Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Team Medallion, CFA Research Challenge'22 Presentation, Final Round
1. RENATA LIMITED (DSE: RENATA)
Pharmaceuticals & Chemicals
Target Price (30.06.2022): 1323 BDT
Closing Price (31.01.2022): 1332 BDT
Capital Gain: -0.69%
HOLD
0.36% Net Upside
Target Price: 1323 BDT
2. Business Description
62.87%
2.66%
16.96%
14.90%
2.12% 0.49%
Revenue Contribution by Segments
Local Pharma
Pharma Export
Animal Health
Contract
Purnava
Agro
10.29
12.68
15.54 16.33
18.88
0.99 0.61 0.47 0.69 0.80
-
3.00
6.00
9.00
12.00
15.00
18.00
21.00
2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21
Local vs Export Pharma Sales (in Mn USD)
Local Export
Segment Current Scenario Potential
Pharma • 5th largest in the country
• 47 new formulations in 2020-21
• Maxpro is the star product
• Have multiple certifications and subsidiaries abroad
• Focus on CNS, cardiovascular and oncology products
• Objective to target a $9.9bn European niche market
• Higher focus on R&D
Contract Manufacturing • Strong partnerships with government and other organization
• Supplies 2/3rd contraceptives of the government
• Recently got a BDT 600mn contract
• Objective to be the biggest suppliers of birth control pills
Animal Health • Market leader with 22.05% market share
• Cyclical pattern of sales and market
• Market expected to grow at 12.50% for the next five years
• Improved husbandry practices
Other Subsidiaries • Restructuring Renata Agro
• Purnava reached profitability this year for the first time
• Foreign subsidiaries to start generating revenue
• Fast growing market of Purnava
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Source: Renata Annual Report 2020-21 Source: Renata Annual Report
3. Local and Export Market Growth
2269
2413
2711
2886
3195
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Revenue of Pharma (in Mn USD)
72.64
89.17
103.46
129.95
135.79
169.02
-
30.00
60.00
90.00
120.00
150.00
180.00
2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21
Pharma Exports (in Mn USD)
1.4xin 4 years 2.3xin 4 years
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Source: IMS Report, Q3 2021 Source: Export Processing Bureau
4. Market Overview
27%
9%
6%
2%
38%
10%
8%
30%
12% 10%
3%
26%
7%
12%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
Cardiovascular Cancer Respiratory Diabetes Communicable Injury Other NCDs
Shift in Global Disease Profile
2008 2018
Demographic Shift
45-55years
Population Mode to Shift
from 15-25 years
Anti-Biotics
Chronic Care
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Source: Country Dashboard, United Nations Population Fund
Source: World Health Organization
6. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Environmental & Social: Giving Back to the Community by Design
2.95%
Of Net Profit Went to CSR
Activities
51.00%
Of the Company Owned
by Sajida Foundation
2.70Mn KG
CO2 Emission Reduced a
Year by the Company
Source: Renata Insight
7. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Strong Corporate Governance & Transparency
Category Key Indicators Score
Executive
Committee
• Independence to scrutinize strategy
3.77
/4.00
• Thorough evaluation of BoD
• Accountability reflected in BoD's activities
• General and Technical Competence of BoD
Audit
Committee
• Power and Access provided to auditor
4.00
/4.00
• Independence of audit committee
• Shareholder's ratification in auditor selection
• Shareholders have knowledge of performance
metrics
Compensation
Committee
• Equity is a part of BoD's compensation
2.75
/4.00
• Performance metrics aligned with shareholders'
wealth maximization
• Rights of minority shareholders protected
Protection of
Shareholder
Right
• Shareholders receive timely dividend payment
3.75
/4.00
• Shareholders can call class meetings and special
meetings
• Each share holds one vote
3.57/4.00
Combined Corporate
Governance Scorecard
Source: Team Analysis
8. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Our Recommendation
Sustainable Revenue Growth in an
Attractive but Competitive Local Market
Shifting Product Focus while Losing
Edge of Star Product
Strong Corporate Governance Leading
to Lower Beta
Despite Good Fundamentals, Current
P/E Leads to a Precautionary Stance
Date 31-Jan-2022
Current Price BDT 1332
Capital Gain -0.69%
Shares Outstanding 107Mn
Market Cap BDT 142Bn
Free Float 48.73%
HOLD
Target Price: BDT 1323
Potential Upside: 0.36%
9. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
1. Sustainable Revenue Growth in an Attractive but Competitive Local Market
Renata’ local pharmaceutical revenue has
grown at a CAGR of 16.40% compared to
11.60% CAGR of the market
Source: Renata Annual Reports, IMS Report, Q3’2021
23.18%
22.52%
5.11%
15.64%
14.70%
16.30%
4.00%
11.60%
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
25.00%
2017-18A 2018-19A 2019-20A 2020-21A
Revenue Growth Rate (Renata vs Market)
Renata Market
10. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
1. Sustainable Revenue Growth in an Attractive but Competitive Local Market
Renata has grown at a CAGR of 16.40%
compared to 11.60% CAGR of the market
Growing but Highly
Competitive Existing Market
59.8
66.1
73.2
78.2
80.5
86.1
91.1 91.4
97.3
109.6
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Healthcare Exp. per Capita in Bangladesh (in USD)
Source: Global Healthcare Expenditure Database, WHO
11. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
1. Sustainable Revenue Growth in an Attractive but Competitive Local Market
Renata has grown at a CAGR of 16.40%
compared to 11.60% CAGR of the market
Growing but Highly
Competitive Existing Market
Source: Renata Annual Report 2020-21
7.30% 7.10%
8.00%
10.00% 9.80%
10.80% 11.00%
11.50% 11.30%
6.00%
5.60%
7.30% 7.40%
7.70% 7.60%
8.50%
8.00%
7.60%
0.00%
2.00%
4.00%
6.00%
8.00%
10.00%
12.00%
14.00%
Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar
Renata's Market Share in Cardiovascular Category
FY20-21 FY19-20
Attractive and Less
Competitive New Market
12. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
2. Shifting Product Focus while Losing Edge of Star Product
Renata has grown at a CAGR of 16.40%
compared to 11.60% CAGR of the market
Growing but Highly
Competitive Existing Market
Source: IMS Report, Q3’2021
Attractive and Less
Competitive New Market
4.89%
2.56%
28.39%
12.86%
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
25.00%
30.00%
Q3'2020 Q3'2021
Maxpro vs Sergel
Growth Rate
Maxpro Sergel
6.9
3.6
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Sergel Maxpro
Market Size of Sergel
vs Maxpro (in Bn
BDT)
Source: IMS Report, Q3’2021
Maxpro, Renata’s
star product is
losing market
share
13. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
2. Shifting Product Focus while Losing Edge of Star Product
Source: Renata Annual Report 2020-21
Source: Renata Annual Report 2020-21
14
17
8
18
47
0
10
20
30
40
50
2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21
Number of New Formulations of Renata
1
3
2
2
8
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Anti-Inflammatory
Oncology
Cadiovascular
Anti-Diabetic
CNS
Renata's New Formulations by Segment in 2020-21
Renata has grown at a CAGR of 16.40%
compared to 11.60% CAGR of the market
Growing but Highly
Competitive Existing Market
Attractive and Less
Competitive New Market
MaxPro, Renata’s
star product is
losing market
share
Renata is creating
a new market in
other product
categories
Renata is gaining
higher market
share through
subsidiaries
14. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Forecasting the Revenue
Renata has grown at a CAGR of 16.40%
compared to 11.60% CAGR of the market
Growing but Highly
Competitive Existing Market
Attractive and Less
Competitive New Market
MaxPro, Renata’s
star product is
losing market
share
Source: Renata Annual Report 2020-21
Renata is creating
a new market in
other product
categories
Renata is gaining
higher market
share through
subsidiaries
Initially higher revenue
than market, but
eventually growing at
market growth rate
14.50% to 13.50%
Revenue Growth Rate
for Renata
23.18%
22.52%
5.11%
15.64%
14.50% 14.50%
14.00% 14.00%
13.50% 13.50%
14.70%
16.30%
4.00%
11.60%
13.50% 13.50% 13.50% 13.50% 13.50% 13.50%
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
25.00%
Revenue Growth Rate (Renata vs Market)
Renata Market
16. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
3. Strong Corporate Governance Leading to Lower Beta
Low Beta Originating from High Investor Confidence
Source: Dhaka Stock Exchange
SAJIDA Foundation as the Majority
Shareholder
Transparent Business Processes
Reflected in Awards, Recognitions, and
Contracts
Strong Balance Sheet from 19% Debt to
Equity Ratio
17. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
4. Despite Good Fundamentals, Current P/E Leads to a Precautionary Stance
26.78
13.89
11.27
10.68
-
5.00
10.00
15.00
20.00
25.00
30.00
35.00
Feb-17 Aug-17 Feb-18 Aug-18 Feb-19 Aug-19 Feb-20 Aug-20 Feb-21 Aug-21 Feb-22
Comparison of PE
RNTL.DH PE BXPH.DH PE SQPH.DH PE ACMR.DH PE
Source: Dhaka Stock Exchange
Optimistic Bias in a Bull Run
48.70%
Increase of Renata’s Price in
Last 2 Years
54.60%
Increase of DSEX in Last 2
Years
20. Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Financial Health: NWC, NAV & NOCFPS
Source: Team Analysis Source: Team Analysis
30.19%
27.16%
28.87%
29.33%
28.91%
28.90%
28.76% 28.76%
28.64% 28.64%
26.50%
27.00%
27.50%
28.00%
28.50%
29.00%
29.50%
30.00%
30.50%
NWC/Sales
221.45
230.90
245.65
263.85
281.57
300.01
319.84
337.10
355.73
371.10
38.12
52.54 52.89
44.34
56.95
57.86
61.78
63.68
67.87
69.53
0.00
10.00
20.00
30.00
40.00
50.00
60.00
70.00
80.00
0.00
50.00
100.00
150.00
200.00
250.00
300.00
350.00
400.00
NAV per share & NOCFPS
NAV per share Net Operating Cashflow per share
21. DCF Valuation
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
4.47%
Terminal Growth Rate
Average Real
Growth Rate per
Capita
Long Term
Inflation Goal
Global Medicine
Market Growth
Rate
6.87%
Cost of Debt
Interest Coverage Ratio: 50.40
Spread: 0.75%
Country Default Spread: 3.06%
Tax Rate: 22.5%
11.23%
Cost of Equity
Risk-free Rate: 7.10%
Beta: .53
Equity Risk Premium: 7.80%
15.58%
Debt to Asset Ratio
10.65%
WACC
Target Price
1277 BDT
Current Price
1323 BDT
Downside
3.48%
Enterprise Value
126 Bn
No. of Shares
107 Mn
22. Relative Valuation
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
PE Ratio
1243 BDT
PEG Ratio
1494 BDT
Target Price
1369 BDT
50% 50%
Current Price
1323 BDT
Upside
2.78%
Factors Considered
Similarity in Business, Profitability, Revenue, and
Demographic traits of the consumers
23. Decision
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
DCF
1277 BDT
PEG (Relative)
1494 BDT
PE (Relative)
1243 BDT
Target Price
1323 BDT
Current Price
1332 BDT
50%
25%
25%
Capital Loss
0.69%
Dividend Yield
1.05%
Net Upside
0.36%
24. Sensitivity Analysis
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Source: Team Analysis
25. Monte Carlo Simulation
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Parameters Used
WACC, Revenue Growth, COGS, Operating
Margin, Terminal Growth Rate
Number of Trials
100,000
25.51%
Outcomes result in a price with
a price yielding 10% upside
26. Risk Matrix
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
Impact
M1. Steep Local
Competition
M2. Supply Chain
Disruption
M2. Supply Chain
Disruption
B1. Capacity
Overutilization
P2. Stringent
Regulations for
Export
F1. Foreign
Exchange
B2.
Underperforming
Subsidiaries
P1. Graduation
from LDC Status
Probability
B1. Capacity Overutilization
B2. Underperforming Subsidiaries
P1. Graduation from LDC Status
P2. Stringent Regulations for Export
M1. Steep Local Competition
M2. Supply Chain Disruption
F1. Foreign Exchange
Business Risk
Financial Risk
Political Risk
Market Risk
Source: Team Analysis
27. Mitigation Strategy
Company & Market ESG Considerations Thesis & Analysis Valuation Sensitivity & Risk
B1. Capacity Overutilization
B2. Underperforming Subsidiaries
P1. Graduation from LDC Status
P2. Stringent Regulations for Export
M1. Steep Local Competition
M2. Supply Chain Disruption
F1. Foreign Exchange
Business Risk
Financial Risk
Political Risk
Market Risk
• Effective capital reinvestment
• Healthy D/E ratio in favor of expansion
• Declining marketing costs of Purnava
• Change in business strategy
• 80% products with expired patents
• Regulatory approvals from MHRA
• Goodwill with UNICEF & WHO
• Targeting high growth products
• Focusing on R&D
• Diversification of sourcing
• Utilizing API park
• USD-denominated receipts from export
• Average lower net exposure
28. Our Recommendation
Sustainable Revenue Growth in an
Attractive but Competitive Local Market
Shifting Product Focus while Losing
Edge of Star Product
Strong Corporate Governance Leading
to Lower Beta
Despite Good Fundamentals, Current
P/E Leads to a Precautionary Stance
Date 31-Jan-2022
Current Price BDT 1332
Capital Gain -0.69%
Shares Outstanding 107Mn
Market Cap BDT 142Bn
Free Float 48.73%
HOLD
Target Price: BDT 1323
Net Upside: 0.36%