SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 1
Baixar para ler offline
Six Nations, One River:
Testing a Model of Perceived Effects of Inter governmental Collaboration on
Sustainable Tourism in the Greater Mekong Sub region
Soriya Yin, PhD., Ingrid E. Schneider, Ph.D., & Stephan Carlson, Ph.D.
Figure 2: Greater Mekong Sub-region, ADB.
Purpose and Research Questions:
Collaboration is one of the most frequently recommended strategies to address
global issues such as climate change, spreading diseases, and fighting terrorism
(Gray, 1989) –– but, does it work for sustainable tourism? A significant theoretical
body exists in inter governmental collaboration, but it relationship with sustainable
tourism is untested. This research sought to test the assumption that sustainable
tourism depends on inter governmental collaboration. Specifically, the study
assessed
1. What factors measure inter governmental collaboration?
2. What factors measure sustainable tourism?
3. To what extent does inter governmental collaboration influence sustainable
tourism (Figure 1, below)?
Methodology:
Study site: The Greater Mekong Sub region, which includes China, Myanmar, Laos,
Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam, is a suitable place for the proposed study due to
its position as a fast growing tourist destination and its length of collaboration
(Figure 2, to your right)
Questionnaire: Online to 1,125 GMS government officers; response = 359
Analysis: Structural equation modeling (SEM)
Variables: Collaboration measured by 8 factors: 1) resources, 2) administration, 3)
regional issues, 4) regional attachment, 5) mutual benefits, 6) trust, 7) governance
and 8) leadership. Sustainable tourism measured by 4 factors: 1) environmental, 2)
economic, 3) cultural and 4) social dimensions. All dimensions measured with
between 4 & 9 items
Figure 1: Proposed Model of Collaboration influence on Sustainable Tourism
Inter governmental
collaboration
Administration
Issues
Resource
Attachment
Mutuality
Trust
Governance
Leadership
Sustainable
Tourism
Economic
Cultural
Environment
Social
Key Findings:
1. What factors measure collaboration? 2. What factors measure sustainable tourism?
3. To what extent does inter governmental collaboration influence sustainable tourism?
.74 .55
Discussion:
The proposed theoretical model was tested with data from the Asia’’s Greater Mekong sub
region. Empirical results reveal a modified model with eight constructs and 23 indicators that
appears to be a better fit to the data set than the proposed model (Fig 3 & 4). Inter
governmental collaboration was redefined by 4 factors (regional attachment, mutual trust,
governance and leadership) instead of 8 and it significantly influenced sustainable tourism (Fig
5). The overall fit of the modified SEM and the acceptable to high standardized loadings of the
constructs suggest empirical support for a relationship between inter governmental
collaboration and sustainable tourism. The study advances conceptual understanding of inter
governmental collaboration in sustainable tourism and adds to limited empirical literature,
particularly in the Greater Mekong Sub region. Existing collaboration models can be
reexamined with these results in mind.
Significance:
The study is significant for at least four main reasons. First, the study contributes to the
existing body of knowledge by providing a more complete and deeper understanding of inter
governmental collaboration and its specific application in tourism. Second, it adds to existing
work by expanding use of the SEM approach in tourism. Third, it informs policy development
by providing scientific information on how to improve inter governmental collaboration to
achieve sustainable tourism. Finally, it provides practitioners with specific and concrete
measurements and indicators of sustainable tourism collaboration.
.54
.73
.92
.82
.86
.87
.77
.57
.61
.74
.92
.55
.54
.28
.96
.74
.63
.73
.75
.53
.29
.53
.84
.67
.73
.75
.56
.33
.37
.55
.73
.84
.70
.63
.68
.83
.80
.49
.70
.88
.95
.84
.76
.92
.84
.80
.82
.91
.80
.67
.64
.33
.56
.82
.80
.57
.24
.49
.78
.90
.71
.58
Figure 3: Inter governmental Collaboration Model Figure 4: Sustainable Tourism Model
Figure 5: Inter governmental Collaboration Having an Effect on Sustainable Tourism

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais de University of Minnesota Tourism Center

TAPPING into Community Tourism Potential in Rural Minnesota's Communities
TAPPING into Community Tourism Potential in Rural Minnesota's Communities TAPPING into Community Tourism Potential in Rural Minnesota's Communities
TAPPING into Community Tourism Potential in Rural Minnesota's Communities University of Minnesota Tourism Center
 
Perceptions of Invasive Species & Their Control Among the MN Tourism Industry
Perceptions of Invasive Species & Their Control Among the MN Tourism IndustryPerceptions of Invasive Species & Their Control Among the MN Tourism Industry
Perceptions of Invasive Species & Their Control Among the MN Tourism IndustryUniversity of Minnesota Tourism Center
 
State of Sustainable Tourism: Assessing waste minimization practices among to...
State of Sustainable Tourism: Assessing waste minimization practices among to...State of Sustainable Tourism: Assessing waste minimization practices among to...
State of Sustainable Tourism: Assessing waste minimization practices among to...University of Minnesota Tourism Center
 
Are Tourism Businesses Using the Internet? An Initial Assessment of Digital P...
Are Tourism Businesses Using the Internet? An Initial Assessment of Digital P...Are Tourism Businesses Using the Internet? An Initial Assessment of Digital P...
Are Tourism Businesses Using the Internet? An Initial Assessment of Digital P...University of Minnesota Tourism Center
 
Waste, water, and energy benchmarking and conservation opportunities for Minn...
Waste, water, and energy benchmarking and conservation opportunities for Minn...Waste, water, and energy benchmarking and conservation opportunities for Minn...
Waste, water, and energy benchmarking and conservation opportunities for Minn...University of Minnesota Tourism Center
 
State of Sustainable Tourism in Minnesota 2013 Initial Assessment of Water an...
State of Sustainable Tourism in Minnesota 2013 Initial Assessment of Water an...State of Sustainable Tourism in Minnesota 2013 Initial Assessment of Water an...
State of Sustainable Tourism in Minnesota 2013 Initial Assessment of Water an...University of Minnesota Tourism Center
 
Nature as Impression for Dao: A Theory of Spiritual Tourism Development in Da...
Nature as Impression for Dao: A Theory of Spiritual Tourism Development in Da...Nature as Impression for Dao: A Theory of Spiritual Tourism Development in Da...
Nature as Impression for Dao: A Theory of Spiritual Tourism Development in Da...University of Minnesota Tourism Center
 
Marketing Profile of Cultural and Historical Travelers to the Twin Cities Met...
Marketing Profile of Cultural and Historical Travelers to the Twin Cities Met...Marketing Profile of Cultural and Historical Travelers to the Twin Cities Met...
Marketing Profile of Cultural and Historical Travelers to the Twin Cities Met...University of Minnesota Tourism Center
 
Differentiating Commuters on Perceived Bike Safety & Transportation Attributes
Differentiating Commuters on Perceived Bike Safety & Transportation AttributesDifferentiating Commuters on Perceived Bike Safety & Transportation Attributes
Differentiating Commuters on Perceived Bike Safety & Transportation AttributesUniversity of Minnesota Tourism Center
 

Mais de University of Minnesota Tourism Center (20)

TAPPING into Community Tourism Potential in Rural Minnesota's Communities
TAPPING into Community Tourism Potential in Rural Minnesota's Communities TAPPING into Community Tourism Potential in Rural Minnesota's Communities
TAPPING into Community Tourism Potential in Rural Minnesota's Communities
 
Ripple Effect Mapping of the Tourism Assessment Program
Ripple Effect Mapping of the Tourism Assessment ProgramRipple Effect Mapping of the Tourism Assessment Program
Ripple Effect Mapping of the Tourism Assessment Program
 
Emerald Ash Borer Interviews
Emerald Ash Borer InterviewsEmerald Ash Borer Interviews
Emerald Ash Borer Interviews
 
Emerald Ash Borer Interviews
Emerald Ash Borer Interviews Emerald Ash Borer Interviews
Emerald Ash Borer Interviews
 
Perceptions of Invasive Species & Their Control Among the MN Tourism Industry
Perceptions of Invasive Species & Their Control Among the MN Tourism IndustryPerceptions of Invasive Species & Their Control Among the MN Tourism Industry
Perceptions of Invasive Species & Their Control Among the MN Tourism Industry
 
State of Sustainable Tourism: Assessing waste minimization practices among to...
State of Sustainable Tourism: Assessing waste minimization practices among to...State of Sustainable Tourism: Assessing waste minimization practices among to...
State of Sustainable Tourism: Assessing waste minimization practices among to...
 
Welcome to the New Tradition: Where we are & Where we are heading to
Welcome to the New Tradition: Where we are & Where we are heading toWelcome to the New Tradition: Where we are & Where we are heading to
Welcome to the New Tradition: Where we are & Where we are heading to
 
Quality of Life: Assessment for Transportation Performance Measures
Quality of Life: Assessment for Transportation Performance MeasuresQuality of Life: Assessment for Transportation Performance Measures
Quality of Life: Assessment for Transportation Performance Measures
 
Perceived Bicycle Safety in Minnesota
Perceived Bicycle Safety in MinnesotaPerceived Bicycle Safety in Minnesota
Perceived Bicycle Safety in Minnesota
 
Economic Impact of the 3M Championship Golf Tournament
Economic Impact of the 3M Championship Golf TournamentEconomic Impact of the 3M Championship Golf Tournament
Economic Impact of the 3M Championship Golf Tournament
 
Are Tourism Businesses Using the Internet? An Initial Assessment of Digital P...
Are Tourism Businesses Using the Internet? An Initial Assessment of Digital P...Are Tourism Businesses Using the Internet? An Initial Assessment of Digital P...
Are Tourism Businesses Using the Internet? An Initial Assessment of Digital P...
 
Chisago Lakes Area: Tourism Assessment Program Case Study 2008-2011
Chisago Lakes Area: Tourism Assessment Program Case Study 2008-2011Chisago Lakes Area: Tourism Assessment Program Case Study 2008-2011
Chisago Lakes Area: Tourism Assessment Program Case Study 2008-2011
 
Understanding & Aligning Transportation with Quality of Life
Understanding & Aligning Transportation with Quality of LifeUnderstanding & Aligning Transportation with Quality of Life
Understanding & Aligning Transportation with Quality of Life
 
Waste, water, and energy benchmarking and conservation opportunities for Minn...
Waste, water, and energy benchmarking and conservation opportunities for Minn...Waste, water, and energy benchmarking and conservation opportunities for Minn...
Waste, water, and energy benchmarking and conservation opportunities for Minn...
 
State of Sustainable Tourism in Minnesota 2013 Initial Assessment of Water an...
State of Sustainable Tourism in Minnesota 2013 Initial Assessment of Water an...State of Sustainable Tourism in Minnesota 2013 Initial Assessment of Water an...
State of Sustainable Tourism in Minnesota 2013 Initial Assessment of Water an...
 
Nature as Impression for Dao: A Theory of Spiritual Tourism Development in Da...
Nature as Impression for Dao: A Theory of Spiritual Tourism Development in Da...Nature as Impression for Dao: A Theory of Spiritual Tourism Development in Da...
Nature as Impression for Dao: A Theory of Spiritual Tourism Development in Da...
 
Marketing Profile of Cultural and Historical Travelers to the Twin Cities Met...
Marketing Profile of Cultural and Historical Travelers to the Twin Cities Met...Marketing Profile of Cultural and Historical Travelers to the Twin Cities Met...
Marketing Profile of Cultural and Historical Travelers to the Twin Cities Met...
 
Differentiating Commuters on Perceived Bike Safety & Transportation Attributes
Differentiating Commuters on Perceived Bike Safety & Transportation AttributesDifferentiating Commuters on Perceived Bike Safety & Transportation Attributes
Differentiating Commuters on Perceived Bike Safety & Transportation Attributes
 
Compare uses of electronic media among urban nature-based tourists
Compare uses of electronic media among urban nature-based touristsCompare uses of electronic media among urban nature-based tourists
Compare uses of electronic media among urban nature-based tourists
 
Profile of Irish Fair of Minnesota Attendees
Profile of Irish Fair of Minnesota AttendeesProfile of Irish Fair of Minnesota Attendees
Profile of Irish Fair of Minnesota Attendees
 

Six Nations, One River: Testings a Model of Perceived Effects of Inter-governmental Collaboration on Sustainable Tourism in the Greater Mekong Sub-region

  • 1. Six Nations, One River: Testing a Model of Perceived Effects of Inter governmental Collaboration on Sustainable Tourism in the Greater Mekong Sub region Soriya Yin, PhD., Ingrid E. Schneider, Ph.D., & Stephan Carlson, Ph.D. Figure 2: Greater Mekong Sub-region, ADB. Purpose and Research Questions: Collaboration is one of the most frequently recommended strategies to address global issues such as climate change, spreading diseases, and fighting terrorism (Gray, 1989) –– but, does it work for sustainable tourism? A significant theoretical body exists in inter governmental collaboration, but it relationship with sustainable tourism is untested. This research sought to test the assumption that sustainable tourism depends on inter governmental collaboration. Specifically, the study assessed 1. What factors measure inter governmental collaboration? 2. What factors measure sustainable tourism? 3. To what extent does inter governmental collaboration influence sustainable tourism (Figure 1, below)? Methodology: Study site: The Greater Mekong Sub region, which includes China, Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam, is a suitable place for the proposed study due to its position as a fast growing tourist destination and its length of collaboration (Figure 2, to your right) Questionnaire: Online to 1,125 GMS government officers; response = 359 Analysis: Structural equation modeling (SEM) Variables: Collaboration measured by 8 factors: 1) resources, 2) administration, 3) regional issues, 4) regional attachment, 5) mutual benefits, 6) trust, 7) governance and 8) leadership. Sustainable tourism measured by 4 factors: 1) environmental, 2) economic, 3) cultural and 4) social dimensions. All dimensions measured with between 4 & 9 items Figure 1: Proposed Model of Collaboration influence on Sustainable Tourism Inter governmental collaboration Administration Issues Resource Attachment Mutuality Trust Governance Leadership Sustainable Tourism Economic Cultural Environment Social Key Findings: 1. What factors measure collaboration? 2. What factors measure sustainable tourism? 3. To what extent does inter governmental collaboration influence sustainable tourism? .74 .55 Discussion: The proposed theoretical model was tested with data from the Asia’’s Greater Mekong sub region. Empirical results reveal a modified model with eight constructs and 23 indicators that appears to be a better fit to the data set than the proposed model (Fig 3 & 4). Inter governmental collaboration was redefined by 4 factors (regional attachment, mutual trust, governance and leadership) instead of 8 and it significantly influenced sustainable tourism (Fig 5). The overall fit of the modified SEM and the acceptable to high standardized loadings of the constructs suggest empirical support for a relationship between inter governmental collaboration and sustainable tourism. The study advances conceptual understanding of inter governmental collaboration in sustainable tourism and adds to limited empirical literature, particularly in the Greater Mekong Sub region. Existing collaboration models can be reexamined with these results in mind. Significance: The study is significant for at least four main reasons. First, the study contributes to the existing body of knowledge by providing a more complete and deeper understanding of inter governmental collaboration and its specific application in tourism. Second, it adds to existing work by expanding use of the SEM approach in tourism. Third, it informs policy development by providing scientific information on how to improve inter governmental collaboration to achieve sustainable tourism. Finally, it provides practitioners with specific and concrete measurements and indicators of sustainable tourism collaboration. .54 .73 .92 .82 .86 .87 .77 .57 .61 .74 .92 .55 .54 .28 .96 .74 .63 .73 .75 .53 .29 .53 .84 .67 .73 .75 .56 .33 .37 .55 .73 .84 .70 .63 .68 .83 .80 .49 .70 .88 .95 .84 .76 .92 .84 .80 .82 .91 .80 .67 .64 .33 .56 .82 .80 .57 .24 .49 .78 .90 .71 .58 Figure 3: Inter governmental Collaboration Model Figure 4: Sustainable Tourism Model Figure 5: Inter governmental Collaboration Having an Effect on Sustainable Tourism