Between 1892 and 1997, a total of 2.1 million people were deported from the United States. A change in laws in 1996 permitted the number of deportees to increase from 70,000 in 1996 to 114,000 in 1997. In 1998, the number of deportees rose to 173,000. The numbers stayed fairly steady until 2003, when the creation of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) infused more money into immigration law enforcement and 211,000 people were deported. From there the numbers have continued to rise – peaking at just over 400,000 in 2012. These numbers are unprecedented: by 2014 President Obama will have deported over 2 million people - more in six years than all people deported before 1997. However, there is more to this trend than these numbers. The content of policies has also changed. There have been relatively low numbers of returns as compared to removals, a reflection of a focus on interior enforcement. There has been a shift towards the deportation of convicted criminals. With these trends, unprecedented numbers of people have been separated from their families in the United States. Obama has not only deported more people than any President; he also has separated more families by focusing on interior enforcement.
5. +
Focus on “criminal aliens”
250,000
200,000
150,000
100,000
50,000
0
Criminal Alien Secure 287 (g) NFOP
Program Communities
6. +
Criminal Removals, 2011
Sexual Family offenses,
Assault, 2961
3572 All other,
Robbery, 3745 27889
Burglary, 3795 Drugs, 43262
Fraud, 4218
Larceny, 5705 Traffic, 43022
Assault, 12755
Immigra on,
37458
7. +
10-fold increase in deportation of
people with US citizen children
Between July
1, 2010, and Sept.
30, 2012, nearly a
quarter of all
deportations—
or, 204,810
deportations—
involved parents with
U.S. citizen children.
8. +
Is there a relationship between
interior enforcement & the focus
on criminal deportations?
9. +
ICE Field offices: 5 along the
southern border.
10. +
Criminal Alien Program mostly
involves removals from ICE offices
not along the Southern Border.
CAP
Total
Field offices: 2011 Charging Ratio
removals
documents
All field offices 396,906 211,623 0.53
Southern Border offices 208,940 47,186 0.23
No Southern Border 187,966 164,437 0.87
11. +
Conclusions
It appears that the focus on criminal deportations has led to
enhanced interior enforcement and more family separations.
However, many questions remain open…
Ideas for digging deeper?
Editor's Notes
These numbers are unprecedented: by 2014 President Obama will have deported over 2 million people - more in six years than all people deported before 1997. However, there is more to this trend than these numbers. The proportion of returns to removals.Focus on criminal aliens.Increased deportation of parents of US citizens.
In 1996, there were 22 times as many returns as removals. This ratio has dropped continuously, and in 2011, for the first time since 1941, the United States removed more people than it returned.
Since 2008, we have witnessed a shift towards more ICE apprehensions. In 2002, ICE apprehensions accounted for 10% of all DHS apprehensions. By 2011, that figure was nearly 50%. Although illegal entries have declined, deportations have continued to rise because of funding for Police/ICE cooperation. ICE can’t do this alone, with only 5,000 agents on the ground.
CAP: 200,000 removals in 2011Scomm: 78,246287(g): 27,000 in 2010.NFOP: 1500
We can address this question by looking at ICE field offices that deport people. There are 25 ICE field offices responsible for deportations. Of these, five include jurisdictions along the southern border: El Paso, Houston, Phoenix, San Antonio, and San Diego. The remainder operate in the interior of the United States.
Whereas deportations are concentrated in the southern field offices, this is not the same for the Criminal Alien charging documents. For example, in 2011, 36,195 people were deported via the El Paso office. In that same year, there were only 4429 CAP charging documents issued in El Paso - a ratio of 0.12. Compare that to New York City, where 3,522 people were deported, yet 7267 CAP charging documents were issued - a ratio of 2.09.
Conclusion*This brief analysis provides some evidence that the focus on criminal deportations has led to enhanced interior enforcement, and that this in turn is the reason so many parents of U.S. citizens are being deported. It would be useful to get a handle on how and why enforcement has changed. One of the most important changes appears to have happened in 2008, when ICE apprehensions shot up from 84,000 to 320,000. What happened within ICE to provoke this change? Many pro-immigrant Obama supporters would like to know if the unprecedented numbers of deportations that have happened under his watch are due to his actions or to those of Congress or other parties. The most marked changes appear to have happened in 2008, the year before Obama was elected. However, President Obama has chosen to continue on the path set by the Bush administration. For example, President Obama appointed Janet Napolitano as Secretary of DHS, and she has made it her mission to achieve a quota of 400,000 deportees a year, even as fewer immigrants have come to the United States illegally. Obama has made it clear that he wants DHS to focus on criminal deportations. This commitment has led to increased Police/ICE cooperation, which has torn millions of immigrants from their homes.