SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Communicating with the public
at large: expectations, frames
         and 'impacts’
         Frans van Dam
           28-09-2012
The Minister (January 2001):

• “The cabinet sees mordern biotechnology as a
  key technology ….”
• “… clarify under what conditions food
  biotechnology is socially acceptible.”
• “… the public debate is a good approach for the
  people to consider whether and when
  biotechnology developments are acceptable”
At our disposal

•   Committee
•   Staff (6 p) + consultancies
•   4,5 M€
•   10 months (March – December 2001)
Report:

• exchange of information
• awareness raised
• recommendations to government

But:
• Did the debate make a change?
• Was ‘the debate’ improved
Lesson 1: Meaningful concepts

• GMO pros & cons

• Food production
• Sustainable agriculture
• Food related concerns
   – Pesticides
   – Additives
   – ….
Lesson 1
Lesson 1
Lesson 2 Impact

• Do not aim too high!
• Objectives: as SMART as possible
• Consider qualitative effects as well
Lesson 3: target group

• The ‘public at large’ does not exist
• Choose your target well
Lesson 4: Test, test & test

• If possible: pre-test your materials
• Look for qualitative data
Communicating with the public at large: expectations, frames and 'impacts’

More Related Content

Similar to Communicating with the public at large: expectations, frames and 'impacts’

The Wicked Problem of Food Security in EU Policy Formation
The Wicked Problem of Food Security in EU Policy FormationThe Wicked Problem of Food Security in EU Policy Formation
The Wicked Problem of Food Security in EU Policy FormationJeroen Candel
 
Social and European Project Design for Non Profit Association
Social and European Project Design for  Non Profit AssociationSocial and European Project Design for  Non Profit Association
Social and European Project Design for Non Profit AssociationElisabetta Meconcelli
 
Rt 1 The different dimensions of universal coverage and access to care
Rt 1 The different dimensions of universal coverage and access to careRt 1 The different dimensions of universal coverage and access to care
Rt 1 The different dimensions of universal coverage and access to careHealth and Labour
 
Influencing Parliament on child maltreatment, prevention and early years.
Influencing Parliament on child maltreatment, prevention and early years.Influencing Parliament on child maltreatment, prevention and early years.
Influencing Parliament on child maltreatment, prevention and early years.BASPCAN
 
GODAN presentation at the 42nd APAN meeting
GODAN presentation at the 42nd APAN meetingGODAN presentation at the 42nd APAN meeting
GODAN presentation at the 42nd APAN meetingJohannes Keizer
 
Guidelines for choosing health promotion material
Guidelines for choosing health promotion materialGuidelines for choosing health promotion material
Guidelines for choosing health promotion materialAccra School of Hygiene
 
The application of One Health: Observations from eastern and southern Africa
The application of One Health: Observations from eastern and southern AfricaThe application of One Health: Observations from eastern and southern Africa
The application of One Health: Observations from eastern and southern AfricaILRI
 
Caitlin Wills Toker
Caitlin Wills TokerCaitlin Wills Toker
Caitlin Wills TokerLucas Cioffi
 
Overview of the FoodRisC project. Aine McConnon. University College Dublin, I...
Overview of the FoodRisC project. Aine McConnon. University College Dublin, I...Overview of the FoodRisC project. Aine McConnon. University College Dublin, I...
Overview of the FoodRisC project. Aine McConnon. University College Dublin, I...comfoodforhealth
 
Learning for UHC conference : Intro - Bruno Meessen
Learning for UHC conference : Intro - Bruno MeessenLearning for UHC conference : Intro - Bruno Meessen
Learning for UHC conference : Intro - Bruno MeessenTheCollectivity
 
Communicating the NBSAP mainstreaming imperative
Communicating the NBSAP mainstreaming imperativeCommunicating the NBSAP mainstreaming imperative
Communicating the NBSAP mainstreaming imperativeJustine Braby
 
Ethical practice in One Health research
Ethical practice in One Health researchEthical practice in One Health research
Ethical practice in One Health researchILRI
 
Novel activities for teaching about epigenetics and ethics
Novel activities for teaching about epigenetics and ethicsNovel activities for teaching about epigenetics and ethics
Novel activities for teaching about epigenetics and ethicsChris Willmott
 
Theo Roelandt: In Praise of Heroic Policy Making
Theo Roelandt: In Praise of Heroic Policy Making Theo Roelandt: In Praise of Heroic Policy Making
Theo Roelandt: In Praise of Heroic Policy Making Theo Roelandt
 
ECON2302 - Lecture #1.pdf
ECON2302 - Lecture #1.pdfECON2302 - Lecture #1.pdf
ECON2302 - Lecture #1.pdfjguinto1
 
Consulting groups of European citizens
Consulting groups of European citizensConsulting groups of European citizens
Consulting groups of European citizensJohn S. Haukeland
 

Similar to Communicating with the public at large: expectations, frames and 'impacts’ (20)

The Wicked Problem of Food Security in EU Policy Formation
The Wicked Problem of Food Security in EU Policy FormationThe Wicked Problem of Food Security in EU Policy Formation
The Wicked Problem of Food Security in EU Policy Formation
 
Social and European Project Design for Non Profit Association
Social and European Project Design for  Non Profit AssociationSocial and European Project Design for  Non Profit Association
Social and European Project Design for Non Profit Association
 
Rt 1 The different dimensions of universal coverage and access to care
Rt 1 The different dimensions of universal coverage and access to careRt 1 The different dimensions of universal coverage and access to care
Rt 1 The different dimensions of universal coverage and access to care
 
2016 08 gxaas
2016 08 gxaas2016 08 gxaas
2016 08 gxaas
 
Influencing Parliament on child maltreatment, prevention and early years.
Influencing Parliament on child maltreatment, prevention and early years.Influencing Parliament on child maltreatment, prevention and early years.
Influencing Parliament on child maltreatment, prevention and early years.
 
GODAN presentation at the 42nd APAN meeting
GODAN presentation at the 42nd APAN meetingGODAN presentation at the 42nd APAN meeting
GODAN presentation at the 42nd APAN meeting
 
Guidelines for choosing health promotion material
Guidelines for choosing health promotion materialGuidelines for choosing health promotion material
Guidelines for choosing health promotion material
 
The application of One Health: Observations from eastern and southern Africa
The application of One Health: Observations from eastern and southern AfricaThe application of One Health: Observations from eastern and southern Africa
The application of One Health: Observations from eastern and southern Africa
 
Caitlin Wills Toker
Caitlin Wills TokerCaitlin Wills Toker
Caitlin Wills Toker
 
Overview of the FoodRisC project. Aine McConnon. University College Dublin, I...
Overview of the FoodRisC project. Aine McConnon. University College Dublin, I...Overview of the FoodRisC project. Aine McConnon. University College Dublin, I...
Overview of the FoodRisC project. Aine McConnon. University College Dublin, I...
 
Thinking through ‘knowledge translation’
Thinking through ‘knowledge translation’Thinking through ‘knowledge translation’
Thinking through ‘knowledge translation’
 
Embeding ESD in Mainstream Education (Helsinki, 2013)
Embeding ESD in Mainstream Education (Helsinki, 2013)Embeding ESD in Mainstream Education (Helsinki, 2013)
Embeding ESD in Mainstream Education (Helsinki, 2013)
 
Learning for UHC conference : Intro - Bruno Meessen
Learning for UHC conference : Intro - Bruno MeessenLearning for UHC conference : Intro - Bruno Meessen
Learning for UHC conference : Intro - Bruno Meessen
 
Communicating the NBSAP mainstreaming imperative
Communicating the NBSAP mainstreaming imperativeCommunicating the NBSAP mainstreaming imperative
Communicating the NBSAP mainstreaming imperative
 
Ethical practice in One Health research
Ethical practice in One Health researchEthical practice in One Health research
Ethical practice in One Health research
 
Novel activities for teaching about epigenetics and ethics
Novel activities for teaching about epigenetics and ethicsNovel activities for teaching about epigenetics and ethics
Novel activities for teaching about epigenetics and ethics
 
Food
FoodFood
Food
 
Theo Roelandt: In Praise of Heroic Policy Making
Theo Roelandt: In Praise of Heroic Policy Making Theo Roelandt: In Praise of Heroic Policy Making
Theo Roelandt: In Praise of Heroic Policy Making
 
ECON2302 - Lecture #1.pdf
ECON2302 - Lecture #1.pdfECON2302 - Lecture #1.pdf
ECON2302 - Lecture #1.pdf
 
Consulting groups of European citizens
Consulting groups of European citizensConsulting groups of European citizens
Consulting groups of European citizens
 

More from unawe

World Space Week and Education in Space by Lauren Napier
World Space Week and Education in Space by Lauren NapierWorld Space Week and Education in Space by Lauren Napier
World Space Week and Education in Space by Lauren Napierunawe
 
Universe Awareness programme in Iran
Universe Awareness programme in IranUniverse Awareness programme in Iran
Universe Awareness programme in Iranunawe
 
The Universe in the Box by Cecilia Scorza
The Universe in the Box by Cecilia ScorzaThe Universe in the Box by Cecilia Scorza
The Universe in the Box by Cecilia Scorzaunawe
 
The Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
The Travelling Telescope by Susan MurabanaThe Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
The Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabanaunawe
 
Astronomy Literacy Goals by Pedro Russo, Cecilia Scorza & H. Lee
Astronomy Literacy Goals by Pedro Russo, Cecilia Scorza & H. Lee Astronomy Literacy Goals by Pedro Russo, Cecilia Scorza & H. Lee
Astronomy Literacy Goals by Pedro Russo, Cecilia Scorza & H. Lee unawe
 
"Universe Awareness Sri Lanka – a volunteer effort" by Thilina Heenatigala
"Universe Awareness Sri Lanka – a volunteer effort" by Thilina Heenatigala"Universe Awareness Sri Lanka – a volunteer effort" by Thilina Heenatigala
"Universe Awareness Sri Lanka – a volunteer effort" by Thilina Heenatigalaunawe
 
UNAWE resources as tools for engaging earth science to calamity hit Filipino ...
UNAWE resources as tools for engaging earth science to calamity hit Filipino ...UNAWE resources as tools for engaging earth science to calamity hit Filipino ...
UNAWE resources as tools for engaging earth science to calamity hit Filipino ...unawe
 
Raise up an astronaut by Barbara ten Berge
Raise up an astronaut by Barbara ten BergeRaise up an astronaut by Barbara ten Berge
Raise up an astronaut by Barbara ten Bergeunawe
 
Astronomy education with the world’s largest radio telescope by the SKA team
Astronomy education with the world’s largest radio telescope by the SKA teamAstronomy education with the world’s largest radio telescope by the SKA team
Astronomy education with the world’s largest radio telescope by the SKA teamunawe
 
Think Physics by Joe Shimwell
Think Physics by Joe ShimwellThink Physics by Joe Shimwell
Think Physics by Joe Shimwellunawe
 
Open Science Centre by Kyra Romero
Open Science Centre by Kyra RomeroOpen Science Centre by Kyra Romero
Open Science Centre by Kyra Romerounawe
 
Maleta: Hacking Universe in a Box by Bernardo Peixoto
Maleta: Hacking Universe in a Box by Bernardo PeixotoMaleta: Hacking Universe in a Box by Bernardo Peixoto
Maleta: Hacking Universe in a Box by Bernardo Peixotounawe
 
Hermetino the space-time traveller by Ilaria Cristofaro
Hermetino the space-time traveller by Ilaria CristofaroHermetino the space-time traveller by Ilaria Cristofaro
Hermetino the space-time traveller by Ilaria Cristofarounawe
 
Engaging kids with music: the Italian astrokids case study by Stefano Sandrelli
Engaging kids with music: the Italian astrokids case study by Stefano SandrelliEngaging kids with music: the Italian astrokids case study by Stefano Sandrelli
Engaging kids with music: the Italian astrokids case study by Stefano Sandrelliunawe
 
Cosmic Light EDU kit by Rosa Doran
Cosmic Light EDU kit by Rosa DoranCosmic Light EDU kit by Rosa Doran
Cosmic Light EDU kit by Rosa Doranunawe
 
Astronomy curriculum of elementary students in Iran by Soheil Nadalipour
Astronomy curriculum of elementary students in Iran by Soheil NadalipourAstronomy curriculum of elementary students in Iran by Soheil Nadalipour
Astronomy curriculum of elementary students in Iran by Soheil Nadalipourunawe
 
The Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
The Travelling Telescope by Susan MurabanaThe Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
The Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabanaunawe
 
Astronomy campaign in Morocco "Let’s discover the solar system" by Darhmaoui ...
Astronomy campaign in Morocco "Let’s discover the solar system" by Darhmaoui ...Astronomy campaign in Morocco "Let’s discover the solar system" by Darhmaoui ...
Astronomy campaign in Morocco "Let’s discover the solar system" by Darhmaoui ...unawe
 
Universe in the Classroom by Edward Gomez
Universe in the Classroom by Edward GomezUniverse in the Classroom by Edward Gomez
Universe in the Classroom by Edward Gomezunawe
 
Universe awareness Croatia by Danijela Takac
Universe awareness Croatia by Danijela TakacUniverse awareness Croatia by Danijela Takac
Universe awareness Croatia by Danijela Takacunawe
 

More from unawe (20)

World Space Week and Education in Space by Lauren Napier
World Space Week and Education in Space by Lauren NapierWorld Space Week and Education in Space by Lauren Napier
World Space Week and Education in Space by Lauren Napier
 
Universe Awareness programme in Iran
Universe Awareness programme in IranUniverse Awareness programme in Iran
Universe Awareness programme in Iran
 
The Universe in the Box by Cecilia Scorza
The Universe in the Box by Cecilia ScorzaThe Universe in the Box by Cecilia Scorza
The Universe in the Box by Cecilia Scorza
 
The Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
The Travelling Telescope by Susan MurabanaThe Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
The Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
 
Astronomy Literacy Goals by Pedro Russo, Cecilia Scorza & H. Lee
Astronomy Literacy Goals by Pedro Russo, Cecilia Scorza & H. Lee Astronomy Literacy Goals by Pedro Russo, Cecilia Scorza & H. Lee
Astronomy Literacy Goals by Pedro Russo, Cecilia Scorza & H. Lee
 
"Universe Awareness Sri Lanka – a volunteer effort" by Thilina Heenatigala
"Universe Awareness Sri Lanka – a volunteer effort" by Thilina Heenatigala"Universe Awareness Sri Lanka – a volunteer effort" by Thilina Heenatigala
"Universe Awareness Sri Lanka – a volunteer effort" by Thilina Heenatigala
 
UNAWE resources as tools for engaging earth science to calamity hit Filipino ...
UNAWE resources as tools for engaging earth science to calamity hit Filipino ...UNAWE resources as tools for engaging earth science to calamity hit Filipino ...
UNAWE resources as tools for engaging earth science to calamity hit Filipino ...
 
Raise up an astronaut by Barbara ten Berge
Raise up an astronaut by Barbara ten BergeRaise up an astronaut by Barbara ten Berge
Raise up an astronaut by Barbara ten Berge
 
Astronomy education with the world’s largest radio telescope by the SKA team
Astronomy education with the world’s largest radio telescope by the SKA teamAstronomy education with the world’s largest radio telescope by the SKA team
Astronomy education with the world’s largest radio telescope by the SKA team
 
Think Physics by Joe Shimwell
Think Physics by Joe ShimwellThink Physics by Joe Shimwell
Think Physics by Joe Shimwell
 
Open Science Centre by Kyra Romero
Open Science Centre by Kyra RomeroOpen Science Centre by Kyra Romero
Open Science Centre by Kyra Romero
 
Maleta: Hacking Universe in a Box by Bernardo Peixoto
Maleta: Hacking Universe in a Box by Bernardo PeixotoMaleta: Hacking Universe in a Box by Bernardo Peixoto
Maleta: Hacking Universe in a Box by Bernardo Peixoto
 
Hermetino the space-time traveller by Ilaria Cristofaro
Hermetino the space-time traveller by Ilaria CristofaroHermetino the space-time traveller by Ilaria Cristofaro
Hermetino the space-time traveller by Ilaria Cristofaro
 
Engaging kids with music: the Italian astrokids case study by Stefano Sandrelli
Engaging kids with music: the Italian astrokids case study by Stefano SandrelliEngaging kids with music: the Italian astrokids case study by Stefano Sandrelli
Engaging kids with music: the Italian astrokids case study by Stefano Sandrelli
 
Cosmic Light EDU kit by Rosa Doran
Cosmic Light EDU kit by Rosa DoranCosmic Light EDU kit by Rosa Doran
Cosmic Light EDU kit by Rosa Doran
 
Astronomy curriculum of elementary students in Iran by Soheil Nadalipour
Astronomy curriculum of elementary students in Iran by Soheil NadalipourAstronomy curriculum of elementary students in Iran by Soheil Nadalipour
Astronomy curriculum of elementary students in Iran by Soheil Nadalipour
 
The Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
The Travelling Telescope by Susan MurabanaThe Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
The Travelling Telescope by Susan Murabana
 
Astronomy campaign in Morocco "Let’s discover the solar system" by Darhmaoui ...
Astronomy campaign in Morocco "Let’s discover the solar system" by Darhmaoui ...Astronomy campaign in Morocco "Let’s discover the solar system" by Darhmaoui ...
Astronomy campaign in Morocco "Let’s discover the solar system" by Darhmaoui ...
 
Universe in the Classroom by Edward Gomez
Universe in the Classroom by Edward GomezUniverse in the Classroom by Edward Gomez
Universe in the Classroom by Edward Gomez
 
Universe awareness Croatia by Danijela Takac
Universe awareness Croatia by Danijela TakacUniverse awareness Croatia by Danijela Takac
Universe awareness Croatia by Danijela Takac
 

Communicating with the public at large: expectations, frames and 'impacts’

  • 1. Communicating with the public at large: expectations, frames and 'impacts’ Frans van Dam 28-09-2012
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5. The Minister (January 2001): • “The cabinet sees mordern biotechnology as a key technology ….” • “… clarify under what conditions food biotechnology is socially acceptible.” • “… the public debate is a good approach for the people to consider whether and when biotechnology developments are acceptable”
  • 6. At our disposal • Committee • Staff (6 p) + consultancies • 4,5 M€ • 10 months (March – December 2001)
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9. Report: • exchange of information • awareness raised • recommendations to government But: • Did the debate make a change? • Was ‘the debate’ improved
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12. Lesson 1: Meaningful concepts • GMO pros & cons • Food production • Sustainable agriculture • Food related concerns – Pesticides – Additives – ….
  • 15.
  • 16. Lesson 2 Impact • Do not aim too high! • Objectives: as SMART as possible • Consider qualitative effects as well
  • 17. Lesson 3: target group • The ‘public at large’ does not exist • Choose your target well
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20. Lesson 4: Test, test & test • If possible: pre-test your materials • Look for qualitative data