2. Additional VoC Lessons
Opt-In Preference-Based
Personalization as a
Competitive Differentiator
153 Step 2: Opt-In Engagement
3. The bar has been raised dramatically for
Even among loyal
online and offline marketers:
customers, expectations
of marketers have • Good customer service is expected and
changed due to:
is a powerful competitive differentiator.
Tough economy
• Increased expectations for value at
Growth of many online
and offline options for
competitive prices.
making purchases:
• Better shipping and handling terms.
• Personalized offers and experiences based
on their individual interests:
“I welcome the targeted
“When I go to the emails, suggestions,
Amazon site, I feel like recommendations. They are
they know what I like.” working to send me only what
I told them was relevant.”
154 Step 2: Opt-In Engagement
4. As a result, customers • Personalization is viewed as a service and
and prospects view
benefit, not just a sales tool.
personalization as
the next step in a
company’s commitment • Online shoppers view personalization as a
to service excellence. requirement for their preferred shopping
venues, rather than as simply a perk.
• Many BtoB decision-makers use Amazon
as their point of reference regarding
expectations for BtoB personalization.
• BtoB and BtoC marketers have to at least
match Amazon!
155 Step 2: Opt-In Engagement
5. Meaningful Personalization
Customers are also savvy regarding the
type of personalization they want.
They want it to be more than just
transaction-based.
“I expect more than just ‘we’ve
looked at everything you’ve bought
over the last X years and this is what
we think you’ll like’. With today’s
technology, I expect much more
than that!”
156 Step 2: Opt-In Engagement
6. Your Top 3 Takeaways?
1.
2.
3.
157 Step 2: Opt-In Engagement
7. Step 2
Step 2: Summary
Opt-In Opt-in is not about passively agreeing to receive email.
Engagement It’s about actively opting in to a relationship and self-
profiling your preferences and aversions.
Your VoC-based opt-in database should include at least,
the following information regarding individual’s:
• Needs
How to Create
• Decision making process
Powerful Opt-In
• Offer
Databases to
• Message
Drive High Impact
• Timing
Personalization
• Media Preferences.
Strategies
Set as your goal: Opt-In rates ranging from 80% to 95%.
158 Step 2: Opt-In Engagement
8. Step 2
Step 2: Summary
Opt-In Five Ways to Win Consumer Confidence:
Engagement
1. Consumers have to trust that the company will
adequately safeguard their information and use it
in a responsible way.
2. “Responsible” means that consumers must believe
that their information will not be rented or sold.
How to Create
3. “Honor my preferences” reflects the expectation
Powerful Opt-In that their “Opt-In” self-profiled preferences will be
Databases to used to drive increasingly targeted communications
Drive High Impact and offers... and suppress those that are not
Personalization relevant per the expressed preferences of
individual customers.
Strategies
159 Step 2: Opt-In Engagement
9. Step 2
Step 2: Summary
Opt-In 4. The value consumers receive in exchange for
Engagement providing in-depth information must be obvious
and compelling. Consumers must see an obvious
improvement in relevance. Applies both to online
and offline experiences.
If the value is not obvious, consumers will assume
you have betrayed their trust and expectations.
How to Create
Powerful Opt-In 5. Consumers must see proof that the company will
Databases to be able to deliver on requirements 1 through 4
Drive High Impact above, not just once, but consistently over time.
Personalization
Strategies
160 Step 2: Opt-In Engagement
14. Step 3:
How to Use the 5 Principles of Multichannel
Marketing
Drawing for 2 Autographed Books:
165 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
15. Step 3: How to Use
the 5 Principles of
Multichannel Marketing
Step 2:
Opt-In
Engagement
Step 1:
VoC
Research
Step 3:
Multichannel
Marketing
166 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
16. On any given day, the
Message Overload
customer will be
exposed to nearly
3,000 media
messages.
They will pay
attention to 52.
They will positively
remember 4.
The chance they will
remember your ad is
0.013%!
D. Mastervich, VP, Sales Strategy, U.S. Postal
Service, VDP Conference Presentation
167 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
17. Multichannel Marketing
Integration
Entire Customer Experience must be integrated:
Must
• Acquisition
Encompass: • Conversion
Message • On-boarding
• Retention
Media mix
• Renewal
Organization
Employee Customer Experience must be integrated:
And…the
Customer Experience • Performance metrics
• Compensation
• Training
• Retention
• Renewal
168 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
18. Multichannel Marketing
Integration
If Integration is so logical…why are so few doing it well?
Must
• Turf
Encompass: • Politics
Message • Fear of change
Media mix
Organization How can you be the agent of change?
And…the
Customer Experience
169 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
19. “Per the DMA,
Let’s Define “Relevance”
93% of marketers
using multiple channels 1. Right message.
have attempted to
integrate their 2. Right time.
messaging.
Only 27.4% of these 3. Right person.
said their efforts
are ‘effective’. . .” 4. Delivered per that individual’s media
DMA Report, “Rowing preferences.
as One: Integrated
Marketing Today,” 4/11
Integrated,
multichannel
irritation!
Without this, all we
have achieved is. . .
170 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
20. Shopper Sentiment: In-Store, Online and
Via Mobile
Online:
• Overall Favorite: 59%
• Easiest: 68%
• Most Convenient: 68%
In-Store:
• Most Reliable: 69%
• Safest: 77%
Mobile:
• Most Convenient: 38%
• Easiest: 27%
• Safety: 7%
(vs. 22% Online)
Nielsenwire 6/6/12
171 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
21. Safeway: Multichannel Innovation
Personalized offers and
prices based on shopper’s
behaviors, habits and profile
information.
“Though use of personal
shopping data might raise
privacy concerns, retailers
are counting on most people
accepting the trade-off, if it
Safeway employee signing up a shopper for
means they get a better custom offers.
price for a product they
want”.
New York Times 8/9/12
172 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
24. Multichannel Marketing
Requires precision timing and synchronization of multiple media
and channels.
Precision integration of traditional and digital media and contact
points.
Per individual’s opt-in
preferences. . .
IDM® is a registered trademark of Ernan Roman Direct Marketing.
175 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
25. 5 Principles of Multichannel Marketing
5
4
3
2
1 1: Start with the Customer (VoC).
176 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
26. Per VoC Findings
Today’s shopper is multi-dimensional;
multi-channel and multi-purpose. Per a recent VoC:
A customer described
Many report using multiple media, often how she likes to watch
at the same time. the TV shows while
browsing the website.
As she finds items to
Alert! purchase, she puts
them in her shopping
The channel used for the purchase is often
not indicative of their shopping habits. cart, prints it, and…
Most used multiple media to shop, calls Customer Service
and often, to purchase. to place
the order.
177 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
27. “. . . Multichannel customers spend Personalized multichannel
two to three times more than communications based on
single-channel shoppers. . . customer’s individual
Consumers who engage with the preferences is a competitive
company across three or more differentiator.
channels spend six times more
than the average customer.” “If I got the information that
was focused on the stuff I
Glen Senk, CEO of Urban Outfitters was interested in, it would
be easier than sorting
through all the products
they have. It would be so
much faster and more
convenient and make
my shopping easier.”
178 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
28. 5 Principles of Multichannel Marketing
5
4
3
2: Create processes for generating feedback from your social
2 media channels and your sales and service reps. This will
provide ongoing qualitative and quantitative VoC guidance.
1 1: Start with the Customer (VoC).
179 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
29. VoC Guidance from CSRs
Based on VoC feedback from Results:
CSR’s, Nordstrom’s upgraded • Immediate customer
their website and inventory adoption.
integration so any item in
• 8% higher sales.
any store (not just
warehouses) is shown on • Fewer markdowns.
their website and shipped to • Better inventory control.
the customer’s nearest • A boost to customer
store, with a notice to the loyalty.
customer. • More add-on store sales.
180 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
31. 2. Select your
item and
method
of delivery
182
Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
32. 3. Select your
location for
pick-up or have
it shipped!
183 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
33. 5 Principles of Multichannel Marketing
5
4
3 3: Synchronize your multichannel mix with
precision and value.
2: Create processes for generating feedback from your social
2 media channels and your sales and service reps. This will
provide ongoing qualitative and quantitative VoC guidance.
1 1: Start with the Customer (VoC).
184 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
36. Multichannel / Multimedia Customers
Per QVC, today’s customers are uniquely Multichannel.
Keep in mind:
• Be accessible when and where the customer chooses.
• The multi-platform approach must be seamless, frictionless,
and agnostic, i.e., every channel must provide a good
customer experience.
• An integrated multi-platform strategy will increase sales.
QVC, 9/23/12
187 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
38. Precision Sequencing and Timing
Web and digital synchronized with beginning of Publicity and continue
Print Email #1/ Outbound Email #2/
Publicity
advertising Mail #1 Calls Mail #2
1 week 1 week 1-24 Per opt-in
hours preferences
after
receipt
189 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
39. Multichannel Marketing
Web:
“Per Forrester…only 3% of sites earned a passing score in terms of the user experience.
3 Reasons:
1. Text legibility and clearly detailed privacy statements. Recommend using 10 to 12 point
dark Sans Searph font against a light background.
2. Menu names aren’t clear and people don’t know where to go.
3. Content and functionality…which are not…based on deep customer research.
“It’s incredibly important to understand your target users…and how you can help them
on your site.”
Per findings by Bronto Software: Poor site usability…among 100 online retail brands results
in an average 70 percent cart abandonment rate.
1 to 1 Media, 5/28/12
190 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
40. Sephora’s Media Integration
Sephora revamped website and mobile apps to integrate in-store and online experiences.
Online searches and purchases are saved to a customer’s profile if they are a member of
Sephora’s loyalty program, Beauty Insider.
“It’s an opt-in service, because Sephora recognizes that not all consumers want to be
tracked. Currently, 20 Sephora stores will have iPads from which store associates
will be able to pull customer data to help them with purchases…
A lot of the information we gathered was from how we would ask for that
information in a store”, Dolan said of the new, targeted online search, adding that
“customers can search across 25 different criteria including age group, SPF, skin type
and more. We have all expertise of Sephora’s staff built into a web interface, and
that’s extremely powerful.”
Bridget Dolan, VP Interactive Media. DM News 4/19/12
191 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
41. Multichannel Marketing
Multichannel
Email:
Success Factors
• “Email may be the base of your communications with
Unless you obtain me, but I’m getting too much junk.”
opt-in message and • “Make it relevant and timely!”
media preferences
and aversions. . . • “And, if it’s really important, send it to me by mail.”
You’ll simply be
engaging in
multichannel
irritation!
192 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
43. From: Daniel Brendler [mailto:D.Brendler@EastHillsChevrolet.onesource1.gmtorque.com]
Sent: Monday, June 28, 2010 11:47 AM
To: ernan@erdm.com
Subject: We received your request for information
Long Island's Premier Chevrolet Dealership!
.
Hello Ernan,
We received your email request for information on the 2010 Corvette, are you interested in purchasing one this month? If so, please
contact me directly for an appointment to discuss your needs.
If you are just looking for information, go to www.chevrolet.com/ (next to the forward slash, fill in the vehicle name, press the space bar and click on
the link).
When you are in the market for a vehicle, please let me know and I will assist you with current incentives and finance options.
Regards,
Danny Brendler
GM Certified Internet Sales Manager
East Hills Chevrolet
DESK: (516)869-8100 X 211
Cell: (516)383-3267
Fax: (516)869-9455
dbrendler@ehchevy.com contactchevydan@gmail.com
194 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
46. From: Carbonite Customer Care [mailto:customer_care@clickemail.carbonite.com]
Sent: Saturday, September 25, 2010 4:37 PM
To: Ernan Roman
Subject: Your initial Carbonite backup is complete
"FEEL GOOD" NEWS!
Your initial Carbonite backup is complete.
Dear Ernan,
Good news: Carbonite has completed your initial online backup for ERNAN-LAPTOP. If you
selected Automatic backup, here's how your backup works:
VoC DRIVEN
MARKETING
197 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
49. Multichannel Marketing
Multichannel Direct Mail:
Success Factors • “Mail should be specific to my role, to what I do all
day long.”
Unless you obtain
• Direct mail should be used as a highly personalized
opt-in message and and relevant communication.
media preferences
and aversions. . . • Direct mail format should reflect value and include:
personalized letter, impact addressed envelope and
You’ll simply be live stamp.
engaging in • Post card mailings are the
multichannel antithesis of this and
irritation! generate low ROI.
200 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
50. Direct Mail Versus Email
Finite Universe of Prospects: 50,000
Profit per unit sold: $200
Direct Mail v2 Direct Mail v1 Email
Cost per solicitation $5.00 $1.50 $0.05
Response rate (sales %) 10% 2% 0.13%
Cost per sale $50.00 $75.00 $38.46
Total # of sales 5,000 1,000 65
Profit $1,000,000 $200,000 $13,000
Can you run a business with 65 sales?
201 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
52. Multichannel Marketing
In Step 4, titled “How to Increase Field sales: Must be trained in
the Power of Your Online and disciplined Pre-Call Planning and
Digital Marketing, we’ll Relationship Selling.
have a detailed discussion of • Must be integrated with your
the following: other contact points for
• Web maximum responsiveness and
• Digital media, including: cost-effectiveness.
Twitter Inbound calls: Highest value,
Facebook. highest conversion medium.
Outbound calls: Proactive, service-
oriented calls to opt-in lists
increases responses 500% - 700%.
203 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
53. 5 Principles of Multichannel Marketing
5
4
4: Re-conceive Inbound as a high value customer interface.
By definition, Inbound callers are more 1) Qualified, and
2) Likely to spend.
3 3: Synchronize your multichannel mix media with
precision and value.
2: Create processes for generating feedback from your social
2 media channels and your sales and service reps. This will
provide ongoing qualitative and quantitative VoC guidance.
1 1: Start with the Customer (VoC).
204 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
54. Inbound Calls Should Provide High Value
However, when inbound
customers call, what they
frequently encounter
are human robots!
Customers have become
conditioned to poor service.
205 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
55. High Value Inbound Calls
What does it cost you in
marketing and promotion
dollars to generate an
Inbound call?
What do your customers
experience when they
call your 800#?
206 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
57. Inbound as a High
Value Experience
Increased sales
Targeted
outbound call
Calls
Personalized
fulfillment
Via email, mail or fax.
Proactive, highly
trained reps
208 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
58. 5 Principles of Multichannel Marketing
5
5: Customer Lifecycle Marketing: 1) Communications must be
deployed at appropriate points in the buying cycle, and
2) Contacts should be driven by opt-in preferences.
4
4: Re-conceive Inbound as a high value customer interface.
By definition, Inbound callers are more 1) Qualified, and
2) Likely to spend.
3 3: Synchronize your multichannel mix with
precision and value.
2: Create processes for generating feedback from your social
2 media channels and your sales and service reps. This will
provide ongoing qualitative and quantitative VoC guidance.
1 1: Start with the Customer (VoC).
209 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
59. Three Key Phases of the Customer Lifecycle
Pre-Sale
VoC-driven integrated multichannel
contacts.
Must gather opt-in preferences.
Sale
Not a “close.” Instead, it’s the
beginning of proactive, value-based
relationship development.
Growth and Retention
Requires ongoing proactive engagement, i.e. “How can we better serve you?”
Ongoing value-added justifies price premium
Proactive generation of repeat sales.
210 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
60. Customer Lifecycle Marketing
Retention Retention
Frequently overlooked. Analyze high revenue/profit
Too much focus on acquisition. potential accounts.
Analyze reasons for your Are you providing true value?
churn/inactive rates: Do you really know what they do
• Customer demographic may and how they use your products?
not be a good fit. Are they being serviced by all
• Industry. your channels?
• Your sales reps.
• Lack of proactive marketing.
211 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
61. Are You Investing Enough in Your Customers?
Top Marketing Investment
producing
customers Top producing customers
Good
customers Good customers
Dormant
Dormant customers & customers &
Qualified prospects Qualified
prospects
Suspects Suspects
Marketing Segmentation
212 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
62. Doug Stein
President
HMS National, Inc.
Doug was a distinguished Fortune 500 consultant for Accenture in the 1990’s.
There he helped manage some of the firm’s most prominent projects while also
being key to the development of significant corporate solutions and industry
offerings that notably increased market share and profit for the world’s largest
consulting firm.
Doug Stein
President In his current position, Doug is the senior executive at HMS National responsible
HMS National, Inc. for developing and delivering innovative growth strategies in a historically
mature and commoditized industry.
dstein@hmsnational.com
www.hmsnational.com
213 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
63. Case Study
How Voice of Customer Insights
Helped Change Our Culture,
the Customer Experience...and
Increased Renewals Over 50%
214 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
64. A home warranty helps homeowners avoid unexpected
home repairs which are often expensive.
The warranty provides coverage against mechanical
failures for many major systems and appliances,
30+ year old privately coverage that is not provided by most homeowners’
held company. insurance policies.
Market and sell home The term of the warranty is typically one year.
warranties through
real estate agents.
Traditionally, Home Warranties cover many systems
and appliances, including:
Use direct marketing to • Air conditioning and heating systems
renew home warranties
• Refrigerators
when the one year
contract, initiated during • Water heaters
purchase of the home, is • Washers/dryers
approaching expiration. • Ovens/ranges
• Electrical systems
• And more. . .
215 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
65. 3-Steps:
Goals of the VoC
Know much more about our customer’s needs. . .
Significantly and use this to drive our marketing.
improve renewal
rates. Establish meaningful opt-in preference-based
relationships.
Improve the
Deploy our
customer
multichannel
experience across mix customer
channels. preferences.
216 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
66. VoC Research Objectives Sample
Step 1 • Stimulate greater renewal rates Customers who
renewed
• Identify what home warranty means to
customers Customers who did
Know Much • Determine how customers define the
not renew
More About value of HMS Segments:
Our • Evaluate claim experiences; strengths and • Home buyers
Customer’s weaknesses who purchased
home warranty
Needs. . . And • Measure level of satisfaction with HMS
Use This to • Home sellers
• Analyze perception of marketing who purchased
Drive Our communications home warranty
Marketing • Gain insights into product enhancements • Filed claim/Did
• Determine willingness to opt-in and self- not file a claim
profile preferences to drive targeted
communications
217 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
67. Voice of Customer Research Learnings
Regardless of The customer Real estate
Customers often
who purchased experience, not agents often
calculate the
the warranty, just the amount drive the
value of the
(i.e. home seller of claims paid, customer’s
warranty if
or home buyer) significantly perception of
they consider
engagement impacts renewal the value of
renewing.
is low. behavior. renewing.
Service
enhancement Customers
Customers are
opportunities expect HMS to
receptive to
identified: be proactive
self-profiling
focus on the throughout the
their interests
end-to-end claims handling
and preferences.
customer process.
experience.
218 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
68. Opt-In Overview
Step 2
Key 1: Collect preferences, (per the Reciprocity of
Establish Value Equation)
Meaningful
Opt-In
Key 2: Deploy truly personalized communications
Preference-
Based
Relationships Key 3: Implement Steps
1&2 above, per privacy
guidelines
219 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
69. VoC-Driven Strategies
Step 3 VoC learnings helped develop more effective strategies for:
• How to engage customers throughout the customer lifecycle
including during the renewal process, e.g. telemarketing, direct
Deploy Our marketing, auto renewal.
Multichannel • Which product to offer, e.g. cross-sell or up-sell.
Mix Per Opt-In
• What additional information to offer regarding home repair and
Preferences maintenance.
Phased implementation began in 2009,
with a major phase recently
implemented in mid-2012.
220 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
70. Implementation Per VoC Research
Pre-VoC, our initial touch point with our customers was informational without
being engaging.
Previous fulfillment kit:
Transactional delivery of
warranty documents
221 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
71. Implementation Per VoC Research
Pre-VoC, our initial touch point with our customers was informational without
being engaging.
Truncated first page of
warranty agreement
Terms and Conditions
made up bulk of the initial
customer touch point.
222 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
72. Implementation Per VoC Research
Post-VoC, we are leveraging this early touch point to immediately engage
each customer.
Added
personalization
New tonality
focused on engaging
the customer
223 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
73. Implementation Per VoC Research
To successfully engage customers, several elements are incorporated from VoC
learnings.
Welcome
page
224 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
74. Implementation Per VoC Research
Created valuable content. This was
not defined by HMS, but instead
by customers and prospects.
225 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
75. Implementation Per VoC Research
Renewal Solicitation Stream
•Having re-engineered upfront customer touch
points, HMS embarked on the overhaul of the
renewal solicitation stream.
•Previously a traditional direct mail process, it was
updated to a highly customized, multi-channel
marketing campaign.
•The solicitation process was engineered with
precise time intervals, to optimize media synergy.
•The overhaul felt logical and accurate, it was
informed by and therefore in part designed by our
customers.
226 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
76. Implementation Per VoC Research
Example: Effective Direct Mail / Touch 4
VOC Insight: Prior marketing efforts didn't strongly motivate
customers to rethink their decision not to renew.
Tactic: Utilized a 3rd and final direct mail touch 20 days prior to
expiration. This oversized piece was printed on 100# Carolina
C2S paper and when folded was 6 X 11 to stand out and create
a large space to call out the impending expiration and the risk
factors of not renewing.
Creative: Designed to be a prominent, large-font, bold piece,
the intent of this mailer was intentionally simple - to cause
customers to think; "how would I afford the cost for failed
items in my home"? It had urgency, call-to-action, and an
incentive for non-claimants.
227 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing
77. Implementation Per VoC Research
Customer engagement through a relationship-oriented call
• Pre-VoC, multi-touch renewal process was Post-VoC, piloted service-
direct mail driven. oriented telemarketing with
focus on certain segments and
• In the VoC, customers expressed receptiveness to, and / a
the results were as positive
and a need for, a dialogue with HMS. as the VoC projected.
• The VoC enabled multi-channel marketing
that drives incremental sales. Noteworthy results from
the calling initiative – a
• Cost of telemarketing is several times 20% increase – was quickly
higher than mail, but the incremental realized, with far greater
sales offset the expense and optimize lift in certain segments.
profitability.
228 Step 3: Multichannel Marketing