SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 13
Jeremy Kennedy - Partner McCullough Robertson Lawyers Dealing with Demonstrations and Protestors – Legal Risk + Response 26 July 2011 12:15pm – 12:35pm 1
2 Case example 2 – Port Waratah Coal Services
3 Risk Injury or death of protestor(s) Injury or death of employee/contractor Loss of production/cost Reputational issues Prosecution by regulators(?) Civil claims
4 Risk - Legal responsibilities Occupational Health and Safety Act 2000 (NSW) duty of care to non-employees – Section 8(2) must ensure people (other than employees) are not exposed to risks to their health and safety duty to trespassers?  duties of controllers of work premises – Section 10
5 Risk - Legal responsibilities Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW) duty of manger or controller of the workplace to ensure health and safety of any person (so far as reasonably practicable) – Section 20  duties of other persons at the workplace to take reasonable care for own health and safety – Section 29  Common law duties of care owed by owners and occupiers
6 Response - Public order powers ,[object Object],Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities Act) 2002 (NSW) Terrorism (Police Powers) Act 2002 (NSW) Inclosed Lands Protection Act 1901 (NSW) Major Events Act 2009 (NSW) Crimes (Criminal Organisation Control) Act 2009 (NSW) Defence Act 1903 (Cth)
7 Response - Public order power examples  Terrorism (Police Powers) Act 2002 (NSW) a ‘terrorist act’ includes advocacy, protest, dissent or industrial action done with the intention of advancing a political, religious or ideological cause and with intent of intimidating the public or a section of the public or government – Section 3  police authorised to exercise special powers  Inclosed Lands Protection Act 1901 (NSW) special protections for ‘inclosed lands’  offence to enter enclosed land without the consent of the owner or occupier of the land – Section 4
8 Response - Civil actions and remedies
9 Case example 1 – Port Waratah Coal Services ,[object Object]
Sought compensation under s77B of the Victim’s Support and Rehabilitation Act 1996
Magistrate Elaine Truscott dismissed application for compensation
PWCS could not prove actual loss suffered and any money awarded was to be given to charity (not compensation),[object Object]
conduct resulted in potential breaches of OHS Act

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque (9)

frozen-foods-and-snacks-market-in-india
frozen-foods-and-snacks-market-in-indiafrozen-foods-and-snacks-market-in-india
frozen-foods-and-snacks-market-in-india
 
竹地牛教案、學習單
竹地牛教案、學習單竹地牛教案、學習單
竹地牛教案、學習單
 
latest resume
latest resume latest resume
latest resume
 
Dealing With Payers With Physician Driven Cost And
Dealing With Payers With Physician Driven Cost AndDealing With Payers With Physician Driven Cost And
Dealing With Payers With Physician Driven Cost And
 
146 animal models of vulnerable plaque
146 animal models of vulnerable plaque146 animal models of vulnerable plaque
146 animal models of vulnerable plaque
 
Jynxs - Mad World
Jynxs - Mad WorldJynxs - Mad World
Jynxs - Mad World
 
Mohamed Abdelmonem
Mohamed AbdelmonemMohamed Abdelmonem
Mohamed Abdelmonem
 
Rk20
Rk20Rk20
Rk20
 
Educamp 09
Educamp 09Educamp 09
Educamp 09
 

Semelhante a Dealing with Demonstartions & Protestors- Legal Risk & Response

The determination of whether noise constitutes a nuisance or a statutory nuis...
The determination of whether noise constitutes a nuisance or a statutory nuis...The determination of whether noise constitutes a nuisance or a statutory nuis...
The determination of whether noise constitutes a nuisance or a statutory nuis...
Michael Owen
 
Applicant guide-mining-activities-conservation-land
Applicant guide-mining-activities-conservation-landApplicant guide-mining-activities-conservation-land
Applicant guide-mining-activities-conservation-land
Kalyan Ram
 
160515 Proportionate Liability Paper
160515  Proportionate Liability Paper160515  Proportionate Liability Paper
160515 Proportionate Liability Paper
Greg Laughton SC
 
Climate Change Litigation (Part 1)I. IntroductionThe I.docx
Climate Change Litigation (Part 1)I. IntroductionThe I.docxClimate Change Litigation (Part 1)I. IntroductionThe I.docx
Climate Change Litigation (Part 1)I. IntroductionThe I.docx
monicafrancis71118
 

Semelhante a Dealing with Demonstartions & Protestors- Legal Risk & Response (20)

Lewis barbe was declared as an expert in safety and accident reconst
Lewis barbe was declared as an expert in safety and accident reconstLewis barbe was declared as an expert in safety and accident reconst
Lewis barbe was declared as an expert in safety and accident reconst
 
The determination of whether noise constitutes a nuisance or a statutory nuis...
The determination of whether noise constitutes a nuisance or a statutory nuis...The determination of whether noise constitutes a nuisance or a statutory nuis...
The determination of whether noise constitutes a nuisance or a statutory nuis...
 
TORT II [nuisance notes]
TORT II [nuisance notes]TORT II [nuisance notes]
TORT II [nuisance notes]
 
Environmental Justice: Challenges, Access and Necessity of National Network
Environmental Justice:Challenges, Access and Necessity of National NetworkEnvironmental Justice:Challenges, Access and Necessity of National Network
Environmental Justice: Challenges, Access and Necessity of National Network
 
Lewis Barbe Expert Witness - Guidrey Case
Lewis Barbe Expert Witness -  Guidrey CaseLewis Barbe Expert Witness -  Guidrey Case
Lewis Barbe Expert Witness - Guidrey Case
 
CHART LAW OF TORT for REVISION 2020 complete.docx
CHART LAW OF TORT for REVISION 2020 complete.docxCHART LAW OF TORT for REVISION 2020 complete.docx
CHART LAW OF TORT for REVISION 2020 complete.docx
 
Environmental Pollution and Common Law Remedies.pdf
Environmental Pollution and Common Law Remedies.pdfEnvironmental Pollution and Common Law Remedies.pdf
Environmental Pollution and Common Law Remedies.pdf
 
Econ367Factum
Econ367FactumEcon367Factum
Econ367Factum
 
An Introduction to Environmental Law by Oliver Campbell QC and Rachel Tandy
An Introduction to Environmental Law by Oliver Campbell QC and Rachel TandyAn Introduction to Environmental Law by Oliver Campbell QC and Rachel Tandy
An Introduction to Environmental Law by Oliver Campbell QC and Rachel Tandy
 
wildlife law consultation paper
wildlife law consultation paperwildlife law consultation paper
wildlife law consultation paper
 
Environmental case law update
Environmental case law updateEnvironmental case law update
Environmental case law update
 
Applicant guide-mining-activities-conservation-land
Applicant guide-mining-activities-conservation-landApplicant guide-mining-activities-conservation-land
Applicant guide-mining-activities-conservation-land
 
What Exactly Is Absolute Liability.pdf
What Exactly Is Absolute Liability.pdfWhat Exactly Is Absolute Liability.pdf
What Exactly Is Absolute Liability.pdf
 
Nuclear Energy, Long Tail Insurance Liabilities
Nuclear Energy, Long Tail Insurance LiabilitiesNuclear Energy, Long Tail Insurance Liabilities
Nuclear Energy, Long Tail Insurance Liabilities
 
Environment law
Environment lawEnvironment law
Environment law
 
Claims Club - March 2019 - London
Claims Club - March 2019 - London Claims Club - March 2019 - London
Claims Club - March 2019 - London
 
The Evolving “Nature” of Environmental Risk: A Responsible Approach for Resid...
The Evolving “Nature” of Environmental Risk: A Responsible Approach for Resid...The Evolving “Nature” of Environmental Risk: A Responsible Approach for Resid...
The Evolving “Nature” of Environmental Risk: A Responsible Approach for Resid...
 
160515 Proportionate Liability Paper
160515  Proportionate Liability Paper160515  Proportionate Liability Paper
160515 Proportionate Liability Paper
 
The Intersection of Bankruptcy and Environmental Law (Series: Bankruptcy Inte...
The Intersection of Bankruptcy and Environmental Law (Series: Bankruptcy Inte...The Intersection of Bankruptcy and Environmental Law (Series: Bankruptcy Inte...
The Intersection of Bankruptcy and Environmental Law (Series: Bankruptcy Inte...
 
Climate Change Litigation (Part 1)I. IntroductionThe I.docx
Climate Change Litigation (Part 1)I. IntroductionThe I.docxClimate Change Litigation (Part 1)I. IntroductionThe I.docx
Climate Change Litigation (Part 1)I. IntroductionThe I.docx
 

Dealing with Demonstartions & Protestors- Legal Risk & Response

  • 1. Jeremy Kennedy - Partner McCullough Robertson Lawyers Dealing with Demonstrations and Protestors – Legal Risk + Response 26 July 2011 12:15pm – 12:35pm 1
  • 2. 2 Case example 2 – Port Waratah Coal Services
  • 3. 3 Risk Injury or death of protestor(s) Injury or death of employee/contractor Loss of production/cost Reputational issues Prosecution by regulators(?) Civil claims
  • 4. 4 Risk - Legal responsibilities Occupational Health and Safety Act 2000 (NSW) duty of care to non-employees – Section 8(2) must ensure people (other than employees) are not exposed to risks to their health and safety duty to trespassers? duties of controllers of work premises – Section 10
  • 5. 5 Risk - Legal responsibilities Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW) duty of manger or controller of the workplace to ensure health and safety of any person (so far as reasonably practicable) – Section 20 duties of other persons at the workplace to take reasonable care for own health and safety – Section 29 Common law duties of care owed by owners and occupiers
  • 6.
  • 7. 7 Response - Public order power examples Terrorism (Police Powers) Act 2002 (NSW) a ‘terrorist act’ includes advocacy, protest, dissent or industrial action done with the intention of advancing a political, religious or ideological cause and with intent of intimidating the public or a section of the public or government – Section 3 police authorised to exercise special powers Inclosed Lands Protection Act 1901 (NSW) special protections for ‘inclosed lands’ offence to enter enclosed land without the consent of the owner or occupier of the land – Section 4
  • 8. 8 Response - Civil actions and remedies
  • 9.
  • 10. Sought compensation under s77B of the Victim’s Support and Rehabilitation Act 1996
  • 11. Magistrate Elaine Truscott dismissed application for compensation
  • 12.
  • 13. conduct resulted in potential breaches of OHS Act
  • 14. possible civil actions against protestors included the torts of interference with contractual relationships, intimidation, nuisance and trespass
  • 15.
  • 16. The conveyor belt transported coal to the Bayswater power station
  • 17.
  • 18. ‘Soft approach’ or ‘hard approach’
  • 25.