SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 5
Preliminary Plan for Regulatory Review
This document sets forth the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation’s preliminary plan for the
review of its existing regulations, pursuant to Executive Order 13563 on Improving Regulation
and Regulatory Review.

PBGC has already begun implementing EO 13563 by reconsidering several regulations PBGC
had previously proposed. In addition, PBGC will be making changes to provide for more
extensive public participation in rulemaking by adding public hearings to its process.

Background

The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) protects the pensions of about 44 million
people in about 29,000 private defined benefit plans. PBGC pays benefits when the sponsors of
those plans cannot. PBGC receives no funds from general tax revenues. All operations are
financed by insurance premiums, investment income, assets from pension plans trusteed by
PBGC, and recoveries from the companies formerly responsible for the trusteed plans.

To carry out these functions, PBGC issues regulations interpreting such matters as the
termination process for defined benefit plans, establishment of procedures for premium
payments, reporting and disclosure of actions by plans and their sponsors that may affect plan
liability, and assessment and collection of employer liability.1

On April 1, 2011, PBGC requested public comments on developing its preliminary plan. PBGC
received comments from four organizations representing employers or pension professionals and
a pension consulting firm.2 PBGC will continue to accept additional comments as it finalizes its
preliminary plan and engages in the regulatory review.

Principles

PBGC makes every effort to issue regulations that implement the law in ways that do not impede
the maintenance of existing defined benefit plans or the establishment of new plans. PBGC
attempts to minimize administrative burdens on plans and participants, improve transparency,
simplify filing, provide relief for small businesses, and assist plans to comply with applicable
requirements. Despite the inherent complexity of pensions and of PBGC’s activities, PBGC is
committed to issuing simple, understandable, flexible, and timely regulations to help employers,
practitioners, and participants.


1
    PBGC’s regulations are in 29 CFR Chapter XL.
2
  The Request is posted at http://www.pbgc.gov/Documents/2011-7805.pdf. Comments received to date are posted
on PBGC’s Web site at http://www.pbgc.gov/Documents/reducing-regulatory-burden-comments(5).pdf. Any
additional comments will be posted as they are received.
PBGC’s preliminary regulatory review plan is designed to ensure that PBGC’s regulations
remain consistent with these principles and to improve its regulatory program and processes.
Many changes have occurred in the decades since PBGC was established and began its
regulatory program, including new legislation, changes in technology, and shifts in the economy
or relevant industries. PBGC’s review of existing regulations will take such changes into
account in order to improve its regulations, always striving to find better alternatives. Further, to
the extent practicable, PBGC will seek to rely on information sources, reporting mechanisms,
and performance standards that are already established and accepted by the regulated
community, thereby reducing duplication and costs, as well as increasing regulatory
coordination, simplicity, and flexibility.

Priorities for Review

Regulations that are not consistent with these principles will be prioritized for review to
determine whether they should be modified, streamlined, expanded, or repealed as appropriate.
PBGC will also prioritize regulations for review based on the following criteria3:

       Regulations affected by a fundamental change since originally promulgated, including
        new legislation, changes in technology, and shifts in the economy or relevant industry.

       Regulations that have raised concerns with PBGC’s regulated community.

       Regulations identified through internal surveys of PBGC departments.

In the spirit of Executive Order 13563, PBGC will apply the retrospective review to all of its
regulations, although it will focus on significant regulations.

Issues in Review

In reviewing a regulation, PBGC will compare the actual consequences of the regulation with the
pre-promulgation projections and expectations about the regulation’s effectiveness, benefits, and
burdens. In each case, PBGC will ask:

       Is the regulation effective?

             o Is the regulation accomplishing its stated goals?
             o What has been the actual burden?
             o Are there unintended beneficial or costly side effects?

       Are there better alternatives?



3
  If PBGC had regulations that were considered economically significant (under the terms of Executive Order
12866), these would be a priority.
                                                        2
PBGC will consider the full range of distributive impacts, rather than focusing exclusively on
impacts to a single community, as well as impacts on PBGC’s broader regulatory program.


Initial List of Rules for Review

Taking into account public comments on its April 1 Request and internal feedback, PBGC
intends to review the following regulations:

          Reportable Events. In response to Executive Order 13563 and comments on its
           November 2009 proposed rule on Reportable Events,4 PBGC was already planning to re-
           propose this rule with an emphasis toward reducing the unnecessary burdens on
           employers and plans. For example, PBGC is considering whether and to what extent it
           can take advantage of other existing reporting requirements and methods to avoid
           burdening companies and plans, and how to implement industry’s suggestion that
           different reporting requirements should apply in circumstances where the risk to PBGC is
           low or compliance is especially burdensome.

          ERISA section 4062(e). In light of industry comments, PBGC will also reconsider its
           2010 proposed rule5 that would provide guidance on the applicability and enforcement of
           ERISA section 4062(e). The statutory provision provides for reporting of and liability for
           certain substantial cessations of operations by employers that maintain single-employer
           plans.

          Voluntary Correction Program. Two comments on regulatory review suggested that
           PBGC expand its current voluntary correction program for errors related to filings and
           other requirements. PBGC will consider this suggestion in conjunction with changes to
           its current premium and information penalty policies. Expansion of the program could
           potentially encourage compliance and reduce compliance costs.

          Premiums. One commenter indicated that some small plans with year-end-valuation
           dates have difficulty meeting the filing deadline because such plans traditionally do not
           have their actuarial valuation for the prior year completed by the due date (i.e., four
           months after year-end). In light of this concern, PBGC will review parts 4006 (Premium
           Rates) and 4007 (Payment of Premiums) to determine whether changes could be made
           that would enable small plans to streamline their premium and funding valuation
           procedures and in doing so reduce actuarial fees.

          Changes in other regulations to improve plan and PBGC administration. PBGC will
           review selected aspects of 29 CFR parts 4022 (Benefits payable in terminated single-
           employer plans) and 4044 (Allocation of assets in single-employer plans), and of
           Subchapter 1 (Withdrawal Liability for Multiemployer Plans) to eliminate obsolete
4
    74 Fed. Reg. 61247 (Nov. 23, 2009).
5
    75 Fed. Reg. 48283 (Aug. 10, 2010).
                                                   3
provisions, simplify language, and fill in gaps where guidance would be helpful to the
        public and the relevant operating departments. These steps could have the effect of
        reducing the overall burden on plan sponsors in determining how to comply with the
        applicable rules. Eliminating certain provisions may reduce the time and cost spent
        indentifying items plan sponsors need to comply with. Simplifying language and
        developing gap-filling guidance could reduce the amount of time and cost spent on
        interpreting rule provisions. Improving PBGC administration allows PBGC to better
        allocate resources. PBGC may also in the future consider reviewing its regulations on
        annual valuation requirements for terminated multiemployer plans (Section 4041A.24)
        and reporting requirements for mergers between multiemployer plans (part 4231) to
        determine whether some requirements may be unnecessary, which could help reduce
        certain administrative costs and preserve plan assets for the benefit of participants.

       Elimination of obsolete regulation. PBGC will remove part 4011 (Disclosure to
        Participants) from its regulations, since that regulation does not apply to plan years
        beginning on or after January 1, 2007. Eliminating this regulation will reduce the amount
        of time and cost spent on identifying items that plan sponsors need to comply with.

       ERISA section 4010. In conformity with several comments on regulatory review, PBGC
        will review part 4010 (Annual Financial and Actuarial Information Reporting) and the
        filing application to see whether it can reduce burden while preserving its ability to
        receive critical information.

In addition, PBGC will review a regulation as soon as practicable following a fundamental
change in circumstances that affects the regulation or in response to comments from stakeholders
or relevant operating Departments. Significant regulations will be reviewed at least every ten
years.

PBGC will prioritize regulatory changes resulting from this review in the context of its broader
regulatory agenda, which includes regulations to implement statutory changes.6 Thus, this
review will supplement that agenda, rather than displace it.

Structure and Staffing

Review of PBGC regulations will be conducted by an inter-departmental working group
consisting of representatives from relevant operational, legal, and policy departments. The
review project will be led by PBGC’s Deputy Director for Policy – a high level official who can
secure cooperation across the Corporation and is independent from operational departments.




6
 In particular, a proposed regulation to implement Pension Protection Act of 2006’s expansion of PBGC’s Missing
Participants program (part 4050) is far along in development and expected to be issued in 2011.


                                                       4
Coordination

Executive Order 13563 calls for greater harmonization and coordination within and across
agencies. Accordingly, PBGC will review selected rules to analyze their impact on the pension
termination insurance program and broader federal agency regulation of pensions. PBGC will
coordinate its review with the other ERISA agencies (Department of Labor, Department of
Treasury, Internal Revenue Service), its Board agencies (in addition to Labor and Treasury, the
Department of Commerce), and the Office of Management and Budget.

Consultation and Public Participation

Executive Order 13563 calls for an “open exchange” of information among government officials,
experts, stakeholders, and the public.

One commenter (an association of major employers that provide defined benefit plans)
recommended that PBGC create a stakeholder advisory group that would meet regularly to
review regulations and discuss other issues related to PBGC’s impact on plan sponsors. PBGC
already has a statutory Advisory Committee, which includes persons from various
constituencies, including employers, employees, and the public. PBGC will consult with the
Advisory Committee to develop a useful role in regulatory activities.

In addition, PBGC is changing its traditional practices for review of its regulations and wants to
involve the public more often in that process. Accordingly PBGC will:

      Hold public hearings on major regulations, rather than relying solely on written
       comments. PBGS also plans to provide additional means for public involvement,
       including on-line town hall meetings and continuing opportunity for public comment on
       PBGC’s Web site.

      Post this preliminary plan for regulatory review and the final plan on PBGC’s Web site
       for public comment, and also post all comments.

      Include information on review of specific regulations in PBGC’s semi-annual Regulatory
       Agenda and annual Statement of Regulatory and Deregulatory Priorities (both are
       available on www. reginfo.gov); PBGC plans to include an explanation of its review
       conclusions in information accompanying any such regulatory changes.

PBGC will review its final regulatory review plan from time to time or in response to public
comment and make appropriate modifications as required to ensure its effectiveness.




                                                 5

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

Protected Wreck Sites at Risk
Protected Wreck Sites at RiskProtected Wreck Sites at Risk
Protected Wreck Sites at Riskm1dunkle
 
The President’s Speech in Cairo: A New Beginning - Chinese
The President’s Speech in Cairo: A New Beginning - ChineseThe President’s Speech in Cairo: A New Beginning - Chinese
The President’s Speech in Cairo: A New Beginning - ChineseObama White House
 
Grandma Esther
Grandma EstherGrandma Esther
Grandma EstherAlan Brody
 
Présentation_Turquie_déc. 2010_2°partie
Présentation_Turquie_déc. 2010_2°partiePrésentation_Turquie_déc. 2010_2°partie
Présentation_Turquie_déc. 2010_2°partieJean-Paul Chéno
 
QPI: Academic & Affective Education
QPI: Academic & Affective EducationQPI: Academic & Affective Education
QPI: Academic & Affective EducationJodiRae
 
E N T Z U T E Z K O O R O I M E N A
E N T Z U T E Z K O  O R O I M E N AE N T Z U T E Z K O  O R O I M E N A
E N T Z U T E Z K O O R O I M E N Aekaitzmg
 
Crew, Foia, Appendix a (part 1) 008511 - 008555
Crew, Foia, Appendix a (part 1) 008511 - 008555Crew, Foia, Appendix a (part 1) 008511 - 008555
Crew, Foia, Appendix a (part 1) 008511 - 008555Obama White House
 
Kantitateak Ezagutu
Kantitateak EzagutuKantitateak Ezagutu
Kantitateak Ezagutuekaitzmg
 
Evaluating the Development and Impact of Feed-In Tariffs
Evaluating the Development and Impact of Feed-In TariffsEvaluating the Development and Impact of Feed-In Tariffs
Evaluating the Development and Impact of Feed-In TariffsDirk Volkmann
 

Destaque (19)

CAR Email 9.5.02 (o)
CAR Email 9.5.02 (o)CAR Email 9.5.02 (o)
CAR Email 9.5.02 (o)
 
RCEC Email 5.30.03
RCEC Email 5.30.03RCEC Email 5.30.03
RCEC Email 5.30.03
 
CAR Email 6.10.02 (d)
CAR Email 6.10.02 (d)CAR Email 6.10.02 (d)
CAR Email 6.10.02 (d)
 
CAR Email 01.24.01
CAR Email 01.24.01CAR Email 01.24.01
CAR Email 01.24.01
 
CAR Email 11.15.01
CAR Email 11.15.01CAR Email 11.15.01
CAR Email 11.15.01
 
Protected Wreck Sites at Risk
Protected Wreck Sites at RiskProtected Wreck Sites at Risk
Protected Wreck Sites at Risk
 
CAR Email 6.5.02 (f)
CAR Email 6.5.02 (f)CAR Email 6.5.02 (f)
CAR Email 6.5.02 (f)
 
The President’s Speech in Cairo: A New Beginning - Chinese
The President’s Speech in Cairo: A New Beginning - ChineseThe President’s Speech in Cairo: A New Beginning - Chinese
The President’s Speech in Cairo: A New Beginning - Chinese
 
Longform friendly gadgets
Longform friendly gadgetsLongform friendly gadgets
Longform friendly gadgets
 
Grandma Esther
Grandma EstherGrandma Esther
Grandma Esther
 
Présentation_Turquie_déc. 2010_2°partie
Présentation_Turquie_déc. 2010_2°partiePrésentation_Turquie_déc. 2010_2°partie
Présentation_Turquie_déc. 2010_2°partie
 
QPI: Academic & Affective Education
QPI: Academic & Affective EducationQPI: Academic & Affective Education
QPI: Academic & Affective Education
 
E N T Z U T E Z K O O R O I M E N A
E N T Z U T E Z K O  O R O I M E N AE N T Z U T E Z K O  O R O I M E N A
E N T Z U T E Z K O O R O I M E N A
 
CAR Email 6.6.02 (a)
CAR Email 6.6.02 (a)CAR Email 6.6.02 (a)
CAR Email 6.6.02 (a)
 
SERA Email 10.4.02
SERA Email 10.4.02SERA Email 10.4.02
SERA Email 10.4.02
 
Crew, Foia, Appendix a (part 1) 008511 - 008555
Crew, Foia, Appendix a (part 1) 008511 - 008555Crew, Foia, Appendix a (part 1) 008511 - 008555
Crew, Foia, Appendix a (part 1) 008511 - 008555
 
CAR Email 7.10.02 (a)
CAR Email 7.10.02 (a)CAR Email 7.10.02 (a)
CAR Email 7.10.02 (a)
 
Kantitateak Ezagutu
Kantitateak EzagutuKantitateak Ezagutu
Kantitateak Ezagutu
 
Evaluating the Development and Impact of Feed-In Tariffs
Evaluating the Development and Impact of Feed-In TariffsEvaluating the Development and Impact of Feed-In Tariffs
Evaluating the Development and Impact of Feed-In Tariffs
 

Mais de Obama White House

White House State of the Union 2016 - Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2016 - Enhanced GraphicsWhite House State of the Union 2016 - Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2016 - Enhanced GraphicsObama White House
 
President Obama's Letter on Countering Iran
President Obama's Letter on Countering IranPresident Obama's Letter on Countering Iran
President Obama's Letter on Countering IranObama White House
 
Western Governors Drought/Wildfire Briefing
Western Governors  Drought/Wildfire BriefingWestern Governors  Drought/Wildfire Briefing
Western Governors Drought/Wildfire BriefingObama White House
 
Secretary Perez to Congress: TAA is a Critical Lifeline for American Workers
Secretary Perez to Congress: TAA is a Critical Lifeline for American WorkersSecretary Perez to Congress: TAA is a Critical Lifeline for American Workers
Secretary Perez to Congress: TAA is a Critical Lifeline for American WorkersObama White House
 
The 2015 Enhanced State of the Union
The 2015 Enhanced State of the UnionThe 2015 Enhanced State of the Union
The 2015 Enhanced State of the UnionObama White House
 
The President's Message for the White House Convening on Community Foundations
The President's Message for the White House Convening on Community FoundationsThe President's Message for the White House Convening on Community Foundations
The President's Message for the White House Convening on Community FoundationsObama White House
 
President Obama's #GivingTuesday Message
President Obama's #GivingTuesday MessagePresident Obama's #GivingTuesday Message
President Obama's #GivingTuesday MessageObama White House
 
Draft of the Gettysburg Address
Draft of the Gettysburg AddressDraft of the Gettysburg Address
Draft of the Gettysburg AddressObama White House
 
Message: Commemorating the 50th Anniversary of the White House Fellows
Message: Commemorating the 50th Anniversary of the White House FellowsMessage: Commemorating the 50th Anniversary of the White House Fellows
Message: Commemorating the 50th Anniversary of the White House FellowsObama White House
 
The Economic Case for Raising the Minimum Wage
The Economic Case for Raising the Minimum WageThe Economic Case for Raising the Minimum Wage
The Economic Case for Raising the Minimum WageObama White House
 
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics Poster
 White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics Poster White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics Poster
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics PosterObama White House
 
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced GraphicsWhite House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced GraphicsObama White House
 
President Obama's Handwritten Tribute to the Gettysburg Address
President Obama's Handwritten Tribute to the Gettysburg AddressPresident Obama's Handwritten Tribute to the Gettysburg Address
President Obama's Handwritten Tribute to the Gettysburg AddressObama White House
 
President Obama's Plan to Fight Climate Change
President Obama's Plan to Fight Climate ChangePresident Obama's Plan to Fight Climate Change
President Obama's Plan to Fight Climate ChangeObama White House
 
President Obama's Deficit Plan
President Obama's Deficit PlanPresident Obama's Deficit Plan
President Obama's Deficit PlanObama White House
 
White House State of the Union 2013 Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2013 Enhanced GraphicsWhite House State of the Union 2013 Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2013 Enhanced GraphicsObama White House
 
Now Is the Time: President Obama's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence
Now Is the Time: President Obama's Plan to Reduce Gun ViolenceNow Is the Time: President Obama's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence
Now Is the Time: President Obama's Plan to Reduce Gun ViolenceObama White House
 
Infographic: Extending Middle-Class Tax Cuts
Infographic: Extending Middle-Class Tax CutsInfographic: Extending Middle-Class Tax Cuts
Infographic: Extending Middle-Class Tax CutsObama White House
 
White House Neighborhood Revitalization Initiative
White House Neighborhood Revitalization InitiativeWhite House Neighborhood Revitalization Initiative
White House Neighborhood Revitalization InitiativeObama White House
 

Mais de Obama White House (20)

White House State of the Union 2016 - Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2016 - Enhanced GraphicsWhite House State of the Union 2016 - Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2016 - Enhanced Graphics
 
President Obama's Letter on Countering Iran
President Obama's Letter on Countering IranPresident Obama's Letter on Countering Iran
President Obama's Letter on Countering Iran
 
Western Governors Drought/Wildfire Briefing
Western Governors  Drought/Wildfire BriefingWestern Governors  Drought/Wildfire Briefing
Western Governors Drought/Wildfire Briefing
 
Secretary Perez to Congress: TAA is a Critical Lifeline for American Workers
Secretary Perez to Congress: TAA is a Critical Lifeline for American WorkersSecretary Perez to Congress: TAA is a Critical Lifeline for American Workers
Secretary Perez to Congress: TAA is a Critical Lifeline for American Workers
 
The 2015 Enhanced State of the Union
The 2015 Enhanced State of the UnionThe 2015 Enhanced State of the Union
The 2015 Enhanced State of the Union
 
The Economy in 2014
The Economy in 2014The Economy in 2014
The Economy in 2014
 
The President's Message for the White House Convening on Community Foundations
The President's Message for the White House Convening on Community FoundationsThe President's Message for the White House Convening on Community Foundations
The President's Message for the White House Convening on Community Foundations
 
President Obama's #GivingTuesday Message
President Obama's #GivingTuesday MessagePresident Obama's #GivingTuesday Message
President Obama's #GivingTuesday Message
 
Draft of the Gettysburg Address
Draft of the Gettysburg AddressDraft of the Gettysburg Address
Draft of the Gettysburg Address
 
Message: Commemorating the 50th Anniversary of the White House Fellows
Message: Commemorating the 50th Anniversary of the White House FellowsMessage: Commemorating the 50th Anniversary of the White House Fellows
Message: Commemorating the 50th Anniversary of the White House Fellows
 
The Economic Case for Raising the Minimum Wage
The Economic Case for Raising the Minimum WageThe Economic Case for Raising the Minimum Wage
The Economic Case for Raising the Minimum Wage
 
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics Poster
 White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics Poster White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics Poster
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics Poster
 
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced GraphicsWhite House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2014 Enhanced Graphics
 
President Obama's Handwritten Tribute to the Gettysburg Address
President Obama's Handwritten Tribute to the Gettysburg AddressPresident Obama's Handwritten Tribute to the Gettysburg Address
President Obama's Handwritten Tribute to the Gettysburg Address
 
President Obama's Plan to Fight Climate Change
President Obama's Plan to Fight Climate ChangePresident Obama's Plan to Fight Climate Change
President Obama's Plan to Fight Climate Change
 
President Obama's Deficit Plan
President Obama's Deficit PlanPresident Obama's Deficit Plan
President Obama's Deficit Plan
 
White House State of the Union 2013 Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2013 Enhanced GraphicsWhite House State of the Union 2013 Enhanced Graphics
White House State of the Union 2013 Enhanced Graphics
 
Now Is the Time: President Obama's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence
Now Is the Time: President Obama's Plan to Reduce Gun ViolenceNow Is the Time: President Obama's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence
Now Is the Time: President Obama's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence
 
Infographic: Extending Middle-Class Tax Cuts
Infographic: Extending Middle-Class Tax CutsInfographic: Extending Middle-Class Tax Cuts
Infographic: Extending Middle-Class Tax Cuts
 
White House Neighborhood Revitalization Initiative
White House Neighborhood Revitalization InitiativeWhite House Neighborhood Revitalization Initiative
White House Neighborhood Revitalization Initiative
 

Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation Preliminary Regulatory Reform Plan

  • 1. Preliminary Plan for Regulatory Review This document sets forth the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation’s preliminary plan for the review of its existing regulations, pursuant to Executive Order 13563 on Improving Regulation and Regulatory Review. PBGC has already begun implementing EO 13563 by reconsidering several regulations PBGC had previously proposed. In addition, PBGC will be making changes to provide for more extensive public participation in rulemaking by adding public hearings to its process. Background The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) protects the pensions of about 44 million people in about 29,000 private defined benefit plans. PBGC pays benefits when the sponsors of those plans cannot. PBGC receives no funds from general tax revenues. All operations are financed by insurance premiums, investment income, assets from pension plans trusteed by PBGC, and recoveries from the companies formerly responsible for the trusteed plans. To carry out these functions, PBGC issues regulations interpreting such matters as the termination process for defined benefit plans, establishment of procedures for premium payments, reporting and disclosure of actions by plans and their sponsors that may affect plan liability, and assessment and collection of employer liability.1 On April 1, 2011, PBGC requested public comments on developing its preliminary plan. PBGC received comments from four organizations representing employers or pension professionals and a pension consulting firm.2 PBGC will continue to accept additional comments as it finalizes its preliminary plan and engages in the regulatory review. Principles PBGC makes every effort to issue regulations that implement the law in ways that do not impede the maintenance of existing defined benefit plans or the establishment of new plans. PBGC attempts to minimize administrative burdens on plans and participants, improve transparency, simplify filing, provide relief for small businesses, and assist plans to comply with applicable requirements. Despite the inherent complexity of pensions and of PBGC’s activities, PBGC is committed to issuing simple, understandable, flexible, and timely regulations to help employers, practitioners, and participants. 1 PBGC’s regulations are in 29 CFR Chapter XL. 2 The Request is posted at http://www.pbgc.gov/Documents/2011-7805.pdf. Comments received to date are posted on PBGC’s Web site at http://www.pbgc.gov/Documents/reducing-regulatory-burden-comments(5).pdf. Any additional comments will be posted as they are received.
  • 2. PBGC’s preliminary regulatory review plan is designed to ensure that PBGC’s regulations remain consistent with these principles and to improve its regulatory program and processes. Many changes have occurred in the decades since PBGC was established and began its regulatory program, including new legislation, changes in technology, and shifts in the economy or relevant industries. PBGC’s review of existing regulations will take such changes into account in order to improve its regulations, always striving to find better alternatives. Further, to the extent practicable, PBGC will seek to rely on information sources, reporting mechanisms, and performance standards that are already established and accepted by the regulated community, thereby reducing duplication and costs, as well as increasing regulatory coordination, simplicity, and flexibility. Priorities for Review Regulations that are not consistent with these principles will be prioritized for review to determine whether they should be modified, streamlined, expanded, or repealed as appropriate. PBGC will also prioritize regulations for review based on the following criteria3:  Regulations affected by a fundamental change since originally promulgated, including new legislation, changes in technology, and shifts in the economy or relevant industry.  Regulations that have raised concerns with PBGC’s regulated community.  Regulations identified through internal surveys of PBGC departments. In the spirit of Executive Order 13563, PBGC will apply the retrospective review to all of its regulations, although it will focus on significant regulations. Issues in Review In reviewing a regulation, PBGC will compare the actual consequences of the regulation with the pre-promulgation projections and expectations about the regulation’s effectiveness, benefits, and burdens. In each case, PBGC will ask:  Is the regulation effective? o Is the regulation accomplishing its stated goals? o What has been the actual burden? o Are there unintended beneficial or costly side effects?  Are there better alternatives? 3 If PBGC had regulations that were considered economically significant (under the terms of Executive Order 12866), these would be a priority. 2
  • 3. PBGC will consider the full range of distributive impacts, rather than focusing exclusively on impacts to a single community, as well as impacts on PBGC’s broader regulatory program. Initial List of Rules for Review Taking into account public comments on its April 1 Request and internal feedback, PBGC intends to review the following regulations:  Reportable Events. In response to Executive Order 13563 and comments on its November 2009 proposed rule on Reportable Events,4 PBGC was already planning to re- propose this rule with an emphasis toward reducing the unnecessary burdens on employers and plans. For example, PBGC is considering whether and to what extent it can take advantage of other existing reporting requirements and methods to avoid burdening companies and plans, and how to implement industry’s suggestion that different reporting requirements should apply in circumstances where the risk to PBGC is low or compliance is especially burdensome.  ERISA section 4062(e). In light of industry comments, PBGC will also reconsider its 2010 proposed rule5 that would provide guidance on the applicability and enforcement of ERISA section 4062(e). The statutory provision provides for reporting of and liability for certain substantial cessations of operations by employers that maintain single-employer plans.  Voluntary Correction Program. Two comments on regulatory review suggested that PBGC expand its current voluntary correction program for errors related to filings and other requirements. PBGC will consider this suggestion in conjunction with changes to its current premium and information penalty policies. Expansion of the program could potentially encourage compliance and reduce compliance costs.  Premiums. One commenter indicated that some small plans with year-end-valuation dates have difficulty meeting the filing deadline because such plans traditionally do not have their actuarial valuation for the prior year completed by the due date (i.e., four months after year-end). In light of this concern, PBGC will review parts 4006 (Premium Rates) and 4007 (Payment of Premiums) to determine whether changes could be made that would enable small plans to streamline their premium and funding valuation procedures and in doing so reduce actuarial fees.  Changes in other regulations to improve plan and PBGC administration. PBGC will review selected aspects of 29 CFR parts 4022 (Benefits payable in terminated single- employer plans) and 4044 (Allocation of assets in single-employer plans), and of Subchapter 1 (Withdrawal Liability for Multiemployer Plans) to eliminate obsolete 4 74 Fed. Reg. 61247 (Nov. 23, 2009). 5 75 Fed. Reg. 48283 (Aug. 10, 2010). 3
  • 4. provisions, simplify language, and fill in gaps where guidance would be helpful to the public and the relevant operating departments. These steps could have the effect of reducing the overall burden on plan sponsors in determining how to comply with the applicable rules. Eliminating certain provisions may reduce the time and cost spent indentifying items plan sponsors need to comply with. Simplifying language and developing gap-filling guidance could reduce the amount of time and cost spent on interpreting rule provisions. Improving PBGC administration allows PBGC to better allocate resources. PBGC may also in the future consider reviewing its regulations on annual valuation requirements for terminated multiemployer plans (Section 4041A.24) and reporting requirements for mergers between multiemployer plans (part 4231) to determine whether some requirements may be unnecessary, which could help reduce certain administrative costs and preserve plan assets for the benefit of participants.  Elimination of obsolete regulation. PBGC will remove part 4011 (Disclosure to Participants) from its regulations, since that regulation does not apply to plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2007. Eliminating this regulation will reduce the amount of time and cost spent on identifying items that plan sponsors need to comply with.  ERISA section 4010. In conformity with several comments on regulatory review, PBGC will review part 4010 (Annual Financial and Actuarial Information Reporting) and the filing application to see whether it can reduce burden while preserving its ability to receive critical information. In addition, PBGC will review a regulation as soon as practicable following a fundamental change in circumstances that affects the regulation or in response to comments from stakeholders or relevant operating Departments. Significant regulations will be reviewed at least every ten years. PBGC will prioritize regulatory changes resulting from this review in the context of its broader regulatory agenda, which includes regulations to implement statutory changes.6 Thus, this review will supplement that agenda, rather than displace it. Structure and Staffing Review of PBGC regulations will be conducted by an inter-departmental working group consisting of representatives from relevant operational, legal, and policy departments. The review project will be led by PBGC’s Deputy Director for Policy – a high level official who can secure cooperation across the Corporation and is independent from operational departments. 6 In particular, a proposed regulation to implement Pension Protection Act of 2006’s expansion of PBGC’s Missing Participants program (part 4050) is far along in development and expected to be issued in 2011. 4
  • 5. Coordination Executive Order 13563 calls for greater harmonization and coordination within and across agencies. Accordingly, PBGC will review selected rules to analyze their impact on the pension termination insurance program and broader federal agency regulation of pensions. PBGC will coordinate its review with the other ERISA agencies (Department of Labor, Department of Treasury, Internal Revenue Service), its Board agencies (in addition to Labor and Treasury, the Department of Commerce), and the Office of Management and Budget. Consultation and Public Participation Executive Order 13563 calls for an “open exchange” of information among government officials, experts, stakeholders, and the public. One commenter (an association of major employers that provide defined benefit plans) recommended that PBGC create a stakeholder advisory group that would meet regularly to review regulations and discuss other issues related to PBGC’s impact on plan sponsors. PBGC already has a statutory Advisory Committee, which includes persons from various constituencies, including employers, employees, and the public. PBGC will consult with the Advisory Committee to develop a useful role in regulatory activities. In addition, PBGC is changing its traditional practices for review of its regulations and wants to involve the public more often in that process. Accordingly PBGC will:  Hold public hearings on major regulations, rather than relying solely on written comments. PBGS also plans to provide additional means for public involvement, including on-line town hall meetings and continuing opportunity for public comment on PBGC’s Web site.  Post this preliminary plan for regulatory review and the final plan on PBGC’s Web site for public comment, and also post all comments.  Include information on review of specific regulations in PBGC’s semi-annual Regulatory Agenda and annual Statement of Regulatory and Deregulatory Priorities (both are available on www. reginfo.gov); PBGC plans to include an explanation of its review conclusions in information accompanying any such regulatory changes. PBGC will review its final regulatory review plan from time to time or in response to public comment and make appropriate modifications as required to ensure its effectiveness. 5