Anúncio
Anúncio

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Anúncio

Team Medallion, Optimity'21, 2nd Round

  1. Team Medallion
  2. British American Tobacco Bangladesh Company Limited (BATBC) Founded in 1911, now the tobacco company with the highest market share of 66% Generates revenue from local cigarette sales, and exports of cigarettes and tobacco leaf Operates in all segments, but focuses more on the top 3 segments High paid-up capital despite only 3.05% of the company being owned by individuals S W O T • High market share • Reputed brand value • Strong corporate governance • Highly efficient productions • Export growth in both finished goods & leaf • Withdrawal of SD on export • Shutting down of ‘Marlboro’ • Negative perception towards the core product • Highly taxed industry • Weak presence in low segment • Anti-tobacco policies across the world & increasing tax • Growing popularity of non- combustible tobacco products
  3. Tobacco Market in Bangladesh BAT holds 66% of the market, JTI holds 21% and the rest is held by the rest of the companies The key 4 external stakeholders are consumers, partners, government, and suppliers The local market has hit a plateau in recent years, but there are endless opportunities in the export- based market There is higher level of competition in the lower segment, but BAT has a monopoly over the higher segments • Tobacco industry is the highest revenue driver of the country • 90% of company’s revenues go to taxes • The price is controlled by NBR through slabs. After every election, changes in fiscal policies change the price and tax levied on tobacco • Inflation has increased significantly in recent times, impacting the supply chain & raw materials • There is an elastic demand, especially towards the high segment of cigarettes • The pricing of cigarettes changes frequently due to changing tax policies • There is generally a negative perception towards tobacco products in the country, especially towards female consumers. • Despite illegal to smoke in public areas, it is socially acceptable to smoke in public gatherings • The company is increasing tech usage to increase efficiency in operations & management • The company has recently used AI to improve its distribution and marketing channels
  4. Tobacco Market in Bangladesh Market Drivers: • Export opportunities • Efficient supply chain • Increased pricing • Decreasing consumption of ‘Bidi’ Market Concerns: • Impact of Covid-19 • Ever-changing tax policies • Low consumer loyalty in low tiers • Increasing alternatives to cigarettes Very High High Moderate Low Very Low Threat of Substitutes Threat of New Entrants Bargaining Power of Suppliers Bargaining Power of Buyers Competitive Rivalry
  5. Considerations & Assumptions Regulations & Declining Markets Covid-19 & Plateau in Domestic Sales Capacity Expansion & Export Opportunities Elasticity of & Monopoly in High-Segments Production & Operational Efficiency Tax Structure & Implications
  6. Consideration 1: Regulations & Declining Markets Alternatives to Cigarettes Control by Government in Tobacco Industry The government will have considerable influence on price and regulations will get stricter Market growth rate in the domestic market will be in single digits and profits have to be driven by price Key Assumptions
  7. Consideration 2: Covid-19 & Plateau in Domestic Sales 26435 30040 35338 39098 43046 50027 53734 49326 50151 55637 0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Domestic Sales of Sticks (in mil) Impact of Covid-19 • Disrupted supply chains & increased inflation • Increased cost of raw materials import • Hindered sales growth rates • Increased operational expenses Other Factors to Consider • Increasing popularity of non-combustible tobacco products and other stimulators • High competition in the lower segments Disrupted supply chains will impact the COGS in the initial years The impact will reduce with increased efficiency and adjusted inflations after 2023 Domestic sales will stay low in the initial years and follow the moving average of the last 5 years Key Assumptions
  8. Consideration 3: Capacity Expansion & Export Opportunities Date of Announcement Investment Approval Amount Investment Objective 28.07.2021 3,202 mil BDT Cater upcoming export opportunities and create contingency capacity 17.02.2021 1,925 mil BDT Increase the manufacturing capacity in Savar Factory to enhance the upcoming export opportunities Price Sensitive Information Regarding Expansion Price, Cost & Duties Comparison between BD & AUS • Profit per stick in Australia is more than 20x that of Bangladesh • Cost of production is higher in Australia than retail price in Bangladesh Profitability in export sales will be higher due to low COGS & no added SD The company will retain its dividend payout of recent years due to high growth & sufficient capacity, will retake expansion after 7-8 years Capacity & Export sales will pick up from 2023-24 after completion of the new projects for expanded and contingency capacity Key Assumptions
  9. Consideration 4: Elasticity of & Monopoly in High-Segments Elasticity & Monopoly in High Segment • Philip Morris announced suspension of production and distribution of ‘Marlboro’ • B&H maintained volume growth after 17% price hike in 2019 • BAT introduced ‘Royals’ in the low segment recently • The market share of ‘Bidis’ have come down to 10% from 30% Market Segmentation & Volume Contribution The rising middle-class population will drive the increased sales of the high segment, this will in turn increase operational efficiency due to economies of scale Sales in the high segment will sustain the domestic gross turnover and future gross turnover will be driven by price Key Assumptions
  10. Consideration 5: Production & Operational Efficiency 58% 58% 56% 54% 53% 55% 52% 50% 53% 51% 46% 40% 31% 29% 29% 30% 28% 24% 30% 25% 10% 30% 50% 70% 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 COGS as a % of Net Turnover OpEx as a & of Gross Profit Decreasing COGS & Operational Costs COGS & OPEX will come down by 1% after three years Both a/c receivable and a/c payable situation will improve following the trend of recent years COGS & OPEX will remain stable in the initial years due to increased raw material costs Key Assumptions 0 10 20 30 40 50 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Receivable Turnover Ratio 0 2 4 6 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 A/C Payable Turnover Ratio
  11. Consideration 6: Tax Structure & Implications SD & Pricing Structure by NBR (2011-20) VAT* HDSC* Export Duty Corporate Tax Surcharge Minimum Turnover Tax 15% 1% 0% 45% 2.5% 1% Effective Tax Rate Pricing of products of all segments will change along with the SD structure. The effective tax rate will be uniform throughout the next 10 years. All segments will initially have a uniform SD of 65% and then follow a linear pattern after a significant growth in 2024 after election. Key Assumptions
  12. Financial Statements: Income Statement Particular Assumption & Driver Capacity • Will Plateau in Initial Years (0-2% Growth) • Will Increase Significantly after Project Completion (~15%) • Will Increase Gradually From that Point (4-6.5%) Volume • Domestic Sales Will Increase Gradually (up to 2.5%) • Export Sales Will Depend on Capacity & Grow Significantly (by 20x in 8 years) Pricing • Will Follow the Changes in SD Sales • Driven by Volume & Pricing Growth SD • Straight 65% on All Segments for 2 Years • Following Linear Regression after Election Year COGS & OPEX • Moving Average of Previous 5 Years (Decrease by .5% on average) • Lesser by 1% in Subsequent Years WPFF • 5% of PBT Effective Tax • 46.5% of PBT after WPFF
  13. Financial Statements: Balance Sheet Particular Assumption & Driver CAPEX & Depreciation • Sales revenue is the key driver • Both will be calculated as a % of sales to simplify the model • Capital asset turnover ratio is used for capital asset forecasting (PPE) A/C Receivable • A/C receivable will reduce gradually due to operational efficiency • The lowest collection period in the next 10 years will be equal to the lowest of the last 5 years Prepaid Expenses • Prepaid expenses will be driven by SD and payment to suppliers A/C Payable • The average growth rate of a/c payable days is an estimate for a/c payable Dividend Payout • Dividend payout is going to be at least 50% as the rate has averaged at around 50% in recent years • The company is at a good cash position and will not require additional retained earnings for capacity expansion
  14. Valuation: Dividend Discount Model 1.13 0.71 0.61 0.59 0.46 0.44 0.46 0.36 0.32 - 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00 1.20 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Dividend Payout Ratio Dividend per Share in 2021: 325% WACC: 8.91% Growth Rate: 4% 661.3 BDT Expected Value per Share Dividend Discount Model No. of shares 540,000,000 Growth rate 4.00% Dividend per Share in 2021 325% WACC 8.91% Expected Value per Share 661.34 CAPM Risk-free Rate 6.71% Market Return 10.00% Beta 0.67 WACC 8.91% Assumptions • The market is assumed to give 10% returns, higher from 8.82% (avg of the last 5 years) • Perpetual growth rate of dividends is assumed to be 4% due to waning tobacco market
  15. Valuation: Discounted Cash Flow Discounting Factor (WACC): 8.91% Perpetual Growth Rate: 4% Enterprise Value: 326,690 mil BDT 605.0 BDT Expected Value per Share
  16. Valuation: Relative Using Forward P/E Company Similarities to BATBC UNILEVERCL • Industry: Food & Allied • Nature: Multi-National Organization MARICO • Nature: Multi-National Organization • Other: Recently started exporting and expanding its capacity BERGERPBL • Nature: Multi-National Organization • Other: Recently started exporting OLYMPIC • Industry: Food & Allied • Other: Exports products GP • Nature: Multi-National Organization • Market Cap: 339,822 mil BDT • Tax Structure: 40% Corporate Tax Name of Company Annualized EPS Market Price Forward P/E Weightage UNILEVERCL 42.80 2,802.70 65.48 10% MARICO 125.46 2,298.00 18.32 15% BERGERPBL 51.32 1,781.00 34.70 15% OLYMPIC 8.24 173.00 21.00 30% GP 25.64 355.20 13.85 30% Average 24.96 Valuation of BATBC Annualized EPS of BATBC 31.92 Market Price of BATBC 654.80 Forward P/E of BATBC 20.51 Considerations: Industry, Nature of Organization, Exporting & Capacity Expansion, Market Cap, Tax Structure 796.6 BDT Expected Value per Share
  17. Ratio Analysis 34% Operating Profit Margin 46% Gross Profit Margin 16% Net Profit Margin 40.16% 33.88% 33.91% 25.83% 32.02% 26.73% 26.98% 29.93% 25.66% 26.29% 26.65% 29.13% 27.81% 28.79% 30.45% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Return on Equity 0.095 0.132 0.175 0 0 0.04 0 0 0 0 0.05 0 0 0.06 0 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Debt to Equity Ratio 2.121 1.729 1.469 1.667 1.527 1.301 1.373 1.462 1.363 1.392 1.434 1.552 1.484 1.528 1.575 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Inventory Turnover
  18. Risk Factors Regulatory Risk Factors Tax regulations are unpredictable. Tax burdens may increase due to higher imposed SD. Price slabs and segments may change as well, impacting demand. Market Index & Technical Factors Stock market is unpredictable. Sudden upward or downward momentum due to other factors might impact the company’s price. E,g, the stock market crash impacted prices for a long time. Currency Risk Factors The current inflation rates may last longer than expected and impact businesses through higher costing of raw materials. Fiscal and monetary policies might be impacted as well. Uncertainties of the Pandemic Covid-19 may change the demand of tobacco products. COGS, OpEx and turnover ratios might be impacted in unexpected ways too if the pandemic persists for long.
  19. Sensitivity Analysis Variables Used: • Growth in Dividend • Dividend per Share in 2021 • Payables Payment Period • Receivable Collection Period • Tax Rate 76.31% Certainty Level of higher valuation than 688 Entire range is from 638.5 to 798.7 Base case is 687.6 After 10,000 trials, the std. error of the mean is 0.2
  20. Scenario Analysis 951.8 BDT 45.4% Best Case Scenario 687.6 BDT 5.05% Base Case Scenario 563.8 BDT -13.87% Worst Case Scenario WACC TP Gain Best Case 7% 800.6 22.31% Base Case 9% 687.6 5.05% Worst Case 11% 563.8 -13.87% DCF Valuation Sensitivity Analysis
  21. Recommendation & Conclusion 661.3 BDT Dividend Discount Model 605.0 BDT Discounted Cash Flow 796.6 BDT Relative Using Forward P/E 687.6 BDT Weighted Average Recommendation: HOLD Current Market Price: 654.6 BDT Target Market Price: 687.6 BDT Upside Potential: 5.05%
  22. Thank you
Anúncio