See the 2,456 pharmacies on the National E-Pharmacy Platform
Improving Quality of Care in Partnership with Governments and Communities_5.8.14
1. Community and Clinical Action:
Maternal and Newborn Health
Graciela Salvador-Davila, Senior Technical Advisor for Maternal and
Newborn Health| Global Health Practitioner Conference, May 2014
2. BACKGROUND | PPH
• PPH is the leading direct cause of maternal deaths worldwide.
– PPH accounts for nearly 1/4th of maternal mortalities
• Time is a major issue.
– A woman can die within 2 hours of onset of PPH if she does not
receive proper treatment
• Barriers to life-saving care are many.
– Slow recognition of danger, need for care
– Distance
– Lack of funds
– Lack of transport
– Weak referral systems
– Stock-outs
– Inadequate provider skills and attitudes
4. PERU
Piura, Lima and
Ayacucho
States
NIGERIA
Katsina, Kano, Lagos,
Nassarawa, Oyo, Yobe,
Ebonyi,
BANGLADESH
Kishoreganj
District
INDIA
Maharashtra,
Rajasthan, Bihar,
Tamil Nadu , (Orissa)
States
TANZANIA
Refugee camp and host
community settings in
Kigoma
PATHFINDER’S CCA-PPH+ MODEL- GLOBAL APPLICATION
5. THE COMMUNITY-FACILITY LINKAGE CONTINUUMCOMMUNITYAWARENESS
Widespread
community
knowledge of
risks of unskilled
birth
attendance, &
pregnancy and
delivery danger
signs
RECOGNITIONOFNEED
Family
members, friend
s, CHWs capable
of identifying
PPH
Community
systems
activated to
respond
TRANSPORT
Community-
level drivers
coordinate with
CHWs and/or
family to
transport
women from
community to
facility
CLINICLEVELCARE
Facility-level
providers
receive
woman, apply
Life Wrap, &
initiate referrals
for life-saving
care as
necessary
Community-wide
education, sensitization, CHW
and/or family training
Community-transport systems
established; contact information
made widely available; community
creates incentives for drivers
Provider/CHW sensitization to
ensure positive, productive working
relationships; facility-wide training
on Life Wrap; provider trainings
6. THE CCA-PPH+ CONCEPTPREVENTION
Majority of
PPH cases
stopped
before they
start
RECOGNITION
Capacity to
identify
PPH, so
transport is
timely URGENTCARE
Providers
have the
skills
necessary to
address PPH
LifeWrap&SHOCKRx
First aid
device
applied to
allow for
referral to
secondary
level
DEFINITIVERx
Transport
Appropriate
care
delivered
2% of women
with PPH go
into shock
25% of maternal
mortality is
caused by
hemorrhage
@ health system level
THE TREATMENT CONTINUUM
8. THE NON-PNUEMATIC ANTI-SHOCK GARMENT (LIFE WRAP)
Evidence-based
Simple technology
Low-cost
= Object of desire
(and forget about the rest!)
9. 2011 external evaluation of Pathfinder CCA-PPH+ programs. Among
the findings:
“PPH in the facilities is decreasing…”
“Promoting just the Life Wrap is not likely to have a large
impact on mortality because the Life Wrap is used in only the
most extreme cases (only 2% of PPH cases lead to shock)…
preventing PPH in the first place (as opposed to treating it when
it gets out of hand) helps many, many more women.”
“…packaging of the full range of interventions to address PPH
was unique and we believe was what made the difference…”
“The Life Wrap provided an entrée into the medical systems of
both India and Nigeria; it served as the ‘admission ticket’ for
the introduction of the continuum of care model.”
“the most effective way to address PPH is not through the Life
Wrap but by strengthening the quality and availability of basic
obstetrical care, including AMSTL…”
THINKING ABOUT THE LIFE WRAP & CONTINUUM OF
CARE MACARTHUR EVALUATION FINDINGS
10. “All the model does is systematically highlight the various
steps that need to be followed to provide very basic
obstetrical care. But it is precisely because the required
interventions are so basic, so old and ‘ho-hum’ that the
introduction of the Life Wrap was so important.”
“Whether the same level of entrée could have been
achieved by Pathfinder without the allure of the Life Wrap
can be disputed. But what is undeniable is the role the Life
Wrap played in introducing the continuum of care model–
a model that definitely strengthened the government
health systems in both countries.”
THINKING ABOUT THE LIFE WRAP & CONTINUUM OF
CARE EVALUATION FINDINGS
12. “This is the next frontier …helping to advance a ‘science of delivery.’
Because we know that delivery isn’t easy – it’s not as simple as just
saying ‘this works, this doesn’t.’ Effective delivery demands context-
specific knowledge. It requires constant adjustments, a willingness to
take smart risks, and a relentless focus on the details of
implementation.”
-Jim Yong Kim, World Bank President
2012 Annual Plenary Session
13. IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE FOR MATERNAL HEALTH
• The world is seeing progress in stemming maternal deaths
– nearly a 50% decline in MMR between 1990 and 2010.
• Looking forward to post-2015, there is still work to be done.
• Majority of maternal death causes are preventable.
• From a clinical practice perspective, we know what works.
So what do we need to know to replicate “what works” & take it to
scale?
15. PREVENTION
Majority of
PPH cases
stopped
before they
start
RECOGNITION
Community
members
can identify
severe PPH LifeWrap&
SHOCKRx
First aid
device
applied at
community-
level prior to
initiation of
transport
URGENTCARE
Providers
have the
skills
necessary to
address PPH
for
stabilization
DEFINITIVERx
Life-saving
care
delivered
(surgery,
blood
transfusion,
medication)
STRETCHING THE CCA-PPH+ TREATMENT CONTINUUM TO COMMUNITY LEVEL
• 25% of maternal mortality is caused by hemorrhage.
• 2/3rds of women with PPH have no identifiable risk factors.
• More than 50% of women in resource-limited settings have no skilled birth attendance and deliver at
community-level.
Community-level
distribution of
misoprostol to
prevent PPH
(Potential to reduce PPH
incidence by up to 50%,
and severe PPH by 80%)
@ community level @ health system level
16. LOGICAL ORDER OF IMPLEMENTATION
The order of implementation is generally:
1. Advocacy: Work with the government and professional organizations, so
all understand and support the initiative. Also donors, other linkage with
other potential partners.
2. Prepare all levels of facilities, but start with the tertiary/referral level to
make sure it is EOC referral ready, including AMTSL and the use of the
Life Wrap, then moving to secondary, and primary levels once the
referral hospitals are ready.
3. Once each facility level is ready, work with government supported front
line workers and CBO’s to engage the communities in raising awareness
of danger signs, and how to avoid the first 3 delays at community level
including an established transport system.
17. THE CCA-PPH MODEL: A SUMMARY
• The CCA-PPH Model is comprehensive, practical, and adaptable
• The elements of the model taken together can have a significant impact
on maternal mortality
• Elements implemented individually have less impact
• The model can be adapted for other causes of maternal mortality such as
pre-eclampsia and eclampsia, sepsis, and prolonged labor
• The Project CD contains the PPH curriculum, the training video and a
toolkit with job aids, a community survey tool and data collection
instruments
18. ADDING PE/ECLAMPSIA TO THE CCA-PPH MODEL
• Pre-eclampsia/eclampsia (PE/E) can be easily rolled into the CAA/PPH
Continuum of Care, utilizing the organized facility levels and community
engagement systems already in place for PPH.
• This can be done after the PPH components are in place, or developed at
the same time as the PPH components.
• Similarly, all the major causes of maternal mortality can be addressed with
these same facility-community systems (sepsis, obstructed/prolonged
labor, unsafe abortion)
19. Program Monitoring and Evaluation Plan
EffectivenessIndicators
Performance Monitoring System
FundsStaffing
Inputs
• Community sensitization and
engagement
• Frontline workers trained in
IEC and referral
• Community organizations
equipped with emergency
transportation
• IEC materials distributed
• Effective referral systems
developed
• Job aids/protocols
developed/adapted
• Health providers trained
• Supervision provided for
sustained and improved
quality of care
• Life Wraps provided to
facilities
• Advocacy meetings with
gov’t officials and other key
stakeholders
Activities Objectives
Performance(output)Indicators
OutcomeIndicators
GoalEffects
1. Increase awareness of
community members of
the danger signs of PPH
and knowledge of
technologies
2. Improve the capacity of
community members to
make the decision to seek
medical care for PPH
3. Increase the ability of
community members to
identify and reach
medical care for obstetric
emergencies and
complications including
PPH
4. Improve the capacity of
health care providers to
provide high-quality
appropriate care
ImpactIndicators
Fig. 1. Program Framework: CCA-PPH Model
Decrease rates
of PPH and
shock
Decrease
maternal
mortality
related to PPH
• Increased access to
and use of emergency
transportation
• Increased referrals
from communities to
lower level facilities to
higher level facilities
• Job aids/protocols
approved and in place
• Increased access to
equipment and
commodities
• Increased practice of
AMTSL by providers
• Increased use of
standard tools for
estimating blood loss
• Appropriate and timely
management of PPH
• Increased use of Life
Wrap for management
of shock
background on model, emphasizing value-add as a holistic approach that accounts for community system, and health & governance systems– all of which are necessary to successful implementation of the modelCommunity:Clinical:PREVENTION:give background on AMSTL, set up that much of this model is compiling known effective interventions and building capacity to implement them in an accurate and timely fashion)AMSTL: Administration of uterotonic drug, Controlled cord tractions with simultaneous countertraction of the uterusFundal massage after delivery of the placentaReduces PPH incidence by up to 60% when HRH are trained, injection safety is assured, and uterotonics, cold chain, etc are in placeIDENTIFY:MANAGE:Government:
Donor support from:MacArthur Foundation (past)NigeriaIndiaTanzaniaMerck 4 Mothers (current)NigeriaIndiaPeruElma & Vodafone (current)Tanzania
Significantly reduces blood loss, time to recovery from shock, and– for those with PPH due to uterine atony who received oxytocin, the Life Wrap had significant effect on blood loss independent of oxytocin.Individuals with brief training can safely apply this first-aid deviceThe garment costs $60 USD and can be worn up to 50 times (with proper care). --$60 for up to 50 lives saved
So often in our industry, we latch on to technologies, innovations, new vaccines as the holy grail for what ails us. The story with the Life Wrap & our CCA-PPH+ model only highlights this. Despite all our own arguments to the contrary and even MacArthur’s evaluation findings, our current projects still face challenges in ensuring total fidelity to the entirety of the model when negotiating with in-country Ministries of Health. This is telling. What is it about our industry that brings so many of us to want the silver bullet– even when we know from our own experience that silver bullets don’t really exist? It’s because these softer touch areas– the dynamics of human interaction, of dynamic systems, of the constellation of political, social, and infrastructural realities– are nebulous, hard-to-pin-down, and harder still to find user manuals for. But that is precisely the kind of information we need– the “user manual” to navigate the realities of global health implementation. To understand how to take an evidence-based intervention or model and yield the same value from it when applied in our own settings or contexts.At Pathfinder, we’re increasingly interested in these soft-touch questions. The “how” questions that we believe we and our sister organizations must get better at discussing, better at answering, better at sharing.
What does it take to implement a successful technical strategy?How can we get better at asking the right questions, and getting the right answers?
Some call this implementation science, but it has many names right now. World Bank is seeing the “science of delivery” as their next frontier. What does it take to deliver, to implement the interventions we know to be effective? What does effective delivery look like?Emphasis: context-specific knowledge, constant adjustments, focus on the details of implementationWhat does it take for an implementer to understand the “how” questions that are critical for implementation?
Re: reduction of PPH by miso stat– from WHO. PROPOSAL FOR THE INCLUSION OF MISOPROSTOL IN THE WHO MODEL LIST OF ESSENTIAL MEDICINES, 2009. Available at http://www.who.int/selection_medicines/committees/expert/17/application/Miso_Incl_1.pdf