrition, so are poor health, malnutrition, and made to incorporate disease-control programmes in large family size key determinants of poverty. In more integrated and manageable packages of basic targeting health interventions at poorer people, there services. The Integrated Management of Childhood are two formidable challenges: to lower the incidence Illness programme is one example of this approach. of outcomes associated with adverse health and poor Developed jointly by WHO and UNICEF, this nutrition and to protect households against poten- programme has been embraced by more than tially impoverishing effects when adverse outcomes 60 countries and has attracted support from a large do occur. number of donor agencies, including more than It is not only that poor people are in ill-health: 25 projects supported by the World Bank. ill-health causes poverty. In Voices of the poor, a recent The conditions included in the package include World Bank study, ill-health emerged as one of the major communicable diseases (pneumonia, diar- principal reasons why households become poor and rhoea, malaria, and measles). The package also remain poor (23). Explanations are numerous: they emphasizes addressing malnutrition, which has been include the burden of health care expenditures shown to contribute to more than half of all incurred by caring for sick household members childhood deaths (22). To a greater extent than many (24), the lost income of the sick, and the lost income earlier strategies, this package includes both treat- of other household members who care for the sick. ment and prevention interventions. In addition to Nationally, although data relating the impact of training health workers in standard case-management health indicators to poverty rates are scarce, evidence protocols for treating all five diseases, the package is emerging about the impact of health on economic urges the promotion of breastfeeding, improvements growth. One study estimated that health and in feeding practices, the use of micronutrient demographic variables accounted for half of the supplements, and vaccines. difference in growth rates between Africa and the rest Even more importantly, the package calls of the world from 1965 to 1990 (25). attention to the need not only to train health Malnutrition is also known to be an important professionals but also to strengthen existing health determinant of poverty through its direct effects on systems to ensure the availability of drugs and loss of earnings: the chronically malnourished work supplies and widespread access to them. Supervision, less and earn less (26, 27). In addition, malnutrition monitoring, and evaluation activities are also empha- exerts indirect effects on health status, cognitive sized. The third, and essential, component of the development, and the productivity of workers. package is the promotion of improved prevention Numerous examples can be cited: non-breastfed and care-seeking behaviours in the community and babies have a 14-fold increased risk of dying from the family. diarrhoea (28); iodine deficiency disorder has been Diseases that contribute directly to childhood estimated to reduce intelligence quotient (IQ) by an mortality are not the only subjects of these new average of 13.5 points (29); and in Chile, iron- initiatives. Increased attention is being paid to early deficient children who were successfully treated childhood development, emphasizing the psychologi- performed 10–400% better on standardized tests cal and intellectual growth of the child. Interventions than anaemic children (30). in childhood development are traditionally focused on Improving health and nutrition especially the family and community and are not delivered among people living in poverty or close to poverty through the health system. Nevertheless, certain is thus likely to pay dividends by contributing to rises aspects of the care of young children have recently in household income and raising incomes will help been added as an option in adapting the Integrated lower mortality. Because of the gross health inequal- Management of Childhood Illness package for ities between rich and poor both within and between countries that want early childhood development to countries it seems reasonable to encourage a change be incorporated as an integral part of recovery from in health programming. If mortality rates, especially childhood illness. Similarly, just as early childhood in childhood, are to be further reduced and stagnating development programmes combine interventions in or reversed trends are to be corrected, it may be more nutrition, health, and psychology to achieve improved important in the future to address the needs of outcomes overall, recent interagency efforts (between specific families and households rather than to WHO, UNICEF, and the World Bank) combine the emphasize the development of programmes aimed teaching of life skills with the provision of appropriate at specific diseases, wherever they might occur. This health services at schools, including adequate water people-oriented approach may be more difficult, and and sanitation facilities. it may entail the development and application of sociological rather than biomedical research. But it is increasingly clear that reducing poverty can be The link between poverty and child achieved by introducing policies and applying programmes that protect households from the health outcomes impoverishing effects of ill health, malnutrition, and It is increasingly understood that the relation between high fertility. health and poverty is bi-directional. Just as low Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10) 1239
  • 7. Special Theme — Child Mortality The future of child health efforts Box 1. A list of key household behaviours for in a changing political environment reducing childhood mortality (11 ) To a certain extent, the easiest part of achieving lasting Reproductive health behaviours reductions in childhood mortality has occurred in Women of reproductive age should delay age of first some countries. In others, the strategies that have been pregnancy, practise birth spacing, limit family size. used — strengthening health systems and training Pregnant women should seek antenatal care at least twice health care providers in the appropriate use of safe, during pregnancy. effective, affordable technologies — have been Women should take iron supplementation during inadequate or not sustainable. In these countries, pregnancy. mortality rates have stagnated or are rising. In all cases, Infant and child feeding practices further improvements will depend to a large extent on Mothers should breastfeed their children exclusively what happens in the household and community and to for about six months. what extent the health system is responsive and will From six months mothers should give children appropriate play a supportive part. The promotion of a limited set complementary feeding and continue to breastfeed for of household behaviours that have direct links to the 24 months (if testing positive for human immunodeficiency prevention and cure of common childhood illnesses virus, current recommendations should be followed). needs to become the centrepiece of intensified activity Immunization practices (see Box 1). Since the ability and willingness of All infants should be taken for measles vaccination at nine families to adopt new behaviours are influenced by a months of age. variety of factors, it will need to be determined locally Infants should be taken for routine vaccinations even when how best to promote these behaviours. Factors sick. influencing the adoption of new behaviours include Pregnant women and other women of childbearing age the household’s resources, attitudes in the community; should seek tetanus toxoid vaccine at every opportunity. and the price, quality, and availability of services and goods such as food, energy, transport, water, and Home health practices Prevention sanitation facilities. All children should sleep under insecticide-treated bednets A graphical depiction of the relation between when indicated. the household or the community and the health Wash hands with soap at appropriate times. system is shown in Fig. 1 (31). The Pathway to All infants and children should consume enough vitamin A, Survival is a guide that distinguishes between by whatever means available. prevention behaviours, such as breastfeeding, that All families should use iodized salt. can be implemented entirely in the home and those, such as vaccination, that require more direct support Treatment from the health system. Similarly, it shows how the Continue feeding and increase fluid intake during illness; management of childhood illness can also be carried increase feeding after illness. Mix and administer oral rehydration salts, or an appropriate out in the home in many instances, with mothers home-available fluid, correctly. responsible for making the critical decision of when Administer treatment and medications according to external support is required. One of the most instruction. attractive features of the pathway is that it can be used as a quantitative tool for measuring problems in Care-seeking practices home care, health care-seeking behaviour, the Seek appropriate care when an infant or child is recognized delivery of primary and secondary health care, as being sick. counselling patients, and the compliance of carers. In fact, a distribution of causes of death can be established on the basis of ‘‘social autopsies’’ taken nutrition and population) sourcebook of the World Bank from mothers whose children have recently died. includes the more distal role of government policies One study in the periurban area of El Alto, near La and actions (Fig. 2). The Mosley–Chen framework Paz, the Republic of Bolivia, where childhood included both social and biological variables. It mortality was high, found that considerably more assumed that all influences on childhood mortality than half of the deaths could be ascribed to at the individual, household, and community levels inadequate knowledge or incorrect behaviour, or operate through a set of common mechanisms, such both, occurring in the household or community. as maternal factors, environmental contamination, Findings such as these support the notion that further nutrient deficiency, injury, and control over personal progress in child survival can only be made by making illness; these were the more proximate determinants. greater investments in communities and families. In the revised framework, the links between policy A recent adaptation of the strategic framework formulation and health outcomes have been made first presented by Mosley & Chen in 1984 adds an more explicit. The revised framework includes health additional dimension to the Pathway for Survival systems interventions and the promotion of appro- model (32). In addition to showing the relation priate household and community behaviours as between the health system and the household and essential intermediate steps between policy and community, the recent Poverty reduction strategy (health, outcome. It recognizes that integrated packages of 1240 Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
  • 8. The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10) 1241
  • 9. Special Theme — Child Mortality interventions, such as the Integrated Management of for a new generation), takes into account four basic Childhood Illness, the Integrated Management of principles: that health interventions have a cumulative Pregnancy and Childbirth, school health pro- impact — the costs and benefits of interventions later grammes, nutritional interventions, and control of in life are partially dependent upon those that occurred both communicable diseases (such as HIV/AIDS, earlier; that sustaining improved outcomes at any stage tuberculosis, and malaria) and noncommunicable of the life cycle depends on interventions occurring diseases, constitute one set of influences on house- during several stages; that interventions in one hold behaviours. Yet policies that determine the generation can influence outcomes in later genera- availability of health services and the financing of tions; and that clearly identifying the different stages of those services and others — such as food supply, the life cycle facilitates the identification of risks for water, sanitation, and other related commodities and both individuals and families. services — are equally important. Finally, it explicitly Identifying the major risks to good health at recognizes that what happens in the household and each stage of the life cycle allows appropriate community is the most proximate determinant of interventions to be selected. These interventions favourable health outcomes (33). could be implemented either exclusively within the Implicit in this approach to achieving good health sector or, consistent with the modified health outcomes is the recognition that childhood Mosley–Chen framework, through other mechan- mortality, for example, does not depend only on isms for influencing household behaviours (34). The interventions in childhood. The health of mothers notion that interventions throughout the life cycle and fathers, siblings, grandparents, and other house- must be implemented to achieve the maximum hold members also influences the health of children. reduction of deaths occurring in childhood will Similarly, interventions during childhood can have an hopefully promote collaboration within the health important influence on health in adulthood. It is sector and between sectors and help ensure that increasingly recognized that interventions in one available resources are used more efficiently and generation can affect health outcomes in the next. effectively. Ensuring adequate nutrition among girls during A discussion of current approaches to reducing childhood and adolescence, for example, can reduce childhood mortality would not be complete without the incidence of low birth-weight babies, an mentioning the legal dimensions of this effort. The important risk factor for early mortality. Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted by the In order to account for these multiple and cross- General Assembly of the United Nations in 1989 and cutting influences, and to organize them in a way that subsequently ratified by all but a small number of can be easily translated into health programmes, the countries, explicitly recognizes a child’s right to health World Bank and its partners have participated in the and health services. Article 24 of the convention elaboration of a life cycle approach (Fig. 3). This obligates all ratifying parties to ‘‘pursue full imple- framework, which includes interventions to be mentation of this right and, in particular, [to] take implemented throughout life (and gives special appropriate measures...to diminish infant and child consideration to the reproductive period for women, mortality.’’ Guidance regarding implementation and which includes pregnancy and the start of a new cycle monitoring of the actions called for by the convention has been developed and disseminated (35). Conclusions We have attempted to present briefly the traditions from which child survival efforts have developed, a concise description of some of the more prominent current initiatives and a few of the ideas being proposed for ensuring continued or resumed progress towards reducing childhood mortality. Although many of the technological tools necessary to address the principal biomedical causes of child- hood mortality in developing countries are available, they have been used in a patchy and inequitable fashion: access to health services and to these tools has been restricted for large parts of the population in many countries. It is increasingly recognized that the health of children is integrally related to poverty, and that there is a strong correlation between high mortality and poverty. Perinatal, neonatal, and early childhood mor- tality have become relatively more important in areas where reductions in mortality have already been 1242 Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
  • 10. The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries substantial. More effective technical interventions order for substantial new reductions in mortality to and strategies for implementing them still need to be be made, disease-specific programmes and those that developed for many of the potentially fatal conditions address the determinants of common causes of that occur earlier in life. But technological advances mortality should be designed to complement each notwithstanding, an increased emphasis on improv- other. Research into new technologies and into new ing health behaviours in households and in commu- ways of influencing household behaviours should be nities must occur if sustainable improvement in strongly and effectively managed, and solutions to outcomes related to children’s health is to be problems of implementation should be disseminated, achieved across all segments of society. Research, widely applied, and evaluated. Strategic approaches, and especially social science research, can contribute such as the Pathway to Survival model, the modified to the development of appropriate behavioural Mosley–Chen framework, and the life cycle ap- interventions but only if the close collaboration proach, should be further developed to provide between the research and the programmatic com- guidance to policy-makers, health service providers, munities can be strengthened. and community leaders. These approaches that are Poverty is an important contributing factor to more community-driven are necessary because the childhood mortality, and economists and international pattern and trends of childhood mortality have financial institutions are beginning to recognize that changed. Although impressive in some places, the adverse health outcomes are an important contributor apparent reductions over the past 20 years sometimes to poverty. Accordingly, it is important that strategies mask the fact that the rate of decline has stalled for aimed at reducing poverty take into account the many people and especially for those who are poor. determinants of poor health outcomes at all stages of Improving children’s survival is an unfinished task, the life cycle. The formulation of policies and but by using innovative multisectoral approaches that programmes that use a broad range of interventions recognize that health outcomes can be influenced in implemented in an integrated manner can result both ways that have not yet been adequately explored, and in improved health and improved standards of living. especially by moving the centre of attention from the The future of child health programmes in health system to the household, additional gains can developing countries depends upon bridging gaps. In be made rapidly and effectively. n Resume ´ ´ L’evolution des programmes de sante infantile dans les pays en developpement : ´ ´ ´ on cesse de cibler les maladies pour cibler les gens Au cours des 30 dernieres annees, les taux de mortalite ` ´ ´ subsaharienne et en Asie du Sud-Est, compromet chez les nourrissons et les enfants ont baisse dans ´ serieusement la poursuite des progres. ´ ` presque tous les pays. En outre, le nombre de deces ´ ` Le present article examine les tendances observees ´ ´ d’enfants est passe d’environ 15 millions a environ ´ ` dans les programmes visant a promouvoir la sante des ` ´ 11 millions, malgre une augmentation du nombre des ´ enfants au cours des dernieres decennies et avance des ` ´ naissances, une resistance croissante aux antibiotiques ´ propositions sur la meilleure facon de concevoir les ¸ et antipaludiques courants et la propagation – difficile a ` programmes futurs. Il passe en revue les differentes ´ enrayer – du syndrome d’immunodeficience acquise ´ approches adoptees dans le passe : les initiatives a court ´ ´ ` (SIDA) dans une grande partie du monde. Plusieurs terme et a objectifs etroits, dirigees contre des maladies ` ´ ´ maladies et problemes de sante, dont les infections ` ´ determinees, comme les premieres campagnes d’eradi- ´ ´ ` ´ respiratoires aigues, les maladies diarrheiques, le ¨ ´ cation du paludisme (un echec) et de la variole (un ´ paludisme, la rougeole et la malnutrition, ont toujours succes), et les strategies de grande envergure, axees sur ` ´ ´ ete les principales causes d’une mortalite infantile ´ ´ ´ le developpement a long terme et sur les communautes, ´ ` ´ elevee, bien qu’il existe contre chacun d’eux des ´ ´ comme les soins de sante primaires. Les programmes ´ interventions sans danger et efficaces. modernes d’eradication de maladies telles que la ´ Nul ne peut garantir que les progres continueront. ` poliomye lite et la dracunculose et les strate gies ´ ´ D’abord, les succes enregistres a ce jour n’ont pas ete ` ´ ` ´ ´ « selectives » de soins de sante primaires, comme le ´ ´ uniformes. Beaucoup de pays pauvres et de regions ´ programme de prise en charge integree des maladies de ´ ´ pauvres de nombreux pays n’ont pas obtenu les memes ˆ l’enfant, essaient de combiner des elements de chacune ´ ´ resultats que les pays prosperes. Ensuite, a mesure que ´ ` ` de ces demarches. ´ les taux de mortalite baissent, differentes affections ´ ´ Le role traditionnellement preponderant des ˆ ´ ´ jouent un role plus determinant : les maladies peri- ˆ ´ ´ programmes de sante infantile semble s’amenuiser. Cela ´ natales et neonatales, contre lesquelles des interventions ´ peut s’expliquer, entre autres, par le fait que le appropriees pouvant etre appliquees sur une grande ´ ˆ ´ mouvement de reforme du secteur de la sante s’est ´ ´ echelle n’ont pas encore ete mises au point, sont ´ ´ ´ davantage preoccupe de considerations administratives ´ ´ ´ desormais la cause d’une proportion plus elevee de deces ´ ´ ´ ´ ` et financieres que des programmes techniques ou ` chez les enfants de moins de cinq ans. Les questions ensembles de programmes. La de centralisation a ´ sexospecifiques doivent aussi etre abordees et la ´ ˆ ´ entraıˆne dans de nombreux pays une deterioration des ´ ´ ´ propagation continue du SIDA, notamment en Afrique fonctions d’appui aux systemes de sante, telles que la ` ´ Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10) 1243
  • 11. Special Theme — Child Mortality formation et l’encadrement du personnel et le suivi et Quatre modeles sont examines. Le guide de la ` ´ l’evaluation des programmes. Toutefois, les strategies ´ ´ survie et une adaptation du cadre de Mosley-Chen techniques, comme celles qui sont appliquees dans le ´ illustrent la relation entre la communaute et le systeme ´ ` cadre des programmes de vaccination et des initiatives de sante, mais sous un angle different. La nouvelle ´ ´ de prise en charge des cas, continuent de s’affiner pour approche du cycle biologique decrit au moyen de ´ ameliorer la prestation des services, renforcer les ´ graphiques comment la sante de l’enfant depend des ´ ´ systemes de sante et, par-dessus tout, favoriser la ` ´ risques et des interventions sanitaires a des ages ` ˆ participation communautaire. differents et des influences entre generations. Enfin, il ´ ´ ´ L’accent est mis de sormais sur la relation ´ est fait mention de la Convention relative aux droits de bidirectionnelle entre la pauvrete et la sante. De grandes ´ ´ l’enfant, et notamment du droit a la sante et aux services ` ´ inegalites en matiere de sante existent entre riches et ´ ´ ` ´ de sante. ´ pauvres, entre pays, au sein des pays et au sein des Bien que l’on dispose dans une large mesure des communaute s. A l’avenir, il peut e tre important ´ ˆ outils technologiques permettant de reduire davantage ´ d’accorder plus d’attention aux menages et aux familles ´ la mortalite infantile, les strategies de mise en œuvre ´ ´ dans lesquels, a cause de la pauvrete ou d’autres ` ´ doivent s’adapter au contexte local. La recherche en facteurs, les enfants sont davantage exposes au risque de ´ sciences sociales, qui vise a trouver des moyens ` mourir. Le message essentiel contenu dans cet article est d’atteindre les communautes et les familles a haut ´ ` que la reduction de la mortalite infanto-juvenile pourrait ´ ´ ´ risque, en particulier celles dont l’acces aux services de ` bien dependre davantage de ce qui se passe dans les ´ sante est entrave par la pauvrete, devient de plus en plus ´ ´ ´ communautes et les menages que de ce qui se passe a ´ ´ ` importante. l’interieur d’un systeme de sante. ´ ` ´ Resumen La evolucion de los programas de salud infantil en los paıses en desarrollo: el punto ´ ´ de mira se desplaza de las enfermedades a las personas Durante los 30 ultimos anos, las tasas de mortalidad de ´ ˜ pasado, a saber: iniciativas a corto plazo y con objetivos lactantes y ninos han disminuido en casi todos los paı´ses. ˜ muy concretos contra enfermedades especı´ficas, como Ademas, el numero de defunciones infantiles ha ´ ´ las primeras iniciativas de erradicacion del paludismo (un ´ descendido de unos 15 millones a cerca de 11 millones fracaso) y de la viruela (un exito), y estrategias amplias, a ´ a pesar del aumento del numero de nacimientos, de ´ largo plazo, de desarrollo, orientadas hacia la comuni- la resistencia creciente a antibioticos y antipaludicos ´ ´ dad, como la de atencion primaria de salud. Los ´ comunes y de la propagacion relativamente incontrolada ´ programas modernos de erradicacion de enfermedades ´ del SIDA en gran parte del mundo. Un numero limitado ´ como la poliomielitis y la dracunculosis y las estrategias de afecciones medicas, como las infecciones respiratorias ´ «selectivas» de atencion primaria, como la de lucha ´ agudas, las enfermedades diarreicas, el paludismo, el integrada contra las enfermedades de la infancia, tratan sarampion y la malnutricion, han constituido sistemati- ´ ´ ´ de combinar diversos elementos de cada uno de esos camente las principales causas de mortalidad infantil enfoques. pese a que existen intervenciones seguras y eficaces La importante funcion que han desempenado ´ ˜ contra cada una de ellas. tradicionalmente los programas de salud infantil parece El progreso continuo no esta asegurado. Primero, ´ estar disminuyendo. Una de las razones podrı´a ser que el hasta la fecha el exito no ha sido uniforme. Muchos ´ impulso hacia la reforma del sector de la salud se ha paı´ses pobres, y zonas pobres de muchos paı´ses, no han centrado mas en consideraciones administrativas y ´ conseguido resultados tan buenos como los mas ricos. ´ financieras que en programas o conjuntos de programas Ademas, a medida que disminuyen las tasas de ´ tecnicos. La descentralizacion ha dado lugar en muchos ´ ´ mortalidad, otras afecciones adquieren mas importancia; ´ paı´ses a un deterioro de las funciones de apoyo a los la mortalidad perinatal y neonatal, para la cual todavı´a sistemas, como la capacitacion, la supervision y la ´ ´ no se han desarrollado intervenciones que puedan vigilancia y la evaluacion de los programas. Sin embargo, ´ implantarse de forma generalizada, contribuye aun mas ´ ´ las estrategias tecnicas, como las de los programas de ´ que antes al numero de defunciones de menores de ´ vacunacion y las iniciativas de gestion de casos, siguen ´ ´ 5 anos. Tambien es necesario abordar las cuestiones ˜ ´ evolucionando para mejorar la prestacion de servicios, ´ relacionadas con la paridad entre los sexos, y la fortalecer los sistemas de salud y, lo que es mas ´ propagacio n continua del sı´ ndrome de inmuno- ´ importante, promover la participacion comunitaria. ´ deficiencia adquirida (SIDA), especialmente en el Africa´ Se destaca la relacionbidireccional entre la pobreza y ´ subsahariana y en Asia Sudoriental, amenaza seriamente la salud. Existen grandes desigualdades de salud entre ricos la continuidad de los progresos. y pobres, entre los paı´ses, dentro de los paı´ses y dentro de En este artı´culo se examinan las tendencias de los las comunidades. En el futuro quiza sea importante dirigir ´ programas de promocion de la salud de los ninos en los ´ ˜ los esfuerzos hacia los hogares y familias en los que, debido ultimos decenios y se formulan sugerencias sobre la ´ a la pobreza u otros factores, los ninos corren mayor peligro ˜ mejor manera de disenar programas en el futuro. Se ˜ de morir. El mensaje clave de este artı´culo es que los futuros analizan los diferentes enfoques adoptados en el avances en la reduccion de la mortalidad de lactantes y ´ 1244 Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10)
  • 12. The evolution of child health programmes in developing countries ninos bien pueden depender de lo que suceda en las ˜ la Convencion sobre los Derechos del Nino, que reconoce ´ ˜ comunidades y los hogares, y no tanto de lo que suceda en el derecho a la salud y a servicios de salud. el sistema de salud. Aunque en gran medida se dispone de herra- Se examinan cuatro modelos. El modelo «La Vı´a mientas tecnologicas para seguir reduciendo la morta- ´ de la Supervivencia» y una adaptacion del marco de ´ lidad infantil, es necesario adaptar las estrategias de Mosley-Chen muestran la relacion entre la comunidad y ´ aplicacion a los contextos locales. Las investigaciones ´ el sistema de salud, pero de forma diferente. El nuevo sociologicas encaminadas a identificar maneras de llegar ´ enfoque del ciclo de vida ilustra graficamente la manera ´ a las comunidades y familias de alto riesgo, especial- en que la salud de los ninos depende de los riesgos e ˜ mente aquellas cuyo acceso a los servicios de salud se intervenciones sanitarios a distintas edades y de halla limitado por la pobreza, estan cobrando una ´ influencias intergeneracionales. Por ultimo se menciona ´ importancia creciente. References 1. UNICEF. The state of the world’s children report 2000. New York, 18. Cutts FT, Henao-Restrepo A, Olive JM. Measles elimination: UNICEF, 2000: 83. progress and challenges. Vaccine, 1999, 17: 47–52. 2. Tulloch J. Integrated approach to child health in developing 19. Vaccine preventable diseases monitoring system, global summary, countries. Lancet, 1999, 354: 16–20. 1999. Geneva, World Health Organization, 1999. 3. Kurz KM, Johnson-Welch C. Gender bias in health care among 20. UNICEF. The state of the world’s children report 2000. New York, children 0–5 years: opportunities for child survival programs. UNICEF, 2000: 92–95. Arlington, VA, United States Agency for International 21. The Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization. Development, the BASICS Project, 1997. A partnership for child health (available on the Internet at 4. Claeson M et al. Reducing child mortality in India in the new http://www.vaccinealliance.org). millennium, Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 22. Pelletier DL et al. The effects of malnutrition on child mortality 78: 1192–1199. in developing countries. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 5. Newell KW. Selective primary health care: the counter revolution. 1995, 73: 443–448. Social Science and Medicine, 1988, 26: 903–906. 23. Narayan et al. Voices of the poor: can anyone hear us? 6. Aylward RB et al. Disease eradication initiatives and general New York, Oxford University Press for the World Bank, 2000. health services: ensuring common principles lead to mutual 24. Ettling M et al. Economic impact of malaria in Malawian benefits. In: Dowdle WR, Hopkins DR, eds. The eradication households. Tropical Medicine and Parasitology, 1994, of infectious diseases. Chichester, UK, John Wiley, 1998: 61–74. 45: 74–79. 7. Walsh JA, Warren KS. Selective primary health care: an interim 25. Bloom DE, Sachs JD. Geography, demography and economic strategy for disease control in developing countries. New England growth in Africa. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1998, Journal of Medicine, 1979, 301: 967–974. 2: 207–295. 8. The evolution of diarrhoeal and acute respiratory disease control 26. Levin H. A benefit–cost analysis of nutritional programs at WHO. Geneva, World Health Organization, Department for anemia reduction. World Bank Research Observer, 1986, of Child and Adolescent Health and Development, 1999 1: 219–246. (WHO/CHS/CAH/99.12). 27. McGuire JS, Austin JA. Beyond survival: children’s growth 9. Feachem RG. Preventing diarrhoea: what are the policy for national development. New York, UNICEF, 1987. options. Health Policy and Planning, 1986, 1: 109–117. 28. Feacham R, Koblinsky M. Interventions for the control of 10. Kirkwood BR. Potential interventions for the prevention diarrhoeal disease among young children: promotion of breast- of childhood pneumonia in developing countries: a systematic feeding. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 1984, review. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 1995, 62: 271–291. 73: 793–798. 29. Bleichrodt N, Born MP. A meta-analysis of research on iodine 11. Murray J et al. Emphasis behaviors in maternal and child health: and its relationship to cognitive development. In: Stanbury JB, ed. focusing on caretaker behaviors to develop maternal and child The damaged brain of iodine deficiency: cognitive, behavioural, health programs in communities. Arlington, VA, United States neuromotor and educative aspects. New York, Cognizant Agency for International Development, the BASICS Project, 1997. Communication, 1994: 195–200. 12. Reich MR. The politics of agenda setting in international health: 30. Walter TI et al. Iron deficiency anemia: adverse effects on infant child health versus adult health in developing countries. Journal psychomotor development. Pediatrics, 1989, 8491: 7–17. of International Development, 1995, 7: 489–502. 31. Waldman RJ et al. Overcoming remaining barriers: the pathway 13. World development report 1993 — Investing in health. to child survival. Arlington, VA, United States Agency for Washington, DC, Oxford University Press for the World Bank, International Development, the BASICS Project, 1996. 1993. 32. Mosley WH, Chen LC, eds. Child survival: strategies for research. 14. Feachem RGA, Phillips MA, Bulatao RA. Introducing adult New York, Population Council, 1984 (Population and Develop- health. In: Feachem RGA et al, eds. The health of adults in ment Review, supplement vol. 10). the developing world. Washington, DC, The World Bank, 1992. 33. Health, nutrition, and population sourcebook for the poverty 15. Gwatkin DR, Guilot M. The burden of disease among the global reduction strategy paper. Washington, DC, Health Nutrition, and poor: current situation, future trends, and implications for strategy. Population Division, The World Bank, 2000. Washington, DC, Human Development Network/Health, 34. Simon J, Rosen S. The family health cycle: creating a context Nutrition, and Population, The World Bank, 2000. for maternal and child health (MCH) interventions. Paper 16. Global eradication of poliomyelitis by the year 2000. Resolution Presented at World Bank Human Development Learning Week, WHA41.28, 41st World Health Assembly, May 1988. Handbook Washington, DC, 22 February 2000. of Resolutions and Decisions, Vol.III, 2nd ed. Geneva, World 35. Hodgkin R, Newell P, eds. Implementation handbook for Health Organization, 1990: 55–56. the convention on the rights of the child. New York, UNICEF, 17. Omer MI. Measles: a disease that has to be eradicated. Annals 1998: 315–340. of Tropical Paediatrics, 1999, 19: 125–134. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2000, 78 (10) 1245