SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 24
Baixar para ler offline
CULTURAL
RELATIVISM
Complied by Dr. Ocon
OBJECTIVES
Consider the Eskimos. They are a remote and
inaccessible people. Numbering only about 25,000, they
live in small, isolated settlements scattered mostly along
the northern fringes of North America and Greenland. Until
the beginning of this century, the outside world knew little
about them. Then explorers began to bring back strange
tales. Eskimo customs turned out to be very different from
our own. The men often had more than one wife, and
they would share their wives with guests, lending them for
the night as a sign of hospitality.
Moreover, within a community, a dominant male might demand -- and get
--regular sexual access to other men's wives. The women, however, were free
to break these arrangements simply by leaving their husbands and taking up
with new partners--free, that is, so long as their former husbands chose not to
make trouble. All in all, the Eskimo practice was a volatile scheme that bore
little resemblance to what we call marriage.
Retrieved from
http://www.blogbeginsatforty.com/wp-
content/uploads/2018/07/inuit-coloring-pages-
inuit-coloring-pages-an-with-husky-in-the-north-
page-esk-on-eskimo-chiefs-coloring-pages.jpg
4
But it was not only their marriage and sexual practices
that were different. The Eskimos also seemed to have
less regard for human life. Infanticide, for example, was
common. . . . Female babies, he found, were especially
liable to be destroyed, and this was permitted simply at
the parents' discretion, with no social stigma attached to
it. Old people also, when they became too feeble to
contribute to the family, were left out in the snow to
die. So there seemed to be, in this society, remarkably
little respect for life. (James Rachels, The Elements of Moral
Philosophy (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1986)u
Cultural Relativism
What is cultural relativism?
Is the view that all beliefs, customs, and ethics are
relative to the individual within his own social context.
“Different cultures have different moral codes” often is used as a
key to understanding morality. Proponents argue that there is not as
universal truth in ethics; there are only the various cultural codes
and nothing more. The customs of different societies is all that exist
In other words, “right” and
“wrong” are culture-specific
Tightening the Definition–
The focus here is on whether or not one culture can judge another; the
focus is not on whether or not one individual can judge another.
6
Cultural Relativism
Challenges our ordinary belief in the objectivity and
universality of moral truths--
It says in effect that there is no such thing as a
universal truth or ethical standard that can be
applied.
Refutes ethnocentrism-- Your own code of ethics
offers nothing special and is no better than that of
another culture.
Sounds appealing…
7
Some Conflicting Approaches
 Moral Realism (aka Moral Objectivism): There are objective moral facts.
Therefore, ethics is somewhat like science: Its task is to discover (not decide)
what these moral facts are.
 Ethical Absolutists: There is a single standard ethical standard; that standard
is usually their own.
 Ethical (cultural or moral) Relativists: Each culture as an island unto itself,
right in its own world, and they deny any overarching standard with which
conflicting cultures (not individuals) can be judged.
 Ethical Pluralists: Cultures can legitimately pass judgments on one another,
but encourages us to listen to what other cultures say about us as well as what
we say about them.
8
What happens when something that is legally
and morally permissible in one culture is illegal
and immoral in another?
 Female circumcision or genital mutilation
 Marriage of underage girls
 Infanticide
 Polygamy
 Slavery
Retrieved from https://encrypted-
tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSjFE3WXaddJGhMVsaJP_aHFk3VUqKu
b2Feh4s8u0a5vlmC48zh
Retrieved from
https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/sites/ito/files/polygamy.jpg
Conflicting Approaches
 Moral Realist– Try to examine the situation and context
to discover the moral “facts.”
 Ethical relativist—Each culture is right unto itself, so
such practices would be morally permissible in some
countries and morally wrong in the US.
 Ethical absolutists—There is a single moral truth in terms
of which all cultures and individuals are to be judged.
 Pluralists—Try to find some middle ground (in some
situations this practice may make sense, less
judgmental)
10
 Treatment of the dead
 Polygamy
 Sharing of wives among Eskimos
 Infanticide
Different Moral Codes
Reminder-- Different cultures have
different moral codes. What is right
within one group maybe abhorrent to
another.
 Label them as backward, uneducated, or primitive.
 Label them heathens…
 Discriminate or harass them.
 Convert them to “our” custom or thought.
What is our reaction to “strange or different”
customs?
correlates with imperialist approaches…
12
“’The right way’ is the way which the ancestors used and which has
been handed down. The tradition is its own warrant. It is not held
subject to verification by experience. The notion of right is in the
folkways.” - William Graham Sumner
“If we assume that our ethical ideas will
be shared by all people at all times,
we are merely naïve.”
Consider ethical ideas in our society
may have changed over the years…
Claims of Cultural Relativists
1. Different societies have different moral codes.
2. The moral code of a society determines what is
right within that society.
3. There is no objective standard that can be used to
judge one societies code as better than another.
4. The moral code of our society offers nothing
special.
5. There is no universal truth in ethics…
6. It is arrogant to judge the conduct of other
societies; we should adopt an attitude of tolerance
toward the practices of other cultures.
14
The Cultural Differences Argument
Right and wrong are only matters of opinion, and opinions vary from culture
to culture. This is cultural differences argument--They argue from facts
about differences between cultural outlooks to making conclusions about
the status of morality How is this a logical fallacy? In other words, how is it
logically unsound?
Different cultures have different moral codes.
Therefore, there are no objective truth in morality.
The trouble is that the conclusion does not follow from the premise—that is
even if the premise is true, the conclusion might be false. – logical fallacy is
called non sequitur. WHY? The premise concerns what people believe; some
believe one way and others believe another, but the conclusion concerns
what really is the case. Just because two cultures believe differently
does inherently mean that one belief cannot be true.
15
Does it follow, from the mere fact
that they disagreed, that there is
no objective truth in the matter?
No, it does not follow—it could be
objectively right or wrong that one or the other was simply mistaken.
The Greeks believed it was
wrong to eat the dead. The
Callatians believed it was right.
It attempts to derive a substantive conclusion about a subject from
the mere fact that people disagree about it.
Caution: This is a simple point of logic. This does not necessarily mean that
the conclusion is false, the logic is that the conclusion does not follow from
the premise.
16
The Consequences of Accepting Cultural Relativism
1. We could no longer say that custom of other societies are morally inferior to
others. (This is one of the main points of Cultural Relativism.)
+ We would have to stop condemning other societies merely because they are different.
- Tolerance towards slavery, anti Semitism, hatred towards ethnic groups, or minorities,
child porn, sex slave trade
• If we took the cultural relativism seriously, we would have to regard these behaviors as
immune from criticism as long as they are considered morally acceptable within the
practicing culture.
2) We could decide whether actions are right or wrong just by consulting the
standards of our society.
In Colonial America slavery was OK, women were not allowed to vote or own property,
primogeniture was practiced, etc.; therefore, these things were right.
+ Deciding what is right or wrong in a situation is easier
- This position requires that we accept moral codes as proper and can not be improved.
•
3. The idea of moral progress is called into doubt
• Progress implies doing things better, but cultural relativism
rejects making judgments about past eras.
• Reform movements such as rights to women and minorities that
implies modern society is better is a judgment that is impossible
to make.
3. The idea of moral progress is called into doubt
• Progress implies doing things better, but cultural relativism
rejects making judgments about past eras.
• Reform movements such as rights to women and minorities that
implies modern society is better is a judgment that is impossible
to make.
18
Problems with Cultural Relativism
1. No blame of other cultures for “wrong” or “evil” deeds.
Are cultures morally infallible?
2. No criticism of our own culture
3. No idea of moral progress
4. In a relativist society the view of the majority
rules. Is this fair?
5. Is tolerance a universal value, in which case
relativism is paradoxical?
7. Don’t we all instinctively believe that some things are
universally right and wrong?
1. Many reject the cultural relativism arguments -- .
It makes sense to condemn some practices
wherever they occur.
2. It makes sense to acknowledge that our society
while imperfect has made moral progress.
3. Because Cultural Relativism implies these
judgments make no sense, the argument goes, it
cannot be right.
The Result?
20
There is less disagreement than it seems
There are differences across societies but the differences are often over-stated.
Need to explore not particular practices or values but the belief systems
that lie behind the practices.
The differences are often in the belief system.
Beliefs—religious beliefs
Physical circumstances of the society
Just because customs differ, there may be
less disagreement on basic values
Example: Eskimos infanticide
“drastic measures are sometimes needed to ensure the family’s survival” The Eskimos values are not
all that different than our own. It is only that life forces upon them choices that we do not have to make”
Universal Values in Societies
 Value of protecting the young
 Truth telling
 Prohibition of murder
There are some moral rules that all societies must have in common,
because those rules are necessary for society to exist.”
What other universal values or moral rules can you think of?
 Prohibition against incest
 Personal responsibility
 The proper role of government is to take care of its citizens
 Everyone should serve their country
 Everyone should obey the law
Lessons From Cultural Relativism
While it rests on invalid argument, it is still an appealing theory…
It warns us about the dangers
of assuming that our
preferences are based upon
some absolute rational
standard. They are not. Many of
our practices are merely
particular to our society and it
is easy to forget this.
Keep an open mind—
Maybe our feelings about
practices, values and beliefs
are merely social conventions.
There are many matters that we tend to
think of in terms of objective right or
wrong, that are really nothing more than
social conventions.
Maybe our feelings are not necessarily
perceptions of the truth…they may be
nothing more than cultural conditioning.
23
Thank you.
24
https://www.csus.edu/indiv/g/gaskilld/ethics/emp%20chapter2.htm
Sources:
Cultural Relatvism. (2014, November 14). Retrieved from
https://www.slideshare.net/miatheresa/cultural-relatvism-41561132
Retrieved from https://www.ebscohost.com/uploads/imported/thisTopic-
dbTopic-1247.pdf
Cultural relativism. (2014, August 28). Retrieved from
https://www.slideshare.net/beansomoray/cultural-relativism-38449104
Retrieved from
https://freerangeresearch.files.wordpress.com/201
2/10/cultural-awareness-learning-module-one.pdf

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Symbollic interactionism in Sociology
Symbollic interactionism in SociologySymbollic interactionism in Sociology
Symbollic interactionism in SociologyMahadmuhib
 
Moral Relativism
Moral RelativismMoral Relativism
Moral Relativismrvigliotti
 
Ethnocentrism & Cultural Relativism
Ethnocentrism & Cultural RelativismEthnocentrism & Cultural Relativism
Ethnocentrism & Cultural RelativismUnnati Garg
 
Cultural relativism
Cultural relativismCultural relativism
Cultural relativismggrey
 
Cultural Relatvism
Cultural RelatvismCultural Relatvism
Cultural RelatvismMia Eaker
 
Cultural relativism and ethnocentrism
Cultural relativism and ethnocentrismCultural relativism and ethnocentrism
Cultural relativism and ethnocentrismJonel Garcia
 
Chapter 6
Chapter 6Chapter 6
Chapter 6MEEvans
 
Chapter 1 The Sociological Perspective
Chapter 1  The  Sociological  PerspectiveChapter 1  The  Sociological  Perspective
Chapter 1 The Sociological Perspectiveplisasm
 
Positive and Negative Effects of Religion
Positive and Negative Effects of ReligionPositive and Negative Effects of Religion
Positive and Negative Effects of ReligionNorlyn Traje
 
Symbolic interactionism
Symbolic interactionism Symbolic interactionism
Symbolic interactionism Leslie Méndez
 
Topic 4 structural functionalism
Topic 4   structural functionalismTopic 4   structural functionalism
Topic 4 structural functionalismDANILO MARIBAO
 
Introduction to Kinship
Introduction to KinshipIntroduction to Kinship
Introduction to KinshipPaulVMcDowell
 

Mais procurados (20)

Symbollic interactionism in Sociology
Symbollic interactionism in SociologySymbollic interactionism in Sociology
Symbollic interactionism in Sociology
 
Social Identity Theory
Social Identity TheorySocial Identity Theory
Social Identity Theory
 
Moral Relativism
Moral RelativismMoral Relativism
Moral Relativism
 
Ethnocentrism & Cultural Relativism
Ethnocentrism & Cultural RelativismEthnocentrism & Cultural Relativism
Ethnocentrism & Cultural Relativism
 
Deviant behavior
Deviant behaviorDeviant behavior
Deviant behavior
 
The human-person-in-the-society
The human-person-in-the-societyThe human-person-in-the-society
The human-person-in-the-society
 
Cultural relativism
Cultural relativismCultural relativism
Cultural relativism
 
Cultural Relatvism
Cultural RelatvismCultural Relatvism
Cultural Relatvism
 
Cultural relativism and ethnocentrism
Cultural relativism and ethnocentrismCultural relativism and ethnocentrism
Cultural relativism and ethnocentrism
 
Chapter 6
Chapter 6Chapter 6
Chapter 6
 
Social Inequality
Social  InequalitySocial  Inequality
Social Inequality
 
Kinship
KinshipKinship
Kinship
 
Chapter 1 The Sociological Perspective
Chapter 1  The  Sociological  PerspectiveChapter 1  The  Sociological  Perspective
Chapter 1 The Sociological Perspective
 
Positive and Negative Effects of Religion
Positive and Negative Effects of ReligionPositive and Negative Effects of Religion
Positive and Negative Effects of Religion
 
Symbolic interactionism
Symbolic interactionism Symbolic interactionism
Symbolic interactionism
 
Topic 4 structural functionalism
Topic 4   structural functionalismTopic 4   structural functionalism
Topic 4 structural functionalism
 
Rational choice
Rational choiceRational choice
Rational choice
 
Introduction to Kinship
Introduction to KinshipIntroduction to Kinship
Introduction to Kinship
 
Ucsp.module1.lesson1
Ucsp.module1.lesson1Ucsp.module1.lesson1
Ucsp.module1.lesson1
 
Deviance
DevianceDeviance
Deviance
 

Semelhante a Week 9 Cultural Relativism.pptx

culturalrelatvism-141114084513-conversion-gate02.pdf
culturalrelatvism-141114084513-conversion-gate02.pdfculturalrelatvism-141114084513-conversion-gate02.pdf
culturalrelatvism-141114084513-conversion-gate02.pdfsadafshahbaz7777
 
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And AbsolutismDifference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And AbsolutismKarrie Garcia
 
Cultural Relativism In The Euthyphro
Cultural Relativism In The EuthyphroCultural Relativism In The Euthyphro
Cultural Relativism In The EuthyphroLynn Holkesvik
 
Phil21 wk4 relativism
Phil21 wk4 relativism Phil21 wk4 relativism
Phil21 wk4 relativism twiggypiggy
 
Cons Of Cultural Relativism
Cons Of Cultural RelativismCons Of Cultural Relativism
Cons Of Cultural RelativismMichelle Wilson
 
427382563-CULTURAL-RELATIVISM-pptx (1).pdf
427382563-CULTURAL-RELATIVISM-pptx (1).pdf427382563-CULTURAL-RELATIVISM-pptx (1).pdf
427382563-CULTURAL-RELATIVISM-pptx (1).pdfsadafshahbaz7777
 
Culturalrelativism
CulturalrelativismCulturalrelativism
Culturalrelativismgee bay
 
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command TheoryCultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command TheoryJennifer Campbell
 
Cultural Relativism And The Moral Code Of Society Essay
Cultural Relativism And The Moral Code Of Society EssayCultural Relativism And The Moral Code Of Society Essay
Cultural Relativism And The Moral Code Of Society EssayKara Webber
 
Negative Aspects Of Cultural Relativism
Negative Aspects Of Cultural RelativismNegative Aspects Of Cultural Relativism
Negative Aspects Of Cultural RelativismLiz Harris
 
What Does Moral Relativism Means
What Does Moral Relativism MeansWhat Does Moral Relativism Means
What Does Moral Relativism MeansMandy Cross
 
Moral Relativism In The Dark Knight
Moral Relativism In The Dark KnightMoral Relativism In The Dark Knight
Moral Relativism In The Dark KnightWhitney Turner
 

Semelhante a Week 9 Cultural Relativism.pptx (20)

culturalrelatvism-141114084513-conversion-gate02.pdf
culturalrelatvism-141114084513-conversion-gate02.pdfculturalrelatvism-141114084513-conversion-gate02.pdf
culturalrelatvism-141114084513-conversion-gate02.pdf
 
Cultural Relativism And Racial Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism And Racial Relativism EssayCultural Relativism And Racial Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism And Racial Relativism Essay
 
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And AbsolutismDifference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
Difference Between Cultural Relativism And Absolutism
 
Cultural Relativism In The Euthyphro
Cultural Relativism In The EuthyphroCultural Relativism In The Euthyphro
Cultural Relativism In The Euthyphro
 
Phil21 wk4 relativism
Phil21 wk4 relativism Phil21 wk4 relativism
Phil21 wk4 relativism
 
Cons Of Cultural Relativism
Cons Of Cultural RelativismCons Of Cultural Relativism
Cons Of Cultural Relativism
 
Cultural Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism EssayCultural Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism Essay
 
427382563-CULTURAL-RELATIVISM-pptx (1).pdf
427382563-CULTURAL-RELATIVISM-pptx (1).pdf427382563-CULTURAL-RELATIVISM-pptx (1).pdf
427382563-CULTURAL-RELATIVISM-pptx (1).pdf
 
Culturalrelativism
CulturalrelativismCulturalrelativism
Culturalrelativism
 
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command TheoryCultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
Cultural Relativism Vs Divine Command Theory
 
Cultural Relativism
Cultural RelativismCultural Relativism
Cultural Relativism
 
Meta-Ethical Cultural Relativism Essay
Meta-Ethical Cultural Relativism EssayMeta-Ethical Cultural Relativism Essay
Meta-Ethical Cultural Relativism Essay
 
Cultural Relativism And The Moral Code Of Society Essay
Cultural Relativism And The Moral Code Of Society EssayCultural Relativism And The Moral Code Of Society Essay
Cultural Relativism And The Moral Code Of Society Essay
 
Ethical Relativism And Moral Relativism
Ethical Relativism And Moral RelativismEthical Relativism And Moral Relativism
Ethical Relativism And Moral Relativism
 
Cultural Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism EssayCultural Relativism Essay
Cultural Relativism Essay
 
Negative Aspects Of Cultural Relativism
Negative Aspects Of Cultural RelativismNegative Aspects Of Cultural Relativism
Negative Aspects Of Cultural Relativism
 
Moral Relativism Defended Summary
Moral Relativism Defended SummaryMoral Relativism Defended Summary
Moral Relativism Defended Summary
 
What Does Moral Relativism Means
What Does Moral Relativism MeansWhat Does Moral Relativism Means
What Does Moral Relativism Means
 
Moral Relativism In The Dark Knight
Moral Relativism In The Dark KnightMoral Relativism In The Dark Knight
Moral Relativism In The Dark Knight
 
Cultural relativism
Cultural relativismCultural relativism
Cultural relativism
 

Mais de ArvinCruz19

The Colonial Philippines - Spanish Occupation History.pptx
The Colonial Philippines - Spanish Occupation History.pptxThe Colonial Philippines - Spanish Occupation History.pptx
The Colonial Philippines - Spanish Occupation History.pptxArvinCruz19
 
ethnic history SYLLABUS.docx
ethnic history SYLLABUS.docxethnic history SYLLABUS.docx
ethnic history SYLLABUS.docxArvinCruz19
 
LDM-2-Course-Reflection.pptx
LDM-2-Course-Reflection.pptxLDM-2-Course-Reflection.pptx
LDM-2-Course-Reflection.pptxArvinCruz19
 
Week 8 Ethics and Culture.pdf
Week 8 Ethics and Culture.pdfWeek 8 Ethics and Culture.pdf
Week 8 Ethics and Culture.pdfArvinCruz19
 
Week 1 Ethics Defined.pdf
Week 1 Ethics Defined.pdfWeek 1 Ethics Defined.pdf
Week 1 Ethics Defined.pdfArvinCruz19
 
Week 2 Dilemmas.pdf
Week 2 Dilemmas.pdfWeek 2 Dilemmas.pdf
Week 2 Dilemmas.pdfArvinCruz19
 
Man and Historical Action.pdf
Man and Historical Action.pdfMan and Historical Action.pdf
Man and Historical Action.pdfArvinCruz19
 

Mais de ArvinCruz19 (8)

The Colonial Philippines - Spanish Occupation History.pptx
The Colonial Philippines - Spanish Occupation History.pptxThe Colonial Philippines - Spanish Occupation History.pptx
The Colonial Philippines - Spanish Occupation History.pptx
 
ethnic history SYLLABUS.docx
ethnic history SYLLABUS.docxethnic history SYLLABUS.docx
ethnic history SYLLABUS.docx
 
LDM-2-Course-Reflection.pptx
LDM-2-Course-Reflection.pptxLDM-2-Course-Reflection.pptx
LDM-2-Course-Reflection.pptx
 
Week 8 Ethics and Culture.pdf
Week 8 Ethics and Culture.pdfWeek 8 Ethics and Culture.pdf
Week 8 Ethics and Culture.pdf
 
Week 1 Ethics Defined.pdf
Week 1 Ethics Defined.pdfWeek 1 Ethics Defined.pdf
Week 1 Ethics Defined.pdf
 
Week 2 Dilemmas.pdf
Week 2 Dilemmas.pdfWeek 2 Dilemmas.pdf
Week 2 Dilemmas.pdf
 
Dilemmas.pdf
Dilemmas.pdfDilemmas.pdf
Dilemmas.pdf
 
Man and Historical Action.pdf
Man and Historical Action.pdfMan and Historical Action.pdf
Man and Historical Action.pdf
 

Último

Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 JournalResearch paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 JournalDr. Manjunatha. P
 
The Journey of Process Safety Management: Past, Present, and Future Trends
The Journey of Process Safety Management: Past, Present, and Future TrendsThe Journey of Process Safety Management: Past, Present, and Future Trends
The Journey of Process Safety Management: Past, Present, and Future Trendssoginsider
 
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)GDSCNiT
 
Conventional vs Modern method (Philosophies) of Tunneling-re.pptx
Conventional vs Modern method (Philosophies) of Tunneling-re.pptxConventional vs Modern method (Philosophies) of Tunneling-re.pptx
Conventional vs Modern method (Philosophies) of Tunneling-re.pptxSAQIB KHURSHEED WANI
 
Governors ppt.pdf .
Governors ppt.pdf                              .Governors ppt.pdf                              .
Governors ppt.pdf .happycocoman
 
Introduction to Data Structures .
Introduction to Data Structures        .Introduction to Data Structures        .
Introduction to Data Structures .Ashutosh Satapathy
 
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptxssuser886c55
 
electricity generation from food waste - based bioenergy with IOT.pptx
electricity generation from food waste - based bioenergy with IOT.pptxelectricity generation from food waste - based bioenergy with IOT.pptx
electricity generation from food waste - based bioenergy with IOT.pptxAravindhKarthik1
 
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structures
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structuresSupport nodes for large-span coal storage structures
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structureswendy cai
 
Navigating Process Safety through Automation and Digitalization in the Oil an...
Navigating Process Safety through Automation and Digitalization in the Oil an...Navigating Process Safety through Automation and Digitalization in the Oil an...
Navigating Process Safety through Automation and Digitalization in the Oil an...soginsider
 
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdfbotanical elements..
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdfbotanical elements..عناصر نباتية PDF.pdfbotanical elements..
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdfbotanical elements..mennamohamed200y
 
Evaluation Methods for Social XR Experiences
Evaluation Methods for Social XR ExperiencesEvaluation Methods for Social XR Experiences
Evaluation Methods for Social XR ExperiencesMark Billinghurst
 
Artificial organ courses Hussein L1-C2.pptx
Artificial organ courses Hussein  L1-C2.pptxArtificial organ courses Hussein  L1-C2.pptx
Artificial organ courses Hussein L1-C2.pptxHusseinMishbak
 
A brief about Jeypore Sub-station Presentation
A brief about Jeypore Sub-station PresentationA brief about Jeypore Sub-station Presentation
A brief about Jeypore Sub-station PresentationJeyporess2021
 
Final PPT.ppt about human detection and counting
Final PPT.ppt  about human detection and countingFinal PPT.ppt  about human detection and counting
Final PPT.ppt about human detection and countingArbazAhmad25
 
Caltrans District 8 Update for the CalAPA Spring Asphalt Conference 2024
Caltrans District 8 Update for the CalAPA Spring Asphalt Conference 2024Caltrans District 8 Update for the CalAPA Spring Asphalt Conference 2024
Caltrans District 8 Update for the CalAPA Spring Asphalt Conference 2024California Asphalt Pavement Association
 
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slideFirst Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slideMonika860882
 
Chapter 2 Canal Falls at Mnnit Allahabad .pptx
Chapter 2 Canal Falls at Mnnit Allahabad .pptxChapter 2 Canal Falls at Mnnit Allahabad .pptx
Chapter 2 Canal Falls at Mnnit Allahabad .pptxButcher771
 

Último (20)

Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 JournalResearch paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
 
Industry perspective on cold in-place recycling
Industry perspective on cold in-place recyclingIndustry perspective on cold in-place recycling
Industry perspective on cold in-place recycling
 
The Journey of Process Safety Management: Past, Present, and Future Trends
The Journey of Process Safety Management: Past, Present, and Future TrendsThe Journey of Process Safety Management: Past, Present, and Future Trends
The Journey of Process Safety Management: Past, Present, and Future Trends
 
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
 
Conventional vs Modern method (Philosophies) of Tunneling-re.pptx
Conventional vs Modern method (Philosophies) of Tunneling-re.pptxConventional vs Modern method (Philosophies) of Tunneling-re.pptx
Conventional vs Modern method (Philosophies) of Tunneling-re.pptx
 
Governors ppt.pdf .
Governors ppt.pdf                              .Governors ppt.pdf                              .
Governors ppt.pdf .
 
Introduction to Data Structures .
Introduction to Data Structures        .Introduction to Data Structures        .
Introduction to Data Structures .
 
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
 
electricity generation from food waste - based bioenergy with IOT.pptx
electricity generation from food waste - based bioenergy with IOT.pptxelectricity generation from food waste - based bioenergy with IOT.pptx
electricity generation from food waste - based bioenergy with IOT.pptx
 
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structures
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structuresSupport nodes for large-span coal storage structures
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structures
 
Navigating Process Safety through Automation and Digitalization in the Oil an...
Navigating Process Safety through Automation and Digitalization in the Oil an...Navigating Process Safety through Automation and Digitalization in the Oil an...
Navigating Process Safety through Automation and Digitalization in the Oil an...
 
FOREST FIRE USING IoT-A Visual to UG students
FOREST FIRE USING IoT-A Visual to UG studentsFOREST FIRE USING IoT-A Visual to UG students
FOREST FIRE USING IoT-A Visual to UG students
 
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdfbotanical elements..
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdfbotanical elements..عناصر نباتية PDF.pdfbotanical elements..
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdfbotanical elements..
 
Evaluation Methods for Social XR Experiences
Evaluation Methods for Social XR ExperiencesEvaluation Methods for Social XR Experiences
Evaluation Methods for Social XR Experiences
 
Artificial organ courses Hussein L1-C2.pptx
Artificial organ courses Hussein  L1-C2.pptxArtificial organ courses Hussein  L1-C2.pptx
Artificial organ courses Hussein L1-C2.pptx
 
A brief about Jeypore Sub-station Presentation
A brief about Jeypore Sub-station PresentationA brief about Jeypore Sub-station Presentation
A brief about Jeypore Sub-station Presentation
 
Final PPT.ppt about human detection and counting
Final PPT.ppt  about human detection and countingFinal PPT.ppt  about human detection and counting
Final PPT.ppt about human detection and counting
 
Caltrans District 8 Update for the CalAPA Spring Asphalt Conference 2024
Caltrans District 8 Update for the CalAPA Spring Asphalt Conference 2024Caltrans District 8 Update for the CalAPA Spring Asphalt Conference 2024
Caltrans District 8 Update for the CalAPA Spring Asphalt Conference 2024
 
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slideFirst Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
 
Chapter 2 Canal Falls at Mnnit Allahabad .pptx
Chapter 2 Canal Falls at Mnnit Allahabad .pptxChapter 2 Canal Falls at Mnnit Allahabad .pptx
Chapter 2 Canal Falls at Mnnit Allahabad .pptx
 

Week 9 Cultural Relativism.pptx

  • 3. Consider the Eskimos. They are a remote and inaccessible people. Numbering only about 25,000, they live in small, isolated settlements scattered mostly along the northern fringes of North America and Greenland. Until the beginning of this century, the outside world knew little about them. Then explorers began to bring back strange tales. Eskimo customs turned out to be very different from our own. The men often had more than one wife, and they would share their wives with guests, lending them for the night as a sign of hospitality. Moreover, within a community, a dominant male might demand -- and get --regular sexual access to other men's wives. The women, however, were free to break these arrangements simply by leaving their husbands and taking up with new partners--free, that is, so long as their former husbands chose not to make trouble. All in all, the Eskimo practice was a volatile scheme that bore little resemblance to what we call marriage. Retrieved from http://www.blogbeginsatforty.com/wp- content/uploads/2018/07/inuit-coloring-pages- inuit-coloring-pages-an-with-husky-in-the-north- page-esk-on-eskimo-chiefs-coloring-pages.jpg
  • 4. 4 But it was not only their marriage and sexual practices that were different. The Eskimos also seemed to have less regard for human life. Infanticide, for example, was common. . . . Female babies, he found, were especially liable to be destroyed, and this was permitted simply at the parents' discretion, with no social stigma attached to it. Old people also, when they became too feeble to contribute to the family, were left out in the snow to die. So there seemed to be, in this society, remarkably little respect for life. (James Rachels, The Elements of Moral Philosophy (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1986)u
  • 5. Cultural Relativism What is cultural relativism? Is the view that all beliefs, customs, and ethics are relative to the individual within his own social context. “Different cultures have different moral codes” often is used as a key to understanding morality. Proponents argue that there is not as universal truth in ethics; there are only the various cultural codes and nothing more. The customs of different societies is all that exist In other words, “right” and “wrong” are culture-specific Tightening the Definition– The focus here is on whether or not one culture can judge another; the focus is not on whether or not one individual can judge another.
  • 6. 6 Cultural Relativism Challenges our ordinary belief in the objectivity and universality of moral truths-- It says in effect that there is no such thing as a universal truth or ethical standard that can be applied. Refutes ethnocentrism-- Your own code of ethics offers nothing special and is no better than that of another culture. Sounds appealing…
  • 7. 7 Some Conflicting Approaches  Moral Realism (aka Moral Objectivism): There are objective moral facts. Therefore, ethics is somewhat like science: Its task is to discover (not decide) what these moral facts are.  Ethical Absolutists: There is a single standard ethical standard; that standard is usually their own.  Ethical (cultural or moral) Relativists: Each culture as an island unto itself, right in its own world, and they deny any overarching standard with which conflicting cultures (not individuals) can be judged.  Ethical Pluralists: Cultures can legitimately pass judgments on one another, but encourages us to listen to what other cultures say about us as well as what we say about them.
  • 8. 8 What happens when something that is legally and morally permissible in one culture is illegal and immoral in another?  Female circumcision or genital mutilation  Marriage of underage girls  Infanticide  Polygamy  Slavery Retrieved from https://encrypted- tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSjFE3WXaddJGhMVsaJP_aHFk3VUqKu b2Feh4s8u0a5vlmC48zh Retrieved from https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/sites/ito/files/polygamy.jpg
  • 9. Conflicting Approaches  Moral Realist– Try to examine the situation and context to discover the moral “facts.”  Ethical relativist—Each culture is right unto itself, so such practices would be morally permissible in some countries and morally wrong in the US.  Ethical absolutists—There is a single moral truth in terms of which all cultures and individuals are to be judged.  Pluralists—Try to find some middle ground (in some situations this practice may make sense, less judgmental)
  • 10. 10  Treatment of the dead  Polygamy  Sharing of wives among Eskimos  Infanticide Different Moral Codes Reminder-- Different cultures have different moral codes. What is right within one group maybe abhorrent to another.
  • 11.  Label them as backward, uneducated, or primitive.  Label them heathens…  Discriminate or harass them.  Convert them to “our” custom or thought. What is our reaction to “strange or different” customs? correlates with imperialist approaches…
  • 12. 12 “’The right way’ is the way which the ancestors used and which has been handed down. The tradition is its own warrant. It is not held subject to verification by experience. The notion of right is in the folkways.” - William Graham Sumner “If we assume that our ethical ideas will be shared by all people at all times, we are merely naïve.” Consider ethical ideas in our society may have changed over the years…
  • 13. Claims of Cultural Relativists 1. Different societies have different moral codes. 2. The moral code of a society determines what is right within that society. 3. There is no objective standard that can be used to judge one societies code as better than another. 4. The moral code of our society offers nothing special. 5. There is no universal truth in ethics… 6. It is arrogant to judge the conduct of other societies; we should adopt an attitude of tolerance toward the practices of other cultures.
  • 14. 14 The Cultural Differences Argument Right and wrong are only matters of opinion, and opinions vary from culture to culture. This is cultural differences argument--They argue from facts about differences between cultural outlooks to making conclusions about the status of morality How is this a logical fallacy? In other words, how is it logically unsound? Different cultures have different moral codes. Therefore, there are no objective truth in morality. The trouble is that the conclusion does not follow from the premise—that is even if the premise is true, the conclusion might be false. – logical fallacy is called non sequitur. WHY? The premise concerns what people believe; some believe one way and others believe another, but the conclusion concerns what really is the case. Just because two cultures believe differently does inherently mean that one belief cannot be true.
  • 15. 15 Does it follow, from the mere fact that they disagreed, that there is no objective truth in the matter? No, it does not follow—it could be objectively right or wrong that one or the other was simply mistaken. The Greeks believed it was wrong to eat the dead. The Callatians believed it was right. It attempts to derive a substantive conclusion about a subject from the mere fact that people disagree about it. Caution: This is a simple point of logic. This does not necessarily mean that the conclusion is false, the logic is that the conclusion does not follow from the premise.
  • 16. 16 The Consequences of Accepting Cultural Relativism 1. We could no longer say that custom of other societies are morally inferior to others. (This is one of the main points of Cultural Relativism.) + We would have to stop condemning other societies merely because they are different. - Tolerance towards slavery, anti Semitism, hatred towards ethnic groups, or minorities, child porn, sex slave trade • If we took the cultural relativism seriously, we would have to regard these behaviors as immune from criticism as long as they are considered morally acceptable within the practicing culture. 2) We could decide whether actions are right or wrong just by consulting the standards of our society. In Colonial America slavery was OK, women were not allowed to vote or own property, primogeniture was practiced, etc.; therefore, these things were right. + Deciding what is right or wrong in a situation is easier - This position requires that we accept moral codes as proper and can not be improved. •
  • 17. 3. The idea of moral progress is called into doubt • Progress implies doing things better, but cultural relativism rejects making judgments about past eras. • Reform movements such as rights to women and minorities that implies modern society is better is a judgment that is impossible to make. 3. The idea of moral progress is called into doubt • Progress implies doing things better, but cultural relativism rejects making judgments about past eras. • Reform movements such as rights to women and minorities that implies modern society is better is a judgment that is impossible to make.
  • 18. 18 Problems with Cultural Relativism 1. No blame of other cultures for “wrong” or “evil” deeds. Are cultures morally infallible? 2. No criticism of our own culture 3. No idea of moral progress 4. In a relativist society the view of the majority rules. Is this fair? 5. Is tolerance a universal value, in which case relativism is paradoxical? 7. Don’t we all instinctively believe that some things are universally right and wrong?
  • 19. 1. Many reject the cultural relativism arguments -- . It makes sense to condemn some practices wherever they occur. 2. It makes sense to acknowledge that our society while imperfect has made moral progress. 3. Because Cultural Relativism implies these judgments make no sense, the argument goes, it cannot be right. The Result?
  • 20. 20 There is less disagreement than it seems There are differences across societies but the differences are often over-stated. Need to explore not particular practices or values but the belief systems that lie behind the practices. The differences are often in the belief system. Beliefs—religious beliefs Physical circumstances of the society Just because customs differ, there may be less disagreement on basic values Example: Eskimos infanticide “drastic measures are sometimes needed to ensure the family’s survival” The Eskimos values are not all that different than our own. It is only that life forces upon them choices that we do not have to make”
  • 21. Universal Values in Societies  Value of protecting the young  Truth telling  Prohibition of murder There are some moral rules that all societies must have in common, because those rules are necessary for society to exist.” What other universal values or moral rules can you think of?  Prohibition against incest  Personal responsibility  The proper role of government is to take care of its citizens  Everyone should serve their country  Everyone should obey the law
  • 22. Lessons From Cultural Relativism While it rests on invalid argument, it is still an appealing theory… It warns us about the dangers of assuming that our preferences are based upon some absolute rational standard. They are not. Many of our practices are merely particular to our society and it is easy to forget this. Keep an open mind— Maybe our feelings about practices, values and beliefs are merely social conventions. There are many matters that we tend to think of in terms of objective right or wrong, that are really nothing more than social conventions. Maybe our feelings are not necessarily perceptions of the truth…they may be nothing more than cultural conditioning.
  • 24. 24 https://www.csus.edu/indiv/g/gaskilld/ethics/emp%20chapter2.htm Sources: Cultural Relatvism. (2014, November 14). Retrieved from https://www.slideshare.net/miatheresa/cultural-relatvism-41561132 Retrieved from https://www.ebscohost.com/uploads/imported/thisTopic- dbTopic-1247.pdf Cultural relativism. (2014, August 28). Retrieved from https://www.slideshare.net/beansomoray/cultural-relativism-38449104 Retrieved from https://freerangeresearch.files.wordpress.com/201 2/10/cultural-awareness-learning-module-one.pdf