Approved at 2010 WorldApproved at 2010 World
ConferenceConference
Whereas,Whereas,
Human trafficking is destructiveHuman trafficking is destructive
to individuals, families, andto individuals, families, and
communities and is fundamentallycommunities and is fundamentally
incompatible with the life given toincompatible with the life given to
us by our loving Creator;us by our loving Creator;
andand
Whereas, Our Eternal CreatorWhereas, Our Eternal Creator
weeps for and with those soweeps for and with those so
enslaved and desires for us to actenslaved and desires for us to act
individually and as a church with aindividually and as a church with a
worldwide presence throughworldwide presence through
individual and corporate efforts toindividual and corporate efforts to
confront and abolish slavery andconfront and abolish slavery and
end human trafficking;end human trafficking;
therefore, be ittherefore, be it
Resolved, That members ofResolved, That members of
Community of Christ, in organizedCommunity of Christ, in organized
groups or as a part of their individualgroups or as a part of their individual
stewardship, investigate whatstewardship, investigate what
resources exist in their area to helpresources exist in their area to help
them fight slavery and assist victims,them fight slavery and assist victims,
and participate in those activities asand participate in those activities as
appropriate given localappropriate given local
considerations.considerations.
Such activities might includeSuch activities might include
participation inparticipation in
•Rescue and Restore Coalitions (in theRescue and Restore Coalitions (in the
United States);United States);
•groups such as Stop the Traffik, Polarisgroups such as Stop the Traffik, Polaris
Project, Not for Sale, and the InternationalProject, Not for Sale, and the International
Organization for Migration;Organization for Migration;
•gathering supplies for basic needs like foodgathering supplies for basic needs like food
preparation, toiletries, and basicpreparation, toiletries, and basic
housekeeping to offer to freed victimshousekeeping to offer to freed victims
through rescue groups;through rescue groups;
sponsoring community training on victimsponsoring community training on victim
recognition;recognition;
organizing and hosting movies, book clubs,organizing and hosting movies, book clubs,
or journal reading to sensitize and educateor journal reading to sensitize and educate
church members and community members;church members and community members;
and be it furtherand be it further
Resolved, That the Human RightsResolved, That the Human Rights
Team identify and recommendTeam identify and recommend
resources to assist local congregationsresources to assist local congregations
and mission centers to advocate forand mission centers to advocate for
victims, assist with efforts to rescuevictims, assist with efforts to rescue
and restore victims, and prosecuteand restore victims, and prosecute
traffickers, and to participate in othertraffickers, and to participate in other
appropriate ways to dismantle andappropriate ways to dismantle and
abolish this modern day slavery.abolish this modern day slavery.
Trafficking: How it Works
Women/children told false promises
Some children sold by parents
Easier to smuggle people than drugs
or weapons
Mafias or loosely organized crime
networks
Hidden in ethnic enclaves and cultural
taboos
People reusable and resalable
Forms of Recruitment
Smuggling networks
Employment agencies
Maid/ housekeeping/nanny schemes
Mail order bride services
Internet schemes
False modeling agencies
Befriending and/or seduction
Illegal foreign adoption agencies
People Trafficked For:
Domestic Servitude
Sex Work
Forced Prostitution
Marriages/Surrogacy
Factory Work
Begging
International
Adoptions
Agricultural Work
Criminal Activity
Restaurant Work
Construction
Hotel/ Motel
Housekeeping
Other Informal Labor
Sectors
Scope of the Problem
Worldwide
600,000 to 800,000 victims trafficked
annually across international borders.
Estimated 80% of victims are women
and girls.
27 million people in slavery
around the world.
$9 billion business
*After drug dealing, human trafficking is tied with illegal arms trade as the 2nd
largest
criminal industry in the world and the fastest growing.
Scope of the Problem
United States
18,000 to 20,000 victims are trafficked
annually into the United States.
750,000 women were trafficked into the
US in the last decade.
300,000 to 400,000
US children are
victims of the sex
trade.
Victim Mindset
Limited/ no English
Unfamiliar with US culture/ systems
Confined
Fearful and/ or distrustful of authority
Unaware that they are a victim
May develop loyalty to trafficker
Unaware of where they are
Fear for safety of family
Needs of Victims
There are four general areas of victim needs:
Immediate assistance
Housing, food, medical, safety and security,
language interpretation and legal services
Mental health assistance
Counseling
Income assistance
Cash, living assistance
Legal status
T visa, immigration, certification
How Many Slaves Work for You?
Let’s take the survey:
www.slaveryfootprint.org
Victim Rights
Safety
Privacy
Interpretation
Information
Legal
Representation
Right to be heard in
court
Civil compensation
Medical assistance
Immigration relief
Repatriation
Case Management
Benefits
Where to Look
BENEATH THE SURFACE!
Migrant or immigrant communities
Areas known for prostitution
Law enforcement
Clinics/doctor’s offices
Restaurants
Hotels
Your own
neighborhood
Red Flags
Living with employer
Poor living conditions
Holding of documents
Signs of abuse
Inability to speak to
individual alone
Victims living at same
premise where they work
or driven to and from
work
Kept under surveillance
Submissive and fearful
Underpaid or unpaid
What to Do
If you think you have come in
contact with a victim of human
trafficking…
if the victim is at risk of imminent
harm,
CALL 911
What to Do
Call the National Hotline
This hotline will help you:
Determine if you have encountered a
victim of human trafficking
Identify local community resources to
help victims
Coordinate with local social service
organizations
Trafficking Information and Referral Hotline
1-888-373-7888
Communication with Victims
Before questioning a potential trafficking
victim, isolate individual from person
accompanying her/him without raising
suspicions.
Enlist a trained interpreter who also
understands victim’s cultural needs.
Importance of indirectly and sensitively
probing to determine if person is
trafficking victim.
SAFETY! SAFETY! SAFETY! SAFETY!
Messages
Gaining victim’s trust is an important first
step in providing assistance
Sample messages to convey:
We are here to help you.
Our first priority is your safety.
If you are a victim of trafficking and you
cooperate, you will not be deported.
If you are a victim of trafficking, you can get
help to rebuild your life safely in this country.
We can find you a safe place to stay.
We can help get you what you need.
We want to make sure what happened to you
doesn’t happen to anyone else.
You are entitled to help. We can help you get
assistance.
How to Get Involved
Join an activist organization like Stop
the Traffik www.stopthetraffik.org or
the Not For Sale Campaign
www.notforsalecampaign.org
Organize your congregation to get
involved
Explore www.acf.hhs.gov/trafficking
for additional information
How to Get Involved
Tell your pastor or youth leader you
want to do something about human
trafficking and help lead activities in
your congregation using the Human
Rights Team electronic resource
packet –
www.cofchrist.org/humanrights/stoptr
affic
The CallThe Call
He has sent me to proclaimHe has sent me to proclaim
release to the captives andrelease to the captives and
recovery of sight to therecovery of sight to the
blind, to let the oppressedblind, to let the oppressed
go free…go free…
Luke 4:18
Notas do Editor
Human trafficking is a devastating human rights violation that takes place not only internationally, but also here in the United States. It is, indeed, a form of modern-day slavery.
Millions of individuals, the majority of which are women and children, are tricked, coerced, sold or forced into situations of slavery-like exploitation from which they are unable to escape.
I’m going to begin today’s presentation with a story:
A woman kept in domestic servitude in the United States for several years was rescued when a neighbor, noticing that she had a large tumor, offered to take the woman to the health clinic. Luckily, the health providers asked the right questions and realized the woman was a victim of human trafficking. As a result, they helped the woman escape her situation and receive the medical care she desperately needed. Her employers received 15-20 years in jail.
This is a success story because, first, the neighbor took the important step in bringing the woman to the health clinic, and second, because the health providers examining the woman were able to look beneath the surface to probe whether or not she was a possible trafficking victim. Today, I’m going to discuss not only the dimensions of human trafficking but also how to identify and work with trafficking victims.
Traffickers use force, fraud, or coercion to exploit their victims.
Force involves the use of rape, beatings and confinement to control the victim. Forceful violence is used especially during the early stages of victimization, known as the ‘seasoning process,’ which is used to break the victims’ resistance to make them easier to control.
Fraud usually involves false offers of employment. For example, women and children will reply to advertisements promising jobs as waitresses, maids and dancers in other countries and are then forced into prostitution once they arrive at their destinations. Fraud may also involve promises of marriage or a better life, in general.
Coercion involves threats, debt-bondage and psychological manipulation. Traffickers often threaten victims with injury or death, or the safety of the victim’s family back home. Coercion may also include things that are culturally pertinent, for example, holding a lock of the victim’s hair to make a voodoo doll or telling the victim that they cannot return home anyways because they are no longer virgins and this would bring great shame to the victims’ families. Victims do experience a lot of shame as a result of their situation and traffickers utilize this negative emotion to further control their victim.
Recruiting people for the purpose of trafficking is not always a difficult task. Traffickers feed upon a person’s or families current situation to coerce them into slavery without them even knowing. For traffickers, victims are merely commodities to be exploited and traded in any market.
Traffickers use a variety of recruitment methods to “lure” victims in. Most victims think they are recruited for legitimate employment or marriage abroad. They are not aware of the inhumane conditions they will face or that they may be forced to pay back the fees, and accrued interest, associated with their recruitment or transportation fees. Often times, the trafficker takes the person’s documents away until the debt has been repaid.
Sometimes, when children are sold into slavery, parents sincerely believe, or hope, that they are giving their child a better life. This would be part of the fraud and false promises propagated by traffickers.
This slide includes the various employment sectors that victims may be found in.
While most of the information we have just covered primarily focuses on international trafficking I would like to take some time to discuss domestic trafficking.
As you can see from these estimates, the incident of human trafficking internationally is quite staggering.
The numbers are hard to accurately depict as this crime remains hidden and often goes unreported.
As these figures show, the problem of human trafficking exists right here in the United States. Like international statistics, accurate national data is difficult to obtain.
However, it is clear that most likely human trafficking is occurring right here in our city, community, probably even close to our neighborhoods.
As we have shown in this presentation, the occurrence of human trafficking is staggering. The most disheartening fact is that many of the victims are hidden, despite that they probably come into contact with us in a variety of ways.
One of the best ways to help combat this problem is to get involved in the effort.
Involvement can be by joining the coalition, or organizing a presentation at your organization, or even by letting the coalition know that your agency is willing to provide services to potential victims.
You can also find additional information regarding human trafficking on the DHSS web site.
Now that b have an understanding of what human trafficking is and who the victims are, we will now discuss some particular strategies for identifying and working with victims.
As a social service provider, it’s important to understand the mindset of trafficking victims.
They fear and don’t trust service providers, the government or the police. Often traffickers tell their victims that they are in the United States illegally and they will be arrested and deported if they try to get help. Trafficking victims often fear or distrust the police because they come from countries where law enforcement is corrupt.
Victims may feel that their current situation is their fault, thus they may feel guilty. They might also feel as though there is no way out of this situation.
Trafficking victims may develop loyalties and positive feelings toward their trafficker as way to cope with their situation – known as the Stockholm or Patty Hearst Syndrome. In these cases, they may even try to protect the trafficker from authorities.
Traffickers frequently move their victims to escape detection. As a result, trafficking victims may not even know what city or country they’re in.
Victims of trafficking also fear for the safety of their family members in their native country, who are often threatened by the traffickers.
People are vulnerable to traffickers for many reasons such as those listed on this slide. It is these vulnerabilities that make them a “target” for traffickers.
While physical restraint, violence, and sexual assault are often used to control, traffickers also use psychological coercion as a way of controlling victims in a more subtle manner.
Isolation: Victims kept from the public, not allowed to leave, do anything on their own.
Dependency: Traffickers make their victims dependent on them for all their needs.
Fear: Traffickers instill fear into their victims, fear for their lives, their families lives, that they will be arrested and deported.
Abuse: physical and sexual abuse as well as emotional.
Shame: Shame created for the situation that they are in, what they have done.
Culture: Women/girls have a lesser place in society, must obey men
Victims of human trafficking are vulnerable human beings who have been subjected to severe physical and emotional coercion. These trafficking victims are usually in desperate need of assistance. First and foremost these victims need to feel safe.
There is a component of the Human Trafficking Grant that ensures a linkage into the mental health systems.
There are benefits and services available to trafficking victims. These benefits and services include legal, healthcare, counseling, housing, food, medical, cash and employment assistance.
Legal assistance is available to victims to help them with their immigration status. It is important to link a possible victim up with an attorney as soon as possible. Once they have continued presence, they are eligible for assistance in the refugee program.
Please be careful when addressing a victim about the possible immigration relief which may be available to them. Due to issues of disclosure, it is better for an attorney to discuss with a victim the particulars of immigration relief measures. This helps emphasize the need to get an immigration lawyer as soon as possible.
Because of the TVPA law, victims of human trafficking are eligible to receive assistance upon certification without regard to their prior immigration status.
Some of the services that are available to them are listed on this slide.
Human Trafficking victims can be found throughout the community if we know what to look for. We need to bring this problem to the surface and begin identifying victims so we can help them recover.
This is a list of the things that a person can look for as possible indications of whether a person may be a victim of trafficking.
While victims may have different experiences, they share common threads, a life marked by:
Abuse
Betrayal of their basic human rights
Control by their trafficker
These indicators show that a person may be controlled by someone else and accordingly, the situation should be further investigated.
(Yes, the pictures are of a woman being smuggled across the Moldovan border in the dash board of a car).
Here are some suggestions for what to do if you need to contact the authorities.
First and foremost, if the person is in danger, CALL THE POLICE.
The Department of Justice Hotline can be used to leave tips or report suspected cases of human trafficking. They take calls concerning both domestic and international trafficking. Also, they have translators on staff.
Rick Rea of the St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department can be contacted if you need a law enforcement perspective. He can be reached at (314) 444-5739, if he is not there leave a message and he will be paged.
If you come across a possible victim and you think that person is in immediate danger or imminent harm, call 911 or your local police.
There are two ways to seek help for trafficking victims.
Through the Office of Victims of Crime grant funding, you can call the International Institute and make a referral or you can call the National Hotline.
You can contact law enforcement. Please see the previous What to Do slide for more information.
You can also get more information at the Department of Health and Human Services website. www.acf.hhs.gov/trafficking
There are a number of special considerations you should keep in mind when working with a potential or known trafficking victim:
Before questioning a potential trafficking victim, it’s vital to isolate the person from the person accompanying him or her. However, try to do this without raising the suspicions of the individual accompanying the potential victim, who may say they are a spouse, other family member or employer. That’s because this individual may actually be the trafficker. You may want to say that your organization policy is to meet with the individual alone.
It’s also important to enlist a trusted interpreter who also understands the individual’s cultural needs. Don’t rely on the individual accompanying the patient to interpret, since this individual could be the trafficker and will likely sanitize the patient’s responses.
If the potential victim is a child, it is important to call in a social services specialist skilled in interviewing children who are trafficking or abuse victims.
Gaining trust with the trafficking victim will be an important first step in providing much-needed assistance to this individual. This slide gives sample messages you may want to convey to trafficking victims to help gain this trust and demonstrate that you care for their well-being and safety.
Many victims are feeling shame as well as fear, which will most likely prevent them from opening up to you. Earning their trust is critical.
As we have shown in this presentation, the occurrence of human trafficking is staggering. The most disheartening fact is that many of the victims are hidden, despite that they probably come into contact with us in a variety of ways.
One of the best ways to help combat this problem is to get involved in the effort.
Involvement can be by joining the coalition, or organizing a presentation at your organization, or even by letting the coalition know that your agency is willing to provide services to potential victims.
You can also find additional information regarding human trafficking on the DHSS web site.
As we have shown in this presentation, the occurrence of human trafficking is staggering. The most disheartening fact is that many of the victims are hidden, despite that they probably come into contact with us in a variety of ways.
One of the best ways to help combat this problem is to get involved in the effort.
Involvement can be by joining the coalition, or organizing a presentation at your organization, or even by letting the coalition know that your agency is willing to provide services to potential victims.
You can also find additional information regarding human trafficking on the DHSS web site.
From Telling The Truth
Human trafficking: Thai workers were physically abused and forced to live in rat-infested housing after being recruited by a labour contractor, based in Los Angeles, to work on farms in Hawaii and Washington, according to a US lawsuit.
In a case echoing John Steinbeck's 1939 novel The Grapes of Wrath the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission said it was the largest human trafficking case to date pursued by the agency against the agriculture industry.
Global Horizons lured Thai workers to the US between 2003 and 2007 with promises of highly paid jobs and temporary visas. It charged recruitment fees of up to $25,000 (£15,000) which the workers often borrowed at home, putting their families in extreme debt, and then confiscated their passports and threatened to deport them if they complained about conditions, commission officials said.
The workers were paid very low wages, lived in dilapidated, rat-infested rooms – where many did not have beds – and were often threatened and physically abused in the fields. The EEOC is seeking back pay and up to $300,000 in damages for each worker. Lawyers said they could not estimate how much was owed in wages and expected the number of workers in the case would increase.
Global Horizons could not be reached for comment.