1. Talking
With Maps
2010
Maps In Motion:
Story Telling With Open
Data
Christopher Osborne
Ito World

2. http://vimeo.com/2598878

4. http://vimeo.com/9182869

15. http://www.ltmuseum.co.uk/collections/

16. http://vimeo.com/11043141

17. ©Thanos
Didangelos

18. "Congestion charging will not reduce
commercial vehicle operations in London
by a single vehicle and will just put up
costs."
Freight Transport Association 2002

19. !"" "#$(#:0,),)5$/#)'(01$2-)3-)$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#D$0&$",5"1,5"'#3$
!
#$%&'()"&*"+,$"-$.+$/0"12+$0.3&0"" ,)$-(0)5#$-)$'"#$:0BD$7-813$/-)',)8#$'-$-B#(0'#$0&$,'$3-#&$0'$B(#&#)'D$
&89M#/'$'-$'"#$V0<-(H&$3#/,&,-)&$-)$'"#$-'"#($B(-B-&#3$/"0)5#&$&#'$$
!"#$#%&'( -8'$,)$'",&$1#0.1#'$
!"" "#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$-.$'"#$/#)'(01$2-)3-)$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#$
! !"" "-&#$1,;,)5$,)$'"#$-(,5,)01$6-)#$0)3$'"#$0&&-/,0'#3$(#&,3#)'&H$3,&/-8)'$
!
7-813$9#$(#:-;#3$0'$'"#$#)3$-.$'"#$/"0(5,)5$30<$-)$=>$?#/#:9#($=@A@$ 6-)#$0(#0&$7-813$/-)',)8#$'-$9#$#1,5,91#$.-($'"#$J#&,3#)'&H$N@O$3,&/-8)'
&-$'"0'$'"#$0(#0$)-$1-)5#($.-(:#3$B0('$-.$'"#$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#$
C$0.'#($'",&$30'#D$'"#(#$7-813$9#$)-$/"0(5#$'-$3(,;#$,)$'"#$%#&'#()$ )&*+,"#-./(0(12$&*3%(#4(356(76%36".(8936.%1#.
*+'#)&,-)$0(#0 !"#$/#)'(01$2-)3-)$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#$70&$,)'(-38/#3$,)$W#9(80(<$
!"" "#$/#)'(01$2-)3-)$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#$7-813$(#'8()$
! =@@XG$Y)$AN$W#9(80(<$=@@Z$,'$70&$#+'#)3#3$7#&'70(3&D$/(#0',)5$0$&,)51#$
&89&'0)',011<$'-$,'&$B(#E#+'#)&,-)$9-8)30(,#&$0&$&"-7)$-)$'"#$:0B$ #)10(5#3$6-)#$,)$7",/"$'"#$&0:#$/"0(5#&D$3,&/-8)'&$0)3$#+#:B',-)&$
-)$B05#$FG$!"#$(#&,3#)'&H$3,&/-8)'$6-)#$7-813$01&-$(#'8()$'-$,'&$$ 0BB1<G$!"#(#$,&$)-$/"0(5#$.-($3(,;,)5$-)$'"#$9-8)30(<$(-03&$0(-8)3$'"#$
B(#E#+'#)&,-)$9-8)30(,#&D$050,)$:0(I#3$-)$'"#$:0B$-)$B05#$F 6-)#$0)3$'"#(#$0(#$01&-$'7-$(-8'#&$'"0'$;#",/1#&$/0)$8&#$'-$/(-&&$'"#$
!"" #&,3#)'&$7"-$1,;#$,)$'"#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$0(#0$K&"03#3$,)$B,)I$-)$'"#$
J 6-)#$38(,)5$/"0(5,)5$"-8(&$7,'"-8'$B0<,)5$0$/"0(5#G$[1#0&#$&##$'"#$$
:0BL$0)3$-'"#($0(#0&$,::#3,0'#1<$03M0/#)'$'-$'"#$9-8)30(<$K&"03#3$,)$ :0B$-)$B05#$FG
B8(B1#L$7-813$/#0&#$'-$9#$#1,5,91#$.-($'"#$J#&,3#)'&H$N@O$3,&/-8)'$0)3$
T&$#+B#/'#3D$'"#$&/"#:#$(#38/#3$'(0..,/$,)$'"#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$0(#0$
30,000 vehicles
7-813$)##3$'-$B0<$'"#$.811$/"0(5#$0.'#($=>$?#/#:9#($=@A@$'-$3(,;#$7,'",)$
9<$0(-8)3$X@D@@@$;#",/1#&$#0/"$30<D$0)3$,),',011<$/-)5#&',-)$,)$'"#$0(#0$
'"#$(#:0,),)5$6-)#$C$'"#$-8'&'0)3,)5$
70&$(#38/#3G$8'$7",1#$'(0..,/$;-18:#&$(#:0,)$7#11$9#1-7$'"-&#$&##)$
9010)/#$.-($0)<$3,&/-8)'#3$/"0(5#$
9#.-(#$'"#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$70&$,)'(-38/#3D$-'"#($/"0)5#&D$,)/183,)5$
B0<:#)'&$0.'#($'"0'$30'#$7-813$9#$
&,5),.,/0)'$3#;#1-B:#)'$0)3$(-03$7-(I&D$"0;#$:#0)'$'"0'$/-)5#&',-)$$
(#.8)3#3$08'-:0',/011<G$P'$&"-813$9#$
"0&$,)/(#0&#3$050,)$K'"-85"$,'$7-813$"0;#$9##)$7-(&#$,)$'"#$09&#)/#$$
)-'#3$'"0'$'"#(#$,&$)-$/"0(5#$B0<091#$
-.$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5LG$
.(-:$4"(,&':0&$?0<$'-$Q#7$R#0(H&$?0<$
reduced emissions..
,)/18&,;#D$&-$'"#$.,(&'$/"0(5,)5$30<$0.'#($ !"#$&/"#:#$"0&$"#1B#3$'-$(#38/#$#:,&&,-)&$-.$/1,:0'#$/"0)5#$50&#&$$
'"#$B(-B-&#3$(#:-;01$-.$'"#$$ 0)3$#);,(-):#)'01$B-118'0)'&$.(-:$;#",/1#&$0)3$#)/-8(05#3$B#-B1#$
%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$0(#0$7-813$9#$ '(0;#11,)5$,)$'"#$0(#0$'-$8&#$B891,/$'(0)&B-('D$-($'-$701I$-($/</1#G$$
!8#&30<$>$S0)80(<$=@AA
!"" )<-)#$7"-$)-$1-)5#($(#U8,(#3$0$:-)'"1<$-($0))801$/"0(5#$7",/"$'"#<$
T encouraged walking, cycling
P'$"0&$01&-$(0,&#3$)#'$(#;#)8#&$'"0'$"0;#$9##)$8&#3$'-$&8BB-('$'"#$
V0<-(H&$!(0)&B-('$]'(0'#5<G$
"03$B8(/"0&#3$9#/08&#$'"#<$3(,;#$,)$'"#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$0(#0$/-813$ ^-7#;#(D$/-)/#()&$"0;#$9##)$(0,&#3$09-8'$'"#$,:B0/'&$-.$'"#$%#&'#()$
0BB1<$'-$"0;#$'"#$-8'&'0)3,)5$9010)/#$-)$'"#&#$03;0)/#$B0<:#)'&$ *+'#)&,-)$-)$'"#$1-/01$#/-)-:<$0)3$-)$B#-B1#$1,;,)5$,)$'"#$6-)#G
(#.8)3#3G$T)<-)#$7"-$"03$B8(/"0&#3$0$7##I1<$/"0(5#$,)$03;0)/#$/-813$
0BB1<$'-$"0;#$'",&$B0<:#)'$(#.8)3#3$B(-;,3#3$)-$B0('$-.$'"#$7##I$"03$
01(#03<$#10B&#3
= X

20. !"#$"%&&'($)*+%),"#,#&-.)*#)"%/#0%)*+%)1%&*%"()23*%(&'#( )*3"<3"<#>2*=0*5#'.%#>:*'.%*#3(&8%(%"'0'32"#2>#;2(&:'%*S2&'3(36%5#'*0>>3;#
!"#$%&'%()%*#+,,-#'.%#/012*#3"43'%5#6'07%.285%*69#):63"%66%6#0"5# 63<"0869#'.%#3"'*25:;'32"#2>#'.%#/012*P6#G1;8%#T3*%#6;.%(%9#'.%#"%=#*205#
'.%#&:)83;#'2#<34%#'.%3*#43%=6#2"#2&'32"6#>2*#'.%#>:':*%#2>#'.%#?%6'%*"# =2*76#&%*(3'#6;.%(%#0"5#;2"'3":%5#6;.228#0"5#=2*7&80;%#'*04%8#&80""3"<B
@A'%"632"B#C.%#(0D2*3'1#2>#'.26%#*%6&2"53"<#'2#'.0'#3">2*(08#;2"6:8'0'32"# E8'.2:<.#C>F#%6'3(0'%6#62(%#3";*%06%#3"#;2"<%6'32"#36#6'388#837%81#'2#0*36%9#
>042:*%5#3'6#*%(2408B '.36#6.2:85#)%#6%'#0<03"6'#'.%#3(&2*'0";%#'.0'#):63"%66%6#0"5#3"53435:086#
C.%#/012*#3";8:5%5#'.%#&*2&2608#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#3"## &80;%#2"#0;;%66#'2#'.%#0*%0#)1#&*340'%#'*0"6&2*'#0"5#'.%#3(&0;'#2"#'.%#
.36#5*0>'#C*0"6&2*'#$'*0'%<1B#E<03"#'.%#(0D2*3'1#2>#'.26%#=.2#*%6&2"5%5# 82;08#%;2"2(1B
=%*%#6:&&2*'34%#2>#'.%#&*2&2608#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"9# $2(%#6(088#*%5:;'32"6#3"#;2"<%6'32"#0*%#%A&%;'%5#3"#'.%#2*3<3"08#;%"'*08#
*0363"<#63(380*#;2";%*"6#'2#'.26%#(%"'32"%5#0)24%B#!"#83<.'#2>#'.369#'.%# F2"52"#G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#N2"%#06#0#*%6:8'#2>#'.%#*%(2408#2>#'.%#
/012*#052&'%5#'.%#&*2&2608#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#3"#.36# ?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"B
&:)836.%5#C*0"6&2*'#$'*0'%<1B
8'(-(6'-.)'/,-6*&)#5)"%/#0'($)*+%)1%&*%"()23*%(&'#(
C.%#;2"6:8'0'32"#'.0'#C>F#36#"2=#:"5%*'073"<#2"#)%.08>#2>#'.%#/012*#
C.%#*%(2408#2>#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#=2:85#*%6:8'#3"#0#*%5:;'32"#2>#
-£55m pa
*%&*%6%"'6#'.%#"%A'#6'0<%#3"#'.%#8%<08#&*2;%66#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#
UVV(#&%*#1%0*#3"#"%'#*%4%":%#>2*#C>FB#?.386'#'.%*%#=2:85#)%#0#*%5:;'32"#
@A'%"632"B#C.%#/012*#36#&*2&263"<#'2#;.0"<%#'.%#G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#
3"#3";2(%#>2*#C>F9#'.26%#=.2#;:**%"'81#&01#'.%#;.0*<%#'2#5*34%#3"#'.%#
$;.%(%#H*5%*#I'.%#8%<08#52;:(%"'#'.0'#5%>3"%6#'.%#=01#'.0'#'.%#
N2"%#=388#"2#82"<%*#.04%#'2#&01B#C.%*%#0*%#0862#6(088%*#2"%S2>>#;26'6#'2#
G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#6;.%(%#2&%*0'%6J#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#
C>F#0662;30'%5#=3'.#*%(243"<#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#6:;.#06#*%(243"<#
@A'%"632"#0'#'.%#%"5#2>#'.%#;.0*<3"<#501#2"#+K#L%;%()%*#+,M,B##
63<"0<%#0"5#%W:3&(%"'B
!>9#2";%#.%#.06#;2"635%*%5#'.%#43%=6#*036%5#3"#*%6&2"6%#'2#'.36#
;2"6:8'0'32"9#.%#5%;35%6#'2#;2">3*(#'.%#;.0"<%69#'.%"#'.%##
2(0'"#(/%(*-.)'/,-6*&)#5)"%/#0'($)*+%)1%&*%"()23*%(&'#(
G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#N2"%#=2:85#*%4%*'#'2#'.%#)2:"50*1#6.2="##
2"#'.%#(0&#2"#&0<%#-9#0"5#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#0"5#0662;30'%5# C.%#&*3(0*1#>2;:6#2>#'.%#G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#6;.%(%#.06#08=016##
O%635%"'6P#Q,R#536;2:"'#=2:85#;%06%#'2#2&%*0'%#>*2(#'.0'#50'%B# )%%"#'2#'0;78%#;2"<%6'32"#0"5#*%5:;%#'*0>>3;B#O%80'%5#*%5:;'32"6#3"#'.%#
%(36632"6#2>#03*#&288:'0"'6#>*2(#4%.3;8%6#3"#'.%#N2"%#.04%#)%%"#=%8;2(%59#
4"-55'6)-(7)6#($%&*'#()'/,-6*&)#5)"%/#0'($)) ):'#.04%#)%%"#;2(&0*0'34%81#6(088#0"5#.04%#"2'#*%6:8'%5#3"#53*%;'#
*+%)1%&*%"()23*%(&'#( (%06:*0)8%#3(&*24%(%"'6#3"#03*#W:083'1#)%;0:6%#2>#'.%#%>>%;'#2>#2'.%*#
>0;'2*6B#G2**%6&2"53"<81#08'.2:<.#C>F#%6'3(0'%6#'.0'#%(36632"6#2>#X/!"#
C>FP6#0"081636#6:<<%6'6#'.0'#*%(243"<#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#=2:85#8%05#
>*2(#'*0>>3;#3"#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#(3<.'#3";*%06%#)1#62(%#YBVR#0"5#
'2#62(%#3";*%06%#3"#'*0>>3;#0"5#;2"<%6'32"#3"#'.%#0*%09#=.%"#62(%#5*34%*6#
%(36632"6#2>#ZHA#)1#62(%#+R9#'.%#*%(2408#2>#'.%#N2"%#=2:85#"2'#)%#
5%'%**%5#)1#'.%#;.0*<%#*%':*"#'2#'.%#N2"%B#
%A&%;'%5#'2#*%6:8'#3"#0#(%06:*0)8%#5%'%*32*0'32"#2>#03*#W:083'1B
/%06:*%6#'.0'#6.2:85#.%8&#'2#(3'3<0'%#'.%6%#3(&0;'6#2>#*%(243"<#'.%#
?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#3";8:5%#0#<%"%*08#*%43%=#2>#63<"08#'3(3"<6#06#=%88#06#
K V

21. !"#$%&'(")*+&","*#,"*-".",#(*
/(#$$"0*1"#-2,"-*%&'3&*%'((*&"(/*
,"023"*"1'--'4$-*'$*+&"*5"-+",$*
67+"$-'4$*#,"#*#$0*#3,4--*84$04$9*
:4,*"7#1/(")*"1'--'4$-*-+#$0#,0-*;4,*
('<&+*<440-*."&'3("-*#$0*1'$'=2-"-*
#,"*/,4/4-"0*+4*="*'$3(20"0*'$*+&"*
84%*61'--'4$*>4$"*-3&"1"*'$*?@A?)*
#$0*'+*'-*#$+'3'/#+"0*+&#+*4%$",-*
#$0*4/",#+4,-*%42(0*-""B*+4*1""+*
+&"*,"C2',"0*"1'--'4$-*-+#$0#,0-*'$*
#0.#$3"9*D&"*84%*61'--'4$*>4$"*
"1'--'4$-*-+#$0#,0-*;4,*=2-"-)*
34#3&"-*#$0*&"#.E*<440-*."&'3("-*
#,"*#(-4*02"*+4*="*+'<&+"$"0*'$*?@A?)*
;2,+&",*,"023'$<*"1'--'4$-*4;*#',*
/4((2+#$+-9*F+&",*1"#-2,"-*'$*+&"*
!#E4,G-*0,#;+*H',*I2#('+E*J+,#+"<E)*
-23&*#-*'1/,4."1"$+-*+4*+&"*"$.',4$1"$+#(*/",;4,1#$3"*4;*+&"*84$04$* D&,42<&*'+-*/,'1#,E*;432-*4$*,"023'$<*34$<"-+'4$*=E*,"023'$<*+,#;;'3)*+&"*
=2-*;(""+*#$0*+#7'-*%42(0*#(-4*&"(/*+4*'1/,4."*#',*C2#('+E9* K4$<"-+'4$*K&#,<'$<*-3&"1"*&#-*=,42<&+*,"023+'4$-*'$*KF?*"1'--'4$-*
;,41*,4#0*+,#$-/4,+*'$*+&"*L4$"9*H334,0'$<(E)*="3#2-"*,"14.'$<*+&"*
5"-+",$*67+"$-'4$*%42(0*="*"7/"3+"0*+4*'$3,"#-"*+,#;;'3*#$0*34$<"-+'4$*
'$*+&#+*#,"#)*#$*'$3,"#-"*'$*KF?*"1'--'4$-*;,41*,4#0*+,#$-/4,+*'$*+&"*
L4$"*4;*#,42$0*MN*'-*('B"(E9*H3+'4$*'-*="'$<*+#B"$*4$*#*84$04$O%'0"*
=#-'-*+4*+#3B("*3('1#+"*3&#$<"*+&,42<&*1"#-2,"-*-"+*42+*'$*+&"*!#E4,G-*
0,#;+*K('1#+"*K&#$<"*!'+'<#+'4$*#$0*6$",<E*J+,#+"<E*#$0*4+&",*1"#-2,"-*
'$*+&"*!#E4,G-*D,#$-/4,+*J+,#+"<E9*D&"-"*'$3(20"*-2//4,+'$<*#*-&';+*+4*
14,"*";;'3'"$+*140"-*4;*+,#$-/4,+)*'1/,4.'$<*4/",#+'4$#(*";;'3'"$3E)*
#$0*-+'12(#+'$<*+&"*0"."(4/1"$+*#$0*2-"*4;*(4%*3#,=4$*."&'3("-*-23&*
#-*"("3+,'3*#$0*/(2<O'$*&E=,'0*"("3+,'3*."&'3("-9*!4,"*'$;4,1#+'4$*4$*
+&"*/,4/4-"0*,"14.#(*4;*+&"*5"-+",$*67+"$-'4$*#$0*'+-*('B"(E*'1/#3+-)*
'$3(20'$<*+&4-"*4$*+&"*"$.',4$1"$+)*3#$*="*;42$0*#+*!!"#$%#$&!#'
P Q

22. 4+(A$:#'+(14D"&A'(A1R+($1,">
3
A5
9+.:.0"/($+"$(.;(+"#.<$,(=
50
!"#$%&%&'()"&*+$,(-.&/.& A.8&/$+?(.;().&'"0*%.&()1$+'%&'(2.&"
02
A
!"0%/"&*03(456(/%07.8&* ).&'"0*%.&()1$+'%&'(2.&" $;*"+(B"0*"+&(CD*"&0%.&(+"#.<$,
>.8,/(&.(,.&'"+($::,?
!"#$%&%&'($//%*%.&$, 05
E$%&(+.$/0(>%*1%&(71$+'%&'(2.&"
A52
A5 20 0
A 5 2 03
@//%*%.&$,(+"0%/"&*03(456 +"0%/"&*03(456 ?+(0+(
/%07.8&*($+"$(=(/%07.8&* /%07.8&*($+"$ F&71$+'"/(+.$/0
@++
4
A10
10
>.8,/(&.(,.&'"+($::,?
A
A1
;'(AB:14&+:: P:)'(A#+( ."*3($/
%&$(# "(016#C12"(*&":
;$(:")1<&$$( K$A$(#B: 6#"#'+(:
SCR UBS
ED
2"&3 6D+&$0'#*D
A4
4",0$( N'(:98&/
GW
;$(:")1<&$$( AD
1
AR
4$,$#$&/ O
NR
ER
H A RR O
ST
LA .
OW
EU
OA
RO I"&/)$9+($
D
AD
1
?'H$&>++)
A 520
A5
A404 A501 6#&$$#
7+&,-++0
NE ROAD %)++,:98&/ 4)$&3$(-$)) !+-$&
6*&89: EBO 6#"#'+(
M+&#D A40 M A RY L !$)$*+, .",)$#:
A2 1
;$(:'(A#+( A 2"00'(A#+( 4'#/1+O
!+-$&
Y
TW 6#"#'+(
9
W ES ?+(0+(
TREET 4+H$(# .+)9+&(
LAD
DS
I"&9)$ OXFOR <"&0$(
A 40 6+D+ 6#C12"8)B:
BRO
M+##'(A %"/:-"#$& J&*D
WE S T C
.')) 4"#D$0&")
KE G
R OAD
ATER
BAYSW 2'**"0'))/
PA 4 20
ROV
6D$>D$&0B: ?+(0+(
RO S
I"/O"'&
RK
%8:D ;$(:'(A#+( 4'#/1+O 4'&*8: 6+8#D-"&3 %&'0A$ !+-$&
A
E
LA
SR
UXBRIDGE ROAD <"&0$(: 7$:#,'(:#$& 6#"#'+( %&'0A$
6#C
NE
A 4 02 0
2
s
OU
Thame
<&$$( L",$:B:
;$(:'(A#+(1G
TE
./0$12"&3 2"&3 6#C1L",$:B: %+&+8AD
4D$):$" GH STREE
A3
./0$12"&3 2"&3 7"#$&)++
2 20
A4 0 2 HI T
A 219
TO N 4+&($& 6#"#'+(
OAD IN G ;('AD#:9&'0A$ AD
R iv er
RO
KR NS
HAW KE ;$(:'(A#+(
GOLD
N
.",,$&:,'#D1G
TO
EAR
RO MP 5'*#+&'" 7$:#,'(:#$&
N8)D", =)/,>'" A4 B
L’S
AD 6#"#'+( !"#$
W
ELL RO %&+,>#+(
R OM W V A %&'#"'(
A321 6
AR
E)$>D"(#1G
CO
A315 IC C 6+8#D %$)A&"H'" BR UX
W
UR
A2
K ID HA 4":#)$
RO
TR
AD
;$(:'(A#+( 4D$):$" GE L 6+8#D-"&3
A4 AD L
OA
TALGARTH R O A D D 5"8FD"))
RO A 2',)'*+ R D .
A2
D
PT O N R
O
%&'0A$
15
E"&)B:14+8&# ROM M AD
4
EFD'9'#'+( OLD B A
20
.",,$&:,'#D LH RO A3
2
21
3
FU
A3
%&'0A$ ’ S GROSVEN O R R O A D A
4$(#&$ NG SEA
KI CH E L K M E N T
A3
BAN 4D$):$" !D$1=H")
22
%&+,>#+( EM
0
DAW 12
4$,$#$&/ A 32 J)9$&# %&'0A$
U
LN A
%&'0A$ 5
ES
ROA D 20
FUL HA M R D. A3
CASTE
A203
%"##$&:$"
%&'0A$ 7"(0:-+&#D
A2
A23
6
03
19
A3
A3
A202
A308 ?",9$#D
16
%"##$&:$"
A215
A2
! "
A 32
17
Q1!&"(:>+&#1O+&1?+(0+(

23. http://www.flickr.com/photos/itolabs/sets/72157622542739701/

27. 31st July 2002:
The High Court dismisses Westminster
Council’s appeal against the Congestion
Charge

30. “Westminster council claimed congestion
charges would push traffic out to
surrounding areas, increasing air pollution
and breaching residents' human rights by
adversely affecting the quality of city life.”
BBC News 2002

33. http://vimeo.com/12269024

35. !"" "#$(#:0,),)5$/#)'(01$2-)3-)$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#D$0&$",5"1,5"'#3$
!
#$%&'()"&*"+,$"-$.+$/0"12+$0.3&0"" ,)$-(0)5#$-)$'"#$:0BD$7-813$/-)',)8#$'-$-B#(0'#$0&$,'$3-#&$0'$B(#&#)'D$
&89M#/'$'-$'"#$V0<-(H&$3#/,&,-)&$-)$'"#$-'"#($B(-B-&#3$/"0)5#&$&#'$$
!"#$#%&'( -8'$,)$'",&$1#0.1#'$
!"" "#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$-.$'"#$/#)'(01$2-)3-)$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#$
! !"" "-&#$1,;,)5$,)$'"#$-(,5,)01$6-)#$0)3$'"#$0&&-/,0'#3$(#&,3#)'&H$3,&/-8)'$
!
7-813$9#$(#:-;#3$0'$'"#$#)3$-.$'"#$/"0(5,)5$30<$-)$=>$?#/#:9#($=@A@$ 6-)#$0(#0&$7-813$/-)',)8#$'-$9#$#1,5,91#$.-($'"#$J#&,3#)'&H$N@O$3,&/-8)'
&-$'"0'$'"#$0(#0$)-$1-)5#($.-(:#3$B0('$-.$'"#$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#$
C$0.'#($'",&$30'#D$'"#(#$7-813$9#$)-$/"0(5#$'-$3(,;#$,)$'"#$%#&'#()$ )&*+,"#-./(0(12$&*3%(#4(356(76%36".(8936.%1#.
*+'#)&,-)$0(#0 !"#$/#)'(01$2-)3-)$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#$70&$,)'(-38/#3$,)$W#9(80(<$
!"" "#$/#)'(01$2-)3-)$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5$6-)#$7-813$(#'8()$
! =@@XG$Y)$AN$W#9(80(<$=@@Z$,'$70&$#+'#)3#3$7#&'70(3&D$/(#0',)5$0$&,)51#$
&89&'0)',011<$'-$,'&$B(#E#+'#)&,-)$9-8)30(,#&$0&$&"-7)$-)$'"#$:0B$ #)10(5#3$6-)#$,)$7",/"$'"#$&0:#$/"0(5#&D$3,&/-8)'&$0)3$#+#:B',-)&$
-)$B05#$FG$!"#$(#&,3#)'&H$3,&/-8)'$6-)#$7-813$01&-$(#'8()$'-$,'&$$ 0BB1<G$!"#(#$,&$)-$/"0(5#$.-($3(,;,)5$-)$'"#$9-8)30(<$(-03&$0(-8)3$'"#$
B(#E#+'#)&,-)$9-8)30(,#&D$050,)$:0(I#3$-)$'"#$:0B$-)$B05#$F 6-)#$0)3$'"#(#$0(#$01&-$'7-$(-8'#&$'"0'$;#",/1#&$/0)$8&#$'-$/(-&&$'"#$
!"" #&,3#)'&$7"-$1,;#$,)$'"#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$0(#0$K&"03#3$,)$B,)I$-)$'"#$
J 6-)#$38(,)5$/"0(5,)5$"-8(&$7,'"-8'$B0<,)5$0$/"0(5#G$[1#0&#$&##$'"#$$
:0BL$0)3$-'"#($0(#0&$,::#3,0'#1<$03M0/#)'$'-$'"#$9-8)30(<$K&"03#3$,)$ :0B$-)$B05#$FG
B8(B1#L$7-813$/#0&#$'-$9#$#1,5,91#$.-($'"#$J#&,3#)'&H$N@O$3,&/-8)'$0)3$
T&$#+B#/'#3D$'"#$&/"#:#$(#38/#3$'(0..,/$,)$'"#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$0(#0$
7-813$)##3$'-$B0<$'"#$.811$/"0(5#$0.'#($=>$?#/#:9#($=@A@$'-$3(,;#$7,'",)$
9<$0(-8)3$X@D@@@$;#",/1#&$#0/"$30<D$0)3$,),',011<$/-)5#&',-)$,)$'"#$0(#0$
'"#$(#:0,),)5$6-)#$C$'"#$-8'&'0)3,)5$
70&$(#38/#3G$8'$7",1#$'(0..,/$;-18:#&$(#:0,)$7#11$9#1-7$'"-&#$&##)$
9010)/#$.-($0)<$3,&/-8)'#3$/"0(5#$
9#.-(#$'"#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$70&$,)'(-38/#3D$-'"#($/"0)5#&D$,)/183,)5$
B0<:#)'&$0.'#($'"0'$30'#$7-813$9#$
&,5),.,/0)'$3#;#1-B:#)'$0)3$(-03$7-(I&D$"0;#$:#0)'$'"0'$/-)5#&',-)$$
(#.8)3#3$08'-:0',/011<G$P'$&"-813$9#$
"0&$,)/(#0&#3$050,)$K'"-85"$,'$7-813$"0;#$9##)$7-(&#$,)$'"#$09&#)/#$$
)-'#3$'"0'$'"#(#$,&$)-$/"0(5#$B0<091#$
-.$4-)5#&',-)$4"0(5,)5LG$
.(-:$4"(,&':0&$?0<$'-$Q#7$R#0(H&$?0<$
,)/18&,;#D$&-$'"#$.,(&'$/"0(5,)5$30<$0.'#($ !"#$&/"#:#$"0&$"#1B#3$'-$(#38/#$#:,&&,-)&$-.$/1,:0'#$/"0)5#$50&#&$$
'"#$B(-B-&#3$(#:-;01$-.$'"#$$ 0)3$#);,(-):#)'01$B-118'0)'&$.(-:$;#",/1#&$0)3$#)/-8(05#3$B#-B1#$
%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$0(#0$7-813$9#$ '(0;#11,)5$,)$'"#$0(#0$'-$8&#$B891,/$'(0)&B-('D$-($'-$701I$-($/</1#G$$
!8#&30<$>$S0)80(<$=@AA P'$"0&$01&-$(0,&#3$)#'$(#;#)8#&$'"0'$"0;#$9##)$8&#3$'-$&8BB-('$'"#$
!"" )<-)#$7"-$)-$1-)5#($(#U8,(#3$0$:-)'"1<$-($0))801$/"0(5#$7",/"$'"#<$
T V0<-(H&$!(0)&B-('$]'(0'#5<G$
"03$B8(/"0&#3$9#/08&#$'"#<$3(,;#$,)$'"#$%#&'#()$*+'#)&,-)$0(#0$/-813$ ^-7#;#(D$/-)/#()&$"0;#$9##)$(0,&#3$09-8'$'"#$,:B0/'&$-.$'"#$%#&'#()$
0BB1<$'-$"0;#$'"#$-8'&'0)3,)5$9010)/#$-)$'"#&#$03;0)/#$B0<:#)'&$ *+'#)&,-)$-)$'"#$1-/01$#/-)-:<$0)3$-)$B#-B1#$1,;,)5$,)$'"#$6-)#G
(#.8)3#3G$T)<-)#$7"-$"03$B8(/"0&#3$0$7##I1<$/"0(5#$,)$03;0)/#$/-813$
0BB1<$'-$"0;#$'",&$B0<:#)'$(#.8)3#3$B(-;,3#3$)-$B0('$-.$'"#$7##I$"03$
01(#03<$#10B&#3
= X

36. !"#$"%&&'($)*+%),"#,#&-.)*#)"%/#0%)*+%)1%&*%"()23*%(&'#( )*3"<3"<#>2*=0*5#'.%#>:*'.%*#3(&8%(%"'0'32"#2>#;2(&:'%*S2&'3(36%5#'*0>>3;#
!"#$%&'%()%*#+,,-#'.%#/012*#3"43'%5#6'07%.285%*69#):63"%66%6#0"5# 63<"0869#'.%#3"'*25:;'32"#2>#'.%#/012*P6#G1;8%#T3*%#6;.%(%9#'.%#"%=#*205#
'.%#&:)83;#'2#<34%#'.%3*#43%=6#2"#2&'32"6#>2*#'.%#>:':*%#2>#'.%#?%6'%*"# =2*76#&%*(3'#6;.%(%#0"5#;2"'3":%5#6;.228#0"5#=2*7&80;%#'*04%8#&80""3"<B
@A'%"632"B#C.%#(0D2*3'1#2>#'.26%#*%6&2"53"<#'2#'.0'#3">2*(08#;2"6:8'0'32"# E8'.2:<.#C>F#%6'3(0'%6#62(%#3";*%06%#3"#;2"<%6'32"#36#6'388#837%81#'2#0*36%9#
>042:*%5#3'6#*%(2408B '.36#6.2:85#)%#6%'#0<03"6'#'.%#3(&2*'0";%#'.0'#):63"%66%6#0"5#3"53435:086#
C.%#/012*#3";8:5%5#'.%#&*2&2608#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#3"## &80;%#2"#0;;%66#'2#'.%#0*%0#)1#&*340'%#'*0"6&2*'#0"5#'.%#3(&0;'#2"#'.%#
.36#5*0>'#C*0"6&2*'#$'*0'%<1B#E<03"#'.%#(0D2*3'1#2>#'.26%#=.2#*%6&2"5%5# 82;08#%;2"2(1B
=%*%#6:&&2*'34%#2>#'.%#&*2&2608#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"9# $2(%#6(088#*%5:;'32"6#3"#;2"<%6'32"#0*%#%A&%;'%5#3"#'.%#2*3<3"08#;%"'*08#
*0363"<#63(380*#;2";%*"6#'2#'.26%#(%"'32"%5#0)24%B#!"#83<.'#2>#'.369#'.%# F2"52"#G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#N2"%#06#0#*%6:8'#2>#'.%#*%(2408#2>#'.%#
/012*#052&'%5#'.%#&*2&2608#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#3"#.36# ?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"B
&:)836.%5#C*0"6&2*'#$'*0'%<1B
8'(-(6'-.)'/,-6*&)#5)"%/#0'($)*+%)1%&*%"()23*%(&'#(
C.%#;2"6:8'0'32"#'.0'#C>F#36#"2=#:"5%*'073"<#2"#)%.08>#2>#'.%#/012*#
C.%#*%(2408#2>#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#=2:85#*%6:8'#3"#0#*%5:;'32"#2>#
*%&*%6%"'6#'.%#"%A'#6'0<%#3"#'.%#8%<08#&*2;%66#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#
UVV(#&%*#1%0*#3"#"%'#*%4%":%#>2*#C>FB#?.386'#'.%*%#=2:85#)%#0#*%5:;'32"#
@A'%"632"B#C.%#/012*#36#&*2&263"<#'2#;.0"<%#'.%#G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#
3"#3";2(%#>2*#C>F9#'.26%#=.2#;:**%"'81#&01#'.%#;.0*<%#'2#5*34%#3"#'.%#
$;.%(%#H*5%*#I'.%#8%<08#52;:(%"'#'.0'#5%>3"%6#'.%#=01#'.0'#'.%#
N2"%#=388#"2#82"<%*#.04%#'2#&01B#C.%*%#0*%#0862#6(088%*#2"%S2>>#;26'6#'2#
G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#6;.%(%#2&%*0'%6J#'2#*%(24%#'.%#?%6'%*"#
C>F#0662;30'%5#=3'.#*%(243"<#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#6:;.#06#*%(243"<#
@A'%"632"#0'#'.%#%"5#2>#'.%#;.0*<3"<#501#2"#+K#L%;%()%*#+,M,B##
63<"0<%#0"5#%W:3&(%"'B
!>9#2";%#.%#.06#;2"635%*%5#'.%#43%=6#*036%5#3"#*%6&2"6%#'2#'.36#
;2"6:8'0'32"9#.%#5%;35%6#'2#;2">3*(#'.%#;.0"<%69#'.%"#'.%##
2(0'"#(/%(*-.)'/,-6*&)#5)"%/#0'($)*+%)1%&*%"()23*%(&'#(
G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#N2"%#=2:85#*%4%*'#'2#'.%#)2:"50*1#6.2="##
2"#'.%#(0&#2"#&0<%#-9#0"5#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#0"5#0662;30'%5# C.%#&*3(0*1#>2;:6#2>#'.%#G2"<%6'32"#G.0*<3"<#6;.%(%#.06#08=016##
O%635%"'6P#Q,R#536;2:"'#=2:85#;%06%#'2#2&%*0'%#>*2(#'.0'#50'%B# )%%"#'2#'0;78%#;2"<%6'32"#0"5#*%5:;%#'*0>>3;B#O%80'%5#*%5:;'32"6#3"#'.%#
%(36632"6#2>#03*#&288:'0"'6#>*2(#4%.3;8%6#3"#'.%#N2"%#.04%#)%%"#=%8;2(%59#
4"-55'6)-(7)6#($%&*'#()'/,-6*&)#5)"%/#0'($)) ):'#.04%#)%%"#;2(&0*0'34%81#6(088#0"5#.04%#"2'#*%6:8'%5#3"#53*%;'#
*+%)1%&*%"()23*%(&'#( (%06:*0)8%#3(&*24%(%"'6#3"#03*#W:083'1#)%;0:6%#2>#'.%#%>>%;'#2>#2'.%*#
>0;'2*6B#G2**%6&2"53"<81#08'.2:<.#C>F#%6'3(0'%6#'.0'#%(36632"6#2>#X/!"#
C>FP6#0"081636#6:<<%6'6#'.0'#*%(243"<#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#=2:85#8%05#
>*2(#'*0>>3;#3"#'.%#?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#(3<.'#3";*%06%#)1#62(%#YBVR#0"5#
'2#62(%#3";*%06%#3"#'*0>>3;#0"5#;2"<%6'32"#3"#'.%#0*%09#=.%"#62(%#5*34%*6#
%(36632"6#2>#ZHA#)1#62(%#+R9#'.%#*%(2408#2>#'.%#N2"%#=2:85#"2'#)%#
5%'%**%5#)1#'.%#;.0*<%#*%':*"#'2#'.%#N2"%B#
%A&%;'%5#'2#*%6:8'#3"#0#(%06:*0)8%#5%'%*32*0'32"#2>#03*#W:083'1B
/%06:*%6#'.0'#6.2:85#.%8&#'2#(3'3<0'%#'.%6%#3(&0;'6#2>#*%(243"<#'.%#
?%6'%*"#@A'%"632"#3";8:5%#0#<%"%*08#*%43%=#2>#63<"08#'3(3"<6#06#=%88#06#
K V

37. !"#$%&'(")*+&","*#,"*-".",#(*
/(#$$"0*1"#-2,"-*%&'3&*%'((*&"(/*
,"023"*"1'--'4$-*'$*+&"*5"-+",$*
67+"$-'4$*#,"#*#$0*#3,4--*84$04$9*
:4,*"7#1/(")*"1'--'4$-*-+#$0#,0-*;4,*
('<&+*<440-*."&'3("-*#$0*1'$'=2-"-*
#,"*/,4/4-"0*+4*="*'$3(20"0*'$*+&"*
84%*61'--'4$*>4$"*-3&"1"*'$*?@A?)*
#$0*'+*'-*#$+'3'/#+"0*+&#+*4%$",-*
#$0*4/",#+4,-*%42(0*-""B*+4*1""+*
+&"*,"C2',"0*"1'--'4$-*-+#$0#,0-*'$*
#0.#$3"9*D&"*84%*61'--'4$*>4$"*
"1'--'4$-*-+#$0#,0-*;4,*=2-"-)*
34#3&"-*#$0*&"#.E*<440-*."&'3("-*
#,"*#(-4*02"*+4*="*+'<&+"$"0*'$*?@A?)*
;2,+&",*,"023'$<*"1'--'4$-*4;*#',*
/4((2+#$+-9*F+&",*1"#-2,"-*'$*+&"*
!#E4,G-*0,#;+*H',*I2#('+E*J+,#+"<E)*
-23&*#-*'1/,4."1"$+-*+4*+&"*"$.',4$1"$+#(*/",;4,1#$3"*4;*+&"*84$04$* D&,42<&*'+-*/,'1#,E*;432-*4$*,"023'$<*34$<"-+'4$*=E*,"023'$<*+,#;;'3)*+&"*
=2-*;(""+*#$0*+#7'-*%42(0*#(-4*&"(/*+4*'1/,4."*#',*C2#('+E9* K4$<"-+'4$*K&#,<'$<*-3&"1"*&#-*=,42<&+*,"023+'4$-*'$*KF?*"1'--'4$-*
;,41*,4#0*+,#$-/4,+*'$*+&"*L4$"9*H334,0'$<(E)*="3#2-"*,"14.'$<*+&"*
5"-+",$*67+"$-'4$*%42(0*="*"7/"3+"0*+4*'$3,"#-"*+,#;;'3*#$0*34$<"-+'4$*
'$*+&#+*#,"#)*#$*'$3,"#-"*'$*KF?*"1'--'4$-*;,41*,4#0*+,#$-/4,+*'$*+&"*
L4$"*4;*#,42$0*MN*'-*('B"(E9*H3+'4$*'-*="'$<*+#B"$*4$*#*84$04$O%'0"*
=#-'-*+4*+#3B("*3('1#+"*3&#$<"*+&,42<&*1"#-2,"-*-"+*42+*'$*+&"*!#E4,G-*
0,#;+*K('1#+"*K&#$<"*!'+'<#+'4$*#$0*6$",<E*J+,#+"<E*#$0*4+&",*1"#-2,"-*
'$*+&"*!#E4,G-*D,#$-/4,+*J+,#+"<E9*D&"-"*'$3(20"*-2//4,+'$<*#*-&';+*+4*
14,"*";;'3'"$+*140"-*4;*+,#$-/4,+)*'1/,4.'$<*4/",#+'4$#(*";;'3'"$3E)*
#$0*-+'12(#+'$<*+&"*0"."(4/1"$+*#$0*2-"*4;*(4%*3#,=4$*."&'3("-*-23&*
#-*"("3+,'3*#$0*/(2<O'$*&E=,'0*"("3+,'3*."&'3("-9*!4,"*'$;4,1#+'4$*4$*
+&"*/,4/4-"0*,"14.#(*4;*+&"*5"-+",$*67+"$-'4$*#$0*'+-*('B"(E*'1/#3+-)*
'$3(20'$<*+&4-"*4$*+&"*"$.',4$1"$+)*3#$*="*;42$0*#+*!!"#$%#$&!#'
P Q